Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 46 OF 2024
Subrata Dey, son of Swapan Kumar Dey,
Resident of Melaghar, behind Ram Thakur Ashram,
Tripura, Pin 799115. (Age-44 years)
……Petitioner.
Vrs.
1. The State of Tripura, (to be represented by) the Secretary,
Department of Labour, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P. S. New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, Pin 799010.
2. The Secretary, Department of Labour, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P. S. New
Capital Complex, Agartala,West Tripura, Pin 799010.
3. The Director of Employment Services & Manpower Planning, Tripura,
Directorate of Employment Services & Manpower Planning, Agartala,
West Tripura, Pin 799001.
4. The Chairman, Joint Recruitment Board, Tripura, Shram Bhavan,
Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin 799001.
5. The Member Secretary, Joint Recruitment Board, Tripura, Shram
Bhavan, Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin 799001.
6. The Controller, Joint Recruitment Board, Tripura, Shram Bhavan,
Office Lane, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin 799001
.…. Respondents.
For the petitioner (s)
: Ms. S. Deb (Gupta), Advocate.
For the respondent (s)
: Mr. S.M.Chakraborty, Advocate General
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.
Dates of hearing and
dates of delivery of
judgment and order
: 25.02.2025 & 27.02.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
: Yes
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order(Oral)
25.02.2025
By means of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner has
prayed for following reliefs:
“(i) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents to show cause
as to why in the nature of mandamus and/or Order/direction shall not be
issued whereby directing the Respondents to recommend the name of the
Petitioner against the post of Junior Operator (Pump)/Junior MultiTasking Operator (Uncommon), in c/w Advt. No.01/2020 and
Notification, dated 12.02.2021, for the posts of Group-C, [Lower Division
Clerk (LDC), Agriculture Assistant (Except TAFS Grade-III), Agriculture
Assistant (TAFS Grade-III), Junior Operator (Pump) & Junior MultiTasking Operator (Uncommon)].
(ii) Issue Rule, upon the Respondents to show cause as to why
Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or Order/direction shall not be
issued whereby directing the Respondents to re-publish the Merit List,
dated 13.09.2023, after including the name of the petitioner therein.
(iii) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why
Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or Order/direction shall not be
issued whereby quashing & cancelling the Letter, dated 12.01.2024,
issued by the Chairman, JRBT.
(iv) Make the Rules absolute.
(v) Pass any further order/orders as this Hon’ble High Court
considered fit and proper.”
2.
The short facts are that the respondents floated an advertisement
on 01.06.2017 [Annexure-13 to the writ petition] for filling up various posts.
One of the posts was Junior Fitter, under Post Code 6. But, the said
advertisement was cancelled. Thereafter, the respondents issued advertisement
no. 01/2020 again on 27.11.2020 [Annexure-1 to the writ petition] for filling
up the posts of Lower Division Clerk (Group-C), Non-Gazetted. Total 1500
posts were shown to the said advertisement. The State-respondents had issued
another notification dated 12th February, 2021 [Annexure-2 to the writ
petition] as a matter of “Revision” of advertisement no. 01/2020, dated
27.11.2020, including corrigendum and addendum related to the recruitment
of 1500 Lower Division Clerk (Group-C) posts by Joint Recruitment Board
(JRBT), Tripura. In the said notification dated 12.02.2021 some posts were
clubbed together and referred to as ‘Junior Multi Tasking Operater’. For
convenience, it may be reproduced in a chart from the said notification.
VACANCY DETAILS
No. of the post(s)
Number of
Reservation status
Group-C, (Non-Gazetted)
vacancies
1. Lower Division Clerk
2.Agriculture
Assistant
(Except TAFS Grade-III)
3.Agriculture Assistant (TAFS
Reservation of posts is as per the
Grade-III)
reservation roster maintained by the
4.Junior Operator (Pump)
concerned departments and as per the State
5.Junior
Multi
Tasking
Government reservation policy. It will be
Operator (Un-common)
notified later.
Total Vacancies
Name of the Pre-revised Scale Corresponding revised Scale of Pay.
Post(Group-C,
of pay
Non-Gazetted)
Lower Division
Clerk
Agriculture
Cell-1 of Level -7 of Tripura State Pay
Assistant (Except PB-2, Pay Band
Matrix, 2018 {Tripura State Civil Services
TAFS Grade-III) Scale Rs.570024000/(Revised
Pay)
First
Amendment
Agriculture
Pay
Rules,2018}.
