Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:277
A.S.No.747 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED : 19.01.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR . JUSTICE N.SATHISH KUMAR
AND
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. SAKTHIVEL
A.S.No.747 of 2018
1. T.Shanmugasundaram
2.Smt.Rashida Banu @ Banumathi
... Appellants
Versus
1. Smt.Palaniammal
2. T.Ramakrishnan (Died)
3. Mrs.Rajeswari
4. Indian Overseas Bank
Cross Cut Road
Gandhipuram
Coimbatore – 641 012
5. S.Vasanthi
6. R.Jagan
7. R.Nandhini
... Respondents
(R2 Died, RR5 to 7 are brought on record as LRs of deceased R2 vide order
of Court dated 28.02.2024 made in C.M.P.Nos.3582, 3587 and 3589 of
2024)
First Appeal filed under Section 96 read with Order 41 of Rule 1 of
CPC against the judgment and decree made in O.S.No.718 of 2011 dated
1/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
02.08.2018 on the file of I Additional District Judge, Coimbatore.
For Appellant
:
For Respondents :
Mr.N.Manokaran
for Mr.P.Chandrasekar
Mr.S.Mukunth
Senior counsel
of M/s.Sarvabhauman Associates
for R3, R5 to R7
Mrs.V.Rajeswari for R4
R1 and R2 (died)
JUDGMENT
(Judgment of the Court was made by N.SATHISH KUMAR, J.)
Aggrieved over the judgment and decree of the trial Court granting
preliminary decree for partition and allotting 1/4th share each to three
plaintiffs and the first defendant, the present appeal came to be filed by the
first defendant.
2. The parties are referred to by their respective ranks before the trial
Court.
3. The suit properties originally belonged to one Thangaraj. First
plaintiff is the wife and second and third plaintiffs are son and daughter
respectively. The first defendant is the younger son of said Thangaraj.
Second defendant is the wife of the first defendant. The suit properties are
2/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
the self-acquired properties of Thangaraj. The said Thangaraj was running a
sole proprietary concern in Item No.1 by name “TRS Enterprises” and he
carried on the said business until his life time. Though the second plaintiff
was associated with the business of his father, from the year 1999, he had his
own business and was residing separately with his family since 2003. The
said Thangaraj and his wife, namely the first plaintiff, were living in Item
No.1 of the suit property. The third plaintiff is the only daughter of deceased
Thangaraj. It is the case of the plaintiffs that the first defendant developed
contact and intimacy with the second defendant, who belongs to Muslim
community and ultimately married her without the knowledge of his parents
and other family members and was residing separately. According to the
plaintiffs, taking advantage of the sympathetic attitude of his mother, the
first defendant began to reside in item No.1 of the property along with his
parents. It is the case of the plaintiffs that after the death of deceased
Thangaraj intestate, the properties devolved on the plaintiffs and the first
defendant in equal shares. After the 16 th day ceremony of said Thangaraj, the
first defendant showed a xerox copy of a Will dated 07.02.2011 said to have
been executed by the deceased Thangaraj and proclaimed that his father has
bequeathed all the properties to him. According to the plaintiffs, the said
3/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
Will is a fabricated and concocted one and brought out by the first defendant
incorporating the recitals to suit his own convenience in connivance with his
allies.
There was no reason for the deceased Thangaraj to disinherit his
wife, who is a heart patient, his elder son, who is a blood cancer patient and
his daughter and recitals in the alleged Will by themselves throw a lot of
doubt about its genuineness and veracity of the same. The recitals in the
alleged Will shows as if provisions made in the Will for Plaintiffs 1 and 3,
but they are in an unrealistic and unworkable manner. The alleged Will was
an unregistered document and does not even contain a clause for revocation,
which is the basic characteristic of a Will.
The description of properties in
the Will particularly the Item No.2 of the property is incorrect and even
during his life time, the deceased Thangaraj had executed a gift deed in
favour of Panchayat transferring 89 square meters of land, but the alleged
Will mentions the total extent of 8.33 acres as an item of bequest. That itself
shows that the Will is a created one. Disputing the alleged Will, the plaintiffs
have filed a suit claiming a share in the suit properties.
