Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MNHC:180
Item no. 141 & 142
REPORTABLE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Crl. Rev. P. No. 9 of 2026
with
MC(Crl. Rev. P.) No. 22 of 2026
[Ref: Special Trial Case No. 16 of 2025]
Mrs. Leila @ Fajitun, aged about 45 years, W/o Md.
Fajurruddin, Keirao Makting Mayai Leikai, P.O. Singjamei
and P.S. Irilbung, Imphal East District, Manipur at present
residing at Kshetri Awang Litan Makhong, Iril Turel Mapan,
P.O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur
…. Petitioner
- Versus 1. The State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner
Home Government of Manipur, New Secretariat, Western
Block, Babupara, Imphal, Manipur 795001.
2. The Officer in Charge, Porompat Police Station, Imphal East,
Manipur-795005
…. Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(Oral)
17.08.2026
[1]
Heard Mrs. G. Pushpa, learned counsel along with Ms. Th.
Ranjeeta, learned counsel on behalf of the petitioner and Mr. H. Samarjit, learned
PP assisted by Mr. W. Niranjit, learned Dy. GA on behalf of the State respondents.
2026:MNHC:180
[2]
The important question of law arisen in the present petition is
regarding ‘jurisdiction of a trial Court in a criminal trial to recall the plea of guilty
of an accused recorded under Section 228(2) of Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 (in short, CrPC) [now, Section 251(2) of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023 (in short, BNSS)] and order of conviction on such plea of guilty
passed under Section 229 of CrPC (now, Section 252 of BNSS); and procedures
to be followed by trial Court while convicting an accused on plea of guilty without
conducting a full trial involving examination of witnesses, the accused and after
hearing both the prosecution and accused parties’.
[3]
The petitioner (Mrs. Leila @ Fajitun) and one, Md. Sabir Khan @
Somi are accused nos. 1 & 2 in FIR No. 10(01)2020 Porompat P.S., Imphal East
under Sections 21(b)/22(b) of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act,
1985 (NDPS Act). The petitioner herein was arrested on 13.01.2020 and released
on bail on 17.01.2020.
[4]
On 11.03.2026, learned Special Court (ND&PS), Manipur at
Lamphelpat framed charges against the petitioner under Sections 21(b) & 22(b)
of the ND&PS Act. The petitioner herein, who is an accused no. 1, pleaded guilty
and accused no. 2 did not plead guilty and claimed to be tried. On the same day,
i.e., on 11.03.2026, accused no. 1, the petitioner herein, was convicted by the
learned Special Judge (ND&PS), Manipur under Sections 21(b) & 22(b) of the ND
& PS Act on her plea of gulity and fixed on 16.03.2026 for hearing on sentence;
and on 27.03.2026 for prosecution witnesses with respect to the accused no. 2.
On 11.03.2026, the petitioner was taken into custody and since then, she was in
custody, post-conviction on her plea of guilty by an order dated 11.03.2026.
[5]
Admittedly, after conviction on plead guilty, on 16.03.2026 the
petitioner filed an application, being Cril. Misc. Bail Application No. 67 of 2026
under Section 229 of CrPC/Section 252 of BNSS, for allowing her to retract from
the plea of guilty made on 11.03.2026. It is stated in para nos. 2 and 7 of the
application dated 16.03.2026 that the plea of guilty was made under wrong
assumption and understanding of facts and law; and she was not aware of the
2026:MNHC:180
outcome of such plea of guilty; and in the circumstances, the application was
made to retract from the plea of guilty and prayed that petitioner be tried as per
law.
[6]
However, by the impugned order dated 23.03.2026, the
application being Cril. Misc. Case No. 67 of 2026 in Special Trial Case No. 16 of
2025 was dismissed on the ground that the Special Court (ND&PS) has no power
and jurisdiction to recall recording of the plea of guilty by petitioner/accused no.
1 under Section 228(2) of CrPC and to recall the conviction order dated
11.03.2026. It was held in para 7 of the impugned that ‘… It is a well settled
law that a criminal Court has no power to alter or review its own order except to
correct a clerical/arithmetical error.’ The petitioner challenged the impugned
order dated 23.03.2026 by way of present petition under Section 36(B) of ND &
PS read with Section 442 of BNSS/401 of CrPC, for setting aside the order dated
23.03.2026 passed by learned Special Court (ND&PS), Manipur. Before the
Special Court, the petitioner relied on the decision of Gauhati High Court in the
case of ‘Samanungba vs. State of Nagaland: 2024 Legal Eagle (GHC)
(Gau) 156’ the same was also rejected in the judgment as not applicable. In a
similarly factual circumstances, in the case of Samanungba, the plea of guilty
made before the Special Court (ND&PS) was intended to be retracted and the
same was rejected by the trial Court. However, Gauhati High Court, in exercise
of inherent and revisional power, allowed the petition on the ground that there
was lacking of voluntariness in the plea of guilty made by the accused and also
failure to comply with the mandatory provisions of ND&PS Act. In the present
case at hand, learned Special Judge (ND&PS), Manipur held that the decision of
Gauhati High Court in Samanungba (supra) does not lay down the proposition
that the Special Court has power to retract the plea of guilty recorded by it and
also to recall the order of conviction on such plea.
