Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
AD 31
S. Banerjee
AR (Ct.)
HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Hiranmay Bhattacharyya
WPA 28380 of 2025
Suja Uddin Molla & Ors.
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the petitioners
:
Mr. Amit Kumar Pan
Ms. Tanusri Santra
For the State-respondent
:
Mr. Asish Kumar Guha
Mr. Jayak Kumar Gupta
Heard on
:
20.03.2026
Judgement on
:
20.03.2026
Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.:
1. Petitioners claim to be the recorded owners of RS Plot No.
1393/2019 within Mouza – Benjanharia, JL No. 14, under Budge
Budge Police Station, in the district of South 24 Parganas.
2. Petitioners allege that their property was initially requisitioned by
initiating a proceeding under Section 3 of the West Bengal Land
(Requisition and Acquisition) Act, 1948 (‘1948 Act’, for short)
followed by issuance of a notice under Section 4(1a) of the 1948
Act. Petitioners state that no award was declared under the 1948
Act during the lifetime of the said Act.
3. Mr. Pan, learned advocate appearing for the petitioners submits
that the property of the petitioners has been utilised but no
compensation has been paid to the petitioner till date. He submits
that since no award was declared within the specified time limit
indicated under Section 7A of the 1948 Act, the notice of
acquisition stood lapsed. He submits that no further step was
taken to convert the acquisition initiated under Section 1948 Act
by invoking the provisions laid down under Section 9(3A) or 9(3B)
of the Land Acquisition (West Bengal amendment) Act, 1997 (‘the
1997 Act’, for short). He submits that since in the meantime the
Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (Act 30 of 2013) has
come into force with effect from January 1, 2014, the respondent
authority should be directed to initiate a fresh acquisition
proceeding under the 2013 Act and to pay compensation in terms
of the said Act.
4. Mr. Gupta, learned advocate appearing for the State submits that
no land acquisition proceeding was initiated under the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 (‘the 1894 Act’, for short) or the Land
Acquisition (West Bengal amendment) Act, 1997. He, therefore,
submits that the land acquisition proceeding cannot be declared to
have lapsed under Section 24 of the 2013 Act as such lapsing
would occur only if a proceeding was initiated under Act I of 1894.
5. Heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective parties
and perused the materials placed.
6. The following facts are not in dispute:
a) One land acquisition proceeding being LA case No. LAII/50(A) of 1967-68 was initiated as per the proposal of the
Superintending Engineer, Flood Circle, Irrigation and
Waterways Directorate for acquisition of 9.0065 acres of
land including of Mouza – Benjanharia and Joychandipur
including RS Plot No. 1393/2019 , JL No. 14 within Budge
Budge Police Station for Charial Diversion Khal under
Charial Basin Drainage Scheme. RS plot nos. 2019 and
1393/2019 are same;
b) The order of requisition under Section 3(1) of the 1948 Act
was passed on December 9, 1968;
c) Possession of the requisitioned land was taken and
delivered to the requiring body on January 16, 1969;
d) Notification under Section 4(1a) of the 1948 Act was
published in the Calcutta Gazette dated May 17, 1974;
7. It has been specifically admitted in the status report that the
award could not be declared within March 31, 1997, i.e., the date
on which the 1948 Act stood expired due to lack of necessary
funds from the Requiring Body.
8. Thus from the stand of the State as reflected in the status report
filed by the respondent, it is evident that no award was passed
during the lifetime of the 1894 Act and the plot in question has
been utilised.
9. The State is also not in a position to restore possession of the said
property to the petitioner/land owner.
10. The issue that falls for consideration is whether the petitioners
are entitled to compensation as per the provision of the 2013 Act.
11. A more or less identical issue fell for consideration before this
Court in the case of Jamaluddin Momin –Vs.- State of West Bengal
& Ors. (WPA 7380 of 2015). In Jamaluddin Momin (supra) it was
held thus:
“14. The 1948 Act was amended by the West Bengal
Land (Requisition and Acquisition) (Amendment)
Act, 1994 which was published in the Calcutta
Gazette on 31.03.1994. By virtue of the said
Amendment Act, Section 3 of the 1948 Act was
omitted. Therefore, the power of the State to
requisition any land was taken away by virtue of the
Amendment Act, 1994 with effect from 01.04.1994.
The validity of the 1948 Act was also extended till
31.03.1997 by virtue of the said Amendment Act.
15. The 1894 Act was also amended by W.B. Act VII
of 1997 in its application to the State of West
Bengal. By virtue of such amendment, sub-sections
(3A) and (3B) were incorporated after Section 9(3) of
the 1894 Act.
