Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
TELEN
KOM
JOHN TELEN KOM
Date: 2023.08.11
13:44:05 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.1082 of 2022
1. Suhas Chakma, Director, National Campaign Against Torture having its
office at C-3/441, Janakpuri, New Delhi-110058.
2. Smt. Soibam Anju Devi, aged about 44 years, Wife of late Palungbam
Kunjabihari Bose of Lairikyengbam makha Leikai, PO & PS Porompat,
Imphal East, Manipur-795010.
3. Smt. Ningthoujam Edina Devi, aged about 39 years, wife of late
Ningthoujam Ananda Singh of Moirangkampu Sajeb Makha Leikai, PS
Porompat & Sawombung Sub-Division, Imphal East, Manipur-795010.
…Petitioners
– Versus –
1. The State of Manipur represented by the Chief Secretary to the
Government of Manipur having its office at old Secretariat, Babupara,
PO 7 PS Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
2. The National Human Rights Commission through its Registrar having
its office at GPO Complex, Manav Adhikar Bhawan, C Block, INA, New
Delhi-110023.
…. Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. O. Kiranjit, Adv & Y. Arunkumar,
Adv.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Shyam Sharma, GA.
Date of reserved.
:
27.06.2023
Date of Judgment & Order :
02.08.2023.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr.Y. Arunkumar, learned counsel for the petitioners and Mr.
Shyam Sharma, the learned Government Advocate for the respondents.
[2]
The writ petition has been filed by the petitioners for issuance of a
writ of mandamus directing the first respondent to comply with the order dated
5.3.2020 passed in NHRC Case No.42/14/4/08-09-FE and to pay an amount of
Rs.5 lakh each as monetary compensation to the next of kin of two deceased
persons, namely Ningthoujam Ananda Singh and Palungbam Kunabihari @
Bose @ Abung and to submit a compliance report along with proof of payment.
[3]
The case of the petitioners is that the first petitioner has filed a
Complaint Case No.42/14/4/08-09-FE before the National Human Rights
Commission (NHRC) in connection with killing of Ningthoujam Ananda Singh
and Palungbam Kunabihari @ Bose @ Abung in a fake encounter by the Manipur
Police Commandos and 16th Assam Rifles at Kanglatombi Makhan Road, Imphal
on 21.1.2009. Despite the recommendation of the NHRC to pay monetary relief
to the next of kin of the two deceased, the first respondent has failed to comply
with the recommendation of the NHRC. The second respondent has also failed
to fulfil its statutory obligation to enforce its order dated 5.3.2020. Earlier, the
first petitioner has approached the Delhi High Court for enforcement of the
recommendation made by the NHRC, however, the same was dismissed with
liberty to approach the Manipur High Court. Hence, the petitioners have filed the
present writ petition.
[4]
The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that, by the order
dated 5.3.2020, the second respondent recommended monetary relief to the
next of kin of the deceased Ningthoujam Ananda Singh and Palungbam
Kunabihari @ Bose @ Abung. However, the first respondent has failed to
comply with the said recommendation of the second respondent till date.
[5]
The learned counsel would submit that the first respondent is duty
bound to implement the orders passed by the second respondent and that the
first respondent has not preferred any appeal against the order dated 5.3.2020
passed by the second respondent and allowed the order to attain finality.
Therefore, the inaction of the respondents is violative of Article 21 of the
Constitution of India. Thus, a prayer has been made to direct the first respondent
to comply with the order dated 5.3.2020 passed in NHRC Case No.42/14/4/0809/FE within the stipulated time.
[6]
Refuting the submissions made by the learned counsel for the
petitioner, the learned Government Advocate submitted that there is no merit in
the writ petition and, therefore, the same is liable to be dismissed.
[7]
This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused the
materials available on record.
[8]
It appears that on 28.1.2009, the first petitioner lodged a complaint
with the second respondent against the alleged extra-judicial killing of
Ningthoujam Ananda Singh and Palungbam Kunabihari @ Bose @ Abung by a
combined force of Manipur Police Commandos and the 16th Assam Rifles at
Kanglatombi Makhan Road, Imphal.
