Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1MFA No.100491 of 2016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 30TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K.MANMADHA RAO
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.100491 OF 2016(ECA)
BETWEEN:
SHRI SUNIL S/O DHARMAPPA LAMANI,
AGE: 33 YEARS, OCC: AT PRESENT NIL,
R/O: UCHAGAON-591128,
TQ: AND DIST: BELAGAVI.
…APPELLANT
(BY SMT. SUNANDA P. PATIL, ADVOCATE)
AND:
MOHANKUMAR B
SHELAR
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
1.
DASTAGIR S/O APPALAL ZANJE,
AGE: 40 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS,
R/O: NANDANI ROAD, AVACHIT NAGAR,
JAYSINGPUR-591101,
TQ: SHIROL, DIST: KOLHAPUR, MAHARASTRA STATE.
(OWNER OF PASSENGER AUTO NO.MH/09/J-2860)
2.
DIVISIONAL MANAGER,
THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD.,
CLUB ROAD, BELAGAVI-590001
(INSURER OF PASSENGER AUTO
RICKSHAW NO.MH-09/J-2860
INSURANCE NO.152302/31/09/01/00002314
VALID FROM 27/06/2009 TO 26/06/2010)
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. M.K. SOUDAGAR, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
NOTICE TO R1-DISPENSED WITH)
THIS MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
30(1) OF THE EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION ACT 1923, PRAYING TO
CALL FOR THE RECORDS CONNECTED WITH ECA NO.221/2014 ON
THE FILE OF THE III ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND
COMMISSIONER UNDER EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION ACT BELAGAVI,
EXAMINE THE SAME AND SET ASIDE THE ORDER DATED 23.11.2015
TO THE EXTENT OF DISALLOWED CLAIM AND ENHANCE THE
COMPENSATION TO THE TUNE OF Rs.10,00,000/-, IN THE INTEREST
OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY.
-2MFA No.100491 of 2016
THIS MFA HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR
JUDGMENT ON 23.01.2026 AND COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K.MANMADHA RAO
CAV JUDGMENT
This appeal is filed by the claimant under Section 30(1) of
the Employees’ Compensation Act, 1923 (for short, ‘EC Act’), for
enhancement of compensation calling in question the judgment
and award dated 23.11.2015 passed by the III Additional Senior
Civil Judge and Commissioner for Employees’ Compensation,
Belagavi (‘the Commissioner’, for short), in ECA No.221/2014,
wherein compensation of Rs.84,672/- with interest at 12% per
annum was awarded.
2.
The
appellant/respondents
herein
are
the
claimant/respondents before the Commissioner.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that:-
The claimant/appellant was employed as a driver under
respondent
No.1
and
was
driving
registration
No.MH-09/J-2860,
Auto
which
Rickshaw
was
bearing
insured
with
respondent No.2-Insurance Company. On 03.02.2010 at about
2.15 a.m., while proceeding from Ganapatipula to Jayasingpur on
-3MFA No.100491 of 2016
Ratnagiri–Kolhapur Road via Amba Ghat, the appellant met with
an accident arising out of and in the course of his employment.
As a result of the accident, he sustained grievous injuries and
was admitted to CPR Hospital, Kolhapur, where he remained as
an inpatient from 03.02.2010 to 22.03.2010 and underwent two
major surgeries. It is the case of the appellant/claimant that he
incurred medical expenses of more than Rs.75,000/- and
continues to be under follow-up treatment.
4.
It was further contended before the Commissioner
that at the time of the accident, the appellant was aged about 26
years and was earning Rs.3,300/- per month. According to him,
due to the injuries sustained in the accident, he has suffered
permanent
physical
disability
resulting
in
loss
of
earning
capacity, loss of future prospects, and amenities of life. On these
grounds, he sought compensation of Rs.10,00,000/- under the
EC Act.
5.
Upon service of notice, respondents appeared and
filed their objections. Respondent No.1 admitted the employer–
employee relationship, ownership of the vehicle, and payment of
salary of Rs.3,300/- per month to the appellant. Respondent
-4MFA No.100491 of 2016
No.2–insurer denied the age, income, nature of injuries, extent
of disability, and employer–employee relationship, and further
contended that the appellant did not possess a valid and
effective driving licence at the time of the accident.
6.
Before the Commissioner, the appellant examined
himself as PW-1 and examined the doctor as PW-2, and got
marked documents as per Exs.P1 to P9. On the other hand,
respondent No.2 got marked documents at Ex.R1.
7.
Upon appreciation of the evidence on record, the
Commissioner framed issues and partly allowed the claim
petition and awarded compensation of Rs.84,672/- with interest
at 12% per annum.
8.
