Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:29019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND, RANCHI
---C.M.P. No.691 of 2024
---Tapeshwar Singh, aged about 59 years, son of late Sukhu
Singh, resident of Co-operative Colony, P.O. and P.S. Saraidhela,
District- Dhanbad
……… Petitioner
--
Versus
--
1.Bharat Coking Coal Limited [BCCL], represented through
Managing Director, Koyla Bhawan, P.O.-BCCL Township, PS
Saraidhela, District Dhanbad
2.General Manager (Bhu Sampada), BCCL, PO BCCL Township,
PS Saraidhela, District Dhanbad
3.The Estate Officer, BCCL, PO BCCL Township, PS Saraidhela,
District Dhanbad
……. Respondents/O.Ps.
----
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S ANJAY KUMAR DWIVEDI
--For the Petitioner(s)
:- Rajeev Ranjan Tiwary, Advocate
:- Mr. Ranjit Kumar Tiwary, Advocate
For Respondent B.C.C.L
:- Dr. Ashok Kumar Singh, Advocate
---
07/24.09.2026
Heard Mr. Rajeev Ranjan Tiwary, the learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner as well as
Dr. Ashok Kumar Singh, the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the respondent Nos.1-3/ Bharat Coking Coal
Limited [BCCL].
2.
This petition has been filed under Article 227 of the
-1-
C.M.P. No.691 of 2024
2026:JHHC:29019
Constitution of India for quashing the order dated
07.08.2023 passed by Principal District Judge, Dhanbad,
passed in Civil Misc. Appeal No. 37/2017, whereby the
appeal preferred by the petitioner has been dismissed and
affirmed the order passed by Estate Officer, dated
22.06.2017.
3.
Mr. Tiwary, the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner submits that the petitioner has
purchase the piece of land admeasuring 11 decimals at
Mauza-Saraidhela, Mauza No.8 for measurement as Khata
No. 90, Plot No. 84, vide registered sale deed executed by
Krishna
Nandan
Employees
Prasad
Housing
Yadav,
Co-operative
Secretary
Society,
B.C.C.L.
Ltd.
vide
registered sale deed dated 30.12.2004 and after purchase
of the same, the petitioner has got the said land mutated
in
the
Shrista
of
State
vide
mutation
case
no.
2959(ii)/2008-09 as contained in Annexure-1 series. He
next submits that after purchase of the said land the
petitioner
approached
Mineral
Area
Development
Authority Dhanbad, for sanction of Map for construction of
residential building and after verifying the same the Map
was sanctioned by Mineral Area Development Authority
Dhanbad, vide letter no. TP-1124/NN/dated 19.01.2015
as contained in Annexure-2. He next submits that the
-2-
C.M.P. No.691 of 2024
2026:JHHC:29019
respondent BCCL vide letter dated 27.02.2015 addressed
to C.O. Dhanbad, has prayed for appointment of Amin to
demarcate plot no. 81, 82, 83, 84, appertaining to Khata
No.10,
under
Mauza
Saraidhela,
Thana
No.8
for
measurement as the same was acquired by B.C.C.L. in
Bhu Arjan Case No.7/65/66 and vide order dated
27.03.2015 and the same was communicated to the
petitioner vide letter dated 27.03.2015 as contained in
Annexure-3 series. He next submits that that thereafter
the said land was measured on 06.04.2015, and as the
petitioner was present at the time of measurement, the
land which was purchased by the petitioner was found
outside the acquired area but, no measurement report
was given to the petitioner despite the fact that the
petitioner has filed representation on 16.07.2015 before
Circle Officer demanding the measurement report. He
next submits that all of a sudden, the petitioner has
received a memo of notice wherein it is informed that the
petitioner has encroached the land of B.C.C.L. accordingly
the petitioner was directed to file show-cause as
contained in Annexure-5. He further submits that on
receipt of the notice, the petitioner appeared and filed his
show-cause wherein petitioner has narrated entire facts
and further petitioner has asserted that petitioner has not
-3-
C.M.P. No.691 of 2024
2026:JHHC:29019
encroached any land of the respondent and the land of
the petitioner falls out-side the acquired land and,
accordingly, prayed for dropping the said proceeding. He
next submits that thereafter the respondents have
adduced
the
evidence
and
without
giving
proper
opportunity to the petitioner to adduce evidence, the
evidence of petitioner was closed without giving proper
information to the petitioner. He next submits that in Case
No. 01/2016 the petitioner has filed a petition on
10.05.2017 with prayer to measure and demarcate the
land in question through a survey knowing Pleader
Commissioner but the same was rejected even without
calling rejoinder and hearing the appellant against which
the
petitioner
has
preferred
Civil.
