Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
Surja Narayan Pradhan
S/o Late Kedar Nath Pradhan,
R/o 51A, Cart Road, Rose Bank,
P.O. and P.S. Darjeeling,
District Darjeeling-734101
West Bengal.
.....
Appellant
Versus
1.
Mrs. Jumden Lepcha,
W/o Shri O.T. Lepcha,
R/o Bhojoghari Fatak,
Below Denzong Gumpa,
Near SBI Bank, P.O. Bojoghari,
P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
Shri. O. T. Lepcha,
S/o Late Phintso Lepcha,
R/o Bhojoghari Fatak,
Below Denzong Gumpa,
Near SBI Bank, P.O. Bojoghari,
P.S. Gangtok, East Sikkim
….. Respondents
Appeal under Order XLI, Rule 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. J. B. Pradhan, Senior Advocate with Mr. Bhusan
Nepal, Mr. D.K. Siwakoti and Ms. Prathana Ghataney
Advocates for the Appellant.
Mr. Sudesh Joshi and Mr. Sujan Sunwar, Advocates for
the Respondents.
Date of hearing
:
27.04.2022
Date of Judgment
:
11.05.2022
JUDGMENT
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
The regular first appeal seeks to challenge the
judgment and decree dated 19.12.2019 passed in Money
Suit No.279 of 2017 by the learned District Judge, Special
Division-I Sikkim at Gangtok (learned District Judge)
dismissing the suit.
2.
The plaint was filed by the appellant-Surja Narayan
Pradhan (the plaintiff) against the respondents-Jumden
Lepcha (defendant no.1) and O.T. Lepcha (defendant no.2).
The plaint alleged that the plaintiff had taken on lease a
property owned by the defendants for running a hotel.
According to the plaint it was agreed between the plaintiff
and the defendant no.1 that the plaintiff would construct
and extend further one and half stories to the existing
residential building, renovate the premises and convert it
into a hotel at the cost of the plaintiff. It was the case of the
plaintiff that, he had, during the course of construction
deposited money in the loan account of defendant no.1
maintained in the State Bank of India towards payment of
loan availed by the defendant no.1 in the name of the hotel.
It was further averred that the plaintiff deposited money in
the account of defendant no.2 as well in the State Bank of
India and Axis Bank India Ltd. On completion of the
construction, extension and renovation in the year 2010 he
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
started running the hotel on mutual consent without
drawing any lease agreement. It is averred that, thereafter,
in the year 2013 a lease deed dated 18.03.2013 (exhibit-12)
was drawn between the plaintiff and defendant no.1 for a
period of eleven months commencing from 01.05.2013 to
31.03.2014 at an annual lease rent of Rs.13 lakhs
excluding water and electricity charges. The construction
and renovation work on the premises was calculated by the
parties jointly and it was found that the plaintiff had
incurred Rs.55 lakhs which was acknowledged in the lease
deed. In fact the defendant no.1 had also undertaken to
pay
back
the
said
amount
between
21.03.2014
to
31.03.2014. The plaintiff further avers that on the expiry of
the stipulated period and when the defendant no.1 was
unable to repay the sum of Rs.55 lakhs, an agreement
dated 15.10.2014 (exhibit-13) was drawn between the
defendant no.1 and the plaintiff whereby the defendant
no.1 agreed to pay a sum of Rs.13,75,000/- in cash on
17.07.2014, a further sum of the same amount in cash on
27.09.2014
and
pay
the
remaining
amount
of
Rs.27,50,000/- by two post dated cheques. It is stated that
the defendant no.1 made payment of Rs.27,50,000/- in two
instalment i.e. 17.07.2014 and 27.09.2014 and informed
the plaintiff that she would pay the remaining amount of
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
Rs.27,50,000/- by two cheques payable from the account
of defendant no.2. On 15.10.2014 the defendant no.2
issued two post dated cheques for a sum of Rs.13,75,000/each, both drawn at State Bank of Sikkim, towards
payment of outstanding amount of Rs.27,50,000/-. It is
averred that before presentation of the first cheque bearing
No.070618 dated 30.12.2014 the defendant no.2 paid
Rs.13,75,000/- in cash and resultantly the cheque was not
presented
for
payment.
On
17.04.2015
the
plaintiff
presented the second post dated cheque bearing No.070619
dated 30.03.2015 which was however, returned by i.e. Axis
Bank Ltd. on account of insufficient funds. The cheque was
re-presented on 09.05.2015 which was once again returned
unpaid due to insufficient funds. Legal notices dated
25.05.2015 and 06.07.2015 were thereafter issued which
was followed by a proceeding under section 138 of the
Negotiable Instrument Act, 1881 which was ultimately
withdrawn. Ultimately, the suit was filed in the year
18.12.2017 against the defendants seeking a decree of
Rs.15,40,000/- inclusive of interest calculated @ 12 % per
annum with a further prayer for pendentlite and future
interest @ 12% per annum.
