Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
TELEN
KOM
Digitally signed
by JOHN TELEN
KOM
Date: 2023.04.21
10:41:32 +05'30'
Item No.103
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.625 of 2020
The State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner(Power),
Government of Manipur, Secretariat Old Block, Babupara, PO & PS
Imphal, District, Imaphal West, Manipur-795001.
…Petitioner
- Versus -
1. Shri Khumanthem Dhanachandra Singh, Naoremthong, Laishram
Leirak, District Imphal West, Manipur-795001
… Principal Respondents
2. The Manipur Information Commission, Secretariat North Block, Ground
Floor, Behind Western Block, PO & PS Imphal, District Imphal West,
Manipur- 795001.
…Proforma Respondent
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V.MURALIDARAN
ORDER
29.03.2023
1.
Challenging the impugned order dated 28.10.2020 passed by the
Manipur Information Commission in Appeal Case No.48 of 2020 whereby
directing the State Public Information Officer/Power Department to furnish
xerox copy of OBC certificates submitted by the selected candidates to
the first respondent within a week and the notice dated 12.11.2020 issued
by the Deputy Registrar (Judl-II) of the Manipur Information Commission,
the Commissioner (Power), Government of Manipur, has filed this writ
petition.
2. Heard Mrs.CH. Sundari, learned Government Advocate
appearing for the petitioner and Ms. Silvia, learned counsel appeared on
behalf of Mr.K.Roshan, learned counsel for the second respondent.
3. Despite the name being printed in the cause list, none appeared
on behalf of the first respondent. The first respondent was called absent
and set ex parte.
4. Assailing the impugned order of the second respondent and the
notice, the learned Government Advocate for the petitioner submitted that
the second respondent/Manipur Information Commission exceeded its
jurisdiction and authority in the order dated 28.10.2020 by directing the
SPIO (Power), Government of Manipur, to disclose the information not
related to the first respondent and the aforesaid direction issued by the
second respondent in Appeal No.48 of 2020 is in clear violation and
blatant abuse of the provisions of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (for
short, “RTI Act”. In fact, the information sought by the first respondent is
barred under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act and the first respondent has
also not disclosed any issue of larger public interest in his RTI application
dated 29.5.2020. Therefore, the order dated 28.10.2020 passed by the
second respondent in Appeal No.48 of 2020 and the subsequent notice
dated 12.11.2020 are liable to be quashed.
5. Supporting the impugned order and issuance of the
consequential notice, the learned counsel for the second respondent
argued that the OBC certificates sought by the first respondent are not
personal documents once it is submitted while applying for a Government
job. Therefore, the second respondent was right in directing the SPIO
(Power) to furnish the xerox copy of the OBC certificates submitted by the
selected candidates. Thus, a prayer has been made to dismiss the writ
petition.
6. This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused
the materials available on record.
7. The first respondent submitted an RTI application dated
29.5.2020 to the SPIO, Manipur Public Service Commission (MPSC),
seeking the following information/documents:
(1)
Certified copy of OBC (Meetei/Meitei) certificate
submitted by the final selected OBC (Meetei/Meitei)
candidates’ of Assistant Engineer (Electrical), Power
Department.
(2)
On what basis the number of post of the Assistant
Engineer increased and to prove all relevant
documents in connection with the increases of the
post.
8. Upon receipt of the RTI application, the MPSC transferred the
same to the Department of Personnel, Government of Manipur, which in
turn transferred to the SPIO, Power Department, Government of Manipur.
Since the required information was not furnished within 30 days from the
date of receipt of RTI application, the first respondent has preferred First
Appeal under Section 19 of the RTI Act before the Secretary (Power).
Since the appellate authority has failed to furnish his decision within a
period of 30 days, the first respondent filed Appeal Case No.48 of 2020
before the second respondent.
9. In the appeal, the SPIO (Power) filed written statement stating
that with respect to Query No.1, the information sought by the first
respondent was exempted under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act and the
said information relates to personal information which has not relationship
to any public activity or interest and also the third party information. With
respect to Query No.2, it has been stated that it is not open to an appellant
to ask in the guise of seeking information and the RTI Act does not cast
on the public authority any obligation to answer the queries. However, by
the impugned order, the second respondent observed as under:
“Reacting to her statement on query No.1, the appellant argued
that the OBC certificate is a public document and it is a temporary
document based on his/her annual income. He also stated his
demand for the said documents is raised on public interest. He
however admitted that in case of query No.2, there is some
incompleteness in the sought information.
Upon hearing from both the parties, the Commission is of the view
that OBC certificate is not a personal document as argued by the
public authority, once it is submitted while applying for a
government job/DPC proceedings. In case of query no.2, it felt
that the said query is incomete and not clear.”
10. While observing so, the second respondent has finally directed
as under:
“Accordingly,
the
Commission
directs
the
SPIO/Power
department to furnish xerox copy of the OBC certificates
submitted by the selected candidates, which is in query No.1 to
the appellant within a week from today.
The Commission further grants a liberty to the appellant to file a
misc. application if the said document is not furnished by the
public authority. Hence, the appeal is closed.”