[7]
On 31.03.2026, this Court issued notice to the present petition
and also stayed further proceeding of the trial Court. During the pendency of the
present petition, the petitioner also filed an application being MC (Cril. Rev. P.)
No. 22 of 2026 for staying of the conviction order and releasing her on bail.
2026:MNHC:180
[8]
The petitioner has also filed another application being MC(Crl.
Rev. P.) No. 15 of 2026 under Section 528 of BNSS praying for allowing to amend
the Cril. Revision Petition No. 9 of 2026 at para no. 2, prayer portion and for
filing a copy of impugned conviction order dated 11.03.2026 passed in Spl. Trial
No. 16 of 2025 by learned Special Court (ND&PS), Manipur. The application was
made on the ground that at the time of filing of the Cril. Revision Petition No. 9
of 2026 before this Court, there was no conviction order dated 11.03.2026 in the
file of the Special Court (ND&PS), Manipur and as such, a copy of the same could
not be annexed by the petitioner. In the present application, the prayer is made
to place on record copy of the order dated 23.03.2026 and order dated
11.03.2026 passed by the learned Special Court, ND&PS, Manipur on the record
of present petition; by an order dated 13.07.2026, the afore-mentioned prayer
was allowed; and subsequently, the petitioner filed re-cast petition along with
the additional documents as prayed for. The order dated 13.07.2026 has attained
finality.
[9]
Mrs. G. Pushpa, learned counsel for the petitioner has raised
2(two) points in the present petition- (i) without fully knowing the effect and
implication of recording a plea of guilty, the petitioner herein, took the plea of
guilty on the 2 charges framed against her under Sections 21(b) & 22(b) of the
ND&PS Act on the wrong assumption that lenient view would be taken in her
case;
and by such plea and she would be released on the period already
undergone; & (ii) while convicting the petitioner by order dated 11.03.2026, the
learned Special Court (ND&PS), Manipur has failed to exercise its discretion
prudently to believe that the plea of guilty recorded by the petitioner, was
genuine and on clear understanding of all implications. It is highlighted that one
line conviction order (as passed in the present case in order dated 11.03.2026)
does not satisfy the statutory requirements of Section 229 of CrPC imposed on a
trial Court, while convicting an accused on plea of guilty without conducting a
full trial.
[10]
The learned counsel for the petitioner refers to the decision of
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of ‘State of Maharashtra vs. Sukhdev
2026:MNHC:180
Singh and Anr.’ reported in (1992) 3 SCC 700’ at para 52 to the point that
plea of guilty is only an admission of fact and before convicting on such plea, the
Court has to satisfy that the plea recorded by the accused must be clear,
unambiguous and on full understanding of all implication. On being satisfied with
genuineness of the plea of guilty with clear understanding of all circumstances
and results, the Court may convict an accused on such plea. She has further
pointed out that the trial Judge has not applied mind for convicting the accused
on plea of guilty and without following procedural safeguards. The learned
counsel for the petitioner also refers to another decision of Gauhati High Court
in the case of ‘Nilima Bose vs. State of Assam & Ors.’ reported in 2022
Legal Eagle (GHC) 661: 2023 (1) GLT 458 at para 42 to the point that plea
of guilty is an admission of fact on which charge is founded and before convicting
an accused, it must be established that all the facts of which charge is found as
well as guilt in respect of them. A scanned reproduction of relevant para is
reproduced below:
[11]
It is also alleged by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the
conviction order dated 11.03.2026 is a post-dated conviction order. When the
learned counsel for the petitioner inspected the file of the trial Court for
preferring the present revision petition, there was no such order; and hence a
2026:MNHC:180
copy of the order dated 11.03.2026 could not be annexed with the petition filed
by her and the same was brought on record by way of MC(Cril.Rev.P.) No. 15 of
2026. It is submitted that since the learned trial Court has failed to exercise
statutory requirement under section 229 of the CrPC/252 of BNSS, the conviction
order dated 11.03.2026 is liable to be set aside and petitioner be permitted to
face trial as per law. It is further prayed that she may be released on bail after
setting aside the conviction order dated 11.03.2026 based on her plea of guilty.
