Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.221 of 2021, WP(C)No.704 of 2020, WP(C)No.705 of 2020, WP(C)No.706 of 2020,
WP(C)No.707 of 2020, WP(C)No.708 of 2020, WP(C)No.709 of 2020, WP(C)No.710 of 2020,
WP(C)No.711 of 2020, WP(C)No.712 of 2020, WP(C)No.713 of 2020, WP(C)No.714 of 2020,
WP(C)No.715 of 2020, WP(C)No.716 of 2020, WP(C)No.725 of 2020, WP(C)No.727 of 2020,
WP(C)No.728 of 2020, WP(C)No.729 of 2020, WP(C)No.730 of 2020, WP(C)No.731 of 2020,
WP(C)No.732 of 2020, WP(C)No.733 of 2020, WP(C)No.734 of 2020, WP(C)No.735 of 2020,
WP(C)No.222 of 2021, WP(C)No.223 of 2021 & WP(C)No.224 of 2021
In WP(C)No.221 of 2021
Sri Ashim Sarkar
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 10 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.704 of 2020
Bimal Chandra Paul
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 9 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.705 of 2020
Sri Manik Paul
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 8 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.706 of 2020
Radheshyam Paul
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 6 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.707 of 2020
Panulal Das
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 8 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.708 of 2020
Rajesh Jamatia
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 7 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.709 of 2020
Prabir Jamatia
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 7 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.710 of 2020
Ratan Jamatia
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 7 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.711 of 2020
Manik Ghosh
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 6 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.712 of 2020
Kamal Debnath
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 6 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.713 of 2020
Apu Debnath
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 8 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.714 of 2020
Santosh Chandra Debnath
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 7 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.715 of 2020
Ajit Chakraborty
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 9 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.716 of 2020
Abdul Hasem
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 8 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.725 of 2020
Sukanta Muhari
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 8 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.727 of 2020
Dilip Datta
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 7 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.728 of 2020
Swapan Chandra Rudra Paul
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 7 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.729 of 2020
Sankar Paul
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 6 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.730 of 2020
Samir Sen
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 6 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.731 of 2020
Babul Das
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 7 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.732 of 2020
Subrata Debnath
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 8 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.733 of 2020
Uma Biswas
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 7 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.734 of 2020
Manohar Debnath
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 8 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.735 of 2020
Sri Sudhir Debnath
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 7 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.222 of 2021
Sri Rajendra Datta
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 6 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.223 of 2021
Sri Gouranga Sen
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 6 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
In WP(C)No.224 of 2021
Sri Sanjib Muhuri
……….Petitioner(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura & 6 Ors.
……….Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
: Ms. R. Guha, Adv.
: Mr. A. Bhowmik, Adv.
Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of Hearing of Judgment
& Order
: 12.04.2022
Whether fit for reporting
: NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Judgment & Order(Oral)
Heard Ms. R. Guha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners as well
as Mr. D. Sharma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the Official-respondents and
Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the Pradhan and Panchayat
Secretary-respondents.
2.
All these writ petitions being WP(C)No.221 of 2021 [Sri Ashim Sarkar
versus The State of Tripura and 10 Ors.], WP(C)No.704 of 2020 [Sri Bimal Chandra
Paul versus The State of Tripura and 9 Ors.], WP(C)No.705 of 2020 [Sri Manik Paul
versus The State of Tripura and 8 Ors.], WP(C)No.706 of 2020 [Radheshyam Paul
versus The State of Tripura and 6 Ors.], WP(C)No.707 of 2020 [Panulal Das versus
The State of Tripura and 8 Ors.], WP(C)No.708 of 2020 [Rajesh Jamatia versus
The State of Tripura and 7 Ors.], WP(C)No.709 of 2020 [Prabir Jamatia versus The
State of Tripura and 7 Ors.], WP(C)No.710 of 2020 [Ratan Jamatia versus The
State of Tripura and 7 Ors.], WP(C)No.711 of 2020 [Manik Ghosh versus The State
of Tripura and 6 Ors.], WP(C)No.712 of 2020 [Kamal Debnath versus The State of
Tripura and 6 Ors.], WP(C)No.713 of 2020 [Apu Debnath versus The State of
Tripura and 8 Ors.], WP(C)No.714 of 2020 [Santosh Chandra Debnath versus The
State of Tripura and 7 Ors.], WP(C)No.715 of 2020 [Ajit Chakraborty versus The
State of Tripura and 9 Ors.], WP(C)No.716 of 2020 [Abdul Hasem versus The State
of Tripura and 8 Ors.], WP(C)No.725 of 2020 [Sukanta Muhari versus The State of
Tripura and 8 Ors.], WP(C)No.727 of 2020 [Dilip Datta versus The State of Tripura
and 7 Ors.], WP(C)No.728 of 2020 [Swapan Chandra Rudra Paul versus The State
of Tripura and 7 Ors.], WP(C)No.729 of 2020 [Sankar Paul versus The State of
Tripura and 6 Ors.], WP(C)No.730 of 2020 [Samir Sen versus The State of Tripura
and 6 Ors.], WP(C)No.731 of 2020 [Babul Das versus The State of Tripura and 7
Ors.], WP(C)No.732 of 2020 [Subrata Debnath versus The State of Tripura and 8
Ors.], WP(C)No.733 of 2020 [Uma Biswas versus The State of Tripura and 7 Ors.],
WP(C)No.734 of 2020 [Monohar Debnath versus The State of Tripura and 8 Ors.],
WP(C)No.735 of 2020 [Sri Sudhir Debnath versus The State of Tripura and 7 Ors.],
WP(C)No.222 of 2021 [Sri Rajendra Datta versus The State of Tripura and 6 Ors.],
WP(C)No.223 of 2021 [Sri Gouranga Sen versus The State of Tripura and 6 Ors.] &
WP(C)No.224 of 2021 [Sri Sanjib Muhuri versus The State of Tripura and 6 Ors.]
are combined for disposal by a common order inasmuch as the factual matrix and
the grounds of challenge against the action of the official respondents are identical
and there is hardly any variation.
