The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. For the foregoing reasons, the grounds urged by the petitioner do not merit acceptance. The impugned detention order reflects due application of mind to the relevant material and the safeguards governing preventive detention have, in the facts placed before this Court, been substantially complied with and the impugned order is not vitiated in any manner, so as to warrant it to be quashed. P a g e | 10
17. The petition is, accordingly, dismissed along with pending application(s) and the impugned detention order is upheld.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
HCP No.21/2026
CM No.905/2026
Reserved on: 18.09.2026
Pronounced on: 25.09.2026
Uploaded on: ______________
Operative part or full judgment: Full
Tariq Ahmad Dar
S/O Ghulam Hassan Dar
R/O Raiwattan Asnoor, Manzgam
Tehsil D.H.Pora, District Kulgam.
…Petitioner(s)
Through: Adv. Parvaiz Amin.
Vs.
1. Union Territory of J&K
through Principal Secretary to Govt.
Home Department,
Civil Sectt. Srinagar.
2. District Magistrate,
Kulgam.
3. Sr. Superintendent of Police,
Kulgam.
4. Station House Officer,
Police Station, Manzgam, Kulgam.
5. Superintendent/Incharge District Jail,
Udhampur.
…Respondent(s)
Through: GA Waseem Gul.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M. A. CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. Through
the
medium
of
the
present
petition,
the
petitioner-detenue has called in question the detention
Page |2
Order No. 07/DMK/PSA/2025 dated 13.12.2025 passed
by respondent No.2-District Magistrate, Kulgam, whereby
he has been detained under Section 8 of the Jammu and
Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978 with a view to prevent
him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the
maintenance of ‘Public Order’.
2. Briefly stated facts of the case are that the detenue is
involved in as many as eleven FIRs for the commission of
offences punishable under Sections 331(4), 305 BNS,
relating to offences concerning theft of livestock/cattle;
that the detaining authority has noticed the repeated
involvement of the detenue in such activities; that the
charge-sheets have been filed in the cases and the detenue
has obtained bail in the said cases; that on consideration
of the entire material placed before it, the detaining
authority has recorded its subjective satisfaction that the
activities of the detenue are not isolated incidents affecting
merely an individual but have acquired such continuity
and potentiality as to disturb the even tempo of public life
and thereby adversely affect maintenance of ‘public order’.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner has assailed the
detention order on several grounds and has contended
that the activities attributed to the detenue constitute at
the highest, violations of ordinary law and order, and could
be dealt with under the ordinary criminal law; that the
detenue was arrested in all the criminal cases and in some
Page |3
of them was admitted to bail; that the bail orders referred
to in the grounds of detention were not supplied to the
detenue and consequently he was deprived of an effective
opportunity of making a representation; that the grounds
of detention are in English, whereas the detenue is stated
to be a Labourer by profession and not conversant with the
English language; that no translated copies of the grounds
were supplied to him and, therefore, the constitutional
guarantee contained in Article 22(5) of the Constitution of
India and the corresponding requirement under Section 13
of the Public Safety Act, stand violated.
4. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents, exadverso, defended the detention order and argued that the
detaining authority considered the entire material placed
before it and, upon an independent assessment thereof,
arrived at the requisite subjective satisfaction; that the
detenue was furnished the grounds of detention and the
relevant material and the contents thereof were explained
to him in a language understood by him; that the bail
orders were only referred to for indicating the present
status of the criminal cases and were not relied upon as
substantive material forming the basis of the subjective
satisfaction.
5. Heard learned counsel for both sides, perused the entire
material placed on record and considered the matter.
Page |4
6. Preventive detention is an exceptional measure, and the
safeguards contained in Article 22(5) of the Constitution
and Section 13 of the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety
Act have to be scrupulously observed. At the same time,
the scope of judicial review in preventive detention matters
is limited. The Court is required to examine whether the
constitutional
and
statutory
safeguards
have
been
complied with and whether the subjective satisfaction of
the detaining authority is founded upon relevant material.
The Court does not sit in appeal over the sufficiency of the
material or substitute its own satisfaction for that of the
detaining authority.
7. The
Supreme
Court
has
reiterated
that
preventive
detention is preventive and precautionary in character and
that the Court cannot substitute its own assessment for
the subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority,
provided the satisfaction is founded upon relevant material
and the statutory safeguards have been complied with. In
the present case, the material placed on record shows that
the detaining authority has not proceeded merely on the
basis of one isolated criminal case. The grounds refer to
eleven FIRs involving similar allegations concerning theft of
livestock/cattle and indicate repeated involvement of the
detenue in such activities. The fact that charge-sheets
have been filed and that the detenue has been enlarged on
bail in the criminal cases, has also been noticed.
Page |5
8. The mere fact that criminal proceedings are pending
against a person does not, by itself, preclude recourse to
preventive detention. Preventive detention operates in a
different
field.
The
relevant
question
is
whether,
notwithstanding the availability of ordinary criminal law,
the antecedent activities and their continuing tendency
furnish material for the satisfaction that the detenue is
required to be prevented from acting prejudicially to public
order.
