Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
HCP No. 117/2024
Reserved on:
14.05.2026 19.02.2026
Pronounced on: 02.06.202626.02.2026
Uploaded on: 02.06.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced-Full
Talib Hussain Aged-39 Yrs.
S/O Sain Ditta
R/O Chatta Sunjwan Sainik Colony,
Chowadi, District Jammu
.....
Appellant/petitioner(s)
Through :- Mr. Rahul Pant, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Tarun Sharma, Advocate.
v/s
.....Respondent(s)
1. UT of J&K
2. District Magistrate, Jammu
Through :- None.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SEKHRI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01.
Challenge in this petition has been thrown to two orders with identical
numbers and date; 27 of 2024 dated 07.06.2024, passed by District Magistrate,
Jammu, under Sections 8 (1) (a) and 8 (1) (a-1) of the Jammu and Kashmir
Public Safety Act, 1978, [“PSA”], vide which petitioner has been directed to be
detained.
02.
As factual matrix would unfold, the Divisional Forest Officer, Jammu
Forest Division, [“DFO”], submitted a dossier to the District Administration
alleging inter alia that petitioner being a habitual land grabber has been enlisted
in the encroachment list of Jammu Forest Division for the encroachment of
forest land in compartments 8/Ch and 9/Ch of Bahu Forest Range, which forms
part of Bahu Conservation Reserve. It was also alleged that petitioner along
with his father was also enlisted in the encroachment list of forest division for
the encroachment of forest land in compartment No. 6/Ch. It was further alleged
that petitioner not only encroached the forest land in Khasra Nos. 1468, 1454
and 1456, but also created hindrance and created law and order issues during the
demarcation. He also made several attempts of land breaking, illegal mining on
forest land etc. with the intention to encroach upon more forest land and
smuggling of forest resources. He would carry illegal tasks clandestinely,
especially during the night hours, by adopting the routes to give a slip to the law
enforcement agencies.
03.
The sponsoring authority, while alleging that petitioner was found
involved in illegal construction and mulba dumping on forest land and illegal
mining and smuggling of forest resources, furnished the detail of following
cases against him:
Case No.
Illegal
encroachment/construction
in
Type of illegal activity
Remarks
Illegal
Construction
on
ForestLand/CriminalTrespass
over Forest Land
Prime land of Sunjwan,
Chowadi
6/Ch
Kanal
Forest
encroachment
Land
Encroachment done
by his father Sain
Ditta
8/Ch
150 Kanal Forest
encroachment
Land
Encroachment done
by his father Sain
Ditta
8/Ch.
Land Breaking and
leveling of Forest Land
Illegal
Fir
No. 8/Ch. (Khasra No. 1468)
25/2022
of
PS
Channi
Himmat
Ja/82
in
Encroachment
list of Jammu
Forest
Division
Ja/87
in
Encorachment
list of Jammu
Forest
Division
Damage Case
No. 04/2024-25
Dated
05.06.2024
(Emphasis supplied)
04.
It is also allegation of the sponsoring authority that petitioner was not
only involved in the encroachment of forest land, but he would carve out plots
by removing the material from hillocks and levelling it, so that levelled forest
HCP 117/2024
land could be used for selling in the form of residential plots, keeping the
citizens in dark about the status of the land and duping them of their hard-earned
money, which has the potential of causing chaos and unrest among the general
public.
05.
On the basis of these allegations, captured in the dossier, respondent no.
2-the detaining authority has come to conclude that there was live and
proximate link between past conduct of the petitioner and the imperative to
detain him for the purpose of prevention and combating his activities prejudicial
to the security of the State, maintenance of public safety and affording
protection to society. The detaining authority propounded two orders bearing
same number and date under Sections 8(1) (a) and 8(1) (a-1) of PSA, whereby
petitioner has been directed to be detained.
06.