3.
Before the challenge is analysed, a note should be placed in respect of
the service of notice. All the respondents have been served in WP(C)704 of 2022,
WP(C)705 of 2022, WP(C)706 of 2022, WP(C)707 of 2022, WP(C)708 of 2022,
WP(C)709 of 2022, WP(C)710 of 2022, WP(C)711 of 2022, WP(C)712 of 2022,
WP(C)713 of 2022, WP(C)714 of 2022, WP(C)715 of 2022, WP(C)716 of 2022,
WP(C)725 of 2022, WP(C)727 of 2022, WP(C)728 of 2022, WP(C)729 of 2022,
WP(C)730 of 2022, WP(C)731 of 2022, WP(C)732 of 2022, WP(C)733 of 2022,
WP(C)734 of 2022, WP(C)735 of 2022, WP(C)222 of 2021, WP(C)223 of 2021,
WP(C)224 of 2021 and WP(C)225 of 2021.
4.
In WP(C)221 of 2021, it appears that the Registry has failed to collect
the service report from the postal department, but the correct address has been
given in the notice issued to the respondents No.7 and 8. The registered notice did
not return on failure of service. As such, the presumption of service is taken under
proviso to Order 5 Rule 9(5) of the CPC which provides that where the summons
was properly addressed, duly sent by the registered post with acknowledgment
due and has not been received by the court within thirty days from the date of
issue of the summons it shall be declared notwithstanding the fact that the
acknowledgment has not been received, that summons has been properly received
by the addressee.
5.
In WP(C)225 of 2021 the respondent No.6 refused to accept the notice
when tendered to him by the postal delivery man. Hence, it is to be declared that
the notice has been duly served on the said respondent following the provisions of
Order 5 Rule 9(5) of the CPC.
6.
All the petitioners were working as the Pump Operator under the Rural
Water Supply Schemes. They were engaged for operation and maintenance of the
pumps under the said Scheme. Their engagement was contractual and that was
not a full time engagement. Their performance was being monitored by the
concerned Gram Panchayat where the individual petitioners were engaged to
operate the pumps.
7.
By the memorandum No.F.6(1)PHE(W)/98 dated 10.05.2000, the
guidelines for handing over maintenance and operation of rural water supply
schemes to the Panchayat Raj and Autonomous District Council Area Bodies were
brought to effect from 10.05.2000. By the said guidelines, all rural water supply
schemes executed by PHE were handed over in phases to the Panchayat/BAC/ADC
all over Tripura for operation and maintenance of the rural water supply schemes.
It was also directed by the said guidelines that a block level user committee to be
constituted for proper operation and maintenance of the scheme. It has been
provided further in the said guidelines as under:
“Salary of the maintenance team, operators and helper, to be
placed with the Panchayat Samiti/Block Advisory Committee
under administrative control of BDO shall be paid by the Water
Resources Department up to October, 2006 and salary etc. from
November, 2006 shall be paid by the respective BDO. The Water
Resource Department will issue LPC as of October, 2006 and
send the same to the respective BDOs along with service book
etc. for maintenance of service record. They will also place fund
with BDOs accordingly.”
8.
It is apparent from the above guidelines that the overall control in
respect of the wages etc. is exercised by the concerned Block Development Officer
(BDO). The Panchayat has role in selection and monitoring the performance of the
Pump Operators. Their report and recommendation are given primacy by the
concerned Block Level Committee and the Block Development Officer. For purpose
of termination, BDOs are the authorities to take the final call for termination of the
pump operator and where the pump operators are working under the Autonomous
District Council the concerned Executive Officer may take call.
9.
The petitioners have in all the writ petitions alleged that (1) they were
not allowed to operate the pump by the extra-legal individuals with the change of
power and (2) the keys of the pump houses were forcibly taken from them. In
some cases, the petitioners were formally terminated on the so called poor
performance or absence from duty. But it is not in dispute that almost in all the
cases no show cause notice was issued. But in WP(C)221 of 2021 [Ashim Sarkar
versus State of Tripura and Others] the show cause notice was issued asking the
petitioner why he was illegally absenting from his place of operation. But the
petitioner has stated in his reply that he was suffering from serious illness during
the period from 04.03.2018 to 23.04.2018. The petitioner has denied the
allegations brought against him. However, on the basis of the so called allegations,
the said petitioner has been removed from the service.
10.
All the petitioners have asserted that in their place, a new person has
been appointed most illegally. It has been also stated that out of threat-perception,
the petitioner could not lodge the complaint in time but in some cases, the
petitioners lodged the complaint to the police, but no action, as expected, has been
taken to protect them for purpose the operating the pump.
11.
The petitioners have, in the said conspectus of fact, urged this court to
set aside the appointments of the private respondent as the pump operator in the
place of the petitioners and to take them back to their service. Wherever, the order
of termination has been issued, that has been sought to be set aside. even the
respondents could not place any engagement order appointing new person as the
Pump Operator.
12.
It appears persuasive that a brief note of facts extracting from the fact
placed by the petitioners in respect of each of the writ petitioners is placed before
appreciating the challenge made in this batch of writ petitions.
