Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:SHC:68
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
Dated : 19th June, 2025
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------DIVISION BENCH : THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWANATH SOMADDER, CHIEF JUSTICE
THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WA No.01 of 2025
:
Appellants
State of Sikkim and Others
versus
Respondent
:
Mani Kumar Subba
Letter Patent Appeal under Chapter V Rule 148 of the High
Court of Sikkim (Practice and Procedure) Rules, 2011
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance
Mr. Zangpo Sherpa, Additional Advocate General with Mr. Mohan
Sharma, Advocate for the Appellants.
Mr. Yam Kumar Subba and Mr. Mukkum Hang Limboo, Advocates for
the Respondent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
Whether the office order bearing no.1615/G/DOP, dated
25-09-2018, of the Govt. of Sikkim, Deptt. of Personnel, ADM.
Reforms, Training and Public Grievances, Gangtok (hereinafter,
“DOPART”), terminating the government service of the respondent
could have been modified to one of compulsory retirement by the
same department, vide office order bearing no.6001/G/DOP, dated
27-02-2019, sans consultation by the Governor with the Sikkim
Public Service Commission (hereinafter, “SPSC”).
(i)
appellants,
On the heels of the above circumstance, whether the
vide
the
order
dated
14-02-2023,
bearing
no.820/G/DOP, could have withdrawn the aforementioned office
order, bearing no.6001/G/DOP, dated 27-02-2019, citing noncompliance of Rule 11 of the Sikkim Government Servants’
(Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1985 (hereinafter, “D&A Rules”) and
restored the penalty of termination, imposed by the prior office
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
order bearing no.1615/G/DOP, dated 25-09-2018, are the two
questions that fall for determination in this intra-Court appeal.
2.
Before delving into the merits of the matter, it is
essential to put forth a brief summation of the facts that led to the
discord between the parties herein.
(i)
In 1994, the respondent was appointed as Assistant
Engineer
in
the
State
Government
and
in
promoted as Divisional Engineer.
(ii)
On 09-07-2012, the Sikkim Vigilance Police Station
registered
an
FIR,
under
Prevention
of
Corruption
the
Act,
provisions
1988,
of
the
against
the
respondent, alleging that he was in possession of
disproportionate assets.
(iii)
A few days later, vide letter dated 18-07-2012,
addressed to the P.C.E.-cum-Secretary, Buildings and
Housing Department, the respondent resigned from
government
service.
suspension,
from
He
was
19-07-2012,
instead
vide
placed
office
on
order
no.967/G/DOP, and his resignation rejected, vide letter
bearing no.9194/G/DOP, dated 13-08-2012, of the
DOPART, on grounds of the pending vigilance case
against him.
(iv)
The respondent sought to withdraw his resignation
letter
dated
18-07-2012
and
also
requested
for
revocation of his suspension, by a letter dated 29-092014, addressed to the Chief Minister of Sikkim. The
suspension order, dated 19-07-2012, was revoked by
office order of the DOPART, bearing no.2588/G/DOP,
dated 04-11-2014.
(v)
Subsequent
thereto,
on
04-11-2016,
the
Sikkim
Vigilance Police sought initiation of departmental action
against the respondent along with other engineers, on
grounds of misconduct and failure to maintain absolute
integrity.
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
(vi)
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
This was followed by issuance of a Memorandum
bearing no.5202/G/DOP, by the DOPART, dated 30-032017, to the respondent for causing disappearance of
GI pipes and passing false bills. The respondent was to
submit his written statement within ten days of receipt
of the charge.
Instead, he applied for voluntary
retirement, vide letter dated 28-07-2017, which was
rejected on 14-10-2017.
(vii)
In addition to the above circumstances, the respondent
also remained incommunicado and was found to be
absent unauthorizedly from work.
On this count, the
DOPART issued Memorandum no.10672/G/DOP, dated
27-06-2017, under Rule 5 of the D&A Rules requiring
him to submit his defence within ten days.
(viii)
The respondent filed two separate responses, both
dated
23-07-2018,
to
the
Memoranda
(supra).
Annexure R-8, denying charges of misappropriation and
Annexure
R-9,
accepting
charges
of
unauthorised
office
order
absence from work.
(ix)
The
DOPART
issued
bearing
no.1615/G/DOP, dated 25-09-2018 and dismissed the
respondent from service.
Admittedly, the dismissal
order was in connection with charges of unauthorised
absence from duty. For the disproportionate assets
charge, the vigilance case is still pending and chargesheet is under preparation.
