Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.526 of 2024
Smt. Sumita Datta
wife of Late Tushar Kanti Muhari,
resident of Rosedale Apartment, Block 5,
Flat No. G(H), PO- Kunjaban, PS- NCC.
District- West Tripura, Pin- 799010, Age54 years.
–Versus–
……… Petitioner(s)
1. The State of Tripura
represented by the Education (School)
Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex, Gurkhabasti,
Agartala, PO- Kunjaban, PS- New Capital
Complex, Sub-Division- Sadar, DistrictWest Tripura
2. The Joint Secretary,
Department of Elementary Education,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat
Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala, POKunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division- Sadar, District- West
Tripura
3.
The
Director
of
Elementary
Education,
Government of Tripura, Shiksha Bhavan,
Akhaura Road, PO- Agartala, PS- West
Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin799001
4.
The
Director,
State
Council
of
Educational
Research
and
Training
(SCERT),
GB Abhoynagar Road, 79
Tilla, Agartala, District- West
Tripura,
Pin-799005
5. Tripura Public Service Commission
(TPSC),
represented by its Secretary, Akhaura
Road, PO- Agartala, PS- West Agartala,
Sub-Division- Sadar,
Tripura, Pin- 799001
District-
West
6. Sri Samir Debbarma,
Senior Lecturer, Office of the District
Institute of Education and Training
(DIET), Kakraban, PO and PS- Kakraban,
District- Gomati Tripura, Pin-799105
7.
Sri
Subha
Padma
Chakma
Senior Lecturer, Office of the District
Institute of Education and Training
(DIET), Kailashahar, Vidyanagar, POPaiturbazar, District- North Tripura, Pin799279
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner (s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Koomar Chakraborty, Adv.
For the Respondent (s)
:
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. K. Pandey, Adv.
Date of hearing & delivery of :
Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting
:
20.11.2025
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel
appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. D. Sarma, learned
Addl. G.A. appearing for the respondent Nos.1 to 4 and Mr. K.
Pandey, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No.5.
[2]
The petitioner initially joined as Postgraduate Teacher
under the Directorate of School Education on 08.01.1997 and
thereafter, she appeared in the examination conducted by the
Tripura Public Service Commission and was selected for the post
of lecturer [Group-B Gazetted] under the District Institute of
Education and Training (for short, ‘the DIET’) and joined to the
said post on 30.06.2004.
[3]
The petitioner’s next higher post of promotion is
Senior Lecturer [DIET]. As per the Senior Lecturer [DIET]
Recruitment
(Amendment)
Rules,
2004,
the
method
of
recruitment is by promotion, failing which by direct recruitment,
and in case of promotion from the post of Lecturer [DIET], the
candidates must have at least 5 years of experience in the said
feeder post. In case of direct recruitment, the candidates must
have
required
academic
qualifications.
According
to
the
petitioner, she possesses all the required qualifications and the
experience for the said post of Senior Lecturer (DIET).
[4]
Admittedly, there are total 6[six] sanctioned posts and
as per 100 point roster maintained under Tripura Scheduled
Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1992, the said
posts are required to be filled up in the following manner:
UR
[5]
ST
SC
By a rejoinder submitted by the petitioner, it is stated
that initially after creation of 6[six] posts of Senior Lecturer on
08.05.1998, one Smt. Swapna Dhar Chowdhury was promoted to
the said post on 08.09.2004 against (UR) category in terms of
the previous rules. Thereafter, the position remained as follows:
UR
ST
SC
[6]
In the year 2007, further promotion was made for
filling up of the said posts, wherein 1[one] UR category
candidate,
namely
Dr.
Mrinal
Chakraborty
and
2[two]
ST
category candidates, namely Rita Debbarma and Jaya Debbarma
were
promoted.
Out
of
these
persons,
one
ST
category
candidate, namely Jaya Debbarma was promoted against UR
category vacancy and therefore, the vacancy position remained
as follows:
UR
[7]
ST
SC
In the year 2012, due to retirement of said Swapna
Dhar Choudhury, 1[one] UR post again falls vacant and therefore,
total vacancy position became as under:
UR
[8]
ST
SC
In the year 2017, one Senior Lecturer, namely Dr.
