The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. 07.2009, the petitioner No. 2 has retired from service w.e.f. 28.02.2010 and the petitioner No. 3 has retired from service w.e.f. 28.02.2009. [2] In column No. 9 of the Recruitment Rules for the post of Inspector CS, Grade-II providing the period of probation, a note is appended thereto which stipulates that drawal of 2nd and subsequent increments is subject to passing of the prescribed Departmental Examination. The petitioner No. 1 passed the Departmental Examination in the year 2007, the petitioner No. 2 passed the Departmental Examination in the year 2007 and the petitioner No. 3 passed the Departmental Examination in the year 1992. However, before passing their Departmental Examination, the petitioners were allowed to draw the 2nd and subsequent increments in their pay w.e.f. 01.02.1984,
01. 04.1981 and 01.04.1984 respectively and they have been enjoying such increments in their pay scale for the last many years. [3] The Secretariat Finance Department (PIC), Government of Manipur, issued an office memorandum dated 03.11.2006 giving certain instructions for verifying the service records of the employees for consideration of grant of financial upgradation under the ACP’s scheme. In para No. 2 of the said office memorandum, it is inter-alia, provided as under:- “Para No. 2…………..**** (iv) To see if the 2nd and subsequent increments have been granted without passing the Departmental Examination as against the requirement of the respective Recruitment Rules. (v) If so, pay is to be regulated from time to time without taking into account the increment(s) so allowed prior to W.P. (C) No. 528 of 2008 Page 2 passing of the Departmental Examination and excess drawal to be recovered. (vi) To verify when the employee passed the said Departmental Examination and when the 2nd and subsequent increment(s) have been allowed without arrear and if the area has been allowed the same is to be recovered." Subsequently, the Registrar of Cooperative Societies, Manipur, issued a notification dated 28.01.2008 notifying grant of financial upgradation to 108 Inspector Cooperative Societies, including the petitioners, under the Assured Career Progression Scheme. Under the said notification it w…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
KABOR Digitally
signed by
AMBAM KABORAMBA
M SAPANA
SAPAN CHANU
Date:
A
2024.01.12
14:08:21
CHANU -08'00'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP (C) No. 528 of 2008
1. Shri Takhellambam Ibochouba Singh, aged about 58 years,
S/o T. Kanglen, Naharup Makhapat, B.P.O. Khetri Bengun,
P.O. & P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
2. Shri Moiranghem Bhubonchandra Singh, aged about 57
years, S/o (L) M. Mani Singh of Khagempalli Pankha, P.O. &
P.S. Singjamei, at present working as Inspector Co-operative
Societies, Manipur.
3. Shri Ringmi Raising, aged about 58 years, S/o (L) Y. Raising
of Paoyai Village, P.O. Paoyai, P.S. Chingngai, Ukhrul
District, Manipur.
Petitioners
Vs.
1. The
State
of
Manipur,
represented
by
the
Commissioner/Secretary (Co-operation), Government of
Manipur.
2. The Commissioner/Secretary (Finance), Government of
Manipur.
3. The Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Government of
Manipur.
Respondents
BEFORE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
For the Petitioners
: Mr. Juno Rahman, Advocate
For the Respondents
: Mr. A. Vashum, Government Advocate
Date of hearing
: 06.12.2023
Date of Judgment & Order : 11.01.2024
JUDGMENT & ORDER
[1]
The present writ petition had been filed with a prayer for quashing
and setting aside the impugned office memorandum dated 03.11.2006 and
impugned order dated 28.01.2008 ordering for recovery of excess payment made
to the petitioners.
W.P. (C) No. 528 of 2008
Page 1
The case of the petitioners is that they were all appointed as
Inspector Co-operative Societies, Grade-II in the Office of the Registrar of
Cooperative Societies, Manipur by orders dated 03.02.1982, 03.04.1973 and
21.04.1983 respectively. The petitioner No. 1 has retired from service w.e.f.
27.07.2009, the petitioner No. 2 has retired from service w.e.f. 28.02.2010 and the
petitioner No. 3 has retired from service w.e.f. 28.02.2009.
[2]
In column No. 9 of the Recruitment Rules for the post of Inspector
CS, Grade-II providing the period of probation, a note is appended thereto which
stipulates that drawal of 2nd and subsequent increments is subject to passing of the
prescribed Departmental Examination.
The petitioner No. 1 passed the Departmental Examination in the year
2007, the petitioner No. 2 passed the Departmental Examination in the year 2007
and the petitioner No. 3 passed the Departmental Examination in the year 1992.
However, before passing their Departmental Examination, the petitioners were
allowed to draw the 2nd and subsequent increments in their pay w.e.f. 01.02.1984,
01.04.1981 and 01.04.1984 respectively and they have been enjoying such
increments in their pay scale for the last many years.
