Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.898 of 2022
Sumit Biswas and 19 Ors.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura and 5 Ors.
….Respondent(s)
WP(C) No.899 of 2022
Md. Abdul Munim and 9 Ors.
….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura and 5 Ors.
….Respondent(s)
WP(C) No.900 of 2022
Imran Hossain Maishan and 21 Ors.
Versus
The State of Tripura and 5 Ors.
….Petitioner(s)
….Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, GA
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. SGI
For the Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
& delivery of
judgment & order
:
19.02.2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment and Order (Oral)
Since common questions of law and facts are involved in all the
writ petitions, these are taken up together for hearing and disposal with the
consent of learned counsel appearing for the parties.
2.
For convenience, WP(C) No.898 of 2022 is taken up as a lead
case and the reliefs claimed in this writ petition may be reproduced here-inbelow:
“i. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why Writ in
the nature of mandamus and/or Order or direction shall not be
issued whereby directing the Respondent to regularize the service of
the
Petitioners
in
the
posts
of
Madrassa
Teachers
(General/Science/Arabic), under the centrally sponsored “Scheme
for providing Quality Education in Madrassa.”(SPQEM)
ii. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a writ in
the
nature
of
Mandamus
and/or
order/orders
and/or
direction/directions of like nature shall not be issued whereby
directing the Respondents to pay monthly salary at par with their
equivalent in the State Govt. w.e.f. 01.01.2017 with arrears.
iii. Make the Rules absolute,
iv. Call for records,
v. Pass any further order/orders as this Hon’ble High Court
considered fit and proper.”
3.
Prior to filing of this writ petition by the present petitioners, I
find similarly situated persons had previously filed other writ petitions
claiming same reliefs. One of those writ petitions was registered as WP(C)
No.519 of 2015 titled as Md. Abdul Wahid vs. The State of Tripura and
Ors. Those writ petitions were disposed of by a common judgment and order
dated 05.01.2016 passed by a learned Single Judge of this Court wherein it
was directed thus:
“Having regard to the circumstances as emerged from the submission
of the learned counsel and being alive to the predicament of the
petitioners, this Court is of the opinion that the State may take
appropriate measure to extend some security to the petitioners’
services.
For that purpose, the state shall reconsider the recommendation made
by the State Level Madrassa Advisory Committee afresh to weigh
whether the petitioners and alike can be regularised or extended with
a fair protection of their services. The secretary to the Government of
Tripura in the School Education Department shall place the matter for
consideration of the council of Ministers for their appropriate
consideration, if required the Government of India may be roped in, in
this exercise. The matter shall be placed by the Secretary to the
Government of Tripura, Education Department for consideration of
the Council of Ministers along with a copy of this order within a
period of 3(three) months from the date when the petitioner shall
submit a copy of the judgment to the said Secretary.
With this observation and direction all these writ petitions are
disposed of.”
4.
In pursuance of the aforesaid judgment and order, the Director,
Elementary Education, Tripura had made a communication dated
04.03.2016(Annexure-6 to the writ petition) to the Under Secretary,
Government of India, Ministry of Human Resource Development, which
reads as under:
“No.F.13(49)-DEE/MADRA/2016
Government of Tripura
Directorate of Elementary Education
(Madrasa Education Cell).
Dated, Agartala, the 04/03/2016
To
Smt. Sharda Sharma
Under Secretary,
Government of India,
Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Department of School Education & Literacy,
Room No.124, C-Wing,
Shastri Bhawan, Gate No-6,
New Delhi-110 115.
Reference:- Judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura passed
on 05-01-2016, 11-01-2016 & 13-01-2016.
Subject:- Regularization or extend with a fair protection of services
of SPQEM Under Graduate Teachers.
Madam,
At present 54 Under Graduate Teachers are working under
SPQEM for whom salary @ Rs.5,000/- per month is being paid from the
State fund as Government of India has stopped sanctioning of their
salary since 2013. Out of them 42 UGTs have filed Writ Petition before
the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura for regularizing their services.
Hon’ble High Court of Tripura has disposed of the Writ Petitions with a
direction to reconsider regularization or extend with a fair protection of
their services and if required Government of India to rope in (copy
enclosed) and to place the matter before the Council of Ministers for
consideration.
It is to be mentioned that the State Level Madrasa Advisory
Committee in its meeting held on 31-12-2009 advised the School
Education Department to initiate a proposal for regularization of
services of the then 127 Modernization Madrasa Teachers (renamed as
SPQEM during 2008-09). But State Govt. could not implement the
decision due to fund constraint.
In view of the above, you are requested kindly to take the matter as
an important issue and provide your valuable views to take further
necessary action.
Matter may be treated as court urgent.
