The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
34. In the above scenario the parties are not willing to reside together in that situation if the decree is not granted no fruitful purpose would be served to maintain the marriage in paper - : 16 :- because there are no chances of re-union. Hence, the appeal filed by the appellant/wife i.e FA No.776/2020 is dismissed and the appeal filed by the appellant/husband i.e FA No.861/2020 is allowed.
35. The judgment and decree passed by trial Court is quashed the petition of the husband under Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, is allowed and the marriage solemnized between the parties on 20.11.2013 is hereby dissolved.
36. The parties shall bear their own costs and advocate fees as per rules. The decree be drawn accordingly. Both the appeals are disposed of accordingly.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
- : 1 :-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND
DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA
ON THE 17th OF JANUARY, 2024
FIRST APPEAL No. 776 of 2020
BETWEEN:PREETI BAM W/O SURESH BAM, AGED
ABOUT 41 YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOUSE
WIFE
252,
JAWAHAR
MARG,
RAJMOHALLA, NEAR BAFNA HOSPITAL,
INDORE/ PRESENT R/O- 1295, 6 FIT ROAD,
SUDAMA NAGAR, SECTOR - D. INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI KAILASH CHANDRA DILLIWAL, LEARNED ADVOCATE FOR THE
APPELLANT).
AND
SURESH S/O SHRI PRAKASHCHANDRA
BAM OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 1201,
GANESH BUILDING, PLOT NO. 34-A,
SECTOR - 11, KOPARKHERAN, NAVI
MUMBA, TEH. AND DIST. THANE
(MAHARASHTRA)
.....RESPONDENT
(SHRI RAKESH KUMAR LAAD, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
- : 2 :-
RESPONDENT).
FIRST APPEAL No. 861 of 2020
BETWEEN:SURESH PRAKASHCHAND BAMB S/O
NOT KNOWN, AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: SERVICE 1201, GANESH
BUILDING, PLOT NO 34-A, SECTOR - 11,
KOPARKHERAN, NAVI MUMBAI, TEH.
AND DISTT. THANE (MAHARASHTRA)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI RAKESH KUMAR LAAD, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
APPELLANT).
AND
PREETI BAM W/O SURESH BAM, AGED
ABOUT 41 YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOUSE
WIFE
252,
JAWAHAR
MARG,
RAJMOHALLA, NEAR BAFNA HOSPITAL,
INDORE/ PRESENT R/O- 1295, 6 FIT ROAD,
SUDAMA NAGAR, SECTOR - D. INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(SHRI KAILASH CHANDRA DILLIWAL, LEARNED ADVOCATE FOR THE
RESPONDENT).
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------This appeal coming on for hearing this day, Justice Devnarayan
Mishra passed the following:
ORDER
This common judgment shall govern the disposal of both the
- : 3 :-
first appeals as both the appeals are arising out of same impugned
judgment.
2. These appeals have been filed under Section 19 of the
Family Court Act being aggrieved by the judgments and decree
passed by Principal Judge Family Court Indore in HMA
No.106/2018 dated 21.10.2020 by which the petition of husband
Suresh Chandra Bam under Section 13(1)(ia) have been dismissed
but the decree of judicial separation has been granted against the
wife Smt. Preeti Suresh Bam. The appeal No.776/2020 has
challenged the decree and judicial separation assailing with the
decree cannot be passed.
3. In this case the respondent/husband Suresh Bam shall be
mentioned as petitioner and appellant/wife Preeti Bam shall be
mentioned as respondent for the convenience.