Learned counsel for the appellant contended that as
per the discharge summary at Ex.P4, the appellant had sustained
fracture of shaft of femur, distal fracture of tibia, and fracture of
the right wrist. PW-2 assessed permanent disability at 55% to
the right lower limb, 30% to the right upper limb, and 25% to
the left upper limb, which comes to 110% disability to the three
limbs in all. It was argued that the cumulative effect of the
injuries
resulted
in
substantial
loss
of
earning
capacity,
-5MFA No.100491 of 2016
particularly considering that the appellant was working as a
driver. It was further contended that the income and age of the
appellant were not properly taken into consideration and that the
compensation awarded is meager and requires enhancement.
9.
In support of her contentions, learned counsel for the
appellant has placed reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble
Madras
High
Court
in
the
case
of D.Shanmuga
Anand
Vs.M.Balasubramanian and another reported in 2012 ACJ
2456, wherein at paragraph 14 it has held as follows:
“14. The evidence on record indicated that the
appellant-claimant was unable to perform the work that he
was doing earlier. Appellant was employed as a driver. The
accident has caused an injury to him which has resulted in
malunited fracture of wrist and malunited tibia on the right
leg, more particularly, there has been loss of bone
segment on the right tibia. This handicap has resulted in
decreasing the muscle power of the limbs as also its
movements. The right leg is essential for driving and is
used for accelerating the vehicle as well as for applying
brakes. Likewise, the left arm is essential for holding and
operating the steering wheel. In such circumstances, when
there is evidence on record to show that the appellant was
unable to carry out the work of driving the vehicle, it
obviously means that he had suffered an injury which
resulted in complete disablement.”
10.
Learned counsel for respondent No.1 supported the
case of the appellant to the extent that the employer–employee
relationship and payment of wages were admitted.
-6MFA No.100491 of 2016
11.
Per contra, learned counsel for respondent No.2–
insurer contended that the Commissioner has assessed the
compensation on the basis of evidence on record and that no
perversity or illegality is demonstrated. Learned counsel filed
objections denying the employee and employer relationship and
the mode of accident. He also denied the occurance of the
accident and spending Rs.75,000/- towards treatment and also
denied that he was aged 26 years and earning Rs.3,300/- per
month and due to accidental injuries he has totally become
disable. He also submits that the claimant was not holding valid
driving licence. The counsel also submits that the orthopedic
surgeon has given disability to the extent of 110% to the three
limbs which he submits is disproportionate as 100% disability to
body means a person dead and very strangely submits that the
disability is assessed 10% more. Therefore, the insurer is not
liable to pay the compensation and hence, prays to dismiss the
appeal.
12.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the materials available on record.
-7MFA No.100491 of 2016
13.
Having considered the submissions advance, in the
present case, the fact that the accident occurred arising out of
and in the course of employment is not in serious dispute. The
employer–employee relationship is admitted by respondent No.1.
The Commissioner has assessed the age and income of the
appellant on the basis of available evidence. With regard to
disability,
though
PW-2
assessed
limb-wise
disability,
the
Commissioner has considered the functional disability at 15% to
the whole body. Looking into the nature of the injuries and by
considering the submissions of both the parties, and the
materials placed on record, this Court deems it appropriate to
consider disability to the whole body at 20%. With regard to
other heads, the Commissioner has awarded just and proper
compensation. Therefore, this Court deems it appropriate to
consider the disability to the whole body at 20% instead of 15%
taken by the Commissioner. Hence, loss of earning capacity
comes to Rs.85,300/-
(Rs.3300/- x 60% x 215.38 x 20% =
Rs.85,290/- rounded of to Rs.85,300/-). Therefore, the claimant
is entitled for compensation of Rs.1,03,032/- (Rs.85,300/- +
Rs.17,732/- [medical bills]).
-8MFA No.100491 of 2016
14.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court
proceeds to pass the following:
ORDER
i.
The appeal is allowed-in-part.
ii.
The judgment and award dated 23.11.2015
passed in ECA No.221/2014 by the III Additional
Senior
Civil
Judge
and
Commissioner
for
Employees’ Compensation, Belagavi, is hereby
modified.
The
claimant
is
entitled
for
compensation of Rs.1,03,032/- *as against
Rs.84,672/- awarded by the commissioner
with interest at the rate of 12% p.a. after
30 days from the date of accident till
deposit on the enhanced compensation of
Rs.18,360/-.
iii.
Apportionment and disbursement shall be in the
same manner as directed by the Commissioner.
iv.
The
trial
Court
records,
if
any,
shall
transmitted to the Tribunal forthwith.
Sd/(DR. K.MANMADHA RAO)
JUDGE
KGK,CT:VP
*Corrected vide court order dated 05.02.2026
Sd/(DR.KMRJ)
be
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review