Yours faithfully
(U.K. Chakma)
Director
Elementary Education
Tripura
PH & FAX NO-0381 230 7828,
E-mail:-madrasaeducell.tripurastate@gmail.com”
5.
From the above correspondence, it comes to fore that the
Director, Elementary Education, Tripura, one of the respondents of the
present writ petition made a request to the Government of India to initiate a
proposal for regularization of services of the then 127 Modernization
Madrasa Teachers(renamed as SPQEM during 2008-09). It was clarified in
the said communication that the State Government was unable to implement
the decision due to fund constraint. However, under Memorandum dated
07.10.2016(Annexure-7 to the writ petition) the State respondents had
revised monthly salary of teachers under SPQEM, which is reproduced
hereunder in tabular form:
Revised Monthly salary of Teachers under SPQEM(in Rs.)
Category of Teacher
Before completion of 5 years
After completion of 5 years
PGT
12,476
26,580
GT
10,316
21,022
UGT
8,606
16,621
Thereafter, a Memo. dated 13.10.2017 had been issued by the
Addl. Secretary & Director, Elementary Education, Tripura informing the
concerned authorities about the re-allocation of fund not exceeding to
Rs.1,48,19,180/-(Rupees one crore forty eight lakhs nineteen thousand one
hundred eighty) only and the same was accorded to the concerned Inspector
of Schools, H.O. & D.D.Os of the Madrasas during Financial Year 2017-18
for payment of 2(two) months salaries to SPQEM Madrasa for the period
from October, 2017 to November, 2017. However, the said Memo dated
13.10.2017 had been cancelled and the same Department had issued another
Memo dated 26.10.2017(Annexure-9 to the writ petition) reducing the reallocation of fund to the extent of Rs.1,00,08,350/-(Rupees one crore eight
thousand three hundred fifty).
6.
In the aforesaid background of facts, I have heard Mr. P. Roy
Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. K. Nath and Mr. K.
Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners. Also heard Mr.
Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, learned GA appearing for the respondents-State
and Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI appearing for the respondent-Union
of India.
7.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel for the petitioners at
the outset has referred to the scheme namely “Scheme of Financial
Assistance for Modernisation of Madrasa Education, 1994”(here-in-after
referred to as “Scheme, 1994”)[Annexure-1 to the writ petition].
Learned senior counsel for the petitioners would contend that
the said Scheme, 1994 is perennial in nature and since the petitioners were
engaged through proper selection process and had been rendering service for
quite a reasonable period of time, their services are necessary to be
regularized and the petitioners are entitled to get regular pay scale as those of
the teachers employed under the Government of Tripura, if not, at least, the
minimum pay of the basic pay paid to the regular teachers under the State
Government. Giving much emphasis to the Scheme, learned senior counsel
for the petitioners has submitted that the scheme itself postulates that the
teachers appointed under the Madrasas would be treated at par the teachers
of the State Government. Referring to Clause 3 of the scheme, Mr. Roy
Barman, learned senior counsel contends that “The salary for teachers
appointed under this scheme will be the same as given to similar teachers
appointed by the respective State Governments.” Learned senior counsel for
the petitioners has further contended that the objective of the scheme is to
encourage traditional institutions like Madrasas and Maktabs by giving
financial assistance to introduce Science, Mathematics, Social Studies, Hindi
and English in their curriculum.
Proceeding further, learned senior counsel for the petitioners
has submitted that the respondents must comply the judgment and order
dated 05.01.2016 passed by this Court in the case of Abdul Wahid(supra)
and other connected writ petitions.
8.
On the other hand, Mr. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI for the
respondent-Union of India has submitted that the petitioners are not at all
entitled to claim regularization since they are appointed under a specified
scheme formulated by the Central Government. Since it is a scheme,
according to learned Dy. SGI, it cannot be perennial in nature and at any
point of time the scheme may be discontinued. The petitioners are not
holding any permanent post created by the Central Government.
Furthermore, the scheme is voluntary in nature and applicable to NonGovernment Organizations.
9.
Opposing the submissions of learned senior counsel for the
petitioners Mr. Bhattacharyya, learned GA adopting the submissions of
learned Dy. SGI has contended that it is settled proposition of law that
regularization cannot be claimed as a matter of right. The service conditions
of the petitioners are governed by the provisions made in the scheme itself.
Their salary structure is also determined by the Government of India and the
State Government cannot in any way be directed to revisit the pay scale of
the petitioners or to regularize their services under the State Government. To
fortify this submission, learned GA has placed reliance upon the decision of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Rajasthan and Ors. vs. Daya Lal and
Ors, (2011) 2 SCC 429. Concluding his argument, Mr. Bhattacharyya,
learned GA has urged this Court to dismiss the instant writ petitions filed by
the petitioners.
10.
I have considered the rival submissions advanced by the learned
counsel appearing for the parties and have perused the scheme as well as
other documents annexed to the writ petition and the counter affidavits.
