Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:HON’BLE JUSTICE RAVI KRISHAN KAPUR
&
HON’BLE JUSTICE CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS.
FAT 525 OF 2013
SURANJAN PANDEY
VS.
BHAGIRATH ADHIKARY
For the Appellant
:
Mr. Suprabhat Bhattacharyay, Adv.
Mr. Abhisek Banerjee, Adv.
Mr. Subhajit Chattopadhyay,Adv.
For the Respondent
:
Mrs. Shohini Chakraborty, Adv.
Reserved On
:
06.08.2026
Judgement On
:
28.08.2026
Uploaded On
:
28.08.2026
CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS, J.:1. This Appeal is filed against a Judgement and Decree dated September 30, 2013
passed by the Learned Civil Judge Senior Division, 2nd Court, Krishnanagar ,
District Nadia in Title Suit no. 44 of 2013 by the Defendant/Appellant whereby
the suit filed by the present Respondent/plaintiff has been decreed.
Brief fact of the case
2. A suit for specific performance of oral agreement of sale of a property was filed
by the respondent/plaintiff which has been described in the schedule of the
plaint alleging denial to execute and register the deed of sale in consonance
with the terms of the oral agreement entered between the parties. The case of
the plaintiff is as follows :
The plaintiff and the father of appellants were well acquainted with each other
and because of their friendship the plaintiff was very affectionate towards the
defendant and had a very cordial relationship.
The defendant /appellant was an unemployed person and since he needed
some money to start a business
intended to sale his property and the
plaintiff/respondent agreed to purchase the said property. After discussion the
consideration price of the property was decided as Rs. 4,00,000/- and
accordingly they made an oral agreement between themselves and in terms of
such oral agreement the plaintiff/respondent paid Rs. 3,50,000/instalments and
it was further
by
decided that the balance amount of Rs.
50,000/- will be paid within a year from such payment of Rs. 3, 50,000/- and
then a sale deed will be registered in favour of the plaintiff/respondent. In view
of their ongoing friendship and having faith on each other the plaintiff did not
take any money receipt or documents and paid that amount of Rs. 3, 50,000/and as the plaintiff/respondent did not have enough money to purchase the
required stamp paper and other expenses for registration, despite giving a
substantial part of the agreed consideration amount the deed was not
registered
by
paying
the
balance
Rs.
50,000/-.
However,
the
defendant/appellant in part performance of the said contract handed over the
possession of the property to the plaintiff/respondent. Since the date of that
oral agreement the plaintiff /respondent kept the disputed property in his own
possession and was enjoying the same and also paid the tax and rents to the
Municipality and other Government Offices. The plaintiff /respondent also
submitted a construction plan for sanction of such plan and started raising the
construction of the building on his own.
3. It was further the plaintiff’s case that after the foundation was constructed the
present appellant with the mala fide intention sent letter through his Advocate
Subodh Chandra Banerjee on May 22, 2008 and demanded balance amount of
Rs. 1,00,000/- and also intimated that their oral agreement has expired in the
month of Poush, 1414 B.S. However, a reply was given through his Advocate
Smt. Mohua Das Chakroborty denying further receiving of Rs. 1,00,000/- and
expiry of the period of their oral agreement. On June 14,2008 again said
Subodh Chandra Banerjee the Learned Advocate send a notice to the Advocate
Mohua Das Chakraborty demanding balance of Rs. 1,00,000/- and also that
on payment of such amount the deed will be executed . The Learned Advocate
on behalf of the plaintiff also informed that only Rs. 50,000/- was due and
payable which he agreed to pay and requested the defendant/appellant to sign
in the document. However, no reply was given after that letter dated July 18,
2008. Lastly, having no other alternative he filed the suit for specific
performance claiming the present appellant.
4. On the contrary, the case of the appellant /defendant is a complete denial of
any oral agreement or receiving any amount towards part consideration which
was specifically denied after entering
appearance in the suit by filing the
written statement. The appellant also denied exchange of any letters between
the advocates and also that another suit has been filed by the plaintiff over the
same cause of action against the present defendant/appellant which was still
pending and the story of refusal to execute registered deed of sale on
20.12.2019 is absolutely false and concocted. It was further denied that any
specific time limit was fixed and the contract is vitiated for necessary definite
particulars about the necessary terms of contract.