[12]
On the other hand, Mr. H. Samarjit, learned PP submits that in
the petition filed before this Court as well as in the application for retraction
being Cril. Misc. Case No. 67 of 2026 filed before the trial Court, it is admitted
by the petitioner herself that the learned Judge has explained to her about the
charge in the language known to her and after fully knowing, she recorded the
plea of guilty; and the counsel for the petitioner was also present at that time.
It is explained that it would be wrong to allege that the trial Judge has failed to
explain the nature of the charge and record shows otherwise. In the impugned
conviction order dated 11.03.2026 at para 6, the plea guilty of the petitioner
herein is reproduced and upon being satisfied of all the circumstances, the
petitioner was convicted under Sections 21(b) and 22(b) of the ND&PS Act. It is
submitted that there is no infirmity in order of conviction dated 11.03.2026, as
the subjective satisfaction mandated under Section 229 of the CrPC has been
complied with by the learned trial Court. Learned PP has also pointed out that
learned trial Judge was right in holding that the trial Court has no power to allow
to retract the recording of plea of guilty by an accused and conviction of such
plea of guilty; and the application for recall was rightly rejected. He further
submits that there is no merit and present petition may be dismissed on this
ground alone. The plea of non-existence of conviction order dated 11.03.2026
and the same being a post-dated order, is only an allegation without any
substance.
[13]
Learned PP also refers to the same decision of Hon’ble Supreme
Court reported in (1992) 3 SCC 700 at para 52 to emphasize that the
requirements under Section 229 of CrPC as mentioned in the same para, have
2026:MNHC:180
fully been complied with by the trial Court by recording the plea of guilty;
explanation was given to the petitioner in the language known to her; and having
been satisfied about the genuineness of plea of guilty in presence of her counsel,
she was convicted. Learned PP submits that there is no legal infirmity in the
impugned order dated 11.03.2026 and application for retraction of plea of guilty
was rightly rejected as the trial Court has no jurisdiction to do so.
[14]
The points for determination involved in the present case
are(i)
Whether trial Court, especially Special Court
(ND&PS), Manipur has jurisdiction to recall recording of
the plea of guilty of accused no. 1 recorded under
Section 229 of CrPC/Section 251 of BNSS in charge order
dated 11.03.2026 and subsequent conviction order
dated 11.03.2026 on such plea of guilty under Section
229 of CrPC/Section 252 of BNNS?
(ii) Whether the conviction on plea of guilty vide order
dated 11.03.2026 satisfies the mandatory provisions of
Section 229 of Cr.P.C./252 of BNSS?
[15]
This Court has gone through in detail the impugned order dated
23.03.2026 and decision of Gauhati High Court in the case of Samanungba
(supra) cited before the Special Court (ND&PS), Manipur. In Samanungba,
conviction order was passed on the basis of plea of guilty; and later on, the
application for retraction of plea of guilty was rejected by the Special Court.
However, Gauhati High Court set aside the conviction order on the ground that
plea of guilty was not made voluntarily and without understanding of the nature
of the allegation. This Court agrees with the observations made by the learned
Special Court, Manipur in para 7 & 8 of the impugned order dated 23.03.2026 to
the points that the decision in Samanungba is not a proposition to the point
that Special Court, ND&PS, Manipur has power to recall and review the order of
recording of plea of guilty and subsequent conviction on such plea. The scanned
2026:MNHC:180
copy of relevant para nos. 7 & 8 in order dated 23.03.2026 are reproduced
below:
[16]
Accordingly, first point is decided to the effect that a trial Court
including the Court of Special Judge (ND&PS), Manipur, has no jurisdiction and
power to recall the recording of plea of guilty of an accused under Section 228(2)
of CrPC/Section 251(2) of BNSS and conviction on such plea of guilty exercising
the power conferred under Section 229 of CrPC/Section 252 of BNSS. However,
it is clarified that such plea of retracting is amenable to revisional jurisdiction of
higher courts.
[17]
With respect to the second point that the plea of guilty was
genuine or not, it will be relevant to reproduce the provision of Section 228(2)
of CrPC.
Section 228: Framing of Charge
(1)
……………….
(2)
Where the Judge frames any charge under clause (b) of subsection (1), the charge shall be read and explained to the accused and
accused shall be asked whether he pleads guilty of the offence charged
or claims to be tried.
