Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
AD 11
S. Banerjee
AR (Ct.)
HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Hiranmay Bhattacharyya
WPA 28855 of 2025
Sri Subrata Biswas
Versus
State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the petitioners
:
Mr. Partha Pratim Roy
Ms. Poulami Chakraborty
For the State-respondent
:
Mr. Rabindranath Pal
Mr. Sasthi Charan Dhara
Heard on
:
06.01.2026
Judgement on
:
06.01.2026
Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.:
1. The petitioner has challenged the orders being nos. 3 and 4 both
dated June 25, 2025 passed by the Additional District Magistrate
(LA), Nadia in this writ petition.
2. The property of the petitioner being RS Plot no. 312 corresponding
to LR plot no. 103, JL No. 53, within Mouza – Simultala, under
Police Station – Kotwali in the district of Nadia was acquired vide
LA Case No. 117/PHE/0910 under the provisions of the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 (‘the 1894 Act’, for short). The notice under
Section 12(2) of the 1894 Act dated August 22, 2013 was issued
and immediately upon receipt of such notice the petitioner by a
letter dated August 29, 2013, raised objection against adequacy of
the compensation amount determined under the Award. The said
written objection was received by the office of the Land Acquisition
Collector, Nadia on August 29, 2013. Thereafter a notice dated
January 8, 2014 was issued to the petitioner requesting the
petitioner to collect the compensation amount from the office of the
Special Land Acquisition Officer, Krishnanagar, Nadia within
February 15, 2014 failing which the amount will be deposited in
the Treasury. The petitioner thereafter received the said amount on
March 5, 2014. Since the matter was not referred by the Collector
for determination by the Court in terms of Section 18 of the 1894
Act, petitioner submitted a representation dated July 20, 2020
before
the
Executive
Engineer,
Public
Health
Engineering
Directorate, Nadia Sub-Division and thereafter demanded justice
from the Collector, Nadia vide learned advocate’s letter dated May
5, 2025 requesting such authority to take necessary steps.
3. Mr. Roy learned advocate appearing for the petitioner submits that
the written objection submitted by the petitioner against the
adequacy of the compensation amount which was received by the
office of the Collector, Nadia on August 29, 2013, ought to have
been treated as a prayer for making reference under Section 18 of
the 1894 Act. In support of such contention, Mr. Roy places
reliance upon a decision of the Hon’ble Division Bench in the case
of Ramesh Chandra Dhara & Ors. –Vs.- State of West Bengal
& Ors., reported at (2014) 1 CHN 716. Mr. Roy further submits
that the petitioner received the compensation amount under
protest and receipt of the compensation amount under protest is
itself sufficient to refer the matter for determination by the Court
under Section 18 of the 1894 Act. In support of such contention
Mr. Roy places reliance upon a decision of the Hon’ble Madras
High Court in the case of Narayanaswamy & Anr. –Vs.- The Special
Tahsildar for Land Acquisition, Adi Dravidar Welfare, Tiruppur &
Anr., reported at 1994 (1) MLJ 393.
4. Mr. Roy, learned advocate appearing for the petitioner places
reliance upon a decision of the Hon’ble Division Bench in the case
of Kusumlata Khandelwal & Ors. –Vs.- Land Acquisition Collector &
Ors., reported at AIR 1974 Cal 396 in support of his contention
that the subject-matter of objection against the determination of
compensation amount is itself sufficient to make a reference under
Section 18 of the 1894 Act.
5. Per contra, learned advocate appearing for the State submits that
in the written objection dated August 29, 2013 the petitioner has
only prayed for redetermination of the compensation amount. He
further submits that no specific prayer for making a reference
under Section 18 of the 1894 Act was made. He submits that
acceptance of the compensation amount would amount to waiver of
his right to make a reference under Section 18 of the 1894 Act.
6. Heard the learned advocates for the parties and perused the
materials placed.