“WP(C)704 of 2020
Sri Bimal Chandra Paul versus State of Tripura and Others
On 07.10.2005, the petitioner joined the post of pump operator at Barabhaiya Gram
Panchayat in WS scheme under Matabari RD Block, Gomati Tripura. On 27.04.2018 the
Chairman including the respondent no.3, 8 and 9 of Barabhaiya gram panchayat vide
its resolution no.2 and 3 arbitrarily decided to remove the petitioner from his post of
pump operator and engaged the respondent no.10 on a false allegation. On 29.10.2018
the respondent no.3 intimated the respondent no.4 regarding the replacement of the
petitioner with the respondent no.10 and had proposed to engage the respondent
no.10 as temporary pump operator under the said scheme. After engaging the
Respondent No.10, in the post of the Petitioner, on 19.11.2018, the respondent no.4
terminated the petitioner from his job without any due procedure or without issuing
any show-cause notice. On 22.11.2018, the respondent no.10 forcibly took away the
keys of the pump house from the petitioner and also obtained his signature on a blank
paper. The petitioner informed the matter verbally to the respondents along with the
Police but, no action was taken. Lastly, on 09.07.2020, the petitioner lodged a
complaint with the SP, Gomati, but till date no action has been taken. The Petitioner
has not been served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)705 of 2020
Sri Manik Paul versus State of Tripura and Others
On 07.10.2005, the petitioner joined the post of pump operator at Bagabasa Gram
Panchayat in WS scheme under Matabari RD Block, Gomati Tripura. On 18.03.2019,
some miscreants of the locality who are supporters of the ruling party put new lock
and key in the pump house on 19.03.2019 the petitioner informed the matter to the
respondent No.4 but no action was taken. On 15.05.2019 some unknown miscreants
opened the door of the pump house and started to operate the pump machine illegally
and asked the petitioner not to come to the pump house. From that day onward the
petitioner could not perform his job and his salary was withheld by the Respondent
No.4 and he refused to put his signature on the work-report/log book. On 08.07.2020
the petitioner submitted a complaint to the SP, Gomati, but no action has been taken
till date. The Petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)706 of 2020
Sri Radheshyam Paul versus State of Tripura and Others
On 01.10.2017, the petitioner joined the post of pump operator at Karaiyamura Gram
Panchayat, Tepania, RD Block, Gomati Tripura under DTW scheme. On 07.06.2018,
some miscreants who are supporters of the ruling party had forcibly taken away the
keys of the pump house from the petitioner and threatened him of his life. They also
obtained the signature of the petitioner on a blank paper forcibly. The Petitioner
verbally complained to all the State Respondents along with the Police but in vain.
Lastly, on 09.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, Gomati, but till date no
action has been taken. The Petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for
termination.
WP(C)707 of 2020
Sri Panulal Das versus State of Tripura and Others
On 21.03.2013, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Pitra Gram Panchayat, Matabari RD Block, Gomati Tripura. On 10.04.2019, some
miscreants who are supporters of the ruling party had taken the signature of the
petitioner on a blank paper forcibly and taken away the keys of the pump house from
the petitioner and threatened him of his life. The petitioner informed the matter
verbally to the respondent no.3 but no action has been taken. Lastly, on 09.07.2020,
the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, Gomati, but till date no action has been taken.
The Petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)708 of 2020
Sri Rajesh Jamatia versus State of Tripura and Others
On 06.12.2007, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Jalema ADC village of Killa RD Block, Gomati Tripura. On 01.01.2019, some miscreants
of the locality, who are supporters of the ruling party, forcibly obtained the signature
of the petitioner on a blank paper and threatened him of his life. They further
threatened him not to come to the pump house and also snatched away the keys of the
same. The miscreants put a new lock in the pump house. From that day onward the
petitioner could not perform his job and his salary had been withheld by the State
Respondents. The petitioner informed the matter verbally to the respondents No.2 and
3 and also to the police but did not take any action into the matter. Thereafter, on
08.07.2020, the petitioner sent a letter to the SP, Gomati, but no action has been
taken. The Petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)709 of 2020
Sri Prabir Jamatia versus State of Tripura and Others
On 18.08.2010, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Jalema Manikya of Killa RD Block, Gomati Tripura under ARWS scheme. On 07.07.2019,
some miscreants of the locality who are supporters of the ruling party had forcibly
obtained the signature of the petitioner on a blank paper and threatened him of his
life. They further threatened him not to come to the pump house and also snatched
away the keys of the same. The miscreants put a new lock in the pump house. From
that day onward the petitioner could not perform his job and his salary had been
withheld by the State Respondents. The petitioner informed the matter verbally to the
respondents No.2 and 3 and also to the police but they did not take any action into the
matter. Thereafter, on 08.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, Gomati, but
no action has been taken. The Petitioner has not been served any show cause notice
for termination.
WP(C)710 of 2020
Sri Ratan Jamatia versus State of Tripura and Others
On 03.05.2004, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Jalema Manikya LI point of Killa RD Block, Gomati Tripura. On 05.07.2019, some
miscreants of the locality who are supporters of the ruling party had forcibly obtained
the signature of the petitioner on a blank paper and threatened him of his life. They
further threatened him not to come to the pump house and also snatched away the
keys of the same. The miscreants put a new lock in the pump house. From that day
onward the petitioner could not perform his job and his salary had been withheld by
the State Respondents. The petitioner informed the matter verbally to the respondents
No.2 and 3 and also to the police but they did not take any action into the matter.
Thereafter, on 08.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, Gomati, but no
action has been taken. The Petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for
termination.
