Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Rai Chattopadhyay
WPA 26678 of 2014
Suvra Banerjee
Vs.
State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Biswarup Ray
: Mr. Gazi Faruque Hossain
: Ms. Varsha Roy
For the State
: Mr. Pinaki Bhattacharyya
: Mr. Kaustav Chatterjee
For the WBCSSC
: Dr. Sutanu Kumar Patra
: Ms. Supriya Dubey
For the respondent No. 6
: Mr. Shuvanil Chakraborty
: Ms. Chandana Ghosh
Judgment on
Uploaded on
: 10.06.2026
: 10.06.2026
Rai Chattopadhyay, J. :1)
The writ petitioner has challenged in this case an order passed
by the Secretary, West Bengal Central School Service
Commission [herein after referred to a “the WBCSSC”], dated
July 1, 2014 and sought for setting aside of the same. Her
other prayer is to direct the respondent to recommend her
name for appointment to the post of assistant teacher in
computer application, in Honours/Post Graduate category,
pursuant to her result in 12th Regional Level Selection Test
[herein after referred to as “12th RLST] conducted by the
WBCSSC for Southern Region.
2)
The petitioner has stated inter alia that she applied and
appeared in 12th RLST held on July 29, 2012. In the relevant
subject, that is „Computer Application‟, there were 8 vacant
posts for the general category candidates amongst which 2
were reserved for the female candidates. The petitioner has
stated that in the vacancy notification nothing was mentioned
with regard to reservation for „in service‟ candidates, that is,
for the temporary teachers.
3)
After being qualified in the written examination, the petitioner
was called for to take part in the „Personality Test‟, which she
has attended on September 4, 2013.
4)
Thereafter a „Combined Merit List‟ of subject „Computer
Application‟ for Southern Region was published, in which the
writ petitioner was placed at 12th position. Her grievance is
that in spite of her position in the „Combined Merit List‟, which
evidently showed that she should be within the zone of
consideration, for being recommended for appointment, she
has never been called for counselling. Instead, the person at
17th position in the „Combined Merit List‟, that is the added
respondent No.6 in this writ petition, who was a general
category/untrained/in-service temporary teacher, has been
called for counselling and ultimately has been recommended
by the Commission for appointment, allegedly superseding the
writ petitioner.
5)
The first writ petition of the present petitioner followed
thereafter, being W.P. No. 822 (w) of 2014, in which the Court
has directed the Secretary, WBCSSC, vide the order dated May
7, 2014, to consider the petitioner‟s grievance and pass a
reasoned order. The resultant order is that dated July 1, 2014,
which is impugned in the instant writ petition.
6)
In the said impugned order dated July 1, 2014, the Secretary,
WBCSSC/respondent No.3 has held inter alia that the
„Combined Merit List‟ is not the „panel‟ of successful
candidates for appointment and place of a candidate in the
„Combined Merit List‟ is not the determining factor for
empanelment, counselling and recommendation; it has held
that empanelment depends on gender and medium wise
number and category of vacancies, as provided under the West
Bengal School Service Commission (Selection of Persons for
Appointment to the Post of Teachers) Rules 2007 as amended
in 2011; it has been further held that reservation of post was
made for „ in service‟ temporary teachers following the
Government notifications published from time to time, over
and above reservation allotted for the SC, ST, OBC-A, OBC-B
and PH category candidates; that recommendation of a male
candidate at a girl‟s school was prohibited. That, following all
paraphernalia as provided in 2007 Rules (amended in 2011),
the „panel‟ has been prepared strictly in order of merit; the
respondent has mentioned in the said impugned order that
candidates are recommended from the „panel‟ and not from the
„Combined Merit List‟. Hence it is stated that the petitioner‟s
allegation is due to her misconception.
7)
So far as the petitioner‟s position in the „Combined Merit List‟
is concerned the said respondent has mentioned in the
impugned order that she is a general, Honours/Post Graduate
category candidate in subject “Computer Application”, for
Bengali medium school. In that segment candidates only up to
7th position in the „Combined Merit List‟ have been called for
counselling and not beyond. Therefore, allegation of
supersession of the petitioner by any candidate in the segment
ranked bellow her, has been denied by the respondent
authority.
