Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE BASANT BALAJI
MONDAY, THE 7TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 17TH CHAITHRA, 1947
RP NO. 474 OF 2025
OP(C) NO.631 OF 2025 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
REVIEW PETITIONER/S:
SULOCHANA GUPTA
AGED 73 YEARS
HOUSE NO. CC VIII/2109 GUJARAT ROAD, MATTANCHERRY, KOCHI,
PIN - 682002
MINAKSHI GUPTA
AGED 44 YEARS
HOUSE NO. CCVIII/2109 GUJARATI ROAD, MATTANCHERRY, KOCHI,
PIN - 682002
BY ADVS.
SNEHA MARIYA JAMES
SUKUMAR NAINAN OOMMEN
RESPONDENT/S:
RAJKUMAR GUPTA
AGED 55 YEARS
FLAT NO. 6D, BAY VIEW APARTMENT, OPP. CHILDREN’S PARK,
PRINCESS STREET, FORT KOCHI, PIN - 682001
VISHNUKANT GUPTA
AGED 52 YEARS
FLAT NO. 1B, SUN RISE APARTMENT, INDIAN CHAMBER ROAD,
MATTANCHERRY, ERNAKULAM, PIN - 682002
RBG ENTERPRISES PRIVATE LIMITED
CIN: U63022KL2005PTC018653 HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT
DOOR NO. VI/93 JEW TOWN, MATTANCHERRY PO, ERNAKULAM, PIN 682002
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
MAHESH KUMAR GUPTA
AGED 48 YEARS
HOUSE NO. CC VIII/2109 GUJARAT ROAD, MATTANCHERRY, KOCHI,
PIN - 682002
SANJAY KUMAR AGARWALA
RESIDING AT HOUSE NO. CCVIII/2109, GUJARATI ROAD,
MATTANCHERRY, KOCHI, PIN - 682002
REGISTRAR OF COMPANIES, ERNAKULAM
BMC ROAD, THRIKKAKARA P.O., KAKKANAD, KOCHI, KERALA, PIN 682021
REGIONAL DIRECTOR
5TH FLOOR, SHASTRI BHAWAN, 26 HADDOWS ROAD CHENNAI, PIN 600006
BY ADVS.
SHERRY SAMUEL OOMMEN
VYDEHI P.(K/000936/2022)
OTHER PRESENT:
ADV P.B KRISHNAN SR, ADV. AKHIL SURESH, ADV SHERRY SAMUEL
OOMMEN
THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 07.04.2025, THE
COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
ORDER
(Dated this the 7th day of April, 2025)
The review petitioners are respondent Nos.3 and 4 in
O.P.(C.) No.631 of 2025. The O.P. was filed by respondent Nos.
1 and 2 herein, for the following reliefs:
“ a) Call for records in EP/01/KOB/2024 before the
Hon'ble National Company Tribunal, Kochi Bench;
b) Quash Exhibit P-11 and P-14 Orders passed by the
Hon'ble National Company Law Tribunal, Kochi Bench
in EP/01/KOB/2024;
c) Issue appropriate directions to the Hon'ble National
Company Law Tribunal, Kochi Bench, to proceed with
the final hearing and expeditiously dispose of
EP/01/KOB/2024 within a time frame deemed
appropriate by this Hon'ble Court:
d) Grant such other reliefs that this Hon'ble Court
deem fit to grant under the facts and circumstances of
the case;”
2. The review petitioners were not served with any notice in
the O.P.(C) and an ex-parte judgment was passed on 20.03.2025.
The fact in issue is under consideration of the apex court in CA
No.4277-4279 /2023, filed by respondent Nos.1 and 2 and CA
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
4586-4589/2023 filed by the petitioners, and the apex court in
CA 4277-4279 /2023 on 21.07.2023, appointed a mediator to sort
out the issues, as it is a family dispute. It was made clear that
both parties will stay their hands in different proceedings which
may have been initiated in the courts.
3. Because of the judgment passed by this court, the issue
has now resurrected again, which is against the order of the apex
court. It is also contended that the O.P.(C) is not maintainable
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, as they have a
statutory remedy under 421 of the Companies Act. So, there is
an error apparent on the face of the record and the judgment
passed in O.P.(C) is to be reviewed and to be dismissed.
4. The respondents filed I.A.No.1 of 2025 in R.P. under
Order 41 Rule 27 CPC read with Rule 154 of the Rules of the
High Court of Kerala, for accepting Annexs.R1(a) to R1(j).
5. Heard the counsels for the review petitioners as well as
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
for the respondents.
6. The question that arise for consideration is whether the
judgment dated 20.03.2025 requires a review under Order 47
CPC.
