Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAIGI
AT JAMMU
CRAA No. 95/2o12
Reseruedon: 23.04.2026
Pronounced on:3g. O 5. 2 02 6
Uploaded on: \o .05.2026
State of J&K through Senior
Superintendent of Police,
Wtetlerthe operatiue part orfull
judgment b pronouned:
Kathua
.... Petitioner(s)
Through
Ms. Mehar Bali, Advocate
vlce
Mr. Ravinder Gupta, AAG
Vs.
Balwinder Kumar Alias Bittu
S/o Karan Singh R/o Badala,
Kathua
... ..Respondent(s)
Through:- Mr. Mayank Gupta,
CORAM:
Advocate.
HON'BLE MRS. JUSHCE SINDHU SITARMA, JITDGE
HON',BLE MR. JIISTICE SI{AIrZ.N' AZE,E,M', JIIDGE
JUDGMENT
SHAIIZAD AZEEM.J
This acquittal appeal is directed against the judgment
dated 07 August 2OL2 passed by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Kathua ("the trial Court") in File No
76/Session titled State Vs. Balwinder Kumar alias Bittu,
whereby the trial Court has acquitted the respondent-
CRAA No. 95/2072
accused, Balwinder Kumar of the offences punishable under
Sections 3O2 / 341 RPC read with Section 4 125 of Arms Act.
PROSECUTION CASE
2. The prosecution case, in brief, is that accused was sent
up for trial on the accusation that, owing to a long-standing
enmity, on 19 July 2OO2 at 6:30 PM, when Nasib Chand
(deceased) was returning home after irrigating his fields and
had reached near the house of Karan Singh S/o Vakilu Ram
R/o Badala, the accused stabbed the deceased in the back
with a Kirch (sharp-edged weapon). The occurrence stated to
have taken place in a lane (Gali) of the village following a
daytime quarrel.
3. The deceased had died enroute to the hospital. PW- 1
Gulshan Kumar is said to have lodged a report on 19 July
I
2OO2 at 7:50 PM.
4. During investigation, all the codal formalities were
completed, including recovery of alleged weapon of offence
pursuant to the disclosure made by the accused.
5. It is noteworthy that, or completion of investigation, the
police presented the challan only against the accused,
though investigation into tJ:e alleged occurrence had also
CRAA No. 95/2072
been conducted against his two brothers, namely, Sohan Lal
and Raj Kuma-r, respectively.
FINDINGS OF THE TRIAL COURT
6. While recording the judgment of acquittal, the trial
Court took into consideration the contradictions regarding
who reached the spot first and where witnesses were at the
time of occurrence. Although independent witnesses were
available, only PW-8 Kiran Jyoti was cited as one; she too
turned hostile. The injuries sustained by the accused were
omitted from the statements recorded under Section 16 1
Cr.PC, according to the trial Court, this omission amounted
to an improvement that cast doubt on the prosecution story.
The recovery of weapon of offence was not proved. Learned
triat Court further held that the medical and other evidence
was insufficient. Accordingly, while granting benefit of
doubt, the accused was acquitted.
GROUNDS OF CHALLENGE AND SUBMISSI,oNs
7. The judgment of acquittal is challenged on the ground
that the statements of material eye-witnesses, namely, PW-2
Kanta Devi, and PW-3 Chaya Devi, have been discarded by
the trial Court without any justifiable reason. It is further
contended that the prosecution proved that the occurrence
CRAA No. 95/2072
took place following a daytime altercation, yet the trial Court
discarded the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses, who
happen to be the relatives of the deceased, contrary to
settled principles of law.
8.
It is also urged that non-examination of independent
witnesses, did not render the prosecution case unbelievable,
particularly when it is supported by medical evidence
showing that the deceased was done to death by stabbing
The petitioner, therefore, prays that the impugned judgment
be set aside.
9. Ex Aduerso, learned counsel for the respondent has
argued in line with the reasoning given by the trial Court in
the judgment under challenge. The same shall be taken note
of at the appropriate stage.