4.The suit was resisted by the first defendant by filing a written
statement containing the allegations which are in brief, as follows:
(i) The allegation that the testator Thangaraj died intestate on
4/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
26.08.2011 is incorrect. It is the case of the first defendant that the testator
had executed a Will dated 07.02.2011 in favour of first defendant
bequeathing the plaint mentioned Items 1 and 2 of properties. The first
defendant denies the allegation that he did not take care of his late father and
states that he only accompanied his late father on the previous day of his
death to attend the Court of Judicial Magistrate VII, Coimbatore. The first
defendant also denied the allegation that the first defendant had stolen
ammonium nitrate bags and appropriated the sale proceeds to himself.
According to the first defendant, the third plaintiff was given in marriage in
the year 1992 and at the time of marriage 120 sovereigns of jewels were
given and his father spent about Rs.4 lakhs for the marriage. It is his further
case that the third plaintiff’s husband property situate in Thomas Street,
Coimbatore and at the time of marriage, there was only ground floor and his
father had renovated the ground floor with modern amenities and had also
given Rs.5 lakhs for constructing the first floor measuring about 1500 sq.feet
and due to the said improvement, the third plaintiff and her husband were
able to earn about Rs.30,000/- as rent per month. It is the case of the
defendants that first defendant’s father also gave jewels to third plaintiff on
several occasions and also gifted a bike to her husband and it was also
5/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
directed in the Will to purchase a house property in the name of the third
plaintiff.
(ii) It is the further contention of the first defendant that his father
spent Rs.5 lakhs towards marriage expenses of the second plaintiff and also
applied for a loan to the tune of one crore in Indian Overseas bank to
promote a private limited company in the name of “T.R.S.Nitrium Private
Limited” and also spent several lakhs for obtaining PAN Number, electricity
connection and for converting the property into an industrial land
by
reposing good faith and belief in the second plaintiff but the second plaintiff
did not cooperate with the father and started a separate business for
manufacturing Ammonium Nitrate in the name of Jagan Enterprises at
Kuniamuthur, Coimbatore and thereby caused loss to his father. It is the
further contention of the first defendant that in the year 1997, the first
defendant joined Coimbatore Aviation Training Academy to get commercial
pilot licence but he was asked by his father to come out of the Aviation
Training and assist him in carrying on the business in the 1 st item of
property. It is the case of the first defendant that from the said date he was
helping his father in all aspects. According to the first defendant, the second
plaintiff and said Thangaraj were never been in cordial terms till the latter
6/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
died and the second plaintiff was responsible for not starting the business in
the name of T.R.S.Nitrium Private Limited and said Thangaraj was forced to
drop the idea of starting new business due to the adamant attitude of the
second plaintiff and the second plaintiff also resigned from the father’s
company on 02.05.2001.
(iii) The first defendant further states that though his father was
against his marriage, after a month, they started to reside with his father and
the second defendant became a Hindu by conversion. It is averred that late
Thangaraj was suffering from various health problems and only these
defendants and their children were taking care of him and even the first
plaintiff, who is the wife of late Thangaraj did not visit him while he was in
the hospital and plaintiffs 2 and 3 also neglected their father. According to
the first defendant, in view of the help and support rendered by the
defendants, his father viz., late Thangaraj executed his last Will dated
07.02.2011 bequeathing the plaint mentioned Items 1 and 2 of the properties
in favour of first defendant and after the death of his father, he had shown
the Will executed by his late father on his own accord to the plaintiffs and
plaintiffs made attempts to destroy the same but he was able to save the Will
from the hands of the plaintiffs. It is the further case of the defendants that
7/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
th
on the 16 day of his father’s ceremony the plaintiffs took away the original
sale deeds pertaining to item No.1 of suit property and the sale deed standing
in the name of their grandmother Ranguthayammal, LIC Bonds and also the
Maruthi Alto Car and gave a false complaint against the first defendant on
14.09.2011.
Since the plaintiffs made attempts to disturb the peaceful
possession and enjoyment of the suit properties, the first defendant filed a
suit for permanent injunction in O.S.No.1595 of 2011 to protect his
possession and the same is pending. It is also alleged that there are criminal
cases pending between the parties. Therefore, it is the contention of the first
defendant that the Will is genuine and it was executed by his father on his
own accord.
