Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Criminal Jurisdiction)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
Sumantra Gupta,
S/o Shri Shaibal Gupta,
R/o Patel Road,
Ward No.2, Siliguri,
District Darjeeling,
P/O. Siliguri and P/S. Bhaktinagar,
West Bengal.
.… Applicant
Versus
…. Respondent
State of Sikkim.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------Application for Anticipatory Bail under Section 438 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
Appearance:
Mr. A. K. Upadhyaya, Senior Advocate with Mr. Sonam
Rinchen Lepcha, Advocate for the Applicant.
Mr. S. K. Chettri, Assistant Public Prosecutor for the
Respondent.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------ORDER
(06.07.2019)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
The locus classicus on the concept of “anticipatory bail”
vis-à-vis the concern for personal liberty under Article 21 of
the Constitution of India is the Constitutional Bench
judgment in re: Shri Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia & Ors. v. State of
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
Punjab1 . The said judgment and the comparatively recent
rendition of the Supreme Court in re: Siddharam Satlingappa
Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.2 were relied upon by Mr.
A. K. Upadhyaya, learned Senior Advocate for the Applicant
who apprehends imminent arrest in view of the lodgment of
First Information Report (FIR) No.0004 dated 16.03.2019 at
the office of the Crime Branch (CID), Police Headquarter,
Gangtok for alleged offences committed by unknown person
under Section 419, 468, 471, 420, 120B of the Indian Penal
Code, 1860 (IPC) as well as Section 66 (C) and Section 66(D)
of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (IT Act).
2.
Emphasizing the need to preserve the personal liberty
of the Applicant the learned Senior Counsel submitted that
the Applicant was not involved in any crime for which
punishment prescribed was death or imprisonment for life.
He pointed out the order dated 04.06.2019 passed by the
learned Judicial Magistrate, 1st Class, East Sikkim and
submitted that the co-accused had already been granted
regular bail. He would draw this Courts attention to a
certificate issued by Katihar Medical College, Bihar dated
25.05.2019 and emphasise that he was a sick person. The
learned Senior Counsel stressed that the Applicant hails
from a respectable family. His father Dr. Saibal Gupta is
1 (1980) 2 SCC 565
2 (2011) 1 SCC 694
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
presently a Professor and Head of the Department of
Forensic Medicine, Katihar Medical College, Bihar and also
its Medical Superintendent and Vice Principal. The Applicant
himself is a Doctor by profession and running a Nursing
Home at Malbazar, Jalpaiguri, West Bengal. The Applicant’s
mother works in a school in Katihar and his wife is also a
medical graduate associated with running the Nursing Home
with her husband. The learned Senior Counsel drew the
attention of this Court to the order dated 30.05.2019 passed
by the learned Sessions Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok in
Criminal Misc. Case (Bail) No. 20 of 2019. This was on an
application for anticipatory bail filed by the Applicant in
anticipation of his arrest for the same FIR for which, after its
rejection, the Applicant seeks protection from this Court.
One of the main contentions, much emphasised by the
learned Senior Counsel, is that the Applicant was not
implicated in the FIR.
3.
The State is being represented from the date of the first
hearing itself. Mr. S.K. Chettri, learned Assistant Public
Prosecutor for the Respondent vehemently objected to the
grant of anticipatory bail to the Applicant. It was submitted
that substantial materials have been collected which directly
implicate the Applicant. The said materials were placed
before this Court for its perusal along with the case diary.
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
The learned Assistant Public Prosecutor submitted that the
Petitioner is also involved in yet another case for which
another FIR bearing no. 201/2018
dated 21.09.2018
(previous FIR) under Section 419 IPC has been registered in
the Sadar Thana, East District at Gangtok against the
Applicant. It was pointed out that the previous FIR also
reflects identical modus operandi as involved in the present
FIR for defrauding aspirants for medical seats in Sikkim
Manipal Institute of Medical Sciences (SMIMS). It was stated
that although attempts have been made to arrest the
Applicant he has been evading it. The learned Assistant
Public Prosecutor relied upon the judgment of this Court in
re: Susanta Kumar Sahoo v. State of Sikkim3 and submitted
that an absconder is not entitled to anticipatory bail.
4.
As held by the Constitutional Bench of the Supreme
Court in re: Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia (supra) Section 438 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C.) which is
concerned with personal liberty cannot be whittled down by
reading restrictions and limitation into it. In order to meet
the challenge of Article 21 of the Constitution of India the
procedure established by law for depriving a person of his
liberty must be fair, just and reasonable. Gurbaksh Singh
Sibbia was a Minister in the Congress Ministry of the
3 (2014) SCC OnLine Sikk. 68
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
Government
of
Punjab.
Grave
allegations
of
political
corruption were made against him. The matter travelled to
the Supreme Court from the judgment of a full Bench of the
High
Court
of
Punjab
and
Haryana
dismissing
the
application for anticipatory bail.
5.