WP(C)711 of 2020
Sri Manik Ghosh versus State of Tripura and Others
On 18.03.2009, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Bagabasa Gram Panchayat, Matabari RD Block, Gomati Tripura. On 16.06.2018, some
miscreants who are supporters of the ruling government of Tripura had forcibly
obtained the signature of the petitioner on a blank paper and threatened him of his
life. From that day onward the petitioner could not perform his job and his salary had
been withheld by the State Respondents. The petitioner informed the matter verbally
to the respondents and Police but no action has been taken till date. Lastly on
09.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, Gomati, but till date no action has
been taken. The Petitioner has not been served any show cause notice.
WP(C)712 of 2020
Sri Kamal Debnath versus State of Tripura and Others
In the year 2009, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Dewanbari Gram Panchayat, LI Killa RD Block, Gomati Tripura. On 13.07.2018, some
miscreants who are supporters of the ruling party had forcibly obtained the signature
of the petitioner on a blank paper and threatened him of his life. On 01.08.2018 the
owner of the land on whose plot the pump machine was set up, had put a new door
and lock in the pump house and thereby restrained the petitioner from performing his
duty. The petitioner informed the matter verbally to the State Respondents and police
but no action has been taken. Lastly, on 08.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to
the SP, Gomati, Tripura but till date no action has been taken. The Petitioner has not
been served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)713 of 2020
Sri Apu Debnath versus State of Tripura and Others
The petitioner had been serving as a Pump Operator under Barabhaiya Gram
Panchayat, Gomati Tripura, since 2016. Due to some technical defect, the dam had
broken for which the pump machine could not be operated. Subsequently, the
petitioner reported the matter to the Respondents no.3, 4, 5 and 8 but, they did not
taken any step to resolve the matter. Thereafter, the Respondent no.5 issued a show
cause notice upon the petitioner on 29.03.2018 basing on some false and unscrupulous
facts. On 02.04.2018, the petitioner submitted his reply to the said show-cause notice
and detailed all the facts and circumstances regarding non-operation of the pump
machine. Surprisingly, the Respondent no.8 was reluctant to sign on the work report
submitted by the petitioner and from the month of April, 2018, the respondent no.5
had stopped the salary of the petitioner. Thereafter on 04.04.2018, some miscreants of
the present ruling party under the leadership of Ramu Sarkar forcibly obtained the
signature of the petitioner on a blank paper and also snatched away the keys of the
pump house from his possession. The petitioner though lodged a complaint with the
Bagma police station but his complaint was not received by them. Lastly, on
08.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, South Tripura, but till date no
action has been taken.
WP(C)714 of 2020
Sri Santosh Chandra Debnath versus State of Tripura and Others
On 01.01.2000, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Rajnagar Gram Panchayat, Matabari RD Block, Gomati Tripura. On 28.06.2018, some
miscreants who are supporters of the ruling party under the leadership of the
Respondent No.8, Bhulan Podder forcibly obtained the signature of the petitioner on a
paper where it was stated that, the Petitioner wanted to leave due to his ill health.
They further threatened him not to come to the pump house and also snatched away
the keys of the same. The miscreants put a new lock in the pump house. From that day
onward the petitioner could not perform his job and his salary had been withheld by
the State Respondents. The petitioner informed the matter in writing to the
respondent No.2 but without taking any action, the Respondent No.2 referred the
matter to the Janatar Darbar of CM for disposal, but nothing happened till date. Lastly,
on 09.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, Gomati, but till date no action
has been taken. The Petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for
termination.
WP(C)715 of 2020
Sri Ajit Chakraborty versus State of Tripura and Others
On 08.10.2014, the petitioner had joined to the post of Pump Operator at Karaiyamura
Gram Panchayat in DTRW scheme under Tepania RD Block, Gomati Tripura. On
04.04.2018, some miscreants under the leadership of the respondent No.10, Joydeb
Ghosh, who are supporters of the ruling party had forcibly obtained the signature of
the petitioner on a blank paper and threatened him of his life. They had also obtained
the signature of the petitioner on a blank paper forcibly. By memo dated 02.08.2018
issued by the respondent no.4 and 08.08.2018 issued by the respondent No.3, the
petitioner was terminated from his service and in his place the respondent No.10 had
been illegally engaged. The petitioner informed the matter verbally to the State
Respondents and police but, no action has been taken. Lastly, on 08.07.2020, the
petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, Gomati, but no action has been taken till date. The
Petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)716 of 2020
Abdul Hasem versus State of Tripura and Others
On 28.09.2006, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Pitra Gram Panchayat, Matabari RD Block, Gomati Tripura. On 19.07.2018, some
miscreants who are supporters of the current ruling party physically assaulted the
petitioner to obtain his signature failing which they snatched the keys of the pump
house. The petitioner informed the matter verbally to the respondent No. 3 and police
but no action has been taken. Lastly, on 09.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to
the SP, Gomati, but no action has been taken till date. The Petitioner has not been
served any show cause notice and has not been paid till date for termination.
WP(C)725 of 2020
Sri Sukanta Muhuri versus State of Tripura and Others
On 21.10.2013, the petitioner was appointed in the post of Pump Operator replacing
his late father, in the Muhuripur Gram Panchayat, Jolaibari RD Block, South Tripura.
From December, 2019, the petitioner was not provided with his salary. Rather on
22.11.2019, in the office of the Muhuripur Gram Panchayat, the signature of the
petitioner was obtained forcibly on a blank paper and threatened him of his life.