5. In the reply filed by the plaintiffs, the plaintiffs denied the
allegations made in the written statement.
6. Based on the above pleadings, the following issues were framed by
the trial Court:
i) Whether the Will dated 07.02.2011 is genuine?
ii) Whether the suit is properly valued?
iii) To what relief?
8/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
7. Before the trial Court, on the side of the plaintiffs PWs 1 to 3 were
examined and Exs.A1 to A37 were marked and on the side of the defendants,
DWs 1 to 3 were examined and Exs.B1 to B52 and Exs.X1 to X10 were
marked as witness documents.
8. The trial Court, based on the above pleadings and documents,
disbelieved the Will propounded by the first defendant and granted a
preliminary decree for partition allotting 1/4th share each to the plaintiffs
and the first defendant in the entire suit properties. Aggrieved over the
same, the present appeal came to be filed by the first defendant.
9. The learned counsel appearing for the appellants/defendants would
mainly contend that the evidence of DWs 2 and 3 were not properly
considered by the trial Court. Learned counsel submits that DW2 is one of
the attesting witnesses of the Will and he has clearly spoken not only about
the execution, but also the attestation of the Will and DW3, the scribe, who
typed the Will, is none other than the lawyer of the testator and their
evidence clearly prove the execution as well as the attestation as required
under law. It is the contention of the learned counsel for appellants that
there is no suspicious circumstances whatsoever to disbelieve the Will.
Merely because the Will has not been registered, that cannot be a ground to
9/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
reject the Will. In the Will itself provisions were made in favour of Plaintiffs
1 and 3. The recitals in the Will clearly show that the first defendant has to
purchase a house to the third plaintiff and also make a deposit in favour of
first plaintiff. Therefore, when sufficient safeguards were made, in respect
of other legal heirs, merely because Plaintiff No.2 has been disinherited, the
Will cannot be disbelieved. If the evidence of DW2 and DW3 is read in its
entirety, the same would show that the Will is a genuine document. Further,
the attesting witnesses were also very close to the family of the testator.
Their evidence do not show any artificiality and proves the Will as required
under law. According to the learned counsel, as there is no suspicious
circumstances brought on record, the Will has to be accepted, but the trial
Court has disbelieved the Will on erroneous grounds. In support of his
contention, learned counsel relied on the judgment of a Division Bench of
this Court in Dr.Shantha Vs. Sharada reported in 2003 (4) CTC 470.
10. Per contra, the learned Senior counsel appearing for the
respondent would submit that the Will propounded by the first defendant is
nothing but a fabricated document and suspicious circumstances are inherent
in the document itself. The manner in which the Will was projected itself
shows that the propounder has not dispelled the suspicious circumstances
10/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
which are inherent in the document itself. Attesting witnesses are none other
than the close associates of Defendant No.1. DW2’s evidence itself clearly
shows that that testator was intended to write a Will in favour of his wife,
daughter and younger son. However, after the draft has been prepared, it is
seen that deceased Thangaraj’s daughter, wife and his elder son were totally
excluded.
11. According to learned Senior counsel, the evidence DW2 is highly
artificial and so called draft Will written by DW3 has not seen the light of
the day. Further writing the Will in unknown place is also highly doubtful.
It is his further contention that if really the testator has bequeathed the entire
properties by giving the description, he would have clearly mentioned about
the Gift Settlement Deed dated 02.11.2010 executed in respect of some
portion of Item No.2 under Ex.P30, whereas the Will has been written as if
there was no transfer effected by the testator. It is further submitted by
learned Senior counsel that one of the attesting witnesses already stood as a
surety while executing anticipatory bail granted to first defendant as
evidenced by Ex.A26 and similarly the other attesting witness along with
first defendant had filed a suit in which DW3 was a lawyer for them. These
facts will clearly lead to the inference that attesting witnesses are none other
11/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
than the persons highly connected to DW3. If really the Will had been hand
written as spoken to by DW2, the copy of the draft Will should have been
produced but the same has not been produced. It is his further contention
that the first plaintiff, namely the wife of the testator, was suffering from
serious heart ailment as per Ex.A28 even two years prior to the alleged Will.
