Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present :-
Hon’ble Justice Amrita Sinha
WPA No. 28953 of 2023
Sudip Kumar Pal
Vs.
The Union of India & Ors.
For the writ petitioner
:-
Mr. Surajit Samanta, Adv.
Mr. Sukhendu Banerjee, Adv.
Mr. Balai Lal Sahoo, Adv.
Mr. Dilip Kumar Mandal, Adv.
Ms. Sohini Samanta, Adv.
For the respondents
:-
Mr. Ashok Kumar Bhowmik, Adv.
Ms. Tanusree Ghosh, Adv.
Heard on
:-
08.04.2026
Judgment on
:-
27.04.2026
Amrita Sinha, J.:1.
The order passed by the Deputy Inspector General (PSO), South Bengal
Frontier, Border Security Force dated 23rd June, 2023 affirming the
order of dismissal dated 4th February, 2023 passed by the disciplinary
authority against the petitioner is impugned in the instant writ petition.
2.
Submission of the petitioner is that the appellate authority lacked the
jurisdiction to either decide or pass any order in the appeal preferred by
him. Malice both in law and in fact has been pleaded. Prayer has been
made to set aside the impugned order of dismissal and the affirmation
thereof and to reinstate the petitioner in service with all consequential
benefits.
3.
It has been submitted that the documents relied upon by the authority,
especially the proceeding of the Court of Inquiry, were never supplied to
the petitioner. He was not aware of the contents of the said documents.
Violation of principle of natural justice has been alleged.
4.
It has been contended that though the petitioner produced documents in
support of not joining service immediately on completion of his leave
period, the authority in hot haste passed the order of dismissal.
5.
Learned advocate for the petitioner submits that the petitioner reported
to duty on 4th February, 2023 as per his commitment made in writing
and handed over to the representative of the authority who visited his
house to enquire about his overstaying of leave, but the authority passed
the order of dismissal on 4th February, 2023 itself without allowing the
petitioner to re-join duty.
6.
It has been submitted that the provision of Rule 22 (2) of the Border
Security Force Rules, 1969 has not been complied with by the authority.
It has been contended that there was no occasion on the part of the
authority to invoke the aforesaid provision to initiate proceeding against
him.
7.
It has further been argued that without a proper finding that the
petitioner wilfully absented from duty, the order of dismissal on the
ground of misconduct cannot be supported in law. It has been contended
that without specific finding by the authority that the absence is wilful,
the employee cannot be held guilty.
8.
In support of such submission, learned advocate for the petitioner relies
on the order passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of
Krushnakant B. Parmar vs. Union of India & Anr. reported in (2012)
3 SCC 178 wherein the Hon’ble Court held that in a departmental
proceeding, if allegation of unauthorized absence from duty is made, the
disciplinary authority is required to prove that the absence is wilful. In
the absence of such finding, the absence will not amount to misconduct.
9.
According to the petitioner, as there is no finding either by the
disciplinary authority or the appellate authority that the absence of the
petitioner or his overstaying of leave was wilful, the same cannot be
treated as misconduct and the dismissal on such ground is liable to set
aside.
10. Learned advocate representing the respondents opposes the prayer of the
petitioner. The affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents mentions that
the petitioner took leave from 19th October, 2022 to 28th October, 2022.
He was supposed to join duty in the forenoon of 29th October, 2022. The
petitioner failed to report on the due date. As per procedure, three letters
dated 7th November, 2022, 14th November, 2022 and 22nd November,
2022 was sent to the recorded home address of the petitioner with
direction to join duty, failing which disciplinary action will be initiated
against him.
11. The petitioner neither responded to the above letters, nor sent any
message giving reason for overstaying of leave. As per Section 62 of the
Border Security Force Act, 1968, to conduct inquiry about his absence,
an Assistant Commandant of the Unit was appointed to conduct one
man Court of Inquiry. As per the remarks of the Court of Inquiry,
Apprehension Roll dated 2nd December, 2022, as per Section 60 of the
Act, was issued to apprehend the petitioner and the same was handed
over to the nearest BSF headquarter.