3.
The defendants filed their joint written statement.
They pleaded inter alia that the suit was not maintainable;
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
that there is no cause of action for filing the suit; that the
plaintiff had no locus standi to file the suit; the suit was
barred by limitation and the suit was bad for non-joinder of
necessary parties. The defendants while denying that there
was any agreement between the plaintiff and the defendant
no.1 also pleaded that the agreement was entered by the
defendant no.1 with one Saraswati Pradhan, wife of the
plaintiff. It was denied that the plaintiff made any deposit
in the account of the defendants and stated that lease rent
used to be paid by Saraswati Pradhan into the said
accounts and not by the plaintiff.
It was stated that
Saraswati Pradhan was the one who ran the hotel and not
the plaintiff. The drawing of the lease deed (exhibit-12) was
admitted by the defendants. It was stated that Saraswati
Pradhan and her husband had told the defendant no.1 that
Saraswati Pradhan had incurred the expense of Rs.55
lakhs for the development of the property of the defendant
no.1 which was accepted by the defendant no.1 in good
faith; that in terms of the lease deed (exhibit-12) the entire
amount of Rs.55 lakhs had been paid by the defendant
no.1 to the plaintiff; in reply to paragraph 9 of the plaint,
that no amount was payable to the partnership firm
“Kasturi Group of Hotels and Living” (the partnership firm).
It was asserted that the lease deed (exhibit-12) was entered
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
by defendant no.1 with the plaintiff in his individual
capacity and not in the capacity of one of the partners of
the partnership firm. It was submitted that the agreement
(exhibit-13) is nonest and its terms not enforceable. The
defendants admitted that the sum of Rs.27,50,000/- had
been paid in two
instalments on 17.07.2014 and
27.09.2014. It was further stated that defendant no.1 paid
another sum of Rs.27,50,000/- in cash in the month of
October, 2014. However, no money receipt had been
obtained. It was stated that the post dated cheques issued
by the defendant no.2 were not returned by the plaintiff
and the defendants did not insist on its return due to the
good relationship they shared. It was further asserted that
before the said cheques were presented for payment, the
defendant no.1 paid the entire dues of the plaintiff by cash
in the last week of October, 2014.
4.
The learned District Judge framed eight issues for
trial. The plaintiff examined himself, his wife Saraswati
Pradhan, his son Swaraj Pradhan, Subhadra Pradhan,
Devasish Chatterjee, Dipen Pradhan, Ashish Pariyar and
Anil Tamang the defendants examined themselves.
5.
The learned District Judge took up the issue of the
maintainability of the suit and locus standi of the plaintiff
to institute the suit to examine it together. It was held that
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
the suit was not maintainable and that the plaintiff had no
locus standi to file the suit. The argument of the learned
counsel for the defendants that the suit was barred under
section 69 of The Indian Partnership Act, 1932 was
accepted. It was found that the suit was filed by the
plaintiff on behalf of the unregistered partnership firm and
therefore,
barred
under
section
of
The
Indian
Partnership Act, 1932.
6.
The learned District Judge also held:-
(i)
that the suit was within time. This finding is not
assailed by the defendants.
(ii)
that the suit was bad for non-joinder of necessary
parties i.e. the wife of the plaintiff as well as Ajay Subba.
(iii)
that it was unable to conclude with certainty that the
defendants had already paid the entire amount as per lease
deed (exhibit-12) while examining the issue whether the
defendant no.1 and/or defendant no.2 have already paid
the entire amount of Rs.55 lakhs to the plaintiff as per
lease deed (exhibit-12).
(iv)
that the plaintiff had proved that the defendants had
accepted their liability of Rs.55 lakhs but as it had
concluded that the plaintiff had no locus standi to file the
suit it was clear that the defendants were not liable to pay
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
to the plaintiff the said amount and the plaintiff had no
right to receive the same.
(v)
that the suit had been filed by the partnership firm
against the defendants as the plaintiff had affirmed an
affidavit in support of the plaint on behalf of the
partnership firm. It was held that the suit filed by the
plaintiff against the defendant was a frivolous suit. It was
accordingly dismissed.
7.