[3]
The Secretariat Finance Department (PIC), Government of Manipur,
issued an office memorandum dated 03.11.2006 giving certain instructions for
verifying the service records of the employees for consideration of grant of financial
upgradation under the ACP’s scheme. In para No. 2 of the said office memorandum,
it is inter-alia, provided as under:-
“Para No. 2…………..****
(iv) To see if the 2nd and subsequent increments have been
granted without passing the Departmental Examination
as against the requirement of the
respective
Recruitment Rules.
(v) If so, pay is to be regulated from time to time without
taking into account the increment(s) so allowed prior to
W.P. (C) No. 528 of 2008
Page 2
passing of the Departmental Examination and excess
drawal to be recovered.
(vi) To verify when the employee passed the said
Departmental Examination and when the 2nd and
subsequent increment(s) have been allowed without
arrear and if the area has been allowed the same is to
be recovered."
Subsequently, the Registrar of Cooperative Societies, Manipur, issued
a notification dated 28.01.2008 notifying grant of financial upgradation to 108
Inspector Cooperative Societies, including the petitioners, under the Assured Career
Progression Scheme. Under the said notification it was also notified that incumbent
shown at Annexure-B, appended to the said notification, have enjoyed the 2nd and
subsequent increments before passing of the Departmental Examination and that
the concerned DDOs should recover the increments in one time or monthly
instalment from their salary and deposit the same in their respective salary head
of Treasury Challan and to submit a monthly recovery report. In the said list of
officers at Annexure-B, the names of the petitioners are at serial No. 1, 21 and 59.
[4]
It has been submitted on behalf of the petitioners that rightly or
wrongly the 2nd and subsequent increments in their pay had been made by the
concerned authorities of the Government without any misrepresentation from the
petitioners and without any fault on their part and that the petitioners have been
enjoying such increments since 1984, 1981 and 1985. The impugned
memorandum/notification for recovery was issued only in the year 2008 after a
lapse of more than 2 (two) decades. It has also been submitted that as all the
petitioners have already retired from service in the year 2009 and 2010 and as it
has been more than 13 (thirteen) years post-retirement, any recovery at such stage
will cause grave hardship to the petitioners and such action of the authorities are
iniquitous and arbitrary and such action deserves to be interfered with by this Court.
W.P. (C) No. 528 of 2008
Page 3
[5]
Mr. A. Vashum, learned Government Advocate appearing for the
respondents submitted that all the petitioners have availed the 2nd and subsequent
increments by misrepresenting expressly (as reflected in the service book showing
their endorsement of signatures in relevant pages of the service books) that they
have cleared the requisite Departmental Exam, though they never cleared the said
Departmental Examination before availing the 2nd and subsequent increments.
However, after examination of the original service books of the
petitioners, the learned Government Advocate fairly submitted that there is no
evidence on record to support such statements made by the respondents.
[6]
The learned Government Advocate further submitted that the
petitioners have enjoyed the 2nd and subsequent increments before passing the
Departmental Examination in violation of the conditions stipulated under the
Recruitment Rules and as such, the drawal of 2nd and subsequent increments are
illegal and accordingly, any action for recovery of such excess drawal from the
petitioners cannot be termed as illegal.
In support of his contentions, the learned Government Advocate cited
the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of “Chandi Prasad
Uniyal and Others vs. State of Uttarakhand and Others” reported in (2012)
8 SCC 417, wherein it has been held under:“8. We are of the considered view, after going through the
various judgments cited at the Bar, that this Court has not laid
down any principle of law that only if there is
misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the recipients of the
money in getting the excess pay, the amount paid due to
irregular/wrong fixation of pay be recovered.
“14. We are concerned with the excess payment of public
money which is often described as “taxpayers’ money” which
belongs neither to the officers who have effected
overpayment nor to the recipients. We fail to see why the
concept of fraud or misrepresentation is being brought in in
such situations. The question to be asked is whether excess
money has been paid or not, may be due to a bona fide
W.P. (C) No. 528 of 2008
Page 4
mistake. Possibly, effecting excess payment of public money
by the government officers may be due to various reasons like
negligence, carelessness, collusion, favouritism, etc. because
money in such situation does not belong to the payer or the
payee. Situations may also arise where both the payer and
the payee are at fault, then the mistake is mutual. Payments
are being effected in many situations without any authority of
law and payments have been received by the recipients also
without any authority of law. Any amount paid/received
without the authority of law can always be recovered barring
few exceptions of extreme hardships but not as a matter of
right, in such situations law implies an obligation on the payee
to repay the money, otherwise it would amount to unjust
enrichment.”