Mrinal Chakraborty under [UR] category retired from service.
Therefore, the vacancy position was changed as under:
UR
[9]
ST
SC
In the year 2018, said Jaya Debbarma who was
promoted against UR category also went on retirement and said
UR category post again became vacant and therefore, the
vacancy position stood as such:
UR
ST
SC
[10]
As per the final seniority list, Annexure-3 of the writ
petition, the petitioner’s position is at Sl. No.5. The relevant
portion of the seniority list is extracted hereunder:
Sl.
No.
**
**
[11]
It
is
Name
Sri Arun Chanda Das
Smt. Manidipa Ganchoudhuri
Sri Banamali Debbarma
Sri Ashes Datta
Smt. Sumita Datta (petitioner)
**
Sri Samir Debbarma
(respondent No.6)
***
Sri Subha Padma Chakma
(respondent No.7)
the
allegation
of
the
Whether
SC/ST
SC
UR
ST
UR
UR
**
ST
**
**
petitioner
that
vide
promotional order dated 25.03.2022, Annexure-6 of the writ
petition, 6[six] persons were promoted against 5 [five] vacant
posts by creating a supernumerary post for the proforma
respondent No.7. It is also the grievance of the petitioner that as
per 100 point roster when such promotional exercise was done,
there were total 3[three] numbers of UR category posts as
indicated above but despite the same, only 2[two] UR candidates
were promoted depriving her from such regular promotion. The
persons who were promoted by said promotional order dated
25.03.2022 are indicated hereunder:
Sl.
No.
Name
Smt. Manidipa Ganchoudhuri, Lecturer
Sri Banamali Debbarma, Lecturer
Sri Ashes Datta, Lecturer
Dr. Subrata Sarkar, Lecturer
Sri Samir Debbarma, Lecturer
Sri Subha Padma Chakma, Lecturer
Category of
the candidate
UR
ST
UR
SC
ST
ST
[12]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner strongly addresses his argument that illegally
the petitioner has been deprived from the benefit of promotion
despite the fact that there were 3[three] vacant UR category
posts and the third post ought to have been filled up by way of
promoting her. Learned senior counsel also submits that despite
the seniority position of Sri Subha Padma Chakma, the proforma
respondent No.7, was at serial No.23 and above him, there were
many other SC and UR category of candidates, none of them
were promoted by creating supernumerary post but without any
basis, illegal favour has been shown to the proforma respondent
No.7.
[13]
On the other hand, Mr. Pandey, learned counsel
appearing for the respondent No.5-TPSC submits that as per the
promotion policy as framed the State by order dated 22.06.2021,
Annexure-5 of the writ petition, promotion can be given only to
the reserved category candidates under the supernumerary post
and no such benefit can be extended to the UR category
candidates. Mr. Pandey, learned counsel particularly relies on the
guidelines under serial Nos.6 and 7 of the said policy which are
reproduced below:
“6. Now the State Government hereby notifies the
following Promotion Policy as follows:
(i) Rule 9 of the Tripura SC & ST Reservation Rules,
1992 and the provisos thereto shall be read in such
a manner that only those SC & ST candidates who
have qualified solely on the basis of merit and have
never taken the benefit of reservation, will be
treated to be own merit candidates and entitle to
occupy the posts meant for general category and
reservation shall be made cadre-wise.
(ii) 100 point roster shall apply only where the
number of posts in the cadre is 4(four) or more.
(iii) Where the post in the cadre are 3(three) or
less, the 3(three) point replacement roster shall be
followed.
(iv) Single post or small cadres cannot be combined
to make the number of posts more than 3(three).
7. Following the above policy, the DPC will identify
employees eligible for promotion to a particular post
against the available vacancies. After this exercise, DPC
shall consider another exercise taking into account the
procedure as stated in the Rule 9 (2) of the Tripura SC &
ST Reservation Rules, 1992. Due to such exercise, if any
candidate is found not considered in the process as
stated in the above process, then such candidates shall
be considered for ad-hoc promotion by creating
supernumerary post(s).”