Section 229: Conviction on plea of guilty
2026:MNHC:180
If the accused pleads guilty, the Judge shall record the plea and
may, in his discretion, convict him thereon.
[18]
On perusal of sub-clause 2 of Section 228 of CrPC, it is clear that
after framing of charge, the Judge has to explain the nature and implication of
charge to the accused and accused shall be asked whether he/she pleads guilty
or not; if the accused does not plead guilty, he/she will face trial; and if pleads
claim guilty, the Court may convict him under Section 229 of CrPC without
proceeding further. It will be relevant to refer the law propounded by Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Sukhdev Singh (supra) at para 52. In that case
Hon’ble Supreme Court says that the plea of guilty is nothing but an admission
of fact and upon recording of such fact, the trial Court has to embark upon a
proceeding where, it should be satisfied that the accused makes the plea of guilty
with clear understanding of the circumstances; such plea should not be
conditional; and should not be made on ambiguous understanding of the nature
of plea. The scanned copy of relevant para 52 is reproduced below:
2026:MNHC:180
[19]
In the case of Nilima Bose (supra), Gauhati High Court in para
42, 43, 63 & 64 held that before an accused be convicted, it must be established
by trial Court that he has admitted the fact on which charge is found, guilty in
respect of them. Plea must be on clear understanding and in serious offence,
extra care should be taken and in ‘para 63 & 64’ it is held that voluntariness of
the plea of guilty must be examined. The aforesaid relevant paras are reproduced
below:
“43. Thus, in cases involving serious offences, it has been
highlighted that though the plea of guilt can be the basis for
conviction, before the order of conviction is passed on the basis
of the plea of guilty, the Court must ensure that the accused
who pleads guilty has been doing so with full knowledge and
was also aware of the consequences of his plea.
44. Therefore, what can be said is that though an accused can
be convicted on his pleading guilty, yet, the Court must exercise
due care and caution to ensure that such a plea had been taken
by the accused voluntarily and with full knowledge and
understanding of the implications, more so, when it relates to
serious offence, for which the Court must also consider the
attending and surrounding circumstances.
63. That apart, we have also noted a significant irregularity in
the proceeding.
The impugned order dated 21.01.2016 records that "considering
the materials on record, Charge under Sec. 14 of Foreigners Act,
1946, is framed against the accused Amit Bose and the contents
of the same is read over and explained to the accused, to which
he pleaded guilty." However, there is nothing on record to show
that such charge was framed as mentioned in the impugned
order. The original record requisitioned contains 30 pages and
we have gone through each and every page. Though chargesheet prepared by the prosecution which was submitted to the
Magistrate, on 18.01.2016 is in the record, yet, there is no
document or record in which framing of charge against accused
is recorded. What is the exact charge framed against the
petitioner's son? There is no such framing of charge in the
record. This itself indicates that the Magistrate proceeded
2026:MNHC:180
against the accused in a hurry. It is difficult to assess the plea of
guilty without reference to the charge framed. In the present
case, we are not able to find the charge framed against the
petitioner's son. Non-availability of document indicating framing
of charge on the record is one of the factors which has been
taken into consideration by this Court in coming to the
conclusion that the Magistrate appeared to have proceeded
against the accused in posthaste to convict the accused on the
said plea of guilty.
As discussed above, the manner in which the learned Magistrate
proceeded to convict the accused, it does not appear that the
plea of guilt was made by the accused voluntarily and after
understanding the consequences thereof.
64. There is nothing on record to indicate that the Magistrate
had taken due care and caution to make the accused understand
that what he was stating before the Court had been made
voluntarily and that he made the statement having fully
understood the implications thereof.”
[20]
It may be appropriate to refer a decision of Division Bench of this
Court in the case of Krishna Bhandari vs. State of Manipur in Crl. A. No. 23
of 2025 dated 11.05.2026. In that case while recording the plea of guilty, the
accused also asked to be tried as per law. However, on such plea of guilty the
accused was convicted by one line order. Division Bench of this Court set aside
the conviction under Section 302 IPC as the plea of guilty was not genuine; and
remanded the matter to be tried afresh, as if the accused did not plead guilty.
In the factual matrix of the present case, it is admitted that on 11.03.2026, the
petitioner, who is an accused no. 1, pleaded guilty and on the basis of such plea
of guilty, the petitioner was convicted under Sections 21(b) & 22(b) of the ND&PS
Act. While recording the conviction, the plea of guilty and explanation by the
Court has been has been recorded in the order of conviction dated 11.03.2026.
