Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED : 15.07.2026
CORAM :
The Hon'ble Mr.Justice N.SATHISH KUMAR
and
The Hon'ble Mr.Justice M.JOTHIRAMAN
A.S.No.130 of 2019
and
C.M.P.Nos.5315 and 5316 of 2019 and 13053 of 2024
T.A.H.Jaffer Ali
.. Appellant
Vs.
1.T.A.H.Niazi Basha
2.Hayath Bi
3.Bibi John
4.Rihana Begum
5.Powshiya Begum
.. Respondents
This appeal suit has been filed under section 96 read with Order XLI Rule
1 of CPC seeking to set aside the judgment and decree dated 24.07.2018
made in O.S.No.7 of 2016 (which was earlier numbered as O.S.No.76 of
2014) on the file of the District Court, Villupuram) on the file of the court
of the II Additional District and Sessions Judge, Tindivanam by allowing
the first appeal and thus render justice.
For Appellant
: Mr.T.Dhanasekaran
For Respondents : Mr.S.N.Ravikumar for R-1
No appearance for RR2 to 5
--1/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
JUDGMENT
(The judgment of the court was made by N.SATHISH KUMAR, J.)
Challenging the preliminary decree and judgment of the trial court,
namely, the II Additional District and Sessions Court, Tindivanam made
in O.S.No.7 of 2016, dated 24.07.2018, granting plaintiff 2/8th share in
the suit property, the present appeal suit is preferred by the first
defendant.
2.The parties in the present appeal suit are hereinafter referred to as
per their rankings before the trial court.
3.The brief facts which are necessary for disposal of the appeal suit
are as follows:
3.1.The plaintiff and defendant no.1 are brothers. The other
defendants, namely defendants 3 to 5 are sisters of plaintiff and first
defendant. The second defendant is the mother of the plaintiff and
defendant nos.1, 3 to 5. The suit properties are separate properties of the
father of the plaintiff and the first defendant, namely Abdul Hameed by
virtue of his purchase under sale deeds dated 23.08.2000 and 10.09.2001
and a registered settlement deed dated 26.05.1970. The said Abdul
2/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
Hameed died intestate in the year 2011. Therefore, the plaintiff and the
first defendant being sons of said Abdul Hameed are each entitled to
2/8th share in the suit properties and defendants 2 to 5 each are entitled to
1/8th share in the said suit properties. Therefore, the plaintiff has filed a
suit seeking for preliminary decree for dividing his 2/8th share in the suit
property.
3.2.According to the first defendant, there is no dispute with regard
to the relationship between the parties. It is the averment of the first
defendant that the plaintiff by suppressing the material facts has filed the
suit. According to him, the first defendant has purchased the suit property
in the name of his father through the earnings of the first defendant. His
father had no financial source to purchase the suit properties. The suit
properties were purchased in the earnings made by the first defendant in
abroad. After the completion of the working period in the abroad in the
year 2011, his father had executed a settlement deed dated 18.05.2011 in
favour of the first defendant and put him in possession and enjoyment of
the suit properties. The first defendant had also accepted the settlement
deed and he has been in possession and enjoyment of the suit properties.
Therefore, according to the first defendant, the suit properties are
absolute properties of the first defendant. The suit properties never
3/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
belonged to joint family. The plaintiff did not even pay single penny to
the joint family. The said Abdul Hameed, during his life time, never
recognised the suit properties as his family properties. The first defendant
has paid the taxes in respect of the suit properties. Hence, he has opposed
the suit filed by the plaintiff.
3.3.In the reply statement, the plaintiff denied the alleged
settlement deed said to have been executed by the father on 18.05.2011 in
favour of the first defendant. The said settlement deed is an unregistered
one and cannot be acted upon. Their father had never executed any
settlement deed during his life time in favour of the first defendant.
3.4.In the additional statement, the first defendant has submitted
that his father had no independent income. The first defendant has
possessed the sale deeds of the suit properties. The first defendant is in
possession and enjoyment of the suit properties with the knowledge of
the plaintiff and other defendants and they have never claimed any right
over the suit properties while their father was alive or after his death and
the first defendant is only paying the taxes in respect of the suit properties
and hence, he has disputed the claim of the plaintiff.
