The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. The writ petition along with all the connected applications are disposed of.
28. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order be supplied to the parties, if applied for, as early as possible. (Smita Das De, J.) The private respondent prays for a stay of the operation of the judgment and order but the same has been objected by the petitioner. Such prayer is turned down and the stay is granted till 24th March 2026. (Smita Das De, J.)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
18.03.2026
ct no. 10
Sl. 01
AGM
WPA 30041 of 2024
IA CAN No. 2 of 2025
IA CAN No. 3 of 2025
Subrata Karmakar
-VersusState of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Debabrata Saha Roy. Sr. Adv.
Mr. Neil Basu.
Mr. Sankha Biswas.
…for the petitioner.
Mr. Amal Kumar Sen, Ld. A.A.G.
Mr. Pantu Deb Roy. Ld. A.G.P.
Mr. Parikshit Goswami.
…for the State.
Mr. Sankar Nath Mukherjee.
Mr. Niraj Gupta.
… for the private respondent.
1. The petitioner in the instant case challenges inter
alia, the resolution of the RTA Board, Kolkata
dated November 20, 2024 wherein the actual
length of the modified route, criss crossing the
Eastern Metropolitan By-pass covers a length of
approximately
kms
via
Kadapara,
Bench
Chemical and Beliaghata.
2. It is further stated that the respondent authorities
have committed a gross illegality by violating the
provisions mentioned in the Notification No. 1010WT/3M-154/2004 dated February 11, 2005 by
granting permission to the private respondent for
variation of the route.
3. The
Notification
dated
February
11,
categorically lays down the conditions which are
enumerated below:
SCHEME
The Calcutta State Transport Corporation, the
South Bengal State Transport Corporation, The
North Bengal State Transport Corporation, the
West Bengal Surface Transport Corporation Ltd
and the Calcutta Tramways (1978) Co. Ltd being
the State Transport Undertakings, for the purpose
of providing an efficient adequate, economical and
properly
co-ordinated
road
transport
service,
operate and run in the public interest, passenger
stage Carriage Service in relation to the area/route
particulars whereof are specified in the schedule
below to exclusion of all other passenger transport
service except:
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
4. Learned
The existing permanent stage carriage
permit holders as on the date of the
publication of the approved scheme in the
route/area specified in the schedule
hereto or in any portion thereof.
……………………………………………
……………………………………………
……………………………………………..
……………………………………………..
State Carriage and Contract Carriage
permit holders Criss crossing E.M.Bye
Pass but not plying along Eastern
Metropolitan By-pass for a distance of
more than 500 Meters.”
counsel
respondent
raised
appearing
a
for
the
preliminary
private
objection
regarding the maintainability of the petitioner’s
locus standi to challenge the route modification,
since the petitioner is an existing operator cannot
challenge the route of another existing operator
where the State respondent has already granted
permission.
5. It is stated by the private respondent that in
Indian Administrative Law a petitioner must show
direct legal injury or a substantial interest in the
matter. Existing operator can challenge permits if
they demonstrate adverse impact in their rights or
operation.
6. The private respondent places reliance upon a
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex court in the case of
Mithilesh Garg & Ors –vs- Union of India & Ors
reported in (1992) 1 Supreme Court Cases 168
and Abdul Hai Khan –vs- Subal Chandra Ghose
and Others reported in (2002) 4 Supreme Court
Cases 519 as to whether an existing operator can
challenge permits solely to prevent competition,
the focus must be on whether they have a right to
demand a monopoly. Promoting efficiency, public
interest and reduced corruption takes precedence
over an existing operators desire to maintain a
monopoly.
7. In Abdul Hai Khan –vs- Subal Chandra Ghose
and Others reported in (2002) 4 Supreme Court
Cases 519, the private respondent relies upon
paragraph
of
this
judgment,
which
is
reproduced below:
“11.From the contentions raised by the learned
counsel for the parties it is clear to us that there is
no dispute about the position of law that the
notified Scheme, whether totally excluding private
operators or partially excluding them is binding on
all concerned so long as it remains in force. At the
same time it is also clear that the Scheme as
framed in 1963 does not totally exclude private
operators. Indeed it permits operation of stage
carriage service by private operators. Therefore,
the Scheme is only a partial exclusion scheme. In
such a case it is not open to a private operator who
is himself operating on a nationalized route on
account of modification of the Scheme to seek a
writ of mandamus to the Authority not to grant
permit to any other private operator on that route
or a route overlapping a portion of the route. To put
it differently, he is not entitled to enjoy a monopoly
of operation of the route. It is up to the Authority to
consider whether the application filed by a private
operator for permit on that route or another route
overlapping that route should be issued or not. In
case the private operator who is operating on the
nationalized route has a grievance that the number
of private operators specified in the notified
Scheme is being exceeded then the permit issued
to the operator/operators in excess of the specified
limit, may be challenged before the statutory for a
in accordance with provisions of the Act. In any
view of the matter, the writ petition seeking the
relief quoted earlier is not maintainable,
particularly when neither the private operators
who are alleged to have got the permits in excess
of the number specified in the notification nor the
State undertaking have been impleaded as parties
in the case. In such a case a prayer for a
declaration in the form as sought in the writ
petition could not be granted.”
