The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. In view of the above discussion, we find sufficient reasons to interfere with the concurrent finding of facts entered into by both the authorities. As it is concurrently found that the landlord bona fide needs the vacant possession of the tenanted premises, the eviction petition is only to RCRev.No.180 of 2024 2025:KER:30159 be allowed, as the tenant failed to prove that there are no other vacant buildings in the nearby locality to shift her business.
10. In the result, the revision petition is allowed. The petitioner is entitled to get vacant possession of the petition-scheduled building as per Section 11(3) of the Act. However, months’ time to the tenant to we grant six the said vacate premises on the following conditions: (i) The respondent shall file an affidavit before the Rent Control Court or the Execution Court, as the case may be, within two weeks from the date of receipt of order, expressing undertaking vacant a certified that possession an copy of this unconditional she will surrender of the petition- scheduled shop room to the petitionerlandlord within six months from the date RCRev.No.180 of 2024 2025:KER:30159 of this order and that, she shall not induct third parties into possession of the petition-scheduled shop room. (ii) The respondent shall deposit the entire arrears of rent as on date, if any, before the Rent Control Court or the Execution Court, as the case may be, within one month from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order, and shall continue to pay rent for every succeeding month, without any default; Needless to say, failing to comply (iii) with any above, one the of time the conditions stated limit granted this by order to surrender vacant possession of the stand petition-scheduled cancelled shop room automatically, and will the RCRev.No.180 of 2024 2025:KER:30159 landlord will be at libe…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. KRISHNA KUMAR
WEDNESDAY, THE 9TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 19TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RCREV. NO. 180 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 15.12.2023 IN RCA NO.3 OF
OF
ADDITIONAL
DISTRICT
COURT
&
SESSIONS
COURT
-
II,
KASARAGOD / II ADDITIONAL MACT, KASARAGODE ARISING OUT OF THE
ORDER DATED 04.12.2019 IN RCP NO.4 OF 2017 OF MUNSIFF COURT,
HOSDRUG
REVISION PETITIONER/APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
T.V.BABU
AGED 60 YEARS
'THUSHARA', AANIKKADI, PALA IN KODAKAD VILLAGE OF
HOSDURG TALUK, KASARAGOD DISTRICT. (REPRESENTED BY
PA HOLDER, BINDU BABU P V, AGED 49 YEARS,
W/O.T.V.BABU, ELECTION IDENTITY CARD NO.JWB1537331,
'THUSHARA', AANIKKADI, PALA IN KODAKAD VILLAGE OF
HOSDURG TALUK, KASARAGOD DISTRICT, PIN - 671315
BY ADVS.
ARUN KRISHNA DHAN
T.K.SANDEEP
ARJUN SREEDHAR
ALEX ABRAHAM
SWETHA R.
HARIKRISHNAN P.B.
GOWRI MENON
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT:
BEENA.K.P
AGED 46 YEARS
'SHIMATTY VASTHRALAYAM, NEAR CHERUVATHUR BUS STAND
IN CHERUVATHUR VILLAGE, HOSDURG TALUK, KASARAGOD
DISTRICT, PIN - 671313
BY ADV JAWAHAR JOSE
THIS RENT CONTROL REVISION HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
02.04.2025, THE COURT ON 09.04.2025 PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
ORDER
P.Krishna Kumar, J.
The landlord who filed an eviction petition
under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease
and Rent Control) Act, 1965 (‘the Act’, for short)
suffered an adverse finding by the Rent Control Court
and
the
Rent
Control
Appellate
Authority
concurrently, is before us by invoking the revisional
jurisdiction of this Court under the Act.
2. The contention of the landlord was that he
bona fide needed the vacant possession of the shop
room rented out to the tenant on 28.04.2006, for the
occupation
of
his
computer-related
dependent
son,
business.
Both
for
starting
the
a
courts
concurrently found that the need projected by the
landlord was bona fide. However, they found that the
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
landlord was in possession of certain other rooms in
the shopping complex owned by him, which also housed
the petition-scheduled shop room. It is also found
that the landlord failed to show any special reasons
for getting the eviction order, in view of the first
proviso to Section 11(3) of the Act.
3. We have heard Sri.Arun Krishna Dhan, the
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioner
and
Sri.Jawahar Jose, the learned counsel appearing for
the respondent.
4. Ordinarily, this Court will be very slow in
interfering
with
the
concurrent
findings
of
fact
entered into by the Rent Control Court and the Rent
Control Appellate Authority, while invoking its power
under Section 20 of the Act. However, in this case,
when we analysed the impugned orders, it was found
that the enquiry conducted by both the courts was
completely
misdirected.
The
burden
of
proof
of
establishing the basic elements of the first proviso
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
to Section 11(3) of the Act is indisputably upon the
tenant.
Further,
this
Court
in
Kakkottakath
Ali
and
Others
Puthiyapurayil
Muhammad
Kakkottakath
Puthiyarambath
Mahamood
and
v.
