The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
09. In view of the above, the appellant is granted six months' time to vacate the shop in question. He is directed to give an undertaking in 2:28:50 PM -6- writing before this Court as well as executing Court that he will vacate the shop within six months from today, failing which the plaintiff shall be entitled for rent @ Rs.4,000/- per month from today till the executing Court passes the order for possession.
10. With the aforesaid observation, Second Appeal stands dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 19th OF JANUARY, 2024
SECOND APPEAL No. 2261 of 2022
BETWEEN:SUSHIL KUMAR SHARMA, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
DOCTOR 49, NITYANAND MARKET SHAHAR SARAI SHOPPING
COMPLEX DISTRICT RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI ARJUN AGRAWAL, ADVOCATE)
AND
YAMINI SHARMA W/O SUNIL KUMAR SHARMA, AGED ABOUT 37
YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOUSEWIFE 4 RAJIV NAGAR RATLAM (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI MOHAMMED IMRAN KHAN, ADVOCATE ON CAVEAT)
This appeal coming on for admission this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
The appellant / defendant has filed this Second Appeal under
Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 against (i) judgment
dated 17.10.2019 passed First Civil Judge, Class – I, Ratlam in Civil
Suit No.22-A/2018, whereby decree of eviction has been passed in
favour of plaintiff and (ii) judgment dated 22.08.2022 passed by the III
Additional District Judge, Ratlam in RCA No.78/2019, whereby the first
appeal filed by the defendant has been dismissed.
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
2:28:50 PM
02.
Facts of the case in short are as under:-
2.1.
The plaintiff being an owner of Shop No.50, Sarai Shopping
-2-
Complex, Nityanand Market, Ratlam filed a suit for eviction and
Rs.4,000/- per month as mesne profit. The plaintiff is the wife of late
Sunil Kumar Sharma, who was elder brother of defendant – Sushil
Kumar Sharma. Late Sunil Kumar Sharma purchased the aforesaid shop
in question vide registered sale deed dated 18.02.2005. The area of the
shop is 14.6 ft. x 8.6 ft. total area 123.25 sq. ft. After the death of her
husband, the plaintiff by way of oral permission given to the defendant
to run the shop on rent. The husband of the plaintiff was a Homeopathy
Doctor and furniture and medicines kept in the shop were given to the
defendant as he is brother-in-law (devar) of her.
2.2.
The plaintiff further pleaded that after the death of her husband,
she was tortured by the defendant and compelled to leave the house
along with two daughters. She came to the house of her father, therefore,
the shop is required for better future of her daughters. When the
defendant did not hand over the possession, she served a notice dated
15.09.2017 which was received by the defendant 23.09.2017. By the
said notice, the tenancy was terminated, hence, she filed a suit for
ejectment.
2.3.
The defendant filed a written statement denying the allegation
made in the plaint. It is further pleaded that father of the defendant was
famous Nadi Vaidya and both of his sons i.e. plaintiff's husband and
defendant used to work in the said medicine shop and lived as joint
family. The suit shop was purchased from the income of the joint family.
Since Sunil Kumar Sharma was elder brother, therefore, shop was
purchased in his name. Hence, the plaintiff is not the exclusive owner of
the shop in question and the defendant being a co-owner is entitled to
retain the possession not as tenant / licensee.
2.4.
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
2:28:50 PM
The learned trial Court framed ten issues for adjudication,
-3-
thereafter, evidences were recorded. Learned trial Court answered the
issue No.1 that the husband of the plaintiff was not the absolute owner
but he purchased the leasehold right. Issue No.2 has been found proved
as the plaintiff gave shop to the defendant for his business. Likewise
issues No.3 & 4 have been answered in favour of the plaintiff. However,
she has been denied the mesne profit. Vide judgment dated 17.10.2019,
the suit has been decreed in favour of the plaintiff by directing the
defendant to handover the vacant possession within one month and
dismissed for the mesne profit.
2.5.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and decree, the
defendant filed first appeal before the District Judge and vide judgment
dated 22.08.2022, the District Judge has dismissed the appeal. Learned
District Judge has held that the defendant has not given any evidence to
show that he was jointly working with late Sunil Kumar Sharma in the
said shop. He has not filed any registration certificate of the shop and
the plaintiff is in the bonafide need of shop. By considering the
aforesaid, the judgment and decree dated 17.10.2019 passed by the Civil
Court has been affirmed. Hence, this second appeal is before this Court.
