Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No.108
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT) No. 7/2026
Date of pronouncement: 13.08.2026
Date of uploading: 17.08.2026
Sumit Nanda
. ....Appellant
Through:- Mr. Supreet Singh Johal, Advocate
v/s
Riti Mahajan
..... Respondent
Through:- Mr. Pawan K Kundal, Sr. Advocate
with
Ms. Jagdeep Kour,Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
14.08.2026
1.
The parties to the present appeals were married on 20.07.2015.
Out of the wedlock, a son, namely, Master Aadvik Nanda, was born on
22.02.2018. The parties are presently embroiled in a dispute concerning the
guardianship and custody of the minor child.
2.
The petitioner-husband is stated to be employed in the software
industry at Pune, Maharashtra, and is earning sufficiently to meet the
financial requirements of the minor child. The respondent-wife was earlier
employed with Larsen & Toubro and, in connection with her employment,
remained in Denmark from 13.04.2019 to 28.07.2019. Thereafter, in the
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT)No.7/2026
year 2021, she was selected to pursue an MBA programme at the University
of British Columbia, Canada.
3.
According
to
the
respondent-wife,
the
petitioner-husband
extended financial assistance to enable her to pursue the aforesaid course
and continued to support her from time to time. She completed her
postgraduate course in Canada in July 2022. Thereafter, she was unable to
secure suitable employment for some time. The minor child, being of tender
age, continued to remain in India.
4.
The respondent-wife subsequently obtained permanent resident
status in Canada. According to her, the relationship between the parties
remained cordial until the year 2022 and, during that period, they had
mutually contemplated settling in Canada. She asserts that, with the
assistance and support of the petitioner-husband, she purchased a
residential property in Canada by raising a substantial loan. According to
her, the petitioner thereafter became reluctant to shift to Canada, inter alia,
on the ground that the education of the minor child would be adversely
affected. Consequently, the respondent continued to travel between India
and Canada.
5.
In February 2024, the respondent-wife took possession of the
house in Canada and returned there on 04.02.2024. In the meantime, the
minor child, who had initially been residing with the maternal grandparents
at Jammu, was taken by the petitioner-father to Pune sometime in the year
2022. The respondent asserts that on 30.10.2023, the petitioner had agreed
to permit her to take the minor child to Canada; however, despite the
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT)No.7/2026
requisite visa having been obtained, neither the petitioner nor the child
ultimately travelled to Canada.
6.
In January 2024, the child was admitted to a school at Pune.
According to the respondent-wife, the relationship between the parties
deteriorated substantially from August 2024 onwards. She returned to
India in the year 2025 and instituted proceedings before the trial Court
seeking, inter alia, her appointment as guardian of the person of the minor
and an
injunction restraining the
petitioner-husband from forcibly
removing the child from her custody.
7.
The petitioner-husband contested the proceedings. His principal
contention was that the welfare and best interests of the child would be
better secured if the child continued to reside with him in India. It was
pleaded that, on account of the respondent having predominantly resided in
Canada, she had gradually become disconnected from the petitioner as well
as the minor child. It was further contended that the respondent had
purchased immovable property in Canada by raising a substantial loan and
that a significant part of her income was required to service the
corresponding
financial
liability.
According
to
the
petitioner,
these
circumstances cast doubt upon her ability to independently meet the dayto-day requirements of the minor child in Canada.
8.
The petitioner-husband also instituted separate proceedings
seeking his appointment as guardian. Both petitions were, accordingly,
taken up together by the trial Court.
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT)No.7/2026
9.
During the pendency of the proceedings, the trial Court disposed
of the respective interim applications and permitted the respondent-wife to
take the minor child to Canada for a period of two years. The petitionerfather was granted liberty to interact with the child through video
conferencing on alternate days for a period of at least five to ten minutes. It
was further directed that, whenever the petitioner travelled to Canada, the
respondent would facilitate his access to and interaction with the minor
child for reasonable periods. The respondent was also directed to return to
India along with the minor upon completion of the stipulated period of two
years, without seeking any further extension.
10.
Aggrieved of the aforesaid order dated 26.05.2026, the petitioner-
husband has preferred the present appeals, being FAO(MAT) Nos. 6/2026
and 7/2026.
11.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
12.
Vide order dated 07.08.2026, the parties were directed to meet at
Falak Restaurant, K.C. Residency, Jammu, and thereafter to appear before
this Court along with the minor child on 10.08.2026. On the said date, the
child was produced before the Court and was interacted with in Chambers.
13.
During the interaction, the child appeared to be intelligent, well-
mannered and capable of expressing his preferences. What emerged most
prominently was his desire for the company and affection of both parents.