The Constitutional Bench noticed that the Cr.P.C. did
not contain any specific provision corresponding to the
present Section 438 Cr.P.C. It was also noticed that the Law
Commission of India, in its 41st report dated September 24,
1969 pointed out the necessity of introducing a provision for
grant of anticipatory bail. The necessity for granting
anticipatory bail, it was observed in the report arose mainly
because sometimes influential persons try to implicate their
rivals in getting them detained in jail for some days. In
recent times, with the accentuation of political rivalry, these
tendencies were showing signs of steady increase.
It was
observed that apart from false cases, where there are
reasonable grounds for holding that a person accused of an
offence is not likely to abscond, or otherwise misuse his
liberty while on bail, there seems no justification to require
him first to submit to custody, remain in prison for some
days and then apply for bail. It was observed that it would
not be practicable to lay down conditions under which alone
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
anticipatory bail could be granted and Superior Courts
would undoubtedly exercise their discretion properly.
6.
The Supreme Court held in re: Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia
(supra) that in regard to anticipatory bail, if the proposed
accusation appears to stem not from motive of furthering the
ends of justice but from some ulterior motive, the object
being to injure and humiliate the Applicant by having him
arrested, a direction for the release of the Applicant on bail
in the event of his arrest would generally be made. However,
besides making a statement that he is innocent and not
involved in the alleged commission of offence the Applicant
herein has neither pleaded nor placed any material to show
that from some ulterior motive to injure and humiliate him
he was sought to be arrested.
7.
The Constitutional Bench of the Supreme Court also
held that on the other hand, if it appears likely, considering
the antecedents of the Applicant, that taking advantage of
the order of anticipatory bail he will flee from justice such an
order would not be made. The submissions of the learned
Assistant Public Prosecutor were focused on the fact that in
spite of the two FIRs the Applicant has been fleeing from
justice.
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
8.
The fact that the Applicant was aware of similar
accusation made against him in the previous FIR but did not
disclose about it in the application before this Court does not
auger well with his claim of innocence.
9.
Mr. A. K. Upadhayaya submitted that although the
Applicant had in fact approached the Sessions Court for
anticipatory bail apprehending arrest in connection with the
same FIR there was no impediment in law to approach the
High Court for anticipatory bail once again as he was
approaching a higher Court.
10. Section 438 Cr.P.C. permits any person who has reason
to believe that he may be arrested on accusation of having
committed a non-bailable offence to approach the High
Court or the Court of Session for anticipatory bail.
11. The Applicant approached the Sessions Court under
Section 438 Cr.P.C. which was rejected vide order dated
30.05.2019. The Applicant has not filed copy of the
application for anticipatory bail preferred before the Sessions
Court.
The
order dated
30.05.2019
reflects
that
the
Applicant had sought to impress the learned Sessions Judge
that there is every possibility of him being arrested in
connection with the present FIR and that there is no
material against him. It was submitted that the CID is
determined to arrest the Applicant only to humiliate and
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
harass him. As argued by Mr. A. K. Upadhayaya before this
Court it was also submitted before the learned Sessions
Judge that Section 438 Cr.P.C. confers ample powers to
protect the Applicant from unjustified arrest when there is
no material against him.
12. The said application for anticipatory bail before the
Sessions Court was objected to by the learned Public
Prosecutor. It was submitted that the offence is of wide
magnitude having great adverse impact on the society in as
much as large number of gullible students and their parents
were cheated by the Applicant on the false promise of
securing admission in the medical institute. It was pointed
out that clinching materials pointing directly towards the
involvement of the Applicant were available. Though FIR was
registered on 16.03.2019 the Applicant had been evading the
Investigating Officer and thus proper investigation has not
been possible. The involvement of the Applicant could also
be seen from other documentary evidence. It was also
pointed out that the Applicant was involved in a similar
matter earlier and therefore his custodial interrogation was
required and if released on bail there was every possibility of
the Applicant abusing his liberty.
13. The
learned
Sessions
Judge
examined
the
case
materials, including the statements of witnesses, case diary
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
and rejected the application for anticipatory bail. It was held
that the alleged offences could not be viewed lightly and the
same are of great magnitude affecting not only the education
system but the society at large. The role of the Applicant was
prima facie direct in the commission of the alleged offence.
Nothing convincing was put forward to suggest false
implication. No explanation was forthcoming regarding the
involvement in similar incidents on earlier occasion although
the learned Public Prosecutor had submitted that he was
involved. Since the registration of the case it has not been
possible
for
the
investigating
agency
to
contact
the
Applicant.
14. The rejection of anticipatory bail application by the
learned Sessions Judge is not in appeal or revision. The
present application for anticipatory bail is an independent
application filed on 07.06.2019 barely one month after the
rejection of the anticipatory bail application by the learned
Sessions Judge.