Therefore, the husband disinheriting his own wife and not making any
provision for her medical treatment itself creates a serious doubt about the
Will.
12. It is further contended by the learned Senior counsel that
admittedly the second plaintiff was also suffering from blood cancer, which
is evident from the documents marked. Therefore, without making any
provision for his medical treatment, the testator bequeathing the entire
property in favour of one of the sons and ignoring his wife and another son,
who is suffering from blood cancer, creates serious doubt about the Will
(Ex.B1). The learned Senior counsel further submitted that there is no
whisper about the Will dated 07.02.2011 in the caveats filed by DW3 under
Exs.A9 to A17 on behalf of first defendant, though the caveats were filed on
10.12.2012. Therefore, it is his contention that only on the later date, the
unregistered Will would have been created to suit the convenience of the
12/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
first defendant. Therefore, the attesting witnesses being the close associates
of first defendant and also client of DW3, the possibility of creating the will
cannot be ruled out. Further, disinheriting his own wife, who was suffering
from Heart ailment and son, who was suffering from blood cancer and
without making any provision for their medical expenses also creates
suspicion about the Will. The learned Senior counsel further submitted that
there are some clauses in the Will to make it appear as if some provisions
have been made, which is also one of the suspicious circumstances inherent
in the document itself. In support of his contentions, the learned Senior
counsel relied on the following judmgents:
i) D.Kausalya Vs. S.Sankaran reported in 2002 (1) CTC 650;
ii) Shivakumar and Others Vs. Sharanabasappa and Others reported
in (2021) 11 SCC 277;
iii) Balathandayutham and another Vs. Ezhilarasan reported in
(2010) 5 SCC 770;
iv) N.Govindarajan Vs. N.Leelavathy reported in 2011 (5) CTC 287;
13. In the light of the above submissions, now the points that arise for
consideration in this appeal are as follows:
i) Whether the unregistered Will dated 07.02.2011 is true
13/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
and valid, if so, whether the propounder dispelled the suspicious
circumstances attached to the Will?
ii) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to partition as prayed
for?
Points 1 and 2:
14. The relationship of the parties are not in dispute. The subject
property was owned by one Thangaraj, the father of plaintiffs 2 and 3 and
first defendant and husband of first plaintiff. The said Thangaraj died on
26.08.2011, after the alleged Will dated 07.02.2011. Though it is pleaded by
the propounder that there was a strained relationship between the plaintiffs
and the testator, however the same has not been substantiated in any manner
by adducing evidence. It is an admitted fact that the second plaintiff was
also residing with the testator initially.
DW1 has also admitted in his
evidence that all of them were residing in the same house and the second
plaintiff was also helping his father in his business, but DW2 has pleaded
feign ignorance about the health condition of the second plaintiff and
admitted that though the second plaintiff started individual business, the
same has been closed in the year 2011 itself. Further, he has admitted in his
evidence that there was no evidence to show that the amount has been spent
14/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
for construction of a house for Plaintiff No.3. His evidence also indicate that
DW3-L.A.Rajkumar, who is a lawyer, had already filed a suit in O.S.No.444
of 2009 on behalf of the first defendant and one Prabhuram, one of the
attesting witnesses. The plaint copy in the said suit has also been filed as
Ex.A3. The said suit has been filed as against the Government officials in
respect of vegetable market in the year 2009 itself. The above document
viz., Ex.A3 makes it very clear that the first defendant and one of the
attesting witnesses Prabhuram are the clients of DW3 from the year 2009.
DW3 has actively participated in preparing Ex.B1-Will.
