The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
23. In view of the major flaw in the orders passed by the respondent authorities which has been referred supra, the other grounds urged by learned counsel for the petitioner become purely academic and are not necessary to be dealt with in the present writ petition.
24. For the foregoing reasons, the writ petition is allowed and the detention order No.H-3301/101/2022-HD-HD, dated 21.10.2022 passed by the Special Secretary (Home), Government of Manipur and its confirmation order dated
26. 12.2022 passed by the Commissioner (Home), Government of Manipur, stand quashed and the detenu is set at liberty. The respondents are directed to release the detenu forthwith, unless his detention is otherwise required as per law in any other case. FR/NFR Sushil WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.04.21 12:10:32 +05'30'
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL
SHARMA
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
Mrs. Taslim Banu, aged about 29 years, W/o Md.
Kabir, aged about 31 years of Lilong Chingkham
Maning, PO/PS Lilong, Thoubal District, Manipur.
........ Petitioner
-Versus1.
The State of Manipur represented by the
Commissioner/Special
Secretary
(Home),
Government of Manipur, Secretariat Building, P.O.
& P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur795001.
2.
The Superintendent, Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa,
P.O. Lamlong & P.S. Heingang, Imphal East,
Manipur- 795010.
3.
The Union of India represented by the Deputy
Secretary
(PIT-NDPS),
Ministry
of
Finance,
Department of Revenue, near North Block, Room
No. 26, Church Road, RFA- Barrack, New Delhi110001.
........ Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioner
::
Mr. Th. Punshiba, Advocate
For the Respondents
::
Mr. Th. Vashum,
Mr. BR Sharma, CGC
Date of Hearing and
Judgment & Order
::
06.04.2023.
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
Page |2
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(ORAL)
(M.V. Muralidaran, Acting CJ)
The wife of the detenu, Md.Kabir, presently
detained in Manipur Central Jail, Imphal, has filed this writ
petition seeking to quash the impugned detention order No.H3301/101/2022-HD-HD, dated 21.10.2022 passed by the Special
Secretary (Home), Government of Manipur and its confirmation
order dated 26.12.2022 passed by the Commissioner (Home),
Government of Manipur.
2.
The facts in a nutshell are as under: On 8.6.2022,
at around 7.40 pm, a process from the Lilong Police Station,
based on information from a reliable source, conducted a search
at the house of the detenu, during which process, they seized
one transparent plastic container from the washroom of the
detenu containing suspected Heroin No.4 (white and light brown
in colour) weighing 7.5 grams. The detenu was arrested at 7.45
pm and the seizure was not witnessed by anyone in the locality.
An FIR was lodged against the detenu vide FIR No.38(06)2022
LIL-PS under Section 21(b) of the ND & PS Act.
3.
It is stated that on 9.6.2022, the detenu was
remanded to police custody for a period of five days from
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
Page |3
9.6.2022 to 13.6.2022 by the Judicial Magistrate First Class,
Thoubal. Subsequently, on 13.6.2022, the detenu was produced
before the learned Special Judge, ND & PS, Thoubal, and
remanded to judicial custody for a period of 15 days from
13.6.2022 to 27.6.2022.
The detenu was again arrested on
13.6.2022 for the trafficking of illicit drugs and sent to the Manipur
Central Jail. However, there is no FIR or record to fortify the
aforesaid re-arrest, except the above FIR.
4.
It is further stated that, on 11.10.2022, the detenu
filed a bail application before the learned Special Judge, ND &
PS, Thoubal and
was released on bail vide order dated
13.10.2022 passed in Cril (Mis.) Bail No.349 of 2022. Thereafter,
impugned detention order No.H-3301/101/2022-HD-HD, dated
21.10.2022 was passed by the Special Secretary (Home),
Government of Manipur, which was confirmed vide order dated
26.12.2022 passed by the Commissioner (Home), Government
of Manipur.
5.
The main plank of the argument advanced by
learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner is that the
detenu was not informed about his right to make a representation
to the authorities concerned against the detention order. It is
further submitted that the grounds on which the order of detention
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
Page |4
was passed were not explained to the detenu in the language
which he understands and, therefore, the detention order is
vitiated.
6.
