The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
3. BHAWAN MORENA (MADHYA PRADESH) .....RESPONDENTS (MR. B.N. MALHOTRA - ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO. 3 Signature Not Verified 08:41:27 PM INSURANCE COMPANY) This appeal coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the following: Since common question of law is involved in aforesaid M.A. Nos. 721 of 2015, 722 of 2015 and 723 of 2015, therefore, they are heard analogously and are decided by this common judgment. For the sake of convenience, facts mentioned in M.A. No. 721 of 2015 are taken into consideration. These appeals have been filed assailing the judgment dated 09.4.2015 passed by Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Datia (M.P.) in Claim Case Nos. 94/2014 filed by appellants of M.A. No. 721 of 2015, Claim Case No.95/2014 filed by appellant of M.A. No.723 of 2015 and Claim Case No.96/2014 filed by appellant of M.A. No. 722 of 2015 for grant of compensation on account of death of Achal Ahirwar and injuries sustained by Sukhdevi and Santosh Jatav in a road traffic accident occurred on 07.5.2014 involving offending vehicle Tractor-trolley bearing registration No.MP06-AA-3572. At the time of accident, respondent No. 1 Panjab Singh Jatav was the driver and respondent No. 2 Sirnam Singh Gurjar was the owner of the offending vehicle and the vehicle was insured with respondent No. 3 - insurance company. Respondents No. 1 and 2 – driver and owner of the offending vehicle remained abse…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE SUNITA YADAV
ON THE 2nd OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. APPEAL No. 721 of 2015
BETWEEN:1.
SUKHDEVI W/O SHRI ARVIND KUMAR, AGED
ABOUT 30 YEARS, R/O GRAM SANORA, TEHSIL AND
DISTRICT DATIA (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
ARVIND KUMAR AHIRWAR S/O SHRI HARIRAM
AHIRWAR, AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS, R/O GRAM
SANORA, TEHSIL AND DISTRICT DATIA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
(BY MR. AKHLESH KUMAR GUPTA - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
PANJAB SINGH JATAV S/O SHRI MANPHOOL
J A T A V GRAM
VINDWA
CHAMBAL
SARAYCHHOLA (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SIRNAAM SINGH GURJAR S/O SHRI LAYAKRAM
SINGH OCCUPATION: NA SHOBHARAMPURA,
CHAK BHANKARI, THANA RITHOURA, JILA
MORENA (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
MANAGER UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY
LIMITED SURANA BHAWAN (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(MR. B.N. MALHOTRA - ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO. 3 INSURANCE COMPANY)
MISC. APPEAL No. 722 of 2015
BETWEEN:SANTOSH JATAV S/O SHRI ARVIND JATAV R/O GRAM
SANORA, TEHSIL AND DISTRICT DATIA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/3/2024
08:41:27 PM
.....APPELLANT
(BY MR. AKHLESH KUMAR GUPTA - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
PANJAB SINGH JATAV S/O SHRI MANPHOOL
J A T AV GRAM VINDAVA CHAMBAL SAYAR
CHHOLA (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SIRNAAM SINGH GURJAR S/O SHRI LAYAKRAM
SINGH
GURJAR
OCCUPATION:
NA
SHOBHARAMPURA, CHAK BHANKARI, THANA
RITHORA (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
MANAGER UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY
LTD. SURANA BHAWAN (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(MR. B.N. MALHOTRA - ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO. 3 INSURANCE COMPANY)
MISC. APPEAL No. 723 of 2015
BETWEEN:SUKHDEVI S/O SHRI ARVIND KUMAR, AGED ABOUT 30
YEARS, OCCUPATION: MAJDURI R/O GRAM SANORA,
TEHSIL AND DISTRICT DATIA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY MR. AKHLESH KUMAR GUPTA - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
PANJAB SINGH JATAV S/O SHRI MANPHOOL
J A T AV GRAM VINDAVA CHAMBAL SAYAR
CHHOLA (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SIRNAM SINGH GURJAR S/O SHRI LAYAKRAM
SINGH
GURJAR
OCCUPATION:
NA
SHOB HAR AM PUR CHAK
BHANKARI THANA
RITHORA (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
MANAGER UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY
L T D . SURANA
BHAWAN MORENA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(MR. B.N. MALHOTRA - ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO. 3 Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/3/2024
08:41:27 PM
INSURANCE COMPANY)
This appeal coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the
following:
JUDGMENT
Since common question of law is involved in aforesaid M.A. Nos. 721 of
2015, 722 of 2015 and 723 of 2015, therefore, they are heard analogously and
are decided by this common judgment. For the sake of convenience, facts
mentioned in M.A. No. 721 of 2015 are taken into consideration.