7.
The counsel for the review petitioner, Sri.Sukumar
Nainan Oommen argued that NCLT, as per order dated
31.12.2021 in C.P. 114/KOB/2019, CP 119/KOB/2019 and CP
125/KOB/2019, had categorically entered into a finding that the
related party transactions done by the respondents are contrary to
the provisions of law and therefore, they are declared as invalid
and in violation of Articles of Association.
8.
It is an admitted fact that Review Application No.
2/KOB/2022 was filed to review the common order passed on
31.12.2021 and to get clarity of the order. The NCLT clarified the
earlier order by enumerating the consequential reliefs passed in
paragraph 55, which reads as follows:
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
“i. The 2nd and 3rdrespondents (ie, Mr Rajkumar Gupta and
Mr Vishnukant Gupta) have vacated office as directors of
the1st Respondent Companies (ie, Mssrs RBG Enterprises
Private Limited, Mssrs RBG Trading Corporation Private
Limited and Mssrs RBG Retail Private Limited) in
accordance with Sections 167(1)(c) and 167(1)(d) of the
Act with effect from. 31.12.2021;
ii. The 2nd and 3rd respondents are not fit and proper persons
to hold the office of Director or any other office connected
with the conduct and management of any company as
contemplated under section 242(4A) of the Act with effect
from 31.12.2021;
iii.
On a consideration of the documents filed by the
Respondent pursuant to the directions of this Hon'ble
Tribunal on 28.07.2021 and 12.08.2021, the affirmation of
the 3rd Respondent (ie, Mr. Vishnukant Gupta) to the
Review Petition, the reliefs sought for in
IA/195/KOB/2021 shall stand allowed. The Registry is
directed to take necessary action forthwith;
iv. In view of our finding that the 2nd and 3rd respondent have
failed to comply with the provisions of Act governing
related party transactions (including Section 184 and 188),
they shall stand disqualified as Directors of the 1 st
respondent Companies having regard to section 164(1)(g)
of the Act with effect from 31.12.2021;
v.
Mrs. Sulochana Gupta (DIN 02233110) and Mr Radha
Ballabh Gupta (DIN-00643069) shall stand appointed as
Directors of the 1st respondent Companies with immediate
effect;
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
vi.
Mrs. Sulochana Gupta (DIN 02233110) and Mr Radha
Ballabh Gupta (DIN -00643069) are hereby directed to
convene the Annual General Meetings of the 1st
respondent
Companies
in
CP/114/KOB/2019,
CP/119/KOB/2019 & CP/125/KOB/2019 for the years FY
2015-2016 till date and to table the financial statements of
the 1st respondent Companies for consideration of the
shareholders;
vii. The 2nd and 3rd respondent, and their spouses, Mrs Ritu
Gupta and Mrs Anika Gupta are hereby directed to refund
all amounts drawn illegally by them through related party
transactions including remuneration, as disclosed in the
financial statements from FY 2015-16 till date, within 30
days from the date of this order.
viii. The Registrar of Companies, Kerala is directed to notify the
change in the Board of Directors of the 1st respondent
Companies (ie, Mssrs RBG Enterprises Private Limited,
Mssrs RBG Trading Corporation Private Limited and
Mssrs RBG Retail Private Limited) within a period of three
working days from today;
ix. The Bankers of the 1st respondent Companies are hereby
directed to immediately change the signatories to the bank
accounts based on the mandate signed by Mrs. Sulochana
Gupta (DIN 02233110) and Mr Radha Ballabh Gupta (DIN
-00643069);
x.
The above directions shall apply in respect of all other
Company Petitions, ie, CP/119/КОВ/2019 and
CP/125/KOB/2019;
xi. The Registry is also directed to immediately forward a
copy of this order to the Registrar of Companies, Kerala
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
for compliance.
2. With the above said directions, the present Application
stands disposed of.”
The original orders in CP/114/KOB/2019, CP/119/KOB/2019
and CP/125/KOB/2019 along with the review order, were
challenged in Company Appeal Nos.18, 19, 20 and 31 of 2022.
NCLAT did not find any error in the common order dated
31.12.2021 and confirmed the findings in respect of related 3rd
party transactions. But since, there was no specific finding of
operation and mis management, the directions given in the review
applications were set aside, which means the clarity given by
incorporating clauses (i) to (xi) in the final order of the Review
Application was set aside and the matter was remanded back to
NCLT for a limited point as to whether the acts committed by the
applicants fall within the ambit of operation and mismanagement.