Pointing out to this court paragraph (7) of the
detention order, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that
albeit the detenu has been termed as a “habitual offender” and it
was averred that the detenu has transported drugs multiple
times, there is on record to show that any case has been
registered against the detenu, except the case in question,
namely FIR No.38(06)2022 LIL-PS.
When there is no case
pending against the detenu, branding him as “habitual offender”
shows the complete cavalier attitude of the respondent
authorities in passing the order of detention.
7.
The next argument made by learned counsel for the
petitioner is that even though the detenu has not made any
representation against the detention order, the authority
concerned, in the order dated 26.12.2022, more particularly in
paragraph (4), has stated that the representation given by the
detenu was rejected by the Advisory Board. He submitted that
this only shows the casual and mechanical manner in which the
detention order has been passed.
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
Page |5
8.
Nextly, it is submitted that the detaining authority
has passed the detention order solely based on his subjective
satisfaction arrived at on the basis of the statement made by the
detenu to the investigating officer. He pleaded that statements
under Section 161 Cr.P.C. cannot be taken as sufficient ground
in the absence of any supportive or corroborative grounds.
9.
On the basis of the aforesaid submissions, Th.
Punshiba, learned counsel for the petitioner prayed for setting
aside of the detention order.
10.
Mr. Th. Vashum, learned Deputy Government
Advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent authorities
reiterated the reasons that weighed with the respondent
authorities in passing the impugned detention order and prayed
for dismissing of this writ petition.
11.
Heard learned counsel on either side and perused
the documents available on record.
12.
Personal liberty is of the widest amplitude covering
a variety of rights and its deprivation shall only be in accordance
with the procedure prescribed by law conformable to the
mandate of the Constitution of India. It is beyond any cavil that
the right of personal liberty is the most cherished fundamental
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
Page |6
right. Preventive detention is a serious invasion of personal
liberty and any improper exercise of power must be jealously
watched and enforced by the court.
13.
At this juncture, it is apposite to refer to Article 22(5)
of the Constitution of India, which reads as under:
“When any person is detained in pursuance of
an order made under any law providing for
preventive detention, the authority making the
order shall, as soon as may be, communicate
to such person the grounds on which the
order has been made and shall afford him
the
earliest
opportunity
of
making
a
representation against the order.”
(emphasis supplied)
14.
The rights guaranteed to a person detained are
stipulated under Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India. When
a person is detained in pursuance of a preventive detention
order, he has to be supplied with the grounds on which the order
was made and he should be afforded the earliest opportunity of
making a representation against the order. The right to make a
representation carried within it a corresponding obligation on the
authority making the order of detention to inform the person
detained of his right to make a representation against the order
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
Page |7
of detention to the authorities who are required to consider a
representation.
15.
In the light of the aforesaid constitutional right and
the law laid down by the Supreme Court, now let us analyse the
case on hand.
16.
Firstly, a perusal of the entire file produced by the
respondent authorities does not show a whit of material in the
form of a representation submitted by the detenu against the
impugned detention order. No person knowing about his right to
make a representation against the detention order will remain
silent without making a representation for months together. At
this juncture, it is appropriate to refer to the relevant portion of
the order dated 26.12.2022 passed by the respondent
authorities:
“And whereas, the Advisory Board constituted
under Section 9 of the said Act after due
consideration
of
the
material
facts,
circumstances, representation submitted by
the detenue and hearing him in person in its
sitting held on 19.12.2022 and report pronounced
on 22.12.2022, has rejected the representation &
unanimously decided that there are sufficient
causes for detention of the detenue under the
provisions of the said Act;”
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
Page |8
17.
When the detenu has admittedly not made any
representation against the detention order, it is not known how
the Advisory Board has considered such representation and the
said fact was reiterated in the order dated 26.12.2022 passed by
the respondent authority.
In fact, the non-making of
representation by the detenu is further fortified by the stand taken
by the respondent authorities in the counter affidavit itself to the
following effect:
“9. That, with reference to Para No.6 of the Writ
Petition, the deponent begs to submit that
Advisory Board in its original proceeding of
sitting didn’t mention about consideration and
rejection/disposal of the same. The same had
been inadvertently printed while preparing
the confirmation orders out of human
error. ….”
[emphasis supplied]
18.
