The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. In the present case the child is residing at Indore and getting education in Indore. Indore is a bigger city as compared to village Barod District Agar, it is but natural that child will get more exposure and he is accustomed with the amenities and education at Indore. He himself wants to reside with maternal grandmother and maternal uncle and his will should be respected.
14. In view of above discussion, no infirmity or perversity is found in the judgment of the trial Court hence, the order of the trial Court is affirmed. The appeal is devoid of any merits and is hereby dismissed. Interim application if any, pending shall stand closed. The appellant shall bear costs of the appeal. Thus, with the above directions, the Miscellaneous Appeal stands disposed off. 5:28:47 PM
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA
ON THE 17th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. APPEAL No. 3528 of 2022
BETWEEN:SUNIL S/O SHREE GOPAL, AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: DAIRY OWNER R/O CHURDI BAZAAR
DHOBI GALI BAROD DISTRICT AGAR MALWA
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(SHRI GOURAV SHRIVASTAVA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE
APPELLANT).
AND
1.
MAYABAI W/O SHREE RAJENDRA KHATWA,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION:
HOUSEWIFE R/O 229/11 LAAL GALI KUMHAR
MOHALLA PARDESHIPURA INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
PAPPU @ DURGA SHANKAR S/O SHREE
RAJENDRA KHATWA, AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS,
R/O 229/11, LAAL GALI KUMHAR MOHALLA
PARDESHIPURA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI DEVDEEP SINGH, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT
NO.1).
This appeal coming on for admission this day, Justice Devnarayan
Mishra passed the following:
ORDER
With the consent of the parties, the matter is heard finally.
2. The present appeal is arising out of the judgment dated 28.04.2022
Signed by: AKANKSHA
LAHORIYA
Signing time: 1/20/2024
5:28:47 PM
passed by the Second Additional District Judge, Agar, District Shajapur in
MJCGW No.3/2021.
3. Facts of the case reveal that the appellant has filed an application under
Section 6 of the Guardian & Wards Act, 1890 claiming custody of minor child
(Sarthak) aged about 7 years. At present, the child is residing with the
respondents who are in-laws (Nani- Mama) of the child. In the application it was
stated by the appellant that marriage was solemnized with the daughter of
respondent No.1 and sister of respondent No.2 named Sapna Khatwa, as per
the Hindu rituals and customs on 30.04.2013 in Indore and out of the wedlock
the appellant and Sapna were blessed with son Sarthak. On 04.01.2016 his wife
expired and the custody of the appellant's son is retained by the respondents.
4. Present appellant is the natural guardian of his son, therefore, for his
paramount interest and for future prospects, the appellant is entitled for the
custody of his son. Learned counsel for the appellant further submitted that
earlier also the appellant has filed an application for obtaining the custody of his
son, but the said application was dismissed. However, the relatives of the
appellant and respondents have amicably settled the dispute by mediating
between the appellant and respondents therefore they have entered into an
agreement on dated 16.03.2020 in execution of which the appellant reached at
respondent's house on dated 10.09.2021 for the custody of his son Sarthak and
the respondents have also peacefully sent the appellant's son alongwith the
appellant to Barod. Thereafter, on 20.09.2021, the respondents brought back
the appellant's son to Indore and on 28.09.2021, the respondents have refused
to send back Sarthak to Barode alongwith the appellant and had further
threatened him to implicate falsely in a miscellaneous case. In order to retain the
custody of the appellant's son, the appellant preferred an application before the
Signed by: AKANKSHA
LAHORIYA
Signing time: 1/20/2024
5:28:47 PM
learned Second Additional District Judge, Agar u/S 6 of the Guardian & Wards
Act, 1890.
In the said application, the respondents have not appeared, hence
they were declared ex-parte.
However, learned Court below framed three
issues in the said application and after recording the evidence of the appellant,
Court below rejected the application of the appellant vide order dated
28.04.2022. Hence, this appeal.
5. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the learned trial Court
has not considered the provisions of the Hindu Minority Guardianship Act,
1956 in which the father is the natural guardian and in this case the minor's
mother is also not alive thus, the ward is not only deprived of love, care and
attention of his mother but the impugned order has deprived the child from the
love, care and attention of his father also. The trial Court has failed to consider
that paramount interest of the ward is vested in the interest of appellant. The
appellant can afford better education and standard of living instead of
respondents. The matter was heard ex-parte before the trial Court even though
the Court has dismissed the application.
6. Counsel for the appellant on the basis of the judgments passed by the
Apex Court in case of Tejaswini Gaud and Ors. Vs. Shekhar Jagdish
Prasad Tewari and Ors. MANU/SC/0692/2019 has argued that when the
father is only surviving parent in that condition the custody of child be given to
the father and welfare of the child has to be determined owing to the facts of
each case. He has also relied on the judgment of Vinay Trivedi Vs. State of
M.P. and Ors. MANU/MP/0605/2021 , Sagar Saxena Vs. The State of
Madhya Pradesh and Ors. MANU/MP/1820/2022 and Anand Kumar and
Ors. Vs. Lakhan Jatav MANU/MP/3112/2022.