03.
Shri Agrawal, learned counsel for the appellant submits that
both the Courts below have wrongly granted the decree of eviction. No
averments were made in the plaint and written statement regarding
benami properties and no issue was framed, therefore, the Courts below
could not have gone into the issue of transaction of transfer of shop
being benami. It is further submitted that the husband of the plaintiff and
defendant being real brother living in the joint family. The shop in
question was purchased from the income of the joint family, therefore,
the plaintiff cannot be said to be an exclusive owner of the shop to seek
eviction of the defendant who is not the tenant in the said shop. Learned
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
2:28:50 PM
-4-
counsel for the appellant has suggested following substantial questions
of law:I. Whether the learned courts below erred in holding that
the provisions of Section 2(9) of the Act of 2016 are only
prospective in nature ignoring the fact that the said provision
is in the form of beneficial legislation taking within its sweep
certain transaction done by a karta or joint hindu family not
to be benami ?
II. Whether the learned courts below have committed
serious error of law by going into the question of the
applicable court fees being fixed or ad-valorem ignoring the
fact that the main relied of mandatory injunction and
possession was never valued by the plaintiff and no court fees
was paid for such relief contrary to Section 17 of the Court
Fees Act ?
III. Whether the learned courts below erred in concluding
that the property belong tot eh deceased husband of this
plaintiff ignoring the contemporaneous evidence showing that
the entire income of family was joint in nature and no
evidence was given by the plaintiff to show that the shop was
purchased out of individual income of plaintiff's husband ?
IV. Whether the learned courts below committed a serious
error of law by dwelling into the issue of benami transaction
even though it was nobody's case that the shop no.50 was
purchased by a benami transaction and no issue was framed
on the question of transaction being benami ?
V. Whether the courts below erred in deciding the issue of
non-joinder of necessary parties as it is clear from the
statements of plaintiff herself that the joint family had
common source of income and shop was purchased out of the
common funds and therefore, all the members of joint hindu
family were necessary parties ?
VI. Whether the courts below erred in holding that the Act of
2016 would not apply to the present case even though the suit
has been filed after the amendment of 2016 ?
04.
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
2:28:50 PM
It is not in dispute that lease hold rights of the shop in question
-5-
was purchased by husband of the plaintiff by registered sale deed. The
defendant came up with the plea that the shop was purchased from the
income of joint family income but no document has been filed to
establish that there was a joint business of plaintiff's husband and the
defendant. No account, balance-sheet, audit reports, registration
certificate of firm or company have been filed before the trial Court to
establish that there was a joint family business running in the said shop
and husband of plaintiff purchased the shop from joint income of the
family, thus, he has failed to discharge the burden.
05.
The defendant entered into the witness box as D.W-2. He has
admitted that in the registered deed, there is no mention of name of
other family member. Had there been any right of the defendant in the
suit property same would have been mentioned in the sale deed. He has
also admitted that no document has been filed that the shop was
purchased from the joint income of the family. The defendant has
already purchased the neighbouring shop from his own income and
dismantle the wall between two shops. Therefore, two shops were
purchased, one by husband of the plaintiff and another by defendant.
06.
Both the Courts below have recorded the concurrent finding in
favour of the plaintiff, therefore, I do not find any question of law
involved in this second appeal and the same is liable to be dismissed.
07.
At this stage, Shri Arjun Agrawal, learned counsel for the
appellant submits that the appellant be given six months' time to vacate
the shop in question.
08.
Learned counsel for the respondent has no objection to the
aforesaid prayer.
09.
In view of the above, the appellant is granted six months' time to
vacate the shop in question. He is directed to give an undertaking in
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
2:28:50 PM
-6-
writing before this Court as well as executing Court that he will vacate
the shop within six months from today, failing which the plaintiff shall
be entitled for rent @ Rs.4,000/- per month from today till the executing
Court passes the order for possession.
10.
With the aforesaid observation, Second Appeal stands
dismissed.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Ravi
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/24/2024
2:28:50 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review