8. In this context the petitioner submits that route
modification infringes specific statutory rights or
procedural norms not merely competitive interest
and
asserts
by
placing
reliance
upon
the
judgments (1) G.T. Venkataswamy Reddy –vsState Transport Authority and Others reported
in (2016) 8 Supreme Court Cases 402; and (2)
Prabhat Pan –vs- State of West Bengal reported
in 2015 (2) CHN (Cal) 185.
9. The petitioner draws the attention of this Court to
paragraph 48 of
G.T. Venkataswamy Reddy
(supra) to demonstrate that once things gets
frozen, the frozen stage can be changed only by
way of permitted process.
10.
It is submitted that the actual length of the
modified route of the private respondent, ‘Criss
crosses’ the E.M. By Pass by plying the vehicle
along with Eastern Metropolitan By-pass for a
distance of more than 500 Meters, runs contrary
to the said notification.
11.
It is submitted that the petitioner is an existing
operator and falls within the exempted category.
12.
The letter and spirit of the Notification dated
February 11, 2005 speaks that any operators
holding permits prior to the date of Notification
shall be exempted and be permitted to ply for a
distance of more than 500 meters.
13.
The private respondent is an existing operator
of a notified route. Subsequently, the route
alignment mentioned in the original permit has
been modified in the year 2025 which runs
contrary
to
the
mandate
of
the
conditions
mentioned in the notification by exceeding the
permissible limit.
14.
The petitioner relies upon a judgment in the
case of Prabhat Pan –vs- State of West Bengal
reported in 2015 (2) CHN (Cal) 185 (supra). In
paragraph 17 of the said
judgment, it has been
categorically held that an existing operator cannot
challenge the grant of a permit to a new operator
for a Stage Carriage or Contract Carriage on the
ground that it prejudices their business, unless
the existing operator has a specific grievance, that
the authorities have ignored. Paragraph 17 of the
said judgment which is reproduced below:
“17. Thus, the dictum in Mithilesh Garg has to be
confined to the context of the challenge therein and
the ratio decidendi has to be seen as follows: that an
existing operator cannot challenge the grant of a
permit to a new operator for a part or the whole of
the route operated on by the existing operator on the
ground that the business on the route or the relevant
part of the route would not warrant the new grant.
Mithilesh Garg cannot be read to imply that in
existing operator prejudiced by an illegal grant of a
new permit for a part or the entirety of the route
covered by the existing operator will have no right to
complain to the authorities of the illegal grant or
carry a grievance before a judicial forum upon the
complaint going unheeded or being rejected.”
15.
It is further submitted that there is an inherent
illegality in the decision of the authority by
modifying the route alignment of the private
respondent since the modifying ‘criss crossing’ the
Eastern Metropolitan By-pass for distance of 500
meters is not in consonance with the conditions
mentioned in the Notification dated February 11,
2005.
16.
The private respondent submits that both the
writ petitioner and the private respondent are
merely rivals in trade. The petitioner cannot claim
to be an aggrieved persons as action of the State
respondent in favour of the private respondent
does
not
infringe
upon
any
statutory
or
fundamental right of the petitioner. The scheme
dated 18.2.2005 is a partial exclusion scheme.
Under Clause 1 of this said scheme both the
petitioner and the private respondent falls under
the exempted category and allows the private
operators who have been operating prior to the
date of publication to continue to ply their vehicles
in the notified area. The State Transport being the
sole beneficiary can
only raise an objection
regarding a deviation from the scheme since
neither the petitioner nor the private respondent
acquires any exclusive vested statutory right as
per chapter IV of the Motor vehicles Act, 1988. It is
further submitted that the Scheme 2005 is based
on the principal of partial exclusion allowing the
private operator. The focus is on whether the route
variation violates the terms of the scheme or
procedural fairness.
17.
The petitioner is not entitled to enjoy a
monopoly of operation of the said route. The
discretion to consider and grant an application for
operation of a modified route rests entirely with
the Transport Authority. The respondent authority
submits that the judgments relied upon by the
petitioner has no manner of application to the
present facts since the Transport authority is the
sole beneficiary of the scheme and has allowed the
prayer of the private respondent without raising
any objection with regard to the variation of the
route in question.