16. Sub-sections (3A) and (3B) of Section 9 of the
1894 Act as incorporated by way of amendment is
extracted hereinafter.
"(3-A) The Collector shall also serve
notice to the same effect on all such persons
known or believed to be interested in any
land, or to be entitled to act for persons so
interested, the possession whereof has
already been taken on requisition under
section 3 of the West Bengal Land
(Requisition and Acquisition) Act, 1948
(hereinafter referred to in this section as the
said Act), as re-enacted by the West Bengal
Land (Requisition and Acquisition) Reenacting Act, 1977, and, in every such case,
the provisions of sub-section (1) of section 4,
section 5, section 5-A, section 6, section 7
and section 8 of this Act shall be deemed to
have been complied with:
Provided that the date of notice under
this sub-section shall be the date of reference
for the purpose of determining the value of
such land under this Act:
Provided further that when the
Collector has made an award under section
11 in respect of any such land, such land
shall, upon such award, vest absolutely in
the Government, free from all encumbrances.
(3-B) The Collector shall also serve notice to the
same effect on all such persons known or believed
to be interested in any land, or to be entitled to act
for persons so interested, the possession whereof
has already been taken on requisition under
section 3 of the said Act, and notice for acquisition
of such land has also been published under subsection (1-a) of section 4 of the said Act, and, in
every such case, the provisions of section 4, section
5, section 5-A, section 6, section 7, section 8 and
section 16 of this Act shall be deemed to have been
complied with:
Provided that the date of publication of notice
under sub-section (1- a) of section 4 of the said Act
shall be the date of reference for the purpose of
determining the value of such land under this Act:
Provided further that in every such case, the
Collector shall make an award under section 11 in
respect of such land only for the purpose of
payment of due compensation to the persons
interested in such land has, upon the Collector
taking possession
thereof, already vested
absolutely in the Government, free from all
encumbrances."
17. Section 9(3B) comes into play where notice under
Section 4(1a) of the 1948 Act has been issued. Since
admittedly notice under Section 4(1a) has not been
issued in the case on hand, Section 9(3B) do not have
any manner of application.
18. Section 9(3A) states that in a case where
possession has already been taken on requisition
under Section 3 of the 1948 Act, the provisions of
Sections 4(1), 5, 5A, 6, 7 and 8 of the 1894 Act shall be
deemed to have been complied with.
19. Proviso thereto states that the date of notice under
Section 9(3A) shall be the date of reference for the
purpose of determining the value of such land under
the 1894 Act.
20. Second proviso states that when the Collector has
made an award under Section 11 in respect of any
such land, shall land, shall upon such award, vest
absolutely
in
the
Government
free
from
all
encumbrances.
21. In the case on hand, possession of the land was
taken under Section 3 of the 1948 Act. Such
possession was taken on requisition. In the absence of
any notice being published under Section 4(1a) of the
1948 Act, the question of vesting of the land as
contemplated under Section 4(2) of the said Act does
not arise.
22. 1948 Act, however, stood expired due to efflux of
time after 31.03.1997. With the expiry of the 1948 Act,
the requisition also ended and the State was obliged to
restore possession of such lands to the land owner/
petitioner.
The
W.B.
Amendment
Act,
however,
empowers the State to continue with possession of
such lands by resorting to Section 9(3A) of the 1894
Act.
23. The effect of the Land Acquisition (West Bengal
Amendment) Act, 1997 fell for consideration in Sabitri
Devi vs. State of W.B. reported at (2002) 3 CHN 108
wherein it was held that revalidation has the effect of
reviving the requisition for acquisition. In paragraph
41 of the said report it has been held that –
"41. The revalidation has the effect of reviving the
requisition for acquisition. As such it is only on the
issue of notices under subsection (3A) or (3B) of
section 9 of 1894 Act, the revalidation takes, effect.
The requisition having ended on the effacement of
the statute the property is to be restored to the
owner. It could also be treated to have been ended
for acquisition where notices under section 4(1a) of
1948 Act stood lapsed before 31st March, 1997. By
reason of 1997 Amendment in West Bengal of
1894 Act a fiction is created. By reason of such
fiction the requisition would stand converted into
acquisition with the issue of notice under section
9(3A) of the 1894 Act, as amended in 1997 in West
Bengal. As soon section 9(3A) is resorted to, the
possession, if continued after requisition and not
restored, shall be deemed to be a possession
revalidated under the Land Acquisition Act which
then would be a possession for acquisition on the
issue of the notification/notice under section
9(3A).........................................."
