Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:72
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------S.B. : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. K. AGNIHOTRI, JUDGE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
Appellants:
1.
State of Sikkim,
through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
The Secretary,
Land Revenue Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok.
3.
The Secretary,
Department of Industries,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok.
4.
The Secretary,
P.W.D. (Building),
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok.
5.
The Director,
Department of Handicrafts & Handloom,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok.
6.
The District Collector,
Office of the District Collectorate,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
versus
Respondent:
Shri Dilli Prasad Sharma,
Son of Late Karna Prasad Sharma,
Resident of Sichey Busty,
P.O. Sichey and P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
An appeal under Order XLI Rules 1 and 2 Read with
Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
--------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. J. B. Pradhan, Additional Advocate General with
Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Government Advocate and Mr.
D. K. Siwakoti, Advocate for the State-Appellants.
Mr. Ashok Pradhan,
Appellant No.5.
Legal
Retainer,
DDHH,
State
Mr. B. Sharma, Senior Advocate with Mr. Bhola Nath
Sharma, Advocates for the Respondent.
----------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
(8th June, 2016)
S. K. Agnihotri, J.
1.
The instant first Appeal emanates from the
judgment and decree dated 27.08.2013 rendered in Title
Suit No. 22 of 2010 filed by the Respondent herein.
2.
The parties are referred herein as per their
litigative status in the suit before the Court below.
3.
The brief facts as projected by the plaintiff are
that his grandfather, namely, late Shyam Lall, Sharma
being the absolute owner of plot number 40 and 41
measuring 0.54 acre and 0.32 acre respectively, situated
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
at Pioneer Reserve Block, Development Area, Gangtok,
East Sikkim, (hereinafter referred to as the “suit land”)
constructed two storied G.C.I. roofing house and resided
therein until his death, in the year 1977.
4.
The father of the plaintiff, namely, late Karna
Prasad Sharma, predeceased his father late Shyam Lall
Sharma, in the year 1970.
The grandfather of the
plaintiff had two sons, one, father of the plaintiff and,
other late Bishnu Prasad Sharma, who died childless.
The plaintiff in succession became the absolute owner of
the aforestated suit land.
The plaintiff’s sisters namely,
Purnima, Jasodha and Narmada are settled in marriage,
not claiming any share in the property.
5.
It was further stated that long time back with
the permission of his grandfather, the Public Works
Department (PWD), the defendant No.4 (4th Appellant
herein) constructed some official quarters temporarily,
with understanding that the same would be vacated as
and when required by the land owner.
There was a
further understanding between the grandfather of the
plaintiff and the officials of the PWD that some contract
work in and around Gangtok Block would be given to his
family members in lieu thereof.
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
6.
It was also agreed upon that in the event the
said temporary structure are kept for a longer period, the
plaintiff and his predecessor in title would be provided
with alternative land.
It is further case of the plaintiff
that the plaintiff has been enjoying possession the
remaining land for the purpose of fodders and grasses.
7.
It is next stated that the said two storied house
collapsed on account of non-maintenance.
The family
member left the premises after death of the plaintiff’s
grandfather and shifted to old house at Sichey, Gangtok.
However, the plaintiff erected one temporary structure in
the year 2009 with the help of old remnants of the house
which
was
dismantled
by
the
defendant
No.6
unauthorizedly and necessitated filing of the present suit,
seeking a declaration of ownership and title of the suit
land and also possession of the same with the structures
thereon.
8.
The plaintiff further sought a declaration to the
effect that the plaintiff is entitled to mutation of the suit
land in his name in the revenue records and also a decree
for
permanent
defendants/appellants
injunction
restraining
the
herein,
officials,
agents,
their
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
representatives from interfering with the possession and
ownership of the plaintiff and also the restoration of the
house (shed) illegally demolished by the defendant No.6.
9.
The 4th defendant in its written statement has
denied the ownership of the grandfather of the plaintiff
on the suit land stating therein that the possession of the
suit land was with the Directorate of Handloom and
Handicrafts
since
time
immemorial
and
the
official
quarters were constructed, thereon.