(x)
The respondent filed an application to the Chief
Minister of Sikkim, dated 25-02-2019, seeking a review
of the office order dated 25-09-2018.
(xi)
In response thereto, the said order of dismissal was
modified to that of compulsory retirement by office
order dated 27-02-2019.
(xii)
On 14-02-2023, this order was set aside and the order
of termination restored.
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
3.(a)
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
The learned single Judge inter alia discussed the
provisions of Rules 10 and 11 of the D&A Rules and observed that,
the Governor, while revisiting the order of dismissal from service
dated 25-09-2018, invoked Rule
10, exercising
the
powers
conferred on him, considered the quantum of punishment imposed
on the respondent and found it to be harsh. Pursuant thereto, the
penalty was reduced to one of compulsory retirement, allowing him
retirement pension, in accordance with the Sikkim (Pension) Rules,
1990. The learned single Judge was of the view that Rule 10 of the
D&A Rules permits the Governor, on his own motion, to call for the
records of the inquiry or revise any order made after consultation
with the SPSC, where such consultation is necessary or whenever
he deems it necessary. In such view of the matter, the office order
dated 27-02-2019, passed in favour of the respondent cannot be
assailed on the sole ground that the commission was not
consulted. It was noticed that even after the passing of the office
order dated 27-02-2019, the appellants took no steps to challenge
or undo it, till the writ petition was filed on 17-11-2022 by the
respondent.
(b)
While considering the provisions of Rule 11 of the D&A
Rules, the Court concluded that no new material or evidence was
placed by the respondent which had the effect of changing the
nature of the case.
That, the failure to consult the SPSC alone
would not change the nature of the case.
More importantly, the
proviso to Rule 11 prohibits any order imposing or enhancing any
penalty by the Governor and mandates the requirement of fair play
and natural justice, by extending a reasonable opportunity of
making a representation against the penalty imposed. Admittedly,
no such opportunity was granted before the impugned order, dated
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
14-02-2023, was passed, withdrawing the office order dated 2702-2019.
It was concluded that the impugned order, dated 14-02-
2023, was passed in the teeth of Rule 11 of the D&A Rules and is
liable to be set aside. The writ petition was allowed, setting aside
the order dated 14-02-2023 and reviving the office order dated 2702-2019.
4.
The stance of the appellants before this Court is that
while modifying the penalty of dismissal from service (25-092018), to compulsory retirement (27-02-2019), the Governor failed
to comply with the mandate of Rule 10 of the D&A Rules, which
requires the Governor to consult with the SPSC at the time of
reviewing major penalty, which aspect the learned single Judge
failed to appreciate. Strength was drawn from the observation of a
three-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court in Indian Administrative
Service (S.C.S.) Association, U.P. and Others vs. Union of India and
Others , which propounded that consultation is mandatory and non-
consultation renders the action ultra vires or invalid or void.
(i)
The next ground canvassed is that before modification
of the order of dismissal by the order of compulsory retirement,
the respondent was not afforded an opportunity of being heard in
terms of Rule 10 of the D&A Rules. On noticing such irregularity,
the appellants initiated the proposal for reviewing the offending
office order, dated 27-02-2019 in terms of Rule 11 of the D&A
Rules.
In the interregnum on 17-11-2022 the respondent filed
WP(C) No.52 of 2022 (Mani Kumar Subba vs. State of Sikkim and
Others) seeking the relief of his retirement benefits.
During the
pendency of the writ petition, the order dated 14-02-2023 was
issued, restoring the penalty of dismissal from service imposed on
1993 Supp (1) SCC 730
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
25-09-2018. The learned single Judge, by setting aside the order
of dismissal, revived the office order dated 27-02-2019, which is in
itself illegal, having been issued without consultation with the
SPSC, apart from which, the respondent had admitted all Articles
of Charges against him.
Reliance was placed on the decisions of
the Division Bench of the Supreme Court in Basawaraj and Another
vs. Special Land Acquisition Officer
and S.D.S. Shipping (P) Ltd. vs. Jay
Container Services Co. (P) Ltd. and Others .
(ii)
It was next argued that no interference in office order
no.1615/G/DOP, dated 25-09-2018, is warranted in this intra-Court
appeal as that order was not assailed by the respondent at any
point in time. That in light of the grounds advanced, the judgment
of the learned single Judge deserves to be set aside.
5.