5. The Learned Trial Court after analysing the evidences adduced by the parties
and arguments advanced by the Learned Advocates decreed the suit mostly
relying upon the advocate’s letter which was exhibited before the Learned
Court. Challenging the same the defendant has come before this Court.
Submissions
6. The Learned Advocate representing the appellant before this Court argued that
the appellant being the defendant by filing his written statement specifically
dealt with each and every allegations and did not admit any of the allegations
in terms of Order VII Rule 3 of CPC and also denied the amount alleged to be
agreed of Rs. 4,00,000/-. It is denied that the respondent/plaintiff paid Rs. 3,
50,000/- as earnest money to him. It is further evident that in terms of Section
136 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 the respondent/plaintiff never called his
advocate for adducing evidence on his behalf when those letters were
specifically challenged by the defendant and the certified copy of those letters
were relied upon before the court without producing the original document.
Further he submitted that the law laid down in this regard is very specific that
even when any document is exhibited without having any objection, the
contents of the document cannot be said to be proved and that is to be proved
in accordance with the Indian Evidence Act.
7. Furthermore, the legal position is not in dispute that mere production and
marking of a documents as exhibit by the court cannot be held to be due proof
of its contents. He relied upon the decision of Narbada Devi Gupta vs
Birendra Kumar Jaiswal & Anr.1
. The Learned Advocate put further
reliance on Alamelu & Others vs State represented by Inspector of Police2,
R.V.E Venkatachala Gounder Vs. Arulmigu Viswesaraswami and V.P.
Temple and Anr.3 and argued that the plaintiff/respondent had not been able
to establish any answer to the question of establishing any type of contract
AIR 2004 SC 175;2003 (8) SCC 745; CDJ 2004 (SC) 23
AIR 2011 (SC) 715, 2011 (1) SCC, 385 CDJ 2011 SC 066
AIR 2003 SC 4548, (2003) 8 SCC 752 , CDJ 2003 SC 922
between two persons and hence no decree for specific performance of such
contract can be passed.
8. Per contra, the Learned Counsel representing the respondent vehemently
opposes the contention of the appellant and argued that the Learned Trial
Court rightly passed the decree of specific performance on the basis of the
evidence adduced and there is no need to interfere with such decree. It is
contended that the appellant admitted the exchange of letters between the
Learned Advocate of the parties and in his written statement did not
categorically deny the said letters of advocates exchanged on behalf of both the
parties. The denials are evasive in nature and in terms of Order VIII Rule 3 of
the Code of Civil Procedure the defendant appellant was under obligation to
deal with those paragraphs very specifically and categorically. Therefore the
opponent has declined to avail himself the opportunity to put his essential and
material case in cross examination and it must follow that the testimony given
could not be disputed at all. He put reliance in this regard in the decision of
A.E.G. Carapiet vs A.Y. Derderian 4 paragraph 9.
9. It is further submitted that the appellant refused to produce his Learned
Advocate as witness and despite a specific question put to him in cross
examination as he denied on oath before the Court to call Subodh Banerjee as
witness to depose in this case. This clearly manifest that the appellant withheld
the evidence of that advocate since it would have been unfavourable for him. It
is therefore to be presumed under Section 114 (g) and 126 of Indian Evidence
AIR 1961 Cal 359
Act that the said advocate was instructed by him to write the said letter. The
Learned Advocate of the appellant contradicted the stand taken by the
respondent regarding non examination of the advocate as witness who wrote
the letters despite the plaintiff reiterated in the statement and tendered the
affidavit in chief where he clearly mentioned about the letters and despite that
no such cross examination was made on behalf of the present appellant.
10. The Learned Advocate further put reliance upon the decision of the High
Court of Calcutta A.E.G. Carapiet Vs. A.Y. Derderian5, Dayamathi Bai vs.