ANALYSIS
(
10. The respondent earned the judgment of acquittal by
deriving benefit of doubt. The trial Court reached this
conclusion on the basis of: (i) contradictions appearing in
the testimonies of the eye-witnesses; (ii) absence of
independent witnesses; (iii) failed to explain the injuries
sustained by the accused; (iv) non-recovery of weapon of
CRAA No. 95/2072
Page 4 of L4
offence; and (") the medical and other evidence being
insufficient to bring home the guilt against the accused.
11. On a perusal of the record, it is seen that the
prosecution case is based on direct evidence supplied by the
widow, daughters and sons of the deceased.
12.
Prosecution has heavily relied upon; PW- 1 Gulshan
Kumar, (accuser/son) , PW-2 Kanta Devi (Widow), PW-3 Chaya
Devi (daughter), PW-4 Mamta Devi (daughter), PW-7 Rakesh
Kumar (son) and PW-8 Kiran Jyoti (only independent witness).
Out of these, PW-4 Mamta Devi was not examined, and PW-8
Kiran Jyoti, though the solitary independent witness, turned
hostile. During her cross-examination, nothing incriminating
against the accused could be elicited.
DISCLOSURE AND RECOVERY
13.
The accused was charged with murdering the deceased
by stabbing him in the back with a Kirch. According to
prosecution, the weapon of offence was recovered on the
disclosure of the accused. To prove the recovery, the
prosecution relied upon PW-6 Battu Ram and PW-9, Raj
Kumar respectively, both brothers-in-law of the deceased
L4.
PW-6 Battu Ram was not examined by the prosecution.
pw-9 Raj Kumar turned hostile, and during his crossCRAII No. 95/2072
examination, nothing incriminating against the accused
could be elicited. Consequently, neither the disclosure nor
the recovery of the weapon of the offence was proved.
15. We are, therefore, left with the direct evidence
supplied by sons, daughters and widow of the deceased. In
order ascertain whether there is any inconsistency,
contradiction, omission or improvement in their testimonies
as held by the trial Court, we proceed to examine the matter
PRESENCE OF
WITNESSES
16. PW- 1 Gulshan Kumar, besides being an eye witness,
was also the accuser. He deposed that he and his brother
PW-7 Rakesh Kumar were cutting grass in their fields when
they heard the cries uBachao, Bachao, Maardiya." They
rushed to the spot and arrived after their mother and
sisters. The witness deposed that he saw the accused
stabbing tJ:e victim and then fleeing from the place of
occurrence.
L7. In contrast, PW -2 Kanta Devi deposed that at the time
of occurrence she, along with her daughters only, rurshed to
the spot. The deceased was evacuated on a cot with the help
of her daughters and then shifted to Kathua Hospitat on a
horse cart. This witness completely negated the presence of
CRAA No. 95/2072
PW- 1 and PW-7 at the time of occurrence. PW-3 Chaya Devi
deposed, inter-alia that her uncle PW-5 Dev Raj had also
accompanied them to the place of occurrence. However, PW-
5 Dev R"j, despite being brother of the deceased was neither
cited as an eye-witness nor did he depose that that he had
accompanied the family members of the deceased at the time
of the occurrence. Thus, the eye-witnesses have given
mutually contradictory statements regarding their presence
at the time of occurrence, and their credibility on this point
is sufficiently eroded.
NON.TXAMINATION OF
WITNESSES
18. PW-3 Chaya Devi deposed that l5-2O villagers were
present at the time of occurrence, whereas PW-7 Rakesh
Kumar claimed that 40-50 persons were present on the spot.
If testimonies of these witnesses are to be believed, villagers
were present; however, the prosecution examined only one
independent witness, PW-8 Kiran Jyoti who was declared
hostile.
19. There is ample evidence on record to show that alleged
occurrence took place in a bustling village lane flanked by a
good number of houses. Nevertheless, the prosecution failed
to examine independent witnesses, though they were
CRAA No. 95/2072
PageT of L4
present. This omission casts serious doubt on the
prosecution story and the manner in which the occurrence
is alleged to have taken place.