The land was
recorded
land
as
“SARKAR
land”
in
the
records
maintained by the Government of Sikkim.
10.
It was further stated that no land records are
available as all the records in the office had been gutted
in fire in the year 1991. The Government quarters were
repaired and constructed long time back in the year
1973, neither the grandfather namely late Shyam Lall
Sharma nor his legal heirs including the plaintiff had ever
objected the construction of government quarters.
The
compound wall on the said land was made in the year
1950, repaired and renovated, thereafter in the year
1973.
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
11.
The 5th defendant reiterated the same in its
written statement further stating that the Government of
Sikkim
was
in
exclusive
possession
and
physical
enjoyment of the suit land for more than 40 years.
Accordingly the land was recorded as “SARKAR land”. It
was also stated that there was no understanding between
the PWD and late Shyam Lall Sharma, for allotment of
alternative
land.
The
PWD
was
in
possession
uninterruptedly without any objection till the year 2008.
12.
The 6th defendant has also filed a written
statement taking slightly different view that the except
recording of the name of late Shyam Lall Sharma in the
records of 1950 as owner of the suit land for the past 40
years, the suit land was in physical possession of the 5th
defendant which was known as “Palden Thondup Cottage
Industries”, and as such the land was rightly recorded as
“SARKAR land”.
13.
It is further stated that late Shyam Lall Sharma
has apparently abondoned his ownership for the last 40
years and as such his legal heirs i:e, the plaintiff, is not
entitled to any right, title and ownership over the suit
land.
The survey record for 1978-80 also clearly
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
indicates that the 5th defendant was in exclusive physical
possession and enjoyment of the land.
14.
On the basis of the pleadings, the Learned
District
Judge
framed
the
following
issues
for
consideration:“(1) Whether
Late
Shyam
Lall
Sharma
(Brahmin) is the recorded owner of the suit
property as per the old land record of 1950-51
and whether the plaintiff, being his grandson is
entitled to inherit the same as per the provision
of law?
(2) Whether the suit land is recorded in the
name of SARKAR or not?
(3) Whether the defendant No.5 is in exclusive
physical possession of the suit land without
objection from anybody for more than 40 years
or not?
(4) Whether the plaintiff has trespassed into
the suit land and have tried to illegally construct
a temporary shed or not?
(5) Whether the grandfather, father and the
plaintiff have alienated the suit property to the
Government at any point of time. If so, whether
they have been compensated for the same?
(6) Whether there is any interpolation in the
record of rights of suit land or not?
(7) Whether the suit is barred by law of
limitation?
(8) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to any relief
or reliefs?”
15.
The issue No.1 was held in favour of the
plaintiff, holding as under:“……Late Shyam Lall Sharma (Brahmin) is the
recorded owner of the suit property as per the old land
record of 1950-51. It follows that the plaintiff, being
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
the grandson of Late Shyam Lall Sharma (Brahmin) is
entitled to inherit the same as per the provision of
law.”
16.
The issue in respect of recording of the name of
“SARKAR” in the land records was decided in favour of
the plaintiff holding that it was an interpolation in the
land records.
On the issue of the exclusive physical
possession of the suit land, it was held that the 5th
defendant was in exclusive possession of the suit land for
more than 40 years.
17.
On the issue of limitation, the Learned District
Judge came to a categorical conclusion that the 5th
defendant has not matured his title over the suit land by
virtue of its possession.
It was further held that the
plaintiff had not constructed the temporary shed illegally
by allegedly trespassing into the suit land.
The next
finding is that neither late Shyam Lall Sharma nor father
late Karna Prasad Sharma, have at any point of time,
alienated the suit land to the government and also no
compensation for the same was paid to them.
18.
The
alleged
understanding
to
construct
temporary quarters by the P.W.D. Department and also
to provide contract work to the family was also not held
as proved.
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
19.
The suit was accordingly decreed in favour of
the plaintiff.
20.