Assistant (TAFS Grade Pay
Structure Grade-III)
Rs.2200/Junior Operator PB-2, Pay Band
Cell-1 of Level -6 of Tripura State Pay
(Pump)
Scale Rs.5700Matrix, 2018 {Tripura State Civil Services
(Revised
Pay)
First
Amendment
Junior
Multi 24000/Grade Pay
Rules,2018}.
Tasking
Rs.2100/Operator
(un-common)
Subject to revision by the Government from time to time.
***
***
***
Junior
(Pump)
Operator Common for Junior Operator (Pump) and Junior Multi
Tasking Operator (Un-common)i.e.
(a) Madhyamik or equivalent examination passed from
any recognized Board/Institution.
And
Junior Multi Tasking
Operator
(un- (b) National Trade Certificate (NTC) issued by National
Council for Vocational Training (NCVT) in any of the
common)
following trade (i) Welder (Gas & Electric), (ii) Plumber,
(iii) Turner, (iv) Fitter, (v) Mechanic Diesel, (vi) Pump
Operator cum Mechanic, (vii) Wireman, (viii) Electrician
Desirable qualifications are also mentioned in the said
notification dated 12.02.2021 where in one of the Clauses [Clause ‘c’] it is
written that “As regards to the candidates who had participated in the
cancelled recruitment process by the Department of Agriculture, they will be
given one time age relaxation in the upper age limit subject to providing
documentary evidence of their participation in the earlier recruitment
processes for the same post(s).”
3.
The petitioner in the earlier recruitment process which was
initiated vide advertisement dated 03.01.2017, applied for the post of ‘Junior
Fitter’. It is an admitted position that the petitioner was qualified to apply for
the post as regards his age because he was covered under Clause ‘c’ of the
notification dated 12.02.2021. The application of the petitioner was accepted
by the State-respondents and he was allowed to take part in the written
examination. Consequently, he appeared before the interview board and
participated in the process along with the copies of his National Trade
Certificate [for short, ‘NTC’] in the branch of ‘Fitter’. Thereafter, the
respondents published final merit list on 13.09.2023 wherein it was reflected
that the last recommended candidate for the post of ‘Junior Multi Tasking
Operator’ had scored 86 marks and last recommended candidate in the post of
‘Junior Operator (Pump)’ had scored 88 marks. Having not found his name in
the merit list, the petitioner had submitted application under Right to
Information Act and sought for reply as regards the marks he obtained in the
examination. Under the RTI reply dated 10.10.2023, it was informed to the
petitioner that he scored 102 marks. Since the petitioner had obtained higher
marks than some of the candidates as stated here-in-above, he had served a
demand notice through his learned counsel on 17.10.2023 requesting the
JRBT authorities to correct the merit list and include his name in the said
merit list as he secured higher marks than many of the candidates whose
names are found in the merit list.
4.
Having found no response, the petitioner had approached this
Court by way of filing a writ petition bearing WP(C) No.729 of 2023. This
Court disposed of the writ petition vide order dated 14.12.2023 directing the
respondents to consider his representation in accordance with law within a
period of four weeks from the date of judgment and order. The petitioner
submitted representation dated 21.12.2023 to the Chairman, JRBT enclosing
therein a copy of the judgment and order passed in WP(C) No.729 of 2023
along with copies of the ITI/ Trade Certificate issued in favour of the
petitioner.
5.
In response to the said representation, the Chairman, JRBT, had
rejected the claim of the petitioner for recommending his name in the merit
list vide impugned communication dated 12.01.2024 on the sole ground that
he was over-aged at the time of submission of his application. It is the case of
the petitioner that in terms of Clause ‘c’ as extracted and quoted here-inabove, he was not over-aged because age relaxation was given under
notification dated 12.02.2021. Thereafter, the petitioner submitted two
applications stating inter alia that the post of ‘Multi Tasking Operator’
includes the post of ‘Fitter’ in terms of the notification dated 12.02.2021. But
the petitioner has not received any satisfactory reply. Hence, the petitioner has
no other alternative and efficacious remedy but to approach this Court by way
of filing the instant writ petition.
6.