8)
In the impugned order the respondent has further mentioned
that in 12th RLST when both the empaneled and wait listed
candidates are exhausted, then only the candidates in the
„Combined Merit List‟, placed bellow them have been called for
counselling, strictly in order of merit; that, trained candidates
have been called for counselling first and after exhaustion of
the trained candidates the untrained candidates have been
called for counselling; that in preparation of panel 100 point
roaster has been duly followed.
9)
The respondent authority has stated in the impugned order
that the respondent No.6 has been called for counselling and
subsequently appointed in a reserved category seat as she has
been an „in service‟ temporary teacher; therefore she belonged
to a different category altogether from that of the present
petitioner; hence she cannot be stated to have superseded the
writ petitioner in any way.
10) In this way the respondent authority has addressed grievance
of the writ petitioner, in the said impugned order.
11) Mr. Biswarup Ray, learned advocate has represented the
petitioner. The argument put forth by him for the petitioner
inter alia is that the impugned order dated July 1, 2014, is a
result of non-application of mind by the respondent authority
and the same is only a mechanical order. That, instead the
respondent authority should have considered the inherent
illegality and arbitrariness in its action to discriminate and
deprive the petitioner from her legitimate claim of being called
for counselling and being appointed, in view of her position in
the merit list. It is submitted that as per the vacancy
notification there was no other reservation, than reservation of
two posts for the female candidates. Therefore, the reasons
shown by the respondent authority in the said impugned order
should be considered as unsustainable being baseless and
unfounded. That the respondent ought to have considered that
the petitioner being the female candidate of general category
has been the second amongst the female candidates in the
„Combined Merit List‟ and thus was entitled to be called for
counselling.
12) It is submitted that appointment of the respondent No.6 is bad
in law in so far as she is not a candidate qualified in terms of
the vacancy notification and her position in the „Combined
Merit List‟. The entire process of appointment has been
challenged stating the same to be incoherent, irrational and
not in accordance with the law. The petitioner has also alleged
that the acts of the respondent authority in declining her
prayer to take part in counselling on the basis of her position
in the „Combined Merit List‟ and in view of the vacancy
notification particularly the reservation of posts mentioned
therein, has been improper, arbitrary, discriminatory, unfair
and unreasonable apart from being grossly illegal.
13) The respondent WBCSSC has been represented by Dr. Sutanu
Kumar Patra, learned advocate. He has made arguments
largely supporting the reasons shown in the said impugned
order. The facts of the case as stated by the writ petitioners are
all admitted in this case. Mr. Patra has denied the petitioner‟s
allegation that she has been illegally superseded by a
candidate of lower rank than her in the „Combined Merit List‟.
He submits that on the basis of the „Combined Merit List‟, the
„panel‟ has been prepared taking care of and giving effect to the
gender and medium wise number and category of vacancies,
including reservation of post to be secured as per the
Government notifications published time to time. For that
matter, in the petitioner‟s segment, the candidates up to 7th
position in the „Combined Merit List‟ has been called for
counselling and not beyond. Hence, he submits that the entire
allegation of the petitioner is misconceived and baseless.
14) He further submits that appointment of respondent No.6 is as
against the reserved category of post for the subject, allotted
for „in service‟ temporary teachers. That the petitioner
belonging to different category altogether, has erroneously
perceived discrimination allegedly made against her, where the
respondent was duty bound to give effect to the Government
notification for reservation of post for „ in service‟ temporary
teachers.
15) In this regard he has pointed out to page 25 of the writ
petition, which is a document of the respondent authority to
rely on the following noted there:
“Note: 10% of the Additional Vacancy is reserved for
Inservice (Temporary) Teachers”.
16) The added respondent No.6, represented by Mr. Shuvranil
Chakraborty, learned advocate has emphasized as to how the
additional posts created by the notification of the School
Education Department, are considered to be included amongst
the vacant posts declared by the respondent authority. In this
regard learned advocate has relied on notification No. 1584SE(S)/1A-01/09(Pt) dated December 21, 2011.