Petition is aggrieved of the impugned orders inter alia on the following
grounds:“a) That perusal of Jammu and Kashmir public Safety Act,
1978 will show that detention order can be passed by
District Magistrate, if he is satisfied as provided under
sub-section I sub-clause (i) and (ii) of section 8 or subclause (a-1) of sub-section (l) of section 8. Admittedly, a
perusal of the facts stated in the order of detention as also
the grounds of detention, does not make out any case of
maintenance of public order nor it is anybody’s case that
the detention order has been passed with a view to prevent the petitioners
from:
i) smuggling (timber or liquor); or
ii) abetting the smuggling of (timber or liquor);or
iii) engaging in transporting or concealing or keeping smuggled timber; or
iv) dealing the smuggled timber otherwise than by engaging in transporting or
concealing or keeping in smuggled (timber or liquor);or
v) harbouring persons engaged in smuggling of(timber or liquor) or abetting
the smuggling of (timber or liquor);
The word timber has also been defined under the Act as Fir, Kail, Chir or
Deodar tree whether in logs or cut up in pieces but does not include firewood.
Since there is not even an iota of allegation against the petitioner that he was
in any way involved in smuggling of timber or any of the activities mentioned
in Section 8, as such detention orders passed by the respondent no.2 is without
jurisdiction and is therefore liable to be quashed.
HCP 117/2024
b) That none of the order of detention is sustainable as the grounds of
detention do not make out any case for the District Magistrate, Jammu ton
invoke the powers under Section 8(l)(a) and sub-clause (a-l) of sub-section (l)
of Section 8 of Jammu and Kashmir public safety act, the perusal of orders
will show that no ground whatsoever is made out for passing the detention
orders as it refers to the petitioner as a land grabber and enlisted in the
encroachment list of Jammu Forest Division for encroachment of various land
in compartments in Bahu Forest Range. In so far as Bahu Forest Range is
concerned, it does not have any Fir, Kail, Chir or Deodar trees and clearly the
orders has been passed on misplaced grounds. The respondent no.2 has no
authority or power under the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978 to
pass a detention order on the ground of petitioner being a land grabber. The
impugned orders are bad in law which is liable to be set-aside by this Hon'ble
Court.
c) That a perusal of the grounds of detention, copy whereof
has been provided to the petitioner, will clearly show that it's simply refers to
the encroachment of forest land. Even the two counts of encroachment
attributed to the father of the petitioner, has been made a ground for
detaining the petitioner. It is not understandable as to how such a draconian
power to detain the person can be invoked by the District Magistrate, Jammu
on such flimsy and non-existent grounds. The District Magistrate traces his
powers to pass the detention order from the provisions of J&K Public Safety
Act, l97B and such power can only be exercised for the reasons as mentioned
in Section 8 of the J&K Public Safety Act, 1978. This is
a case where the power to detain the petitioner has been exercised by the
District Magistrate, Jammu for the object, which is alien to the J&K Public
Safety Act, 1978. The subjective satisfaction arrived at by the District
Magistrate, Jammu as such, has very serious legal flaw and the detention
order is liable to be set aside on this ground only.
d) That the petitioner has been made available two different
orders bearing the same order number with the same date. One order is
elaborate whereas, another order does not make the elaborate reasons. A
perusal of the detention order passed under clause (a-r) of sub-section I of
section 8 will show that the same has been passed with a view to prevent the
petitioner from acting in any manner which is prejudicial to the encroachment
of the forest, smuggling of forest resources and public order. A perusal of the
order will show that the Respondent No.2 is himself not sure as to why the
petitioner is being detained. Respondent No.2 has failed to draw a distinction
between the grounds on which, the detention can be made under the provisions
of the J&K public Safety Act, 1978 and has mixed up all the grounds to
pass the detention order in question. The said approach
on the part of the Respondent No.2 completely defies logic and clearly reflects
the total non-application of mind on the part of the Respondent No.2. The
detention order has been passed by the Respondent No.2 for wrong
purposes on vague, extraneous and irrelevant grounds. The District
Magistrate, Jammu has no authority whatsoever to pass the detention order on
the ground, the same has been passed and it is a clear case of abuse of
power on the part of the Respondent No.2, the order as such is not sustainable.
