Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2026.06.26 13:31:03 +05'30'
REPORTABLE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Sl. No. 1
W.P.(Crl.) No. 20 of 2026
Ashish Joseph aged about 38 S/o Surinder Joseph R/O 27-A,
Third Floor L/S, Front Portion, Masjid Moth, Near Uday Park,
VTC: Andrewsganj, PO: Andrewsganj, South Delhi, NEW
DELHI-110049.
... Petitioner
Versus
1.
The State of Manipur represented by Chief Secretary
Government of Manipur, P.O. Mantripukhri & P.S.
Heingang, Imphal East, MANIPUR -795002.
2.
The Superintendent of Police Imphal West, P.O. & P.S.
IMPHAL, Manipur – 795113.
3.
The Officer-in-Charge, Patsoi Police Station, PO.
Langjing Achouba & PS Patsoi, Imphal West, Manipur795113.
4.
Sarangthem Pushparani Devi (DETENU) aged about
30 D/O Pradeepkumar Singh.
5.
Pradeep Kumar Singh (father of the Detenu).
6.
MS. NG. Ibetombi Devi W/o Pradeep Kumar Singh
(mother of the detenu)
Respondent Nos. 4 to 6 are all
resident of Patsoi Part-I, Patsoi
Sub-Division,
PO.
Langjing
Achouba & PS Patsoi, Imphal
West, Manipur – 795113.
... Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For petitioner
For respondent Nos. 5 and 6
Mr. Kuldeep Singh Grewal,
Advocate along with Ms. Soniya
Panwar and
Mr.
Dayali
Elangbam,
Advocates
Mr. RK Umakanta, senior
advocate
and
Public
Prosecutor, State of Manipur
instructed by Mr. W. Niranjit,
State Counsel
Mr. Ng. Somorjit, Advocate
Date of Order
25.06.2026
For respondent Nos. 1 to 3
ORDER
[M. Sundar, CJ]
[1]
Read this in conjunction with and in continuation of order
dated 22.06.2026 made in the captioned WP which reads as follows :
‘REPORTABLE
Sl. No. 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P.(Crl.) No. 20 of 2026
Ashish Joseph aged about 38 S/o Surinder Joseph
R/O 27-A, Third Floor L/S, Front Portion, Masjid
Moth, Near Uday Park, VTC: Andrewsganj, PO:
Andrewsganj, South Delhi, NEW DELHI110049.
... Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Manipur represented by Chief
Secretary Government of Manipur, P.O.
Mantripukhri & P.S. Heingang, Imphal East,
MANIPUR -795002.
2. The Superintendent of Police Imphal West, P.O.
& P.S. IMPHAL, Manipur – 795113.
3. The Officer-in-Charge, Patsoi Police Station, PO.
Langjing Achouba & PS Patsoi, Imphal West,
Manipur- 795113.
4. Sarangthem Pushparani Devi (DETENU) aged
about 30 D/O Pradeepkumar Singh.
5. Pradeep Kumar Singh (father of the Detenu).
6. MS. NG. Ibetombi Devi W/o Pradeep Kumar
Singh (mother of the detenu)
Respondent Nos. 4 to 6 are all
resident of Patsoi Part-I, Patsoi
Sub-Division,
PO.
Langjing
Achouba & PS Patsoi, Imphal West,
Manipur – 795113.
... Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL
SINGH
For respondent Nos. 5 and 6
Mr. Kuldeep Singh Grewal, Advocate
along with Mr. Dayali Elangbam,
Advocate
Mr. RK Umakanta, senior advocate
and Public Prosecutor, State of
Manipur instructed by Mr. W.
Niranjit, State Counsel
Mr. Ng. Somorjit, Advocate
Date of Judgment & Order
22.06.2026
For petitioner
For respondent Nos. 1 to 3
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(ORAL)
[M. Sundar, CJ]
[1]
This order will now dispose of the captioned WP (Writ
Petition).
[2]
This order is to be read in conjunction with and in
continuation of proceedings/orders made in the previous listing on
20.06.2026 which reads as follows:
‘Suppl.-1, Sl. No. 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P.(Crl.) No. 20 of 2026
Ashish Joseph aged about 38 S/o Surinder Joseph
R/O 27-A, Third Floor L/S, Front Portion, Masjid
Moth, Near Uday Park, VTC: Andrewsganj, PO:
Andrewsganj, South Delhi, NEW DELHI110049.
... Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Manipur represented by Chief
Secretary Government of Manipur, P.O.
Mantripukhri & P.S. Heingang, Imphal East,
MANIPUR -795002.
2. The Superintendent of Police Imphal West, P.O.
& P.S. IMPHAL, Manipur – 795113.
