The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. Taking into consideration, this Court finds that it is admitted case of the authorities that the petitioner has executed work in urgent basis to avoid darkness in the area and produce bills from local market, thus, the impugned order cannot sustain. The impugned order dated November 17, 2025 is set aside and quashed.
21. WPA 27682 of 2025 is allowed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S/L 13
15.06.2026
Court. No. 25
Sourav
WPA 27682 of 2025
Sri Subhra Sekhar Ghosal
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
Mr. Amales Ray, Sr. Adv.
Ms. Mousumi Bhowal
Mr. Aman Gupta
Mr. Ishan Bhattacharya
… for the petitioner.
Mr. Subrata Roy
Mr. Guddu Singh
… for the Union of India.
1.
The petitioner has filed the present writ application
challenging the impugned order dated November 17, 2025
issued by the Executive Engineer (SG) (QS &C), Joint
Director (Contracts) for the Chief Engineer by removing
the name of the petitioner from the approved list of the
contractors of the Head Quarter with immediate effect.
2.
The petitioner is the approved contractor under the
Military Engineering Services and was awarded with all the
works as described in schedule as appear in Page No. 79 of
the present writ application. On May 13, 2025, the Chief
Engineer has issued show-cause notice to the petitioner on
the allegation that the petitioner has submitted four fake
bills of M/s. Paul Automobile and M/s. Ajay Battery and
accordingly, the petitioner is directed to show-cause why
the petitioner’s name shall not be removed from the
approved list of the contractors.
3.
The petitioner has submitted a reply on May 20, 2025
informing that the materials which have been supplied by
the petitioner is of the approved make and even till date no
complaint has been received against the materials
supplied. The materials supplied by the petitioner is
genuine. The staff of the petitioner has purchased the said
materials from the local shop and unable to deliver the
genuine bills and the petitioner was not aware that the staff
of the petitioner has submitted the bills from the local
market. On receipt of the show-cause reply submitted by
the
petitioner,
the
authorities
have
recorded
the
proceeding by recommending for suspension of the
business of the petitioner for a definite period not for
lifetime. Subsequent to the resolution taken by the
authorities, the impugned order is passed.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that in the
resolution, the authorities have admitted that the
contractor had attended all the complaint instantly and
even on night or during storm/rainy season, made the
equipment in serviceable condition. To run the equipment
in urgent basis obviously either he had to procure the
materials from the local market or he had used the
materials which were held with him but without genuine
purchase voucher. It is also recorded that perhaps
procuring of materials from dealer may delay to the users
and may result darkness of the particular area for a long
time, due to which the petitioner has procured the
materials from the local market. In the recommendation, it
is also held that the petitioner is a hard worker, technically
and financially sound, intended to complete the work in
before time, always ready for execution of any kind of
difficult work and not a litigated minded.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that there is no
allegation that the materials which have been supplied by
the petitioner are not genuine one or not up to the mark.
The only allegation is that the petitioner has submitted the
vouchers from the local market instead of from the
authorized agents in terms of the special condition of the
contracts. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the only allegation with regard to producing of the
vouchers from the local market and not from the
authorized agents, the respondent authorities cannot
remove the name of the petitioner from the approved list of
the contractors.
6.
The petitioner in support of his submission has relied upon
the judgment in the case of State of Odisha and Others
Vs. Panda Infraproject Limited reported in (2022) 4
SCC 393 and submits that debarment can never be
permanent and the period of debarment would invariably
depend upon the nature of the offence committed by the
erring contractor. By referring the said judgment, the
petitioner submits that in the present case, the only
allegation is that three false bills have been submitted by
the petitioner from the local market instead of the
authorized agents but the materials supplied by the
petitioner is upto the mark. There is no allegation that the
materials supplied by the petitioner is degraded but the
respondent authorities have removed the name of the
petitioner from the approved list permanently which is not
sustainable under law.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
authorities submits that the petitioner has violated the
special condition of the contract. He further submits that
as per the contract, the contractor has to produce the
vouchers/invoices
from
the
manufacturer
or
their
authorized agents for full quantity of the materials but in
the present case, the petitioner has submitted the false
vouchers from the local market and as such, the petitioner
has violated the terms and condition of the contract.
8.
Learned counsel for the respondent has further relied upon
the instruction submitted by the authorities wherein it is
mentioned that the Military Engineering Services (MES)
provides strategic engineering support to the Indian Army,
Navy and Air Force. The department cannot place its trust
in
a
contractor
whose
integrity
is
compromised,
particularly when executing works inside the sensitive
defence installations. Deploying substandard or unverified
equipment in such zones poses a direct security hazard to
the nation.
9.
By referring the said clause, the respondent authorities
have further relied upon the guidelines for suspension,
debarment, demotion and removal of MES contractor
wherein Clause d(ii) provides that the cancellation of
enlistment can be done for violation of any condition of the
contract and the contractor fails to abide by the condition
of enlistment. By relying upon the said document, the
respondent submits that the petitioner by submitting the
fake document has violated the terms and conditions of the
contract and as such, the authorities have rightly removed
the name of the petitioner from the approved list of the
contractor.
10.
Heard the learned counsel for the respective parties.
Perused the materials on record.
11.
The respondent authorities have issued the show-cause
notice to the petitioner on the ground that the petitioner
has submitted the bill of M/s. Paul Automobile and M/s.
Ajal Battery dated April 15, 2023, June 5, 2023, August 5,
2023 and August 10, 2023 which are fake. On receipt of the
show-cause of notice, the petitioner has submitted his
reply. In the reply the petitioner has categorically stated
that the employees of the petitioner purchased the
materials from the local market and unable to deliver the
genuine bills and have produced the bills from the local
market not from the authorized agencies or manufacturers.