e) That passing of two different detention orders on same grounds without
even justifying detention of petitioner under the provisions of Jammu and
Kashmir public Safety act, 1978, shows lack of application of mind by
detaining authority, rendering the detention orders unsustainable in eyes of
law, therefore, required to quash by this Hon'ble Court.
f) That a perusal of the second order of detention will show
that it does not disclose any reason to invoke the power
Under Section 8(l)(a) of the J&K public Safety Act, 1978. A perusal of Section
HCP 117/2024
8(l)(a) of the J&K public Safety Act, 1978 will show that power can be invoked
by the District Magistrate to issue the order of detention with respect to a
person in order to prevent such person from acting in any manner prejudicial
to the security of the State or maintenance of public order. The grounds,
which have been given to the petitioner along with the detention order clearly show
that it is not a case of public order in any manner and detention order is not
justified on the grounds served upon the petitioner as it is not a
case of threat to the public order in any manner. The
reasons mentioned in the detention order running into four pages, going by
any stretch of imagination do not justify the detention order. The detention
order itself is on the ground for which the detention is not permissible
under Jammu and Kashmir safety act, 1978. The reading of the order as a
whole will show that the allegation against the petitioner is that he had
entered into the forest land, raised illegal construction into the forest land and
assuming for the sake of the argument that the allegations are true though
denying them vehemently, even then, passing of the detention order in question
is not justified.
g) That the illegality committed by respondent no. 2 can
well be seen from the fact that the detention order has been passed on the
basis of a dossier submitted by the Divisional Forest officer Jammu and the
perusal of order no. PSA 27 of 2024 dated 07.06.2024 will show that one
order has been passed in exercise of power conferred upon respondent no. 2
by Clause (a-l) of sub-section (1) of section 8 of Jammu and Kashmir public
safety Act, 1978 whereas, there is another order with the same order number
and date, which has been passed by the respondent no.2 in exercise of power
conferred upon him under section 8 (1) (a) of Jammu and Kashmir public
Safety Act, 1978. A perusal of both the orders will show that neither under
section 8(1) (a) nor under section g sub- section (l) clause (a-1), The order
could have been passed as it is neither a case of security of the State nor it is a
case of public order and in so far as the smuggling of timber is concerned,
there is not even any whisper in this regard in the present detention order.
Further the sponsoring agency for passing of the detention order is the
Divisional Forest Officer, Jammu and the power of detention of the petitioner
was being invoked on the ground that he has illegally encroached the forest
land. Invoking of the power as such under section 8(l)(a) is absolutely without
jurisdiction and it was not a case of any kind of threat to the security of the
State or public order in any manner. The attempts to deprive them petitioner of
his personal liberty is such a vague and unsustainable illegal order, which is
serious violation of the fundamental right to liberty of the petitioner. Petitioner
is being deprived of his liberty in a most casual, illegal and arbitrary manner,
the orders impugned, as such, are not sustainable and liable to be set aside.
h) That the grounds of detention as specified in the order will show that there
is no reason whatsoever given except registration of one F.I.R no.25/2022 with
the police Station Channi Himmat, Jammu for commission of offences under
Section 447 I..P.C and Section 26 of Forest Act. Section 26 of the Forest Act
prescribes the acts prohibited in the forest and section 447 of IPC deals
with the criminal trespass. Petitioner fails to understand as to how this F.I.R is
relevant in any manner to order the detention of the petitioner in order to
prevent him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the security of the state
or the maintenance of public order or even preventing him from indulging into
smuggling of timber. The detention of the petitioner has been ordered on
totally irrelevant grounds, as such the subjective satisfaction arrived by the
District magistrate before passing the order of the detention is vitiated. The
impugned
orders
have
been
based
on
vague,
extraneous
and irrelevant grounds. The power of detention has been invoked for wrong
purpose.
h) That the grounds of detention as specified in the order
will show that there is no reason whatsoever given except registration of one
F.I.R no.25/2022 with the police Station Channi Himmat, Jammu for
HCP 117/2024
commission of offences under Section 447 I.P.C and Section 26 of Forest Act.