3. The Officer-in-Charge, Patsoi Police Station, PO.
Langjing Achouba & PS Patsoi, Imphal West,
Manipur- 795113.
4. Sarangthem Pushparani Devi (DETENU) aged
about 30 D/O Pradeepkumar Singh.
5. Pradeep Kumar Singh (father of the Detenu).
6. MS. NG. Ibetombi Devi W/o Pradeep Kumar
Singh (mother of the detenu)
Respondent Nos. 4 to 6 are all
resident of Patsoi Part-I, Patsoi
Sub-Division,
PO.
Langjing
Achouba & PS Patsoi, Imphal West,
Manipur – 795113.
... Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
(ORDER)
(Order of the Court was made by Mr. M. Sundar, CJ)
20.06.2026
[1]
Mr. Kuldeep Singh Grewal and Mr. Dayali
Elangbam, learned counsel on record for the writ
petitioner is before this Court (physical Court). To be
noted, the writ petitioner is before this Court on the
Video Conferencing (V.C.) platform.
[2]
Captioned WP (Writ Petition) has been filed
with a habeas corpus plea alleging that R4 (Sarangthem
Pushparani Devi), daughter of
Pradeepkumar Singh
(R5), aged about 30 years has been illegally detained by
her parents i.e., R5 and R6. To be noted, ‘R4’, ‘R5’ and
‘R6’ denote ‘fourth respondent’, ‘fifth respondent’ and
‘sixth
respondent’
respectively
and
similar
abbreviation/short form is being used for other
respondents also.
[3]
To be noted, R4 is being referred to as
‘detainee’ solely for the sake of
convenience and the
same shall not be construed as expression of any opinion
one way or the other in this order.
[4]
The case of the writ petitioner is that the writ
petitioner and detainee met in Delhi, they have known
each other for over 4 (four) years now, they have decided
to get married, writ petitioner’s parents and detainee’s
parents have met and parents of both (detainee and writ
petitioner) are aware of intended marriage. Detainee, in
March of 2026 was requested by R6 to come over to
Imphal for making purchases for wedding, detainee
travelled from Delhi to Imphal on 29.03.2026 but
thereafter, the writ petitioner alleges that instead of
taking steps for marriage, the detainee has been illegally
detained against her will by her parents and detainee is
being forced to completely detach herself from the writ
petitioner. It is the further specific case of writ petitioner
that detainee is being illegally detained incommunicado
and when she managed to lay her hands on her mobile
phone, she made a call to the writ petitioner on
23.05.2026. It is also the case of the writ petitioner that
a purported self-declaration has been extracted from the
detainee involuntarily by coercion on 30.05.2026.
[5]
To be noted, the writ petitioner approached
Hon’ble Supreme Court inter-alia by resorting to Article
32 of the Constitution of India and Hon’ble Supreme
Court vide order dated 12.06.2026 made in Writ Petition
(Criminal) No. 229 of 2026 reserved the right of the writ
petitioner to invoke writ jurisdiction of this Court,
pursuant to which captioned WP has been presented in
this Court on 19.06.2026.
[6]
Prima facie case for issue of notice made
out.
[7]
Issue notice to all respondents.
[8]
Mr. W. Niranjit Singh, learned State
Counsel led by Mr. RK Umakanta, learned senior
advocate and learned State Public Prosecutor, is present
in Court and Mr. W. Niranjit Singh, learned State
Counsel, accepts notice for official respondents R1 to
R3. This Court is informed that R5 and R6 reside within
the jurisdiction of the police station i.e., Patsoi police
station and the Officer-in-Charge of this Patsoi police
station is R3. Besides, notice in conventional mode/s to
R4 to R6, State Counsel shall communicate this order to
R4 to R6 through R3 forthwith.
[9]
Learned State Public Prosecutor to ensure
that R4 (detainee) is produced in this Court through/by
R3 on Monday (22.06.2026).
[10]
List under a suitable cause list caption on
Monday.
[11]
List on 22.06.2026.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sushil
P.S. I : Upload forthwith
P.S. II : All concerned will stand bound by instant
order vide web copy uploaded in High Court
website inter-alia as the same is QR coded.’
[3]
Pursuant to afore-referred earlier proceedings/orders of this
Court, today R-3 Mr. Soram Sarat Kumar, MPS (Proby), Officer-incharge, Patsoi Police Station along with Ms. M. Dhaneshwori Devi,
Ms. Th. Manileima Devi and Ms. W. Debala Devi, Women
Constables of Patsoi Police Station were in Court and they produced
R-4 (detainee). To be noted, short forms/abbreviations used in earlier
proceedings/orders continue to be used in instant order for the sake
of convenience and clarity.