17) Another notification No. 1585-SE(S)/ES/S/1S-26/2010(Part)
dated December 21, 2011, has also been referred to by the
respondent No.6 and the following portion thereof to suggest
as to how her candidature has been rightly and properly
considered by the respondent authority, in terms of the
notification;
“Note 3.— Only those Candidates serving as Part-Time
Teacher/Para-Teacher/Contractual-Teacher/ Assistant Teacher
duly approved by the competent authority (by whatever name
known) in any Junior High/High School/Higher Secondary School
recognized by the West Bengal Council of Higher Secondary
Education, West Bengal Board of Secondary Education or
equivalent
or
a
Samprasarak/Samprasarika/Mukhya
Samprasarak/Samprasarika in MSK or Shikha Mitra in Rabindra
Mukta Vidyalaya or a Special Educator under PBSSM will be
eligible to get the facility as laid down in item no. (ii) of Section C
of Part C of Schedule II of the said rules provided that, the
candidate has to continue his/her service till the date of
application. The marks in this clause to be calculated as per
his/her experience in continuous service on the last date for
his/her application against the advertisement for the selection of
Assistant Teacher by the School Service Commission of that
respective year. Final recommendation will be issued by the
concerned Regional School Service Commission subject to the
verification from the District Inspector of Schools or DPO or DP &
RDO or DNO or any other competent authority concerned. Any
adverse report from the District Inspector of Schools (SE)
concerned must be liable to the cancellation of his/her
candidature at that point of time.”
18) The respondent authority and the respondent No.6 are ad-
idem to state that the declared vacancy included the additional
posts created vide the notification No. 1584-SE(S)/1A01/09(Pt) dated December 21, 2011. And also that 10%
thereof would be considered as reserved for „ in service‟
temporary teachers as per the notification No. 1585SE(S)/ES/S/1S-26/2010(Part) dated December 21, 2011. In
this regard they have urged that the contention of the writ
petitioner that “10% Additional Posts” mentioned in the
document of the respondent authority at page.25 of the writ
petition, have to be additional posts created if any, during the
selection process and not otherwise, may be discarded as not
maintainable.
19) Having heard the learned advocates for the parties and upon
consideration of the materials placed on record, this Court
finds that the central controversy in the present writ petition
revolves around the true import and effect of Notification No.
1585-SE(S)/ES/S/1S-26/2010(Part) dated December 21, 2011
and whether the vacancies declared in the selection process
were to be construed as inclusive of the additional posts
created under Notification No. 1584-SE(S)/1A-01/09(Pt) dated
December 21, 2011. The ancillary issue is whether 10%
reservation for in-service temporary teachers was liable to be
carved out from such declared vacancies.
20) The petitioner has stated that the vacancy position disclosed in
the recruitment notification was exhaustive and immutable
and that no reservation for in-service temporary teachers could
have been applied in absence of express specification in the
vacancy notification itself. Such contention, however,
overlooks the statutory and administrative framework
governing the selection process conducted by the West Bengal
Central School Service Commission. The recruitment process
cannot be viewed in isolation from the Government
notifications operating in the field at the relevant point of time,
particularly when such notifications form part of the governing
policy regulating the mode and manner of preparation of panel
and reservation of vacancies.
21) It appears from the materials on record that Notification No.
1584 dated December 21, 2011 created additional posts in the
concerned category. Simultaneously, Notification No. 1585
dated December 21, 2011 specifically provided that 10% of the
additional vacancies would stand reserved for in-service
temporary teachers. The expression “Additional Vacancy”
appearing in the note relied upon by the respondents cannot
be interpreted in the narrow and restrictive manner, sought to
be advanced by the writ petitioner, so as to confine its
meaning
only
to
vacancies
arising
subsequent
to
commencement of the selection process. Such interpretation
would defeat the very object of the policy decision embodied in
Notification No. 1585.
22) The language employed in the notifications, read harmoniously
and purposively, unmistakably demonstrates that the
additional posts created under Notification No. 1584 became
part of the total vacancy strength available for recruitment and
consequently attracted the reservation contemplated under
Notification No. 1585. Once the newly created posts stood
integrated with the declared vacancy structure for the purpose
of recruitment, reservation of 10% thereof for in-service
temporary teachers became a mandatory consequence flowing
from the Government policy itself. The respondent authorities,
therefore, cannot be faulted for treating the declared vacancies
as inclusive of the posts created under Notification No. 1584
and thereafter earmarking 10% thereof for in-service
temporary teachers.