15. According to DW1, the Will has been prepared in the office of the
Advocate. Though he has not accompanied his father on the said date, the
execution of the Will has been informed later by his father. According to
him, the Will has also been handed over by the lawyer later. If Ex.A7 is
carefully seen, one of the attesting witness Prabhuram has already signed in
a letter submitted to the police station. The evidence of one of the attesting
witnesses clearly shows that attesting witness and first defendant are known
to each other from the year 2009. Though the first defendant has already
filed a suit in O.S.No.1595 of 2011 as per Ex.A8, prior to that caveats have
been entered by the some lawyer under Exs.A9 to A17. Caveats have been
15/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
entered on 10.12.2012. However, there is no mention whatsoever with
regard to the existence of the Will at the relevant point of time. The initial
burden lies on the propounder of the Will to prove not only the execution
and attestation of the Will, but also to dispel the suspicious circumstances
attached to the Will.
Though the first defendant examined one of the
attesting witnesses as DW2 to prove the Will, on a careful perusal of
evidence of DW2, it is seen that the Will was written in the ground floor of
the building known as “India Towers” and the contents have been dictated
by the testator and the same have been written by DW3 in his own hand
writing and thereafter, DW3 went to fourth floor of his office and typed
Ex.B1-Will and later the Will has been signed by the testator in the presence
of the attesting witnesses and attesting witnesses have also signed in the
document. Though the chief examination of DW3 satisfies the parameters
of law for proof of a Will, on careful perusal of the entire evidence,
particularly the cross-examination clearly indicates that his evidence is
highly artificial. Though DW2 is 30 years younger than the testator,
according to DW2 he is known to the testator since his father was in close
association with the testator. According to DW2, they know the entire
family members. It is relevant to note that if really DW2 has known the
16/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
entire family members, there is feign ignorance about the blood cancer
suffered by plaintiff No.2. These facts create doubt about his closeness to
the family members of the testator. His admission in the cross-examination
clearly shows that Thangaraj has given instruction to his lawyer to write a
Will in favour of his wife, Palaniammal, daughter Rajeswari and also his
younger son. The relevant portion of his deposition is as follows:
“…..j';fuh$;
kw;Wk;’
jhd ;
,isa
capy ;
mtuJ
kidtp.
kfs ; Mfpnahh ; bgau;fSf;F
vGjntz;Lk ;
vd;W
kfs;.
kl;Lk;
brhd;dhuh
vd;why;.
j';fuh$;
brhy;y
mth;’mt;thWjhd;’brhd;dhh;/
brhy;y uh$;Fkhh; capiy vGjpdhh;///”
16. The above admission makes it clear that the testator was intended
to write a Will to three persons viz., his wife, only daughter and younger son
whereas it is seen from Ex.B1 that the entire property has been bequeathed
only in favour of younger son. Recitals in Ex.B1 will show that the second
plaintiff was doing business individually and since the first defendant was
looking after the testator and his wife, the testator had intention to bequeath
entire property to the first defendant. The recitals further indicate that after
clearing the loan availed by the testator, the first defendant has to create
17/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
some deposit in favour of first plaintiff, the wife of the testator. The recitals
also indicate that the first defendant according to his capacity has to
purchase one house to the third plaintiff. It is relevant to note that absolutely
there is no recital in the Will with regard to the medical ailments suffered by
the wife of the testator. Exs.A28 and A29 filed on behalf of the plaintiffs
clearly show that the wife of the testator was suffering from heart ailments
and she requires replacement of aortic valve. The medical advice has been
given in the year 2009 itself. Ex.A29 shows that the second plaintiff was
suffering from leukemia in chronic phase even in the year 2007. Absolutely
there is no mention whatsoever about serious ailments of his elder son and
also his wife. When admittedly strained relationship was not established
between the husband and wife, it is the duty of prudent husband to make a
provision for medical expenses of his wife who has been suffering from
heart ailment. Though the second plaintiff, the elder son of the testator said
to have started a new business, which is competitive to his father, the
evidence of DW1 itself clearly indicate that the new business started by
elder son was closed down and he was also suffering from blood cancer. As
long as there was no strained relationship between elder son and his father,
the normal conduct of a father was to make at least some provision for
18/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
medical treatment of his son. Therefore, ignoring these facts and
bequeathing the entire valuable properties to only one son, who is also
initially married other religion person, creates serious doubt about the
genuineness of the Will. Disinheriting the wife and elder son who were
struggling for their life creates a serious doubt about genuineness of the Will.