When specifically asked whether he wished to go to Canada, the child
appeared inclined to continue residing in India rather than relocate to
Canada.
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT)No.7/2026
14.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the matrimonial
relationship between the parties has deteriorated to such an extent that the
respondent-wife intends to settle permanently in Canada. It is apprehended
that the impugned order may effectively enable the respondent to remove
the child beyond the territorial jurisdiction of the Indian Courts and that,
once the child is taken to Canada, securing meaningful physical access to
him may become exceedingly difficult for the petitioner.
15.
It is further submitted that the respondent is presently without
regular employment. According to the petitioner, she was working from
home after returning from Canada in 2025 but has since lost her
employment. It is, therefore, contended that she presently has no assured
source of income and had herself stated before the trial Court that she
intended to sustain herself from rental income generated from the property
in Canada.
16.
Ld. Sr. Counsel for the respondent-wife, on the other hand,
supports the order passed by the trial Court. It is submitted that the
arrangement is purely interim and permits the respondent to take the child
to Canada only for a limited period of two years. Adequate safeguards have,
according to the respondent, been incorporated in the order to preserve the
petitioner's access to the child and to secure the return of the respondent
and the minor to India upon expiry of the stipulated period.
17.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the respondent
fairly submitted that the respondent does not intend to remain in Canada
indefinitely and requires some time to settle her financial affairs and
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT)No.7/2026
dispose of the property acquired there, which is subject to substantial
financial liabilities. It is her case that the decision to acquire the property
and contemplate settlement in Canada had originally been taken with the
active financial and other support of the petitioner-husband, who has
subsequently resiled from that understanding.
18.
Allegations have also been made regarding the petitioner's
association with another woman. According to the respondent, continuation
of the child exclusively in the petitioner's custody would, in such
circumstances, not advance the welfare and best interests of the minor.
These allegations, however, are matters which would necessarily require
proof during trial and cannot, at this interlocutory stage, be treated as
established facts.
19.
The proceedings before the trial Court have been instituted
under Sections 7, 10, 17 and 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890,
read with Sections 6 and 13 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act,
1956.
20.
Both parents are natural guardians of the child and have
legitimate claims to his care and companionship. Such claims, however,
cannot be adjudicated merely by balancing the competing rights of the
parents. In all matters concerning custody and guardianship, the
controlling and paramount consideration is the welfare and best interests of
the minor child.
21.
The Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 is intended not merely to
regulate the physical custody of a minor but also to secure the protection of
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT)No.7/2026
the minor's health, maintenance, education and overall well-being.
Questions of custody cannot, therefore, be determined on considerations of
parental entitlement alone. A child is neither property nor a commodity to
be divided between contesting parents. Matters affecting a child require
sensitivity, compassion and a careful assessment of the child's emotional,
educational, physical and psychological welfare.
22.
Section 7 of the Guardians and Wards Act empowers the Court,
where it is satisfied that the welfare of a minor so requires, to appoint a
guardian of the person or property of the minor, or both. Section 4 defines a
“guardian” as a person having the care of the person of a minor or of his
property, or of both.
23.
The provisions of the Guardians and Wards Act are secular in
their operation. In “ABC v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2015) 10 SCC 1”, the
Supreme Court reiterated the centrality of the welfare of the child in
guardianship proceedings.
24.
The Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, on the other
hand, governs questions of minority and guardianship amongst Hindus. As
explained by the Supreme Court in “Githa Hariharan v. Reserve Bank of
India, (1999) 2 SCC 228”, the statutory scheme governing Hindu minority
and guardianship has to be understood by reading the applicable
enactments harmoniously.
25.
Section
2 of the
Hindu
Minority and Guardianship Act
specifically provides that its provisions are supplemental to, and not in
derogation of, the Guardians and Wards Act. The two enactments must,
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT)No.7/2026
therefore, be read conjointly, always subject to the overriding consideration
of the welfare of the minor.
26.
Section 6 of the Act of 1956 recognises the father and, after him,
the mother as natural guardians of a Hindu minor boy or unmarried girl,
while providing that the custody of a child who has not completed the age of
five years shall ordinarily be with the mother. The statutory designation of a
natural guardian does not, however, confer an indefeasible right to custody.
The ultimate inquiry remains as to what arrangement would best promote
the welfare of the child.
27.
Where both parents are otherwise fit, the Court is required to
assess their competing claims in the context of the child's age, emotional
bonds, educational needs, stability, existing environment, capacity of each
parent to provide care, and, where the child has attained sufficient
maturity, his or her preference. No single circumstance can be treated as
conclusive.
28.
