Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Krishna Rao
WPA No. 29396 of 2024
Swapan Kumar Manna & Ors.
Versus
State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Subir Sanyal, Sr. Adv.
Ms. Sumouli Sarkar
Mr. Sourojit Mukherjee
.....For the petitioners.
Mr. Himadri Barua
Mr. Biswajit Das
.....For the respondent no. 11.
Mr. Sounak Bhattacharya
Mr. A. Haldar
Ms. Debanwita Pramanik
.....For the respondent nos. 12, 13 & 14.
Ms. Koyeli Bhattacharya
Mr. Manas Bhattacharya
.....For the WBBSE.
Mr. Sayan Ganguly
.....For the State.
Hearing Concluded On : 16.01.2026
Judgment on
: 29.01.2026
Krishna Rao, J.:
1.
The petitioners have filed the present writ application praying for a
direction upon the respondents to admit the girls of the petitioners in
their respective classes in the Secondary Section (Classes V to X) for the
Academic Session 2025, setting aside the order dated 2nd September,
2004, passed by the Assistant Secretary of the Board and the order
dated 11th April, 2017, passed by the President of the Board.
2.
The petitioners also prayed for a direction upon the respondent Board
to reintroduce and permit co-education system for girl students in the
Sonamui Co-Education School from the Academic Session- 2025.
Sonamui Co-Education School was recognized by the Board as a CoEducation Higher Secondary (Old) School on and from 6th January,
1965.
3.
One Sadhan Chandra Ghorai and his legal heirs by way of registered
Deed of Gift dated 22nd July, 1965, gifted eighty eight (88) Sataks of
land in Mouza- Sonamui, District- Paschim Medinipore for the purpose
of establishment, development and extension of education both for girls
and boys students. Accordingly, Sonamui Co-Education School was
established and was recognized by the Board as a Co-Education Higher
Secondary School on and from 6th January, 1965.
4.
On 2nd December, 1988, Sonamui Girl’s School recognized by the Board
which is situated within the ½ km. distance from Sonamui CoEducation School. On 11th December, 1988, the Managing Committee
of Sonamui Girl’s School adopted a resolution to request the Board to
withdraw the co-education status of the Goura Sonamui Co-Education
School on the basis of the Board’s Circular dated 17th September, 1955
and 16th July, 1956.
5.
The Board vide its letter dated 12th August, 1991, informed the Head
Master of the Sonamui Co-Education School that the Co-education
system should be discontinued gradually year by year with effect from
1993 to 1994 and thereafter the extension of recognition for running
co-education school was made provisionally upto 30th April, 1996 on
condition to follow the decision communicated to the Board dated 12th
August, 1991.
6.
The Sonamui Girl’s School moved a writ petition before this Court
praying for implementation of Memo No. 2829/G/1 dated 12th August,
1991 and restraining the authorities of Sonamui Co-Education School
from admitting girl students. This Court by an order dated 6th March,
2008, disposed of the said writ application directing the Board to
consider and dispose of the representation of the petitioners dated 24th
May, 1993 and to pass a reasoned and speaking order. The Assistant
Secretary of the Board by a letter dated 2th September, 2004, requested
the Secretary, Sonamui Co-Education School to discontinue the coeducation system from Class V to Class VIII from the academic session
as the permission of the same has long been withdrawn by the Board.
7.
Some of the guardians of the students of Sonamui Co-Education School
filed a writ application before this Court. Initially, this Court passed an
ad interim injunction restraining the respondents from giving any effect
or further effect to the impugned order dated 2nd September, 2004 and
the interim order is extended till 2nd December, 2004. As none appears
on behalf of the petitioners, the said writ petition was dismissed for
default by an order dated 28th June, 2013.
8.
In the year 2011, one Nimai Chandra Matya of Sonamui Girl’s School
filed a writ petition for implementation of the order dated 2nd
September, 2004 and prayed for discontinuation of the co-education
system from Class V to Class VIII in Sonamui Co-Education School.
This Court by an order dated 11th April, 2012, dismissed the writ
application with costs.
9.
On 15th July, 2014, the Administrator of the Board passed an order
holding that in case of breach of Board’s order dated 2nd September,
2004, the Board will take stern view. On 6th January, 2014, some
guardians of the girl students have filed a writ petition before this Court
being W.P. No. 33388 (w) of 2014 challenging the order passed by the
Board dated 15th July, 2014. This Court by an order dated 6th January,
2014, directed that the girl students who have already been admitted in
the co-education school to continue their studies in the same school.
