Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 20th JULY, 2017
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in RFA No.18 of 2016
Appellant
:
Shri Taktuk Bhutia @ T. T. Bhutia,
Managing Director,
M/s. North East Group of Engineers (P) Ltd.,
M. G. Marg,
Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondents :
1.
M/s. Pure Coke,
17, Government Place East,
4, Esplanade Mansion,
Kolkata – 700 069,
West Bengal.
2.
Shri Tamal Ghosal,
Partner,
M/s. Pure Coke,
17, Government Place East,
4, Esplanade Mansion,
Kolkata – 700 069,
West Bengal.
3.
Shri Pankaj Tibrawala,
Partner,
M/s. Pure Coke,
17, Government Place East,
4, Esplanade Mansion,
Kolkata – 700 069,
West Bengal.
4.
M/s. Vodafone Essar South Limited,
C-48, Okhla Industrial Area,
Phase II,
New Delhi – 110 020.
5.
M/s. Tata Teleservices Limited,
Jeevan Bharati,
10th Floor,
124, Connaught Circus,
New Delhi – 110 001.
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in RFA No.18 of 2016
Shri Taktuk Bhutia @ T. T. Bhutia vs. M/s. Pure Coke and Others
Application for condonation of delay in re-filing the
RFA under Rules 16, 17 and 18 of the Sikkim High
Court (Practice and Procedure) Rules, 2011
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Jorgay Namka, Legal Aid Counsel for the Appellant.
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, Mrs. Manita Pradhan and Mr. Sujan Sunwar,
Advocates for the Respondents No.1 to 3.
Mr. Sudhir Prasad, Advocate for the Respondent No.4.
Mr. Megh Nath Dhungel, Advocate for Respondent No.5.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The instant Petition under Rules 16, 17 and 18 of the
Sikkim High Court (Practice and Procedure) Rules, 2011 (for short
“P. P. Rules”), purports to be a Petition for condonation of fifty-one
days delay, in filing the Regular First Appeal (RFA).
2.
The facts relevant for the disposal of this Petition are
that, on 07-10-2015, the Defendants No.1 to 3 (the Respondents
No.1 to 3 herein), filed an Application under Order VII Rule 11, read
with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short
“CPC”), before the Learned District Judge, East Sikkim, at Gangtok,
in Money Suit No.06 of 2015, Taktuk Bhutia vs. M/s. Pure Coke and
Others. The Application was allowed vide the impugned Order dated
12-05-2016, inter alia, with the finding that the Suit was barred by
limitation and the Court had no jurisdiction in the matter, thereby
dismissing the Suit of the Plaintiff (the Appellant herein).
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in RFA No.18 of 2016
Shri Taktuk Bhutia @ T. T. Bhutia vs. M/s. Pure Coke and Others
3.
Assailing the impugned Order for the first time before
this Court on 09-08-2016, the Appellant filed a First Appeal from
Order (FAO), according to the Appellant, within the period of
limitation, but was not listed before the Court, due to defects
pointed out therein.
On 15-10-2016, the FAO was re-filed after
curing of defects. The Registry declined to place the matter before
the Court for a second time as the Counsel for the Appellant lacked
a specific letter from the Sikkim State Legal Services Authority
(SSLSA), appointing him as Counsel for appearance in the matter
before the High Court. Consequent thereupon, the SSLSA was
approached, necessary letter obtained and the FAO re-filed on 1011-2016. Following the above events, the Appellant again withdrew
the FAO No.03 of 2016 on 15-11-2016 and on being so advised,
filed the present RFA on 16-11-2016, leading to, according to him, a
total delay of fifty-one days. That, the delay occurred due to nonavailability of the Appellant and also due to the ensuing festive
season. That, the Appellant shall suffer irreparable loss and injury,
if the Appeal is not allowed, hence, the Petition be allowed
condoning the delay on the grounds put forth.
4.
In response, it was contended by Learned Counsel for
the Respondents No.1 to 3 that, firstly, the Appellant has not come
to the Court with clean hands, as the Plaint reveals that the contract
was awarded to the North-East Group of Engineers Private Limited
and not to the Petitioner by name, i.e., Taktuk Bhutia. The contract
being between two Companies, it is evident that he is filing the Suit
in a representative capacity, being the Managing Director of the
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in RFA No.18 of 2016
Shri Taktuk Bhutia @ T. T. Bhutia vs. M/s. Pure Coke and Others
Company.
But he has obtained free Legal Aid, because he is a
Tribal, which he is not entitled to in terms of Section 12 of the Legal
Services Authorities Act, 1987 (in short “Legal Services Act”) and
Regulation 30(6) of the Sikkim State Legal Services Authority
Regulation, 1998 (in short “SSLSA Regulation”), in view of the
foregoing circumstance, thereby misleading the Court. In the next
leg of his argument, it was contended that the delay infact is not of
“fifty-one days”, but of “one hundred days” inasmuch the impugned
Order having been pronounced on 12-05-2016, the limitation
expired on 10-08-2016 and the appeal was admittedly filed on 1611-2016.