K.M. Shaffi6 on the point of raising objection regarding admissibility of
certified copies of the documents which was marked with exhibit and admitted
in evidence , but later on objected taking the point that the objection was not
as to the admissibility of the certified copy but to the mode of proving falsity
within the procedural law and can be waived Therefore there is no scope for
further challenging the said modes of that document which clearly established
the execution of the letters and accordingly prayed for dismissal of the instant
appeal.
Analysis
11. The point falls for consideration in this appeal is that as to whether the
Learned Court erred in passing the decree merely relying upon the certified
copies of the letters the contents of which were not proved by adducing
evidence by the Advocates who wrote the letters ,but were marked exhibits .
1960 SCC online Cal 44
(2004) 7 SCC 107
12. The factual matrix of this case unveils the
dispute pertains to an oral
agreement entered into between the appellant and the father of respondents
whereby it was agreed that the disputed property will be sold on an
consideration amount of Rs. 4, 00,000/- out of which Rs. 3, 50,000/- was to
be paid prior to the execution of the sale deed on some instalments and the
balance Rs. 50,000/-to be paid at time of registration of the sale and on failure
to pay the balance amount the sale deed will not be registered .In order to
prove the case the plaintiff deposed before the Court and tendered his affidavit
in chief and the certified copy of the letter dated May 22, 2008, dated June 11,
2008 , dated June 14, 2008 as well as the reply letter dated July 18, 2008
were marked as exhibits 1, 2, 3, and 4 respectively. It was also deposed that all
the original letters are lying in other suit being title suit no. 106 of 2009 and
therefore the certified copies were filed.
13. It is evident from the record that no objection was raised on behalf of the
present appellant/defendant while those documents were marked as exhibits.
The plaintiff during his evidence failed to disclose the date when the discussion
was held with the father of the present appellant regarding sale of suit land.
However he deposed that no agreement for sale was effected between him and
the defendant .The plaintiff further failed to say the date of making payment by
way of instalment and or the number of instalment or how he paid the money
to the defendant. He could not produce any independent witness
to prove the
monetary transactions or regarding receipt of the said amount of instalment. It
is admitted that the plaintiff had filed a title suit being Title suit no. 106 of
2009 against the present appellant/defendant which was dismissed followed by
an appeal filed before the Learned District Judge, Nadia which is still pending.
However he denied about that no oral agreement took place but could not
remember the date when said agreement took place.
14. From his evidence it can be found that a sanctioned plan has been passed in
favour of the present appellant /defendant by Nawadwip Municipality and
admitted that
about 8 years ago an oral agreement was formed and
denied
that possession was not delivered in his favour. He filed the certified copy of
L.R. R.O. R which stood in the name of the appellant/defendant.
15. In this case the plaintiff has not adduced any other witnesses. The present
appellant deposed as D.W. 1 who denied to have any acquaintance with the
plaintiff prior to filing of the suit. He stated that plaintiff might have talked with
his father but not with him and he never agreed to sale the schedule land at
Rs. 3, 00,000/- or at any amount. He denied to have accepted any advance
money of Rs. 2, 50,000/- or any sum. According to the witness the possession
of the suit property was under him and he paid the Municipal tax as well as
the Government rent and also received the summons of the Court from the
concerned court in connection with Title suit no 106 of 2009. The said suit was
dismissed after he appeared and filed his written statement. When the
transaction took place the present appellant/defendant was a student and
pursuing his M.A and his father used to look after all the property matter and
domestic matters. He denied to have received any amount from the plaintiffs. It
further transpires from his cross-examination that he admitted the Learned
Advocate Mr. Subodh Banerjee who practices in Nabadwip Chouki Court was
known to him.
His testimony further reveals that that the entire talk of
settlement about the property in dispute was not with him but with his father
who has expired. This witness denied of any letter dated May 28, 2008 made
through advocate Subodh Banerjee by him and or served upon the plaintiff or
any demand of further amount of Rs. 1, 00,000/-made from plaintiff by a
notice. He also denied to receive any notice through the advocate of the plaintiff
and also denied to sell the land upon remaining Rs. 1,00,000/-. The specific
question was put to him by the plaintiff/respondent to which the reply was
given by the witness that he shall not call the Advocate Subodh Banerjee as
witness to depose in the case on behalf of defendant also no other witness
adduced evidence.