Section 26 of the Forest Act prescribes the acts prohibited in the forest and
section 447 of IPC deals with the criminal trespass. Petitioner fails to
understand as to how this F.I.R is relevant in any manner to order the
detention of the petitioner in order to prevent him from acting in any manner
prejudicial to the security of the state or the maintenance of public order or
even preventing him from indulging into smuggling of timber. The detention of
the petitioner has been ordered on totally irrelevant grounds, as such the
subjective satisfaction arrived by the District magistrate before passing the
order of the detention is vitiated. The impugned orders have been based on
vague, extraneous and irrelevant grounds. The power of detention has been
invoked for wrong purpose.
i)
That
in
communication
bearing
no.
978lDMJ/Judicial/
2024-25 dated 07.06.2024 as has been sent by respondent
no.2 to the government, he has mentioned that the detention order has
been passed on the basis of detailed report received from the
Superintendent of police Jammu, where as it is only a dossier given by
the
respondent no. 2 by the Divisional Forest officer, Jammu and this
speaks volumes about the non-application of mind, on part of
respondent no.2 before passing the detention order. There is not even a
single incident mentioned in the grounds to justify the detention of the
petitioner under Jammu and Kashmir public Safety Act,
1978 and entire exercise has been conducted illegally and without
jurisdiction.
i) That the detention order could not have been passed on
totally non-existent grounds. Not even a single ground
exists to support any of the detention order. It appears
that the District Magistrate himself was unaware of the
grounds on which the detention order was to be passed,
as such, he has passed two separate orders with the same
number and date, whereas detention orders will show that
neither there is ground of public order nor allegation of timber
smuggling on the petitioner. The order is outcome of malice in law and
no satisfaction whatsoever could have been arrived at the material
placed, before passing the detention order it appears that the
respondent no.2 has failed to realize the distinction between the law
and order and public order.
k) That there is yet another important aspect of the matter
and the perusal of the grounds will show that the same
refers to F.I.R no.2512022. The said F.I.R is a stale F.I.R
for the purpose of passing the detention order. There is
no live link between the FIR in question and passing of
the detention order dated 07.06.2024. The detention order
passed against the petitioner as such is in complete
violation of Jammu and Kashmir public Safety Act, l97g
and also the rights guaranteed to petitioner under the Article 2l and22
of the Constitution.
l) That it appears that Respondent No.2 has failed to
understand the distinction between the law and order and
public order. As a matter of fact, Hon'ble Supreme court has already
explained the aforesaid distinction in the following manner:
"It will thus appear that just as “public order" in the rulings
of this Court (earlier cited) was said to comprehend
disorders of less gravity than those affecting, security of
State", "law and order" also comprehends disorders of less
HCP 117/2024
gravity than those affecting "public order". One has to
imagine three concentric circles. Law and order represents
the largest circle within which is the next circle representing
public order and the smallest circle represents security of
state. It is then easy to see that an act may affect law and
order but not public order just as an act
may affect public order but not security of the State. By using
the expression "maintenance of law and orde4r" the District
Magistrate was widening his own field of action and was
adding a clause to the Defence of India Rules."