Others
(2022(4) KLT 221) held that it is obligatory on the
part of the tenant to specifically plead and prove
the
identity
of
the
vacant
buildings
in
the
possession of the landlord if he wants to get the
advantage of the first proviso to Section 11(3) of
the Act. The Court followed the earlier decision of
the High Court of Kerala in Dineshan Pillai P.B. v.
Joseph (2019(3) KHC 206) while arriving at the above
finding.
The
incumbent
Court
upon
the
also
observed
landlord
to
that
it
is
not
disclose
in
his
pleadings the availability of other vacant buildings
in
his possession.
It is
beneficial to
quote the
relevant findings in the said decision:
“8.
In
Vasantha
Mallan
v.
N.S.
Aboobacker Siddique [2020 (1) KHC 21] the
question that arose before a Division Bench
of this Court was whether a landlord is
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
bound to plead under the first proviso to
Section 11(3) of the Act, the availability
of vacant building in his possession and
seek to explain special reason for nonoccupation of such premises, in a proceeding
initiated for eviction of the tenant under
Section 11(3) of the Act. The Division Bench
held that the initial burden to prove that
the landlord is in possession of vacant
building, if any, is only upon the tenant
unless the landlord himself admits any such
vacant building to be in his possession.
Only when the primary burden of proof in
this behalf is discharged by the tenant, the
burden shifts to the landlord to show
otherwise or that the vacant premises are
not suited to his needs. It is up to the
tenant alone to take up the contention and
prove that landlord is in vacant possession
of the premises.
9. In Vasantha Mallan, relying on the
law laid down by the Apex Court in M.L.
Prabhakar [(2001) 2 SCC 355] the Division
Bench held that, it is not incumbent on the
landlord to disclose in his pleading the
availability of vacant building in his
possession. The non-disclosure of vacant
premises cannot be picked up as a reason or
circumstance to doubt the bona fides of the
claim of the landlord put forward under
Section 11(3) of the Act. It is not
obligatory for the landlord to disclose in
his pleadings the details of the vacant
buildings available in his possession. Nor
does the first proviso to Section 11(3) of
the Act insists the landlord to plead that
the buildings available in his possession
are not sufficient to meet his requirements.
10. In Dineshan Pillai P.B. v. Joseph @
Jose [2019 (3) KHC 206] a Division Bench of
this Court was dealing with a case in which
one of the contentions of the tenant was
that, the landlord has several other vacant
buildings of his own, in his possession, to
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
start the proposed business. The Division
Bench noticed that, the pleadings are very
vague with respect to the first proviso to
Section 11(3) of the Act. It is stated that
the landlord has several other buildings. No
particular vacant room has been identified
or pointed out in the pleadings. The
Division Bench opined that, it is obligatory
on the part of the tenant to plead and prove
the identity of the vacant building in the
possession of the landlord. In the absence
of
specific
pleadings,
disclosing
the
identity of the vacant building in the
possession of the landlord, it can be said
that the tenant has not discharged the
initial burden of proof under the first
proviso to Section 11(3) of the Act.
xxxxxxxxxxx
13. In Ext.P2 counter, the tenant has
stated that the landlord and her husband
have several other vacant buildings in the
locality for starting a provision store. No
particular
vacant
room,
allegedly
in
possession of the landlord or her husband,
has been identified or pointed out in Ext.P2
counter filed in the RCPs. It is obligatory
on the part of the tenant to plead and prove
the identity of the vacant building in the
possession of the landlord, in order to
attract the first proviso to Section 11(3)
of the Act. Therefore, in the absence of
specific
pleadings
in
Ext.P2
counter
disclosing
the
identity
of
any
vacant
building in the possession of the landlord,
it can only be said that the tenant has not
discharged the initial burden of proof under
the first proviso to Section 11(3) of the
Act.”
(Emphasis added)
The
Court
discloses
further
the
held
identity
that
of
the
unless
vacant
the
tenant
buildings
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
allegedly in the possession of the landlord, he could
not even be permitted to take out a commission for
local inspection.
5. The pleadings of the tenant in the present
case
are
almost
identical.
It
is
relevant
to
reproduce paragraphs 6 and 8 of the counter filed by
the respondent:
“6.
It
is
respectfully
submitted
that
the
petition scheduled room is part of a huge
shopping complex, by name Thushara Shopping
Complex
are
belonging
three
floors
to
the
for
petitioner.
the
said
There
building
including the basement. There are about 30
rooms in the said shopping complex out of
which the petition schedule room is situate
in the ground floor. The petitioner himself
is in possession of some portion of the said
building
where
he
is
conducting
a
super
market by name Thushara Super Market which is
being managed by the petitioner’s son. The
petitioner is also conducting a business in
grocery in retail and wholesale in the same
building under the name and style “Thushara
Traders”.
The
petitioner
is
employed
under
the Government of Qatar and he is permanently
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
there
in
connection
with
his
employment.
