Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRAA No. 62/2017
Reserved on:
23.04.2026
Pronounced on: 04.05.2026
Uploaded on:
04.05.2026
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced:
State of Jammu and Kashmir
through
Police
Station,
Rembhal, Udhampur.
…. Petitioner(s)
Through:-
Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate
vice Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG
Vs.
Rakesh Singh, S/o Kartar
Singh,
R/o
Assi
Phalata,
District Udhampur.
…..Respondent(s)
Through:-
Mr. Sachin Sharma, Advocate.
Respondent present in person.
CORAM: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE SINDHU SHARMA, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
SHAHZAD AZEEM-J
1.
This acquittal appeal is directed against the judgment
dated 30 April 2016 passed by learned Principal Sessions
Judge, Udhampur (‘the Trial Court’) in File No. 80/Sessions
titled State Vs. Rakesh Singh, whereby the trial Court has
acquitted the respondent-Rakesh Singh of the offences
punishable under Section 302, 401, 201 of Ranbir Penal
Code (RPC).
CRAA No. 62/2017
PROSECUTION CASE
2.
Prosecution case, in brief, is that the respondent-
Rakesh Singh (accused), a bachelor from the Rajput Caste
alleged to have taken sexual advantage of Late Subadri Devi
(deceased), belonged to Scheduled Caste (SC) Community
and mother of two children who was staying with her
parents at Aghar Ballian, Reasi after obtaining divorce from
her husband. The accused after being caught in the room of
the deceased in the intervening night of 20/21 April 2014,
though had no genuine intention of entering into an intercaste marriage with the deceased, but on the false pretext of
solemnizing the Court marriage in Reasi Court, instead took
the deceased in the morning of 21 April 2014 to the Maand
Jungle (East Maand Forest). Whereafter, in order to get rid of
the deceased, murdered her. Accused hid the cell phone and
the pair of gold earrings in the Bai Nallah, Katra Jungle
under the bushes after concealing in a plastic bag. The dead
body was recovered on 24 April 2014.
3.
This is the short and brief accusation on which the
accused was put on trial for the commission of offences
punishable under Sections 302, 404, 201 of RPC.
4. For the sake of brevity and in order to avoid repetition,
further details relevant for the adjudication of appeal on
CRAA No. 62/2017
hand shall be taken note of hereinafter while appreciating
the evidence at appropriate stage.
FINDINGS OF THE TRIAL COURT
5.
The trial Court, while acquitting the accused held
that
the
prosecution
case
is
completely
based
on
circumstantial evidence. The trial Court has held that the
prosecution failed to prove “Disclosure, recovery” and “Last
Seen Theory”. The trial Court also held that the “medical
evidence” being inconclusive, and the prosecution case
suffers from major contradictions, omissions and delayed
disclosure, therefore, rendering the prosecution story as
unreliable, hence, had come to the conclusion that the
prosecution has not established a conclusive link connecting
each individual circumstance with the other, and the
accused.
6.
The trial Court was of the view that the evidence do not
bridge the gap between “may be true” and “must be true” so
essential for a Court to see, while finding the guilty of an
accused, particularly, in cases based on circumstantial
evidence. Therefore, the trial Court has acquitted the
accused of the charges, vide impugned judgment under
challenge.
CRAA No. 62/2017
SUBMISSIONS
7.
The judgment of acquittal is challenged on the ground
that the impugned judgment is a result of non-application of
judicial mind on facts as well as on law, which renders the
same bad in the eyes of law. The appeal has also been filed
on the ground that the prosecution has established the guilt
of the accused beyond any reasonable shadow of doubt but
trial Court has not properly appreciated the evidence
brought on record and has ignored the statements of
material witnesses, thereby acquitting the respondent.
According to the appellant, the accused has committed
heinous crime where strict view was required to be taken in
view of the legal position settled by the Apex Court regarding
the disclosure statement and Last Seen Theory, thus, the
judgment is liable to be set aside.
8.
Ex Adverso, learned counsel for the respondent has
argued in line with the reasoning given by the trial Court in
the judgment under challenge and same shall be taken note
of hereinafter at the appropriate stage.
ANALYSIS
9.