10. Some of the guardians have again filed a writ petition before this Court
being W.P. No. 1081(w) of 2017 praying for permission for co-education
status. This Court by an order dated 23rd February, 2017, disposed of
the writ application directing the Board to consider the representation
of the guardians dated 4th November, 2016. In compliance of the said
order, the President of the Board has passed the impugned order on
11th April, 2017.
11. Mr. Subir Sanyal, Learned Senior Advocate representing the petitioners
submits that there are at least 8 Co-Education Schools/ Institutions in
the locality of Daspur Block-I and Daspur Block-II within the 4 kms.
Out of the said eight Co-Education Institutions, Sonamui Co-Education
School is the best school having three storied building consisting of 36
class rooms with separate sitting arrangements for girls and boys with
ten (10) ladies toilets and four (4) boys toilets apart from separate
urinals both for boys and girls, teachers’ toilet and urinal and common
room both for boys and girls separately. He submits that the said
schools are having all facilities like library, playground, indoor game
complex-cum-auditorium, multi gym facilities, solar system/ panel,
sound system and laboratory.
12. Mr. Sanyal relied upon the Report of the Committee on the Status of
Women in India issued by the Government of India, Department of
Social Welfare, Ministry of Education and Social Welfare in the month
of December, 1974 and submits that the Committee was of the view
that the girls whose parents had no objection should be free to use coeducational facilities in boys schools. The Commission, however,
prescribed specific conditions in the way of mixed staff, teaching of
subjects, which appeal to girls such as home craft, music, drawing etc.
and separate facilities for co-curricular activities for such Institutions.
13. Mr.
Sanyal
submits
that
the
Commission
has
categorically
recommended that at the middle and secondary stages, separate
schools may be provided in areas where there is a great demand for
them. But the efforts to pursue co-education as a general policy at
these stages should continue side by side. He further submits that
there should be no ban on admission of girls to boys’ Institutions.
14. Mr. Sanyal relied upon the judgment in the case of Rama Nath Tiwari
and Others Vs. Committee of Management and Another reported in
1992 SCC OnLine All 809 and submits that the Allahabad High Court
has held that all educational institutions at all levels should be coeducational. Co-education is healthy and good for the development of
the personalities of both boys and girls, if there is co-education boys
and girls will know how to interact with each other in a healthy manner
and this will also help them toward social adjustability.
15. Mr. Sanyal further relied upon the judgment in the case of State of
Tamil Nadu and Others Vs. K. Shyam Sunder and Others reported
in (2011) 8 SCC 737 and submits that the right to education under
Article 21-A of the Constitution of India be read in conformity with
Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution and there must be no
discrimination in quality of education. He submits that uniform
education system would achieve the code of common culture, removal
of disparity and depletion of discriminatory values in human relations.
16. Mr. Himadri Barua, Learned Advocate representing the respondent
no.11 submits that by an order dated 6th January, 2015 in W.P. 33388
(W) of 2014, the Coordinate Bench of this Court directed that the girl
students who have already been admitted in the Sikshayatan shall
continue to pursue their studies till such time their parents/ guardians
wish them to do so or till they take the relevant Madhyamik Parikshas
or other examinations. The decision of the WBBSE, conveyed by the
memo dated 2nd September, 2004 and memo dated 15th July, 2014
shall not have any effect insofar as they are concern. The Court also
directed the authorities of the school not to admit any new girl student
in any class henceforth. By an order dated 18th September, 2015, the
Court clarified the order dated 6th January, 2015 that the authorities
shall not admit any new girl students in Classes V to VIII.
17. Mr. Barua further submits that by an order dated 18th September,
2015, the Court has further directed that the admissions granted to
such 33 students would be regularized and the Board shall treat them
to be duly admitted students of the Sikshayatan. But the Court
directed the authorities with effect from the next academic session not
to admit any new girl student in Classes V to VIII.
18. Mr. Barua submits that again a writ petition was filed being W.P. 1081
(W) of 2017 challenging the order memo dated 2nd September, 2004 and
15th July, 2014, issued by the Board and the Coordinate Bench of this
Court by an order dated 23rd February, 2017, disposed of the writ
petition
by
directing
concern
authorities
to
dispose
of
the
representation dated 4th November, 2016 in terms of the order passed
by this Court in W.P. 33388 (W) of 2014 within a period of three (3)
months.