Thereafter, the lock of the pump house was broken by the miscreants and a new lock
was put on the door of the pump house. The petitioner though lodged a complaint with
the Baikhora police station but his complaint was not received by them. Thereafter, the
petitioner informed the matter in writing to the Respondent No.2 and 3 but they also
failed to take any action. Lastly, on 06.07.2020, the Petitioner wrote a letter to the SP,
South Tripura, but till date no action has been taken. The petitioner has not been
served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)727 of 2020
Sri Dilip Datta versus State of Tripura and Others
On 08.03.2002, the petitioner was given engagement as pump operator under
Hrishyamukh Gram Panchayat, Hrishyamukh RD Block, South Tripura. On 08.12.2019,
some miscreants of the locality who are supporters of the ruling party had forcibly
taken away the keys of the pump house from the possession of the petitioner and put
the pump house under new lock and key. From that day onward the petitioner could
not perform his job and his salary had been withheld. The petitioner informed the
matter verbally to the State respondents and police but they did not take any action
into the matter. Thereafter, on 07.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP,
Gomati, but no action has been taken. The Petitioner has not been served any show
cause notice for termination.
WP(C)728 of 2020
Sri Swapan Chandra Rudra Paul versus State of Tripura and Others
On 16.03.2015, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator at West
Paikhala Kowya charra under Rajnagar RD Block, Belonia, South Tripura. On
21.03.2018, some miscreants of the locality who are supporters of the ruling party had
forcibly obtained the signature of the petitioner on a blank paper and threatened him
of his life and asked him not to come to the pump house and they had also taken away
the keys of the pump house forcibly and put the pump house under lock and key. From
that day onward, the petitioner could not perform his job and his salary had been
withheld. The petitioner informed the matter verbally to the respondents No.2 and 3
but they did not take any action into the matter. Thereafter, on 07.07.2020, the
petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, Gomati, but no action has been taken. The
Petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)729 of 2020
Sri Sankar Paul versus State of Tripura and Others
On 14.05.2008, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Muhuripur Gram Panchayat, Bokafa RD Block, South Tripura. On 22.11.2019, in the
office of the Muhuripur Gram Panchayat, the signature of the petitioner was forcibly
obtained on a blank paper and threatened him of his life. Thereafter the old lock of the
pump house was broken by the miscreants and a new lock was put on the door of the
pump house. The petitioner though lodged a complaint with the Baikhora police station
but his complaint was not received by it. Thereafter the petitioner informed the matter
in writing to the respondent no.3 but no action has been taken till date. Lastly, on
06.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, Gomati, but no action has been
taken till date. The Petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for
termination.
WP(C)730 of 2020
Sri Samir Sen versus State of Tripura and Others
On 01.10.2003, the petitioner had joined the post of Pump Operator at West Paikhala
GP under BC Nagar RD Block, Belonia, South Tripura. On 14.05.2019, some miscreants
of the locality who are supporters of the ruling government of Tripura had forcibly
taken away the keys of the pump house from the possession of the petitioner and put
the pump house under lock and key. The petitioner informed the matter verbally to the
respondents No.2 and 3 but they did not take any action into the matter. Thereafter,
on 07.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, South Tripura, but no action has
been taken. The Petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)731 of 2020
Sri Babul Das versus State of Tripura and Others
On 01.07.2007, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
North Sarasima Gram Panchayat, Hrishyamukh RD Block, South Tripura. On
30.09.2018, in the office of the North Sarasima Gram Panchayat the signature of the
petitioner was forcibly obtained on a blank paper and threatened him of his life.
Thereafter, the old lock of the pump house was broken by the miscreants and a new
lock was put on the door of the pump house. The petitioner though lodged a complaint
with the Belonia police station but his complaint was not received by it. Thereafter, the
petitioner informed the matter in writing to the respondent no.3 but no action has
been taken till date. Lastly, on 07.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP,
South Tripura, but no action has been taken till date. The Petitioner has not been
served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)732 of 2020
Sri Subrata Debnath versus State of Tripura and Others
On 01.05.2012, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Sarasima Panchayat, Hrishyamukh RD Block, South Tripura. On 22.11.2019, the
respondent No.8, Panchyat Secretary, issue a notice to the petitioner for rerturning the
keys of the pump house. The petitioner did not abide by such arbitrary order and since
then the salary of the petitioner has not been withheld by the State Respondents.
Thereafter, the petitioner informed the matter in writing to the respondent No.3 but no
action has been taken till date. Lastly, on 07.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to
the SP, South Tripura, but no action has been taken till date. The petitioner has not
been served any show cause notice. The petitioner was threatened by the Respondents
No.8 and 9 (Tapan Debnath) of dire consequences. The petitioner lodged an FIR dated
02.12.2019 (Annexure-4) and he was further threatened by antisocial miscreants of
the present ruling party. The petitioner wrote a letter to the Respondent No.6, but till
date no action has been taken. The petitioner has not been served any show cause
notice for termination.
WP(C)733 of 2020
Sri Uma Biswas versus State of Tripura and Others
On 17.10.2005, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
West Paikhala Gram Panchayat, Bharat Chandra Nagar RD Block, South Tripura. On
28.03.2019 and subsequently on 14.04.2019, some miscreants of the locality who are
supporters of the ruling party had forcibly obtained the signature of the Petitioner on
a blank paper on threat perception and asked his not to come to the pump house. From
that day onward the Petitioner could not perform his job and his wages had been
withheld. The petitioner verbally informed the matter to all the State Respondents and
further narrated the entire event in writing to the Hon’ble Minister, PWD on
01.04.2019 and also went to the Police several times but none of his complaints were
acted upon. Then the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, South Tripura on 07.07.2020,
but no action has been taken. The petitioner has not been served any show cause
notice for termination.