Hence the entire business establishments at
Cheruvathur belonging to the petitioner are
managed by his son. Hence the contention that
the
son
of
the
petitioner
has
no
other
avocation is absolutely incorrect.
8.
There
are
many
vacant
rooms
which
are
suitable for computer business in the very
same
building
where
the
situate.
belonging
petition
The
to
the
schedule
petitioner
has
petitioner,
premises
are
inducted
new
lessee in the building which is Vijaya Bank
after the sending of registered notice to the
respondent.
The
said
sufficient
for
accommodating
business
projected
in
rooms
the
are
more
the
than
alleged
petition.
The
petitioner also has in his possession vacant
buildings at Chanadukkam near to his house.”
(emphasis added)
The concurrent finding was rendered on the basis of
the above pleadings. The entire enquiry conducted by
the
Rent
Control
Court
was
seemingly
under
the
assumption that it was the burden of the landlord to
prove
that
there
were
no
vacant
rooms
in
her
possession. At one point, the Rent Control Court even
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
went on to hold that “So, the burden is upon the
petitioner to show that there are no vacant rooms
suitable for his purpose in his possession and that
even if there is any such room, he needs the petition
schedule
room
for
special
reasons.
Here
the
petitioner has not pleaded about the possession of
other rooms in the same building.”
6. Both the authorities placed heavy reliance
on
the extract
of the
building register
from the
Grama Panchayath concerned, which shows that certain
rooms are in the possession of the landlord. Mere
production of a record from the local authority does
not relieve the burden of the tenant. It is wellsettled law that the admissibility of a document in
evidence and the proof of its contents or the truth
of the facts stated in it are entirely different and
distinct aspects. What is required to be proved by
the tenant to attract the first proviso to Section
11(3)
of
the
Act
is
the
physical
existence
of
a
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
vacant building in the possession of the landlord.
Even if it is noted in the register maintained by the
local authority that a particular building is in the
vacant possession of the landlord, that would not
amount to proof of the fact that the said building
was
actually
possession
vacant
of the
and
the
same
landlord. Such
was
facts are
in
the
to be
proved through direct evidence or in the other manner
permitted
under
the
Indian
Evidence
Act/Bharatiya
Sakshya Adhiniyam.
7. Interestingly,
in
the
present
case,
the
landlord took out a commission to show that rooms in
the shopping complex owned by him were not vacant.
However, the Rent Control Court did not act upon the
said evidence on the ground that the Commissioner did
not inspect all the rooms in the said complex.
8. Both the authorities gave much emphasis on
the admission made by PW1, the wife of the landlord,
that she is in possession of certain other shop rooms
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
in the shopping complex other than the rooms in which
a supermarket is being run by the landlord. However,
we
find
no
reason
to
uphold
this
finding.
PW1
specifically stated in the chief affidavit as well as
during cross-examination that she and her husband are
conducting a supermarket and a trading business in
the said shopping complex in different rooms and the
licence for the said business was taken in her name.
The said statement has no relevance in the present
enquiry as the burden of the tenant is to show that
the
landlord
building/rooms
was
in
vacant
of
his
own,
possession
at
the
of
time
another
when
the
eviction petition was filed.
9. In view of the above discussion, we find
sufficient reasons to interfere with the concurrent
finding
of
facts
entered
into
by
both
the
authorities. As it is concurrently found that the
landlord bona fide needs the vacant possession of the
tenanted premises, the eviction petition is only to
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
be allowed, as the tenant failed to prove that there
are no other vacant buildings in the nearby locality
to shift her business.
10. In
the
result,
the
revision
petition
is
allowed. The petitioner is entitled to get vacant
possession of the petition-scheduled building as per
Section
11(3)
of
the
Act.
However,
months’
time
to
the
tenant
to
we
grant
six
the
said
vacate
premises on the following conditions:
(i)
The
respondent
shall
file
an
affidavit before the Rent Control Court
or the Execution Court, as the case may
be, within two weeks from the date of
receipt
of
order,
expressing
undertaking
vacant
a
certified
that
possession
an
copy
of
this
unconditional
she
will
surrender
of
the
petition-
scheduled shop room to the petitionerlandlord within six months from the date
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
of this order and that, she shall not
induct third parties into possession of
the petition-scheduled shop room.
(ii) The
respondent
shall
deposit
the
entire arrears of rent as on date, if
any, before the Rent Control Court or
the Execution Court, as the case may be,
within
one
month
from
the
date
of
receipt
of
a
certified
copy
of
this
order, and shall continue to pay rent
for every succeeding month, without any
default;
Needless to say, failing to comply
(iii)
with
any
above,
one
the
of
time
the
conditions
stated
limit
granted
this
by
order to surrender vacant possession of
the
stand
petition-scheduled
cancelled
shop
room
automatically,
and
will
the
RCRev.No.180 of 2024
2025:KER:30159
landlord will be at liberty to proceed
with
the
execution
of
the
order
of
eviction.
Sd/-
A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE
JUDGE
Sd/-
P.KRISHNA KUMAR
JUDGE
sv
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review