19. Mr. Barua submits that in terms of the order dated 23rd February,
2017, the Board has passed an order on 11th April, 2017, upholding the
decision of the Board dated 15th July, 2014 and warned the School not
to admit any girl student in the Secondary level. Being aggrieved with
the said order, again a writ petition is moved before this Court being
W.P. No. 24581 (W) of 2017. The said writ petition is still pending and
thus the present writ petition is not maintainable.
20. Ms. Koyeli Bhattacharyya, Learned Advocate representing the West
Bengal Board of Secondary Education submits that by an order dated
2nd September, 2004, the Board has requested the School to
discontinue co-education from Classes V to VIII as the permission for
the same has long been withdrawn by the Board.
21. Ms. Bhattacharyya further submits that in compliance of the order
passed by the Coordinate Bench of this Court in C.O. No. 7637 of 1994,
the Administrator of the Board passed a reasoned and speaking order
dated 15th July, 2014, directing the Boy’s School not to continue coeducation in violation of the order passed by the Board dated 2nd
September, 2004.
22. Ms. Bhattacharyya further submits that decision is taken by the Board
taking into consideration that there is sharp decline in the roll of the
girl students in girls’ school though the girls’ school is situated within
100 mtrs. from the co-education school and whereas the co-education
school admitted abnormal strength in their school. She further submits
that the Board has taken decision in the year 2004 and in the year
2014 and the Coordinate Bench of this Court by an order dated 6th
January, 2015, directed the co-education school not to admit any girl
student in Classes V to VIII henceforth.
23. The respondent no.3 has filed a report stating that at present in the
academic session of the School enrolment of students is 663, and 21
teachers are posted in the said school including 1 (one) contractual
teacher and 2 (two) para teachers and the ratio between the teachers
and students is 32:1. It is further stated in the report that the West
Bengal Board of Secondary Education has the right to allow the school
authority to continue with the co-education facilities upon fulfillment of
certain conditions.
24. Sonamui Co-Education School was recognised by the Board as a CoEducation Higher Secondary School with effect from 6th January, 1965.
Subsequent to the establishment of Co-Education School, in the same
vicinity
within
½
KM
from
another
school,
namely,
Sonamui
Khirodamoyee Balika Vidyalaya was established on 2nd December,
1988. Initially the said school was up to Class IV and subsequently it
was upgraded upto Class X.
25. After establishment of girls’ school within ½ KM from the co-education
school in the same locality, the Managing Committee of the girls’ school
requested the Board to withdraw the permission of Co-Education
School status from Class V to Class VIII as the girls’ school is facing
difficulties to have girl students admitted in the girls’ school.
26. The Assistant Secretary of the West Bengal Board of Secondary
Education by an order dated 2nd September, 2004, requested the
Secretary of the Goura Sonamui Kunjabehari Adarsha Sikshyatan to
take steps to discontinue co-education from Classes V to VIII from this
academic session as the permission of the same has long been
withdrawn by the Board.
27. As per direction passed by the Coordinate Bench of this Court dated 6th
March, 2008 in C.O. No. 7637(W) of 1994, the Board has passed the
following order on 27th June, 2014:
“The Girls’ School is confronted with an
existence crisis because of sharp decline in roll
strength whereas co-education Boys’ school
situated within 100 meters from the Girls’ School
has admitted registered abnormal growth at the
cost of the roll strength of the Girls. In order to
protect and preserve its existence, the Managing
Committee of the Girls School has prayed for
withdrawal/no further extension of permission for
retention of co-education system in the Boys’
School.
The
very
existence
of
Sonamui
Kshirodamoyee Balika Vidyalaya Jr. Girls’ School
is at stake. In the representations dated
24.05.1993 and 18.11.2013 respectively, the Girls
School prayed for withdrawal of permission for
running
co-education
in
Goura
Sonamui
Kunjabehari Adarsha Sishayatan. It appears from
the material on record that Board withdrew such
permission for running co-education from the said
Boy’s school vide Board’s Memo No Mis (LW)
3215/G/04 dated 02.09.2004. The Boy’s school
challenged the said order of the Board by filling a
writ petition being W.P. No. 20039 (W) of 2004
before the Hon’ble High Court and obtained order
of interim stay which was extended from time to
time. But eventually the said writ petition was
dismissed for default on 28.06.13.