WP(C)734 of 2020
Sri Manohar Debnath versus State of Tripura and Others
On 01.05.2012, the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Sachindranagar Gram Panchayat, Jirania RD Block, West Tripura. On 03.07.2018, some
miscreants who are supporters of the ruling party had forcibly obtained the signature
of the Petitioner on a blank paper and took away the keys of the pump house on
threatening him of his life and of dire consequences. The petitioner informed the
matter verbally to the Respondents and to the police but no action was taken. Lastly,
on 10.07.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to the SP, West Tripura, but till date no
action has been taken. The petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for
termination.
WP(C)735 of 2020
Sri Sudhir Debnath versus State of Tripura and Others
On 15.02.2002, the petitioner was appointed as the Pump Operator North Sarasima
Gram Panchayat, Hrishyamukh RD Block, South Tripura, under A.R.W.S. Scheme. On
04.04.2018, some miscreants of the locality who are supporters of the ruling party had
forcibly taken away the keys of the pump house from the possession of the petitioner
and put the pump house under lock and key. From that day onward the Petitioner
could not perform his job and his wages had been withheld. The petitioner informed
the matter verbally to the state-respondents but they did not take any action till date.
Thereafter, on 07.07.2020 the petitioner submitted a letter to the SP, South Tripura,
but no action has been taken thereon. The petitioner has not been served any show
cause notice for termination.
WP(C)221 of 2021
Sri Ashim Sarkar versus State of Tripura and Others
The Petitioner herein had been serving as a Pump Operator under West Charakbai
Gram Panchayat since 2015. Due to his illness he had to go on medical leave from
04.03.2018 to 23.04.2018 and subsequently on 24.04.2018, he had joined into his
service supported with medical certificates issued by the medical officer. Thereafter, in
continuation of his service on 27.05.2018 some miscreants belonging to the ruling
party had forcibly obtained the signature of the Petitioner on a blank paper and also
took the keys of the pump house from the Petitioner on threat and restrained the
Petitioner for performing with his job. Surprisingly, on 11.11.2019 and on 04.12.2019,
the Petitioner was issued with show cause notices on some false and unscrupulous
facts to which he had submitted his replies on 14.11.2019 and on 12.12.2019
respectively narrating all the facts/incidents as to how he was restricted from
performing his job and forcefully removed from his place of work. The Petitioner
though narrated all the incidents to the respondents, but they had not taken any action
in this regard. The Petitioner also went to lodge a complaint with the Baikhora police
station but his complaint was not received by them. Lastly, on 06.07.2020, the
Petitioner lodged a complaint with the SP, South Tripura, but till date no action has
been made. After removing the petitioner from his service illegally and arbitrarily, the
pump machine today is being operated by some other persons who are supporters of
ruling party, which is violative to the principle of natural justice and not tenable in the
eye of law. Despite the Petitioner sought for reliefs but, till today due to illegal and
arbitrary inaction of the Respondent-authorities, the Petitioner had been deprived of
his legitimate right to continue his service as the Pump Operator. Hence, this Writ
Petition. The petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)222 of 2021
Sri Rajendra Datta versus State of Tripura and Others
On 31.08.1999 the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Muhuripur Gram Panchayat and after joining, the petitioner had been serving his
duties uninterruptedly and to the utmost satisfaction of the people of the Panchayat
without any complaint, whatsoever. On 05.09.2018, some miscreants who are
supporters of the ruling party had forcibly taken away the keys of the pump house on
threat perception. From that day onward, the petitioner could not perform his job. The
petitioner informed the matter to the State Respondents but, till date the petitioner
has been left with no remedy. Lastly, on 06.07.2020, the petitioner lodged a complaint
with the SP, Belonia, but till date no action has been taken. The petitioner has not been
served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)223 of 2021
Sri Gouranga Sen versus State of Tripura and Others
On 01.08.2009 had joined the post of Pump Operator at Kanchannagar Gram
Panchayat under Bokafa RD Block and since after joining, the petitioner had been
serving his duties uninterruptedly and to the utmost satisfaction of the people of the
Panchayat without any complaint, whatsoever. On 04.03.2018, some miscreants who
are supporters of the ruling party had forcibly taken away the keys of the pump house
on threat. From that day onward the petitioner could not perform his job. The
petitioner informed the matter verbally to the SP, Udaipur, but till date no action has
been taken. The petitioner has not been served any show cause notice for termination.
WP(C)224 of 2021
Sri Sanjib Muhuri versus State of Tripura and Others
On 06.01.2004 the petitioner was appointed to the post of Pump Operator under the
Muhuripur Gram Panchayat and after joining, the petitioner had been serving his
duties uninterruptedly and to the utmost satisfaction of the people of the Panchayat
without any complaint, whatsoever. On 05.01.2020, some miscreants who are
supporters of the ruling party had forcibly taken away the keys of the pump house on
threat perception. From that day onward, the petitioner could not perform his job. The
petitioner informed the matter verbally to the State Respondents but, till date the
petitioner has been left with no remedy. Lastly, on 06.07.2020, the petitioner lodged a
complaint with the SP, Belonia, but till date no action has been taken. The Petitioner
has not been served any show cause notice.
WP(C)225 of 2021
Sri Deb Kanta Jamatia versus State of Tripura and Others
On 12.12.2007 had joined to the post of Pump Operator at Jolema ADC village under
Killa RD Block and since after joining, the petitioner had been serving his duties
uninterruptedly and to the utmost satisfaction of the people of the Panchayat without
any complaint, whatsoever. On 01.07.2019, some miscreants who are supporters of
the ruling party had forcibly taken away the keys of the pump house on threat. From
that day onward the petitioner could not perform his job. The petitioner informed the
matter verbally to the State Respondents but, till date the petitioner has been left with
no remedy. Lastly, on 09.07.2020, the petitioner lodged a complaint with the SP,
Udaipur, but till date no action has been taken. The petitioner has not been served any
show cause notice.