Learned
counsel
for
the
respondent
per
contra
contended that dismissal of the respondent from service is
disproportionate to the misconduct of absence from duty, which
argument was buttressed with the decision of a Division Bench of
the Supreme Court in State of Punjab and Others vs. Dharam Singh4,
wherein the Court directed the competent authority to issue an
order of compulsory retirement, instead of removal from service,
despite the finding of wilful absence on the part of the delinquent
officer.
That, disproportionate penalty is violative of Article 14 of
the Constitution of India as held in a Division Bench of the
Supreme Court in Ranjit Thakur vs. Union of India and Others5. That,
the Governor reduced the punishment of dismissal to compulsory
retirement, by exercising his quasi-judicial powers under Rule 10 of
the D&A Rules, wherein the requirement of consultation is merely
(2013) 14 SCC 81
(2003) 9 SCC 439
(1997) 2 SCC 550
(1987) 4 SCC 611
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
directory. A five-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court in State of U.P.
vs. Manbodhan Lal Srivastava
observed that the requirement of
consultation under Article 320(3)(c) of the Constitution of India is
not mandatory and the absence of such consultation does not
vitiate penalty proceedings.
It was further argued that failure to
consult the commission does not constitute a valid ground to
challenge a disciplinary action in a Court of law and the State
cannot take advantage of its own procedural lapse.
The order
dated 14-02-2023, is not sustainable in law, having been reviewed
under Rule 11 of the D&A Rules, which permits review only on the
discovery of new materials or evidence, which was not so.
The
principles of natural justice were also flouted as the respondent
was denied an opportunity of filing a representation before
issuance of the order, dated 14-02-2023.
Attention was drawn to
Regulation 7(2)(viii) of the Sikkim Public Service Commission
(Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1986 (hereinafter,
“SPSC Regulations”), which provides that consultation with the
commission is exempted at any subsequent stage where the
commission has already given advice and no fresh question has
arisen for determination, apart from which it was urged that Rule
58 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business of the Sikkim
Public Service Commission (hereinafter, “SPSC Rules”), provides for
consultation before imposition of sentence and not for modification
or reduction of penalty. On the grounds advanced, the writ appeal
deserves a dismissal.
6.
We have meticulously examined the pleadings, the
documents on record and perused the impugned judgment.
AIR 1957 SC 912
We
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
have also carefully considered the rival contentions advanced by
learned counsel.
7.
As can be culled out from the arguments advanced
before us, the respondent was issued Memorandum bearing
no.10672/G/DOP, dated 27-06-2017. The Articles of Charge,
framed against the respondent was that he had remained absent
from duty with effect from 11-04-2016 without prior sanction for
leave. Vide, the Memorandum bearing no.5202/G/DOP, dated 3003-2017, the DOPART framed charges against the respondent for
causing disappearance of GI pipes and passing false bills.
(i)
Vide two separate responses, both dated 23-07-2018,
to each of the Articles of Charge, the respondent denied the
allegations in the Memorandum dated 30-03-2017, while the
Articles
of
Charge
in
Memorandum
dated
27-06-2017
for
unauthorised absence from work were admitted.
Thus, the
argument
that
of
learned
Additional
Advocate
General
the
respondent had admitted “all charges” against him, which led to
the order of dismissal, is not correct.
(ii)
The appellants had also argued that the order of
dismissal dated 25-09-2018, warrants no interference by this Court
as no grievance was raised in the pleadings. We are indeed aware
of the legal position.
It has been held in a litany of judgments
that, punishment of removal from service imposed upon the
respondent may be harsh but it is a matter which the disciplinary
authority or the appellate authority should consider and not the
High Court or the Administrative Tribunal [See State Bank of India
and Others vs. Samarendra Kishore Endow and Another ].
Judge Bench
(1994) 2 SCC 537
In a five-
in State of Orissa and Others vs. Bidyabhushan
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
Mohapatra ,
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
the Supreme Court held that having regard to the
gravity of the established misconduct, the punishing authority had
the power and jurisdiction to impose punishment. The penalty was
not open to review by the High Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution. However, it may also been seen that in Ranjit Thakur
(supra), after finding the appellant guilty on Court martial, he was
dismissed from service and the sentence of imprisonment was
imposed as permitted by the Army Act, 1950. While quashing the
said
punishment
on
the
grounds
that
it
was
strikingly
disproportionate, the Supreme Court observed inter alia that the
sentence has to suit the offence and the offender. It should not be
vindictive or unduly harsh. It should not be so disproportionate to
the offence as to shock the conscience and amount in itself to
conclusive evidence of bias. Thus, it concludes that irrationality and
perversity are recognised grounds which warrant judicial review.
