Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Calcutta High Court
28.09.2026
Item No.55
Court No.30
g.b.
Criminal Revisional Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
CRR 5121 of 2024
Sushanta @ Susanta Naskar.
Vs.
State of West Bengal & Anr.
Mr. Sekhar Kumar Basu, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Ranadeb Sengupta
Mr. Sachin Talukdar
….For the Petitioner
Mr. Amartya Ghose
Mr. P. Dan
….For the State
1.
The petitioner has challenged the proceeding being
G.R. No. 1463 of 2024 arising out of Sonarpur Police
Station Case No. 232/2024 dated 27.02.2024 under
Sections 498A/323/379/34 of the Indian Penal Code
initiated by the opposite party No. 2 on the basis of a
petition of complaint under Section 156(3) of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973 primarily on the grounds
that on the basis of self-same allegations a prior
proceeding had already been initiated at the behest of
the opposite party No. 2 and that the impugned
proceeding is a counter blast to a proceeding initiated
much prior by the petitioner against the opposite
party No. 2.
2.
The petitioner further denies the factum of marriage
with the opposite party No. 2 and it is his specific case
that the opposite party No. 2 is not his legally wedded
wife.
3. On 09.08.2023 the petitioner initiated Sonarpur Police
Station Case No. 834 of 2023 under Sections 406, 34
of the Indian Penal Code for investigation against the
opposite party No. 2, Puspa Das (Mother of the
opposite party No. 2) and Netai Chandra Das (Father
of opposite party No. 2). Allegations in the complaint
were to the effect that the opposite party No. 2 along
with her family members duped and cheated the
petitioner to part with jewellery and furniture worth
lakhs of rupees on the pretext that the opposite party
No. 2 is an unmarried lady and that she intends to
marry the petitioner.
4. On 26.08.2023 Baruipur Police Station Case No. 1084
of 2023 under Sections 498A, 323, 406 of the Indian
Penal Code registered against the petitioner at the
behest of the opposite party No. 2. Allegations were to
the effect that subsequent to the marriage of the
petitioner with the opposite party No.2, she had been
subjected to both physical and mental torture. She
goes on to allege that on 21.08.2023 she had been
driven out from her rented accommodation and the
petitioner broke her household articles while leaving
with the articles mentioned in the written complaint.
She also alleged to have been strangulated by the
petitioner.
5. On 27.02.2024 Sonarpur Police Station Case No. 232
of 2024 dated 27.02.2024 on the basis of self same
allegations as above lodged by the opposite party No.
against
the
petitioner
and
others
alleging
commission of offences punishable under Sections
498A, 323, 379, 34 of the Indian Penal Code,
Allegations made were to the effect that the opposite
party No. 2 resided with the petitioner at an
accommodation rented out by the co-accused namely,
Jiban Sarkar. She goes on to allege that during her
stay at the aforementioned accommodation, apart
from the petitioner and his mother, the landlord as
aforesaid and his family members used to torture her.
6. She further alleges that the petitioner was involved in
an illicit relationship with the land lord's wife and
when she protested, she used to be beaten up. The
opposite party No. 2 further states that when she
along with her mother went to Sonarpur Police Station
to lodge a diary, the petitioner along with the land lord
locked her house and also stole all her belongings.
Upon confronting the land lord and his family
members, they allegedly abused her and asked her to
leave the premises. They purportedly also threatened
to kill her unless she complies with the same. She
goes on to allege that on 15.01.2024, while she was
residing with her mother, the accused came to her
residence and intimidated her since she had lodged a
case against them. Further, they allegedly caught hold
of her neck and when her mother attempted to rescue
her, they pushed her aside causing her to fall. In the
impugned First Information Report in addition to the
petitioner and his mother, the landlord and his family
members have also been roped in.
7. The petitioner states that the impugned proceeding is
a counter blast to the First Information Report lodged
first in time by the petitioner against the opposite
party
No.
and
her
family
for
cheating
misappropriation of jewellery and furniture.
8.