11.
On perusal of the scheme, I find that the scheme is purely
voluntary to be fully funded by the Central Government. The scheme is
basically formulated to develop the educationally backward minorities
pursuing their education in traditional institutions like Madrasas and
Maktabs with the inclusion of subjects like Science, Mathematics, Social
studies etc. in their curriculum. Clause 3(I) of the Scheme clearly speaks of
financial assistance where 100% grants to be provided by the Central
Government to ensure the appointment of qualified teachers in Science,
Mathematics,
Social
traditional/voluntary
studies
and
languages
organizations/Government
engaged
aided
in
institutions
such
for
modernization of Madrasa Education.
12.
Further, under Clause 3 of the Scheme, 1994 it is clearly stated
that “In the present scheme, it is proposed to give 100% Central Assistance
for salary in addition to other items of the scheme, in order to encourage the
voluntary organizations to modernize their curriculum.” Clause 5 of the
Scheme, 1994 prescribes Eligibility Conditions, which is as under:
“5. ELIGIBILITY CONDITIONS:
1.
Voluntary organizations/societies/trusts which are registered under
central or state Govt. Acts or Wakf Boards shall be eligible to apply for
assistance under the scheme.
2.
Only those voluntary agencies which have been in existence for
three years would be considered for assistance under this scheme.
3.
Such voluntary organizations should:
-
have a proper constitution of Articles of Association;
-
have a properly constituted managing body with its power and
duties clearly defined in the constitution;
-
be in a position to secure the involvement, on voluntary basis, of
knowledgeable persons for furtherance of their programmes;
-
not be run for the profit of any individual or a body of individuals;
-
not discriminate against any person or group of persons on the
ground of language or sex, etc.
-
not function for the furtherance of the interests of any political
party;
-
not in any manner incite communal disharmony.”
Again, Clause 6 of the Scheme, 1994 prescribes the
implementation and monitoring, which is as under:
“6. IMPLEMENTATION AND MONITORING:
The scheme will be implemented by the State Governments as a
Central Scheme under which 100% financial assistance will be provided to
state Governments for implementation of this scheme. All requests for
financial assistance shall, as a rule, be entertained by the State
Governments on the prescribed application forms. These will be
considered on merits by the State level grant-in-aid committees.
Monitoring report regarding the number of Madrasas receiving
assistance, total number of beneficiary students and the amount received
and utilized by the madrasas, shall be furnished to the Department of
Education, Govt. of India on annual basis. The performance of the scheme
may be reviewed after completion of three years of its operation.
Organisations requesting for financial assistance will apply on the
prescribed APPLICATION FORM.(ANNEXURE-I).
-
The application will be addressed to the Education Secretary
in the State/UT, who will be the Chairperson of Grant-in-Aid
committee in the State/UT.
-
Education Secretary can also nominate any officer to act as
Chairperson in his place if he/she so desires.
Other members of the committee will include:
-
One representative from the Department of Education,
Government of India.
-
One/two
representatives
from
Madrasa
Education
Management/Board.
-
One eminent educationist.
-
TA/DA to attend these meetings will be borne by the concerned
Deptt./Institutions/Organisations
nominating
their
representative to attend the Grant-in-Aid Committee meetings.
The
grant
will
be
admissible
to
only
those
organizations/institutions who will submit the updated statement of
accounts for all the grant-in-aids received by them from central/State
governments for the preceding one year duly certified.
The accounts/records of activities of the organization shall be
available on demand for inspection to Central/State Government.”
13.
I have perused the Scheme, 1994, which has enough relevance
to resolve the disputes raised in this writ petition.
14.
It is stated in the writ petition that the said Scheme, 1994 had
been restructured during the period 2014-15 which covers two special subschemes
namely,
“Scheme
for
Providing
Quality
Education
in
Madrasa(SPQEM)”
and
“Infrastructure
Development
of
Minority
Institutions(IDMI)”. It is further stated that Scheme for Education of
Madrasas and Minorities(for short, SPEMM) comprising of SPQEM and
IDMI will be a Centrally Sponsored scheme, rather than be continued as
100% grant scheme and the funding pattern under SPEMM(comprising of
SPQEM and IDMI) would be similar to other centrally sponsored schemes
i.e., 90:10 for NE States, Himachal Pradesh, Jammu & Kashmir and
Uttarakhand. So, under the revised scheme the funding pattern has been redetermined as 90:10.
15.