[7]
I have heard the submissions advance by the learned counsel
appearing for the parties at length and also carefully examined all the materials
available on record.
In the present case, the admitted position is that before passing the
requisite Departmental Examination, the petitioners were granted the 2nd and
subsequent
increments
in
their
pay
by
the
authorities
without
any
misrepresentation or fault on the part of the petitioners. There is also no evidence
on record to support the statements made by the respondents in their additional
affidavits that the petitioners availed the 2nd and subsequent increments by
misrepresenting expressly that they have cleared the requisite Departmental
Examination. In fact, after careful examination of the original service books of the
petitioners, the learned Government Advocate fairly submitted that he did not find
any evidence to support such statements made by the respondents. In such a
situation, the only issue to be decided is whether it is permissible in law to let the
respondents recover any excess payment made to the petitioners after a delay of
more than 2 (two) decades.
In my considered view, such issue has been decided by the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of “State of Punjab and Others vs. Rafiq Masih (White
W.P. (C) No. 528 of 2008
Page 5
Washer and others) reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334”. The relevant paragraphs
of the judgment are as under:-
“13. First and foremost, it is pertinent to note, that this Court in
its judgment in Syed Abdul Qadir case recognized, that the issue
of recovery revolved on the action being iniquitous. Dealing with
the subject of the action being iniquitous, it was sought to be
concluded, that when the excess unauthorized payment is
detected within a short period of time, it would be open for the
employer to recover the same. Conversely, if the payment had
been made for a long duration of time, it would be iniquitous to
make any recovery. Interference because an action is iniquitous,
must really be perceived as, interference because the action is
arbitrary. All arbitrary actions are truly, actions in violation of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The logic of the action in
the instant situation, is iniquitous, or arbitrary, or violative of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India, because it would be
almost impossible for an employee to bear the financial burden,
of a refund of payment received wrongfully for a long span of
time. It is apparent, that a government employee is primarily
dependent on his wages, and if a deduction is to be made from
his/her wages, it should not be a deduction which would make
it difficult for the employee to provide for the needs of his family.
Besides food, clothing and shelter, an employee has to cater,
not only to the education needs of those dependent upon him,
but also their medical requirements, and a variety of sundry
expenses. Based on the above consideration, we are of the view,
that if the mistake of making a wrongful payment is detected
within five years, it would be open to the employer to recover
the same. However, if the payment is made for a period in
excess of five years, even though it would be open to the
employer to correct the mistake, it would be extremely
iniquitous and arbitrary to seek a refund of the payments
mistakenly made to the employee.
“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship
which would govern employees on the issue of recovery, where
payments have mistakenly been made by the employer, in
excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may, based on the
decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as a ready
reference, summarise the following few situations, wherein
recoveries by the employers, would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III
and Class IV service (or Group C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the
employees who are due to retire within one year, of the
order of recovery.
W.P. (C) No. 528 of 2008
Page 6
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the
excess payment has been made for a period in excess
of five years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a higher
post, and has been paid accordingly, even though he should
have rightfully been required to work against an inferior
post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the
conclusion, that recovery if made from the employee, would
be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an extent, as
would far outweigh the equitable balance of the employer’s
right to recover.”
[8]
In paragraph No. 15 of the judgment of the “Chandi Prasad Uniyal
Case (Supra), the Hon’ble Apex Court held that except few instances pointed out
in Syed Abdul Qadir case and in Col. B.J. Akkara case, the excess payment made
due to wrong/irregular pay fixation can always be recovered, thereby indicating
that there are certain instances where recovery cannot be made.
In the case of Rafiq Masih (White Washer) (Supra), after
considering the judgment rendered in Chandi Prasad Uniyal case (Supra) and
various other Supreme Court judgment relating to the subject matter, the Hon’ble
Apex Court has laid down the few situations/exceptions wherein recoveries by the
employers are not permissible in law. One of the situations where recovery cannot
be made is when the excess payment has been made for a period in excess of 5
(five) years before the order of recovery is issued.
[9]
In the present case as the alleged excess payment was made to the
petitioners for a period of more than 2 (two) decades before issuing the impuged
recovery orders, this Court is of the considered view that such action of the
respondents for making recovery of the excess payment is impermissible and illegal
in view of the aforesaid judgment rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court. Accordingly,
the present writ petition is disposed of by directing the respondents not to make
W.P. (C) No. 528 of 2008
Page 7
any recovery from the petitioners in terms of the impugned office memorandum
dated 03.11.2006 and impugned notification dated 28.01.2008.
With the aforesaid directions, the present writ petition is disposed of.
Parties are to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Sapana
W.P. (C) No. 528 of 2008
Page 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review