Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
13.02.2026
Sl. No. 33 (DL)
Ct. No.14
AN
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
W.P.A. No. 28555 of 2025
Tapas Kumar Mandal & ors.
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Sabyasachi Chatterjee
Mr. Badrul Karim
Mr. Sarajit Roy
Mr. Aritra Ghosh
Mr. Sayed Hossain
…for the Petitioner.
Mr. Subir Sanyal, ld. Sr. Adv.
Mr. Dwarikanath Mukherjee
Mr. Ratul Biswas,
Mr. Kaushik Chowdhury
…for the WBBPE.
Mr. Sirsanya Bandopadhyay, ld. Sr. Adv.
Ms. Tapati Samanta
…for the State
Ms. Asha G. Gutgutia
…for the NCTE.
1.
Affidavit of service filed on behalf of the petitioners is
taken on record.
2.
By the present writ petition, the petitioners seek for
relaxation of age in order to participate in the ongoing
recruitment process in terms of the Notification dated
25th September, 2025.
3.
The petitioners contend that they are enrolled as Para
Teachers under “Sarva Siksha Abhijan”, a scheme of the
Government of India that was launched for eradicating
drop out rates amongst the students from Class I to
Class V who live in urban as well as rural areas. The
petitioners have passed the Teacher Eligibility Test 2022
(in short, ‘TET’). They have also passed the Diploma in
Elementary Education (in short, ‘D.El.Ed’) in the year
2019 for the Session 2015-17.
The petitioners are
unable to participate in the ongoing recruitment process
in terms of the Notification of Board dated 25 th
September, 2025 since they have crossed the maximum
age limit of 50 years. Hence this writ petition claiming
for relaxation of age upto 55 years.
4.
Mr. Sabyasachi Chatterjee, learned advocate appearing
for the petitioners submits that in the Rules pertaining
to recruitment of Assistant Teachers in upper primary
level provides the age limit relaxable upto 55 years. He
also indicates that in the direct recruitment of Special
Educators under the West Bengal Primary Schools
Special Education Teachers Training Rules, 2025, the
age is relaxable upto 55 years. Therefore, the petitioners
should also be granted relaxation of age till 55 years.
He seeks for appropriate orders.
5.
On the contrary, Mr. Subir Sanyal, learned senior
advocate appearing for the Board submits that Rule 6(1)
of West Bengal Primary School Teachers Recruitment
Rules, 2016 (as amended upto date) (hereinafter
referred to ‘Rules of 2016’) clearly provides that no
person shall be appointed by the Council as a teacher
unless he has completed 18 years as on 1 st Day of
January of the year of advertisement and has not
completed the age of 40 years as on 1 st Day of January
of the year of advertisement. Therefore, there is a clear
bar for any relaxation of the age. For the para teachers
as per Note 7, 10% of the total posts that have been
earmarked without disturbing the 100 point roster. The
Note further provides the maximum age limit relaxation
upto 50 years for the para teachers. There cannot be
any issuance of a mandamus contrary to the statutory
rules. Moreso, the rule does not provide for relaxation of
age after attainment of the maximum age limit. In
support of his contention, he relies on the following
decisions:
(i)
Malda District Primary School Council & anr.
versus Md. Faridur Rahaman & ors. reported in
(2001) 1 CHN 204;
(ii)
Chairman, Ad-hoc Committee, District Primary
School Council, Burdwan versus Rabindra Nath
Ghosh & ors. reported in (2001) 2 CLJ 161;
(iii) Golam Morshed Mondal & ors. versus The State
of West Bengal & ors. (MAT 2101 of 2025)
6.
Furthermore, the recruitment rules of 2016 have not
been challenged in the present proceedings. The rules
for
the
special
educator
and
upper
primary
are
altogether separate rules and the petitioners cannot
seek for parity on the basis of the said rules. He seeks
for dismissal of the writ petition.
7.
Heard learned advocates for the respective parties and
perused the materials on record.
8.
The only issue which falls for consideration is whether
the petitioners are entitled to relaxation of age limit upto
55 years or not.
9.
In order to examine the aforesaid issue, it would be
apposite to reproduce rule 6(1) of the Rules of 2016 and
Note 7 as hereunder:
“6(1). No person shall be appointed by the Council
as a teacher unless he is a citizen of India and has
completed the age of 18 years as on 1 st day of January
of the year of advertisement and has not completed the
age of 40 years on the 1st day of January of the year of
advertisement as specified in sub-rule (3).”
“Note 7. The State Government may, by
notification in the Official Gazette, earmark upto 10% of
the total posts for the candidates belonging to Parateachers without disturbing the 100-point roster as
notified by the State Government from time to time, in
such-manner as may be mentioned in such notification.