The perusal of the grounds of detention will show that
the case neither falls under the public order nor under the security of
the state but unfortunately, unmindful of the aforesaid legal position,
the detention order has been, passed against the petitioner on totally
vague, extraneous and irrelevant grounds.
m) That it is unheard of that on same grounds, two different
detention orders are passed. perhaps it is for the first time that a
District Magistrate has passed two separate orders of detention on the
same set of grounds of detention on the asking of the sponsoring
agency, Divisional Forest Officer which is Divisional Forest Officer.
n) That keeping in view the fact that detention orders are
absolutely illegal, without jurisdiction and have been passed for
extraneous reasons, petitioner is invoking the jurisdiction of this
Hon'ble Court at the pre-execution stage as every citizen has been held
to be entitled to save his liberty by invoking the jurisdiction of the
Hon,ble High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution even at
the pre-execution stage.”
07.
The respondents, at the foremost, have questioned maintainability of the
petition at the pre-execution stage.
08.
According to the respondents, to entertain a petition of Habeas Corpus, it
is mandatory that a person is under illegal detention and since petitioner is
evading the due process of law, petition is liable to be summarily dismissed.
09.
It is contention of the respondents that since petitioner is a habitual land
grabber, enlisted in the encroachment list of Jammu Forest Division for
encroachment of forest land in different compartments, and ordinary law of the
land failed to deter him, impugned order came to be passed by the detaining
authority to prevent him from indulging in similar activities.
HCP 117/2024
10.
It is also contention of the respondents that mention of Section 8(1) (a-1)
PSA was a clerical error and was inadvertently made, but impugned order was
passed under Section 8(1) (a) of PSA.
11.
Respondents have prayed for dismissal of the petition.
12.
Having heard arguments, I have gone through the file and the detention
record.
13.
Mr. Rahul Pant, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner, has
relied upon Additional Secretary to the Government of India vs. Alka
Subash Gadia; 1992(1) SCC 496 to reiterate the grounds urged in the petition.
14.
Per contra, Mr. P.D Singh, learned counsel for respondents has
emphasized his stand taken in the counter affidavit.
15.
Before we proceed to dilate upon the grounds urged in the memo of
petition, it shall be proper to have a look at Section 8(1) (a) and clause (a-1) of
sub-section (1) of Section 8 of PSA, which for the facility of reference, are
extracted below:“8. Detention of certain persons:- (1) The Government
may—
(a) if satisfied with respect to any person that with a view to
preventing him from acting in any manner prejudicial to(i) the security of the State or the maintenance of the public
order; or
(ii).............
[(A-1) if satisfied with respect to any person that with a
view to preventing him fromi) smuggling (timber or liquor); or
ii) abetting the smuggling of (timber or liquor);or
iii) engaging in transporting or concealing or keeping
smuggled timber; or
iv) dealing the smuggled timber otherwise than by
engaging in transporting or concealing or keeping in
smuggled (timber or liquor);or
v) harbouring persons engaged in smuggling of(timber or
liquor) or abetting the smuggling of (timber or liquor);
.............
.............”
HCP 117/2024
16.
It is evident from a plain reading of Clause (A-1) of sub-section (1) of
Section 8 PSA that it can be invoked with a view to prevent a person from
smuggling timber or liquor or abetting the same, or engaging in the
transportation or concealing or keeping the smuggled timber or dealing in the
smuggled timber, or otherwise engaging in the transportation or concealment or
keeping or harboring persons engaged in the smuggling or abetting the
smuggling of timber or liquor, which are not allegations against the petitioner.
17.
Allegation against the petitioner is that he is a habitual land grabber and
enlisted in the encroachment list of Jammu Forest Division for the
encroachment of forest land in various compartments along with his father. He
became a hindrance in the demarcation of the forest land and made several
attempts of land breaking, illegal mining of forest land etc. with an intention to
encroach upon the forest land and smuggle forest resources. Another allegation
against him is that he was involved in carving out plots on the forest land and
selling them in the form of residential plots, duping the citizens of their hardearned money, which has the potential of causing chaos and unrest in the
general public.
18.