The plaint has been filed by the plaintiff. Besides an
averment that the plaintiff is a partner in the partnership
firm there is no indication in the pleadings that the suit
was filed on behalf of the partnership firm. However, the
affidavit in support of the plaint states:
“i. That I am one of the partner of “Kasturi Group of
Travel and Living” having its office at 51 A, Cart
Road, Rose Bank, P.O. and P.S. Darjeeling, District
Darjeeling and I being one of the partner of the
partnership firm and I am duly authorised to affirm
this affidavit by the present partners on behalf of
the partnership firm.”
8.
It was because of this affidavit the learned District
Judge concluded that the plaint had in fact been filed on
behalf of the partnership firm. In order to examine the
correctness of this finding it may be relevant to examine
certain provision of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 (CPC).
The provisions relating to pleadings generally are contained
in Order VI CPC. It is well settled that in the absence of
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
pleading, evidence, if any, produced by the parties cannot
be considered and no party should be permitted to travel
beyond its pleadings. The object of pleading is to enable the
opposite party to know the case it has to meet. In
construing a pleading court must read the petition as a
whole. Order VI Rule 14 provides that every pleading shall
be signed by the party and his pleader (if any). Order VI
Rule 15 provides that every pleading shall be verified in the
manner prescribed. Sub-rule 4 thereof provides that the
person verifying the pleading shall also furnish an affidavit
in support of his pleadings. In Salem Advocate Bar
Association, Tamil Nadu vs. Union of India1 the Supreme
Court held that the affidavit required to be filed under
Order VI Rule 15(4) has the effect of fixing additional
responsibility on the deponent as to the truth of facts
stated in the pleadings. It was however, made clear that
such an affidavit would not be evidence for the purpose of
the trial.
9.
Mr. Sudesh Joshi, learned counsel for the defendants
submitted that it was not only the affidavit which contained
the assertion indicating that the suit had in fact been filed
on behalf of the partnership firm but the plaintiff had also
exhibited the partnership deed as well as produced his wife
AIR 2005 SC 3353
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
Saraswati Pradhan (P.W.1) and Swaraj Pradhan his son
(P.W.2) to prove that the plaintiff was in fact a partner in
the partnership firm. As noted earlier the plaintiff had
pleaded that he was a partner in the partnership firm. In
that view of the matter exhibiting the partnership deed
(exhibit-1) would be only to prove that he was a partner in
the partnership firm as pleaded by him. The evidence of
Saraswati Pradhan and Swaraj Pradhan does not also state
that the suit was filed by the plaintiff on behalf of the
partnership firm. The averments in the plaint make it clear
that the plaintiff had sued the defendants in his individual
capacity and not on behalf of the partnership firm. The
affidavit in support of the plaint cannot be taken as
evidence as was done by the learned District Judge. The
affidavit itself merely states that the plaintiff was a partner
in the partnership firm and he was authorised by the other
partners to affirm the affidavit on behalf of the partnership
firm. It did not indicate that the plaint was filed by the
partnership firm. Consequently, the finding of the learned
District Judge that the suit was filed by the partnership
firm is found to be incorrect and hence set aside. Section
69(2) of The Indian Partnership Act, 1932 would come into
play only when a suit to enforce a right arising from a
contract is instituted in any court “by or on behalf of a firm
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
against any third party unless the firm is registered and the
persons suing are or have been shown in the Register of
Firms as partners in the firm.” As it is seen that the suit was
filed by the plaintiff in his individual capacity section 69(2)
of The Indian Partnership Act, 1932 is not attracted and
consequently the fact that the partnership firm was
unregistered would have no consequence in the suit.
10. On the issue of locus standi of the plaintiff to file the
suit the agreement (exhibit-13) entered between the
partnership firm and the defendant no.1 becomes relevant.
11. On reading the judgments of the Supreme Court
referred to by the learned Senior Counsel for the plaintiff
i.e. B. K. Muniraju vs. State of Karnataka & Ors.2 and
Transmission Corporation of Andhra Pradesh Limited & Ors. vs.
GMR Vemagiri Power Generation Limited & Anr.3 it is clear that
in order to know the real nature of the document, one has
to look into the recitals and the intention is to gather from
it, the conduct of the parties and evidence on record. The
question of construction of a document is to be decided by
finding out intention of the executants, firstly, from a
comprehensive reading of the terms of the document itself,
and then by looking into, to the extent permissible, the
prevailing circumstances which persuaded the author of
(2008) 4 SCC 451
(2018) 3 SCC 716
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
the document to executed. With a view to asserting the
nature of a transaction, the document has to be read as a
whole. A sentence or term used may not be determinative of
real nature of transaction. It is also certain that the terms
of the agreement have to read first to understand the true
scope and meaning of the same with regard to the nature of
the agreement that the parties had in mind. It would not be
safe of exclude any word in the same. When a contract has
been reduced to writing we must look only to that writing
for ascertaining the terms of agreement between the parties
but it does not follow from this that it is only what is set
out expressly and in so many words in the document that
can constitute a term of the contract between the parties. If
on a reading of a document as a whole, it can fairly be
deduced from the words actually used therein that the
parties had agreed on a particular term, there is nothing in
law to prevent them from setting up that term. The terms of
a contract can be express or implied from what has been
expressed.
construction
It is in the ultimate analysis a question of
of
the
contract.