Misc.
Appeal
no.34/2017. However, the Estate Officer has passed the
order dated 22.06.2017 stating therein that the petitioner
has encroached the land, and against that, the petitioner
has preferred the appeal before the learned Principal
District Judge, Dhanbad which was registered as Civil.
Misc. Appeal no.37/2017 which was rejected by order
dated 07.08.2023. Mr. Tiwary, the learned counsel for the
petitioner further submits that on perusal of the appellate
order, it is crystal clear that the documents which the
petitioner has relied has not been discussed therein and
-4-
C.M.P. No.691 of 2024
2026:JHHC:29019
he next submits that it is an apparent error which can be
rectified by this Court sitting under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India. He next submits that in the order of
the Estate Officer it has been noted that the petitioner
herein has filed Sale Deed no.2864 dated 27.5.2004,
Order sheet of Mutation No.2969(ii)/2008-09, Correction
Slip, Rent Receipts, Sanction letter of M.A.D.A. dated
19.01.2015,
Xerox
Copy
of
letter
vide
No.BCCL/ED/2015/3527 dated 27.02.2015, Nazir Receipt
dated 24.03.2015, Xerox copy of the Letter issued to
Anchal Amin Dated 27.03.2015, Xerox copy of the letter
submitted to the C.O., Dhanbad dated 16.7.2015 and
Xerox copy of the Reminder addressed to the C.O.,
Dhanbad dated 20.01.2016. He next submits that
although the above documents have been noted in the
order of the Estate Officer of the respondent/BCCL,
however, the learned appellate court has not discussed
about the said documents and straightway has wrongly
held that the petitioner herein has not produced any
document to make out his case and has held that the
petitioner has encroached the land and in view of that, he
submits, that the appellate order may kindly be set aside.
4.
On the other hand, Dr. Ashok Kumar Singh, the
learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent
-5-
C.M.P. No.691 of 2024
2026:JHHC:29019
nos.1 to 3/Bharat Coking Coal Limited –BCCL submits that
this Court sitting under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India, unless finds that there is apparent error in the
order of the learned appellate court on record, this Court
may not pass any order. He next submits that the land in
question was acquired in Bhu Arjan Case No. 7/65/66 by
the respondent/BCCL and the petitioner herein has
encroached the land and, therefore, the Estate Officer has
rightly passed the order which has been affirmed by the
learned appellate court. He also submits that the mutation
is not a document to declare the right, title and interest
and even the passing of Map by the MADA has got no
value to the issue under consideration and in view of that,
those documents are having no force to entertain this
petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India and
he next submits that unless the order is perverse, this
court may not quash the order as the learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner has not been able to show
any perversity in the impugned order and on these
grounds he submits that this CMP may kindly be
dismissed.
5.
In view of above submission of the learned
counsels appearing on behalf of the petitioner as well as
the respondent/BCCL, the Court has gone through the
-6-
C.M.P. No.691 of 2024
2026:JHHC:29019
materials on record and finds that admittedly the
petitioner has purchased 11 decimals of land by the sale
deed dated 07.05.2004 and the same was mutated in
favour
of
the
petitioner
in
Mutation
Case
no.
2959(ii)/2008-09 and Correction Slip was also issued, the
Rent receipt has also been issued and the M.A.D.A has
passed the Map for construction of the house. Prima facie,
all these materials suggest that the petitioner has
occupied the said land pursuant to the said purchase and
it has been pointed in course of the argument that so far
as the plot no.84 is concerned, it is having 44 decimals
and the respondent /BCCL has acquired only 11 decimals
of land whereas the petitioner is claiming that part of the
land of 11 decimals as acquired by the petitioner by way
of sale deed. In this background, the petitioner has filed a
petition before the Estate Officer for measurement,
however, that has been erroneously rejected by the Estate
Officer and against that the petitioner herein has moved
before the appellate authority, however, during the
pendency of the appeal of rejecting the appointment of
the survey knowing Pleader Commissioner, the Estate
Officer has disposed of the case.
6.
