The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. 15 hrs and prepared inquest report in the presence of available witness. The railway ticket was recovered from the body of the victim which was seized. Subsequently the dead body was sent for post mortem examination. After investigation investigating officer submitted Final report. Pursuant to the filing of the application Respondent Railway Authority contested the case by filing written statement. Learned Tribunal upon considering the evidence and upon hearing the Learned Advocates was pleased to dismiss the claim case by observing as follows:‘The applicant could not succeed in proving by adducing cogent evidence that the deceased was travelling in a train on the date of incident and that his death was caused by injury due to fall from a running. Besides the journey ticket could not be proved to have belonged to the deceased.’ The appellant/applicant being aggrieved by the Judgment and Award passed by the Learned Tribunal has come up with the instant application. Heard Learned Advocate for the appellant and learned Advocate for the respondent. Perused the evidence adduced and materials on record. Learned Advocate for the appellant submits that the Learned Tribunal gave much weightage to the statement of Debu Maity and Prasenjit Kanji before RPF which is internal investigating agency like investigator of insurance companies in motor accident claim cases. Such statement was give…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Biswaroop Chowdhury
F.M.A. 1886 of 2025
Sulata Kanji and Anr.
VERSUS
Union of India
For the appellants/claimants:
Mr. Sujay Sinha, Adv.
For the respondent/Union of India:
Mr. Moti Sagar Tewari, Adv.
Mr. Aritra Shankar Ray, Adv.
Last Heard on: July 30, 2026
Judgment on: August 17, 2026
Biswaroop Chowdhury, J:
The appellant before this Court was an applicant in a case under Section
16 of Railway Claims Tribunal Act 1987 read with Section 124-A of Railways
Act 1989, and is aggrieved by the Judgment and Award dated 24-05-2023
passed
by
Vice-Chairman
(IIu)/KOL/19/2022.
RCT/Kolkata
in
claim
Application
No.
OA
The case of the applicant before the Learned Tribunal may be summed
up thus:On 23/10/2021 the victim who was a resident of Falta on early morning
came to Diamond Harbour station along with his wife Sulata Kanji which was
nearest and convenient railway station from his house and after purchasing a
return Journey ticket from Diamond Harbour to Ghutiari Shariff, both of them
boarded a local train from Diamond Harbour Station. He was on his way to
Ghutiary Sariff to his relatives house and also for some personal work purpose.
On their way they alight at Sonarpur Junction station to catch a train for
Ghutiary Sariff as there is no direct train service available on that particular
route from Diamond Harbour. After completion of his work and brief stay at his
relative’s house they again came to Sonarpur Junction station and boarded a
down Diamond Harbour local train from that station to reach his house at
Diamond Harbour. As the train was very much crowded the victim and his wife
could not board in the same compartment, the victim’s wife boarded adjacent
compartment and the victim only managed to stand near the gate of the
compartment where continuous jostling was going on and when the train
reached at KM post no. 18/5-18/7 in between Sonarpur and Subhasgram
station, due to the pressure of the inside passengers he lost his balance and
fell down from running train and died at the place of occurrence. The victims
wife who was in the adjacent compartment came to know from other
passengers that some person has fallen down from the adjacent compartment.
Subsequently when the train reached Diamond Harbour station she alighted
from the train and waited for her husband but could not find him in the station
after a lot searching she informed his family members about such incident and
also informed his brother who was a resident near Sonarpur. In the meantime
on being officially informed by the booking supervisor of Sonarpur railway
station through a memo which was treated as first information report,
investigating officer of Sonarpur GRPS reached the accident spot at about
17.15 hrs and prepared inquest report in the presence of available witness. The
railway ticket was recovered from the body of the victim which was seized.
Subsequently the dead body was sent for post mortem examination. After
investigation investigating officer submitted Final report.
Pursuant to the filing of the application Respondent Railway Authority
contested the case by filing written statement.
Learned Tribunal upon considering the evidence and upon hearing the
Learned Advocates was pleased to dismiss the claim case by observing as
follows:‘The applicant could not succeed in proving by adducing cogent evidence
that the deceased was travelling in a train on the date of incident and that his
death was caused by injury due to fall from a running. Besides the journey
ticket could not be proved to have belonged to the deceased.’