Assailing the impugned judgment and decree,
the Learned Additional Advocate General would contend
that
the
5th
defendant
was
in
exclusive
physical
possession of the suit land for almost 40 years which was
accordingly recorded as “SARKAR land” in the Khasra
maintained by the 6th defendant. It is further contended
that the land records, namely, Khatiyan Parcha of 195152 (Exhibit-1) and the map pertaining to the survey
operation (Exhibit-4) are insignificant as the same ceased
to become operative by virtue of the State Government
Notification No.6 dated 04.02.1984.
21.
Mr. Pradhan would next contend that the
Directorate of Handicrafts and Handlooms, being in
exclusive possession of the suit land had constructed a
compound wall without any objection from anyone
including the plaintiff. Lastly, it is contended that the
Learned
District
Judge
had
misinterpreted
and
misapplied the ratio laid down by the Supreme Court in
State of Haryana vs. Mukesh Kumar and Others1.
1.
(2011) 10 SCC 404
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
22.
On the other hand, Mr. B. Sharma, Learned
Senior Counsel appearing for the plaintiff, would contend
that the suit land was in possession of PWD with
permission of the grandfather of the plaintiff, there was
one temporary structure in the suit land and the
remaining open space was used by the
Plaintiff for
fodder and grasses.
23.
The Learned Senior Counsel would further
contend that the question of limitation would not apply in
the instant case as possession of the 5th defendant was
permissive and became hostile and adverse only when
they dismantled structure put up by the plaintiff on
13.11.2009 after Notice received on 12.11.2009.
The
instant suit was filed on 24th February, 2011.
The
Learned Senior Counsel relies on C. Natarajan vs. Ashim
Bai and Another2; Kanaya Ram and Others vs. Rajender
Kumar
and
Others3;
and
Bangalore
Development
Authority vs. N. Jayamma4.
24.
I
have
perused
the
pleadings,
documents
annexed thereto, the impugned judgment and decree
carefully and also considered the submissions advanced
by the Learned Counsel for the parties thoughtfully.
2.
3.
AIR 2008 SC 363
AIR 1985 SC 371
4.
AIR 2016 SC 1294
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
25.
A copy of the Khasra (Exhibit D/5D) indicating
the survey operation of 1970 maintained in the office of
the 6th defendant indicates that the name of the
grandfather of the plaintiff late Shyam Lall Sharma was
struck out and ‘SARKAR’ was mentioned therein without
there being any description as to how the suit land was
transferred to ‘SARKAR’ (Government).
26.
The Learned District Judge on examining the
documents had rightly come to the conclusion that it was
clear case of interpolation as the Khatiyan Parcha
(Exhibit-1) is the survey operation of 1951-52 East
Sikkim which clearly indicates the name of late Shyam
Lall Sharma in respect of the suit land as the owner.
27.
The Learned Additional Advocate General had
further produced a copy of the letter dated 3rd July, 1957
(Exhibit D/5A and D/5B) in support of his contention that
Palden Thondup Institute for Cottage Industries was in
exclusive possession of the suit land, the said letters
reveal only appointment of Superintendent of the said
Industries.
They do not reflect the location of the said
Cottage Industries and as such both the letters are of no
assistance.
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
28.
The defendants could not produce any other
document
except
Exhibit
D/5D
wherein
the
words
‘SARKAR’ is mentioned after striking out name of late
Shyam Lall Sharma. The defendants have produced the
sketch map (Exhibit D/5E) wherein the plot No.40 and
41 are indicated as vacant with one temporary structure.
The Cottage Industry is not located on the said plots,
except the entire area comprising plot nos. 36, 35, 40,
41, 39, 38 and 37, are shown as now under possession
of Directorate of Handicraft and Handloom, Government
of Sikkim.
29.
The defendants have also produced certain
communications (Annexures D/4A, D/4B, D/4C and
D/4D) which indicate that some repair work was done in
respect of quarters in May 1973, August 1976, August,
1977 and September, 1974, respectively.
30.
The repair and construction of the quarters,
thereon the suit land do not establish that the suit land
belongs to the government. The plaintiff have produced
certain certificates, namely, Certificates of Identification
(Exhibits 13 and 14) wherein the residents of the family
members of the plaintiff are shown as Pioneer Reserve,
the location of the suit land.
