Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27354
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE JOBIN SEBASTIAN
FRIDAY, THE 28TH DAY OF MARCH 2025/7TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MACA NO.3012 OF 2018
AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED IN OPMV NO.804 OF 2014
OF ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT & SESSIONS COURT - VIII, ERNAKULAM
/IV ADDITIONAL MACT, ERNAKULAM
APPELLANTS/PETITIONERS
SUSY SCARIA,
AGED 68 YEARS,
EDAYANAL HOUSE, PAZHAMTHOTTAM P.O,
PAZHAMTHOTTAM, ERNAKULAM
SHINEY IVAN,
AGED 50 YEARS,
W/O.IVAN, (D/O.SKARIA), THEKKUMMATTATHIL,
ARAKKUNAM, NEAR MULANTHURITHY ERNAKULAM DIST.
SHEENA BIJU,
AGED 45 YEARS,
W/O.BIJU, (D/O.SKARIA), MATTAMANA HOUSE,
KALOOR, ERNAKULAM.
SHINJU,
AGED 41 YEARS,
S/O.SKARIA, EDAYANAL HOUSE, PAZHAMTHOTTOM,
PAZHAMTHOTTOM.P.O., ERNAKULAM.
BY ADV PAUL K.VARGHESE
RESPONDENT/2ND RESPONDENT
THE MANAGER, NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY
KOLENCHERY(POLICY NO. 570802/31/11/6700009708).
ERNAKULAM - 682311.
2025:KER:27354
M.A.C.A No.3012 of 2018
BY ADV SRI.N.S.NAJEEB
THIS MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY
HEARD ON 28.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:27354
M.A.C.A No.3012 of 2018
JUDGMENT
The petitioners in O.P.(M.V.) No. 804 of 2014 on the
file of the
Additional Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal,
Ernakulam have preferred this appeal seeking enhancement
of compensation awarded by the Tribunal on account of the
death of Skaria E.V, who died in a motor accident that
occurred on 09.09.2012.
2.
The case of the petitioners in brief is as
follows:On 09.09.2012, at 2.45 p.m., while Skaria, the
deceased in this case was riding a motorcycle bearing
registration
No.KL-7-AM-223
through
Pazhamthottam
-
Pulinchodu public road, a tempo tracks bearing registration
No. KL-8-AC-1661, driven by the 1 st respondent in a rash
and negligent manner and going ahead of the motor cycle
driven by Skaria, suddenly stopped and took reverse
without giving any signal and the backside of the tempo
track hit on the front side of the motorcycle ridden by
Skaria.
Due to the impact of the hit, Skaria fell on to the
2025:KER:27354
M.A.C.A No.3012 of 2018
road causing severe injuries.
Immediately after the
incident, though the injured was rushed to the hospital, due
to the serious nature of the injuries sustained in the
accident, he died on 25.06.2013.
3. The owner cum driver of the offending tempo
track vehicle was arrayed as 1st respondent, whereas, the
insurer of the said vehicle was arrayed as 2nd respondent.
The 2nd respondent contested the petition by filing a written
statement mainly disputing the quantum of compensation
claimed.
4.
During trial, from the side of the Petitioners
Exts.A1 to A14 were marked.
No evidence, whatsoever,
was adduced from the side of the respondent.
5.
After trial, the tribunal came to the conclusion
that the accident occurred solely due to the rash and
negligent driving of the tempo track bearing registration No.
KL-8-AC-1661 by the 1st respondent and being the insurer
the 2nd respondent was held liable to pay the compensation.
The compensation was quantified as Rs. 12,84,000/- with
2025:KER:27354
M.A.C.A No.3012 of 2018
interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of
petition till realisation and proportionate costs.
Seeking
enhancement of the compensation awarded, the petitioners
have come up with this appeal.
6.
counsel
I heard Sri.Paul.K.Varghese, the learned
appearing
for
petitioners,
Sri.N.S.Najeeb,
the
learned counsel for the respondent.
7.
From
the
rival
contentions
raised,
it
is
gatherable that the main dispute that revolves around this
appeal is with respect to the quantum of compensation
awarded.
The learned counsel for the appellants would
submit that the compensation awarded by the tribunal
under various heads is too meager and is not sufficient to
compensate the loss suffered by the bereaved family of the
deceased.
According to the Counsel the tribunal erred in
assessing the income of the deceased reasonably and
awarded only a meager amount under the head loss of
dependency.
The counsel further pointed out that as the
injured died nine months after the accident the pain and
2025:KER:27354
M.A.C.A No.3012 of 2018
suffering endured by the deceased due to the accident
which continued till his death ought not to have been
overlooked by the tribunal while awarding the compensation
under the head of pain and sufferings.
Per contra, the
learned counsel for the respondent would submit that the
compensation awarded by the tribunal under various heads
is reasonable, just,
fair, and, adequate and warrants no
interference.
8.
A perusal of the award reveals that for the
purpose of determining the compensation under the head of
loss of dependency, the tribunal assessed the income of the
deceased at Rs.7,000/-.
Though, in the petition it was
stated that the deceased was a businessman at the time of
the accident and was earning a monthly income of
Rs.30,000/-, no evidence, whatsoever, was produced from
the side of the petitioners to substantiate their contentions
regarding the occupation and income of the deceased.
Nonetheless, admittedly, the accident occurred in the year
2015.
Therefore,
in
view
of
the
decision
in
2025:KER:27354
M.A.C.A No.3012 of 2018
Ramachandrappa
v.