There was automatic revival of the Board’s
earlier order vide Memo No Mis (LW) 3215/G/04
dated 02.09.2004 with the dismissal of the writ
application preferred by the Boy’s School.
At the time of hearing, Secretary & the
Headmaster of the Boy’s school submitted that
they are running the co-education which they
cannot do after revival of the Board’s order under
vide Memo No Mis (LW) 3215/G/04 dated
02.09.2004 consequent to the dismissal of the writ
application.
Since the withdrawal of permission from
running co-education is still in force the
representation dated 24.05.1993 may be disposed
of with a direction to the Boy’s school not to
continue co-education in violation of the Board’s
direction given under vide Memo No Mis(LW)
3215/G/04 dated 02.09.2004 because the Board
still strict to its decision as conveyed in the said
memo.
If the Boy’s school still ventures to continue
the co-education in breach of the direction
contained Board’s Memo No. Mis(LW) 3215/G/04
dated 02.09.2004, the Board be left with no other
option than to take stern view in this matter.
The representation file by the petitioner dated
24.05.1993 & 28.11.13 are disposed of
accordingly.”
28. Being aggrieved with the order dated 27th June, 2014, some of the
parents of girl students of Goura Sonamui Kunjabehari Adarsha
Sishayatan have filed writ petition being W.P. No. 33388 (W) of 2014.
The Coordinate Bench of this Court disposed of the said writ petition on
6th January, 2015 by passing the following order:
“It appears on perusal of the order of the
Administrator that there was an earlier order dated
2nd September, 2004 passed by the WBBSE
discontinuing co-education from Classes-V to VIII in
the said Sikshayatan, which was communicated
by the Assistant Secretary (G), WBBSE vide memo
dated 2nd September, 2004; such memo was
challenged before this Court in W.P. 20039 (W) of
2004 and interim stay was obtained; such writ
petition was ultimately dismissed for default on
28th June, 2013 and the said order not having been
recalled, the memo dated 2nd September, 2004
revived, as a result of which the authorities of the
said Sikshayatan were under a legal disability to
admit girl students in Classes-V to VIII.
It further appears that the WBBSE had taken
a decision to discontinue co-education facilities in
the said Sikshayatan accepting the representation
made
by
the
authorities
of
Sonamui
Kshirodamoyee Balika Vidyalaya (hereafter the
‘girls’ school’). It was the claim of the authorities of
the said girl’s school that there was an abnormal
increase of girls students in the said Sikshayatan
where for want of adequate number of girl
students, the girls’ school, which was situated near
to the said Sikshayatan, was immensely suffering
and on the verge of closure.
I need not examine the controversy as to
whether the WBBSE was justified in discontinuing
the co-education facilities in the said Sikshayatan,
since a decision to that effect has been taken more
than a decade ago. However, having regard to the
fact that such order was challenged before this
Court and such challenge in effect has failed by
reason of dismissal of W.P. 20039 (W) of 2004 for
default, I am of the further view that interest of
justice would be best served if the equities are
balanced and this writ petition is disposed of at
this stage by issuing necessary direction.
Accordingly, I direct that the girl students who
have already been admitted in the said
Sikshayatan shall continue to pursue their
students till such time their parent/guardians wish
them to do so or till they take the relevant
Madhyamik Parikshas or other examinations, and
the decision of the WBBSE, conveyed by memo
dated 2nd September, 2004 and memo dated 15th
July, 2014 (enclosing copy of the impugned order of
the Administrator of the WBBSE) shall not have
any effect insofar as they are concerned. However,
the authorities of the said Sikshayatan shall not
admit any new girl student in any class henceforth.
It
is
made
abundantly
clear
that
notwithstanding the arrangement to be worked out
by this order, the WBBSE shall be at liberty in the
interest of education of students of the locality to
take any further decision that might be necessary
including review of the decision as communicated
by the memo dated 2nd September, 2004.
The writ petition stands disposed of.”