4. The brief facts of the case are that the parties are governed
by Hindu law and marriage of the petitioner and the appellant was
solemnized on 20.11.2013 at Nathdwara Rajasthan as per Hindu
Rites and Customs. The petitioner was residing in joint family at
Mumbai after marriage both the parties started residing at Mumbai
and just after 15 days of marriage respondent/wife started
quarreling and fighting without any reason over petty issues with
the petitioner and his family members using filthy language. The
respondent make false allegations that the petitioner and his family
members are demanding dowry. Respondent many times in the
night used to take out money from the petitioners wallet without
- : 4 :-
intimating the petitioner and thus, she has taken around Rs.1 to
1.25 lakhs from the pocket of the petitioner that was money of the
employer as he was collecting money from various customers of
his employer and he after collection comes to his residence and
collection money was kept in his wallet. When the petitioner
inquired from his wife she boldly stated that she has spent the
money and quarreled on the said issue. The respondent assualted
the petitioner and used filthy words. The respondent was wearing
dresses and sarees which are not warranted or accepted in the
middle class family or society. The respondent always used to
force and threaten the petitioner to buy a flat in her name, when
the petitioner tried to pursue her to understand that due to financial
status he cannot purchase a flat she quarreled with the petitioner.
5. Further pleaded that the respondent was not doing the
household work and also refuse to have relations and also says that
she does not want any child from the petitioner. She threatened the
petitioner that she will call her brother to Mumbai to teach a lesson
to him and his family members and after making a quarrel
threatened the petitioner and many a times locked the bedroom of
the petitioner so, the petitioner slept in Varandah. One such
incident happened on 13.02.2014 the respondent had called her
brothers at the house of the maternal uncle Shri Dinesh Sancheti,
at Mumbai on the behest of meeting her brother, the respondent
insisted the petitioner to take her to uncles's house in Mumbai but
petitioner told the respondent to call her brothers to their
- : 5 :-
matrimonial house the respondent refused to do so. He sent his
father and brother who went with respondent to his uncle's house
at Mumbai. The respondent insisted to carry all her ornaments with
her and on her instance all the ornaments were taken on the same
day and handed over to the maternal uncle in presence of
respondent's brother. The respondent stayed in the house of the
maternal uncle, father and brother of the petitioner returned. On
14.02.2014 the petitioner along with his brother went to take her
back on Valentine's Day but the respondent refused to come at
matrimonial home and abused and threatened the petitioner.
6. On 15.02.2014 the respondent went to his parents home at
Indore without the consent of the petitioner and without any reason
and never returned till today. On 01.06.2014 the petitioner and his
father went to respondent's house to take her back to matrimonial
home but the respondent and her family member insulted the
petitioner and his family members, respondent and her family
members demanded huge money and Flat in respondent's name in
Mumbai as the respondent intention was to break away the
petitioner from his joint family. The petitioner further states that
the respondent and her family members had threaten the petitioner
and his relative with dire consequences and roping them in false
cases if they don't accept their demand.
7. The petitioner also called the respondent through phone
but the respondent never showed interst in talking with petitioner
and had always quarreled with the petitioner on phone without any
- : 6 :-
reason. On 14.11.2014 the respondent sent a notice through an
advocate and demanded huge amount as a maintenance. The
petitioner replied to the notice on 29.11.2014 through his advocate
and called the respondent to come and co-habit in the matrimonial
home. The respondent never replied to the notice and not complied
with the same. She has filed false case for maintenance against the
petitioner in the Family Court Indore. In the proceedings of
conciliation at Family Court Indore the respondent never showed
the willingness to settle the matter and the respondent demanded
Five Crore rupees to settle the dispute thus, she wants to harrass
and torture the petitioner. The petitioner further states that the
respondent's behaviour has caused tremendous mental agony and
torture. The petitioner is entitled for the decree of divorce.
8. The respondent/wife in her reply has stated that the
petitioner has filed the petition for divorce on the insistence of
some other person to avoid petitioner from paying maintenance to
respondent and residing with her. In reply to the maintenance
application the petitioner has admitted that he is willing to co-habit
with the respondent. She has also specifically denied that she made
any quarrel with the petitioner or she has used any filthy language
to the petitioner or his family members. She has never locked the
bedroom. She has never alleged any false allegations against the
petitioner. The respondent states that the respondent's in-laws
treated the respondent as their daughter till nearly for two months.