4.On the basis of the pleadings, the trial court has framed the
following issues:
4/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
i)Whether Abdul Ameed was the absolute owner of the
suit properties, as claimed by the plaintiff?
ii)Whether the suit properties were purchased by D1’s
money, as claimed by the Defendant?
iii)Whether in 2011, D1 was put in possession and
enjoyment of the suit properties?
iv)Whether the suit is barred by limitation?
v)Whether the plaintiff is entitled to 2/8th share in the
suit properties?
vi)To what other relief the plaintiff is entitled to?
5.On the side of the plaintiff, one Thaharunissa was examined as
P.W.1 and Exs.A.1 to A.6 were marked. On the side of the defendants,
D.W.1 and D.W.2 were examined and Exs.B.1 to B.13 documents were
marked.
6.Based on the evidence and materials available on record, the trial
court had granted preliminary decree in favour of the plaintiff by granting
2/8th share in the suit properties. Challenging the same, the first
defendant has filed the present appeal.
7.The first defendant has also filed two petitions under Order XLI
5/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
Rule 27 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908, namely C.M.P.Nos.5316 of
2019 and 13053 of 2024 in order to receive some of the documents as
additional documents in the appeal. It is the contention of the counsel
appearing for the first defendant that the trial court has not granted the
relief in favour of the first defendant / appellant on the ground that the
settlement deed dated 18.05.2011 has not been produced during the
course of evidence. Therefore, it is just and necessary that the first
defendant may be permitted to file the documents, in particular settlement
deed dated 18.05.2011. It is further stated that after the execution of the
settlement deed, the father of the first defendant had also handed over the
other documents relating to the suit properties and therefore, it is stated
that those documents are also relevant to prove his case. Hence, he has
sought to file the following documents as additional documents:
Sl.
Date
Doc.No.
Description of Documents
Nature of
Documents
1.
22.08.1969 1181/1969 Sale
Deed
executed
by Photocopy
Samikannu Maistry in favour of
Sundara Maistry
2.
26.05.1970 620/1970
3.
22.09.1975 1534/1975 Sale Deed executed by 1) Photocopy
Kalappa
Chetty,
2)Perumal
Chetty & 3)Vazhmuni Chetty in
favour
of
Neelavathi
W/o.Sundara Maistry
6/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Hibba alias Gift Settlement Deed Photocopy
executed by Abdul Hameed in
favour of Khader Bee W/o.Abdul
Majid
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
4.
02.11.1982 1836/1982 Sale
Deed
executed
by Photocopy
Samikannu Maistry in favour of
Manicka Chettiar
5.
01.04.1993
Kist Receipt No.556307 issued to Photocopy
T.A.Abdul Hameed for fasli 1402
6.
29.01.1994
Kist Receipt No.580125 issued to Photocopy
T.A.Abdul Hameed for fasli 1403
7.
Enquiry Notice issued by Spl. Photocopy
Tahsildar (Natham Land Tax
Scheme), Tindivanam for Survey
No.246/1C to Adbul Sameed
S/o.Abdul Majid
8.
31.07.1996
9.
23.08.2000 1338/2000 Sale
Deed
executed
by Photocopy
1)Neelavathi
Ammal
W/o
Sundara Maistry, 2)Raghu S/o.
Sundara Maistry for himself and
for his Minor sons 1)R.Senthil
Murugan,
2)Gurumoorthy,
3)Vinayagan & 4)Aiyappan in
favour of T.A.Abdul Hameed
Thoraya Patta issued by Spl. Photocopy
Tahsildar (Natham Land Tax
Scheme), Tindivanam for Survey
No.246/1C to
Abdul Sameed S/o.Abdul Majid
10. 10.09.2001 1438/2001 Sale Deed executed by Manicka Photocopy
Chettiar in favour of T.A.Abdul
Hameed
11.