16. From the above nature of evidence it is very much apparent that excepting the
oral version of the plaintiff there is no other evidence to substantiate that any
oral agreement was entered into with the plaintiff and the father of the present
appellant. However, the only documents which were placed to substantiate
such contention are the letters addressed by the Learned Advocates on behalf
of both the parties to each other. The core contention has now been crystallised
to ascertain whether the said letters which were the certified copies of the
original are sufficiently proved, over which the Learned Court delivered such
judgement.
17. The appellant has relied upon the decisions of Narbada Devi Gupta vs
Birendra Kumar Jaiswal (supra) where three rent receipts were relied upon
and the main question raised by the appellant before the Court was on the
admissibility and evidentiary value of those documents. The main thrust of the
argument strenuously advanced by the Learned Counsel was that mere
admission of the signature of the plaintiff on the back portion of the rent
receipts and marking those as exhibit by the Court cannot be taken as due
proof to execution of the rent receipts by the original lady. It was argued that
exhibits are marked with the signatures of the plaintiff on the back portion of
the rent receipts and such making could not be taken to be proved on due
execution and issuance of rent receipts. Reliance was heavily placed of the case
of Kamji Dayawala and Sons Pvt. Ltd. Vs Invest Import7 In paragraph 16 of
the said decision it was held that“….The legal position is not in dispute that mere
production and marking of a document as exhibit by the
court cannot be held to be a due proof of its contents. Its
execution has to be proved by admissible evidence that is
by the evidence of those persons who can vouchsafe for
the truth of the facts in issue. The situation is, however,
different where the documents are produced, they are
admitted by the opposite party, signatures on them and
also admitted and they are marked thereafter as exhibit
by the Court......”
18.
In the decision of Alamelu and Ors. (Supra) relates to the date of birth of
the girl and the High Court relied solely on the certificate issued by doctor and
however the facts and circumstances of the case do not have any semblance
with the facts of the present case and is distinguishable. In the decision of K.
Nanjappa (dead) by LRS (supra) it was observed that7
(1981) 1 SCC 80
“The mode of proving the contents of a document is dealt with, in Section 61 to
66 of the Indian Evidence Act. The contents of a document may be proved either
by the primary or secondary evidence. Primary evidence means, the document
itself produced for the inspection of the Court.” In the said case the original
agreement itself was produced for inspection of the court and it did not require
attestation being an agreement of sale. The signature of the person alleged to
have signed the document the execution of which must be proved by evidence
and with the signature purporting to be that of executants is in his hand
writing and the other matter in the document that is its body must also to be
proved by the prove of hand writing of a person purporting to have written the
document.
In other judgements as relied upon all the above decisions were considered and
therefore we propose not to discuss each and every judgement since the issue
raised are similar in nature.
19. The decision relied upon by the Learned Advocate of the respondent in the
case of Dayamati Bai(supra) a certified copy of a sale deed was exhibited
where no objection was raised and the document was marked and admitted in
evidence and the suit was decreed . An appeal was preferred against that and
the judgement of R.V.E Venkatachala Gounder (supra) as relied upon by the
appellant was discussed, where the Hon’ble supreme court took note of the
decision of Roman Cathalic Mission Vs State of Madras8. In the said case it
was observed that:8
AIR 1966 SC 1457
“…..Ordinarily an objection to the admissibility of evidence
should be taken when it is tendered and not subsequently.
The objections as to admissibility of the documents in
evidence may be classified into two classes: (i) an objection
that the document which is sought to be proved by itself
inadmissible in evidence and (ii) where the objection does
not dispute the admissibility of the document in evidence
but is directed towards the mode of proof alleging the
same to be irregular or insufficient. In the first case merely
because a document has been marked as “an exhibit” an
objection as to its admissibility is not excluded and is
available to be raised even at a later stage or even in
appeal or revision. In the latter case, the objection should
be taken when the evidence is tendered and once the
document is admitted in evidence and marked as an
exhibit, the objection that it should not have been admitted
in evidence or that the mode adopted for proving the
document is irregular cannot be allowed to be raised at
any stage subsequent to the marking of the document as
an exhibit…..”