The
allegations
giving
rise
to
both
the
First
Information Report lodged by the opposite party No. 2
are one and the same. While in 1st First Information
Report only the petitioner had been arraigned as an
accused, in the impugned 2nd First Information
Report in addition to the petitioner, the landlord along
with his family members have also been arraigned as
an accused.
9. The State has placed the case diary.
10.
Section 498A of IPC, lays down:“498A. Husband or relative of husband of a
woman subjecting her to cruelty.—Whoever,
being the husband or the relative of the
husband of a woman, subjects such woman to
cruelty shall be punished with imprisonment for
a term which may extend to three years and
shall also be liable to fine.
Explanation.— For the purpose of this section,
“cruelty” means—
(a)any wilful conduct which is of such a nature
as is likely to drive the woman to commit
suicide or to cause grave injury or danger to life,
limb or health (whether mental or physical) of
the woman; or
(b)harassment of the woman where such
harassment is with a view to coercing her or
any person related to her to meet any unlawful
demand for any property or valuable security or
is on account of failure by her or any person
related to her to meet such demand.
Ingredients of offence. -The essential
ingredients of the offence under sec. 498A are
as follows:(1) A woman was married;
(2) She was subjected to cruelty;
(3) Such cruelty consisted in (i) any lawful conduct as was likely to drive
such woman to commit suicide or to cause
grave injury or danger to her life, limb or health
whether mental or physical;
(ii) harm to such woman with a view to coercing
her to meet unlawful demand for property or
valuable security or on account of failure of
such woman or any of her relations to meet the
lawful demand;
(iii) the woman was subjected to such cruelty by
her husband or any relation of her husband.”
11. In Dara Lakshmi Narayana & Ors. vs State of
Telangana & Anr., in Criminal Appeal No. …………
of 2024 (arising out of SLP (Criminal) No. 16239
of 2024, decided on December 10, 2024, the
Supreme Court held:-
“15. An offence is punishable under Section
498A of the IPC when a husband or his
relative subjects a woman to cruelty, which
may result in imprisonment for a term
extending up to three years and a fine. The
Explanation under Section 498A of the IPC
defines “cruelty” for the purpose of Section
498A of the IPC to mean any of the acts
mentioned in clauses (a) or (b). The first limb of
clause (a) of the Explanation of Section
498A of the IPC, states that “cruelty” means
any wilful conduct that is of such a nature as
is likely to drive the woman to commit suicide.
The second limb of clause (a) of the
Explanation of Section 498A of the IPC, states
that cruelty means any wilful conduct that is
of such a nature as to cause grave injury or
danger to life, limb or health (whether mental
or physical) of the woman. Further, clause (b)
of the Explanation of Section 498A of the IPC
states that cruelty would also include
harassment of the woman where such
harassment is to coerce her or any person
related to her to meet any unlawful demand
for any property or valuable security or is on
account of failure by her or any person related
to her to meet such demand.
16. Further, Section 3 of the Dowry Act deals
with penalty for giving or taking dowry. It
states that any person who engages in giving,
taking, or abetting the exchange of dowry,
shall face a punishment of imprisonment for a
minimum of five years and a fine of not less
than fifteen thousand rupees or the value of
the dowry, whichever is greater. Section 4 of
the Dowry Act talks of penalty for demanding
dowry. It states that any person demanding
dowry directly or indirectly, from the parents
or other relatives or guardians of a bride or
bridegroom
shall
be
punishable
with
imprisonment for a term which shall not be
less than six months, but which may extend to
two years and with fine which may extend to
ten thousand rupees.
18. A bare perusal of the FIR shows that the
allegations made by respondent No.2 are
vague and omnibus. Other than claiming that
appellant No.1 harassed her and that
appellant Nos.2 to 6 instigated him to do so,
respondent No.2 has not provided any specific
details or described any particular instance of
harassment. She has also not mentioned the
time, date, place, or manner in which the
alleged harassment occurred. Therefore, the
FIR lacks concrete and precise allegations.