Patta No.13 issued to Abdul Photocopy
Hameed S/o.Abdul Majid
12. 23.12.2001 R.T.R./
Proceedings of the Scheme Zonal Photocopy
302/2001-2 Officer, Patta Pass Book Scheme,
Tindivanam – Zone 5 for change
of Patta in the name of Abdul
Hameed for
Survey No. Extent in Hectares
150/10
0.29.5
150/14
0.27.0
150/15
0.28.0
7/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
13. 18.05.2011 18.05.2011 Settlement Deed executed by Photocopy
T.A.Abdul Hameed in favour of
the Petitioner T.A.H.Jaffar Ali
8.In the counter affidavits filed in the said applications, it was
submitted that these documents were very much available and kept in the
father’s house and the same were taken by the appellant / first defendant
without the consent of the others. The settlement deed was a created one.
It is submitted that a criminal case has already been filed against the first
defendant and is pending in Crime No.469 of 2022 for creating forged no
objection certification in the name of the Taluk Tahsildar and hence, the
applications are opposed.
9.The learned counsel for the appellant / first defendant mainly
would submit that the trial court has non suited the defendants mainly on
the ground that the settlement deed dated 18.05.2011 was not produced.
According to the appellant, the entire suit properties were purchased in
the name of the father out of the income of the first defendant. Therefore,
the father of the first defendant has executed the settlement deed and
therefore, he was in possession and enjoyment of the suit properties. It
was further contended that the first defendant has paid the necessary
taxes in respect of the suit properties. Therefore, if the additional
documents are allowed to file and if the same are marked and an
8/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
opportunity is given to the parties, the first defendant can establish his
case. The learned counsel would further submit that as per the
Mohammedan Law, when the gift was accepted and the possession has
also been taken, it is considered that he is in occupation of the suit
properties and therefore, the trial court is not right in decreeing the suit in
favour of the plaintiff.
10.The learned counsel for the plaintiff/first respondent herein
would submit that the so-called additional documents now sought to be
filed are only photocopies. The alleged settlement deed dated 18.05.2011
though pleaded in the written statement, in the chief examination, the first
defendant had never stated anything about the same. It was contended
that only the photocopies were filed by the first defendant and that the
originals have not seen the light of the day. That apart, merely because
some kist receipts were filed that the kist has been paid by one of the coowners, the same is not the determinant factor to prove the alleged gift. It
is further contended by the learned counsel for the plaintiff that if really
these documents were in possession of the first defendant, the same
should have been filed at the time of trial itself. The first defendant, had
in fact, admitted that all those documents were in his possession and if so,
there was no reason as to why the first defendant has not filed those
9/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
documents during trial. Therefore, as a matter of right, those documents
cannot be received as additional documents at the appellate stage. It is
further contended that the suit properties are absolute properties of their
father. The specific stand taken by the first defendant / appellant was that
he has purchased the property in the name of his father and therefore, he
has elected the plea of benami. Once he has elected the plea of benami
before the trial court, now the first defendant cannot rely upon the
inconsistent plea and cannot seek for permission to receive those
documents as additional documents. Hence, the learned counsel for the
plaintiff / first respondent opposed those two applications and prayed for
dismissal of the same.
11.In the light of the submissions made, the points that arise for
consideration in this appeal are as follows:
(i)Whether additional documents now sought to be
filed are admissible and relevant for disposal of the case
on hand?
(ii)Whether the parties are entitled to respective
shares in the suit properties left by the father?
(iii)To what other relief the parties are entitled to?
10/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
Point No.(i):
12.The appellant is the first defendant in the suit. The suit has been
originally laid by his brother seeking for partition of suit properties held
by their father one Abdul Hameed. The relationship between the parties
in the suit is not in dispute. It is the case of the plaintiff that the father
Abdul Hameed died intestate leaving behind the plaintiff and defendants
as his legal heirs. Therefore, the plaintiff is entitled to 2/8th share. The
first defendant has taken a defence to the effect that the entire property
was purchased in the name of his father out of the income derived by the
first defendant from the job in the foreign country and therefore, the plea
of benami was taken. That apart, another plea was also taken that his
father had executed a settlement deed dated 18.05.2011. Therefore, he
took possession of the property and he is paying the taxes in respect of
the properties.