8.
Rules 10 and 11 of the D&A Rules were elaborately
discussed by the learned single Judge in the impugned Judgment.
The
same
Rules
are
extracted
hereinbelow
for
clear
comprehension;
“10. Revision.-
(1)
Notwithstanding anything contained in
these rules, the Governor may at any time, either on
his own motion or otherwise, call for the records of
any inquiry or revise any order made under these
rules or under the rules repealed by rule 12 from
which an appeal is allowed but from which no appeal
has been preferred or from which no appeal is
allowed, after consultation with the Commission
where such consultation is necessary and may-
(a)
confirm, modify or set aside the
order, or
(b)
confirm, reduce, enhance or set
aside the penalty imposed by the
order, or impose any penalty
(c)
AIR 1963 SC 779
where no penalty has been
imposed, or
remit the case to the authority
which made the order or to any
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
(d)
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
other authority directing such
authority to make such further
inquiry as it may consider proper
in the circumstances of the case,
or
pass such other orders as it may
deem fit.
Provided that no order of imposing or
enhancing any penalty shall be made by any Revision
Authority unless the Government servant concerned
has been given a reasonable opportunity of making a
representation against the penalty proposed and
where it is proposed to impose any of the penalties
specified in the clauses (v) to (ix) of rule 3 or to
enhance the penalty imposed by the order sought to
be reviewed to any of the penalties specified in these
clauses, no such penalty shall be imposed except
after an inquiry in the manner laid down in rule 5 and
after
giving
reasonable
opportunity
to
the
Government servant concerned of showing causes
against the penalty proposed on the evidence
adduced during the inquiry and except after
consultation with the Commission where such
consultation is necessary.
11.
Review.- The Governor may, at any time,
either on his own motion or otherwise, review any
order passed under these rules, when any new
material or evidence which could not be produced or
was not available at the time of passing the order
under review and which has the effect of changing
the nature of the case, has come, or has been
brought to his notice.
Provided that no order imposing or enhancing
any penalty shall be made by the Governor unless
the Government servant concerned has been given a
reasonable opportunity of making a representation
against the penalty proposed or where it is proposed
to impose any of the major penalties specified in rule
3 or to enhance the minor penalty imposed by the
order sought to be reviewed to any of the major
penalties and if an inquiry under rule 5 has not
already been held in the case, no such penalty shall
be imposed except after inquiring in the manner laid
down in rule 5, subject to the provision of rule 7, and
except after consultation with the Commission where
such consultation is necessary.”
[emphasis supplied]
9.
The office order bearing no.6001/G/DOP, dated 27-02-
2019, reveals that the Governor had invoked the powers conferred
on him under Rule 10 of the D&A Rules. The Governor, vide the
office order of 27-02-2019, while considering the quantum of
punishment imposed on the respondent was of the view that the
penalty was harsh and had decided to modify the order by reducing
the penalty to compulsory retirement.
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
10.
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
On a bare reading of Rule 10 of the D&A Rules, (a) we
find that the Governor is conferred with the discretion of taking
steps on his own motion to call for the records of any inquiry or
refuse any order made under the D&A Rules and (b) the Governor
is also conferred with the power of consulting the SPSC when he is
of the view that “such consultation is necessary”. The Rule thus
permits the Governor to exercise his discretion as regards
consultation. (c) The Rule further empowers the Governor to
confirm, modify, reduce, enhance or set aside any penalty. (d) The
caveat is revealed in the proviso to the Rule, wherein, for
imposition and enhancement of penalty, the offending officer is to
be afforded reasonable opportunity to make a representation
against the proposed penalty.
No enhancement ensued with the
order of modification, dated 27-02-2019, nor was there any
imposition of fresh penalty. The penalty of dismissal imposed vide
office order dated 25-09-2018 was in fact downgraded to that of
compulsory retirement.
Consequently, when the Governor did not
consider it necessary to consult the SPSC by exercising his
discretion then the issue ought to be given a quietus.
Relevant
reference can also be made to Regulation 7(2)(viii) of the SPSC
Regulations which reads as follows;
“7.
Disciplinary cases.-
(1)
…………………………………………
(2)
…………………………………………
(viii) in which the Commission has, at any
previous stage, given advice in regard to the order to
be passed and no fresh question has thereafter arisen
for determination.