The second respondent, after taking
cognizance and upon hearing the parties, held that the deceased were killed by
the combined force in an extra-judicial manner and their right to life was violated
by the police. After issuance of show cause notice under Section 18 of the
Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 and after calling for response from the first
respondent, vide order dated 5.2.2020, the second respondent recommended
payment of Rs.5 lakh each as monetary compensation to the next of kin of the
two deceased namely Ningthoujam Ananda Singh and Palungbam Kunabihari
@ Bose @ Abung and submit a compliance report along with proof of payment
within six weeks positively. It also appears that subsequent to the passing of the
order, on 21.9.2020, the second respondent wrote a letter to the first respondent
and directed to submit the compliance report of the order dated 5.3.2020 and
closed the case observing that it will be open for the next of kin of the deceased
to approach the competent Court of law for claiming the relief.
[9]
Being aggrieved by the closure of the case without seeking
compliance of the order dated 5.3.2020, the first petitioner has filed W.P.(C)
No.1939 of 2021 before the Delhi High Court. By the order dated 20.9.2022, the
Delhi High Court dismissed the said writ petition. While dismissing the writ
petition, the Delhi High Court granted liberty to the petitioner therein to approach
the jurisdictional High Court. The operative portion of the order dated 20.9.2022
reads thus:
“5. The Court notes that the entire issue emanates from the order of
05 March 2020 which dealt with certain incidents which are stated to
have taken place in the State of Manipur. In that view of the matter
and since it would always be open for the petitioner to approach the
jurisdictional High Court for enforcement of orders that may have
been passed by the Commission, the Court finds no ground to
continue this writ petition any further. It shall consequently stand
dismissed with liberty reserved as aforesaid.”
[10]
The order dated 20.09.2022 has been passed by the Delhi High
Court after hearing the respondent State and the NHRC and pursuant to the
liberty aforesaid, the petitioners have filed the present writ petition.
[11]
As stated supra, the NHRC directed the Chief Secretary of the
Government of Manipur to pay an amount of Rs.5 lakh each as monetary
compensation to the next of kin of the deceased persons. The first petitioner is
the Director of the National Campaign for Prevention of Torture and the
petitioners 2 and 3 are the next kin of the deceased Ningthoujam Ananda Singh
and Palungbam Kunabihari @ Bose @ Abung respectively. There is no dispute
on it.
[12]
As could be seen from the records that after passing of the order
dated 5.3.2020, the petitioners have approached the NHRC and complained
about the non-compliance of the direction/recommendation made by the NHRC.
In fact, the NHRC had also addressed a letter to the Chief Secretary of the State
of Manipur to take steps for compliance of the order.
[13]
As rightly argued by the learned counsel for the petitioners, the
order dated 5.3.2020 passed by the second respondent has attained finality. In
the absence of the order dated 5.3.2020 being set aside, modified and/or
reviewed, it is the bounden duty of the first respondent to comply with the
recommendation made by the NHRC. The failure of the compliance of the order
of the second respondent by the first respondent is defeated the purpose of
enacting the legislation.
[14]
The National Human Rights Commission, after considering the
provisions of the Act which have been made to enforce the constitutional
protection of life and liberty by enabling the Commission to grant compensation
for violations of human rights, has rightly recommended compensation of Rs.5
lakh each payable by the first respondent to the next of kin of the deceased
persons. As stated supra, in the absence of the order dated 5.3.2020 being set
aside by the higher forum/court, it is the duty of the first respondent to comply
with the said direction issued the second respondent.
[15]
In a catena of decisions, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the
State Governments are expected to abide by the directions issued by the NHRC
in regard to compensation and other issues as may arise from time to time. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court has also held that if the people of our country are
deprived of human rights or cannot have them enforced, democracy itself would
be in peril.
[16]
In the case on hand, having recommended compensation to the
next of kin of the deceased by the second respondent, the petitioners 2 and 3
who are wife of late Palungbam Kunjabihari Bose and the wife of Ningthoujam
Ananda Singh, have not yet received the compensation and for one reason or
the other, the first respondent is dragging the matter, which necessitated the
petitioners to approach this Court for direction to direct the first respondent to
comply with the order dated 5.3.2020 passed in NHRC Case No.42/14/4/0809/FE. This Court is of the view that there appears to be some merit in the case
of the petitioners and, accordingly, they are entitled to the relief prayed for in the
writ petition.
[17]
At this juncture, this court feels it just and proper to refer to certain
observations of a Full Bench of the Madras High Court in the case of Abdul
Sathar vs. The Principal Secretary to Government, Home Department and Ors.