13.Having taken such inconsistent plea in the written statement, in
the evidence, he has proceeded as if the first item of the property was
gifted in the name of the father by his mother and other items of
properties were purchased by Abdul Hameed out of the consideration
paid by the first defendant. In nutshell, it is the stand of the first
defendant that the suit properties were purchased in the name of his father
11/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
as benami. Further, D.W.1 has also stated that the father himself has
partitioned the suit properties in the year 1999 and the shares of the
plaintiff and other defendants were given. Though in the written
statement, the inconsistent plea of unregistered settlement deed dated
18.05.2011 has been pleaded, in the chief examination, he has never
whispered anything about the so-called unregistered document of
settlement deed dated 18.05.2011. In the cross examination, he has taken
a stand that though his father died on 29.10.2011, he has settled the
property in his favour, but he has never whispered about the so-called
settlement deed dated 18.05.2011. Therefore, having elected the plea of
benami and previous partition, he has not projected the settlement deed
dated 18.05.2011 during his evidence in the chief and also in the cross
examination.
14.That being the position, now the settlement deed dated
18.05.2011, i.e., the so-called unregistered settlement deed said to have
been left by the father was sought to be projected in the appeal at the
appellate stage. It is relevant to note that though the first defendant /
appellant has taken an inconsistent plea about the existing settlement
deed dated 18.05.2011, there was no reason as to why has he has not filed
those documents before the trial court during trial when the so-called
12/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
documents are very much available with the first defendant. Therefore, in
the absence of explanation explaining the exercise of due diligence
during trial and despite such exercise of due diligence, such documents
were not within his knowledge or could not be produced after the
exercise of due diligence at the time of trial, as a matter of right, those
documents cannot be filed in the appellate stage. According to the first
defendant / appellant, those documents were given by the father after the
execution of the settlement deed. Such being the position, nothing has
prevented the first defendant to produce those documents before the trial
court. It is not the case of the appellant / first defendant that those
documents were not within his knowledge or could not be produced after
due diligence before the trial court. Therefore, without establishing due
diligence aspect and further the aspect that documents were not within his
knowledge and therefore, he could not produce the same before the trial
court after exercising due diligence, as a matter of right, at the appellate
stage, such additional documents cannot be received.
15.Further, it is to be noted that the court may admit additional
documents if the court requires any document which enables the court to
pronounce the judgment and for any other substantial cause, the court
may allow such documents. But on perusal of those documents which are
13/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
sought to be filed as additional documents, it is seen that they are
photocopies of the documents. The documents are sale deeds, gift
settlement deeds, kist receipts, etc., The loss of originals were never
accounted for. If the originals are available, there was no reason as to
why he has not filed the same before this court. Therefore, the very filing
of photocopies without accounting for loss of original cannot be
admitted. In any event, it is not the case of the appellants that these
documents were not in his possession and that he had no knowledge
about those documents and despite due diligence and search, he was not
able to produce those documents at the time of trial and that those
documents came into his possession at a later point of time. Such being
the position, as a matter of right, these documents cannot be used.
Further, even assuming that the originals are available, these documents
sought to be filed are in no way relevant to prove the case of the first
defendant for the simple reason that having taken two different pleas, one
benami transaction and another settlement deed, in the evidence he has
given up the plea of settlement, whereas he has projected the case as if
the entire property was purchased by him in the name of his father.
Having elected one plea, the first defendant cannot be allowed to take up
inconsistent plea in the appellate stage. For that reason also, we are of the
14/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
view that the additional documents filed at this stage and that too
photocopies of the documents cannot be permitted to file as additional
documents. Hence, the applications filed in this regard, namely
C.M.P.Nos.5316 of 2019 and 13053 of 2024 stand dismissed.