9. It is true that there is a distinction between a mere
disturbance of ‘law and order’ and an activity prejudicial to
‘public order’. The distinction cannot be determined merely
by the nomenclature of the offence, the nature, frequency,
continuity
and
impact
of
the
activities
upon
the
community have to be considered. The Supreme Court has
emphasised that the question is whether the activities
affect the even tempo of public life and thereby transcend
the ordinary law-and-order domain. In the case on hand,
the detaining authority has relied upon the repeated
nature of the alleged activities, the number of criminal
cases and the continuing pattern attributed to the
detenue. The satisfaction recorded by the detaining
authority, therefore, cannot be characterised as being
founded upon a solitary or stale incident. This Court, while
exercising its limited jurisdiction in a Habeas Corpus
Petition, cannot substitute its own assessment of the
Page |6
material for the satisfaction recorded by the competent
authority.
10.
The contention regarding the bail orders also does
not, in the facts of the present case, persuade this Court to
invalidate the detention order. The grounds themselves
disclose that the detaining authority was conscious of the
fact that the detenue had been granted bail in the criminal
cases. Thus, the existence and effect of the bail orders
were not concealed from the detenue. The reference to the
bail orders in the grounds is essentially to demonstrate
that, notwithstanding his release in the criminal cases, the
detenue was at liberty and there existed an apprehension
of recurrence of the activities attributed to him.
11.
The position would undoubtedly be different if a
document which constituted the very foundation of the
subjective satisfaction was withheld from the detenue. The
constitutional requirement is that the material relied upon
by the detaining authority must be made available so as to
enable the detenue to make an effective representation. In
the present case, however, the bail orders, on the material
placed before this Court, have not been shown to
constitute such independent foundational material; their
substance/status is already reflected in the grounds
themselves.
12.
The
more
substantial
challenge
relates
to
the
language of the grounds. It is settled that the grounds of
Page |7
detention have to be communicated to the detenue in a
language which he understands so as to enable him to
make an effective representation. The Supreme Court has
reiterated that mere physical service of grounds in a
language not understood by the detenue would not satisfy
Article 22(5) of Indian Constitution. However, the question
in
every
such
case
is
ultimately
one
of
effective
communication and effective knowledge. The Court has
also
recognised
that
where
the
record
affirmatively
establishes the detenue's understanding of the language
and his actual knowledge of the grounds, the detention
cannot be invalidated on the basis of a purely formal
objection concerning the language of the document. In
Sarfaraz Alam v. Union of India reported as 2024 INSC
18, the Supreme Court found compliance with Article
22(5) on the basis of the contemporaneous record
demonstrating the detenue's knowledge of English and his
reading and understanding of the grounds and relevant
documents.
13.
In the present case, the material placed before the
Court
as
also
the
counter
Affidavit
filed
by
the
respondents, demonstrates that the contents of the
detention order and grounds were communicated and
explained to the detenue in a language understood by him
and that he was informed of his right to make a
representation. The petitioner has not been able to
Page |8
demonstrate any specific aspect of the grounds which
remained
beyond
his
comprehension
or
any
actual
prejudice occasioned to his right of representation. The
mere fact that the original grounds were prepared in
English cannot, in the circumstances of the present case,
be viewed in isolation from the manner in which the
grounds were actually communicated to the detenue and
the contemporaneous record relating to their service and
explanation. The constitutional requirement is directed
towards securing an effective opportunity of representation
and the Court has to examine the substance of compliance
rather than merely the form. It is also significant that the
petitioner has not been able to point out any material
circumstance which was concealed from him and which, if
furnished, would have altered his opportunity to make an
effective representation. The grounds disclose the FIRs, the
nature
of the allegations, the antecedents, conduct
attributed to the detenue and the basis upon which the
detaining authority apprehended
recurrence
of such
activities.
14.
On a cumulative consideration of the material placed
before this Court, it cannot be held that the subjective
satisfaction recorded by the detaining authority is based
on irrelevant or extraneous considerations. Nor can it be
said that the satisfaction is founded merely upon one
isolated criminal case. The material discloses repeated
Page |9
involvement in similar activities, spread over a number of
criminal
cases,
which
the
detaining
authority
has
considered in the context of their impact upon ‘public
order’. It may not be out of place to say that the repeated
commissions of thefts, even after his release on being
admitted to bail, amounts to create fear psychosis in the
local population, worrying about the safety of their
properties, alarming them to be alert, spoiling their peace
of mind.
15.
It needs to be emphasised that this Court is not
required to determine whether the detenue is guilty of the
offences forming the subject matter of the FIRs. The
criminal liability of the detenue is to be adjudicated by the
competent criminal courts in accordance with law. The
limited
question
before
this
Court
is
whether
the
preventive detention order suffers from any constitutional
or statutory infirmity warranting interference. On the
material available, this Court finds no such infirmity.
16.
For the foregoing reasons, the grounds urged by the
petitioner
do
not
merit
acceptance.
The
impugned
detention order reflects due application of mind to the
relevant material and the safeguards governing preventive
detention have, in the facts placed before this Court, been
substantially complied with and the impugned order is not
vitiated in any manner, so as to warrant it to be quashed.
P a g e | 10
17.
The petition is, accordingly, dismissed along with
pending application(s) and the impugned detention order is
upheld.
18.
Scanned detention record, as produced by learned
counsel for the respondents, is directed to be sent back
through him.
(M. A. CHOWDHARY)
JUDGE
Srinagar
25.09.2026
Muzammil. Q
Whether the order is reportable:
Yes / No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review