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for
[14]
the State-respondents during his submission refers to the
proposal, sent by the Joint Secretary, Directorate of Elementary
Education, Government of Tripura [Annexure-R/2 to the counter
affidavit filed by the respondent No.5] to the TPSC and submits
that there were 5[five] vacant posts [UR-2, SC-1, ST-2] of Senior
Lecturer when such promotional exercise was done. Thereafter,
as
per
the
notification
dated
22.06.2021
containing
the
promotion policy as indicated above, the department prepared a
chart following the instruction No.6 of the said policy and also
prepared another chart following the instruction No.7 thereof. In
the said exercise, it was found that Sri Banamali Debbarma,
whose name was found place in the combined promotional list,
ought to have been promoted against UR category candidate as
per Rule 9 of Tripura SC & ST Reservation Rules but due to the
bar created under instruction No.6 of the policy, he was
promoted against ST quota and therefore, he was deprived of
from getting promotion against common UR category quota and
consequently, Subhapada Chakma, who would otherwise be
promoted against ST quota has also been deprived from getting
promotion against such ST quota and therefore, the department
proposed for creation of supernumerary post for promotion of
said Subha Padma Chakma complying the instruction No.7 of the
policy. Thus, no error was committed by the DPC for promoting
Subha Padma Chakma.
[15]
Mr. Debbarma, learned Addl. G.A. also further refers
to the chart prepared in Form-2 containing proforma for
inspection of 100 point roster by the department submits that out
of 3[three] UR posts, one was occupied by 1[one] UR category
candidate and therefore, only 2 UR category of posts fell vacant
and
consequently,
2[two]
persons
namely
Manidipa
Gan
Chowdhury and Ashesh Datta were promoted against said 2[two]
UR vacant posts and there was no scope of promotion of the
present petitioner against UR category post. Learned Addl. G.A.
further submits that when the department after proper scrutiny
found that there were only 2[two] vacant posts of UR category
candidate and 2[two] posts of ST category candidate, there is no
reason to interfere with the impugned promotional order. He
prays for dismissal of the writ petition.
[16]
After taking into consideration the submissions of both
sides and the materials placed on record, it appears to the Court
that, according to the department's proforma for inspection of
the 100 point roster [Annexure-R/3 to the counter affidavit filed
by respondent No.5], there were only two vacant posts in the UR
category, two posts in the ST category, and one post in the SC
category available for filling up the same by way of promotion.
However, as per the rejoinder submitted by the petitioner, when
the promotional exercise was done, there were 3[three] numbers
of UR category vacant posts, one number of ST category vacant
post and one SC category of such vacant post, which is
contradictory to the version of the respondents. The said
rejoinder is submitted being supported with an affidavit and the
respondents have not countered it by filing any additional
affidavit. Learned Addl. G.A. submits that a scope may be given
to the respondents for filing the additional affidavit as a counter
to said rejoinder after proper verification of the record. However,
this Court is not inclined to give further scope to the respondents
at this belated stage of final hearing, for, after such rejoinder
was submitted by the petitioner on 15.05.2025, the matter was
adjourned to several dates but during the said period, none of
the respondent sought for leave to submit any additional
affidavit.
[17]
In view of the above position, this Court is of the view
that the matter is required to be revisited by the respondents
No.1 to 5 regarding the actual vacancy position under UR and
reserved category when the said promotional exercise was done
and to rectify the defects, if any, found on such verification and
to
modify
the
said
promotional
order
dated
25.03.2022
accordingly, if so required. Consequently, the respondent Nos. 1
to 5 are directed to revisit the vacancy position of the post of
Senior Lecturer existing as on the date when the promotional
exercise was done and to take necessary steps in this regard in
light of what has been observed hereinabove. The entire exercise
should be completed within 8[eight] weeks from the date of
receipt of copy of this order.
With such observations and direction, this writ petition
is disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2025.11.27 17:35:27 +05'30'
Sujay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review