[Order dated 5.2.2021 passed in W.P.No.41791 of 2006 etc. batch cases], which
read thus:
“490. In the conspectus of the above discourse, the following is our
summation to the terms of the Reference:
(i) Whether the decision made by the State Human Rights
Commission under Section 18 of the Protection of Human Rights Act,
1993, is only a recommendation and not an adjudicated order
capable of immediate enforcement, or otherwise?
Ans: The recommendation of the Commission made under Section
18 of the Act, is binding on the Government or Authority. The
Government is under a legal obligation to forward its comments on
the Report including the action taken or proposed to be taken to the
Commission in terms of Sub Clause (e) of Section 18. Therefore, the
recommendation of the H.R. Commission under Section 18 is an
adjudicatory order which is legally and immediately enforceable. If
the concerned Government or authority fails to implement the
recommendation of the Commission within the time stipulated under
Section 18(e) of the Act, the Commission can approach the
Constitutional Court under Section 18(b) of the Act for enforcement
by seeking issuance of appropriate Writ/order/direction. We having
held the recommendation to be binding, axiomatically, sanctus and
sacrosanct public duty is imposed on the concerned Government or
authority to implement the recommendation. It is also clarified that if
the Commission is the petitioner before the Constitutional Court
under Section 18(b) of the Act, it shall not be open to the concerned
Government or authority to oppose the petition for implementation of
its recommendation, unless the concerned Government or authority
files a petition seeking judicial review of the Commission's
recommendation, provided that the concerned Government or
authority has expressed their intention to seek judicial review to the
Commission's recommendation in terms of Section 18(e) of the Act.
(ii) Whether the State has any discretion to avoid implementation of
the decision made by the State Human Rights Commission and if so,
under what circumstances?
Ans: As our answer is in the affirmative in respect of the first point of
Reference, the same holds good for this point of Reference as well.
We having held that the recommendation is binding, the State has no
discretion to avoid implementation of the recommendation and in
case the State is aggrieved, it can only resort to legal remedy seeking
judicial review of the recommendation of the Commission.
(iii) Whether the State Human Rights Commission, while exercising
powers under sub-clauses (ii) and (iii) of clause (a) of Section 18 of
the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, could straight away issue
orders for recovery of the compensation amount directed to be paid
by the State to the victims of violation of human rights under subclause (i) of clause (a) of Section 18 of that enactment, from the
Officers of the State who have been found to be responsible for
causing such violation?
Ans: Yes, as we have held that the recommendation of the
Commission under Section 18 is binding and enforceable, the
Commission can order recovery of the compensation from the State
and payable to the victims of the violation of human rights under Sub
Clause (a)(i) of Section 18 of the Act and the State in turn could
recover the compensation paid, from the Officers of the State who
have been found to be responsible for causing human rights violation.
However, we clarify that before effecting recovery from the Officer of
the State, the Officer concerned shall be issued with a show cause
notice seeking his explanation only on the aspect of quantum of
compensation recoverable from him and not on the aspect whether
he was responsible for causing human rights violation.
'(iv) Whether initiation of appropriate disciplinary proceedings against
the Officers of the State under the relevant service rules, if it is so
empowered, is the only permissible mode for recovery of the
compensation amount directed to be paid by the State to the victims
of violation of human rights under sub-clause(i) of clause(a) of
Section 18 of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, from the
Officers of the State who have been found to be responsible for
causing such violation?'
Ans: As far as the initiation of disciplinary proceedings under the
relevant Service Rules is concerned, for recovery of compensation,
mere show cause notice is sufficient in regard to the quantum of
compensation recommended and to be recovered from the
Officers/employees of the concerned Government. However, in
regard to imposition of penalty as a consequence of a delinquent
official being found guilty of the violation, a limited departmental
enquiry may be conducted only to ascertain the extent of culpability
of the Official concerned in causing violation in order to formulate an
opinion of the punishing Authority as to the proportionality of the
punishment to be imposed on the official concerned. This procedure
may
be
followed
only
in
cases
where
the
disciplinary
authority/punishing authority comes to the conclusion on the basis of
the
inquiry
proceedings
and
the
recommendations
of
the
Commission that the delinquent official is required to be visited with
any of the major penalties enumerated in the relevant Service
Regulations.
As far as imposition of minor penalty is concerned, a mere show
cause notice is fair enough, as the existing Service Rules of all
services specifically contemplate only show cause notice in any
minor penalty proceedings.