The appellant/applicant being aggrieved by the Judgment and Award
passed by the Learned Tribunal has come up with the instant application.
Heard Learned Advocate for the appellant and learned Advocate for the
respondent. Perused the evidence adduced and materials on record.
Learned Advocate for the appellant submits that the Learned Tribunal
gave much weightage to the statement of Debu Maity and Prasenjit Kanji before
RPF which is internal investigating agency like investigator of insurance
companies in motor accident claim cases. Such statement was given almost
after 7 months after the incident which clearly violates clause 7(2) of the
Railway Passengers (Manner of Investigation of Untoward Incidents Rules
2003’) which clearly mentioned that investigation by force/RPF must be
completed within sixty days from the date of untoward incident. In the instant
case incident occurred on 23/10/2021 and enquiry report submitted after six
months after the schedule dates therefore veracity of RPF’s enquiry report lacks
credence.
Learned Advocate further submits that journey ticket is verified by
respondent railway itself which is reflected in verification letter in DRM Report.
Learned Advocate also submits that from the statement of Bhanu
Senapati ASI/RPF who went to spot after incident it is clear GRPS found ticket
in his presence. Also as per daily diary entry of RPF which is a part of DRM
report, ticket recovered from accident spot is clearly mentioned in DRM report.
Thus from the Detailed Accident Report (DAR) it is mentioned that ticket
number which is also mentioned in the report prepared by GRPS and also filed
in DRM report.
Learned Advocate further submits that Railway has never disputed, time
of occurrence, place of occurrence recovery of dead body from railway track,
thus railway accident stands admitted.
It is submitted that, the inquest report records deceased travelled with
his wife, due to overcrowding both boarded different compartments the
deceased accidentally fell between Sonarpur and Subhasgram, and relatives
subsequently searched and found the body.
It is submitted that the final report of Police Authority nowhere
concludes that it is a case of suicide, trespass, murder or natural death.
It is further submitted that Court can also take Judicial notice of the fact
that sometimes it is not possible by the enquiry authority i.e. GRPS to write
down and prepare and complete every document like inquest report and
seizure list on the accident spot as in most of the cases accident spot is in such
places where there are vast stretches of multiple railway tracks where trains
continuously pass and standing in stones of track, sometimes in night it is not
possible for the GRPS to note down everything on paper at spot and even
finding and obtaining signature of local independent witness at accident spot
where no body generally wants to sign police documents as witness in fear of
legal trouble.
Learned Advocate also submits that accidental fall is established and the
claimants are entitled to compensation.
Learned Advocate relies upon the following Judicial decisions:Rajni and Another. VS Union of India and Anr.
Special Leave Petition (C) No. 19549 of 2024.
Supreme Court of India.
Anima Sarkar VS Union of India.
FMA. 1169 of 2021.
Learned Advocate for the respondent Railway Authority submits that
seizure list was not prepared at the spot of the dead body neither it was
prepared in accordance with law and as such inquest report and the seizure
list were prepared in a doubtful manner and as such the evidence depends
upon hearse.
Learned Advocate further submits that appellant alleged in the claim
that she was travelling with the victim but she never produced any ticket nor
present in the coach at the time of incident.
Learned Advocate also submits that the inquiry report duly approved by
DRM was submitted wherein it was found that the incident was knock down
and not fall from the running train.
Learned Advocate relies upon the following Judicial decisions:Rajni and Another VS Union of India and Anr.
Special Leave Petition (C) No. 19549 of 2024.
Smt. Kum Kum Roy VS Union of India.
2017 SCC. Online Cal-198.
It is true that different types accidents takes place in the Railway area,
but it is to be remembered that all accidents cannot be termed as untoward
incident. It is only on the untoward incident the compensation can be awarded.
Thus before proceeding to decide on the issue it is necessary to
understand the provision of compensation for untoward incident.