Point Nos.(ii) and (iii):
16.As stated above, the relationship between the parties are not in
dispute and the suit properties are admittedly in the name of the father
Abdul Hameed and he died intestate in the year 2011 has also been
admitted by first defendant himself. It is the contention that except the
first item, the other item of properties were purchased by the father out of
the income of the first defendant. It is relevant to note that the plea of
benami cannot be pressed into service because it is clearly prohibited as
per section 3 of the Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act,
1988. Before the amendment of the said Prohibition of Benami Property
Transactions Act, 1988, the provision says, no person shall enter into any
benami transaction, though sub clause (2) of section 3 permits purchase
of the property by any person in the name of his wife or unmarried
daughter and it shall be presumed, unless the contrary is proved that the
said property had been purchased for the benefit of the wife or the
unmarried daughter. Therefore, the purchase of the property in the name
15/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
of the father and other members, except wife and unmarried daughter, is
totally prohibited under section 3 of the Benami Transactions
(Prohibition) Act, 1988. Section 4 of the Act prohibits any claim or action
to enforce any right in respect of any property held benami against the
person in whose name the property is held or against any other person
shall lie by or on behalf of a person claiming to be the real owner of such
property. Similarly, no defence based on any right in respect of any
property held benami is also permissible under sub clause (2) of section 4
of the Act. Therefore, the plea of Benami set up by the first defendant /
appellant has no legs to stand and the plea of first defendant has to fail
with regard to his claim of absolute right over the suit properties.
17.In the chief examination also, he has never pleaded about the
so-called settlement and he has relied on the kist receipts for fasli year
1421 Ex.B.10 and Ex.B.12 for the year 2014-2015. It is relevant to note
that these documents were obtained after the death of his father. Further,
when the cross examination of D.W.1 is perused, it is seen that he has
taken a stand that the property has been sold to him by his father. This
inconsistent stand of the first defendant militate against his own plea in
the written statement. Further, the so-called unregistered settlement deed
was also not spoken either in the chief examination or in the cross
16/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
examination, particularly with regard to the date of settlement. Such
being the position, having elected the plea of benami and failed, the first
defendant cannot be permitted to rely on the other inconsistent plea at the
appellate stage. The cross examination of D.W.1 shows that the plaintiff
and defendants 3 to 5 also used to reside in the suit properties and his
definite stand in the cross examination was that he has asserted his right
only based on the sale executed by his father which is also contrary to the
pleadings and further, he has also admitted that his mother has a share in
his father’s property. Therefore, from the above, it is clear that the
property stood in the name of the father and the father died intestate and
the so-called settlement deed has not been established and the
inconsistent plea of benami was taken which has also failed and
therefore, as the legal heirs of said Abdul Hameed, the plaintiff and
defendants are certainly entitled to share as per the Mohammedan Law.
The plaintiff and the first defendant being the sons, they are each entitled
to 2/8th share and the other defendants are each entitled to 1/8th share in
the suit properties. Therefore, point nos.(ii) and (iii) are answered.
18.In view of the above, we do not find any merit in the appeal
filed by the first defendant / appellant. The appeal suit fails and the same
is dismissed. The judgment and decree passed by the trial court granting
17/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
preliminary decree of 2/8th share in favour of the plaintiff is confirmed. It
is open to the first defendant / appellant and other defendants in the suit
to pay necessary court fee in respect of their respective shares during the
allotment of shares in the final decree proceedings. No costs.
Consequently, the connected CMP No.5315 of 2019 is closed.
(N.S.K., J.) (M.J.R., J.)
15.07.2026
Index : Yes / No
Speaking Order /Non speaking order
vvk
To
1.II Additional District and Sessions Court,
Tindivanam.
2.Section Officer,
VR Section,
Madras High Court,
Chennai.
18/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
2026:MHC:3005
A.S.No.130 of 2019
N.SATHISH KUMAR, J.
and
M.JOTHIRAMAN, J.
vvk
A.S.No.130 of 2019
and
C.M.P.Nos.5315 and 5316 of 2019
and 13053 of 2024
15.07.2026
19/19
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review