13.
Mr. D. Sharma, learned Addl. G.A. has appeared for the Official-
respondents and stated that those respondents have filed their reply in
WP(C)221/2021,
WP(C)713/2020,
WP(C)224/2021,
WP(C)725/2020,
WP(C)706/2020,
WP(C)730/2020,
WP(C)711/2020,
WP(C)733/2020
and
WP(C)734/2020 and the respondents have adopted the reply of WP(C)221/2021 in
WP(C)222/2021, WP(C)223/2021 and WP(C)225/2021. Mr. Sharma, learned Addl.
G.A. has quite categorically stated that the writ petitioner of WP(C)225/2021
namely Debkanta Jamatia has been reengaged as the Pump Operator and as such,
the reliefs sought in WP(C)225/2021 has become infructuous. It appears from the
submission of Mr. Sharma, learned Addl. G.A. that the respondents have taken the
common stand in all the writ petitions except the writ petition being WP(C)225 of
2021.
14.
In para-11 of the reply filed by the respondents in WP(C)221/2021
[Ashim Sarkar versus State of Tripura and Others], it has been stated that several
complaints had been received against the petitioner from the Panchayat bodies of
West Chrakbai Gram Panchayat and from villagers of West Charakbai Gram
Panchayat. It has been alleged against the petitioner that the petitioner is not
operating the pump. He had been working in a company at Agartala. It has also
been stated in the reply that the incident of the physical obstruction or that his
keys were taken forcibly by some person are not supported by any reliable proof. It
has been also asserted that a notice was issued to the petitioner and that was
received by his brother. As the petitioner was not working, his working report was
also not sent for purpose of releasing his salary/wages bills. Consequently, his
salary was not released. For this, the respondents cannot be held responsible.
They have enclosed copies of the complaints with their reply. But there is no
statement in the reply to the effect that those were served on the petitioner for his
response. The petitioner has filed the rejoinder in response to the reply and
categorically stated that the allegations of not operating the pump is completely
false and the petitioner has no knowledge about the complaints which are being
relied by the respondents in order to shield their arbitrary action. In paras-13 and
14 of the rejoinder filed by the petitioner, it has been asserted that no copy of the
complaint and the notice was ever sent to the petitioner. The petitioner has
categorically stated that he never ceased to operate the pump and he is willing to
operate the pump. The story that the petitioner had abandoned his duty and got
engaged in a company is manufactured and has been denied by the petitioner.
15.
Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel has appeared for the Pradhan and
Panchayat Secretary in WP(C)222/2021, WP(C)224/2020, WP(C)725/2020 and
WP(C)729/2020. The reply has been filed on their behalf. In all those replies, filed
through Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel, the respondents have stated that the
petitioners had resigned voluntarily. The petitioner in WP(C)222/2021 had resigned
on 09.01.2020 [see page-33 of the reply filed by those respondents]. It has been
also stated that after receipt of the resignation, the petitioner was asked to appear
before the BDO and he had submitted that he had tendered the resignation
voluntarily for his ill health. The state-respondents have not averred anything in
that line. However, it has been asserted that his resignation was accepted. In his
place one Sujit Patwari has been engaged as the Pump Operator. No engagement
letter has however been placed before this court. The said appointment has not
been challenged in the writ petition. In view of the aforesaid development, the writ
petition has become infractuous. Moreover, the allegation of physical obstruction
has been discarded by the police investigation in P.S. Case No.2020 BKR 047. The
story of resignation has been strongly denied by the petitioner by stating that the
signature borne in the resignation letter is not the signature of the petitioner.
16.
The writ petitioner of WP(C)729/2020 had also tendered the resignation
and that was also accepted after three notices having sent to him. In his place one
Ashish Sarkar has been engaged as the Pump Operator but no engagement letter
has been produced. Neither has it surfaced from any records. The similar plea of
maintainability has been raised in this writ petition.
17.
According
to
Mr.
Bhowmik,
learned
counsel
the
petitioner
of
WP(C)725/2020 had also tendered resignation but they have failed to give the date
of the resignation or the details of whether the notice was issued or the resignation
has been accepted or not. Those respondents have raised a new plea in
WP(C)224/2020 stating that the petitioner did not wait to receive a notice in
respect of the termination but rushed to this court. They have admitted that even
though no notice was issued for termination, one Sri Sanjib Muhuri was engaged to
operate the Pump. Those respondents have generally contended that the
petitioners do not have any right on the engagement inasmuch as the engagement
is contractual one and governed by the terms and conditions as laid down in the
appointment letter. There cannot be any issue over that aspect.
18.
Having scrutinised the replies filed in the other writ petitions as noted
above, it appears that no notice was issued before the termination and abruptly
the petitioners were debarred in discharging their duties as the pump operator. In
place of terminated pump operators, in a very few cases, it has been claimed that
new persons have been engaged for operating the pump without following any
transparent method.
19.
In response to the submission made by the counsel for the respondents
as noted above, Ms. Guha, learned counsel has categorically stated that the
Official-respondents have not raised the plea of resignation. In WP(C)713/2022,
apart from WP(C)221/2021, the respondents have claimed that two show cause
notices were issued but the petitioner never replied to the said show cause notices.
But the petitioner of that writ petition has claimed that no such notice was ever
received by him. the respondents did not lay any record to prove the service.