On perusal of the appellate court order, it
transpires that the learned appellate court has said that
-7-
C.M.P. No.691 of 2024
2026:JHHC:29019
the petitioner has not filed any document to claim his
case which is an apparent error on the record in view of
the order of the Estate Officer wherein he has noted that
the aforesaid documents, which has been noted in
the argument of Mr. Rajeev Ranjan Tiwary, the learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner, which prima
facie, suggest that the learned appellate court has
overlooked the same and erroneously held that the
petitioner has not filed any document.
7.
This Court is in agreement with the argument
advanced by Dr. Ashok Kumar Singh, the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the respondent/ BCCL regarding
Article 227 of the Constitution of India. There is no doubt
that Article 227 of the Constitution of India confers a right
of
superintendence
over
all
Courts
and
tribunals
throughout the territories in relation to which the High
court exercises the jurisdiction but no corresponding right
is conferred upon a litigant to invoke the jurisdiction
under said Article as a matter of right. In fact, power
under this Article casts a duty upon the High Court to
keep the inferior Courts and tribunals within the limits of
their authority and that they do not cross the limits,
ensuring the performance of duties by such Courts and
tribunals in accordance with law conferring power within
-8-
C.M.P. No.691 of 2024
2026:JHHC:29019
the ambit of the enactments creating such courts and
tribunals. Only wrong decisions may not be a ground for
exercise of jurisdiction under this Article unless the wrong
is referable to grave dereliction of duty and flagrant abuse
of power by the subordinate Court and tribunals resulting
in grave injustice to any party. A reference may be made
to the case of Ouseph Mathai v. M. Abdul Khadir,
(2002) 1 SCC 319.
8.
Further, the jurisdiction under Article 227 of the
Constitution may be restrictive in sense that it is to be
invoked only to correct errors of jurisdiction. But when a
court asks itself a wrong question or approaches the
question in an improper manner, even if it comes to a
finding of fact, the said finding of fact cannot be said to
be one rendered with jurisdiction and it will still be
amenable to correction at the hands of the High Court
under Article 227 of the Constitution. The failure to render
the necessary findings of support its order would also be
a jurisdictional error liable to correction under Article 227
of the Constitution of India. A reference may be made to
the case of Kishore Kumar Khaitan v. Praveen
Kumar Singh, AIR 2006 SC 1474.
9.
What has been discussed hereinabove, the learned
appellate court has made an apparent error on the record
-9-
C.M.P. No.691 of 2024
2026:JHHC:29019
holding that the petitioner has not filed any document and
on the contrary, the documents have been filed which has
been noted in the order of the learned Estate Officer of
respondent/ BCCL, and further, the dispute is there with
regard to 11 decimals of land of plot no.84 and the
petitioner has purchased the same by way of sale deed
whereas the BCCL is also claiming 11 decimals acquired of
plot no.84. It is not the case of the respondent/BCCL that
it has acquired the entire chunk of plot no.84 and if the
said situation is there, it was incumbent upon the
authority concerned to take the measurement as prayed
by the petitioner herein which has not been done.
10.
In view of above facts, reasons and analysis, the
impugned order dated 07.08.2023 passed by Principal
District Judge, Dhanbad in Civil Miscellaneous Appeal
No.37 of 2017 is, hereby, set-aside.
11.
The said Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No.37 of 2017
is, hereby, restored to the file of learned Principal District
Judge,
Dhanbad
who
will
decide
the
said
Civil
Miscellaneous Appeal afresh considering the documents
filed by the petitioner after providing the opportunity of
hearing to the petitioner as well as the Opposite party/
Respondent –BCCL as the said Civil Misc. Appeal is of the
year 2017 and in view of that, the petitioner and the
-10-
C.M.P. No.691 of 2024
2026:JHHC:29019
respondent/BCCL are directed to appear before the
leaned court concerned.
12.
It is open to the learned appellate authority if he
comes to the conclusion for coming to the correct finding,
he may get the land in question measured in presence of
both the parties by the competent State authority and the
petitioner as well as the respondent-BCCL are directed to
appear before the learned court concerned at 10.30 A.M.
on 05.10.2026.
13.
This petition being C.M.P. No.691 of 2024 is
allowed in the above terms and disposed of.
( Sanjay Kumar Dwivedi, J.)
SI/ A.F.R
Dated : 24.09.2026
Uploaded/ 29.09.2026
-11-
C.M.P. No.691 of 2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review