15. A three Judge Bench of the Rajasthan High Court in re:
Ganesh Raj v. State of Rajasthan4
while answering the
question whether second or subsequent bail application
under Section 438 Cr.P.C. is maintainable or not held:
2005 SCC OnLine Raj 319
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
“25. In the ultimate analysis, placing reliance on the ratio
indicated in Kalyan Chandra Sarkar's case (supra), we hold that
second or subsequent bail application under section 438 Cr.P.C.
can be filed if there is a change in the fact situation or in law
which requires the earlier view being interfered with or where the
earlier finding has become obsolete. ……..”
16. One ground which has not been dealt with by the
learned Sessions Judge is the ground of illness pressed
before this Court. The certificate of the Katihar Medical
College, Bihar is dated 25.05.2019. The said certificate
advices bed rest for the Applicant for a period of four weeks.
The period of four weeks expired on 22.06.2019. The
application for anticipatory bail was disposed by the learned
Sessions Judge on 30.05.2019 on which date the said
medical certificate dated 25.05.2019 ought to have been
available and if desired pressed before the Sessions Court.
However, there is no mention about any claim for bail on the
ground of illness before the Sessions Court. The certificate
dated 25.05.2019, it is noticed, has been issued by the same
Medical College in which the Applicant claims his father is
the Professor and Head of the Department of Forensic
Medicine as well as the Medical Superintendent and Vice
Principal. In any case it is quite evident that the Applicant
has had more than his share of rest needed for his ailment,
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
if at all. This ground therefore, would not per se entitle him
for anticipatory bail.
17. The next contention which needs to be addressed is the
claim of parity as the co-accused in the FIR had been
granted bail by the learned Judicial Magistrate vide order
dated 04.06.2019. The order dated 04.06.2019 was passed
on an application for regular bail. The learned Judicial
Magistrate thought it fit to grant bail to the Petitioner therein
on the ground that the offence is not punishable with death
or imprisonment for life and that there was nothing on
record to show that the Petitioner shall abscond or tamper
with evidence and witnesses for the prosecution. In the
present case the case diary reflects that the Applicant fled
when sought to be apprehended. In spite of knowledge of two
FIRs lodged against him the record reflects that the
Applicant has failed to join the investigations. A perusal of
the order dated 30.05.2019 passed by the learned Sessions
Judge reflects that the Applicant had filed another bail
application no. 3 of 2015 before this Court in yet another
case. The learned Assistant Public Prosecutor submits that
the failure of the Applicant to join in the investigation has
hampered the investigation. In the circumstances, no parity
can be claimed for an order of anticipatory bail on the
ground that the co-accused has secured regular bail. No
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
further change in circumstance or changes in the law have
been pleaded by the Applicant.
18. Mr. A. K. Upadhayaya strenuously urged that if granted
anticipatory bail he would join in the investigation. The fact
that he had moved the Sessions Court for anticipatory bail
more than a month prior to approaching this Court does
reflect that the Applicant is aware of the accusation of the
commission of cheating by personation; forgery for the
purpose of cheating; using as genuine forged document or
electronic record; cheating and dishonesty inducing delivery
of property; criminal conspiracy; identity theft and cheating
by personation by using computer resource made against
him. It is also evident that the Applicant was made aware of
lodgement of the previous FIR at least during the hearing of
his anticipatory bail application before the Sessions Court.
The case diary however, reflects that he has not only evaded
arrest but fled from justice when sought to be apprehended.
19. This Court is strongly of the opinion that this is
therefore not a fit case for exercising discretion under
Section 438 Cr.P.C. in favour of the Applicant. It does not
sound to reason to arm the Applicant with anticipatory bail
when pitted against such grave allegation of defrauding
young medical aspirants with the lure of admission in
SMIMS. The fact that there are more than one FIR registered
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
for similar offences reveal the gravity of the situation. In
such circumstances, custodial interrogation may be a
necessity and consequently it would greatly harm the
investigation
and
impede
the
prospect
of
further
investigation if the Applicant is granted anticipatory bail.
20. On the touchstone of the law declared by the Supreme
Court in re: Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre (supra) while
considering the prayer for grant of anticipatory bail the
balance in favour of the investigating agency to ensure free
fair
and
full
investigation,
far
outweighs
all
other
consideration sought to be projected in favour of the
Applicant. In any case no ground to satisfy the reason for
which Section 438 was originally incorporated in Cr.P.C has
been urged or made out by the Applicant. Per contra, both
Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia (supra) and Siddharam Satlingappa
Mhetre (supra) were relating to alleged political rivalry. Unless
the investigating agency is given a free hand in the light of
the allegations made against the Applicant the absolute
truth may not surface. The materials collected by the
investigating agency so far placed for perusal before this
Court does reflect prima facie involvement of the Applicant in
the offences alleged. The lodging of more than one FIR for
commission of similar offences for different periods of time
also reflects accusation of repeated commission of similar
Sumantra Gupta v. State of Sikkim
Bail Application No. 01 of 2019
offences. Considering the conduct of the Applicant which has
definitely not been amenable for investigation thus far the
question of granting anticipatory bail does not arise.
21. The application for anticipatory bail is rejected.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
06.07.2019
to/
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review