12.
It is not the case of the authorities that the bills which have
been submitted by the petitioner have not been issued by
M/s. Paul Automobile or M/s. Ajay Battery. It is the
specific case of the respondent authorities that the
petitioner instead of submitting the bills from the
authorized agents or manufacturer has submitted the bills
from the local market. Thus, it cannot be said that the
petitioner has submitted the fake bills. Only the petitioner
has not submitted the bills from the authorized agents or
manufacturer, had submitted the bills from the local
market. On receipt of the show-cause notice, the
authorities have taken a resolution which reads as follows:“The subject work was an emergent nature of
work. Importance of PMS is too much being
existence of 17 Corps. A numbers of regiment
alongwith vital/important installation are in
PMS.
To
continue
the
enhanced
security,
continuous power supply is warranted even in
breakdown from state electricity board for which
DG sets are to be run instantly and continuously.
The said Contractor had attending all the
complaint instantly and even on night or during
storm/rainy season, made the equipment in
serviceable condition by hook & Crook. To run the
equipment in urgent basis obviously either he had
to procure the materials from local market or he
had used the materials which were held with him,
but without genuine purchase voucher. Perhaps
procuring or material from dealer may delay to
the users and may result darkness of the
particular area for a long time. However,
whatever he had done, the contract admitted his
fault and the same is punishable offence.
Recommendation:- the contractor M/s United
Builders
is
a
hard
worker,
technically
&
financially sound, intend to complete the work in
before time, always ready for execution of any
kind of difficult work and not a litigated minded.
The Contractor M/s United Builders has admitted
the allegation and given his assurance for not
repeating of such mistake vide his letter No. Nil
dated 20th May 2025. Keeping in views, the
undersigned recommended for suspension of
business dealing for a definite period, not for
lifetime.”
13.
In the resolution, the authorities have admitted that the
petitioner is working as a contractor under the respondent
authorities for the several years and the petitioner is
attending all the complaint instantly and even in the night
or during storm/rainy season and made the equipment in
serviceable condition. It is also recorded that the petitioner
might have been borrowed the materials supplied by the
petitioner either from the local market or from his stock. In
the resolution, it is not the case made out by the
respondent authorities that the bills submitted by the
petitioner with regard to the M/s. Paul Automobile or M/s.
Ajay Battery are fake one. Only in the show-cause notice,
the authorities have used the word ‘fake’ but It is not the
case that the said bills were not issued by the M/s. Paul
Automobile or M/s. Ajay Battery.
14.
The special terms and conditions of the contract, Clause
17.7 reads as follows:
“Contractor shall produce vouchers/invoices from
the manufacturers and/or their authorized agents
for the full quantity of the materials, as applicable
as a pre-requisite before submitting claim for
payment for advances on account of the work
done and/or materials collected in accordance
with Condition 64 of General Conditions of
Contracts IAFW-2249. Production of vouchers by
the
contractor
shall
be
his
MANDATORY
contractual obligations and shall be fulfilled by
him for claiming any payment. Contractor is
required to produce purchase vouchers for
materials appearing in the BOQ from the list of
materials
requiring
purchase
vouchers
as
appended below:(a) PCC/RCC
(b) Painting
(c) GI Tubing
(d) PVC (SWR) Pipe
(e) PVC Bend
(f) Water Proofing Compound
(g) Sanitary Fittings
(h) PVC frame and Shutter”
15.
As per the said Clause, the petitioner has to submit the
voucher/invoice from the manufacturer or the authorized
agent but the petitioner has not submitted the same. Thus,
if the materials which have been supplied by the petitioner
is a genuine one and there is no allegation that the
materials which have been supplied by the petitioner is
degraded or not from the branded company, the only
allegation with regard to the bills submitted by the
petitioner from the local market, the authorities cannot
pass the bills raised by the petitioner but the authorities
cannot take severe action by removing the name of the
petitioner from the approved list of the contractor.
16.
The terms and conditions for cancellation of the enlistment
provides that violate any condition of the contract or fails
to abide by the condition of the enlistment. If the petitioner
has not produced the bills from the manufacturer or the
authorized agent, but the materials supplied by the
petitioner is not defective. The authorities cannot pass the
bills of the petitioner till the petitioner not produces
bills/vouchers from manufacturer or authorized agent but
it cannot say that the petitioner has submitted fake bill.
17.
It is not the case that M/s. Pal Automobiles or M/s. Ajay
Battery have not issued the said bill and the petitioner has
forged the said bill.
18.
As per the condition of the enlistment, the competent
authority may suspend, remove or blacklist the contractor
for submission of non-bona fide tenders or for technical or
other delinquency and in the resolution it is recommended
for suspension of business dealing for a definite period, not
for lifetime but the impugned order is for the lifetime and
not for any definite period.
19.
This Court finds that while imposing penalty of removal of
the petitioner from approved list of contract, the
competent
authority
failed
to
consider
the
recommendation wherein it is categorically recorded that
to run the equipment in urgent basis either he had to
procure the materials from local market or had used the
materials which were held with him but without genuine
purchase vouchers. It is also recorded that procured
materials from dealer may delay the users and may result
darkness of a particular area for a long time.
20. Taking into consideration, this Court finds that it is
admitted case of the authorities that the petitioner has
executed work in urgent basis to avoid darkness in the area
and produce bills from local market, thus, the impugned
order
cannot
sustain.
The
impugned
order
dated
November 17, 2025 is set aside and quashed.
21.
WPA 27682 of 2025 is allowed.
22. Urgent photostat certified copies of this order, if applied
for, be supplied to the parties upon compliance with all the
necessary formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review