And
again
it
is
well
established that in construing a contract it would be
legitimate to take into account surrounding circumstances.
12. The lease deed (exhibit-12) was between defendant
no.1 as the lessor and the plaintiff as the lessee. The
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
original lease deed (exhibit-12) was exhibited by the
plaintiff. His as well as the signatures of the defendants
were identified by the plaintiff. The defendants did not
dispute the execution of the lease deed (exhibit-12). Its
execution is therefore, proved. There is no indication in the
lease deed (exhibit-12) that the lease was taken by the
partnership firm or that the amounts payable therein was
payable to the partnership firm. In the lease deed (exhibit12) the defendant no.1 had acknowledged the fact that the
plaintiff had spent a sum of Rs.55 lakhs in renovating the
hotel of the defendant no.1 and undertook to pay the entire
amount between 21.03.2014 to 31.03.2014. Admittedly,
however, this payment was not made which led to the
execution of the agreement (exhibit-13) between the
defendant no.1 as the lessor and the partnership firm as
the lessee. The execution of the agreement (exhibit-13) is
also not in dispute and adequately proved by the plaintiff.
The agreement (exhibit-13) acknowledged the fact that
Rs.55 lakhs was owed by the defendant no.1 to the
plaintiff. Mr. J. B. Pradhan, learned Senior Counsel for the
plaintiff was absolutely correct while he pointed out how
the word “lessee” was used in the agreement (exhibit-13) to
describe both the plaintiff as well as the partnership firm.
Reading the agreement (exhibit-13) as a whole it is clear
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
that it was entered between the partnership firm and the
defendant no.1. The recitals in the agreement (exhibit-13)
also indicate that the plaintiff has been referred to as the
leassee. The agreement (exhibit-13) clarifies that it was
entered upon as the defendant no.1 had failed to make
payment of Rs.55 lakhs to the plaintiff on time as per the
lease deed (exhibit-12) and therefore, they had mutually
agreed to ease the repayment schedule in the manner
provided therein. The terms and conditions enumerated in
the
agreement
(exhibit-13)
makes
it
clear
that
the
defendant no.1 was liable to pay Rs.55 lakhs to the
plaintiff; it acknowledges that the defendant no.1 had made
two payments of Rs.13,75,000/- on 17.07.2014 and
27.09.2014 to the plaintiff; the defendant no.1 undertook
to
pay
to
the
Rs.27,50,000/-
plaintiff
by
two
the
remaining
post
dated
amount
cheques
of
dated
30.12.2014 and 30.03.2015 issued by the defendant no.2
in favour of the plaintiff; and after full and final payment
the plaintiff undertook to hand over vacant possession of
the two floors which he had taken in possession as a
security for the payment. It is the case of the plaintiff that
insofar as the first cheque bearing No.070618 dated
30.12.2014 drawn on State Bank of India for an amount of
Rs.13,75,000/- is concerned the defendant no.2 paid this
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
amount prior to its presentation and therefore, it remained
in the custody of the plaintiff. The plaintiff has also averred
that
the
30.03.2015
second
for
cheque
the
bearing
amount
of
No.070619
dated
Rs.13,75,000/-
was
presented for payment but was returned unpaid due to
insufficient funds. This cheque has been exhibited by the
plaintiff as (exhibit-14). It reflects that the cheque was also
drawn by the defendant no.2 in favour of the plaintiff and
not the partnership firm.
13. Considering the recitals in the agreement (exhibit-13)
and the surrounding circumstances including the lease
deed (exhibit-12) earlier entered it is evident that the
agreement (exhibit-13) merely rescheduled the payment
terms and although the agreement (exhibit-13) was entered
between the partnership firm and the defendant no.1 the
payment was still liable to be paid to the plaintiff and not
the partnership firm.
14. Although in the plaintiff’s evidence on affidavit he
states
that
the
agreement
was
drawn
between
the
defendant no.1 and the plaintiff, his wife Saraswati
Pradhan and also a partner in the partnership firm has
clarified in her evidence on affidavit that the agreement
(exhibit-13) was in fact drawn between defendant no.1 and
the partnership firm.