Thereafter, she was tortured and harassed with demands of dowry
- : 7 :-
by the petitioner and his family members. She has never put on
clothes not acceptable to middle class society. She has never
forced the petitioner to buy a Flat. She has also specifically denied
all the allegations and it is further pleaded notice dated 14.11.14 is
lawful and respondent has stated the factual position therein. No
ground of cruelty for divorce is made out. No ground of Section
13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act is accrued to the petitioner
hence, the petition be dismissed.
9. The petition of the respondent/husband filed before Civil
Judge, Senior Division Thane (Maharashtra) was transferred by the
Hon'ble Apex Court from that Court to Principal Judge Family
Court Indore vide order dated 16.05.2018 in Transfer Petition
(Civil) No.1722/2016. Thus, the matter was submitted for the trial
before the Family Court Indore.
10. The Family Court Indore framed the issues and after
recording the evidence of both the parties passed the impugned
judgment.
11. Being aggrieved by the judgment the appellant/husband
has filed that appeal on the ground that the trial Court has
erroneously
denied
the
decree
of
divorce
whereas
the
respondent/wife has challenged the judgment on the ground that
no cruelty was proved and the Family Court has wrongly passed
the decree of judicial separation, the petition be dismissed.
12. Learned counsel for the appellant/husband has filed an
I.A No.521/2024 under Order 41 Rule 27 of the CPC for taking
- : 8 :-
additional documents on record and by that he has requested to
take in record the certified copy of Family Court order dated
15.05.18, 21.05.18 and the proceedings on that Court 25.05.18 to
proceeding from 21.05.18, 23.05.18.
13. Learned counsel for the appellant/wife has argued that
the allegation of the petitioner that appellant/wife was taking out
money from the pocket has not been proved by the petitioner but
the trial Court accepted and passed the decree on that ground. The
petitioner has only pleaded two or three instances of cruelty
against the appellant/wife, the same cannot be treated as cruelty
for the ground of judicial separation.
14. The Family Court has wrongly shifted the burden of
proof to the respondent. The petitioner cannot take the advantage
of weakness of the respondent. The Family Court has not looked
into cross-examination of the petitioner/husband particularly in
para 33 and 34. The trial Court has wrongly approached Section 10
of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
15. Learned counsel for the respondent/wife has relied on the
judgment of Deepika alias Baby V. Naresh Chandra Singhania
AIR 1999 SC (Allahabad 1719), Rajesh Kumar Chandra V.
Savita Chandra AIR 219 Chattisgarh 39.
16. Learned counsel for the petitioner/husband has submitted
before the Family Court it was proved that wife was treating the
husband with cruelty and on that ground divorce was prayed but
the trial Court without any sufficient reason has denied the decree
- : 9 :-
of divorce. The parties have resided jointly for only 15 days after
that wife is separately residing in her paternal home at Indore. The
respondent has filed an application for maintenance under Section
125 of Cr.P.C and she has also filed a complaint under the
Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act,2005 and from
the day of marrriage she treated the husband with cruelty.
Heard both the parties and perused the record.
17. First of all we have considered the arguments of the
party on I.A No.519/2024 i.e taking additional documents on
record. In the instant case it is admitted that respondent/wife filed
an application under Section 125 of Cr.P.C before the Family
Court Indore in the martimonial case arising out of the impugned
judgment has been passed, the issues have been framed on
13.04.11 and the case was listed for recording the evidence on
31.07.19 and the statements of respondent witnesses were lastly
recorded on 29.02.2020.
18. The documents that have been produced to be taken on
the record is the ordersheet of the Family Court in the proceeding
of maintenance case MJC No.15/15 and the order passed in that
maintenance proceeding dated 25.05.18. Thus, these documents
were already in existence and these documents were not produced
before the Family Court during trial. The only ground stated in the
application is that the respondent/wife is a women and she is not
having legal knowledge but it is clear from the case proceeding of
divorce in the Family Court, she was being represented through
- : 10 :-
her counsel and thus, unawareness of legal provisions is not a good
ground and other reasons have not been assigned hence, I.A
No.519/2024 is rejected and the additional docments are not taken
on record.
19. Considering the other points on the merit it is admitted
fact that both the parties are governed by Hindu law and thus,
provisions of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 are applicable on the
parties.