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
It is to be noted that the review petitioners have not filed any
appeal against the order dated 31.12.2021. Against the appellate
order of NCLAT, the original petitioners as well as the review
petitioners filed separate appeals as civil appeal Nos.42774279/2023 and 4586-4589/2023 before the apex court and Ext.P5
common order dated 21.7.2023, was passed.
9. Along with I.A.No.1 of 2025 in the Review Petition,
Ext.Nos.R1(a) to R1(j) orders of the apex court are produced.
After the order dated 21.7.2023, on 14.5.2024, the apex court
was appraised of the fact that one of the parties terminated the
mediation and thereafter, the learned counsel appearing for RBG
group was directed to take instructions whether they are willing
to join mediation again and posted the case to 26.7.2024. On
26.7.2024, again the apex court has taken note of the fact and
directed the senior counsel representing the parties to hold a
meeting with the parties to reach an amicable settlement. But, in
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
spite of earnest efforts, amicable settlement could not be arrived
and thereafter, on 17.09.2024, Ext.P6 order was passed staying
the order of remand appearing in paragraph No.44, till the final
disposal of the appeal.
10. Though the review petitioners sought for a stay of the
impugned final order of NCLAT in Company Appeal Nos.18,
19,20 and 31 of 2022 as far as it set aside the order of NCLAT, in
Kochi, in review application in Review Appeal No.02 of 2022 in
CP.Nos.114, 119 and 125 of 2019 dated 16.3.2022, the apex court
did not grant a stay. In such circumstances, the respondents in the
Review Petition had approached this court under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India, for a disposal of the Execution Petition
filed by them as EP. 1/KOB/2024.
11. It is a settled proposition of law and provision under
Order 41 Rule 5 CPC that an appeal shall not operate as a stay of
proceedings under a decree or order appealed from except so far
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
as the appellate court may order, nor shall execution of a decree
be stayed by reason only of an appeal having been preferred from
the decree. Since there was no stay, the NCLT was free to proceed
with the execution petition.
12. One of the grounds raised by counsel for the review
petitioner is that Ext.P11 order of NCLT dated 6.12.2024, was
neither challenged in appeal under Section 241 of the Companies
Act nor in this proceedings, and unless it is set aside, propriety
demands no interference should have been done by this court.
13. Counsel for the petitioner relied on the judgment of
the apex court in Board of Control for Cricket in India and
another v. Netaji Cricket Club and others (2005 KHC 883)
wherein, the court has held as follows:
“91. It is true that in Moran Mar Basselios Catholicos v.
Most Rev. Mar Poulose Athanasius (1955 (1) SCR 520: AIR 1954
SC 526) this Court made observations as regards limitations in the
application of review of its order stating:
"Before going into the merits of the case it is as well to
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
bear in mind the scope of the application for review which
has given rise to the present appeal. It is needless to
emphasise that the scope of an application for review is much
more restricted than that of an appeal. Under the provisions
in the Travancore Code of Civil Procedure which is similar
in terms to Order 47 Rule 1 of our Code of Civil Procedure,
1908, the court of review has only a limited jurisdiction
circumscribed by the definitive limits fixed by the language
used therein. It may allow a review on three specified
grounds, namely (i) discovery of new and important matter
or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was
not within the applicant's knowledge or could not be
produced by him at the time when the decree was passed, (ii)
mistake or error apparent on the face of the record and (iii)
for any other sufficient reason. It has been held by the Judicial
Committee that the words 'any other sufficient reason' must
mean 'a reason sufficient on grounds, at least analogous to
those specified in the rule." but the said rule is not universal.
92. Yet again in Lily Thomas (Lily Thomas v. Union of India,
2000 (6) SCC 224: 2000 SCC (Cri) 1056) this Court has laid down
the law in the following terms
"52. The dictionary meaning of the word 'review' is 'the
act of looking, offer something again with a view to
correction or improvement. It cannot be denied that the
review is the creation of a statute. This Court in Patel Narshi
Thakershi v. Pradyumansinghji Arjunsinghji (1971 (3) SCC
844: AIR 1970 SC 1273), held that the power of review is not
an inherent power. It must be conferred by law either
specifically or by necessary implication. The review is also
not an appeal in disguise. It cannot be denied that justice is a
virtue which transcends all barriers and the rules or
procedures or technicalities of law cannot stand in the way of
administration of justice. Law has to bend before justice. If
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
the Court finds that the error pointed out in the review petition
was under a mistake and the earlier judgment would not have
been passed but for erroneous assumption which in fact did
not exist and its perpetration shall result in a miscarriage of
justice nothing would preclude the Court from rectifying the
error." (emphasis supplied).”