18.
Having heard the parties at length in the light
of the above judgment this Court finds that the
petitioner has sufficient interest to challenge the
modified route alignment covering a distance
exceeding the permissible limits which de hors the
mandate of the notification dated 11.02.2005. The
judgments relied upon by the private respondent
have
no
manner
of
application
and
is
distinguishable both in facts as well as in law. The
judgments are relevant only for considering the
prayer of an application for a route permit which is
not the subject matter of challenge in the instant
writ petition. The objection raised by the private
respondent regarding the locus standi of the
petitioner has no legs to stand and is thus
dismissed.
19.
Since the question of the locus of the petitioner
to challenge the modified route of the private
respondent has already been decided, the writ
petition being WPA 30041 of 2024 shall now be
taken up for consideration on merits.
20.
The petitioner in the instant case has been
granted permanent stage carriage (Bus) permit by
the STA West Bengal in respect of route Barasat to
Baruipur via Jessore Road, Airport No.1 gate, VIP
Road Ultadanga, EM-Bypass, RG Kar Hospital,
Garia which has been subsequently renewed on
30.7.2024 till 21.07.2029.
21.
The petitioner challenges the resolution dated
20.11.2024 on the ground that action of the State
Respondents is illegal as such action is de hors the
scheme formulated by the Government of West
Bengal vide the Notification dated 11.02.2005. It is
further contended by the petitioner that allowing
such variation is violating the clause 6 of the said
notification
which
has
been
allowed
by
the
respondent no. 5 to the Private Respondent to
modify
the
route
beyond
meters,
such
modification is arbitrary and illegal in the eye of
law.
22.
Mr. Amal Kumar Sen, learned A.A.G. and Mr.
Pantu Deb Roy. Ld. A.G.P. submits that an
existing operation prior to 2005 is exempted; there
is no bar on plying the vehicle exceeding the
permissible limit of 500 meters.
23.
The State respondent draws the attention of the
report dated June 6. 2025 by relying upon
paragraph 12 and 14 of the report from which it
transpires that the distance between Ultadanga to
Beliaghata
via
Kadapara,
Bengal
Chemicalsis
about 4.6kms on the E.M. By-pass, is covered
under the Notification dated February 11, 2025,
the
relevant
paragraphs
of
the
report
are
reproduced below :
“12. In this context, the R.T.A. Board, North 24Parganas in a meeting held on 19th April, 2025
allowed the proposal for alteration of route
alignment from Ultadanga to Beliaghata via
Kadapara, Bengal Chemical which is about 4
kilometer without altering both the termini point
instead of VIP Road, Ultadanga, SDF Building,
Science City, Chingrighata, subject to publication
of the notification of variation/alteration of the
said route from the end of the Transport
Department, Government of West Bengal. A copy
of the said resolution dated 19th April, 2025 is
annexed hereto and marked with the letter “R-1”.
14. Moreover, from the Google map, it would be
evident that the distance between Ultadanga to
Beliaghata via Kadapara, Bengal Chemicals is
about 4.6 kms on the E.M. Bye-pass, which is
covered under the notification dated 11th
February, 2005. In this context, a copy of the
screenshot taken from the google map evidencing
distance between Ultadanga and Beliaghata is
annexed hereto and marked with the letter “R2”.”
24.
As per the report of the State respondent, it
appears that the length of the modified route
alignment of the private respondent actually ‘criss
crossed’ the Eastern Metropolitan By-pass.
25.
In view of the above, the resolution no. 9 of RTA
Board, Kolkata meeting dated November 20, 2024
and
all
consequential
steps
taken
pursuant
thereto including the decision of the RTA Board,
North
Parganas
dated
notification
bearing
no.
19.4.2025
and
4730-WT/TPT-
18011/43/2025 dated 19.9.2025 issued by the
Secretary, Transport Department, Government of
West Bengal is hereby quashed and set aside. The
members
of
added
respondent
no.
10.
i.e.
members of route no. DN-16 and route no. DN16/1 bus syndicate, shall be restricted to ply their
vehicles strictly in accordance with the route
alignment
specified
in
their
original
permits
without any variation.
26.
Henceforth, the statutory authorities under the
act shall keep a vigil and watch on the erroneous
and illegal exercise of power in granting permits
under the liberalized policy.
27.
The writ petition along with all the connected
applications are disposed of.
28.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order be
supplied to the parties, if applied for, as early as
possible.
(Smita Das De, J.)
LATER
The private respondent prays for a stay of
the operation of the judgment and order but the
same has been objected by the petitioner.
Such prayer is turned down and the stay
is granted till 24th March 2026.
(Smita Das De, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review