Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
26.02.2026
A.Bhar
SL. No. 1
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELALTE SIDE
SA 58 OF 2025
With
IA No.: CAN/2/2025, CAN/3/2025
Sujoy Parui And Ors.
-VersusKaushalya Sarkar And Ors.
Mr. Satyam Mukherjee,
Mr. Purnendu Shekhar Ghosh,
Mr. Saibal Rakshit,
…for the appellants.
Mr. Susenjit Banik,
Mr. Soumyajit Bhatta,
Mr. Prasenjit De,
….for the Opposite Party No. 1 to 7.
This is an application under Order XXXIX.
Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure filed by the
Respondents/plaintiffs with a prayer to direct the
appellants/opposite parties to remove the bamboo and
wood material piled up in front of the suit property to
enable petitioners to get ingress and egress smoothly
to their residential house thereby setting aside and/or
discharging and/or varying the order of injunction
dated April 16, 2025 passed by the Hon’ble Division
Bench presided over by His Lordship the Hon’ble
Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharya in CAN. No-1/2023.
It is the contention of the petitioners that the Hon’ble
Division Bench by order dated April 16, 2025 was
pleased to admit the appeal and direct the parties to
maintain Status Quo as regards possession nature and
character in respect of the suit property and further
directed that the parties shall remain restrained from
creating any third party interest in respect of the said
property till disposal of the said application.
It is further contended that the said
opposite parties after the dismissal of the said title
appeal by the Learned 8th Court of Additional District
Judge at Barasat on September 29, 2023 with the help
of their men and agents have forcefully entered into the
suit schedule property on April 8, 2024 and piled up
bamboo and woods in front of the suit scheduled land
to obstruct the ingress and egress of the petitioners.
It is also contended that one written
complaint was lodged with the Deganga Police Station
but due to the existence of interim order the Police
Authority could not remove the obstruction.
The
Appellants
filed
affidavit
in
opposition to the petition denying the allegations
contained therein.
On 01-12-2025 an order was passed
appointing a special officer to enquire into the
allegations made by the respondents/plaintiffs. It was
observed and directed as follows.
‘The Learned Special Officer shall visit
the suit property and verify as to whether the ingress
and egress of the respondent nos. 1 to 7 is being
obstructed. Further the Learned Special Officer shall
take necessary photographs of the suit property and
the area where the obstruction is being made and after
ascertaining the same as to whether there is any other
alternative of ingress and egress of the respondent no.
1 to 7. The Learned Special Officer shall upon notice to
all the parties and their advocates cause the enquiry.
Such enquiry must be caused within two weeks from
the date of communication of this order and a report
should be submitted on or before 07-01-2026.’
Pursuant to the Order dated 01-12-2025
the Learned Special Officer conducted the enquiry
upon
notice
and
submitted
report
with
certain
observations.
The Learned Special Officer has observed
that on enquiry of the suit property he found that a
single storied building lying and situated about 100
feets away from the main road connected by the
Kuchha road/pathway and there is no boundary wall
in front of the suit property. He found a ruinous
Ambassador Car is standing and in its left hand side
there is a pathway which is measuring about 3 feet
wide approximately through which the respondent nos.
1 to 7 used to ingress and egress. There is no
obstruction of their ingress and egress. He had not
found any bamboo and wood materials piled up in
front of the suit property. He also found that there is
no alternative ingress and egress in the suit property
save and except the Kuchha road/pathway starting
from Shiva Temple on the left hand side of the main
road which is leading to the suit property.