29. After the order dated 6th January, 2015, one Civil Application being
CAN No. 1559 of 2015 was filed for clarification of the order dated 6th
January, 2015 and a Contempt Application was also filed being CPAN
No. 175 of 2015 on the allegation of violation of the said order. The
Court has taken up both the applications together and passed the
following order on 18th September, 2015 which reads as follows:
“6. None has disputed that by an order dated
02.09.2004, the Board had restrained the
authorities of the said Sikshayatan from admitting
girl students in Classes V to VIII. There was no
restriction insofar as admission of girl students in
Classes IX to XII. Therefore, the order dated
06.01.2015 cannot be read in a manner restricting
the right of the applicant in CAN 1559 of 2015 to
admit students in Classes IX to XII. The portion of
the order dated 06.01.2015 extracted (supra) in
paragraph 2 shall be construed accordingly i.e. the
authorities of the said Sikshayatan are entitled to
admit girl students in Classes IX to XII till such
time a contra order is passed by the Board in this
regard.
7. Insofar as the admission of 33 students in
Classes V, VI and IX are concerned, allegedly, in
violation of the order dated 06.01.2015, I am
satisfied that due to communication gap the
applicant in CAN 1559 of 2015 proceeded to make
such admissions. There was no ill motive of the
applicant to lower the dignity, majesty and prestige
of this Court.
8. In this view of the matter, I direct that the
admissions granted to such 33 students would be
regularized and the Board shall treat them to be
duly admitted students of the said Sikshayatan.
However, it is made clear that with effect from the
next academic session, the authorities of the said
Sikshayatan shall not admit any new girl student
in Classes V to VIII.
9. I have considered the submission of Mr.
Barua that Sonamui Kshirodamoyee Balika
Vidyalaya has since been granted recognition as a
high school (upto Class X) and that the authorities
of the said Sikshayatan should not be allowed to
admit students even in Classes IX and X for the
same reason communicated in the Board's order
dated 02.09.2004.
10. I am afraid, no such order can be passed
for the simple reason that it is for the Board to
make an appropriate order in this regard. Since the
Board has not yet passed any order restricting the
authorities of the said Sikshayatan from admitting
students in Classes IX and X, the prayer made by
Mr. Barua does not merit acceptance.
11. CPAN 175 of 2015 and CAN 1559 of 2015
stand disposed of, without costs.
12. The other portions of the order dated
06.01.2015 shall stand intact.”
30. Again some of the parents of the girl students have filed a writ
application being W.P. No. 1081 (W) of 2017, challenging the order
dated 2nd September, 2009 and 15th July, 2014. The said writ petition
is disposed of on 23rd February, 2017 by passing the following order:
“Accordingly, without going into the merit of
the case, the writ petition is disposed of by
directing the concerned authorities to dispose of the
representation dated 4th November, 2016 so filed
by the petitioners in terms of the order passed by
this Hon’ble High Court in W.P. 33388 (W) of 2014
as also after affording an opportunity of hearing to
all the interested parties within a period of three
months from the date of communication of this
order.”
31. In compliance of the order dated 23rd February, 2017, the impugned
order is passed by the Board on 11th April, 2017 which reads as
follows:
“After thorough scrutiny of relevant documents
and taking into account the submission made at
the time of hearing, it is revealed that the total roll
strength of the girls’ school is around 200. The
school has been converted to a sponsored
institution on 18.05.2015. But what is strange is
that Goura Sonamui K.B. Adarsha Sikshayatan
has admitted 33 girls students in the year 2015
violating the order dt. 06.01.2015, passed by the
Hon’ble High Court in W.P. No. 33388 (W) 2014,
and also the directive issued by the W.B.B.S.E.,
conveyed vide Memo No. 178/C/1 (law) dt.
15.07.2014. The H.M. of the Co-education school
has himself admitted this fact at the time of
hearing. There is at present 52 girls students in
Class X and 53 girls students in Class IX.
In view of the above, I, President,
W.B.B.S.E. dispose of the representation of the
petitioners dt. 04.11.2016 by uploading the earlier
decision conveyed Vide Memo No. 178/C/1 (Law),
dt. 15.07.2014. The authority of Goura Sonamui
Kunja Behari Adarsha Sikshayatan is warned once
again not to admit anymore girls students in the
secondary level. Any dilly-daily or violation of this
directive will invite stern measures.”
32. Though by an order dated 6th January, 2015, this Court directed the
Co-Education School not to admit any girl student in any class
henceforth and given liberty to the WBBSE in the interest of education
of students of the locality to take further decision that might be
necessary including review of the decision dated 2nd September, 2004.
The order dated 6th January, 2015, was modified/ clarified by an order
dated 18th September, 2015, allowing the co-education school to admit
girl students in Classes IX to XII till such time, contra order is not
passed.