The Appellant’s ground for delay having occurred on
account of the filing of the FAO is not a bona fide ground, as two
months were evidently taken to rectify defects. That, although the
Appellant attributed the delay also to the lack of appointment letter
from SSLSA, no correspondence was placed before the Registry to
substantiate this point. Thus, the Petition is frivolous and deserves
dismissal.
Reliance
was
placed
on
the
decisions
of
Esha
Bhattacharjee vs. Managing Committee of Raghunathpur Nafar Academy
and Others1
and Basawaraj and Another vs. Special Land Acquisition
Officer2.
5.
The Respondent No.5 in his Written Response averred
that the grounds furnished for the delay do not reveal “sufficient
cause” as required under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 (for
short “the Limitation Act”).
(2013) 12 SCC 649
(2013) 14 SCC 81
That, the errors committed by the
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in RFA No.18 of 2016
Shri Taktuk Bhutia @ T. T. Bhutia vs. M/s. Pure Coke and Others
Appellant while filing the present Appeal are not bona fide mistakes
and are no grounds for condoning the delay. Moreover, this Court
vide Order dated 15-11-2016 passed in FAO No.03 of 2016 had
allowed the Appellant to withdraw the FAO with liberty to file afresh,
but had not condoned the delay.
That, the delay of fifty-one days
is deliberate and unexplained, and thereby ought to be dismissed.
6.
No verbal submissions were placed by Learned Counsel
for Respondents No.4 and 5.
7.
Anxious consideration was given to the rival contentions
of Learned Counsel for the parties and the impugned Order dated
12-05-2016 perused.
8.
Although the Petition purports to be one for condonation
of delay, the provisions under Rules 16, 17 and 18 of the P. P.
Rules, have been erroneously invoked, instead of the provisions of
Section 5 of the Limitation Act. The said rules are being reproduced
hereinbelow for convenience;
“16. Court’s Power to dispense with compliance
with the Rules:- The Court may, for sufficient cause
shown, excuse the parties from compliance with any of
the requirements of these Rules and may give such
directions in matters of practices and procedure as it
may consider just and expedient.
17. Power of Court to make appropriate
orders:An application to be excused from
compliance with the requirements of any of the rules
shall, in the first instance, be placed before the
Registrar who may without interfering or dispensing
with any mandatory requirements of the rule shall
place before the Court for appropriate order thereon,
on a convenient day.
18. Inherent power of the Court not affected:Nothing in these Rules shall be deemed to limit or
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in RFA No.18 of 2016
Shri Taktuk Bhutia @ T. T. Bhutia vs. M/s. Pure Coke and Others
otherwise affect the inherent powers of the Court to
make such orders as may be necessary for the ends of
justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the
Court.”
A bare reading of the aforesaid provisions would indicate that
the Court is not clothed with powers to waive statutory provisions.
9.
Be that as it may, even if, this Court for the purpose of
doing real and substantial justice between the parties, is to presume
that the Petition is one under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, the
Appellant under the said provision is required to satisfy the Court
that he has “sufficient cause” for not preferring the Appeal, or
making the Petition within the period prescribed.
10.
In the light of the above principle, we may examine
whether the facts placed before this Court, discussed in seriatim,
would establish “sufficient cause”.
(i)
The impugned Order having been issued on 12-05-2016,
the period of limitation would end on 10-08-2016, being
ninety days, in terms of Article 116 of the Limitation Act.
The FAO was filed on 09-08-2016, which was evidently
not placed before the Court on account of defects
pointed out. After the defects were cured, the FAO was
filed for the second time on 15-10-2016, but remained
unlisted due to dearth of letter of appointment of Legal
Aid Counsel from the SSLSA. Rectifications were made
as per requisites of the Registry and the FAO once again
filed on 10-11-2016. Thereafter, the appellant withdrew
the FAO, registered as FAO No.03 of 2016, on 15-11-
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in RFA No.18 of 2016
Shri Taktuk Bhutia @ T. T. Bhutia vs. M/s. Pure Coke and Others
2016, and on 16-11-2016 filed the RFA along with the
instant Petition seeking condonation of delay.
(ii)
Simple calculations would reveal a total delay of ninetyeight days instead of the fifty-one days sought to be
erroneously projected by the Petitioner.
As per the
Petitioner, a delay of twenty-seven days occurred
between 09-08-2016 and 15-10-2016 which is clearly a
wrong calculation.
That, from 15-10-2016 to 10-11-
2016, a delay of twenty-four days occurred, this is also
erroneous.
What the Appellant seeks to submit by
stating that he came to learn of “the above anomalies
only on 21-10-2016” is anyone’s guess, considering the
events and dates that have already been unfolded
above.