Provided that the qualifications for such categories
of candidates shall be the same as mentioned in these
rules:
Provided further that notwithstanding anything
contained in these rules, the upper age limit of
candidates to be appointed as teachers by earmarking
10% of the total posts, shall be relaxable upto the
period of service rendered by such candidates, subject
to maximum of 50 years of age as on the 1 st day of
January of the year of advertisement.”
10. Upon conjoint reading of rule 6(1) and Note 7 of the said
Rules, the maximum age limit for a para teacher under
the rules is 50 years. Needless to mention that all the
petitioners have crossed the age limit of 50 years.
11. The Hon'ble Division Bench in Md. Faridur Rahaman
(supra) while answering the similar question observed as
follows:
“15. Similarly when the Rule says that candidates
upto the age of 40 years are eligible, a candidate who
has crossed the age of 40 years is ineligible. There is
no power to relax the age limit. If such a candidate is
employed and for that matter permitted to appear at the
interview, will it not be unauthorized? Statutory law is
binding law. Rule of law imposes an obligation to
adhere to statutory laws. No Court can give a direction
contrary to a statutory law. It is incorrect to assume
that in Excise Superintendent’s case (supra) Supreme
Court gave any direction contrary to a law prescribed
by statute.”
12. In Rabindra Nath Ghosh (supra), the Hon'ble Division
Bench observed as follows:
“The learned Division Bench held that there is no
provision for condonation of age bar in the rules,
therefore, the Court cannot in exercise of extraordinary
jurisdiction issue any such direction contrary to the
statutory rules and in an identical situation set aside
the order of the learned Single Judge. The learned
Counsel for the respondent invited our attention to the
earlier judgment passed by the same learned single
Judge (Amitava Lala) in the case of (16) Tapan Kumar
Mondal State of West Bengal & Ors. reported in 2000
(1) CHN 833. It appears that the attention of the
learned Single Judge was not invited to the decision
reported in Biman Chandra Karmakar v. State of West
Bengal (supra), and the learned Single Judge again
passed the same order as in the impugned case. Be
that as it may, facts remains that the Division Bench
has already taken a view in Biman Chandra Karmakar
v. State of West Bengal (supra), that no administrative
instruction can be issued contrary to Recruitment &
Leave Rules, 1991 framed under Section 106 of the
West Bengal Primary Education Act, 1973. Therefore,
the learned Single Judge was not correct in issuing the
direction to the authorities to forward the name of such
petitioners as ex-census employees and to consider
sympathetically for grant of relaxation in age. The
learned Counsel for the respondent invited our attention
to the decision of the Supreme Court in (17) Bir Bajrang
Kumar v. State of Bihar, AIR 1987 SC 1345, and
submitted that inconsistent order should not be passed
by co-ordinating bench of same Court. In the present
case, we, are only following the decision given by the
Division Bench in the case of M. A. T. No. 392 of 2000,
therefore, there was no question of passing inconsistent
order, on the contrary it appears that the learned Single
Judge's attention was not invited to the Division Bench
Judgment wherein in an identical situation a similar
contention as in the above matter has been overruled
by the Division Bench. This appears to be a serious
lapse on the part of the Counsel who appeared before
the learned Single Judge that they have not invited the
attention of the learned Single Judge to the Division
Bench Judgment in M. A. T. No. 392 of 2000.
Therefore, the view taken by the learned Single Judge
in the case of Tapan Kumar Mondal v. State of West
Bengal (supra), and in the impugned order is in per
curiam. Hence, the appeal is allowed and the order
passed by the learned Single Judge is set aside with no
order as to costs.”
13. In Golam Morshed Mondal (supra), the Hon’ble Division
Bench considering the provision of rule 6 dismissed the
appeal
where
the
petitioner
contended
for
age
relaxation.
14. Therefore, it clearly manifests from the aforesaid
proposition laid down by the Hon'ble Division Bench
that rule of law imposes an obligation to adhere to the
statutory rules and no Court can give a direction
contrary to statutory rules. Needless to note that in the
present writ petition, there is no challenge to the Rule 6
of recruitment rules of 2016. As observed earlier, the
rules since do not provide for age relaxation beyond 50
years, the prayers made in the writ petition seeking for
age relaxation falls short of merit.
15. Accordingly, the writ petition being W.P.A. No. 28555
of 2025 stands dismissed.
16. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
17. All connected applications, if any, stand disposed of.
18. There shall be no order as to costs.
19. Urgent certified photostat copy of this order, if applied
for, shall be given to the parties as expeditiously as
possible on compliance of all necessary formalities.
(Bivas Pattanayak, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review