The respondents by way of filing counter affidavit has stated that
at the time of scrutiny of applications, the petitioner was found over-aged and
thus he was not eligible to appear in the selection process. Further, it is
mentioned in the counter affidavit (Para-11) that the petitioner had appeared
before the interview board as per notice of the department dated 01.06.2017
for the post of ‘Junior Fitter’ under Post Code 6 held on 05.07.2017 against
token no.4, which incidentally is not the ‘same post’ for which advertisement
was issued by the JRBT. More particularly, the candidature of the petitioner
had been rejected on two grounds, firstly, the petitioner was over-aged at the
time of submission of application in response to notification dated 12.02.2021
and secondly, the respondents did not issue advertisement for filling up the
post of ‘Junior Fitter’ but ‘Multi Tasking Operator’ (un-common).
7.
It is further stated in the counter affidavit (Para-18) that Sri Arpan
Sarkar and Sri Debabrata Debnath under UR category at Sl. No.1965 and Sl.
No.1963 were recommended in the final merit list for the post of ‘Junior Multi
Tasking Operator (un-common)’ and ‘Junior Operator (Pump)’ having scored
86 marks and 88 marks respectively as well as considering their National
Council for Vocational Training Certificate as required vide notification dated
12.02.2021.
8.
In the light of above facts, questions fall for determination in the
instant writ petition are that (1) whether the petitioner was over-aged at the
time of submission of his application i.e. as per notification dated 12.02.2021
and (2) whether the application of the petitioner can be rejected as he
submitted application against the post of ‘Junior Fitter’ in the earlier
advertisement dated 03.01.2017.
9.
I have heard Ms. S. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner. Also heard Mr. S.M.Chakraborty, learned Advocate General
assisted by Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. on behalf of the Staterespondents. Ms. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner has submitted that under notification dated 12.02.2021, the
petitioner was not over-aged though on that date the petitioner attained the age
of 41 years 08 months 24 days. The submission of learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner was based on age relaxation clause containing in Clause ‘c’
of the relevant portion of the notification dated 12.02.2021 which stipulates as
a matter of reiteration that “As regards to the candidates who had participated
in the cancelled recruitment process by the Department of Agriculture, they
will be given one time age relaxation in the upper age limit subject to
providing documentary evidence of their participation in the earlier
recruitment processes for the same post(s).”
10.
Admitted fact is that the petitioner had applied for the post of
‘Junior Fitter’ in response to the earlier advertisement which was issued by the
State-respondents on 03.01.2017. During the course of hearing learned
counsel appearing for the respondents has not disputed this fact.
11.
I have gone through the said age relaxation Clause as quoted
here-in-above. In my opinion, the application of the petitioner had to be
entertained or accepted in view of above quoted Clause ‘c’. Accordingly, the
first question is decided in favour of the petitioner.
12.
Now, coming to the second question for determination, it is
relevant to revisit the notification/advertisement and the chart reproduced
here-in-above. In the revised notification/advertisement dated 12th February,
2021, advertisement for filling up of 5 (five) nature of posts were made. These
are- 1. Lower Division Clerk having number of vacancies 1500; 2. Agriculture
Assistant (Except TAFS Grade-III) having number of vacancies 22; 3.
Agriculture Assistant (TAFS Grade-III) having number of vacancies 443; 4.
Junior Operator (Pump) having number of vacancies 236 and 5. Junior Multi
Tasking Operator (un-common) having number of vacancies 209. In the said
advertisement, eligibility criteria including essential qualifications for filling
up the above posts are also mentioned.
13.
It comes to fore that for filling up the post of ‘Junior Multi
Tasking Operator (un-common)’, the essential qualifications are having a
valid NTC issued by National Council for Vocational Training (NCVT) in any
of the following trades: (i) Welder (Gas & Electric), (ii) Plumber, (iii) Turner,
(iv) Fitter, (v) Mechanic Diesel, (vi) Pump Operator cum Mechanic, (vii)
Wireman, (viii) Electrician, etc.
14.
During the course of hearing, this Court had made specific query
to learned Advocate General to show this Court as to whether there is any post
which is called ‘Junior Multi Tasking Operator (un-common)’. Learned
Advocate General has fairly submitted that there is no such post. From the
reply of learned Advocate General, it is also surfaced that under the National
Council for Vocational Training (NCVT) there is no course under the
nomenclature of ‘Junior Multi Tasking Operator (un-common)’.
15.