[21]
This Court is of the view that up to this stage, the first
requirement of the provisions of Section 229 of CrPC that the Judge shall record
the plea of guilty is satisfied. However, it is a settled proposition of law that a
plea of guilty by the accused does not mandatorily amount to conviction for the
2026:MNHC:180
said offence; and it will be indicated by the second part of Section 229 of CrPC,
which lays down a Court may convict an accused on such plea, if the Court is
otherwise satisfied that the plea was made with clear understanding of the
offences and implications thereof. In the present case, after making plea of guilty
on 11.03.2026, the petitioner immediately filed an application i.e. Cril. Misc. Case
No. 67 of 2026 on 16.03.2026 for recalling the plea of guilty on the ground that
she was under a mistaken impression and was not fully aware of the nature of
the plea made by her. The scanned copy of the relevant para nos. 2 & 7 of the
aforesaid application are reproduced below for clarity:
[22]
From the above quoted para 2 & 7 of the application, it is clear
as daylight that at the time of making plea of guilty on 11.03.2026, the petitioner
was not fully aware of the nature of the charge and the consequence of plead
guilty; and the same was made under the impression that a lenient view would
be taken. Later on, she came to know that she would be liable to be sentenced
with a maximum imprisonment of 10 years. In the circumstances, the application
for retraction and recall of the plea of guilty was made. However, the same was
rejected by the learned Special Court (ND&PS), Manipur, as it does not have any
jurisdiction for retraction of the plea of guilty and conviction made on such plea.
[23]
This Court is of the view that reading together ‘paras 2 & 7’ of the
application made by her before the trial Court post-conviction on plea of guilty,
it appears that petitioner did not have a clear understanding about the plea of
2026:MNHC:180
guilty made by her, implications and the subsequent effect on her; perhaps she
made the plea expecting a lenient view from the Court. On perusal of the
conviction order dated 11.03.2026, it is evident that conviction order is ‘one and
half line’ which means that the trial Judge did not exercise the discretion
conferred on it by the mandatory provisions of Section 229 of CrPC, as explained
by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Sukhdev Singh (supra). It is not in
dispute that recording the plea of guilty by the accused is nothing but an
admission of the fact; however, before convicting on the plea of guilty in exercise
of the power under Section 229 of the CrPC without going into full trial, it is the
duty of the trial Court to have a subjective satisfaction to all the factual
circumstances that the plea is genuine or is made on clear understanding of the
offences and all the consequent results of such plea. Making an application for
retraction shows that the plea of guilty made by the petitioner, is without
complete understanding of the nature of plea including the consequence thereof.
[24]
In the circumstances, this Court is of the view that the second
limb of the mandatory provisions of Section 229 of CrPC is not satisfied in the
present case. Hence, the conviction order dated 11.03.2026 passed by the
learned Special Judge (ND & PS), Manipur in Special Trial Case No. 16 of 2025
is set aside qua the petitioner herein, who is an accused no. 1 (Mrs. Leila @
Fajitun); and she be tried afresh, as if she did not plead guilty. Matter is
remanded to the learned Special Judge (ND&PS), Manipur for proceeding as per
law. Both accused no. 1 (the petitioner herein) and accused no. 2 (Md. Sabir
Khan @ Somi) are directed to be tried together for the offences charged order
dated 11.03.2026 against them, as if both did not plead guilty. Since the
petitioner is in custody post-conviction order dated 11.03.2026, she be
immediately released from the custody, if not required in any other case, on
the same conditions as contained in the bail order dated 17.01.2020 passed by
the trail Court.
[25]
With these observations, the Cril. Rev. Pet. No. 9 of 2026 is
allowed, conviction order dated 11.03.2026 is set aside; and matter is remanded
for retrial, as directed supra. All pending applications are disposed of accordingly.
2026:MNHC:180
[26]
Send a copy of this order to the (i) Special Judge (ND&PS),
Manipur for information and proceeding as per law, & (ii) Superintendent of
Manipur Central Jail, Imphal for effecting release of the petitioner. Further,
Registry is directed to make available a copy of this order to the learned counsel
appearing for the parties.
[27]
Registry is also directed to send a copy of this order to the
Director, Manipur Judicial Academy with a request for imparting awareness of
this decision on Sections 228/229 of CrPC (now, Sections 251/251 of BNSS) to
all Judicial Officers.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Thoiba
signed by
KHOIROM Digitally
KHOIROM
BIPINCHAN BIPINCHANDRA
SINGH
2026.08.18
DRA SINGH Date:
17:15:52 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review