Signed by: AKANKSHA
LAHORIYA
Signing time: 1/20/2024
5:28:47 PM
7. Learned counsel for the respondents has submitted that the mother of
the minor has committed suicide due to ill treatment of the appellant/husband
and from his childhood the minor was residing with her mother who was
residing in her parental home and when the mother of the minor child died he
continued to reside in the custody of her maternal grandmother and maternal
uncle. The previous application of the appellant under the Guardianship &
Wards Act, 1890 readwith Section 6 of the Hindu Minority Guardianship Act,
1956 was dismissed on 31.07.2018 and the trial Court after due consideration
has passed the impugned order dated 28.04.2022. Trial Court has considered all
the aspect regarding the welfare and education of the minor child. The minor
was produced before this Court and in this case the minor has expressed his
desire to reside with respondents. No interference is called for in the order of
the trial Court.
8. On relying on the judgment of Nil Ratan Kundu and Another Vs.
Abhijit Kundu (2008)9 SCC 413 has argued that in the matter of guardianship
of a child the problem has to be solved with human touch not on the basis of
statutory right of the parents and strict rules of evidence and procedure but
Court must give due weightage to child's ordinary comfort, contentment, health,
education, intellectual development and favourable surroundings
as well as
physical comfort and moral values.
9. We have gone through the record it is admitted that the appellant was
married with Sapna on 30.04.2013 and from their wedlock the minor child
(Sarthak) was born. In the meantime the wife(mother of the minor child) died on
06.04.2016 (Exhibit P-2). In the judgment passed by First Additional District
Judge, Agar Distict Shajapur in ST No.51/2016 by that it is disclosed that wife
Signed by: AKANKSHA
LAHORIYA
Signing time: 1/20/2024
5:28:47 PM
of the appellant died by consuming poisonous substance and criminal case
under Section 306 of IPC was registered against the appellant. The parents of
the deceased and appellant entered into a compromise on 16.03.2020 and it
appears that on the basis of that compromise the respondent and other family
members has not supported the case of prosecution hence, the appellant was
acquitted from the charge under Section 306 of IPC and as per Exhibit P-3 in
MJC No.04/2016. The application for custody filed by the appellants was
dismissed by Additional District Judge Agar, District Shajapur and the second
application was filed after compromise between the parties.
10. The matter was heard ex-parte before the trial Court wherein the
statements of appellant Sunil (A-1), one evidence of Puralal (A-2) and Rajesh
(A-3) were recorded but the trial Court has considered the previous order
Exhibit P-3 and the compromise of 16.03.2020 Exhibit P-1 and the trial Court
has considered the fact that the minor is residing with maternal grand mother
and maternal uncle at Indore and after compromise i.e Exhibit P-1 the child has
resided for 10 days with the appellant in Indore and the trial Court has
concluded that the appellant failed to disclose that how many family members
are with him and how he will provide better upbringing and education to his son
and he has also failed to prove that the interest of his child is in residing with
him.
11. From the order of this Court on 03.10.2023 it is clear that the child
was personally called and his statement were recorded in which he has
expressed that he would like to reside with the respondents and not with the
appellants. The minor is residing with his maternal grandmother and maternal
uncle before the death of her mother i.e since 2016. He is now accustomed with
the environments of Indore and at present he is taking education at Indore. The
Signed by: AKANKSHA
LAHORIYA
Signing time: 1/20/2024
5:28:47 PM
appellant has failed to demonstrate that the child is being ill treated or is not
being provided the education and necessaries to support his education and
hobbies.
12. As per the judgment of Nil Ratan Kundu and Another Vs. Abhijit
Kundu (2008)9 SCC 413 in deciding the custody of child the interest of the
child is paramount consideration and not the rights of the parties. In the case of
Sagar
Saxena
Vs.
The
State
of
Madhya
Pradesh
and
Ors.
MANU/MP/1820/2022, Vinay Trivedi Vs. State of M.P. and Ors.
MANU/MP/06505/2021 the child was produced before the Court in the writ
of Habeas Corpus in that case the custody was handed over to the father. In
the case of Tejaswini Gaud and Ors. Vs. Shekhar Jagdish Prasad Tewari
and Ors. MANU/SC/0692/2019 the Apex Court has also considered the
matter in writ of Habeas Corpus and the Court has further held that welfare of
the child is paramount consideration in the case of custody and custody is not
bound by mere rights of the parents.
13. In the present case the child is residing at Indore and getting
education in Indore. Indore is a bigger city as compared to village Barod
District Agar, it is but natural that child will get more exposure and he is
accustomed with the amenities and education at Indore. He himself wants to
reside with maternal grandmother and maternal uncle and his will should be
respected.
14. In view of above discussion, no infirmity or perversity is found in the
judgment of the trial Court hence, the order of the trial Court is affirmed. The
appeal is devoid of any merits and is hereby dismissed. Interim application if
any, pending shall stand closed. The appellant shall bear costs of the appeal.
Thus, with the above directions, the Miscellaneous Appeal stands disposed off.
Signed by: AKANKSHA
LAHORIYA
Signing time: 1/20/2024
5:28:47 PM
15. Registry is directed to sent the original record back to the Tribunal
immediately alongwith the copy of this order.
C.c as per Rules.
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
akanksha
Signed by: AKANKSHA
LAHORIYA
Signing time: 1/20/2024
5:28:47 PM
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review