These appeals have been filed assailing the judgment dated 09.4.2015
passed by Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Datia (M.P.) in Claim Case Nos.
94/2014 filed by appellants of M.A. No. 721 of 2015, Claim Case No.95/2014
filed by appellant of M.A. No.723 of 2015 and Claim Case No.96/2014 filed by
appellant of M.A. No. 722 of 2015 for grant of compensation on account of
death of Achal Ahirwar and injuries sustained by Sukhdevi and Santosh Jatav in
a road traffic accident occurred on 07.5.2014 involving offending vehicle
Tractor-trolley bearing registration No.MP06-AA-3572. At the time of accident,
respondent No. 1 Panjab Singh Jatav was the driver and respondent No. 2
Sirnam Singh Gurjar was the owner of the offending vehicle and the vehicle was
insured with respondent No. 3 - insurance company.
Respondents No. 1 and 2 – driver and owner of the offending vehicle
remained absent before learned claims tribunal and were proceeded ex-parte.
Respondent No. 3 – Insurance company filed its written statement and
denied the averments made in the claim petition and further stated that the
alleged offending vehicle was not involved in the accident and at the time of
accident, driver of the alleged offending vehicle did not have valid and effective
driving license, therefore insurance company is not liable to pay the
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/3/2024
08:41:27 PM
compensation.
Learned claims tribunal after hearing the parties and going through the
evidence available on record calculated the compensation to the tune of
Rs.62,500/- in Claim Case No.94/2014, Rs.41000/- in Claim Case No.95/2014
and Rs.6500/- in Claim Case No. 96/2014, however, dismissed the claim
petitions of the claimants.
Learned counsel for the claimants argued that learned claims tribunal has
wrongly dismissed the claim petitioners by observing that appellants - claimants
failed to establish the involvement of the offending vehicle in the accident. It is
further argued that learned claims tribunal did not go through the record and the
statements of the witnesses who corroborated the case that the accident
occurred on account of rash and negligent driving of offending vehicle. Further
argument is that after completion of investigation, charge-sheet has also been
filed against respondent No. 1 - driver of the Tractor-trolley bearing registration
No.MP06-AA-3572 which shows the involvement of the offending vehicle in the
accident. Learned claims tribunal has also assessed the compensation on the
lesser side, therefore, impugned award deserves to be set aside and just and
proper compensation be granted to the appellants.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the insurance company argued
that learned claims tribunal on the basis of evidence available on record rightly
dismissed the claim petition filed by the appellants - claimants, therefore, the
appeal be dismissed having no merits.
Heard learned counsel for the rival parties and perused the available
record.
The claimant Sukhdevi has examined himself as AW-1 and corroborated
her case in her oral evidence as well as filed documents of criminal case such as
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/3/2024
08:41:27 PM
FIR Ex.P-1, Spot Map Ex.P-3, Memo of Seizure Ex.P-5 and Vehicle
Inspection Report Ex.P-7 etc. pertaining to this accident.
AW-2 Santosh has also corroborated the statement of Sukhdevi and
deposed that it was the driver of offending vehicle Tractor-trolley bearing
registration No.MP06-AA-3572 who by rash and negligent driving of the vehicle
at the time of accident hit the motorcycle No.MP07-MK-1636 on account of
which deceased Achal Ahirwar died whereas Sukhdevi and Santosh sustained
injuries.
The insurance company has examined B.N. Dwivedi as DW-1.
According to this witness, the offending vehicle is malafidely involved in
connievance with the driver and owner of the offending vehicle just to get the
compensation. This witness has proved statement of eye-witnesses recorded
under Section 161 CrPC during investigation of the criminal case relating to this
accident as per Ex.D-4. Even on the basis of documents filed by insurance
company, it is found that eye-witness Bhupendra in his statement has stated that
the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of driver of offending
vehicle Tractor-trolley bearing registration No.MP06-AA-3572.
