Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:31877
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.B. SNEHALATHA
WEDNESDAY, THE 9TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 19TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 656 OF 2021
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT IN OP NO.790 OF 2016 OF FAMILY
COURT, PALAKKAD
APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO.1 IN O.P:
T.C.MANI
AGED 79 YEARS
S/O. CHAMI, THEKKUMPURAM RAKKANDIYIL, VEMBALLUR,
THENKURISSI AMSOM, ALATHUR TALUK, PALAKKAD
DISTRICT, PIN-678671.
BY ADVS.
P.B.KRISHNAN
P.B.SUBRAMANYAN
SABU GEORGE
MANU VYASAN PETER
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER IN OP:
SAJITHA .K.M, AGED 38 YEARS
D/O.K.K.MANI, W/O. LATE SUNIL, RESIDING AT KAKKODU
VEEDU, KOZHUKKULLI, ELEVAMPADAM P.O.,
KIZHAKKANCHERY AMSOM AND DESOM, ALATHUR TALUK,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT, PIN-678684.
BY ADVS.
T.R.HARIKUMAR
ADITHYA RAJEEV
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON
8.4.2024, THE COURT ON 09.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Mat.A.No.656 of 2021
DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN & M.B.SNEHALATHA, JJ
------------------------------------------Mat.A.No.656 of 2021
------------------------------------------Dated this the 9th day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
M.B.Snehalatha, J
Challenge in this appeal is to the judgment and decree of
the
Family Court, Palakkad, by which it granted a decree in
favour of the respondent herein/petitioner in the Original Petition,
for return of her gold ornaments and cash.
2. For the sake of convenience, parties shall be referred
to by their rank in the Original Petition as petitioner and
respondent.
3.
Original Petition was filed by the petitioner/wife
against her father-in-law and mother-in-law contending as
follows:
4. The marriage of the petitioner with respondents’ son
Sunil was solemnized on 16.09.2007 in accordance with Hindu
religious rites and ceremonies. At the time of marriage, petitioner
was given 35 sovereigns of gold ornaments and cash of ₹1 lakh
Mat.A.No.656 of 2021
from her house.
Her husband Sunil was suffering from
tuberculosis even prior to the marriage and his parents, namely,
respondents 1 and 2 suppressed the said fact from her and her
family.
Respondents misappropriated 30 sovereigns of gold
ornaments and the cash of ₹1 lakh of the petitioner.
They
pledged and sold the gold ornaments under the pretext of raising
money for the treatment expenses of Sunil.
On 1.2.2016,
petitioner’s husband Sunil committed suicide. Subsequent to the
death of her husband Sunil, respondents demanded her to leave
the matrimonial home. When the petitioner demanded back her
gold ornaments and cash of ₹1 lakh misappropriated by them, 1 st
respondent agreed to transfer 25 cents of property in favour of
the petitioner and on 12.02.2016, he executed a document
agreeing to transfer 25 cents of his land to the petitioner. But
due to the undue interference of his son-in-law, 1st respondent
did not transfer the land as agreed.
Respondents are liable to
return the 30 sovereigns of gold ornaments and cash of Rs.1 lakh
misappropriated by them.
5.
2nd respondent in the Original Petition/mother-
in-law died during pendency of the petition.
6.
1st
respondent/father-in-law
filed
counter,
denying the petitioner's case that she was given 35 sovereigns of
Mat.A.No.656 of 2021
gold ornaments and cash of ₹1 lakh from her house. He also
denied
the
allegation
regarding
misappropriation
ornaments and cash belonging to the petitioner.
of
gold
He contended
that petitioner had only 20 sovereigns of gold ornaments and the
said ornaments are with her. Petitioner is also in possession of 7
sovereigns of gold ornaments given to her at the time of
marriage by the respondents and their son Sunil. There was no
agreement to give 25 cents of land to the petitioner towards the
value of the gold ornaments and money as alleged by the
petitioner and no such agreement was executed by the 1st
respondent as alleged. During the post-funeral rituals of the
respondents’ son Sunil, petitioner and her men had obtained the
signature of the respondent in certain papers and documents by
coercion.
Respondent is not aware of the nature of the said
documents as he was grief-stricken on account of the death of
his
son.
The
petitioner's
husband,
Sunil,
was
undergoing
treatment for a period of three years prior to his death and the
entire treatment expenses were met by the son-in-law of the
respondent. Respondent is not liable to return any gold or cash
to the petitioner as alleged.
7.
After trial, the Family Court decreed the Original
Petition in part, granting a decree in favour of the petitioner
Mat.A.No.656 of 2021
directing the 1st respondent to return 19.5 sovereigns of gold
ornaments and cash of ₹1 lakh to the petitioner.
8.
1st respondent in the Original Petition assails the
said judgment and decree, contending that the Family Court has
not analyzed the evidence in its correct perspective; that he has
not taken any gold or cash of the petitioner; that the Family
Court went wrong in granting a decree for return of gold
ornaments and cash.
9.
whether
the
The point for consideration in this appeal is
impugned
judgment
and
decree
need
any
interference by this Court.
10.
Admittedly, the marriage of the petitioner with
Sunil, who is the son of the respondent was solemnized on
16.09.2007 as per Hindu customary rites and ceremonies.
Petitioner, who was examined as PW1 has testified that at the
time of her marriage, she was given 35 sovereigns of gold
ornaments and an amount of ₹1 lakh by her parents. Her further
version is that respondents misappropriated her 30 sovereigns of
her gold ornaments and cash of ₹1 lakh under the pretext of
providing treatment to her husband Sunil who was suffering from
tuberculosis and who was HIV Positive.