Subsequently, the petitioners in some cases informed the occurrence of
intimidation but no investigation, except in one case, as claimed, took place on
those allegations. In WP(C)734/2020, it has been stated that as per the resolution
of the Gram Sabha the petitioner was removed and another person has been
engaged to operate the pump. But no records have been produced to show that
the petitioner was ever afforded any opportunity for laying his version. The
allegations made in respect of the writ petitioner of WP(C)224/2021, Ms. Guha,
learned counsel has submitted that nobody has been appointed in his place, but
the petitioner has not been allowed to operate the pump most arbitrarily. From the
brief note against each of the writ petition, it is apparent that the following
common allegations have been made by the writ petitioners :
“[a] Physical intimidation dictating not to operate the pump.
[b] Taking away the keys of the pump house by applying criminal force,
but for circumstances of uncertainty and fear, immediately no police help
could be taken. Even, when the police was informed, they did not act to
protect the interest the petitioners.
[c] In most of the cases, no notice was issued before the impugned
termination or forced debarment.
[d] In two case where the notice was issued but in one case the reply
was not at all considered by the competent authority till the date of filing
the writ petition and in another case the writ petitioner did not receive
the show cause notice as claimed to have been issued.
[e] The writ petitioners have been stated to have resigned from the
engagement which, however, has been squarely denied by the writ
petitioners by stating that they did not file any resignation. In one case
the petitioner has claimed that the signature appearing on the so called
resignation letter is not his. The signature is fabricated.”
20.
Having scrutinised the records as produced with the writ petition as well
as with the counter-affidavit, where-ever the counter-affidavit has been filed, this
court is of the view that no notice was issued to the petitioner before termination
having extended the opportunity of filing the response or where the notice has
been issued, the reply was either not considered or the petitioner did receive the
purported notice inasmuch as no piece of document has been produced by the
respondents to show that despite receipt of the notice, the petitioner has preferred
to not reply. But in all the cases except in one, the substitute person have been
claimed to have engaged to operate the pumps. but no record to that effect has
been placed in this court for scrutiny.
21.
Production was the onus of the respondents who have claimed of such
fresh engagement. When the reply has been filed by the respondents, they have
stated that either there was dissatisfaction from the Panchayat body or the people
of the Panchayat area against the writ petitions as they were not regularly
operating the pump or for a long time they were absent from the duty. If the
service is not satisfactory, the respondents may, after affording a reasonable
opportunity to the Pump Operators, terminate the service but when any action is
based on allegation, the person against whom such allegation has been made has
right to reply to such allegation. Without opportunity of filing the reply or evidence
to rebut such allegation, the action of termination is bound to be arbitrary and
liable to be set aside. In the present case, termination has in all cases been given
effect to, as claimed by the respondents, without any notice or by engaging the
other person as the pump operator. It has been stated that in WP(C)225/2021 the
petitioner has been recalled to operate the pump.
Ms. Guha, learned counsel, however has submitted that she has no such
instruction from the petitioner. Thus, this court can rely an affirmed statement in
regard. So it is declared that the writ petitioner of WP(C)225/2021 has been
granted the relief by the respondents.
22.
It appears that the BDO has the substantial control over the engagement
of the petitioner, but in no case he had issued the termination letter. True it is that
the engagement of the petitioner cannot be tantamount to holding of a civil post
and as such, the petitioners cannot claim any right over the post for continuance
beyond the period as prescribed by the contract of engagement. But in the present
case, the respondents have definitely acted arbitrarily and/or they have allowed
such action to continue, even though, such action is unsustainable under the rule
of law. The Constitutional methods have been given a go bye and hence, this Court
does not have any other alternative but to observe that the abrupt disengagement
of the petitioners are unsustainable and hence those actions are interfered with
and set aside. A pattern that surfaced is grossly against the tenets of the rule of
law.
23.
Hence, the respondents, except the private respondents, shall reengage
the petitioners within a period of 1(one) month from the date of receiving the
order of this court. If there is any complaint against the petitioner in respect of
their service as the Pump Operator, the concerned Block Development Officer be
forwarded with the said complaint. On initial scrutiny of the said complaint if there
appears any substance prima facie, the BDO shall issue show cause to the
concerned Pump Operator so that he can make his response substantively against
such complaint. Thereafter, the BDO may enquire and decide appropriately. So far
the issue of resignation is concerned, wherever is applicable, the concerned Block
Development Officer shall issue a specific show cause asking whether such
resignation has been tendered by the Pump Operator voluntarily or at all and after
the response is received from the concerned pump operator, the appropriate order
be passed by the BDO.
24.
It is really shocking to note that no pubic authority had come forward to
lift the veil of the allegations made by the petitioners. In the replies filed by the
Official-respondents it has not been clearly denied in order to state that there had
been no intimidation at all. What they have stated is that the police was not
reported and in one case the police did not find any evidentiary material to hold
that there was intimidation. But the element of intimidation loses its relevant when
this court has noted that the petitioners were unceremoniously disengaged without
any notice or in one case without deciding the reply filed by the petitioner.
25.
Fairness in the action is the core value of the rule of law. The public
servant cannot be the instrument of any action which goes against the fairness of
action. The public servants shall, at all the time, remind themselves that they are
obligated by the constitution to protect the rule of law and not to subvert it. Thus,
they should reverse all actions which might come in the way of reengagement of
the petitioners as directed. However, under the circumstances, this court is not
inclined to grant any back wage to the petitioners, but the wages of the working
period shall be released within 30 (thirty) days from the day of receiving a copy of
this order from the petitioners.
In terms of the above all the writ petitions are allowed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review