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
31.
I have also examined the depositions made by
the various witnesses, wherein the constant stand taken
by the witnesses of the defendant are that the 5th
defendant was in continuous possession of the suit land
and attempt was made by the plaintiff for construction of
the small kutcha structure which was demolished as the
plaintiff had no right to enter into the suit land. However,
it is not stated by any witness as to how the 5th
defendant came into possession of the suit land and also
from which date or year, the 5th defendant was in
possession.
32.
the
No evidence have come forward in respect of
stated
understanding
between
the
PWD
and
grandfather of the plaintiff to the effect that PWD was
allowed to construct temporary structure and also about
assurance of the PWD to give some contract work in and
around Gangtok town in lieu thereof.
33.
On examination of the aforestated documents
and also the deposition of the witnesses, I am of the
considered view that the findings as aforestated recorded
by the Learned District Judge to the effect that the suit
land belongs to late Shyam Lall Sharma, grandfather of
the plaintiff and the plaintiff is entitled to inherit the
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
same under provisions of law is just, proper and lawful.
The appellants have not assailed the finding of the
relationship of the plaintiff with late Shyam Lall Sharma,
being grandson and also his entitlement of being
successor in interest and title.
34.
On the question of adverse possession, the
possession of the 5th defendant as aforestated was
permissive and not hostile.
that
there
was
a
The case of the plaintiff is
temporary
structure
and
family
members of late Shyam Lall Sharma were enjoying
grasses and fodders grown in the vacant land, could not
be contradicted by the defendants. Mere possession of
the suit land does not confer any title on the 5th
defendant as the first and foremost requirement is that
the possession should be open and hostile to the legal
owner of the land.
The period of limitation prescribed in
Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963, is 12 years from
the day, possession of the defendant becomes adverse
to the plaintiff.
35.
In State of Haryana vs. Mukesh Kumar and
Ors.1 (supra) where the State Government through
Superintendent of Police filed a suit for a declaration to
the effect that it has acquired the rights of ownership by
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
way of adverse possession over the land belonging to
the
respondent
therein
on
the
ground
that
the
possession of the State Government perfected the title,
the Supreme Court, considering all aspects of matters
held as under “45. If the protectors of law become the
grabbers of the property (land and building),
then, people will be left with no protection and
there would be a total anarchy in the entire
country. It is indeed a very disturbing and
dangerous trend. In our considered view, it must
be arrested without further loss of time in the
larger
public
interest.
No
government
department, public undertaking, and much less
the Police Department should be permitted to
perfect the title of the land or building by
invoking the provisions of adverse possession
and grab the property of its own citizens in the
manner that has been done in this case.”
36.
facts
Further, contention of Mr. Pradhan is that the
in
Mukesh
Kumar
and
Ors.1
(supra)
is
distinguishable and as such ratio laid down is not
applicable to the facts involved in the instant case as
defendants herein, being the public authorities, have not
sought for declaration of title.
To bolster this, he relies
on a decision of the Supreme Court in State of Madhya
Pradesh vs. Narmada Bachao Andolan & Anr.5 wherein
5.
2011 7 SCC 639
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
it was held as under:“64. The court should not place reliance
upon a judgment without discussing how the
factual situation fits in with a fact situation of
the decision on which reliance is placed, as it
has to be ascertained by analysing all the
material facts and the issues involved in the
case and argued on both sides. A judgment
may not be followed in a given case if it has
some
distinguishing
features.
A
little
difference in facts or additional facts may
make a lot of difference to the precedential
value of a decision. A judgment of the court
is not to be read as a statute, as it is to be
remembered that judicial utterances have
been made in setting of the facts of a
particular case. One additional or different
fact may make a world of difference between
the conclusions in two cases. Disposal of
cases by blindly placing reliance upon a
decision is not proper. (Vide MCD v. Gurnam
Kaur43, Govt. of Karnataka v. Gowramma44
and State of Haryana v. Dharam Singh45.)”
37.