It is evident from a bare perusal of aforesaid allegations that impugned
orders have been passed by the detaining authority on misplaced and nonexistent grounds. No ground whatsoever is made out for passing the detention
orders, in terms of clause (A-1) of sub-section (1) of Section 8 PSA. The
allegations merely refer to the petitioner as a land grabber enlisted in various
encroachments of Jammu Forest Division. Therefore, subjective satisfaction
arrived at by the detaining authority is found legally flawed and impugned
orders are liable to be quashed on this ground alone.
HCP 117/2024
19.
Be that as it may, the sponsoring authority furnished a list of cases against
the petitioner including FIR No. 25/2020 of Police Station Channi Himmat and
Damage Case No. 04 of 2024 regarding land breaking and illegal levelling of
forest land. Surprisingly, in addition to these two cases, the other two cases
reported are with respect to the encroachment of seven kanals of forest land and
150 kanals of forest land only by his father-Sain Ditta. It is apparent from the
list of cases provided by the detaining authority that petitioner is sought to be
detained under PSA for an activity alleged to have been committed by his
father, which clearly reflects total non-application of mind on the part of the
detaining authority.
20.
Countervailing the stand of the petitioner, present petition is sought to be
resisted by the respondents on the predominant premise that it is not
maintainable at the pre-execution stage. According to the respondents, to
entertain a petition for Habeas Corpus, it is a pre-requisite that a person should
have been under illegal detention and since petitioner is evading the due process
of law, the petition in the present form is not maintainable.
21.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Alka Subash Gadia, has held that it is not
correct to say that writ court has no power to entertain grievances against any
detention order prior to its execution. It was held that such power could be used
in proper cases, though such cases have been few and the grounds on which
Courts could interfere at the pre-execution stage are limited in scope, however,
Court cannot decline to entertain such writ petition at the pre-execution stage if
it is prima facie satisfied (i) that impugned order is not passed under the Act
under which it is purported to have been passed, (ii) that it is sought to be
executed against a wrong person, (iii) that it is passed for a wrong person, (iv)
HCP 117/2024
that it is passed on vague, extraneous and irrelevant grounds (v) and that the
authority which passed it had no authority to do so.
Relevant excerpts, for the facility of reference, are extracted below:“............
(30)...........The courts have the necessary power and they have used it in
a proper cases as has been pointed out above, although such cases
have been few and the grounds on which the courts have interfered with
them at the pre-execution stage are necessarily very limited in scope
and num-ber, viz., where the courts are prima facie satisfied (i) that the
impugned order is not passed under the Act under which it is purported
to have been passed, (ii) that it is sought to be executed against a wrong
person, (iii) that it is passed for a wrong purpose, (iv) that it is passed
on vague, extraneous and irrelevant grounds or (v) that the authority
which passed it had no authority to do so. The refusal by the courts to
use then extraordinary powers of Judicial review to interfere with the
detention orders prior to their execution on any other ground does not
amount to the abandonment of the said power or to their denial to the
proposed detenu, but prevents their abuse and the perversion of the law
in question.
(31)..............
(32) This still leaves open the question as to whether the detenu is
entitled to the order of detention prior to its execution at least to verify
whether it can be challenged at its pre-execution stage on the limited
grounds available. In view of the discussion aforesaid, the answer to
this question has to be firmly in the negative for various reasons. In the
first instance, as stated earlier, the Constitution and the valid law made
there-under do not make any provision for the same. On the other hand,
they permit the arrest and detention of a person without furnishing to
the detenu the order and the grounds thereof in advance. Secondly,
when the order and the grounds are served and the detenu is in a
position to make out prima facie the limited grounds on which they can
be successfully challenged, the courts, as pointed out earlier, have
power even to grant bail to the detenu pending the final hearing of his
petition. Alternatively, as stated earlier, the court can and does hear
such petition expeditiously to give the necessary relief to the detenu.