(v) Whether Officers of the State who have been found to be
responsible by the State Human Rights Commission for causing
violation of human rights under Section 18 of the Protection of Human
Rights Act, 1993, are entitled to impeach such orders passed by the
Commission in proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution and
if so, at what stage and to which extent?
Ans: As we have held that the recommendation of the Commission
under Section 18 of the Act is binding and enforceable, the
Officers/employees of the State who have been found responsible for
causing violation of human rights by the Commission, are entitled to
assail such orders passed by the Commission by taking recourse to
remedies of judicial review provided under the Constitution of India.
It is open to the aggrieved officers/employees to approach the
competent
Court
to
challenge
the
findings
as
well
as
conclusion,
since
the
recommendations of the Commission.
491. As a
corollary to
the
above
recommendation of the H.R. Commission is held to be binding, an
officer/employee concerned can resort to appropriate legal remedy
at any stage qua complaint or inquiry by the Commission but only on
substantial legal grounds.
492. Before we part with this Reference, we are constrained to
express our considered opinion that despite all the provisions in the
Act, covering wide spectrum of human rights concerns in consonance
with the Rule of Law governing our polity, in the absence of an inbuilt
and integral provision within the explicit frame work of the Statute, a
perception has been gaining ground in the corridors of the
implementing authorities that the recommendation of the H.R.
Commission lacks legal sanctity and hence can be trifled with. Such
perception and point of view on the part of the implementing authority
may not augur well towards addressing the complaints of human
rights violation in the country where the written Constitution reigns
supreme and is placed at the altar of our governance.
493. Although the history after the introduction of the Act, reveals that
by and large the recommendations of the Commission have been
implemented, any discretion to the implementing authorities to either
accept or not accept the recommendation would only lead to
avoidable delay, forcing the Commission to invoke Section 18(b) of
the Act.
494. In a constitutional democracy, there is always a possibility of
change of Governments, policy makers and so are the policies. The
policies are always in a state of fluidity depending on expectations
resulting in shifts and changes of perspective framework of the policy
makers. In such circumstances, at the time of enactment of the Act,
an assurance given on behalf of the Treasury Bench by the Hon'ble
Minister concerned that recommendation of the H.R. Commission
would be accorded due respect as in the case of recommendation of
the Finance Commission and the Government in the past had never
declined to accept the recommendation of the Finance Commission
as matter of healthy convention.
495. The history of politics and governance has been witnessing
constant change through evolution of different policies and as a
consequence of such change any convention observed in the past
has its breaking point in tune with the time. Therefore, the Act which
was introduced providing a public law remedy, cannot be operated
on the basis of the assurance of the Hon'ble Minister concerned,
unless the assurance is transformed into a letter of law for all the time
to be followed.
496. The avowed intention of the policy framed at that point of time
was clear but at the same time, following any convention after all is a
only a matter of choice at the end of the day. If in this context, we are
of the considered opinion that the intention of the framers may be
given a statutory sanction within the Act itself to make the Act a
complete code in itself instead of invoking the jurisdiction of the
Constitutional Court for execution of the recommendation.
497. We earnestly trust and hope that the Parliament in its collective
wisdom would bring necessary amendments in the Act to provide
wherewithal to the Commission for direct execution of the
recommendation. By such initiation, the learned Parliament would be
according befitting status to the Commission steered by the high
constitutional dignitaries of the highest legal order.
498. In the said circumstances, we hereby suggest to the policy
makers to make suitable amendment/s in the Act providing for an
internal/self-contained mechanism qua Human Rights Commission
for enforcing its recommendations under Section 18 of the Act. By
such amendment/s, the Act would become complete in all fours,
leaving no room for procrastination in offering remedial action
promptly.”
(emphasis supplied)
[19]
In the case on hand, the order of the NHRC has attained
finality and is not subject matter of challenge by the respondents.
Therefore, the proposition in the aforesaid directives of the Full Bench of
the Madras High Court only leads to the conclusion that the respondents
are bound to comply with the recommendation of the NHRC.
[20]
In the result,
(i) The writ petition is allowed.
(ii) The first respondent is directed to comply with
the order dated 5.3.2020 passed in NHRC Case
No.42/14p/4/08-09-FE and to pay the amount of
Rs.5 lakh each as monetary compensation to the
petitioners 2 and 3, within a period of twelve
weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.
(iii)
There will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review