……………………………………………………”
The advice of the SPSC was already obtained when the order of
dismissal dated 25-09-2018 was issued and therefore as no fresh
question arose for determination, there was indeed no necessity for
fresh consultation.
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
(i)
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
Rule 58 of the SPSC Rules provides that the SPSC shall
be consulted in all cases of disciplinary matters, pertaining to civil
posts, except where it is exempted under the Rules. It is not the
case of the appellants that the SPSC was not consulted at all.
Hence, this argument need detain us no further.
(ii)
When the appellants seek to foist the entire alleged
shortcoming on the Governor, the provisions of Article 166 of the
Constitution cannot be ignored, which provides that all executive
action of the Government of a State, shall be expressed to be
taken in the name of the Governor. In such a circumstance, it is
evident that the appellants were themselves responsible for the
modification made, with the shortcomings they seek to enumerate.
11.
The argument that the respondent ought to be given
an opportunity to make a representation, before modification of the
order of dismissal dated 25-09-2018 to one of compulsory
retirement dated 27-02-2019, to meet the ends of justice, is also a
misplaced argument as the proviso to Rule 10 explains that such
opportunity is for cases where the Governor proposes to “impose
or enhance penalty”. By modifying the office order dated 25-092018, there was no proposal for “imposing” or “enhancing” the
penalty. The penalty of dismissal already imposed was reduced in
its severity. Nonetheless, it is not even the respondent’s case that
he was denied an opportunity of filing a representation before
office order dated 25-09-2018 was modified. We need not dwell on
this any further.
(i)
Rule 11 (supra) provides for review, empowering the
Governor either of his own motion or otherwise to review any order
passed under the D&A Rules, when new material or evidence,
which could not be produced or was not available at the time of the
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
concerned order and which has the effect of changing the nature of
the case is brought to his notice.
(ii)
In our considered view, Rule 11 of the D&A Rules is not
even applicable, since no such circumstances envisaged in Rule 11
viz., new materials or evidence not available prior in time was
discovered and produced and changed the nature of the case, has
been flagged before us. In fact, it is the order dated 14-02-2023
which while setting aside the office order of 27-02-2019, bypassed
the provisions of the Rules. By reviving the order of 25-09-2018,
in effect, the penalty was enhanced from that of compulsory
retirement to dismissal from service and the respondent ought to
have been given an opportunity of being heard.
(iii)
Consequently, we find no error in the conclusion of the
learned single Judge that when an order of compulsory retirement
with compulsory retirement benefits was passed in favour of the
respondent on 27-02-2019, the impugned order dated 14-02-2023,
imposing the penalty of dismissal of service, without hearing the
respondent cannot be sustained.
12.
We also deem it appropriate to point out that the law
relating to the exercise of intra-Court jurisdiction is crystallised by
a Division Bench of the Supreme Court in Management of Narendra &
Company Private Limited vs. Workmen of Narendra & Company
wherein it was held that;
“5. ............................ Be that as it may, in an
intra-court appeal, on a finding of fact, unless the
Appellate Bench reaches a conclusion that the finding
of the Single Bench is perverse, it shall not disturb
the same. Merely because another view or a better
view is possible, there should be no interference with
or disturbance of the order [Narendra & Co. (P) Ltd. v.
Workmen, WP No. 41489 of 2002, decided on 14-3-2008 (KAR)]
passed by the Single Judge, unless both sides agree
for a fairer approach on relief.”
(2016) 3 SCC 340
2025:SHC:68
WA No.01 of 2025
State of Sikkim and Others
vs. Mani Kumar Subba
In Airports Authority of India vs. Pradip Kumar Banerjee10,
(i)
the Division Bench of the Supreme Court observed as follows;
“41. The position is, thus, settled that in an
intra-court writ appeal, the appellate court must
restrain itself and the interference into the judgment
passed by the learned Single Judge is permissible
only if the judgment of the learned Single Judge is
perverse or suffers from an error apparent in law.
However, the Division Bench, in the present case,
failed to record any such finding and rather,
proceeded to delve into extensive reappreciation of
evidence to overturn the judgment of the learned
Single Judge.”
13.
In the wake of the foregoing discussions, the above
settled questions for determination are answered accordingly. We
are, therefore, of the considered view that the impugned judgment
of the learned single Judge warrants no interference.
14.
The writ appeal, therefore, stands dismissed and
pending applications, if any, stand disposed of accordingly.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds/sdl
(2025) 4 SCC 111
( Biswanath Somadder )
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review