Thirdly, in the rare cases where the detenu, before being served with
them, learns of the detention order and the grounds on which it is made,
and satisfies the Court of their existence by proper affirmation, the court
does not decline to entertain the writ petition even at the pre-execution
stage, of course, on the very limited grounds stated above. The court no
doubt even in such cases is not obliged to interfere with the impugned
order at that stage and may insist that the detenu should first submit to
it. It will, however, depend on the facts of each case. The decisions and
the orders cited above show that in some genuine cases, the courts
have exercised their powers at the pre-execution stage, though such
cases have been rare. This only emphasises the fact that the courts
have power to interfere with the detention orders even at the preexecution stage but they are not obliged to do so nor will it be proper for
them to do so save in exceptional cases. Much less can a detenu claim
such exercise of power as a matter of right. The discretion is of the
court and it has to be exercised judicially on well settled principles.”
22.
The petitioner, as stated, is sought to be detained on the allegations of
encroachment of the forest land and that too with respect to two instances of
alleged encroachments done by his father. There is no allegation with respect to
smuggling or abetting the smuggling, or engagement in transportation or
HCP 117/2024
concealment or keeping of smuggled timber, or otherwise dealing with
smuggled timber, or harbouring persons engaged in smuggling or abetting the
smuggling of timber or liquor, within the meaning of Clause (A-1) of subsection (1) of Section 8 PSA. Therefore, present case is squarely covered under
grounds (ii), (iii) & (iv) of Alka Subash Gadia, because impugned orders under
Sections 8(1) (a) and 8 (1) (A-1) have been passed by the respondent detaining
authority, for a wrong purpose, against a wrong person and on absolutely vague,
extraneous and irrelevant grounds.
23.
It appears that, realizing the mistake and taking a cue from the grounds of
challenge urged in the present petition, respondents have come forward with the
plea that there was a clerical error and impugned order, in essence, has been
passed under Section 8(1) (a) and not 8(1) (A-1) of PSA. If it is so, then
impugned order of detention, purported to have been passed by the detaining
authority under Section 8(1) (a), runs in patent contradiction to the grounds of
detention that petitioner is a habitual land grabber. It appears from the tone and
tenor of the impugned order and the grounds of detention that detaining
authority is oblivious to decide as to under which provision, petitioner is to be
detained; viz. under Section 8(1) (a), which is relatable to the security of the
State and maintenance of public order, or Section 8(1) (A-1), relating to
smuggling of (timber or liquor) or abetting the smuggling of (timber or liquor)
or matters related thereto.
24.
It is a matter of common experience that grounds of detention furnished
to a detenue in Habeas Corpus matters would often contain generic allegations
forming part of the dossier submitted by the sponsoring authority, without any
independent application of mind. Such a “copy-paste” culture on the part of
detaining authorities would fundamentally infringe upon fundamental rights of
HCP 117/2024
citizens guaranteed under the Constitution. Personal liberty of a person cannot
be trifled in such a cavalier fashion. The detaining authorities are expected to act
neutrally between the State and the individual liberty of a citizen and cannot
afford to act as a rubber stamp of sponsoring authorities. Preventive detention is
a drastic precautionary measure intended to intercept future crimes, but it cannot
be invoked to punish a citizen for unsubstantiated claims. Therefore, detention
orders which merely “copy-paste” the dossiers of sponsoring authorities,
without independent evaluation of the detaining authorities, are illegal.
25.
Viewed from any angle, it is manifest from the grounds of detention
supplied to the petitioner in the present case that it is neither a case involving
threat to the security of the State, nor a case relating to the maintenance of
public order, or a case relatable to Clause (A-1) of sub-section (1) of Section 8
of PSA.
26.
For the foregoing reasons, present petition is allowed, impugned orders
are quashed and petitioner is directed to be immediately released from the
detention.
27.
However, since there are serious allegations against the petitioner,
regarding encroachment over a huge chunk of forest land, respondents shall be
at liberty to work out and avail appropriate civil and criminal remedies against
him.
28.
Disposed of.
(Rajesh Sekhri)
Judge
JAMMU
02.06.2026
Abinash
Whether the judgment is speaking? Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable? Yes
HCP 117/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review