The plaintiffs/respondents took exception
to the report of the Special Officer. It is contended that
Learned Special Officer, considered said R.S. Dag
No.887 as the suit property which can be revealed from
the entire report as he has said that there is Kuchha
road/pathway connecting the suit property with the
metal pucca road and he has also stated that the suit
property is about more or less 100 feet away from the
main pucca road and there is a single storied building
lying and situated about 100 feet away from the main
road
connected
by
the
said
village
Kuchha
road/pathway and there is no boundary wall in front of
the suit property; whereas in the said application being
CAN-No-3 of 2025 it has been specifically mentioned
that the suit schedule property in R.S. plot No-886
which is measuring about 4 decimal of land and
immediately western side of the said land the main
road situates. The R.S. Plot No. 886 is the only
entrance and exit point of the petitioners to the Plot
no-887 where the residential building of the petitioners
situates as such questions of raising boundary wall in
between the two properties cannot arise. It is also
contended that the Learned Special Officer absolutely
failed to consider that the said 3 feet wide path way
cannot be the appropriate passage way for ingress and
egress of an Ambassador car. The Learned Special
Officer has taken several photographs of the said 3 feet
passage but failed to consider the other piled up
bamboos and wood materials situated just beside the
said 3 feet narrow pathway as it appears in the
annexed photographs.
The appellants have filed opposition to
the exception submitted by the plaintiffs/respondents.
It is contended by the appellants that the alleged
ambassador car which is admittedly in a ruinous
condition was brought in front of the residential home
of the petitioners by themselves by availing one of the
other two alternative paths of egress and ingress much
prior to institution of the suit. Thereafter due to
construction on one of the adjacent plots (not the suit
plot) the said alternative paths stood obstructed and
accordingly, the petitioners have not been able to move
their vehicles from plot No. 887. The appellants have
denied that the suit plot No. 886 was at all availed by
the Petitioners/Respondents No. 1 to 7 or that the
same was at all obstructed by the Appellants/Opposite
Party No. 1 to 6.
From specific two photographs appearing in
the page nos. 49 and 50 in the said report it will
transpire that beside the said 3 feet narrow passage
bamboo and other wood materials and some plastics
has been piled up in the said R.S. Plot No. 886 i.e. the
suit property. The basic contention of the petitioners
was that immediately after being lost in the title appeal
on April 08, 2024, the appellants/opposite parties with
the help of their men and agents have forcefully
entered into the suit scheduled property and piled up
bamboo and woods in the suit schedule land to
obstruct the ingress and egress of the petitioners. As
such the petitioner herein has not only referred the
access to their residential house through the suit
property by feet but also by car which they were
unable to ply in the road on and from the date when
such obstruction was created.
Upon considering the material in issue
and upon hearing the Learned Advocates this Court is
of the view that as the Learned Special Officer was
directed to enquire as to whether the ingress and
egress of the respondent no. 1 to 7 is being obstructed
the Learned Special Officer observed in the negative.
However
with
regard
to
the
movement
of
the
ambassador car as it is observed that the car is in a
ruinous condition and is stranded in the place from
2014, and upon perusing the picture of the car this
Court is of the view that at this stage that the car is
not in a moving condition no direction is required to
clear the materials for movement of the car. However
as it appears from photographs that many wooden and
bamboo articles are staged at the suit plot to which the
plaintiffs
has
objection,
plaintiffs/respondents
have
and
as
the
obtained
decree
with
regard to the suit plot the plaintiffs/respondents have
right to use the suit plot freely without interference by
defendants. As it is the case of the plaintiffs that the
obstruction is made after the order passed by the
appellate Court at this stage it would be just and
reasonable to permit the defendants appellants to keep
the bamboo and wooden articles where it is lying
subject to the deposit of costs of Rs. 10,000/-. This
deposit is a security amount subject to the result of the
appeal.
In
the
event
appeal
succeeds
the
defendants/appellants will be permitted to take back
the
deposit
and
in
the
event
appeal
fails
plaintiffs/respondents will be paid the security deposit.
Hence application CAN-3 of 2025 stands
disposed. The defendants/appellants are permitted to
keep the bamboo and wooden articles in the suit plot
which is lying at present, subject to the deposit of costs
of Rs. 10,000/- before the Registrar General High
Court Calcutta. In the event appeal succeeds the
defendants/appellants will be permitted to withdraw
the
security
deposit.
In
the
event
appeal
fails
plaintiffs/respondents will get the security deposit and
articles in suit plot will have to be removed. The
Learned Special Officer stands discharged. Let a final
remuneration of 100 G.M. be paid to Learned Special
Officer by the respondents. Costs to be deposited
within 2 weeks.
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review