17. Be that as it may, though recitals in the Will indicate as if the
propounder viz., the legatee was taking care of the mother, when the
evidence of DW1 in this regard is carefully perused, he does not even know
whether his mother was admitted for heart ailment or suffering from any
heart ailment and in fact he has admitted in his cross examination that he do
not know the health condition of his mother after his father's death. These
facts clearly create some serious doubt about the recitals in the Will that the
first defendant was taking care of his mother in all aspects.
18. Now coming to the evidence of DW2 and DW3, it is the specific
case of the DW2 that the recitals were dictated by the testator and draft has
been prepared by DW3. DW2 and DW3 have spoken in unison that the draft
has been prepared in the first floor of the building whereas the office of the
third defendant situate in fourth floor.
According to DW2 and DW3,
initially the draft Will has been hand written by DW3, later he went to the
19/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
fourth floor office, typed the Will and executed the same. Admittedly the
third defendant is having office at fourth floor and when such being the case,
drafting the Will in the ground floor is also highly doubtful. DW2 and DW3
never stated in their evidence that in whose presence the draft Will has been
prepared. It is to be noted that vide Ex.A30, the testator has gifted an extent
of 89 square meter of land in II item of suit property to Local Body by virtue
of the Gift Settlement Deed dated 02.11.2010. Therefore, the testator having
gifted said extent, certainly he would have given the details while drafting
the Will whereas alleged Will proceeds as if there was no encumbrance or
transfer of the property and the entire property including the property, which
was already gifted by the testator, has been bequeathed. This aspect is also
creates doubt about genuineness of the Will.
19. It is further to be noted that DW2 also admitted that second
plaintiff was also helping his father and though DW2 claims that he is very
close to the family of the testator, his evidence clearly indicate that he does
not even know that second plaintiff was suffering from cancer and further
his evidence also indicate that the first plaintiff Planaiammal was residing
with her husband Thangaraj till his death. If really DW2 was close to
Thangaraj and aware of the family members, he should have at least known
20/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
the serious illness of second plaintiff. His evidence to the effect that he is a
close friend of the testator creates a serious doubt whereas he was very close
only to DWs 1 and 3. DW2’s evidence further indicates that only DW2
stood as a surety while executing the bond for anticipatory bail obtained by
the first defendant and DWs 1 and 2 are having close conduct and they used
to go for horse riding together. It is relevant to note that DW3, the so called
scribe said to have prepared Ex.B1-Will. According to him, the Will has
been prepared in the Administrative Office of the India Tower.
After
preparing the draft Will, he went to his Office in the fourth floor and
thereafter, he typed the Will. His evidence also clearly indicate that he has
already appeared for first defendant and another attesting witness one
Prabhuram and also filed a suit on their behalf earlier.
20. Further the evidence of DW3 also shows that he appeared for said
Prabhuram in O.S.No.154 of 2011 filed by his mother. The Vakalat filed in
the said suit has been marked as Ex.A18. However, he pleaded feign
ignorance about who has brought the two attesting witnesses at the relevant
point of time. The fact remains that DW2, one of the attesting witness is
close associate of DW1 and he used to go for horse riding with DW1 and
also stood as a surety for executing anticipatory bail obtained by DW1
21/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
whereas another attesting witness is also client of DW3. These facts clearly
indicate that attesting witnesses were brought only by DW3. If really DW2
was in close contact with the family of the testator, he should have at least
known about the serious decease suffered by one of the family members of
the testator, namely the second plaintiff. Further, as discussed above, DW1
also pleaded feign ignorance about his mother's heart ailment. Therefore, the
very recitals in the Will that DW1 was taking care of his mother also creates
serious doubt. Further, the father having executed the gift deed in respect of
certain extent of the land in second item, once again including the entire
property is also creates serious doubt.
Further when the caveats were
entered on behalf of the first defendant by DW3, on 10.12.2012, there was
no whisper whatsoever with regard to the existence of the Will and the
existence of the Will has been informed only later on the 16 th day ceremony
of their father whereas while filing the caveat there is no mention about the
existence of the Will. These facts also creates serious doubt about the
execution of the Will. Even assuming that the testator had an intention to
execute a Will, the evidence of DW2 indicates that he had intention to
bequeath the properties to three persons whereas Ex.B1-Will was prepared
as if the entire property has been bequeathed only to one person.