Section 124A of Railway Act 1989 provides as follows:S.124-A. Compensation on accident of untoward incident-When in the
course of working a railway an untoward incident occurs, then whether or not
there has been any wrongful act, neglect or default on the part of the railway
administration such as would entitle a passenger who has been injured or the
dependant of a passenger who has been killed to maintain an action and
recover
damages
in
respect
thereof,
the
railway
administration
shall
notwithstanding anything contained in any other law, be liable to pay,
compensation to such extent as may be prescribed and to that extent only for
loss occasioned by the death of or injury to a passenger as a result of such
untoward incident.
Provided that no-compensation shall be payable under this Section by
the railway administration if the passenger dies or suffers injury due to:-
a) Suicide or attempted suicide by him,
b) Self-inflected injury,
c) His own criminal act,
d) Any act committed by him in a State of intoxicated or insanity.
e) Any natural cause or disease or medical or surgical treatment unless
such treatment becomes necessary due to injury caused by the said
untoward incident.
Explanation- For the purposes of this section ‘passenger’ includes
i)
a railway servant on duty; and
ii)
a person who has purchased a valid ticket for travelling by a train
carrying passengers on any date or a valid platform ticket and
becomes a victim of an untoward incident.
Section 123(C) of the Railways Act 1989 defines untoward incident:S.123(C) ‘untoward incident’ means
i) the commission of a terrorist act within the meaning of sub-section
i) of Section-3 of the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act
1987 (28 of 1987) or
ii) the making of a violent attack or the commission of robbery or dacoity
or iii) the indulging in rioting shoot out or arson.
By any person in or on any train carrying passengers or in a waiting hall
clock room or reservation or booking office or on any platform or in any
other place within the precincts of a railway station or,
2) the accidental falling of any passenger from a train carrying
passengers.
It is the case of the applicants/appellant that the victim fell down from
the crowded train.
It is held in different Judicial pronouncements that in claim for
compensation on account of untoward incident it is always not possible for the
family of the victim to arrange for witnesses who have seen the victim falling
thus reliance is to be made on report of Police Authority and Railway Authority.
However in the instant case the applicant has examined herself as A.W.1
She has specifically stated about accompanying her husband on the date of
accident She has further stated that from Ghutiary Shariff she came along with
her husband to Sonarpur in a train and after getting down at Sonarpur she
and her husband the victim herein boarded Diamond Harbour Local. She also
stated that she boarded ladies compartment and her husband boarded a
general compartment due to overcrowding. In the cross-examination also A.W.1
reiterated that on 23-10-2021 she was travelling in the same train by which
her deceased husband was travelling. She also stated that she was in Ladies
Compartment whereas her husband was in a general compartment. He was
standing near the door of the compartment and due to rush of passenger he fell
down. Thus from the specific statements of A.W.1 it is clear that she and her
husband boarded the same train. Although there is no direct evidence of her
husband falling down from the train but the evidence that the train being
crowded is there and it is further stated that her husband was standing near
the door of the compartment and due to rush of passengers he fell down.
Ordinarily a husband and wife will board the same compartment however due
to certain exigencies they are compelled to board different compartments.
Crowd in general compartment is one of the reason why a lady is bound to
board a ladies compartment while her husband boards general compartment
sometimes standing at the door and sometimes hanging at the risk of his life.
The statement of A.W.1 that she and her husband boarded the same crowded
local in different compartment and the victims body found at the railway track
gives sufficient ground to draw inference of falling down from the train.
In this regard it is necessary to quote the observation of the Hon’ble
Punjab and Haryana High Court in the case of Union of India VS Rajesh Kumar
reported in AIR 2003 PondH-141. The Hon’ble Court in the said decision
observed as follows:‘7. Expansion of Railway Department, laying down more railway lines is
a commendable work but can it be allowed to be carried out at the cost of
respect and dignity of a citizen. He purchases the ticket, pays the money for his
travel but after accepting the money Railway Department is not even bothered
as to whether he has to be given a seat or not. It is expected out of the
Chairman of the Railway Board that he should look into this aspect in the
larger perspective and improvise the method to be followed all over the country
so that a passenger when he buys the ticket travels comfortably after having
been provided a seat because he has paid for it.’