11.
The 1st respondent in his counter statement has
Mat.A.No.656 of 2021
admitted that at the time of marriage, petitioner had only 20
sovereigns of gold ornaments. 1st respondent has no case that
the parents of the petitioner had no financial capacity to give her
35 sovereigns of gold ornaments and cash of ₹1 lakh to her at
the
time
of
her
marriage
as
spoken
to
by
PW1.
To substantiate petitioner's case that she had 35 sovereigns of
gold ornaments, she has produced Exts.A7 and A7B photographs.
It is to be borne in mind that respondent has admitted in his
counter statement that petitioner had worn 20 sovereigns of gold
ornaments at the time of her marriage. The said admission made
by him also probabalise the version of the petitioner that at the
time of marriage, she was given 35 sovereigns of gold by her
parents.
Respondent has not entered into the witness box to
speak his case on oath and offer himself for cross examination.
We find no reason to suspect the genuineness of the version of
the petitioner that at the time of her marriage, she was given 35
sovereigns of gold ornaments and cash of ₹1 lakh by her parents.
12.
The case of the petitioner is that out of her 35
sovereigns of gold ornaments, 30 sovereigns of gold ornaments
were taken by her parents-in-law on various occasions for
pledging and sale under the pretext to raise money for the
treatment of her husband.
Mat.A.No.656 of 2021
13.
It is an admitted case that petitioner's husband,
Sunil died on 01.02.2016. It has also come out in evidence that
he was tested HIV positive. It is also in evidence that petitioner is
also tested HIV positive.
14.
The specific case of the petitioner is that after
the death of her husband Sunil, her father-in-law and mother-inlaw demanded her to leave the matrimonial home. According to
her, when she demanded them to return her gold ornaments and
cash
misappropriated
by
them,
1st
respondent
in
the
OP/appellant herein executed Ext.A3 document agreeing to
transfer 25 cents of land in lieu of her 30 sovereigns of gold and
cash of ₹1 lakh taken by him. Her further version is that though
1st respondent agreed to transfer 25 cents of land, he resiled
from the said promise due to the interference of his son-in-law.
15.
1st respondent has admitted his signature in
Ext.A3 document.
His case is that petitioner and her men
obtained his signature in certain papers under coercion and he is
not aware of the contents of it. But it is to be borne in mind that
1st respondent has not entered into the witness box to deny
Ext.A3 document, which admittedly bears his signature.
By
virtue of the said document dated 12.2.2016, respondent had
agreed to transfer 25 cents of land to the petitioner. PW3
Mat.A.No.656 of 2021
Swaminathan who is a neighbour of the parties has testified that
he is a witness to the execution of Ext.A3 Karar by the 1 st
respondent and PW3 has affixed his signature as a witness of
Ext.A3. PW3 has also testified that after the death of petitioner’s
husband Sunil, when the in-laws of the petitioner demanded her
to leave the matrimonial home, the local people intervened and
mediated in the matter and when the petitioner demanded the
respondent to return her gold ornaments, the respondent agreed
to transfer his
25 cents of property in favour of the petitioner
and it was under the said circumstances, Ext.A3 document was
executed by the respondent.
16.
We find no reason to disbelieve the case of the
petitioner that it was in lieu of her gold ornaments and cash of ₹1
lakh taken by the respondent, that he agreed to transfer 25
cents of land in favour of the petitioner. It is an admitted fact
that respondent resiled from Ext.A3 agreement and he did not
transfer the land as agreed to in Ext.A3.
17.
entire
gold
Though the respondent would contend that the
ornaments
of
the
petitioner
is
with
herself,
respondent failed to substantiate the said contention by adducing
any evidence. As stated earlier, 1st respondent has not even
entered into the witness box to speak his case on oath.
Mat.A.No.656 of 2021
Therefore, his case that the petitioner is in possession of her
entire gold ornaments and he has not taken any gold ornaments
is untenable as rightly held by the learned Family Court.
18. In Iswar Bhai C.Patel @ Bachu Bhai Patel v. Harihar
Behera and another (1999 KHC 1076), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that when a party fails to enter into the witness box to
speak his case on oath, an adverse inference can be drawn that
the case canvassed by him is incorrect.
19.
PW1,
In the petition as well as while examined as
petitioner has specifically described her 30 sovereigns of
gold ornaments taken by the respondent. It is in evidence that
out of the said items of gold ornaments described in the petition,
items 1 to 3 ornaments weighing 10.5 sovereigns which had
been pledged in the bank by her late husband Sunil was
redeemed by her after the death of Sunil by remitting the loan
amounts. The version of PW2, namely the Secretary in charge of
Koduvayoor Service Co-operative Bank coupled with Exts.A8 and
A9 fortifies the case of the petitioner that 10.5 sovereigns of gold
ornaments pledged in the said bank by her husband Sunil was
redeemed by her after the death of her husband.
It was after
deducting the said 10.5 sovereigns of gold ornaments, from out
of the 30 sovereigns claimed by the petitioner, the Family Court
Mat.A.No.656 of 2021
granted a decree in her favour directing R1 to return 19.5
sovereigns of gold ornaments.
20.
Petitioner is entitled to get back 19.5 sovereigns
of gold ornaments and cash of ₹1 lakh as rightly found by the
learned Family Court and this Court finds no reason to interfere
with the said findings of the learned Family Court.
Accordingly, the appeal fails and is dismissed.
Parties shall suffer their respective costs.
Sd/DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
JUDGE
Sd/M.B. SNEHALATHA
JUDGE
Mms/ab
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review