25. A mere reference to the names of family
members in a criminal case arising out of a
matrimonial
dispute,
without
specific
allegations indicating their active involvement
should be nipped in the bud. It is a wellrecognised fact, borne out of judicial
experience, that there is often a tendency to
implicate all the members of the husband’s
family when domestic disputes arise out of a
matrimonial discord. Such generalised and
sweeping
accusations
unsupported
by
concrete evidence or particularised allegations
cannot form the basis for criminal prosecution.
Courts must exercise caution in such cases to
prevent misuse of legal provisions and the
legal process
and avoid unnecessary
harassment of innocent family members. In
the present case, appellant Nos.2 to 6, who
are the members of the family of appellant
No.1 have been living in different cities and
have not resided in the matrimonial house of
appellant No.1 and respondent No.2 herein.
Hence, they cannot be dragged into criminal
prosecution and the same would be an abuse
of the process of the law in the absence of
specific allegations made against each of
them.
28. The inclusion of Section 498A of the IPC
by way of an amendment was intended to
curb cruelty inflicted on a woman by her
husband and his family, ensuring swift
intervention by the State. However, in recent
years, as there have been a notable rise in
matrimonial disputes across the country,
accompanied by growing discord and tension
within
the
institution
of
marriage,
consequently, there has been a growing
tendency to misuse provisions like Section
498A of the IPC as a tool for unleashing
personal vendetta against the husband and
his family by a wife. Making vague and
generalised allegations during matrimonial
conflicts, if not scrutinized, will lead to the
misuse
of
legal
processes
and
an
encouragement for use of arm twisting tactics
by a wife and/or her family. Sometimes,
recourse is taken to invoke Section 498A of the
IPC against the husband and his family in
order
to
seek
compliance
with
the
unreasonable
demands
of
a
wife.
Consequently, this Court has, time and again,
cautioned against prosecuting the husband
and his family in the absence of a clear prima
facie case against them.
29. We are not, for a moment, stating that any
woman who has suffered cruelty in terms of
what has been contemplated under Section
498A of the IPC should remain silent and
forbear herself from making a complaint or
initiating any criminal proceeding. That is not
the intention of our aforesaid observations but
we should not encourage a case like as in the
present one, where as a counterblast to the
petition for dissolution of marriage sought by
the first appellant-husband of the second
respondent herein, a complaint under Section
498A of the IPC is lodged by the latter. In fact,
the insertion of the said provision is meant
mainly for the protection of a woman who is
subjected to cruelty in the matrimonial home
primarily due to an unlawful demand for any
property or valuable security in the form of
dowry. However, sometimes it is misused as
in the present case.
30. In the above context, this Court in G.V.
Rao vs. L.H.V. Prasad, (2000) 3 SCC 693
observed as follows:
“12. There has been an outburst of
matrimonial disputes in recent times. Marriage
is a sacred ceremony, the main purpose of
which is to enable the young couple to settle
down in life and live peacefully. But little
matrimonial skirmishes suddenly erupt which
often assume serious proportions resulting in
commission of heinous crimes in which elders
of the family are also involved with the result
that those who could have counselled and
brought about rapprochement are rendered
helpless on their being arrayed as accused in
the criminal case. There are many other
reasons which need not be mentioned here for
not encouraging matrimonial litigation so that
the parties may ponder over their defaults and
terminate their disputes amicably by mutual
agreement instead of fighting it out in a court
of law where it takes years and years to
conclude and in that process the parties lose
their “young” days in chasing their “cases” in
different courts.”
31. Further, this Court in Preeti Gupta vs.
State of Jharkhand (2010) 7 SCC 667 held
that the courts have to be extremely careful
and cautious in dealing with these complaints
and must take pragmatic realties into
consideration while dealing with matrimonial
cases. The allegations of harassment by the
husband’s close relatives who had been living
in different cities and never visited or rarely
visited the place where the complainant
resided would have an entirely different
complexion. The allegations of the complainant
are required to be scrutinized with great care
and circumspection.