Since there is variation insofar as the numbering of
prosecution
witnesses
in
the
challan
and
impugned
judgment of the trial Court is concerned, therefore, for the
CRAA No. 62/2017
sake of clarity and to keep the record straight, we propose to
mention the prosecution witnesses in the same seriatim as
mentioned in the impugned judgment of the trial Court.
10.
The prosecution case is based on circumstantial
evidence
and
in
order
to
complete
the
chain
of
circumstances, so as to bring home the guilt against the
accused, the prosecution had mainly relied upon three
circumstances, i.e. “Last Seen Theory”, “Disclosure, and
Recovery”.
11.
The case set up by the prosecution is that in the
intervening night of 20-21 April 2014, the accused was
caught in the room of deceased and when the family
members
of
the
deceased
have
enquired
about
his
undesirable presence, the accused alleged to have narrated
a false story that he is in relationship with deceased,
therefore, wanted to marry today itself in the Reasi Court.
Accordingly, in the morning of 21 April 2014, he took away
the deceased, however, when after 2-3 days, she did not
return home, a missing report alleged to have been lodged
on 25 April 2014 by PW-2, Sobha Ram, the father of the
deceased in the police station, Reasi.
12.
However, in the evening of 25 April 2014, PW-20,
Sheru Ram, the brother of the deceased was informed by the
CRAA No. 62/2017
police of police post, Tikri about the recovery of the dead
body of a woman from Maand Jungle, which was later
identified by him as that of the deceased.
13.
The prosecution heavily relied upon the fact that the
accused and deceased were last seen together on 21 April
2014 while leaving the house of the deceased on the pretext
of solemnizing marriage, but she did not return and
thereafter, her dead body was found on 24 April 2014.
14.
To prove that the accused and deceased were last
seen together on 21 April 2014, inter-alia, the prosecution
has relied upon the testimonies of the PW-2, Sobha Ram
(father of deceased), PW-5, Usha Rani (Sister-in-law of
deceased), PW-13, Punjab Dai (mother of deceased), PW-20,
Sheru Ram (brother of deceased) and PW-12, Rakesh (Minor
son of deceased). All these witnesses have deposed in
contradiction to each other and their testimonies are full of
improvements, omissions and embellishments, therefore,
have demolished the Last Seen Theory on which the
prosecution case primarily hinges.
15.
According to PW-2, Sobha Ram, accused and
deceased left the house together at 6 a.m, for solemnization
of their Court marriage. PW-5, Usha Rani deposed that the
CRAA No. 62/2017
accused left the house but after 20-25 minutes, had
returned and then he took the deceased at 6.30 a.m-7 a.m.
16.
PW-13, Punjab Dai deposed that accused left the
house at 7 a.m, however, deceased had gone from house
thereafter at 8 a.m. PW-20, Sheru Ram deposed that the
accused left the house first, deceased departed one hour
later.
17.
The most important witness is the PW-12, Rakesh
(minor son of deceased) who deposed that his mother while
departing from the house had told him that she is going to
the houses of certain persons for work and she will be back
home in the evening. He further deposed that deceased
departed from the house two hours after the accused had
left.
18.
PW-2, Sobha Ram deposed that the accused and
deceased left at 6 AM, however, PW-5, Usha Rani deposed
that the accused firstly had gone from house and again
returned after 20-25 minutes and then took the deceased at
around 6.30-7.00, AM, however, these facts did not find
mention in their earlier statements recorded under Section
161 Cr.PC. Insofar as the time of leaving the accused and
deceased immediately before the occurrence from the house
CRAA No. 62/2017
of deceased is concerned, there are contradictions in the
testimonies of PW-2 and PW-5.
19.
PW-13, Punjab Dai, mother of the deceased had
completely demolished the prosecution case. She deposed
that the accused left the house at 7 a.m and thereafter, at 8
a.m, deceased had also gone from there, therefore, there was
a gap of one hour when accused and deceased were last
seen together.
20.
Similarly, PW-20, Sheru Ram, brother of deceased
also deposed in line with PW-13, Punjab Dai and deposed
that the accused firstly left the house and after a gap of one
hour, deceased had left the house.
21.
Lastly, the very important star witness PW-12,
Rakesh, the minor son of the deceased deposed that the
accused had left the house, two hours after the accused.