20. Petitioner Suresh (PW-1) has stated that marriage was
solemnized at Nathdwara and they went to Mount Abu for
honeymoon after that both went to Bombay where the petitioner
was residing in joint family. The petitioner in para 9 of his
examination in chief has stated that the respondent/wife was
quarreling with him and demanded to purchase a Flat at Bombay
in her name. He was working as Salesman and after collection he
used to keep the collection money in his pocket. The respondent
has taken out money from his pocket in three to four occasions
amounting to Rs.1 to 1.25 Lakhs and when he make her to
understand she may quarrel and lock the bedroom. The respondent
was quarreling and creating such situation that he had to sleep in
Varandah. The respondent was making quarrel regarding house
hold work.
21. On 13.02.2014 she went to Dinesh Sancheti home and on
next day when he and his mother went to call her back she did not
returned and with his brother returned to Indore. On 19.04.2015 he
- : 11 :-
with Mahaveer and Sunil came to Indore, to take her back to
Mumbai. On 31.05.2014 he with his family members, his brotherin-law and Dinseh Sancheti came to took appellant/wife from
Indore to Mumbai but she did not returned, they had booked the
train ticket for 01.06.2014 and he has exhibited the train ticket
Ex.P-3 to P-6.
22. The petitioner Suresh has further stated that he tried to
take the respondent to matrimonial home but failed. On 14.11.2014
the respondent sent a legal notice (Ex. P-7) and he sent the reply
(Ex.P-8). The respondent has filed an application under Section
125 of the Cr.P.C. During conciliation proceeding of that case he
realized that the respondent is not willing to reside with him so, he
has filed an application for divorce. He has also stated till
13.02.2014 they resided in Mumbai and from that date they are
residing separately.
23. In the cross-examination of this witness the statement
has not been challenged on the point that the respondent was
misbehaving with the petitioner and his family members, she was
quarreling and pressurising the petitioner to purchase a Flat in
Mumbai in her name and taking out money from petitioner's
pocket without his knowledge. Further she was not cooking food
and not taking care of the family members, she was not doing any
household work. Regarding the behaviour of respondent, she has
left the petitioner/husband without proper reason. It is also not
been challenged that she was threatening the petitioner.
- : 12 :-
24. The respondent/wife in her statement has stated that
petitioner/husband and his family members were trying to
implicate her for false case and the petitioner and his family
members have taken her finger prints on knife, gun and wooden
rod and were torturing her. The petitioner and his family members
were harassing her for wearing small clothes and tried to declare
her a person of un-sound mind. She is having doubt that petitioner
and his family members were mixing abonxious susbtance in her
food. The petitioner and his family members making a video of her
taking out gold and silver ornaments from the Alimrah and trying
to pressurise her to sign on blank paper and stamps. She wants to
reside with her husband but needs protection and if she got
pregnant
from
the
co-habitation
of
the
petitioner,
the
petitioner/husband will be liable to maintain her child and if she
come to Bombay and if on return his parents did not keep her with
themselves then all the responsibilities will be on petitioner.
25. She has further stated that the appellant/husband is
demanding Rs.2 lakh for the expense of hotel incurred in marriage
ceremony. The appellant/husband and his family members were
playing black magic upon her and threatened that they will draw
her blood from the knife and by that they will perform black magic
and by that they were trying to cause her injury. Her brother-in-law
was also torturing her. The appellant/husband and his family
members were threatening respondent/wife that they will kill her.
She has admitted that after 15.02.2014 she has never returned to
- : 13 :-
her martimonial home at Mumbai and admitted that on 19.04.2015
her husband came to Indore to took her to Mumbai. They have
applied to obtain the salary certificate of the appellant/wife
through RTI. She had admitted that she has filed the application
for maintenance and regarding domestic violence. She denied that
she tried two times to slap her husband.
26. From the above factual matrix admittedly the marriage
was
solemnized
on
20.11.2013
and
on
13.04.2014
the
respondent/wife returned to her matrimonial home thus, she has
resided only for a period of 2.5 months with her husband at her
matrimonial home and after that she is residing at Indore.