33. The finding of the Board in the impugned order is that the total
strength of the girls’ school is 200 and the school is converted to a
sponsored institution on 18th May, 2015, but the Co-Education School
admitted 33 girls’ student in violation of the order passed by this Court
dated 6th January, 2015 and the direction of the Board dated 15th July,
2014. As regard to the violation of the order dated 6th January, 2015, is
concern, this Court in a contempt proceeding held that due to
communication gap, the Co-Education School proceeded to make such
admission and there was no ill motive of the Co-Education School to
lower down the dignity, majesty and prestige of this Court. Thus the
finding of the Board is not correct and in contrary to the order passed
by this Court dated 18th September, 2015. As regard to the the violation
of the directives, this Court has already confirmed the admission of the
girl students, thus, now it cannot be said that the Co-Education School
authorities have violated the directives dated 15th July, 2014.
34. By the impugned order, the Board has affirmed the decision of the
Board dated 15th July, 2014. The only ground for withdrawal of coeducation system by the Board is due to sharp decline in roll strength
in the girls’ school and dismissal of writ application filed by the Boys
School against the order dated 2nd September, 2004. The writ petition
was dismissed not on merit. The same was dismissed for default. This
Court by an order dated 6th January, 2015, given liberty to the Board in
the interest of education of students of the locality to take further
decision that might be necessary including review of the decision dated
2nd September, 2004.
35. The Board of Secondary Education, West Bengal issued a Circular No.
37/56 dated 16th July, 1956 wherein directives have been issued in
connection with the girl’s education in the State. In the said Circular,
directions for Co-Education was also issued which reads as follows:
“(1) Co-education: The Board of Secondary
Education, West Bengal has not accepted the
principle of co-education as such in schools. Girl
students are not admitted in Boys’ Schools and
vice versa, as general rule.
Only in exceptional circumstances the Board
grants permission for the admission of a limited
number of girl students subject to the following
conditions being fulfilled as laid down in Board’s
Circular No. 48/55 dated 17th September, 1955:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
Separate sitting arrangement for girls.
Separate common room facilities.
Separate sanitary conveniences.
Escort for girls to and from the school.
That at least one lady teacher is appointed
in the School.
[It is, however, felt that the appointment of
such a lady teacher may not be made unless the
number of girl pupils reading in a Boys' School
exceeds 30 in the two top classes.] Such a lady
teacher when appointed should be co-opted as a
member of the Managing Committee.
The following additional conditions are laid
down in the light of experience:
(i) The total number of students in a class
including the number of girl students should
not exceed the prescribed number of students
for a class and the area per student shall be
provided at the rate not less than 10 sq.ft per
pupil in view of the fact that separate sitting
arrangement for the girl students will have to
be provided in a class of mixed pupils and as
such the accommodation available in such a
classroom should be more than what is
ordinarily accepted as the floor space per
pupil, i.e. 8 sq.ft per pupil.
(ii) The total number of girl students to be
admitted in Classes VIII and below should not
ordinarily exceed 30.
(iii) Girl students in Classes IX and X will not
ordinarily be permitted unless there are strong
justifications for this and each case will be
dealt with according to its merits.
(iv) Permission for admission of girl students in
Classes IX and X shall be on a temporary
basis subject to the condition No. (v) Under
para 1 above. But guardians in such cases
shall be asked to get their girls admitted in
regular Girls’ schools as early as possible.
(vi) Permission for admission of girls students
in any class shall not be given where there are
Girls’ school in the neighborhood within a
radius of one mile in a city or a town, and
within two miles of a school situated in rural
areas; and also if such Girls’ schools in the
neighborhood are in a position to admit the
additional number.”
36. Sonamui Co-education School was recognized by the Secondary
Education on 6th January, 1965. Sonamui Girls’ School was recognized
on 2nd December, 1988. After recognition of Girls’ School and as per the
request of the said school, the Board by a Memo No. 2829/G/1 dated
12th August, 1991, directed the co-education system should be
discontinued from the Session 1993-1994 and running co-education
school was made provisionally till 30th April, 1996. Thereafter several
writ proceedings have been initiated as described above. In the month
of December, 1974, the Government of India, Department of Social
Welfare, Ministry of Education and Social Welfare, published a report
the Co-Education system was also taken into consideration which
reads as follows:
“6.65 The imbalances just pointed out make it
difficult to put forward a set pattern of
recommendations. Besides the general problems of
education, there are certain specific issues on
which it is not feasible to insist upon a uniform
pattern for the whole country. One such example is
co-education. This issue has been examined by
various Committees and Commissions.