PW-12 further deposed that when deceased left the house,
she told him that she is going for work in the houses of
certain persons.
22.
From the testimonies of these star prosecution
witnesses, who are none other than parents, brother, son
and sister-in-law of the deceased, the Last Seen Theory
sought to be relied upon by the prosecution is totally
demolished as there is complete contradiction as to the time
CRAA No. 62/2017
of leaving the house together by the deceased and the
accused, inasmuch as, the witness went to the extent of
deposing that accused much before the deceased had left
the house, therefore, the question of last seen together is
rendered totally improbable.
23.
The next circumstance is alleged disclosure and
recovery, which was made in pursuance of a disclosure
statement made by the accused, in respect of one pair of
gold earrings and a mobile phone belonging to the deceased,
which were recovered at the instance and identification of
the accused from the Bai Nallah, Katra vide recovery memo
EXTP-7/IV dated 17 June 2014, witnessed by PW-8, Govind
Ram and Head Constable Sukhdev Singh. The disclosure
statement is the EXTP-7/III.
24.
PW-8, Govind Ram and Head Constable Sukhdev
Singh were the witnesses to the disclosure statement and
recovery memo, however, Head Constable Sukhdev Singh
was not examined by the prosecution, whereas, PW-8,
Govind Ram deposed that the disclosure statement EXTP7/III is not the document which was prepared on 17 June
2014 as that document was signed by him, Kaka and one
Gorkha boy. Therefore, the trial Court was correct in holding
that PW-8, Govind Ram had completely defaced
CRAA No. 62/2017
the
disclosure statement and recovery memo and thus, made
these documents highly doubtful and unreliable.
25.
The prosecution story of recovery and seizure of the
mobile phone and earrings of the deceased at the instance of
the accused has also been completely falsified by PW-11,
Farman Ali. This witness went un-to depose that the mobile
phone was found lying beside the dead body and earrings
were still worn in her ears. This witness had demolished the
alleged recovery of mobile phone and earrings of the
deceased at the instance of the accused, as alleged by the
prosecution.
26.
The expert opinion also did not support the
prosecution case that the deceased was done to death by
strangulation with headgear, however, in the post-mortem
examination report, no definite cause of death could be
ascertained.
27.
From the above noted facts, it can be safely
concluded that the prosecution has miserably failed to prove
that the accused and deceased were seen last together and
further that the recovery on which the prosecution has
banked upon alleged to have been made in pursuance of the
disclosure and identification of the accused, therefore, these
important links in the chain of circumstances are missing,
CRAA No. 62/2017
rendering
the
chain
of
circumstantial
evidence
as
incomplete.
28.
The allegation against the accused is that he and
the deceased left the house on 21 April 2014 and the dead
body of the deceased was found on 24 April 2014. However,
there is no other positive material on record to show that the
deceased was last seen together with the accused and in the
intervening period of four days, there was nobody in contact
with the deceased, therefore, in the absence of any other link
in the chain of circumstantial evidence, it cannot be said
that only inference that could be drawn is the guilt of the
accused.
29.
Lastly, we are not oblivion of the fact that in the
case of an acquittal, the appellate Court must bear in mind
that there is a double presumption in favour of the accused
and where two views are possible, the one favouring the
accused is leaned in. In support of this proposition, a
reference advantageously can be made to the judgment
passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Chandrappa Vs.
State of Karnataka; (2007) 4 SCC 415.
CONCLUSION
30.
Considering
the
material
contradictions,
the
improvements inasmuch as the failure of the prosecution to
CRAA No. 62/2017
prove last seen and alleged recovery based on disclosure
statement of the accused, we do not find any illegality on
facts or law has been committed by the trial Court while
recording the acquittal of the accused.
31.
Accordingly, while concurring with the judgment of
the trial Court, the instant appeal is dismissed being devoid
of merit.
32.
Record be sent back to the trial Court with due
dispatch.
(Shahzad Azeem)
Judge
(Sindhu Sharma)
Judge
Jammu:
04.05.2026
Tarun/PS
Whether approved for reporting:
Whether the order is speaking
CRAA No. 62/2017
Tarun Kumar Gupta
2026.04.12 10:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
:
:
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review