20. The Hon’ble Apex court further took note of the decision of the Privy Council in
Gopal Das vs Thakurji9 in which it was held that:“when the objection to the mode of proof is not taken ,the
party cannot lie by until the case comes before a court of
appeal and then complain for the first time of the mode of
proof. That when the objection to be taken is not the
AIR 1943 PC 83
document is in itself inadmissible but that the mode of
proof was irregular ,it is essential that the objection should
be taken at the trial before the document is marked as an
exhibit and admitted to the record.”
21. In the present case when the plaintiff submitted certified copies of the letters
were written by two advocates as per instruction of their respective client who
are both the plaintiff and the defendant and when those letters were taken on
record and marked as an exhibit, no objection was raised by the appellant and
the execution of those letters were also not challenged. That apart in the plaint
specifically the letters were described to be addressed by whom
but in the
written statement excepting stating the averments as false no specific denial
can be found . Despite expressing the execution of letters as false no attempt
was made on behalf of the defendant to dispel the same by calling upon the
advocate rather he denied to call that advocate to adduce evidence .Therefore
even if the argument advanced by the appellant is considered that the contents
of the background is not proved there is no denial of the fact that the mode of
execution of the document being the letters were never objected to and hence it
is not open to the appellant to object such mode of prove at the time of hearing
of appeal before this court. It was held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that in
such situation if the objection had been taken at the trial stage the plaintiff
could have met it by calling for the original document which was on record in
co-lateral proceedings. Similarly in this case also the original letters were there
in the other proceedings which is undisputed but the appellant made no
attempt to call the record neither he raised objection regarding mode of
execution of the documents.
22. Therefore the sum and substance appears that the mode of execution that is
the letter issued by the advocates at the instruction of the appellant was given
to the plaintiff/respondent and a reply was given to the appellant against
which further reply was given. Not only that a reply letter was given on behalf
of the plaintiff/respondent. Therefore where the entire case rests on the oral
agreement and
the certified copies of the letters exchanged by the Learned
Advocates on behalf of the respective parties are marked with exhibit without
objection and the mode of execution was not challenged and further the
Appellant denied to cite the said advocate to adduce evidence before the court,
which otherwise would have been the best recourse to dispel the case of the
plaintiff ,it obviously raise the question the question of presumption in favour
of the plaintiffs that those letters were issued to the respondent/plaintiff on
the basis of settled law that whenever the opponent has declined to avail
himself to the opportunity
to put the essential and material case in cross
examination ,it must follow that he believed that the testimony given could not
be disputed at all.(Emphasis relied on A.E.G. Crapiet vs A.Y. Derderian
(supra).
23. Since the proceeding being a civil dispute it is not expected that it is to be
proved beyond the shadow of all reasonable doubts and once the letters were
exhibited without objection and even regarding execution of the letters at the
stage of trial and the plaintiff was able to create a higher degree of probability
the onus to prove then the onus shifts upon the defendants which he has failed
to discharge
and in absence of thereof it is to be held that the plaintiff’s
burden of proof has been duly discharged .
Conclusion
24. Hence in view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances and the law laid down
in this regard we do not find any cogent reason to interfere with the judgement
and decree passed in favour of the Appellant/plaintiff and there is no merit in
the case.
25. The Appeal stands dismissed. The Judgement and decree passed by the
Learned Trial Court on September 30, 2013 is hereby affirmed.
26. Liberty is granted to the appellant to withdraw the amount alongwith any
interest accrued thereon lying deposited with the Trial Court as recorded in the
order dated 13th July, 2016 passed in FAT of 2013.
28. No order as to costs.
29. Decree to be drawn up in accordance with law.
30. Urgent certified copy if applied by any of the parties to be supplied subject to
observance of all formalities.
I agree
(RAVI KRISHAN KAPUR,J.)
(CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review