6.66 In 1953, the Secondary Education
Commission observed that there could be no hard
and fast policy with regard to co-education as
social attitudes differed very greatly in this
Respect. The Commission, therefore, recommended:
(i) opening of separate schools wherever
possible as they were likely to offer better
opportunities for physical, social and mental
development of the girls,
(ii) girls whose parents had no objection should
be free to use co-educational facilities in
boys' schools. The Commission, however,
prescribed specific conditions in the way of
mixed staff, teaching of subjects which
appeal to girls such as home craft, music,
drawing, etc. and separate facilities for cocurricular activities for such institutions.
In 1959, the National Committee on Women's
Education recommended that co-education should
be adopted as a general policy at the primary
stage, but as a transitional measure, separate
schools may be provided in places where there was
a strong public demand for them and enrolment of
girls was large enough to justify separate schools.
At the middle and secondary stages more coeducational schools should be started, subject
should be started, subject to the condition of
adequate attention being paid to special needs and
requirements of girls. Separate secondary schools
for girls should, however, be provided specially in
rural areas. The Committee while recommending
alternatives in areas where co-education was not
acceptable, suggested efforts to remove difficulties
and apprehensions against co-education by
providing right type of staff, encouraging parental
visits and the appointment of women teachers and
women heads in co-educational institutions.
6.72 In our opinion, the considerations of
efficiency, economy as well as equal opportunity
require the acceptance of co-education as a long
term policy. In view of the divergent social
attitudes, however, we recommend:(i) Co-education should be adopted as the
general policy at the primary level;
(ii) at the middle and secondary stages
separate schools may be provided in areas
where there is a great demand for them. But the
effort to pursue co-education as a general policy
at these stages should continue side-by-side;
(iii) at the university level co-education should
be the general policy and opening of new
colleges exclusively for girls should be
discouraged;
(iv) there should be no ban on admission of
girls to boys' institutions;
(v) wherever separate schools/colleges for
girls are provided, it has to be ensured that they
maintain required standards in regard to the
quality of staff, provision of facilities, relevant
courses and co-curricular activities;
(vi) acceptance of the principle of mixed staff
should be made a condition of recognition for
mixed schools. There is a misgiving, however,
that this provision may lead to exclusion of girls
from some schools. Therefore, it is suggested
that this measure may be reviewed a few years
after it is implemented;
(vii) wherever there are mixed schools,
separate toilet facilities and retiring rooms for
girls should be provided.”
37. In the meantime Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education
(RTE) Act, 2009, came into force. In the case State of Tamil Nadu and
Others Vs. K. Shyam Sunder and Others reported in (2011) 8 SCC
737, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that:
“21. The right to education is a fundamental
right under Article 21-A inserted by the Eighty-sixth
Amendment of the Constitution. Even before the
said amendment, this Court has treated the right to
education as a fundamental right.
22. There has been a campaign that right to
education under Article 21-A of our Constitution be
read in conformity with Articles 14 and 15 of the
Constitution and there must be no discrimination in
quality of education. Thus, a common syllabus and
a common curriculum is required. The right of a
child should not be restricted only to free and
compulsory education, but should be extended to
have quality education without any discrimination
on the ground of its economic, social and cultural
background. Arguments of the propagators of this
movement draw support from the judgment of the
US
Supreme
Court in Brown v. Board
of
Education overruling
its
earlier
judgment
in Plessy v. Ferguson where it has been held
that “separate education facilities are inherently
unequal” and thus, violate the doctrine of equality.
22. The propagators of this campaign
canvassed that uniform education system would
achieve the code of common culture, removal of
disparity and depletion of discriminatory values in
human relations. It would enhance the virtues and
improve the quality of human life, elevate the
thoughts which advance our constitutional
philosophy of equal society. In future, it may prove
to be a basic preparation for the uniform civil code
as it may help in diminishing opportunities to those
who foment fanatic and fissiparous tendencies.
