The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Therefore this court after giving an anxious consideration is of the view that the amount of rs 1200/- is required to be to be enhanced but not to the extent of Rs 8000/- and hence the order passed by the learned Revisional court is to be modified.
16. Accordingly this criminal revisional application stands allowed .The order passed by the revisional court is set aside so far the amount of maintenance granted in favour of the daughter and the order is modified so far the amount granted in favour of the wife to Rs 2500/- from Rs 4000/-.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:HON’BLE JUSTICE CHAITALI CHATTERJEE (DAS)
CRR NO.1386 of 2020
+
IA NO:CRAN/1/2020
SWAPAN KUMAR MALLICK
VS.
SMT. BHABANI MALLICK & ANR.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Sandipan Ganguly, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Biswajit Manna, Adv.
For the O.Ps.
:
Mrs. Rituparna De Ghosh, Adv.
Last heard on
:
08.04.2026
Judgement on
:
08.04.2026
Uploaded on
:
10.04.2026
CHAITALI CHATTERJEE (DAS), J. :1. This is an application filed under Sections 397/401 read with Section 482 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973, against the judgment and order dated February 19,
2020 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court, Suri,
Birbhum, in connection with the Criminal Revision No.06 of 2017, thereby setting
aside the order of the learned Judicial Magistrate, 2nd Court, Suri, Birbhum, passed in
Criminal Misc. Case No.187 of 2013 under Section 127 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure.
2. The case of the petitioner in brief is that the marriage of the petitioner with the
opposite party no.1 was held on February 12, 1996 according to the Hindu
rites and customs and thereafter they lived together and led conjugal life and a
female child was born from their wedlock.
On July 20, 1997, she left her
matrimonial home alleging torture upon her by the petitioner and her in-laws
and lodged a complaint under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code and an
order of acquittal was passed by virtue of a judgment and order dated
December 13, 2000 .In the year 1988, the opposite party no.1 filed the first
application under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure praying for
maintenance and initially an interim maintenance was granted which got
dismissed subsequently, with the observation that the case made out is
absolutely false. After that, again in the month of July, 2001, she along with
the opposite party no.2 being the daughter filed a second proceeding under
Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
3. The records reveals a long standing matrimonial discord giving rise to
numerous litigation between the parties specially in connection with
proceeding under Section 125 Cr.P.C . Several
a
revisional applications were
filed before this Court against almost each and every order passed by the
Learned Magistrate and the quantum of maintenance was modified on several
occasions
and lastly in the year 2008, after remand from this Court, the
learned Magistrate passed an order directing the petitioner to pay each of t
4. Another revisional application was filed being CRR 3436 of 2009 whereby the
learned coordinate Bench modified the amount to the tune of Rs.1200/- per
month to be paid to the opposite party no.1 and Rs.800/- per month to the
opposite party no.2 with effect from February 10, 2005.
5. During pendency of that revisional application, opposite party no.2 filed an
application under Section 127 of the Code of Criminal Procedure praying for
enhancement of the amount of maintenance to Rs.5000/- per month to each of
the opposite parties and such prayer was initially rejected by the learned
Magistrate on August 30, 2016 with the observation that as the order of High
Court was passed in the year 2016 affirming the quantum of maintenance as
Rs.1200/- plus Rs.800/- per month, in order to avoid confusion of judicial
indiscipline no enhancement order to be passed.
6. Challenging that, the opposite party filed a revisional application before the
learned Sessions Court on February 03, 2017. The revisional court also issued
summons for production of pension records of the petitioner.
Accordingly,
such documents were placed and the revisional court further issued summons
to the Branch Manager, Allahabad Bank, Palashpuly Branch.
The present
petitioner being aggrieved filed a revisional application which was disposed of
on September 20, 2019 directing the revisional court to dispose of the motion
on merits after setting aside the order passed by the revisional court. The said
criminal revisional application being Criminal Motion (Revision) No.06 of 2017
was disposed of on February 19, 2020 directing the petitioner to pay each of
the opposite parties a sum of Rs.4000/- per month as maintenance.
7. Being aggrieved thereby, this revisional application has been filed.
8. Learned Senior Advocate Mr. Sandipan Ganguly representing the petitioner,
strenuously contended that the learned revisional court without assigning
appropriate reason passed such order arbitrarily without applying his judicial
mind,
despite being aware the petitioner is a retired person and a pension
holder and no further development in the income of the present petitioner
could be shown by the opposite party no 2. The further contention is that the
maintenance was granted in favour of the daughter of the parties when she
attained majority in the year 2014. The application under Section 127 of the
Code was filed in March, 2013 and the order of maintenance was affirmed by
the High Court the year 2016 which was also included the maintenance
towards the minor.
Therefore, the amount paid after November, 2014 is in
excess since the daughter attained majority and is not entitled to any
maintenance under Section 127 of the Code. Accordingly prayed for setting
aside such order.
9. The learned advocate representing the opposite party no.2 has been engaged
by the Calcutta High Court Legal Services Committee since none appeared on
behalf of the opposite party no.2 despite receiving notices served upon her.
It
is submitted by the learned advocate for the opposite party no.2 that under the
scheme under Section 125 of the Code which is a beneficial legislation an
unmarried major daughter is entitled to maintenance. That apart, the order of
maintenance of Rs.1200/- plus Rs.800/- totaling Rs.2000/- was granted by
the court way back in the year 2008 and during this long passage of time,
considering the surrounding circumstances and market values, the amount of
Rs.2000/- was enhanced to Rs.8000/- to the opposite party no 2 and her
daughter which was just and proper. In this context, she has relied upon the
case of Abhilasha Vs. Parkash & Ors.1.