22/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
21. It is to be noted that testator's wife was suffering from heart
ailment from the year 2009 and she was also advised to undergo aortic valve
replacement surgery. Normal human conduct of any husband would be to
make provisions for his wife’s treatment whereas the recitals in the Will
states that only after clearing the loan availed by the testator, the first
defendant has to make some deposit, which appears to be artificial. Further,
what is the nature of the loan availed by the testator is also silent in the Will.
Ex.A26 also clearly shows that DW2, one of the attesting witnesses stood as
surety in the criminal Court for Defendant No.1. All these facts clearly show
that attesting witnesses were close to DW1 and DW3, who is a lawyer and
already appeared for one of the attesting witnesses and Defendant No.1. The
evidence of DW1 shows as if he was incharge of entire business of his
father, namely the testator and he was taking care of him till his death. His
evidence also clearly indicates that he was in active confidence and
dominant position. Therefore, the entire burden lies on him to prove that
there was good faith in transaction. Therefore, when a person who was very
close to Defendant No.1 and also appeared for first defendant in a suit,
written the Will separately in an unconnected building, later typed the said
Will in the fourth floor, namely lawyer's office also creates serious doubt
23/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
about the execution of the Will by the testator. Further, excluding the name
of his wife and his elder son, who were struggling for their life and
bequeathing the entire properties to the younger son also creates serious
doubt. When the attesting witness was very close to the first defendant and
the lawyer, who appeared for the first defendant in another suit and also for
one of the attesting witnesses and the Will was initially hand written in an
unconnected building and later typed in the fourth floor, namely in the
lawyer's office would also create serious doubt about the execution of the
Will by the testator. Though disinheriting one of the legal heirs itself is not a
suspicious circumstance, but disinheriting the wife, who was suffering from
heart ailment and not making any provision in the Will for her medical
treatment itself creates serious doubt about the Will. Further, the recitals in
the Will shows that there is a direction to the first defendant to purchase a
house according to his capacity for the third plaintiff and after clearing the
loan to make some deposit in the name of the first plaintiff exhibits attached
artificiality. Therefore, the possibility of creating the Will later with the
connivance of the attesting witnesses and DW3, the lawyer who appeared
for the first defendant in the earlier suit cannot be ruled out and further
bequeathing the entire property even without reserving the right of
24/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
revocation also creates serious doubt about the Will. If the testator had an
intention not to revoke the Will, DW3 being a lawyer would have advised
for outright transfer by way of settlement instead of writing the Will without
the revocation clause also shows attached artificiality. When the above
suspicious circumstances are inherent in the entire transaction, we are not
inclined to believe the Will particularly due to exclusion of aged wife who
was also ailing. That apart, when there is no strained relationship between
the testator and the other son, who is also suffering from cancer, excluding
him from any of the properties also creates serious doubt about the Will.
Therefore, merely because the execution and attestation stated to have been
proved through the evidence of Dws 2 and 3, as the propounder has not
discharged his burden dispelling the above suspicious circumstances pointed
out by us we are not in a position to accept that Ex.B1-Will is a genuine
document validly executed by the testator. We are also of the view that the
facts of the case in Dr.Shantha Vs. Sharada (cited supra) referred to by the
learned counsel for appellants does not come to his aid.
22. As far as the Will is concerned, Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Shivakumar and Others Vs. Sharanabasappa and Others (cited
25/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
supra) has summarized the principles governing the adjudicatory process
concerning proof of a Will and the same reads as follows:
"12. For what has been noticed hereinabove, the relevant
principles governing the adjudicatory process concerning proof of a
Will could be broadly summarised as follows:–
12.1. Ordinarily, a Will has to be proved like any other
document; the test to be applied being the usual test of the
satisfaction of the prudent mind. Alike the principles governing the
proof of other documents, in the case of Will too, the proof with
mathematical accuracy is not to be insisted upon.
12.2. Since as per Section 63 of the Succession Act, a Will is
required to be attested, it cannot be used as evidence until at least
one attesting witness has been called for the purpose of proving its
execution, if there be an attesting witness alive and capable of
giving evidence.