Mr. Pradhan has further referred to a decision
of the Supreme Court in Natural Resources Allocation, in
Re, Special Reference No.1 of 20126, contending that the
ratio laid down in a particular set of facts would be a
decision on the facts of the case decided in the case in
hand. Since the facts of Mukesh Kumar1 (supra) case
was different, the ratio laid down is not applicable to the
facts of the instant case.
38.
6.
There is no quarrel on the issue that the law
(2012) 10 SCC 1
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
declared by the Supreme Court under Article 141 of the
Constitution emanates from a Judgment upon which, the
question of law is raised and decided.
39.
Indisputably the
facts involved in Mukesh
Kumar and Ors.1 (supra) was different to that of the
instant one, however, the ratio laid down therein was
that the government, or public authorities, shall not take
recourse to the principle of adverse possession on the
basis of being in possession for a long time, depriving an
ordinary citizen of his Constitutional right to the property,
without
satisfying
the
basic
essentials
of
adverse
possession.
40.
The Supreme Court in C. Natarajan Vs. Ashim
Bai & Anr.2 after analyzing all the cases on issue has held
as under:“18 ……Limitation would not commence
unless there has been a clear and
unequivocal threat to the right claimed by the
Plaintiff. In a situation of this nature, in our
opinion, the application under Order VII, Rule
11(d) was not maintainable……”
41.
In
Hemaji
Waghaji
Jat
vs.
Bhikhabhai
Khengarbhai Harijan and Others7 the Supreme Court
7.
AIR 2009 SC 103
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
referring to the earlier decision of Karnataka Board of
Wakf vs. Government of India and Others reiterated
the prerequisites for claiming
adverse possession as
under:“18. …..The court further observed that plea
of adverse possession is not a pure question
of law but a blended one of fact and law.
Therefore, a person who claims adverse
possession should show: (a) on what date he
came into possession, (b) what was the
nature of his possession, (c) whether the
factum of possession was known to the other
party, (d) how long his possession has
continued, and (e) his possession was open
and undisturbed. A person pleading adverse
possession has no equities in his favour.
Since he is trying to defeat the rights of the
true owner, it is for him to clearly plead and
establish all facts necessary to establish his
adverse possession.”
42.
In JA Pye (Oxford) Ltd and another v Graham
and another9. Lord Browne-Wilkinson, LJ., formulated the
principle of adverse possession as under:“[40] … To be pedantic, the problem could be
avoided by saying there are two elements
necessary for legal possession: (1) a sufficient
degree of physical custody and control (‘factual
possession’); (2) an intention to exercise such
custody and control on one’s own behalf and for
one’s own benefit (‘intention to possess’). What is
crucial is to understand that, without the requisite
intention, in law there can be no possession. …..”
In the case on hand the defendants expressed
their intention to possess the suit land first time on
13.11.2009 when the structure put up by the plaintiff
8.
(2004) 10 SCC 779
9.
[2002] 3 All England Law Reports 865
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
was demolished recently, not 12 years prior to the date
of the filing of the instant suit.
43.
Applying the well settled Principle of law in
respect of claim of adverse possession to the case on
hand, the defendant have not perfected their title in the
suit law on the basis of the continuous possession as the
defendant have not produced any evidence or documents
except a copy of the Khasra (Exhibit D/5D) survey
operation of 1970 wherein the word “SARKAR” was found
as interpolation, without stating the complete description
of transfer/alienation of the suit land in favour of the 5th
defendant. Consequently the alleged possession of the 5th
defendant is permissive entitling the plaintiff to obtain
declaration and possession thereof. The Learned District
Judge has rightly decreed the suit in favour of the
plaintiff.
44.
I do not find any infirmity, impropriety and
illegality in the judgment and decree rendered by the
Learned District Judge which is sought to be impugned in
the instant appeal.
2016:SHC:72
R.F.A. No. 12 of 2014
State of Sikkim & Ors. Vs. Dilli Prasad Sharma
45.
Resultantly the Appeal is dismissed. No order
as to costs.
( S.K. Agnihotri )
Judge
08-06-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
to
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review