[4]
R-5 and R-6 were also present in Court and they are
represented by Mr. Ng. Somorjit, learned counsel. As regards R-1 to
R-3 (official respondents), Mr. RK. Umakanta, learned senior
advocate and Public Prosecutor, State of Manipur instructed by Mr.
W. Niranjit Singh, learned State counsel is before this Court.
[5]
As regards the writ petitioner, he is before this Court on the
Video Conferencing (VC) platform and his counsel Mr. Kuldeep
Singh Grewal and Mr. Dayali Elangbam are before this Court
(physical Court).
[6]
Considering the nature of the matter, facts and circumstances
of the case, this Court deemed it appropriate to have the statement of
R-4 recorded in-camera rather than in open court. The same was done
(after interaction of R-4 with members of this Division Bench) by
learned Registrar (Vigilance) of this Court who is a serving woman
District Judge in the District Judiciary of Manipur.
[7]
R-4, who is clearly a major (29 years), as alluded to supra,
wants to go back to Delhi, pursue her career there and make her own
personal choice with regard to marriage. At the moment, she intends
to marry the writ petitioner.
[8]
R-4 has also made a statement that she would prefer that her
parents (R-5 and R-6) and other members of her family are not taken
to task though she is not now allowed to go out of her home alone
and though her laptop (Lenovo) and mobile phone (we refrain from
giving the mobile number in this judicial order) have been forcibly
taken away/snatched by her parents/brother and she has for all
practical purposes detained at home by R-5, R-6, her brother and
other members of her family for nearly three months now.
[9]
R-4 also made it clear that she does not want Mr. Ng.
Somorjit, learned counsel to appear for her as she involuntarily
signed in a paper (appears to be Vakalatnama) at the instance
of/insistence of R-5 and R-6. Mr. Ng. Somorjit, learned counsel very
fairly submitted that he would withdraw his Vakalatnama for R-4.
The Vakalatnama is determined dispensing with the formality of
filing a determination application. To be noted, this determination of
vakalatnama is owing to nature of the matter and this shall not serve
as precedent in all cases. Appointment of new counsel is not
necessary as matter is drawing to a close.
[10]
After recording of the aforesaid statement, this Court
resumed open court hearing and had interaction with R-5 and R-6 in
open Court.
[11]
This Court directed presence of R-2 and Mr. Ksh. Shivakanta
Singh, IPS, Superintendent of Police, Imphal West District, Manipur
is present in Court.
[12]
All the afore-referred counsel on both sides agreed to give a
closure to the captioned matter and abide by directions of this Court
which will be set out infra. To be noted, there will be a post disposal
ATR listing with a window to re-open the matter, if necessary. To be
noted, ‘ATR’ denotes ‘Action Taken Report’.
[13]
Mr. Kuldeep Singh Grewal and Mr. Dayali Elangbam,
learned counsel on record for the writ petitioner submitted, on
instructions, (after a telecon with writ petitioner) that the writ
petitioner who is now in Delhi will fly down to Imphal tomorrow and
will go with R-4 to Delhi. R-4 submitted in open Court, on her own
volition, that she will travel to Delhi with writ petitioner. R-2 is
directed to give adequate security/protection and ensure that writ
petitioner and R-4 are not harmed in any manner as it is submitted
that writ petitioner had received some threats. This Court makes it
clear that this observation is made as a matter of abundant caution
and as a direction is required to R-2 and therefore, this shall not be
read as an expression of any view or opinion on whether there was a
threat or not.
[14]
The statement given by R-4, Ms. Sarangthem Pushparani
Devi, (duly signed) is put in a sealed envelope and sealed envelope
shall now be in the custody of Registrar (Judicial) of this Court for
further/future reference, if there is any need. This course is adopted
as R-4 submitted that she does not want R-5, R-6 and her family
members to be put in difficulty because of her statement as long as
she is allowed to go to Delhi, pursue her career and marry writ
petitioner.
[15]
As regards the mobile phone and laptop of R-4, Mr. Ng.
Somorjit, learned counsel for R-5 and R-6, on instructions, very fairly
submitted that the mobile phone [this Court is informed that it is an
i-phone 11 (Red)] and Laptop [Lenovo] were taken away forcibly
from R-4, the devices are being brought to Court by her brother {son
of R-5 and R-6, Mr. Muktaraj Sarangthem} and that R-5, R-6 and
Mr. Muktaraj Sarangthem would handover the same i.e., mobile
phone and laptop to R3 who will in turn handover the same to R4
(detainee) today.