Manager,
Royal
Sundaram
Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd. [2011 (13) SCC 236] the
tribunal ought to have assessed the monthly income of the
deceased at Rs. 8,500/-notionally. The deceased was aged
70 years at the time of the accident. The petitioners herein
are the wife, two daughters, and son of the deceased.
Admittedly, the children of the deceased are major and
were married also.
Therefore, they are not entitled to be
treated as dependents of the deceased eventually, they are
not entitled to get any amount as compensation under the
head loss of dependency. However, the 1 st petitioner being
the wife of the deceased is certainly entitled to get
compensation under the said head. As the total number of
dependents is only one, ½ of the income of the deceased
has to be deducted towards his personal expenses.
After
deducting the said amount income of the deceased can be
reasonably fixed at Rs.4,250/-. The deceased was aged 70
at the time of the accident and applying the principle laid
down in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation
2025:KER:27354
M.A.C.A No.3012 of 2018
[2010 (2) KLT 802 (SC)], the multiplier applicable is 5.
Hence, the 1st petitioner is entitled to get an amount of Rs.
2,55,000/- (Rs. 4,250/- x 12 x 5) as compensation under
the head of loss of dependency.
Already an amount of
Rs.2,10,000/- has been awarded by the tribunal under the
head of loss of dependency.
After deducting the said
amount, the 1st petitioner is entitled to get an amount of Rs.
45,000/- (Rupees Forty Thousand Five Hundred Only) as
additional compensation under the said head.
9.
Similarly, an amount of Rs.40,000/- has been
awarded by the tribunal as compensation under the loss of
consortium in favour of the 1st Petitioner. Obviously, the 1st
Petitioner being the wife of the deceased she is certainly
entitled to get compensation under the said head. However
in view of the decision in National Insurance Company
Ltd Vs Pranay Sethi [2017 (4) KLT 662 SC] the 1 st
petitioner is entitled to get an amount of Rs.48,000/- as
compensation under the head of loss of consortium.
Remaining petitioners being the children, their close relation
2025:KER:27354
M.A.C.A No.3012 of 2018
ship and bondage with the deceased will certainly entitle
them
to
get
consortium.
compensation
under
the
head
loss
of
Hence an amount of Rs.48,000/- each is to be
awarded as compensation under the head of loss of
consortium in favour of petitioners 2 to 4.
Hence the
petitioners are entitled to get an amount of Rs.1,52,000/as additional compensation under the said head.
As a
reasonable amount is awarded under the head of loss of
consortium the petitioners are not entitled to get any
amount as compensation under the head of loss of love and
affection. Therefore the amount of Rs.50,000/- awarded by
the tribunal under the head of loss of love and affection is
to be deducted from the total compensation awarded.
10.
Admittedly, the accident occurred on
09.09.2012. As evident from the records, immediately after
the accident the injured was taken to a hospital and he had
undergone 180 days of impatient treatment.
sustained the following injuries in the accident.
Left Fronto Temporo Parietal A/C SDH;
Left Temporal Contusion;
He had
2025:KER:27354
M.A.C.A No.3012 of 2018
Left Temporal Bone Fracture;
Left Subcondylar Mandible Fracture;
Right Temporo Parietal Bone Gracture;
Extradural Abscess;
Left Temporal ICH.
11.
The treatment records further reveal that he
underwent five major surgeries as part of the treatment.
The pain and sufferings endured by the deceased due to the
injuries and the treatment procedures underwent by him
cannot be overlooked while awarding compensation under
the head of pain and suffering. Furthermore, this is not a
case of instantaneous death. The injured died nine months
after the accident.
Evidently, he was in a vegetative state
and was totally bedridden after the accident, till his death.
The said fact must certainly be taken note of while awarding
compensation under the head of pain and sufferings. I am
of the view that an amount of Rs.1,00,000/- is to be
awarded under the said head as well. Already an amount of
Rs.25,000/- has been awarded by the tribunal under the
head of pain and sufferings.
After deducting the said
amount, the petitioners are entitled to get an amount of
2025:KER:27354
M.A.C.A No.3012 of 2018
Rs.75,000/-(Rupees
Seventy
Five
Thousand
Only)
as
additional compensation under the said head.
12.
As I have already mentioned, this was not a case
of instantaneous death. The injured survived nine months
after the accident with serious injuries. He became totally a
bed-bound man after the accident.
Therefore the loss of
amenities and enjoyment of life
cannot be undermined
while awarding compensation. I am of the view that, an
amount of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees Twenty Five Thousand
Only) is to be awarded under the head of loss of amenities
and enjoyment of life.
13.
Therefore, an amount of Rs.2,65,000/-
(Rs.45,000/-+ Rs.1,20,000/- + Rs.75,000/- + Rs.25,000/-)
need to be added to, and an amount of Rs. 50,000/- is to
be deducted from the total compensation awarded by the
tribunal.
In the light of the aforesaid observations and findings,
the appeal is allowed by enhancing the compensation by a
further amount of Rs.2,47,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Forty
2025:KER:27354
M.A.C.A No.3012 of 2018
Seven Thousand Only) with interest at the rate of 7.5% per
annum on the enhanced compensation from the date of
claim petition till the date of deposit. The respondent
insurance company is ordered to deposit the enhanced
compensation
with
interest
before
the
tribunal
with
proportionate costs within a period of three months from
the date of receipt of the certified copy of this judgment.
Sd/JOBIN SEBASTIAN
JUDGE
Cak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review