7. The Award was passed on August 22, 2013 under the 1894 Act,
i.e., prior to coming into force of the Right to Fair Compensation
and
Transparency
in
Land
Acquisition,
Rehabilitation
and
Resettlement Act, 2013 (‘the 2013 Act’, for short), which came into
force with effect from January 1, 2014. The notice under Section
12(2) of the 1894 Act was issued on August 22, 2013 and the
compensation was disbursed on February 15, 2014. Since the
Award was made prior to January 1, 2014, i.e., prior to
commencement of the 2013 Act, the entire proceeding shall be
governed under the 1894 Act and not under the 2013 Act. (see
Indore Development Authority –Vs.- Manoharlal & Ors., reported at
(2020) 8 SCC 129)
8. The petitioner submitted a letter dated August 29, 2013 disputing
the adequacy of compensation. The said written objection was filed
within a week from the date of issuance of the notice under Section
12(2) of the 1894 Act. The Additional District Magistrate (LA),
Nadia in the order being no. 3 dated June 25, 2025 after observing
that the petitioner received the Award compensation under protest
on February 15, 2014 recorded that no formal application for
reference was filed within the stipulated period of limitation and
the subsequent representations made by the petitioner in 2020
and 2025 is well beyond the period of limitation for seeking a
reference under Section 18(2) of the 1894 Act. By the order being
no. 4 dated June 25, 2025, the District Magistrate (LA), Nadia
rejected
the
claim
of
the
petitioner
for
enhancement
of
compensation and interest upon holding that such claim is barred
by limitation under Section 18(2) of the 1894 Act as it fails to
satisfy the mandatory requirement for a valid reference application.
9. The question that arises for consideration is whether the written
objection of the petitioner by letter dated August 29, 2013 can be
treated to be an application seeking reference under Section 18 of
the 1894 Act.
10. After going through the said letter dated August 29, 2013 this
Court finds that the petitioner after specifically stating that he had
right, title, interest and possession in respect of the property in
question also stated about the classification of the said land and
that the compensation amount was determined at Rs. 2,09,757/for the scheduled land whereas the market value of such value is
more than Rs. 50,000/- per decimal. The petitioner also annexed a
copy of the sale deed no. 5777 of 2012 in support of his claim for
the market value of the property in question.
11. After going through the said letter dated August 29, 2013 styled
as written objection, this Court is of the considered view that the
petitioner raised specific objection against determination of the
compensation amount by the said Award.
12. In order to decide as to whether the letter dated August 29, 2013
can be construed to be an application seeking reference under
Section 18 of the 1894 Act, it would be beneficial to recapitulate
the provisions of Section 18 of the 1894 Act for which the same is
extracted hereinafter:
“18. Reference to Court. - (1) Any person interested
who has not accepted the award may, by written
application to the Collector, require that the matter
be referred by the Collector for the determination of
the
Court,
whether
his
objection
be
to
the
measurement of the land, the amount of the
compensation, the person to whom it is payable, or
the apportionment of the compensation among the
persons interested.
(2) The application shall state the grounds on which
objection to the award is taken: Provided that every
such application shall be made(a) if the person making it was present or
represented before the Collector at the time when
he made his award, within six weeks from the
date of the Collector's award;
(b) in other cases, within six weeks of the
receipt of the notice from the Collector under section
12, sub-section (2), or within six months from the
date of the Collector's award, whichever period
shall first expire.”
13. From a bare reading of the said provision this Court is of the
considered view that the Collector is obliged to make reference for
determination of the Court in case a person interested has not
accepted the Award and by a written application to the Collector
seeks the matter to be referred by the Collector for the
determination of the Court and such objection may relate either to
the measurement of land, the amount of compensation, the person
to whom it is payable, or the apportionment of the compensation
among the person interested.
14. After going through the letter dated August 29, 2013, it appears
to this Court that the petitioner raised specific grounds of objection
with regard to the amount of compensation determined by the said
Award.
15. The Hon’ble Division Bench in the case of Ramesh Chandra
Dhara (supra) held that even if there was no specific prayer for
making a reference but there was a challenge to the Award, the
same would satisfy the condition precedent for a valid reference.
The Hon’ble Division Bench further held that a dispute challenging
the legality of the Award is sufficient. The Hon’ble Division Bench
held thus:
“…. We have considered the application submitted
by the writ petitioners. Although there was no
specific prayer for making a reference, but there
was a challenge to the award, inter alia, on the
allegation that the award was passed without any
basis. Conditions precedent to a valid reference is
that any person interested,
accepted
the
award,
who having not
desires
to
have
an
adjudication of the claim by the Court, should,
within the period of limitation prescribed in the
proviso to Section 18 of the said Act ask for a
reference. There is no prescribed form for asking for
a reference. A dispute challenging the legality of
the award is sufficient.