In the present case, the parents of the petitioner-husband are
stated to be no more, whereas the parents of the respondent-wife reside in
Jammu. During the period when the respondent was pursuing higher
studies and thereafter residing in Canada, the child remained with his
maternal grandparents at Jammu until 2022, whereafter he was taken to
Pune. At present, the child is stated to be residing at the maternal
grandparents' house in Jammu and is attending school there.
29.
The petitioner is employed at Pune and appears financially
capable of bearing the expenses of the child. The respondent, though
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT)No.7/2026
presently without regular employment, is well qualified, holds permanent
resident status in Canada and owns property there, albeit subject to
substantial financial liabilities.
30.
Ordinarily, an appellate Court would be slow to interfere with an
interlocutory arrangement concerning custody, particularly where the final
guardianship proceedings remain pending and the parties are yet to lead
their evidence. The impugned order, therefore, requires interference only if
the arrangement made by the trial Court is found, on the material presently
available, not to advance the welfare of the child.
31.
One
circumstance
assumes
considerable
significance.
The
respondent-wife remained in India for more than a year while pursuing the
custody proceedings and is stated to have lost her employment during this
period. Prior thereto, when she was pursuing her studies and employment
in Canada, the child continued to reside in India under the care of his
maternal grandparents and father, while the respondent-maintained
contact with him through visits and virtual interaction.
32.
The existing arrangement, therefore, demonstrates that the
respondent has, for a considerable period, been able to maintain her
relationship with the child despite residing abroad. Conversely, taking the
child to Canada for two years at the present stage would entail removing
him from the social, familial and educational environment in which he is
presently settled.
33.
The preference expressed by the child during interaction with the
Court also cannot be altogether ignored. The child is about eight years of
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT)No.7/2026
age and appeared capable of articulating his wishes. His preference is not
determinative by itself; nevertheless, it constitutes a relevant circumstance
in assessing his welfare. He expressed an inclination to remain in India
and, more importantly, a desire to enjoy the companionship of both
parents.
34.
The respondent has permanent resident status in Canada and
owns immovable property there. She admittedly requires time to settle the
financial liabilities associated with that property and, according to her own
case, intends eventually to dispose of the same. In these circumstances,
immediately relocating the child to Canada for two years would introduce
substantial
uncertainty
into
his
present
living
and
educational
arrangements.
35.
The apprehension expressed by the petitioner that meaningful
access to the child may become difficult once the child is taken outside
India cannot, in the peculiar facts of the present case, be dismissed as
wholly unfounded. The safeguards incorporated by the trial Court
undoubtedly seek to protect the petitioner's access; nevertheless, the
practical
difficulties
inherent
in
enforcing
physical
access
across
international borders are also relevant while determining an interim
custody arrangement.
36.
The respondent may, therefore, first settle her property-related
and other affairs in Canada. The question of any subsequent relocation of
the child, if sought, can be considered on its own merits, keeping in view
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT)No.7/2026
the circumstances then prevailing and, above all, the welfare and best
interests of the child.
37.
The trial Court appears to have attached insufficient weight to
the child's existing environment, his expressed preference, the continuity of
his education and family relationships in India, and the uncertainty
attendant upon his relocation to Canada for a limited period of two years.
These considerations assume particular importance because the order
under challenge is only an interim arrangement and the competing claims
of the parties to guardianship and permanent custody are yet to be finally
adjudicated upon evidence.
38.
In the totality of the circumstances, this Court is of the
considered view that permitting the respondent-wife, at this stage, to take
the minor child to Canada for a period of two years would not advance the
welfare and best interests of the child. The impugned arrangement would
uproot the child from his presently settled environment despite his
expressed inclination to remain in India.
39.
It is clarified that the observations made herein are confined to
the adjudication of the interim custody arrangement and shall not prejudice
either party in the pending guardianship proceedings. The trial Court shall
determine their respective claims independently, on the basis of the
evidence led before it and uninfluenced by any observation touching upon
the merits of the final custody dispute contained in this order. For the
reasons recorded above, both appeals are allowed by setting aside the
impugned order dated 26.05.2026.
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT)No.7/2026
40.
The parties shall be at liberty to establish their respective claims
regarding guardianship and custody before the trial Court in accordance
with law. The trial Court shall endeavour to decide the proceedings
expeditiously, bearing in mind that in matters concerning the custody of a
minor child, prolonged uncertainty itself may operate to the detriment of
the child's welfare.
41.
The appeals stand disposed of, along with all connected
applications, if any.
(SanjayParihar)
Judge
JAMMU
13.08.2026
Sneha
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
FAO(MAT)No.6/2026
c/w
FAO(MAT)No.7/2026
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review