10. After hearing the rival contentions and on careful perusal of the entire facts
and circumstances of the case, it is found that there is a chequered history of
litigations between the parties against each other starting from the year 1998.
Initially an application was filed under Section 125 of the Code by the opposite
party no 2 for an order of maintenance was turned down.
The second
application was filed in the year 2001 and the Hon’ble Court while modifying
the amount kept open the issue of maintainability of the second petition under
Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which was never decided.
However, the amount of maintenance as granted by the learned Magistrate has
been complied with .According to him, he has paid Rs.2.2 lakh in excess of the
total amount and he made application for adjustment of such amount in the
execution petition which has not been entertained.
11.
It further transpires that the point raised by the learned Senior Advocate
questioning the legality of the order passed by the revisional court pertaining
to enhancement on the ground that the order was passed by the High Court
just before few months prior to that order and accordingly rightly refused to
pass further enhancement but this court differs from such approach in view
of the fact that the said revisional application was filed challenging the order
passed in October 2008 whereby the petitioner was directed to pay Rs.1500/1
2020 Supreme (SC) 541
per month to each of the parties and the order of the learned Co-ordinate
Bench was passed in the year 2016 ,modifying the quantum of maintenance
to Rs.1200/- per month plus Rs.800/- per month with effect from February
10, 2005. It is clear from the records that the order passed in March, 2013 in
connection with the 127 CrPC proceeding was not the subject matter before
the revisional court or before the High Court. Therefore, the observation by
the learned Magistrate not to enhance the amount in order to maintain the
judicial discipline was probably not the correct observation and therefore the
intervention by the learned revisional court warrant no further interference in
this regard. At the same time, it is seen that present petitioner retired from
service in the year 2004 and is a pension holder since 2004. The order of
revisional court glaringly
manifest that the learned court could not arrive at
the conclusion regarding the exact income of the present petitioner since he
did not produce the relevant documents in this regard but nothing could be
placed by any of the parties that the status of the petitioner is no longer
confined to a pension holder and he has other source of income.
12. The learned revisional court enhanced the amount from Rs.2000/- to
Rs.8000/- without assessing the income or without arriving at a just and
logical conclusion as to what prompted him to enhance such an amount to
that extent in absence of any materials to suggest the increase of income of the
petitioner. This court further cannot be oblivious to the fact that the amount of
maintenance was of Rs 1200 /- is really a meager amount and in the present
market condition is difficult for
sustenance . Hence in such circumstances
this Court is also of the view that the order passed by the revisional court
warrant interference.
13. With regard to the point raised regarding the entitlement of the daughter to
claim maintenance after attaining majority, the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court passed in Abhilasa vs Prakash (supra) as relied upon by the
opposite party no.2
be look into. The Hon’ble Supreme court also discussed
the scheme of 125 Cr.P.C as well as the Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act
and held that the scope of the scheme under the Hindu Adoption and
Maintenance Act is wider than the scope of 125 Cr.P.C.
Therefore, an
unmarried major daughter is not entitled to claim the maintenance in a
proceeding filed under Section 125 of the Code.
14.
Hence the issue is set at rest that a major and unmarried daughter is not
entitled to ask for maintenance in a proceeding under Section 125 Cr.P.C .
Therefore considering the entire facts and circumstances this Court is of the
view that in order to assess the exact amount to be enhanced, the income of
the husband must be assessed on the basis of the document to be furnished
by him before the learned Magistrate. The purpose of granting maintenance is
not to penalize the husband but to make arrangement to the wife for her
sustenance with dignity and status very similar to the status of the husband.
The petitioner is an ex-serviceman a pension holder since 2004. However no
pension paper was produced by him before the learned Magistrate which
otherwise draws an adverse inference against his bona fide to maintain his
family and hence a further opportunity is given to the petitioner to produce the
relevant document to show his current income.
15.
Therefore this court after giving an anxious consideration is of the view that
the amount of rs 1200/- is required to be to be enhanced but not to the extent
of Rs 8000/- and hence the order passed by the learned Revisional court is to
be modified.
16. Accordingly this criminal revisional application stands allowed .The order
passed by the revisional court is set aside so far the amount of maintenance
granted in favour of the daughter and the order is modified so far the amount
granted in favour of the wife to Rs 2500/- from Rs 4000/-.
17. The learned Magistrate is directed to assess the quantum of maintenance
afresh considering the income of both the parties after giving them an
opportunity of hearing.
18.
The petitioner is directed to pay an amount
of Rs.2500/- per month to the
wife per month in the interregnum period till such assessment is made and
such amount will be paid with effect from February 19, 2020. No further
amount is required to be paid towards the maintenance of daughter who has
attained majority in the year 2004.The arrear amount accumulated if any to be
paid in 6 equal instalments from this date .The current amount should be paid
within 7th of each month and in default of payment of such amount the wife
shall proceed with the execution case.
19. It is further made clear that there will be no adjustment to the amount
already paid by the petitioner towards the maintenance of his daughter
pursuant to the direction of the co-ordinate Bench till February 19, 2020 and
the petitioner will clear the amount if any accumulated towards maintenance
of the daughter pursuant to the direction passed by the co-ordinate Bench till
February 19, 2020.
20. Urgent Photostat certified copies of this order, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties upon compliance of all necessary formalities.
[CHAITALI CHATTERJEE (DAS), J.]
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review