From the notification dated 12th February, 2021 which was issued
in revision to Advertisement No.01/2020 dated 27 th November, 2020 vis-à-vis
taking into account the submission of learned Advocate General that there is
no such post under the nomenclature of ‘Junior Multi Tasking Operator (uncommon)’, it becomes crystal clear that essential qualification for filling up
the post of ‘Junior Multi Tasking Operator (un-common)’ is-- (a) Madhyamik
or equivalent examination passed from any recognized Board/Institution and
(b) one has to possess a certificate of Welder (Gas & Electric), Plumber,
Turner, and Fitter, etc. These are the vocational training courses and
certificates thereof which altogether has given the nomenclature of the post as
‘Junior Multi Tasking Operator (un-common)’. In other words, a person
having qualification of Madhyamik or equivalent passed examination and
having
NTC
in
any
of
the
streams
as
mentioned
in
the
notification/advertisement is eligible to apply for the post of ‘Multi Tasking
Operator (un-common)’. Indubitably, the petitioner is Madhyamik passed and
having National Trade Certificate (NTC) issued by the National Council for
Vocational Training (NCVT) in the trade of ‘Fitter’. Since the trade of ‘Fitter’
comes under the purview of the post of ‘Junior Multi Tasking Operator (uncommon)’, in my opinion, the rejection of the candidature of the application
on the ground that the petitioner does not possess essential qualification since
he applied for the post of ‘Fitter’ is erroneous. Further, in the opinion of this
Court, the State-respondents have failed to properly construe that a person
having certificate in the trade of ‘Fitter’ comes under the purview of ‘Junior
Multi Tasking Operator (un-common)’. This Court, at this juncture has asked
learned Advocate General as to why they have not enclosed the trade
certificates of Sri Arpan Sarkar and Sri Debabrata Debnath in this case.
16.
In view of this, learned Advocate General has fairly submitted
that he will produce the necessary certificates in respect of Sri Arpan Sarkar
and Sri Debabrata Debnath on the next date i.e. on 27.02.2025.
17.
List the matter on 27.02.2025 for verification whether these two
candidates had any trade certificates as ‘Junior Multi Tasking Operator (uncommon)’ and for continuation of the dictation of the judgment.
27.02.2025 18.
Today, in terms of the order dated 25.02.2025,
learned Advocate General has placed National Trade Certificates issued in
favour of Arpan Sarkar and Debabrata Debnath, by Directorate General of
Training, Ministry of Skill Development and Entrepreneurship, Government
of India and National Council for Vocational Training, Ministry of Skill
Development and Entrepreneurship, Government of India, where the names of
the trades against Arpan Sarkar and Debabrata Debnath have been shown as
‘Electrician (NSQF)’ and ‘Electrician’ respectively.
19.
Placing the said two National Trade Certificates, learned
Advocate General has firstly submitted that there is no course or trade under
the nomenclature of ‘Junior Multi Tasking Operator (un-common)’. I reiterate
that the respondents have failed to show any such record justifying the fact
that there is any trade which is called as ‘Junior Multi Tasking Operator (uncommon)’. In view of this, the plea of the respondents that the petitioner being
applied for the post of ‘Fitter’ instead of the post of ‘Multi Tasking Operator
(un-common)’ is disqualified and ineligible to find his place in the select list.
20.
Considering the nomenclature of different courses or trades as
narrated here-in-above, this Court may easily come to a definite conclusion
that the posts of ‘Fitter’, ‘Electrician’, ‘Welder’, Turner, etc. come under the
purview of nomenclature ‘Multi Tasking Operator (un-common)’. Admittedly,
the petitioner secured much higher marks (102) than those of many candidates
including Arpan Sarkar and Debabrata Debnath. Learned Advocate General
has fairly submitted that there are vacant posts still lying with the respondents.
As such, the persons who already have been appointed even though they
secured lesser marks than that of the petitioner should not be disturbed. So, the
respondents are directed to accommodate the petitioner and publish a revised
select list showing the name of the petitioner as successful candidate and
consider the issuance of his appointment against the post of ‘Multi-Tasking
Operator (un-common)’, if he is otherwise eligible within a period of
30(thirty) days from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
21.
Mr. D. Sarma, learned Additional G.A. has submitted that this
order must not be treated as judgment in rem but a judgment in personam and
should be confined only relating to the petitioner here-in-above. According to
me, this submission of learned Additional G.A. is reasonable and logical. This
process cannot be continued perpetually and this judgment cannot be treated
as precedent if similar applications are filed in future.
22.
Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands allowed and thus
disposed.
23.
Copies of the National Trade Certificates relating to Arpan Sarkar
and Debabrata Debnath, as produced by learned Advocate General, may be
kept on record for future reference.
JUDGE
signed by SANJAY GHOSH
SANJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2025.03.01 16:59:52 +05'30'
sanjay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review