The aforesaid averment in the counter affidavit
clearly establishes that the detenu has not made any
representation against the detention order.
19.
The Apex Court in Lallubhai Jogibhai Patel v.
Union of India, (1981) 2 SCC 427, has emphatically held that
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
Page |9
the mere statement that the grounds of detention were fully
explained to the detenu, who does not know English, is not
sufficient compliance of the mandate of Article 22(5) of the
Constitution. The relevant portion of the said decision is
reproduced hereunder:
“ ‘Communicate’ is a strong word which means
that sufficient knowledge of the basic facts
constituting the ‘grounds’ should be imparted
effectively and fully to the detenu in writing in a
language which he understands. The whole
purpose of communicating the ‘grounds’ to the
detenu is to enable him to make a purposeful
and effective representation. If the ‘grounds’
are only verbally explained to the detenu
and nothing in writing is left with him in a
language which he understands, then that
purpose is not serve, and the constitutional
mandate in Article 22(5) is infringed.”
20.
That
apart,
the
Hon’ble
Apex
Court
in
Powanammal v. State of Tamil Nadu and another, (1999) 2
SCC 413, has categorically held that non-supply of the detention
order in a language that the detenu understands impairs the
detenu’s right to make an effective representation. Similarly, in
Chaju Ram v. The State of Jammu and Kashmir, (1970) 1
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
P a g e | 10
SCC 536, the Hon’ble Apex Court held that handing over the
grounds of detention to detenu in an alien language frustrates his
right to make an effective representation.
21.
The detenu, in the instant case, is an illiterate, as
submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner. By virtue of the
decisions referred supra, oral explanation or oral translation of
the grounds of detention would not amount to communicating the
grounds to a detenu. The respondent authorities have not
produced any document to show that the grounds of detention
have been furnished to the detenu in writing in a language which
he understands. In the communication dated 26.10.2022, the
Superintendent, Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa, has stated as
under:
“… a copy of the Grounds of detention along
with relevant documents was served to the
detenu namely, Mohamed Kabir (31 years) S/o
(L) Md. Hassan Khan of Lilong Chingkham
Maning,
PO/PS-Lilong,
Thoubal
District,
Manipur and obtained his acknowledgement
receipt in all the connected documents of
the copy marked “O/C” in token of receipt
after
translating
the
contents
in
the
language known to him on 24/10/2022 at 6.30
PM….”
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
P a g e | 11
In the order dated 24.10.2022, an endorsement has
been made to the following effect:
“Received a similar copy and I understand
all the contents.”
But, in the grounds of detention in page 1 of the writ
petition it is mentioned only as :
“Md. Kabir Ali Date 24/10/2022 Time : 6:30 P.M.”
21.
As this Court doubted the very endorsement made
by the detenu to the aforesaid effect, the respondent authorities
were directed to produce the original files. On perusal of the
original file pertaining to the detention of the detenu, firstly, we
have not found any document to show that the grounds of
detention were translated and given to the detenu in the
language which he understands. The endorsement, referred
supra, only seems to be a subsequent insertion by the
respondent authorities. The respondents have miserably failed
to show that the grounds of detention and relied upon documents
were communicated to the detenu in the language known to him.
22.
The action of the respondent authorities falls foul of
the constitutional made under Article 22(5) of the Constitution of
India and is also against the dictum laid down by the Hon’ble
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
P a g e | 12
Apex Court in the judgments referred supra.
The ultimate
conclusion this court can infer is that the entire procedure
adopted by the respondent authorities reeks of malafide and
reveals a complete non-application of mind.
23.
In view of the major flaw in the orders passed by the
respondent authorities which has been referred supra, the other
grounds urged by learned counsel for the petitioner become
purely academic and are not necessary to be dealt with in the
present writ petition.
24.
For the foregoing reasons, the writ petition is
allowed and the detention order No.H-3301/101/2022-HD-HD,
dated 21.10.2022 passed by the Special Secretary (Home),
Government of Manipur and its confirmation order dated
26.12.2022 passed by the Commissioner (Home), Government
of Manipur, stand quashed and the detenu is set at liberty. The
respondents are directed to release the detenu forthwith, unless
his detention is otherwise required as per law in any other case.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(Cril.) No. 31 of 2023
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review