The Apex Court in the case of Mangla Ram vs. Oriental Insurance
Co. Ltd.; 2018 AIR SC 1900 has held that in a case where charge-sheet has
been filed against the driver of the offending vehicle points out towards
complicity in driving vehicle negligently and rashly.
The Apex Court in the caes of Kusum Lata and Ors. vs. Satbir and
Ors.; 2011 ACJ 926 has held that in a case relating to motor accident claims,
the claimants are not required to prove the case qas it is required to be done in a
criminal trial. The claimants are required to establish their case merely on the
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/3/2024
08:41:27 PM
touchstone of preponderance of probability.
In the case of Anita Sharma & Ors. vs. New India Assurance
Company Ltd. & Anr.; 2021 ACJ 17 it has been held that strict principles of
evidence and standard of proof like in a criminal trial are inapplicable in motor
accident claim cases. Standard of proof in this is preponderance of probability
rather than beyond reasonable doubt. The same view has also been adopted by
the Supreme Court in the case of Vimla Devi & Ors. vs. National Insurance
Co. Ltd. & Ors.; 2019 ACJ 454 and it has been held that strict proof on
accident caused by a particular vehicle in a particular manner may not be
possible to be done by the claimants. Claimants were merely to establish their
case on the touchstone of preponderance of probability. Standard of proof
beyond reasonable doubt could not have been applied.
In this case, the driver of the offending vehicle has not appeared before
learned claims tribunal to contradict the version of the claimants. Under these
circumstances, learned claims tribunal has wrongly disbelieved the evidence of
the claimant witnesses.
In view of the above discussions, the findings of the learned claims
tribunal that the claimants failed to prove the involvement of the offending
vehicle in the said accident is found to be against the settled principle of law and
evidence on record, therefore, the impugned judgment dated 09.4.2015 passed
in Claim Case Nos. 94/2014, 95/20145 and 96/2014.
Now the question before this Court is whether the learned claims tribunal
has calculated just and proper compensation?
In Claim Case No.94/2014
This case was filed for compensation on account of death of deceased
Achal Ahirwar.
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/3/2024
08:41:27 PM
Learned claims tribunal on the basis of postmortem report has rightly
fixed the age of the deceased as 8 years at the time of accident, however, the
compensation was calculated on the lesser side.
In the case of Kishan Gopal and another vs. Lala and others (2014) 1
SCC 244, Hon'ble Apex Court treated the notional income of deceased child
at
Rs. 30,000/- as including future prospects in place of Rs. 15,000/- as
specified in the IInd Schedule of the M.V. Act and applying the multiplier as
specified in the judgment of Sarla Verma & Others vs. Delhi Transport
Corporation and Another (2009) 6 SCC 121.
Therefore, in view of the case law of Kishan Gopal (supra), National
Insurance Company vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors.; 2017 ACJ 2700 and Smt.
Sarla Verma (supra), considering the notional income of the deceased child to
be Rs.30,000/- multiplier of 17 looking to the age of mother of the child to be
30 years and Rs.70,000/- under conventional heads, total compensation amount
comes to Rs.5,80,000/- [(30000X17) 70000].
As such, claimants of Claim Case No.94/2014 (appellants in M.A.
No.721 of 2015) are entitled for compensation to the tune of Rs.5,80,000/(Rupees Five Lakh Eighty Thousand only).
The compensation amount Rs.41000/- in Claim Case No.95/2014 and
Rs.6500/- in Claim Case No. 96/2014 calculated by learned claims tribunal are
found to be just and proper and no interference is warranted in the same.
Insurance Company is directed to pay the compensation amount to the
claimants of the respective claim petitions along with interest at the rate of 6%
per annum from the date of filing of claim petition till realization. The
compensation amount shall be paid within 12 weeks from the date of receipt of
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/3/2024
08:41:27 PM
certified copy of this order.
If the compensation is in excess to the valuation of appeal, the difference
of the Court fee (if not already paid) shall be deposited by the claimant within
four weeks' from today and proof thereof shall be submitted before the
Registry. Thereafter, Registry shall issue the certified copy of the order passed
today.
Appeals stand allowed to the aforesaid extent and disposed of.
Original copy of this order be kept in M.A. No. 721 of 2015 and a
certified copy of this judgment be kept in connected M.A. Nos. 722 of 2015
and 723 of 2015.
(SUNITA YADAV)
JUDGE
AKS
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/3/2024
08:41:27 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review