27. From the statement of Suresh (PW-1) and the documents
exhibited by him it is clear that on 19.04.2015 and 31.05.14 the
petitioner came Indore and he tried to bring her wife back to
Mumbai but she did not returned to her matrimonial home and in
the same year on 14.11.2014, she sent a notice for maintenance
and reply was sent by the petitioner. From that notice it is clear
that after marriage she resided only 03 days in Mumbai and after
that on 14.12.2013 she went with her husband and as per notice it
is alleged that the petitioner and her family members were
demanding dowry to her and were pressurising her and forcing her
to sign on blank papers and stamps and other allegations. The
respondent/wife has failed to prove all these allegations.
28. The petitioner/husband has alleged that wife was
misbehaving with him and his family members and always
- : 14 :-
quarreling, not doing the househdold work, nor preparing food and
pressurising petitioner/husband to purchase a Flat in her name at
Mumbai and taking out money from his pocket without his
knowledge. These fact have not been challenged in the crossexamination of the petitioner.
29. The facts during the pendency that have been taken on
record is that the respondent/wife has filed a case of domestic
violence against her husband and in her reply of the petition and in
her statement she has alleged that the family members were
playing black magic on her, they were mixing abnoxious substance
in her food, they trying to make a video that she is stealing gold
and silver ornaments from the Almirah and also taking her finger
prints on the knife, gun and other arms. She has clearly stated that
the petitioner and his family members were treating her with
cruelty.
30. She has specifically stated that she is not ready and
willing to reside with her husband till protection is provided to her.
Thus, from February,2014 the parties are residing separately. There
are no chances of re-union between the parties.
31. From the instances that have been brought on record, the
conduct of the wife with her husband cannot be said to be normal
and the allegations as leveled by the respondent/wife against her
husband that have not been proved clearly constitute cruelty. On
the ground that have been alleged by the petitioner/husband has
not been challenged by the wife in the cross-examination so be
- : 15 :-
treated as admitted. Thus, the instances of that cruelty are clearly
proved. Thus, it is proved that after solemnization of marriage the
wife treated her husband with cruelty.
32. I have gone through the judgment relied by the
respondent/wife in Rajesh Kumar Chandra V. Savita Chandra
AIR 219 Chattisgarh 39. In this case the Chattisgarh High Court
has held that the divorce cannot be granted only on the general
allegations of cruelty unless especifically pleaded and proved by
reliable evidence is not applicable in this case as the husband has
proved the cruelty and the allegations as alleged by the
respondent/wife, she has failed to prove them and this fact itself
constitute cruelty. The judgment of Deepika alias Baby V. Naresh
Chandra Singhania AIR 1999 SC (Allahabad 1719), in that case
the husband failed to prove the cruelty and the wife was ready and
willing to live with her husband and husband failed to show any
efforts to live with her wife on that basis the decree of divorce was
denied.
33. In this case as discussed above, the trial Court himself
has found grounds of cruelty but denied the decree of divorce and
in between these period from the passing of the decree till today
the parties have not tried to reside together. This fact is also against
the wife.
34. In the above scenario the parties are not willing to reside
together in that situation if the decree is not granted no fruitful
purpose would be served to maintain the marriage in paper
- : 16 :-
because there are no chances of re-union. Hence, the appeal filed
by the appellant/wife i.e FA No.776/2020 is dismissed and the
appeal filed by the appellant/husband i.e FA No.861/2020 is
allowed.
35. The judgment and decree passed by trial Court is
quashed the petition of the husband under Section 13(1)(ia) of the
Hindu Marriage Act, is allowed and the marriage solemnized
between the parties on 20.11.2013 is hereby dissolved.
36. The parties shall bear their own costs and advocate fees
as per rules. The decree be drawn accordingly. Both the appeals
are disposed of accordingly.
37. A photocopy of this order be kept in the records of the
connected case.
C.C as per Rules.
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
akanksha
LAHORIYA
Date: 2024.01.29 18:00:49 +05'30'
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review