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
15. The learned Senior Counsel’s submission that the suit
was filed not by the partnership firm or on behalf of the
partnership firm but by the plaintiff in its individual
capacity is correct. As it has been found that the money
was payable to the plaintiff as per the lease deed (exhibit12) as well as the agreement (exhibit-13) it was the plaintiff
who had a right to sue the defendants. Therefore, it cannot
be said that the plaintiff did not have the locus standi to file
the suit.
16. This court disagrees with the opinion of the learned
District Judge that the plaintiff had no locus standi to file
the suit since it was filed by on behalf of the partnership
firm which was unregistered and therefore, barred by
section 69(2) of The Indian Partnership Act, 1932.
17. The learned District Judge has also opined that the
suit was bad for non-joinder for both the Sarawati Pradhan
and Ajay Subba. The lease deed (exhibit-12) and the
agreement (exhibit 13) acknowledged that the money owed
by the defendant no.1 was payable to the plaintiff. It has
been held that the suit was filed by the plaintiff in his
individual capacity. Resultantly, this court is not in
agreement with the opinion of the learned District Judge
that the suit was bad for non-joinder of Saraswati Pradhan
and Ajay Subba. They were not necessary parties.
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
18. The other issue which was examined by the learned
District Judge was whether the defendant no.1 and/or
defendant no.2 had already paid the total amount of Rs.55
lakhs to the plaintiff as per lease deed (exhibit-12)? The
burden to prove this issue would be upon the defendants
as it was they who pleaded so. In her evidence on affidavit
the defendant no.1 stated that she had paid the entire
amount of Rs.55 lakhs to the plaintiff and nothing
remained to be paid. In cross-examination she admitted
that the terms and conditions of the lease deed (exhibit-12)
was read over and agreed by her as well as the plaintiff and
they were valid and enforceable. She also admitted that she
had not filed any documents to substantiate the payment
of remaining amount of Rs.27,50,000/- to the plaintiff. She
admitted that neither in written statement nor in her
evidence on affidavit had she mentioned the place, time,
the date where the alleged payment of Rs.27,50,000/- was
made. She also admitted that she had not filed any
documents to substantiate that she had paid the entire
amount to the plaintiff in the last week of October. Similar
admissions were made by the defendant no.2 during his
cross-examination. The defendants have failed to discharge
their burden to prove what they alleged in the written
statement and therefore, it is held that defendant no.1 and
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
defendant no.2 had failed to prove that they paid the total
amount of Rs.55 lakhs to the plaintiff as per the lease deed
(exhibit-12) and nothing further was owed.
19. The learned District Judge examined whether the
defendant no.1 and or defendant no.2 are still liable to pay
Rs.13,75,000/- to the plaintiff along with interest thereon.
The learned District Judge held that the defendants had
accepted the liability of Rs.55 lakhs. The learned District
Judge
considered
the
issuance
of
cheque
bearing
No.070619 for a sum of Rs.13,75,000/- and held that it
clearly proved that the defendants had a liability to
discharge. However, in view of the learned District Judge’s
conclusion that the plaintiff had no locus standi to file the
suit it was held that the defendants were not liable to pay
to the plaintiff the said amount and the plaintiff had no
right to receive the same. As held hereinabove the plaintiff
did have the locus standi to file the present suit for realizing
the amounts owed by the defendants to the plaintiff as per
the agreement (exhibit-13). Therefore, the finding of the
learned District Judge that the suit was false and frivolous
is also set aside. It is held that the suit was neither false
nor frivolous. The impugned judgment and decree of the
learned District Judge is set aside. The appeal is allowed.
Surja Narayan Pradhan vs. Jumden Lepcha & Anr.
R.F.A. No. 04 of 2020
20. Consequently, it is held that the defendant no.1 was
liable to pay the remaining amount of Rs.13,75,000/- to
the plaintiff. The defendant no.1 shall also pay interest at
the rate of 10.2% per annum on the principal sum from the
date of the suit till the date of the decree. Further,
defendant no.1 shall also pay in addition an interest on the
principal sum @ of 6% per annum from 30.03.2015 till the
filing of the suit and from the date of the decree till the date
of actual payment. In terms of section 35 CPC the cost of
the present appeal shall be paid by the defendant no.1 to
the plaintiff.
21. A decree shall be drawn accordingly.
22. A copy of the judgment shall be sent to the Court of
the learned District Judge, Special Division-I, Gangtok,
East Sikkim for compliance.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
Approved for reporting :
Internet :
to/
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review