TESTIMOIITY OF HOSTILE WITNESS
2o.. Surprisingly, PW-8 Kiran Jyoti, though declared
hostile and cross-examined by the prosecution, deposed
during her cross-ex€unination by the defence counsel that
after hearing the noise she remained there for a minute but
did not see PW-7 Rakesh Kumar, PW- 1 Gulshan Kumar,
PW-2 Kanta Devi, PW-3 Chaya Devi or PW-4 Mamta Devi or
the accused-Balwinder Kumar. Despite completely negating
the presence of these eye witnesses and the accused at the
time of occurrence, she was not re-exarnined by the
prosecution to clarify the presence of accused, the deceased
or the eye witness. Therefore, in view of the law laid down by
C
t
Honble Supreme Court in Talari Naresh Vs. The State of
Telangana; 2026 SCC OnI;lne SC 852 the testimony of the
hostile witness cannot be brushed aside. Paragraph 9 of the
judgment assumes importance, which reads thus:-
g. Therefore, uhen the testlmong ol a hostlle
wltness ls admlsslble subJect to be feeded W
corroboratlon and the conulctlon on thqt bcsls
could be arrhted at, the reuerse ls o,lso tnte o.s, a
calnon of appreclatlon of euldence. What
u
CRAA No. 95/2072
necessarllg tmlrltes ls that as the euldence ol a
hostlle ultness co;n be used for conulctlng the
accused, such euldence could lnd,eed be applted
and utlllsed also for tle purpose of acqultttng the
accused, when uhat is testtfied bg the hostlle
ultness lnsplres credlbllttg, uhen read ulth the
other ealdence on record, elther ocular or
documentary. The dlcf,;.tm utould be tha,t the
testlmong of a hostlle urltness or statetnent ln the
deposltlon of hosttle urltness could be properlg
emploged to dlscredlt the prosectttlon case and a
concluslon of o;cqulttal could uell be supported
through tt and could be founded thereln^"
2L. It has been held that if the evidence of a hostile
witness can be used for convicting the accused, such
evidence can indeed be applied and utilized also for the
purpose of acquitting the accused, provided, the testimony
inspires credibility, when read with the other evidence on
record, whether ocular or documentar5r.
22. As already noted, the presence of eye-witnesses stands
c
)
sufficiently corroded by their mutually contradictory
statements given by none other than sons, daughters and
widow of the deceased. When the testimony of the hostile
witness is tested on the anvil of law, it lends credence to the
findings returned by the trial Court regarding the absence of
eye-witnesses at the time of the occurrence
CRAA No. 95/2072
INJI'RIES SUSTAINED BY THE ACCUSED AND
IMPROVEMENTS
23. The injuries sustained by the accused were also not
explained which renders the prosecution story doubtful. PW-
1 Gulshan Kumar completely denied that the accused
received any injury on the day of the occurrence. To the
contra4r, PW-2 Kanta Devi, PW-3 Chaya Devi and PW-7
Rakesh Kumar admitted that the accused was injured and
hospitalized but they c€une up with the theory that the
accused stabbed himself on the neck with the same Kirch
used on the deceased right after committing his murder
However, this "self-stabbing" fact was never mentioned in
the FIR or in any of their statements recorded under Section
161 Cr.PC. The omission of such a material fact constitutes
a serious improvement that renders the testimonies of these
witnesses untruthful.
J
24. PW-13 Dr. Varinder Kumar examined the accused on
19 JuIy 2OO2 at 7 PM. The trial Court called for File No
34/Sessions titled State Vs. Gulshan Kumar arising out of
counter FIR regarding the s€une occurrence. As per the
medical examination, the accused had suffered injuries on
the neck below the chin, right side and an abrasion on the
chest. The prosecution failed to account for these injuries
CPAA No. 95/2072
Such omission assumes great significance, particularly
when evidence consists of interested or related witnesses.