12. A show cause notice dated 27th December, 2022, proposing dismissal
from service, was issued to the petitioner along with a copy of the Court
of Inquiry and the remarks made thereon. No response was received from
the petitioner. A movement order dated 1st February, 2023, was issued in
favour of another constable to proceed to the residence of the petitioner
to ascertain the reason for his prolonged absence without notice or any
information.
13. The constable met the petitioner on 2nd February, 2023, in his recorded
home address and handed him a copy of the show cause notice and a
copy of all other previous notices along with a copy of the Court of
Inquiry and the remarks made thereon. On that date the petitioner
handed over a hand written communication to the said constable
addressed to the Unit Commandant stating that he will join duty on 4th
February, 2023. The petitioner did not turn up on 4th February, 2023,
nor sent any communication to the office.
14. Being satisfied that the petitioner remained absent illegally without
sufficient cause since the forenoon of 29th October, 2022, and his
retention in the disciplined force was undesirable, the disciplinary
authority passed order of dismissal against the petitioner with effect
from 4th February, 2023. The appeal preferred by the petitioner dated
11th March, 2023, against the order of dismissal, stood rejected.
15. It has been disclosed in the affidavit that prior to dismissal from service,
several opportunities were given to the petitioner to rectify his conduct
and to discipline himself. On many occasions disciplinary action was
taken against him. On five occasions his overstaying of leave was
regularized. He was imposed punishment with fine for being absent
without leave and to suffer rigorous imprisonment in Force custody
thrice for overstaying leave.
16. After dismissal from service, the petitioner applied for reinstatement on
3rd April, 2023. A brief history of his case mentioning the good and the
bad entries with remarks of the Unit Commandant were forwarded to the
frontier headquarters seeking advice. The Inspector General, Border
Security Force, after careful consideration of all the records, rejected the
prayer of the petitioner.
17. According to the respondents, the petitioner does not have good
antecedent and he is a habitual offender. His service is not desirable in
the disciplined Force.
18. It has been submitted that the authority acted strictly in accordance
with the Act and the corresponding Rules to dismiss the petitioner from
service and prayer has been made not to interfere with the order of
dismissal.
19. I have heard and considered the rival submissions made on behalf of
both the parties and perused the materials placed before this Court.
20. The service of the petitioner has been terminated by invoking Rule 22 (2)
of the Rules, 1969 which deals with dismissal or removal on account of
misconduct.
The
petitioner
was
found
absenting
from
duty
by
overstaying his leave period without any prior intimation or notice. As
many as three opportunities were given to the petitioner to report to
duty. He failed to respond to any of the notices issued to him.
21. The authority even sent a representative to his recorded home address to
ascertain as to why he did not report to duty. The petitioner disclosed by
way of a hand written communication addressed to the Commandant
that he would return on 4th February, 2023. Despite such intimation, the
petitioner did not revert to report for duty on the said date. It was only
then that the authority took a decision to dismiss him from service.
22. The petitioner has averred in the writ petition that he went to join his
battalion on 4th February, 2023 as promised, but he was not allowed to
resume duty. There is no proof in support of such averment of the
petitioner. The aforesaid statement of the petitioner has been specifically
controverted
by
the
respondents.
The
consistent
stand
of
the
respondents is that the petitioner neither joined duty on 4th February,
2023, nor sent any communication or reply to any of the notices issued
to him explaining the reason for not attending duty and remaining
absent without any reasonable cause.
23. The very first communication made by the petitioner after his dismissal
is dated 11th March, 2023 by which he prayed for reinstatement in
service. The petitioner has averred that he received the order of dismissal
dated 4th February, 2023, on 10th February, 2023 by post. The petitioner
waited for more than a month to seek reinstatement. The conduct of the
petitioner suggests that he did not take any steps for the entire month
from 10th February, 2023 till 11th March, 2023.