24.In State of Orissa v. Mamata Mohanty,
this Court emphasised the importance of education
observing that education connotes the whole course
of scholastic instruction which a person has
received. Education connotes the process of
training and developing the knowledge, skill, mind
and character of students by formal schooling. The
Court further relied upon the earlier judgment
in Osmania University Teachers' Assn. v. State of
A.P., wherein it has been held as under:
“30. … Democracy depends for its very life on
a high standard of general, vocational and
professional education. Dissemination of learning
with search for new knowledge with discipline all
round must be maintained at all costs.”
The case at hand is to be proceeded with
keeping this ethical backdrop in mind.”
38. This Court finds that the Board has withdrawn Co-Education System of
Classes V to VIII only on the ground that the Girls’ school is confronted
with an existence crisis because of sharp decline in roll strength. There
is no allegation that the Co-Education School has violated any terms
and conditions. Whereas the petitioners have given details of eight coeducation schools within the radius of four (4) kilometers adjacent to
each other including the petitioner’s Co-Education School but the
Board has taken decision for withdrawal of Co-education system for
Classes V to VIII of the petitioner’s school without any cogent reasons.
39. In the case of Rama Nath Tiwari & Ors. Vs. Committee of
Management and Another reported in 1992 SCC OnLine All 809,
the Allahabad High Court held that:
“6. Article 39(f) of the Constitution states that
“The State shall in particular direct its policy
towards securing that children are given
opportunities and facilities to develop in a healthy
manner.
7. In my opinion development in a healthy
manner for children is best possible in coeducation. The right to education in Articles 41 and
45 must be construed consistently with Article
39(f).
8. In a paper entitled—
“A PSYCHOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVE
ADOLESCENCE:
A
RATIONALE
FOR
EDUCATION.”
ON
CO-
9. Ms. Komila Thapa, Lecturer in the
Psychology Department in the Allahabad University
has said.” It would be tenable to argue that the coeducational system, as opposed to same-sex
Schools would provide an opportunity for
adolescents to interact with the same-gender as
well as opposite-gender peer groups. This would
prepare the ground for a healthier, more open
interaction between the sexes and would promote
healthy attitudes towards issues of sexuality. Also,
as co-education offers a first-hand opportunity to
observe the behaviour patterns of other adolesecnts
of the same and opposite-gender, the advantages
accruing would be two-fold:
(i) the adolescent would be able to
sharpen and refine his/her personal, identity.
(ii) sex-role identities would be more
clearly articulated and defined therein. Also
ensuring problems would be more easily
resolved.
10. Thus the adolescent's perceptions of
issues of identity, friendship and sexuality, all
critical and significant issues at this juncture as
well as for future well-being would be influenced
by experiences in co-educational system. It is
hoped that as this system enables a freer
interaction between the two sexes, the adolescent
would not always “meander through a terrain,
hewn out of fantasies of intimacy, a landscape
whose contours are shaped by the more obscure
desires and fears men and women entertain in
relation to each other.”
40. It is the specific case of the petitioners that Sonamui Co-education
School is the best school in the said locality. The school is situated in
three storied building consisting of 36 class rooms with separate sitting
arrangements for boys and girls and other facilities of urinals and
toilets. The schools are having good library, playground within the
school campus, indoor game complex-cum–auditorium and laboratory
and other facilities.
41. This Court finds that the Board has not considered the facilities
available in the Co-Education School, the Right of Children to Free and
Compulsory Education Act (RTE), 2009 and desires of the parents and
girl students of the said locality. Time and again, the parents of girls’
student filed writ proceeding challenging the decision of the Board. The
Board has taken into consideration the request made by the Sonamui
Kshirodamoyee Balika Vidyalaya that there is sharp decline in roll
strength due to existence of Co-education School is situated within 100
mtrs. from the girls school but has not taken into consideration that
the Co-education School is established in the year 1965 and still the
parents of the girls’ student intending that their daughters be studied
in the Co-Education School.
42. Co-education is a setup where the boys and girls studied together
under one roof without any distinction. The Co-education system is a
necessity in the present time due to several reasons. Under this system,
boys and girls receive physical, moral values and academic education
together. It allows boys and girls to compete each other. Students
studying in co-education schools are exposed to diversity during early
school life.
43. Considering the above, this Court finds that the reasons by which the
Board has taken the decisions for withdrawal of Co-Education System
from Class V to Class VIII is not justifiable and accordingly the order
dated 2nd September, 2004, 15th July, 2014 and 11th April, 2017 are set
aside and quashed.
44. WPA No. 29396 of 2024 is allowed.
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the
Judgment placed on the official website of the Court.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review