25. In Nand La,l and Ors. Ys. The State of
Chhatttsgarh; (2023) 70 SCC 47O it was held that in a
murder case the non-explanation of injuries sustained by
the accused at about the time of the occurrence or in the
course of altercation is a very important circumstance from
which the Court can draw an inference that the prosecution
has suppressed the genesis and origin of the occurrence and
has not presented the true version. It was further held that
witnesses who have denied the presence of injuries on the
person of the accused are lying on a most material point
and
therefore, their evidence is unreliable. This dictum
assumes even greater importartce when the prosecution
witnesses are interested parties or relatives of the deceased.
Thus, this is another circumstance which discredits the
I
prosecution case.
ANTE-
FIR
26. The occurrence is alleged to have taken place on 19
July 2OO2 at 6.30 PM and the FIR is stated to have been
lodged at 7 .SOPM on the s€une day. PW- 1 Gulshan Kumar
the accuser and son of the deceased, stated in his crossexamination that he and his brother had gone to the police
CRAA No. 95/2072
station the next day at 7 AM to lodge the report. However,
the FIR shows tJre reporting date as 19 July 2OO2 at 7:5O
PM i.e. about O1 hour 20 minutes after the occurrence. This
is another circumstance that casts serious doubt on the
prosecution story and the manner in which it is sought to be
projected.
27. Once, it is show:l, as per the version of informart, that
the FIR is ante-dated and was not lodged at the time it was
reported, the necessary inference is that the Investigating
Officer deliberately failed to record the first information
report on receipt of information of the cognizable offence and
prepared it after due deliberation. This renders the
investigation tainted, and it would be unsafe to rely upon
such a tainted investigation.
28. This discrepancy raises serious doubt regarding the
genuineness and spontaneity of the FIR. If it appears to be
back-dated (ante-dated), Court views it as evidence of
possible manipulation, either by the police to make the case
appear prompt or
by the informant to fill gaps after
consultation. This further casts doubt viz-a-viz the
credibility of the informant and the first information report
that led to the investigation and the trial of the accused.
Our view is fortified by the fact that two brothers of the
CRAA No. 95/2O72
Page t2 of 74
accused, Sohan Lal and Raj Kumar did not face the trial as
the challan was restricted only to the accused.
FINDING AND CONCLUSION
29. We have noticed major contradictions among the eyewitnesses on the point of their location at the time of the
alleged occurrence, (whether in the fields or in the house)
and the sequence in which they reached the spot. Secondly;
despite the presence of villagers at the time of the
occurrence, no independent witness was examined; only one
independent witness, PW-S Kiran Jyoti, was cited who
turned hostile. Thirdly; the prosecution failed to explain the
injuries sustained by the accused in the occurrence, which
shows that the prosecution suppressed the genesis of the
crime. Besides this, the prosecution miserable failed to prove
the disclosure and recovery of the weapon of offence. The
case is also marred by material omissions and
improvements.
30. We, therefore, find no reason to interfere with the
judgment of the trial Court nor do we Iind any illegality,
either on facts or in law, committed by the trial Court while
acquitting the accused by granting him the benefit of doubt.
31. Lastly, we also endorse the cardinal principle of
criminal law reiterated time and again that if two reasonable
CRAA No. 95/2072
rt
views €rre possible on the evidence, one pointing to guilt and
other to innocence, the Court must adopt the view that
favours the accused. Even a small, material improbability in
tJ:e prosecution's story can shatter its consistency and
create a reasonable doubt.
32. Accordingly, while concurring with the judgment of
the trial Court, the instant appeal is dismissed being devoid
of merit.
33. Record be sent back to the trial Court with due
dispatch
(Shahza Azeeml
Judge
J,*b(Sindhu Sharmal
Judge
Jammu:
30.05.2026
Tarun/PS
Whether approued for reporting :
CRAA No. 95/2072
Surinder Kumar
2026.05.30 13:57
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Y,*,XZ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review