24. The petitioner ought to know that he is serving in a disciplined Force.
Any type of indiscipline or misconduct cannot be expected to be tolerated
while serving in the Force. The Border Security Force has the
responsibility to ensure security of the citizens of this country at the
borders. It has the solemn duty to prevent trans-border crime, smuggling
and unauthorized entry into and exit from the Indian Territory. The
members of the Force are to maintain a definite style of functioning and
there cannot be any laxity in the same.
25. From the performance of the petitioner as detailed in the affidavit of the
respondents, it is clear that on repeated occasions the petitioner
overstayed his leave. The authority regularized such leave at least on five
occasions. He was also imposed punishment for being absent from work
without any sanctioned leave. He even paid fine for his absence. He was
also awarded punishment to suffer rigorous imprisonment for ten days
on 12th October, 2000 for remaining absent without any cause for 105
days and suffered further rigorous imprisonment for fourteen days on
14th June, 2021 for overstaying of leave without sufficient cause for total
108 days.
26. The figures mentioned herein above clearly depict that the petitioner was
not committed to his duty. He frequently and abruptly absented himself
from work without sanction and without any information. The members
of the Force are always assigned a specific duty. If a member suddenly
absents himself from duty without any reasonable cause, then it
becomes very difficult for the superior officer to regulate the members of
the Force. If leniency and sympathy is shown to a particular member of
the Force, then maintaining strict discipline amongst other members of
the Force will become a challenge.
27. It is common knowledge that the members of the Force are required to
remain very alert and attentive in their duties. It is absolutely not
expected that any member of the Force will behave in such an
indisciplined manner. The same amounts to misconduct. After perusing
the records of the case of the petitioner, the authority came to a
conclusive finding that the service of the petitioner in the Force is
undesirable.
28. It does not appear that the authority acted with any malice either in law
or in fact as alleged by the petitioner. Reasonable opportunity of hearing
was given to the petitioner in his defence. It does not appear that there
has been violation in the principle of natural justice in the disciplinary
proceeding initiated against him. Though it has been submitted that all
documents in respect of the subject proceeding was not provided to the
petitioner but, surprisingly, the said non supply of document(s) was
never reported to the authority. There is no communication from the end
of the petitioner praying for supply of any document at any point of time.
29. The submission of the petitioner that the authority acted in hot haste
also cannot be accepted. The petitioner himself intimated the Unit
Commandant that he would join on a particular date but he failed to do
so. The authority had no other option but to pass necessary order after it
was noticed that the petitioner did not report to duty. There was
absolutely no reason to wait further for the petitioner to resume work.
30. Moreover, how long is the authority expected to wait for him to re-join?
The authority is not expected to wait for eternity. The petitioner was not
doing any favour to the country; he was being paid for the services
rendered. A member of the Force cannot be expected to drop in and
absent himself as per his own sweet will. Each member of the Force has
to act responsibly. Careless and irresponsible attitude of a member of the
Force cannot be supported under any circumstances.
31. It also does not appear that either the disciplinary or the appellate
authority acted without jurisdiction in passing the impugned order of
dismissal or affirming the same. The authority acted in accordance with
the Act and the corresponding Rules to get rid of the black sheep from
the Force.
32. In Krushnakant (supra) the Court found that there was evidence led by
the charge sheeted officer that he was prevented to sign the attendance
register and to perform duty. On such finding, the Court held that the
authority was required to prove that the absence was wilful. Without
such finding, the absence will not amount to misconduct.
33. Such is not the case here. The petitioner was never restrained from
attending his duty. On the contrary, the petitioner deliberately absented
himself from work. He failed to avail the repeated opportunities given to
him to rectify his conduct. He displayed total lack of dedication in his
job. Such a member is a burden to the Force. The Authority decided to
dismiss him from service. The Court does not find any error with the
order of dismissal.
34. Hence, no order can be passed in favour of the petitioner in the instant
writ petition. The writ petition fails and is hereby dismissed.
35. No costs.
36. Urgent certified photocopy of this judgment, if applied for, be supplied to
the parties or their advocates on record expeditiously on compliance of
usual legal formalities.
(Amrita Sinha, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review