23) This Court also finds substance in the contention of the
respondent authorities that the “Combined Merit List” by itself
does not confer an indefeasible or vested right to appointment.
The combined merit position merely determines inter se merit
amongst candidates, whereas the actual preparation of panel
and recommendation necessarily depend upon several
statutory variables including category-wise reservation,
gender-wise distribution, medium-wise allocation and other
reservations mandated by Government notifications. The
petitioner‟s reliance solely upon her position in the “Combined
Merit List”, therefore, is misplaced.
24) The materials on record further disclose that respondent no.6
belonged to the category of in-service temporary teachers and
her candidature was considered against a reserved vacancy
earmarked for such category pursuant to Notification No.
1585. The petitioner admittedly did not belong to such
reserved category. Consequently, comparison between the
petitioner and respondent no.6 is legally impermissible and
impossible too, as candidates belonging to distinct reservation
categories cannot claim parity for the purpose of appointment
against posts considered to be reserved for the „ in service‟
temporary teachers. The concept of equality enshrined under
Article 14 of the Constitution is one of equals being treated
equally and not unequals being treated alike. Once the State
creates a valid classification founded upon intelligible
differentia and having nexus with the object sought to be
achieved, candidates falling outside such classification cannot
complain of hostile discrimination. The reservation extended in
favour of in-service temporary teachers was based upon a
conscious policy decision of the Government and the same
cannot be diluted merely because a candidate of another
category secured higher position in the combined merit list.
Merit has to operate within the framework of the applicable
reservation policy and cannot override a legally sanctioned
classification. Therefore, the petitioner‟s allegation of
supersession by respondent no.6 is misconceived both on facts
and in law.
25) The
Courts are required to construe administrative
notifications in a manner which advances the object sought to
be achieved rather than frustrates the same by adopting an
unduly literal or restrictive interpretation, hence, purposive
interpretation is the key and also supports the stand of the
respondent authority. Notification No. 1585 was evidently
issued to extend limited protective reservation to in-service
temporary teachers in respect of the additional posts created
by the Government. The construction suggested by the
petitioner would render the notification otiose and ineffective,
which is impermissible in law. A statutory or administrative
instrument must be read in a manner so as to give meaningful
effect to every part thereof and not in a manner which would
make any portion redundant or unworkable. The
interpretation advanced by the respondents, therefore,
preserves the efficacy and operational intent of both
Notifications No. 1584 and 1585 and harmonises them within
the recruitment framework.
26) It is equally well settled that judicial review in matters of
selection and recruitment is confined to examining illegality,
arbitrariness, mala fide or procedural impropriety. The Court
does not sit as an appellate authority over administrative
decisions taken in accordance with applicable rules and policy
notifications. Unless the action of the authority is shown to be
patently contrary to law or actuated by arbitrariness,
interference under Article 226 of the Constitution is
unwarranted.
27) In the present case, this Court does not find any manifest
illegality in the action of the respondent authorities in treating
the declared vacancies as inclusive of the newly created posts
under Notification No. 1584 and thereafter reserving 10%
thereof for in-service temporary teachers in terms of
Notification No. 1585. The impugned order dated July 1, 2014
reflects due consideration of the petitioner‟s grievance and
discloses cogent reasons in support of the decision arrived at
therein. The petitioner has failed to establish violation of any
statutory provision or infringement of any enforceable legal
right.
28) For the reasons aforesaid and applying the doctrinal principles
governing
purposive
interpretation
of
administrative
notifications, limited scope of judicial review in recruitment
matters, and the settled principle that inclusion in a merit list
does not create an indefeasible right to appointment, this
Court finds no merit in the writ petition.
29) Accordingly, the writ petition stands dismissed. The impugned
order dated July 1, 2014 passed by the Secretary, West Bengal
Central School Service Commission is affirmed. There shall,
however, be no order as to costs.
30) Urgent certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance with all requisite
formalities.
(Rai Chattopadhyay, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review