12.3. The unique feature of a Will is that it speaks from the
death of the testator and, therefore, the maker thereof is not
available for deposing about the circumstances in which the same
was executed.
This introduces an element of solemnity in the
decision of the question as to whether the document propounded is
the last Will of the testator. The initial onus, naturally, lies on the
propounder but the same can be taken to have been primarily
discharged on proof of the essential facts which go into the making
of a Will.
12.4. The case in which the execution of the Will is
surrounded by suspicious circumstances stands on a different
footing. The presence of suspicious circumstances makes the onus
26/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
heavier on the propounder and, therefore, in cases where the
circumstances attendant upon the execution of the document give
rise to suspicion, the propounder must remove all legitimate
suspicions before the document can be accepted as the last Will of
the testator.
12.5. If a person challenging the Will alleges fabrication or
alleges fraud, undue influence, coercion et cetera in regard to the
execution of the Will, such pleas have to be proved by him, but even
in the absence of such pleas, the very circumstances surrounding the
execution of the Will may give rise to the doubt or as to whether the
Will had indeed been executed by the testator and/or as to whether
the testator was acting of his own free will. In such eventuality, it is
again a part of the initial onus of the propounder to remove all
reasonable doubts in the matter.
12.6. A circumstance is “suspicious” when it is not normal or
is ‘not normally expected in a normal situation or is not expected of
a 43 normal person’'. As put by this Court, the suspicious features
must be ‘real, germane and valid’ and not merely the ‘fantasy of the
doubting mind.’
12.7. As to whether any particular feature or a set of features
qualify as “suspicious” would depend on the facts and
circumstances of each case. A shaky or doubtful signature; a feeble
or uncertain mind of the testator; an unfair disposition of property;
an unjust exclusion of the legal heirs and particularly the
dependants; an active or leading part in making of the Will by the
beneficiary thereunder et cetera are some of the circumstances
which may give rise to suspicion. The circumstances above-noted
27/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
are only illustrative and by no means exhaustive because there
could be any circumstance or set of circumstances which may give
rise to legitimate suspicion about the execution of the Will. On the
other hand, any of the circumstance qualifying as being suspicious
could be legitimately explained by the propounder. However, such
suspicion or suspicions cannot be removed by mere proof of sound
and disposing state of mind of the testator and his signature coupled
with the proof of attestation.
12.8. The test of satisfaction of the judicial conscience comes
into operation when a document propounded as the Will of the
testator is surrounded by suspicious circumstance(s). While
applying such test, the court would address itself to the solemn
questions as to whether the testator had signed the Will while being
aware of its contents and after understanding the nature and effect
of the dispositions in the Will?
12.9. In the ultimate analysis, where the execution of a Will is
shrouded in suspicion, it is a matter essentially of the judicial
conscience of the Court and the party which sets up the Will has to
offer cogent and convincing explanation of the suspicious
circumstances surrounding the Will."
23. A Division Bench of this Court in D.Kausalya Vs. S.Sankaran
(cited supra) has held that when the Executor of will did not state anything
to show that there was strained relationship between testator and eldest
daughter and giving preference to one heir and excluding another branch
will constitute suspicious circumstance and such suspicion should be
28/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
dislodged by the propounder.
24. In the considered opinion of this Court, the evidence adduced by
DWs 1 to 3 do not inspire the confidence of this Court to accept the validity
of the Will.
25. In view of the above discussion, we do not find any infirmity in
the judgment of the trial Court granting partition by disbelieving Ex.B1 Will.
Hence, this appeal suit is dismissed and the judgment and decree of the trial
Court dated 02.08.2018 made in O.S.No.718 of 2011 shall stand confirmed.
However, considering the relationship of the parties, there shall be no order
as to costs.
[N.S.K.,J.]
[R.S.V.,J.]
19.01.2026
Index: Yes/No
gpa
To
I Additional District Judge
Coimbatore
29/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
A.S.No.747 of 2018
N.SATHISH KUMAR, J.,
AND
R. SAKTHIVEL, J.,
gpa
A.S.No.747 of 2018
19.01.2026
30/30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review