Next, on plain reading of the offer of appointments issued in
favour of the petitioners it transpires that the petitioners were offered a
purely temporary post of General Teacher under the Centrally sponsored
Plan Scheme, namely, “Scheme for Providing Quality Education in
Madrasa”(SPQEM) implemented by the Education(School) Deptt., Tripura
on fixed honorarium basis Rs.6,000/-(Rupees Six thousand) only per month
as per schematic pattern of SPQEM Scheme. The terms and conditions of
appointment are as under:
“i) The appointment is purely on temporary basis and till continuation of
this scheme by the Government of India.
ii) Rates of monthly honorarium may be changed as per norms of
Government of India.
iii) The appointed teacher shall have to undergo short course training as
and when organized by the Director of School Education.
iv) Taking of an Oath of Allegiance to the Constitution of India in the
prescribed form.
v) Their fixed honorarium shall be drawn by the Office of the concerned
Inspector of Schools from their respective date of joining.”
16.
It is pertinent to mention herein that the restructured scheme
further provides funding pattern where it is stipulated that Rs.6,000/- per
month for Graduate Teacher and up to Rs.12,000/- per month for Graduate
with B.Ed./Post Graduate/Post Graduate with B.Ed. would be made for
maximum of 3(three) teachers per Madrasa and up to Rs.5,00,000/- per year
per Madrasa Board.
17.
In the light of the aforesaid facts narrated here-in-above, I am of
the firm opinion that the petitioners are not entitled to get their services
regularized under the State respondents. It is revealed that the Scheme is
made for developing the standard of education in the traditional institutions
like Madrasas and Maktabs by way of introducing Science, Mathematics,
Social studies, etc.
The funding pattern is 90:10 ratio, i.e. to fulfill the object of the
Scheme, 90% of the total expenditure would be borne by the Central
Government and 10% by State Government. Hence, the State Government
has minimum liability to allocate fund for the teachers appointed under the
said Scheme, 1994 read with the restructured schemes.
The Central Government has not created any sanctioned post
against which such teachers can be permanently appointed or absorbed. In
the appointment letter, it is clearly written that the appointment is purely on
temporary basis and till continuation of the Scheme, 1994 formulated by the
Government of India.
From the Memorandum of offer of appointment as extracted in
the preceding paragraph[para 15], it is evident that rates of monthly
honorarium also to be fixed by the Government of India and it may be
changed as per norms of the Government of India.
18.
That apart, this Court in exercise of its extraordinary and
discretionary power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India cannot
direct the State to regularize or permanently absorb an employee in absence
of any sanctioned vacant posts considering the financial involvement
necessary for creation of such posts. This Court has no expertise to evaluate
the economic scenario of the State. The financial position is to be considered
by the State Government itself and in this respect, the Court should not step
into the shoes of the Government. The Court also has no power to
unilaterally direct the Government to pay the minimum pay of the basic pay
to the teachers appointed under the State Government since the nature of
appointment vis-à-vis the status and position of the petitioners cannot in any
way be treated as equal to that of the teachers appointed under the State
Government.
19.
Furthermore, it is settled proposition of law that claim of
regularization cannot be made as a matter of right. The equality clause
contained in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India should be
scrupulously followed and the Court should not issue a direction for
regularization of services of an employee which would be violative of the
Constitutional Scheme(Daya Lal(supra)). It is also settled that the salary
pattern in respect of an employee shall be governed by the terms mentioned
in the appointment letter. The concerned employee has preferred to join the
service knowingfully well that on being appointed, he would be paid the
salary which is mentioned in the terms of offer of appointment itself. In the
case of Daya Lal(supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has clearly held that
the right to claim a particular salary against the State must arise under a
contract or under a statute. In the instant case, undisputedly the petitioners
are paid the salary which is mentioned in their terms of appointment vis-à-vis
the Schemes.
20.
That keeping in mind, the submission of learned senior counsel
for the petitioners that the petitioners are entitled to equal pay for equal
work, according to me, the petitioners cannot be treated at par the regular
teachers appointed under the State Government. Here, without amplifying
the matter, it is clear that the status and position of the petitioners is clearly
distinguishable as they were not appointed against any regular sanctioned
posts alike the teachers appointed under the State Government in accordance
with a specified Recruitment Rule framed under Article 309 of the
Constitution of India; in contra-distinction the appointments of the
petitioners directly and manifestly emanated from a Scheme formulated by
the Central Government in a particular situation to achieve a different object,
that is, to standardize education in Madrasas, and similar other organizations
working in this field as stated in the preceding paragraphs.
21.
The above dissimilarities disentitle the petitioners to be treated
at par the teachers appointed under the State Government.
The service
conditions of the petitioners are exclusively governed by the provisions
envisaged in the said Scheme vis-à-vis the memorandum of appointment
encapsulating the terms and conditions mentioned therein.
22.
For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, I do not find
any merit in the present writ petitions and accordingly, the above bunch of
writ petitions stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed by
SANJAY Digitally
SANJAY GHOSH
Date: 2024.02.26
GHOSH 17:34:38 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review