24. In case the State resorts to Section 9(3A), the
possession of lands taken on requisition and not yet
restored to the land owners shall be deemed to be a
possession revalidated under the 1894 Act. Such
possession would then be a possession for acquisition
upon issuance of notice under Section 9(3A) of the
1894 Act.
25. It is evident from the Memo dated 10.08.2011
issued by the Collector, Murshidabad to the Principal
Secretary to the Government of West Bengal, Land and
Land Reforms Department which has been annexed to
the affidavit-in-opposition of the State that notice
under Section 9(3A) has not been served to the
concerned parties as the fund was not available. The
affidavit was affirmed sometimes in the month of
September, 2022.
26. Section 9(3A) of the 1894 Act casts an obligation
upon the State to serve notice on all such persons
known or believed to be interested in any land or to be
entitled to act for the persons so interested in a case
where possession of the land was taken under Section
3 of the 1948 Act to revive the requisition for
acquisition.
27. In view of the admitted fact that notice under
Section 9(3A) has not been served upon the concerned
person, this Court is of the considered view that the
proceedings initiated under 1948 Act stood lapsed with
the
effacement
of
the
said
statute.
This
Court
accordingly holds that the authorities of the State are
possessing the lands in question illegally and forcibly
without any authority of law.
28. In the case on hand, possession of the land was
taken over in exercise of the power of requisition under
a temporary statute. Such statute was valid till
31.3.1997.
Such
land
has
been
utilised
for
a
permanent purpose without taking any steps to
acquire the same. The power to acquire lands falls
within the purview of eminent domain of the State.
Article 300A of the Constitution of India states that no
person can be deprived of his property save by
authority of law. The land acquisition laws provide a
complete mechanism for deprivation of property of a
person in accordance with law. Such laws provide for
payment of fair compensation to the land losers.
Alleged payment of 80% of the estimated land value, by
no stretch of imagination, can be construed to be a fair
compensation in accordance with the relevant statute
that provides for acquisition of land. Therefore,
utilisation
of
property
without
payment
of
fair
compensation to the land owner(s) is in violation of
Article 300A of the Constitution of India. Such act
amounts to colourable exercise of power by the State
and the State is duty bound to pay compensation in
accordance with law. Since the land owner is deprived
of
his
property,
State
is
obliged
to
pay
fair
compensation to such land owner in accordance with
law.
29. It is not in dispute that the property in question
has been utilised for the purpose of construction of
road. State is also not in a position to restore the land
to the land owners. The proceedings under the 1948
Act has already been held to have lapsed. The 1894
Act has since been replaced and the 2013 Act has
come into force with effect from 01.01.2014.
30. In Aziman Bibi (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court
after noting that the land owned by the writ petitioners
has been utilised pursuant to the initial declaration
and also noticing that the acquisition proceeding stood
lapsed, directed the State to take steps for notifying
the
acquisition
once
again
and
determine
compensation in accordance with law.
31. In Ganesh Samanta (supra), the notice under
Section 4(1a) stood lapsed. The Hon'ble Division Bench
after noticing the Special Bench decision of this Court
in State of West Bengal vs. Sabita Mondal reported at
(2011) 3 CHN (Cal) 555 held that the State Government
could have completed the acquisition proceeding by
applying the provision of Section 9(3A) of the Land
Acquisition Act. However, in view of the subsequent
development
in
Land
Acquisition
laws
with
the
enactment of the 2013 Act, and particularly in view of
Section 24(1)(a) of the said Act, the Hon'ble Division
Bench directed the State to complete the acquisition
proceeding by following the relevant provisions of the
2013 Act.
32. As the State has utilised the lands in question and is
not in a position to restore possession of the lands to the
petitioner/ land owner and also that the proceeding under
the 1948 Act stood lapsed, the proposition laid down in
Aziman Bibi (supra), and Ganesh Samanta (supra) shall
squarely apply to the case on hand. This Court, therefore,
holds that the State respondents should be directed to
initiate a proceeding for acquisition afresh in accordance
with the 2013 Act and to complete the same within a
stipulated time.”
12. The decision in Jamaluddin Momin (supra) shall squarely apply
to the case on hand. Accordingly, this Court holds that the
respondents authorities should be directed to initiate a proceeding
for acquisition afresh in accordance with the 2013 Act and to
complete the same within a stipulated time.
13. In view thereof, the writ petition stands allowed.
14. The respondents, including the Collector, South 24 Parganas,
being the 2nd respondent, are directed to take steps for initiating a
proceeding for acquisition afresh in terms of the provisions of Right
to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 and to complete the
same including payment of compensation as expeditiously as
possible but positively within a period of six months from the
receipt of a server copy of this order.
15.
There shall be, however, no order as to costs.
16. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance of requisite formalities.
(Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review