(iii)
This Court in Shri Tara Kumar Pradhan vs. Shri Yuba Kumar
Pradhan3
has pointed out that an Application or RFA
cannot be deemed to be filed, unless all defects are
cured, the same observation holds good for the facts
and circumstances herein.
(iv)
The paucity of a letter from the SSLSA was the other
ground listed for the delay, but compliance thereafter
took more than twenty-six days.
What ensued in the
twenty-six days is not forthcoming from the Petitioner.
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in RFA No.16 of 2016 decided on 19-04-2017
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in RFA No.18 of 2016
Shri Taktuk Bhutia @ T. T. Bhutia vs. M/s. Pure Coke and Others
(v)
Pertinently, it may be observed here that the grant of
free Legal Aid to the Petitioner is a matter which can be
considered by the SSLSA and if after scrutiny the
requisite conditions are unfulfilled in terms of Section 12
of the Legal Services Act and Regulation 30(6) of the
SSLSA Regulation, the free Legal Aid is liable to be
withdrawn.
(vi)
The ground of non-availability of the Appellant is indeed
absurd.
If the Appellant was so interested, he could
have made himself available to enable his Counsel to
take steps.
Furthermore, the reasons and grounds of
such non-availability have not been elucidated. Nothing
prevented the Appellant from approaching the Registry
during the festive season, apart from which the dates of
such festivities have not been disclosed.
11.
In this context, this Court is aware that Courts should
avoid a pedantic approach while making technical considerations for
the delay, in order to have a justice-oriented approach and mete out
substantial justice. At the same time, one cannot lose sight of the
fact that no presumption can be attached to deliberate causes of
delay, such as gross negligence as exhibited hereinabove.
In this
regard, reference can be made to the decision in Esha Bhattacharjee1
wherein it was held as follows;
“21. ………………………………………………………………
21.9. (ix) The conduct, behaviour and attitude
of a party relating to its inaction or negligence are
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in RFA No.18 of 2016
Shri Taktuk Bhutia @ T. T. Bhutia vs. M/s. Pure Coke and Others
relevant factors to be taken into consideration. It is so
as the fundamental principle is that the courts are
required to weigh the scale of balance of justice in
respect of both parties and the said principle cannot be
given a total go by in the name of liberal approach.
21.10. (x) If the explanation offered is
concocted or the grounds urged in the application are
fanciful, the courts should be vigilant not to expose the
other side unnecessarily to face such a litigation.
21.11. (xi) It is to be borne in mind that no one
gets
away
with
fraud,
misrepresentation
or
interpolation by taking recourse to the technicalities of
law of limitation.
21.12. (xii) The entire gamut of facts are to be
carefully scrutinized and the approach should be based
on the paradigm of judicial discretion which is founded
on objective reasoning and not on individual
perception.
21.13. (xiii) The State or a public body or an
entity representing a collective cause should be given
some acceptable latitude.
22. To the aforesaid principles we may add
some more guidelines taking note of the present day
scenario. They are:
22.1. (a) An application for condonation of delay
should be drafted with careful concern and not in a
haphazard manner harbouring the notion that the
courts are required to condone delay on the bedrock of
the principle that adjudication of a lis on merits is
seminal to justice dispensation system.
22.2. (b) An application for condonation of delay
should not be dealt with in a routine manner on the
base of individual philosophy which is basically
subjective.
22.3. (c) Though no precise formula can be laid
down regard being had to the concept of judicial
discretion, yet a conscious effort for achieving
consistency and collegiality of the adjudicatory system
should be made as that is the ultimate institutional
motto.
22.4. (d) The increasing tendency to perceive
delay as a non-serious matter and, hence, lackadaisical
propensity can be exhibited in a nonchallant manner
requires to be curbed, of course, within legal
parameters.”
The parameters of consideration have been succinctly set
forth, the grounds put forth by the Petitioner do not merit
I.A. No.01 of 2016 in RFA No.18 of 2016
Shri Taktuk Bhutia @ T. T. Bhutia vs. M/s. Pure Coke and Others
consideration as it is evident that no attention has been paid to the
drafting, the delay calculated is erroneous and above all, no reasons
even on week to week basis for the delay have been placed before
the Court, giving the impression that the Court is being taken for
granted.
The Petition obviously cannot be dealt with in a routine
manner as the interest of not only the Petitioner, but the Opposite
party has also to be borne in mind.
12.
The grounds for delay taken by the Petitioner fall short
of the requirement of Law, as “sufficient cause” for not taking steps
on time is sadly devoid in the instant case.
13.
Resultant,
the
grounds
put
forth
deserve
no
consideration. Consequently, the Petition is dismissed, as also the
Appeal.
14.
Copy of this Order be sent to the Learned Trial Court
along with Records of the Court, and to the Member Secretary,
SSLSA forthwith for information and compliance.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
20-07-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review