[16]
It is pertinent to record that at the request of R-6, R-6 and R-
4 (detainee) i.e., mother and daughter had substantial interaction for
considerable time in court and after interaction also R-4 reiterated her
statement/stand that she wants to leave for Delhi with writ petitioner,
pursue/continue her career and marry writ petitioner.
[17]
As R-4 and all concerned did not want to precipitate the
matter, the statement of R-4 is being kept in a sealed cover in custody
of Registrar (Judicial) as alluded to supra.
[18]
The following order is made:
(i)
R-2 shall now give adequate police protection/escort
to R-4 to go over to her residence at Patsoi Part – I,
near YMC Club, Imphal West, Manipur – 795113 and
take her personal effects including her marksheets and
other education related certificates. An inventory of
what she takes shall be made and maintained in
jurisdictional Police Station. This shall be done
forthwith i.e., today;
(ii)
R-4 will leave for Delhi tomorrow or day after
tomorrow
(23.06.2026
Tuesday
or
24.06.2206
Wednesday) with writ petitioner. R-2 shall provide
adequate police protection and security to R-4 and writ
petitioner to ensure that they board the flight to Delhi;
(iii)
R-4 till leaving for Delhi will stay in a place of her
choice, be it the residence of her friend/s or hotel and
R-2 shall ensure that adequate police protection is
given to R-4 and writ petitioner in their place of stay
until they board the flight.
[19]
Captioned WP disposed of as closed in the aforesaid manner.
[20]
Though captioned matter is disposed of in the aforesaid
manner, the same shall be listed under the caption ‘Action Taken
Report’ (‘ATR’) on Thursday (25.06.2026) and R-2 shall file an ATR
on that day.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sushil/Bipin
FR/NFR
P.S. I : Upload forthwith
P.S. II : All concerned will stand bound by instant order
vide web copy uploaded in High Court website
inter-alia as the same is QR coded.’
[2]
Pursuant to aforesaid order dated 22.06.2026, captioned
matter is listed before this Court today under the cause list caption ‘FOR
ACTION TAKEN REPORT’.
[3]
On behalf of writ petitioner, counsel on record Mr. Dayali
Elangbam is present in Court (physical Court) and his co-counsel Mr.
Kuldeep Singh Grewal, learned counsel on record along with Ms. Soniya
Panwar is before this Court on the Video Conferencing (V.C.) platform. As
regards R1 to R3, Mr. W. Niranjit Singh, learned State Counsel led by Mr.
RK Umakanta, learned senior counsel and learned State Public Prosecutor
is before this Court (physical Court). As regards R5 and R6, Mr. Ng.
Somorjit, learned counsel is before this Court (physical Court).
[4]
To be noted, R4 is now in Delhi and Mr. Kuldeep Singh
Grewal, learned counsel on record for writ petitioner along with Ms. Soniya
Panwar is before this Court on the Video Conferencing (VC) platform as
alluded to supra, writ petitioner and R4 (detainee) are present along with
them. Mr. Kuldeep Singh Grewal submits that he is addressing this Court
on VC platform from his chambers in Delhi. To put it differently, writ
petitioner and R-4 are before this Court on the V.C. platform.
[5]
As regards ATR, an ATR signed by R3 has been placed before
this Court under cover of a letter dated 24.06.2026 bearing Reference No.
7/14/SP-IW/2026/11278 from R2 to learned State Counsel. To be noted,
learned counsel for writ petitioner and learned counsel for R5 and R6 have
been favoured with copies of ATR.
[6]
All the afore referred counsel, State Counsel, senior counsel
and State Public Prosecutor, counsel for writ petitioner, counsel for R-5
and R-6 as well as writ petitioner and R4 submit in one voice in unison
that afore referred order dated 22.06.2026 in captioned WP has been duly
complied.
[7]
Before writing the concluding paragraph, this Court deems it
appropriate to place on record its appreciation to all parties and their
counsel i.e., writ petitioner, official respondents, detainee (R4), parents of
detainee (R5 and R6) for taking a fair and balanced approach, particularly
R2, R3 and their team for deft and swift action and filing an ATR that
articulates the events and trajectory with absolute specificity and clarity
inter alia making it clear that afore-referred WP order has been duly
complied.
[8]
Recording due compliance, case file qua captioned matter is
consigned to records (to be noted, ‘consigned to records’ would mean that
Registry need not list this matter anymore) as the captioned WP has
already been disposed of vide afore referred order dated 22.06.2026.
However, statement of R-4 in sealed envelope will continue to be in safe
custody of learned Registrar (Judicial) of this Court.
JUDGE
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
P.S. I : Upload forthwith
P.S. II : All concerned will stand bound by instant order vide web
copy uploaded in High Court website inter-alia as the same
is QR coded.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review