The case of the appellant is further strengthened by the report of the
Police Authority under Section 174 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. In the
said report it was observed that the deceased along with his wife for Special
Requirement went to Ghutiary Sariff by train and at the time of returning to
Diamond Harbour by train the victim and his wife boarded separate
compartment of same train due to overcrowding from Sonarpur station when
the train departed from subhasgram station the wife of the person since
deceased came to know that some person had fallen down from the running
train due to pressure of overcrowding. After arriving at Diamond Harbour wife
of the victim being unable to find her husband after a lot of searching returned
to her home and informed her relatives over phone.
Relatives became suspicious and started searching along the track from
Sonarpur, after arriving near Chanditala they found their relative’s dead body.
As per their belief he fell down from running train and died.
Now the point for consideration is whether the victim was travelling with
valid Railway Ticket.
Upon perusal of report of RPF in Entry 1387 dated 23/10/2021 it
appears that the said personnel found that GRP/SPR conducted search with
dom and found three parts of one Somsung Mobile and one railway ticket was
found from T.shirt pocket but no seizure list was prepared in his presence.
Further in the ‘Detail Accident Report’ the ticket which was recovered
from the passenger at the site is mentioned Bhanu Senapati ASI/RPF.
POST/SRP
in
his
statement
before
Ashutosh
Kumar
Gautam
SI/RPF/Post/SRR(E.O) who has stated that on 13-10-2021 at 16.30 hrs he
was deployed for duty as Duty Officer in C Shift i.e. from 14.00 hrs to 22.00
hrs as detailed by post Commander of RPF/Post/Sonarpur. During his duty
period when he was on round at about 16.30 hrs an information received from
SCNL/SDAH as well as PC/Sonarpur that one incident of knock down occurred
in between Sonarpur and Subhasgram Railway station at km no-18/05. After
receiving the information he along with CT/G Biswas o0f RDF/Post/SPR
rushed to the spot and noticed one dead body of unknown male person aged
about 35 years was lying near km. no-18/05 in between Sonarpur and
Subhasgram Railway station. GRPS/Sonarpur officer and staff found one
railway ticket no-UT M-38348998 from T.Shirt Pocket of deceased person and
one samsung mobile phone in between KM no-18/05-18/07 but no seizure list
was prepared by GRPS/SPR Officer in his presence. He also conducted an
enquiry from local people and it could be learnt that the person was knocked
down by unknown Train. Thus the detail accident report of police authority
mentioning the ticket number recovered and the statement of Bhanu Senapati
mentioning the ticket number which tallies goes to show that the victim was a
bona fide passenger with valid ticket. When report of the Police Authority and
statement of ASI RPF shows railway ticket was recovered the technicality in
preparing seizure list should not be gone into. The Detail Accident Report
statement of Bhanu Senapati, Report submitted by Police under Section 174 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure clearly establish that the deceased was a
passenger with valid ticket. Upon perusal of the record it also appears that
claimant Sulata Kanji had to appear before Ashutosh Kumar Gautam
SI/RPF/POST/SONARPUR, and make statements and from the statement no
contradictions appear.
Thus upon considering the evidence adduced and materials on record
this Court is of the view that the appellants have been able to establish
untoward incident as per Section 124A of the Railways Act 1989. Thus the
appellants are entitled to the compensation as prayed for.
Hence this Appeal FMA-No-1886 of 2025 stands allowed. Judgment and
Award
dated
24-05-2023
passed
by
Vice-Chairman
RCT/Kolkata
in
OA(IIu)/Kol/19/2022 is set aside. The appellants are entitled to compensation
of Rs. 8 lakh along with interest @6% per annum from date of filing claim case
till today. The Respondent Union of India shall deposit Rs. 8 lakh along with
interest @6% per annum before Registrar General High Court at Calcutta. Such
deposit shall be made within 8 weeks from the date of communication of this
Order.
The appellants will be entitled to withdraw the compensation upon
compliance of necessary formalities.
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)
LaterLearned Advocate for the respondent prays for stay of this order and the
same is refused.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, should be
made available to the parties upon compliance with the requisite formalities.
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review