32. We, therefore, are of the opinion that the
impugned FIR No.82 of 2022 filed by
respondent No.2 was initiated with ulterior
motives to settle personal scores and grudges
against appellant No.1 and his family
members i.e., appellant Nos.2 to 6 herein.
Hence, the present case at hand falls within
category (7) of illustrative parameters
highlighted in Bhajan Lal. Therefore, the High
Court, in the present case, erred in not
exercising the powers available to it
under Section 482 CrPC and thereby failed to
prevent abuse of the Court’s process by
continuing the criminal prosecution against the
appellants.”
12. In State of Haryana and Others v. Ch. Bhajan Lal
and Others, 1992 Supp. (1) 335, the Supreme Court
held:“102. In the backdrop of the interpretation of
the various relevant provisions of the Code
under Chapter XIV and of the principles of law
enunciated by this Court in a series of decisions
relating to the exercise of the extraordinary
power under Article 226 or the inherent powers
under Section 482 of the Code which we have
extracted and reproduced above, we give the
following categories of cases by way of
illustration wherein such power could be
exercised either to prevent abuse of the process
of any court or otherwise to secure the ends of
justice, though it may not be possible to lay
down any precise, clearly defined and
sufficiently
channelised
and
inflexible
guidelines or rigid formulae and to give an
exhaustive list of myriad kinds of cases wherein
such power should be exercised.
(1) Where the allegations made in the first
information report or the complaint, even if they
are taken at their face value and accepted in
their entirety do not prima facie constitute any
offence or make out a case against the accused.
(2) Where the allegations in the first information
report
and
other
materials,
if
any,
accompanying the FIR do not disclose a
cognizable offence, justifying an investigation
by police officers under Section 156(1) of the
Code except under an order of a Magistrate
within the purview of Section 155(2) of the
Code.
(3) Where the uncontroverted allegations made
in the FIR or complaint and the evidence
collected in support of the same do not disclose
the commission of any offence and make out a
case against the accused.
(4) Where, the allegations in the FIR do not
constitute a cognizable offence but constitute
only a non-cognizable offence, no investigation
is permitted by a police officer without an order
of a Magistrate as contemplated under Section
155(2) of the Code.
(5) Where the allegations made in the FIR or
complaint are so absurd and inherently
improbable on the basis of which no prudent
person can ever reach a just conclusion that
there is sufficient ground for proceeding against
the accused.
(6) Where there is an express legal bar
engrafted in any of the provisions of the Code or
the concerned Act (under which a criminal
proceeding is instituted) to the institution and
continuance of the proceedings and/or where
there is a specific provision in the Code or the
concerned Act, providing efficacious redress for
the grievance of the aggrieved party.
(7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly
attended with mala fide and/or where the
proceeding is maliciously instituted with an
ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on the
accused and with a view to spite him due to
private and personal grudge.”
13. The present case is thus clearly covered by the
guidelines in
State
of
Haryana
vs
Bhajanlal
(Supra) (Para 102).
14. Prima facie it also appears to be a family property
dispute, between the de facto complainant and her
husband
on
one
side
and
the
other
family
members (in laws) on the other.
15. The materials in the case diary in the present case
shows that the allegations are general in nature.
As such permitting the case to proceed against the
petitioner herein, will clearly be an abuse of the
process of law, considering that none of the
ingredients required to constitute the offences
alleged are present against the petitioner herein.
16. CRR 5121 of 2024 is thus allowed.
17. The proceeding being G.R. No. 1463 of 2024 arising
out of Sonarpur Police Station Case No. 232/2024
dated 27.02.2024 under Sections 498A/323/379/34
of the Indian Penal Code, is hereby quashed in
respect of the petitioner namely Sushanta @
Susanta Naskar.
18. All connected applications, if any, stands disposed of.
19. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
20. Copy of this judgment be sent to the learned Trial
Court for necessary compliance.
21. Urgent certified website copy of this judgment, if
applied for, be supplied expeditiously after complying
with all, necessary legal formalities.
(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review