We are of the opinion, considering the petition
submitted by the writ petitioners in the office of the
Collector, that the person interested, in substance,
challenges the award and, thus, it should be
construed for ends of justice. A prayer for valid
reference without such representation was made
and, thus, it should be construed for ends of
justice. A prayer for valid reference without such
representation was made within the period of
limitation.
The Supreme Court of India in the case of A.
Viswanatha Pillai and
others Versus
Special
Tahsildar for Land Acquisition No. IV and others
reported
in
AIR
SC
noted
that
undoubtedly there was no express averment in the
reference application under Section 18 of the said
Act that the referring claimant was seeking a
reference on his behalf and on behalf of his three
brothers, but held, inter alia, that it was surprising
that State having acquired the property of a citizen
would take technical objections regarding the
entitlement of the claim. Although the Supreme
Court of India recognized that the State certainly
has right and is entitled to resist claim for
enhancement and lead evidence in rebuttal to prove
the prevailing price as on the date of notification
and ask the court to determine the correct market
value of the lands acquired compulsorily, but as
regards
the
persons’
entitlement
to
receive
compensation, it has no role to play. ……..”
16. In Narayanaswamy & Anr. (supra) it was held that the written
endorsement of protest at the time of receipt of the compensation
amount should be construed as a demand for reference and that
should suffice the purpose of Section 18(1) of the 1894 Act.
17. It is well-settled that there is no prescribed form for seeking a
reference under Section 18 of the 1894 Act and a challenge to the
legality of the Award is sufficient for seeking reference under
Section 18 of the 1894 Act.
18. By applying the proposition of law laid down in the aforesaid
decisions, this Court is of the considered view that the letter dated
August 29, 2013 satisfies the conditions precedent for seeking a
valid reference and the same satisfies all the tests laid down under
Section 18 of the 1894 Act.
19. That apart, it is not in dispute that the petitioner also received
the compensation amount determined by the Award under protest,
which would imply that the petitioner is disputing the adequacy of
the compensation amount. Acceptance of compensation amount
under protest would also satisfy the condition precedent for
making a reference under Section 18.
20. The proviso to sub-Section (2) of Section 18 of the 1894 Act
under clauses (a) and (b) prescribes the time limit within which an
application seeking reference under Section 18 of the 1894 Act
should be made. This Court has already observed that the letter
styled as written objection challenging the adequacy of the
compensation was submitted before the Collector within a week
from the date of issuance of the notice under Section 18(2) of the
1894 Act. This Court, therefore, holds that the letter raising
objection against the award was filed within the time limit
stipulated in proviso to sub-Section (2) of Section 18 of the 1894
Act.
21. Since the reference under Section 18 of the 1894 Act by way of
letter dated August 29, 2013 was submitted within the stipulated
time limit, this Court holds that there was inaction on the part of
the Collector in not making a reference for the determination of the
Court with regard to the objections raised in the said letter dated
August 29, 2013.
22. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in A. Viswanatha Pillai & Ors. –Vs.Special Tahsildar for Land Acquisition No. IV and Ors., reported at
AIR 1991 SC 1966, after noting that in the facts of that case that
there was no express averment in the reference application under
Section 18, i.e., seeking a reference on his behalf and on behalf of
his three brothers, observed that it is surprising that the State
having acquired the property of a citizen would take technical
objections regarding the entitlement of the claim. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court further observed that the State certainly has a
right and entitled to resist the claim for enhancement and lead
evidence in rebuttal to prove the prevailing price as on the date of
notification and ask the Court to determine the correct market
value of the lands acquired compulsorily under the Act and it is for
the claimants inter se to lay the claim for compensation and the
Court would examine and award the compensation to the rightful
person.
23. To the mind of this Court the prayer for reference under Section
18 could not have been rejected on technical grounds.
24. For the aforesaid reasons this Court holds that the orders
impugned in this writ petition suffers from infirmity and the same
are liable to be satisfied and quashed and are accordingly set aside
and quashed.
25. The writ petition stands allowed. The Collector under Act I of
1894, Nadia, being the respondent no. 2, is directed to make a
reference under Section 18 of the 1894 Act within a period of six
weeks from the date of receipt of a server copy of this order.
26. There shall be, however, no order as to costs.
27. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance of requisite formalities.
(Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review