14. The apex court in Sanjay Kumar Agarwal v. State
Tax Officer and another [(2024) 2 SCC 362], held as follows:
“It is very pertinent to note that recently the Constitution
Bench in Beghar Foundation vs. Justice K.S. Puttaswamy
(Retired) and Others, held that even the change in law or
subsequent decision/judgment of co-ordinate Bench or larger
Bench by itself cannot be regarded as a ground for review.
16. The gist of the afore-stated decisions is that
(i)
A judgment is open to review inter alia if there is a
mistake or an error apparent on the face of the record.
(ii) A judgment pronounced by the Court is final, and
departure from that principle is justified only when
circumstances of a substantial and compelling
character make it necessary to do so.
(iii) An error which is not self-evident and has to be detected
by a process of reasoning, can hardly be said to be an
error apparent on the face of record justifying the court
to exercise its power of review.
(iv) In exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47 Rule 1
CPC, it is not permissible for an erroneous decision to
be "reheard and corrected."
(v) A Review Petition has a limited purpose and cannot be
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
allowed to be "an appeal in disguise."
(vi) Under the guise of review, the petitioner cannot be
permitted to reagitate and reargue the questions which
have already been addressed and decided.
(vii) An error on the face of record must be such an error
which, mere looking at the record should strike and it
should not require any long-drawn process of
reasoning on the points where there may conceivably
be two opinions.
(viii) Even the change in law or subsequent
decision/judgment of a co-ordinate or larger Bench by
itself cannot be regarded as a ground for review.”
15. A reading of Ext.P11 would show that the NCLAT only
directed issue of notice with a copy of petition to respondent
Nos.3 and 7, and a rejoinder to be filed within a week and it was
observed that the Tribunal may wait for the outcome of the matter
pending before the supreme court. In order to give a direction to
NCLT, invoking under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,
Ext.P11 need not be set aside. It is also brought to the notice
through I.A.No.1 of 2025 that the review petitioners have already
approached the apex court by filing an I.A. in Civi Appeal No.
4586/4589/2023, to stay the proceedings in execution petition
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
pending before NCLT, Kochi, and the same is yet to be numbered.
16.
On going through judgment dated 20.3.2025, this
court has only directed to take up E.P./01/KOB/2024 and if
pleadings are completed, dispose of the same within a time frame,
since there was no stay from the Hon’ble apex court in proceeding
with the E.P. Hence , I do not find any error apparent on the face
on record to review the same under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC, more
particularly,
when
the
review
petitioners have
already
approached the Hon’ble apex court with a similar prayer.
Therefore, the Review Petition stands dismissed.
Sd/BASANT BALAJI, JUDGE
dl/
RP 474/25
2025:KER:31089
APPENDIX OF RP 474/2025
RESPONDENT ANNEXURES
Annexure R1(a)
A TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION SEEKING INTERIM
RELIEF IN I.A.128185 OF 2023 BEFORE THE HON’BLE
SUPREME COURT IS PRODUCED HEREWITH
Annexure R1(b)
A TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION SEEKING INTERIM
RELIEF IN I.A.138540 OF 2023 BEFORE THE HON’BLE
SUPREME COURT IS PRODUCED HEREWITH DATED 03-072023
Annexure R1(c)
A TRUE COPY OF THE PLAINT IN O.S. NO. 12 OF 2025
IS PRODUCED HEREWITH DATED 07-02-2025
Annexure R1(d)
A TRUE COPY OF THE PLAINT IN O.S. NO. 22 OF 2025
IS IS PRODUCED HEREWITH DATED 12-03-2025
Annexure R1(e)
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT IN
26.07.2024 IN CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4277-4279 OF 2023
WITH CIVIL APPEALS NOS. 4586-4589/2023 IS
PRODUCED HEREWITH
Annexure R1(f)
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT IN
14.12.2023 IN CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4277-4279 OF 2023
WITH CIVIL APPEALS NOS. 4586-4589/2023 IS
PRODUCED HEREWITH
Annexure R1(g)
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT IN
14.05.2024 IN CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4277-4279 OF 2023
WITH CIVIL APPEALS NOS. 4586-4589/2023 IS
PRODUCED HEREWITH
Annexure R1(h)
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT IN
05.08.2024 IN CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4277-4279 OF 2023
WITH CIVIL APPEALS NOS. 4586-4589/2023 IS
PRODUCED HEREWITH
Annexure R1(i)
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT IN
12.08.2024 IN CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4277-4279 OF 2023
WITH CIVIL APPEALS NOS. 4586-4589/2023 IS
PRODUCED HEREWITH
Annexure R1(j)
A TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION FILED BEFORE THE
SUPREME COURT IN CIVIL APPEALS NOS. 45864589/2023 IS PRODUCED HEREWITH DATED 29-03-2025.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review