11. The aforesaid observation and findings recorded by the second
respondent is absolutely incorrect as the personal information or details
submitted by an employee to an employer for the purposes of his
employment are expected to be kept confidential. Such details cannot be
available to all and sundry. However, if the competent authority is satisfied
that a larger public interest warrants the disclosure of such information,
the same can be disclosed.
In the case on hand, admittedly, the first
respondent is a stranger to the Department and have not connected with
the OBC certificates submitted by the selected OBC candidates of
Assistant Engineer (Electrical), Power Department, Government of
Manipur.
12. It is settled law that there is no public interest in furnishing OBC
certificates which relate to third parties. That apart, the information sought
by the first respondent relates to third party information which is barred
from disclosure under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, which reads thus:
“(j) information which relates to personal information the
disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity
or interest, or which would cause unwarranted invasion of
the privacy of the individual unless the Central Public
Information Officer or the State Public Information Officer or
the appellate authority, as the case may be, is satisfied that
the larger public interest justifies the disclosure of such
information. ….”
13. The import of personal information envisaged under Section
8(1)(j) of the RTI Act has been exemplified in the context of the ratios of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
14. In O.K. Ghosh v. E.X. Joseph, AIR 1963 SC 812, it has been
held that Section 8(1)(j) of the Act of 2005 ensures that all information
pertaining to public authorities, including personal information are not
given blanket access to the public at large. Before any such information
is sought the information seeker has to disclose a reason for ‘sustainable
public interest’ that would permit its disclosure.
15. Time and again, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the
personal records, including name, address, caste, physical, mental and
psychological status, marks obtained, grades and answer sheets, are all
treated as personal information. Similarly, professional records, including
qualification,
performance,
evaluation
reports,
ACRs,
disciplinary
proceedings, etc. are all personal information. Medical records, treatment,
choice of medicine, list of hospitals and doctors visited, findings recorded,
including that of the family members, information relating to assets,
liabilities, income tax returns, details of investments, lending and
borrowing, etc. are personal information. Such personal information is
entitled to protection from unwarranted invasion of privacy and conditional
access is available when stipulation of larger public interest is satisfied.
16. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Bihar Public
Service Commission v. Saiyed Hussain Abbas Rizwi, (2012) 13 SCC
61, while explaining the term "public interest" held:
"22. The expression "public interest" has to be understood
in its true connotation so as to give complete meaning to
the relevant provisions of the Act. The expression "public
interest" must be viewed in its strict sense with all its
exceptions so as to justify denial of a statutory exemption
in terms of the Act. In its common parlance, the expression
"public interest", like "public purpose", is not capable of any
precise definition. It does not have a rigid meaning, is
elastic and takes its colour from the statute in which it
occurs, the concept varying with time and state of society
and its needs (State of Bihar v. Kameshwar, AIR 1952 SC
252). It also means the general welfare of the public that
warrants recognition and protection; something in which the
public as a whole has a stake [Black's Law Dictionary (8th
Edn.)]."
17. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Girish Ramchandra
Deshpande v. Central Information Commissioner and Others, (2013)
1 SCC 212 held:
“13. We are in agreement with the CIC and the courts below
that the details called for by the Petitioner i.e. copies of all
memos issued to the third Respondent, show cause notices
and orders of censure/punishment etc. are qualified to be
personal information as defined in Clause (j) of Section 8(1)
of the RTI Act. The performance of an employee/officer in an
organization is primarily a matter between the employee and
the employer and normally those aspects are governed by
the service rules which fall under the expression "personal
information", the disclosure of which has no relationship to
any public activity or public interest. On the other hand, the
disclosure of which would cause unwarranted invasion of
privacy of that individual. of course, in a given case, if the
Central Public Information Officer or the State Public
Information Officer of the Appellate Authority is satisfied that
the larger public interest justifies the disclosure of such
information, appropriate orders could be passed but the
Petitioner cannot claim those details as a matter of right.”
18. Thus, it is clear that the certified copy of OBC (Meetei/Meitei)
certificates relate to third parties is barred from disclosure under Section
8(1)(j) of the Act of 2005. While being so, the second respondent ought
not to have directed the SPIO, Power Department, to furnish the xerox
copy of the OBC certificates submitted by the selected candidates.
19. It is apposite to mention that the information relating to caste of
a person would also fall within the definition of “personal information” and,
thus, this would also be exempted from disclosure under Section 8(1)(j) of
the RTI Act.
20. No shred of materials had been produced by the first
respondent to justify that disclosure of the information sought was
warranted in larger public interest. Merely stating that disclosure of the
information sought would be in the interest of public is plainly insufficient.
Moreover, the caste of a person is exempted from disclosure under the
RTI Act being a personal information. Therefore, second respondent has
erred in directing the SPIO, Power Department, to furnish xerox copy of
the OBC certificates submitted by the selected candidates, which are not
related to the first respondent himself. Consequently, the notice dated
12.11.2020 issued by the second respondent to the petitioner is also liable
to be quashed. It is also to be noted that knowing fully well the legal
position as well as no case in his favour, the first respondent has failed to
appear before this Court. That apart, the conduct of the first respondent
in not appearing before this Court would prove that he has no case at all.
21. For all the reasons stated above, the writ petition is allowed.
The impugned order dated 28.10.202 passed by the second respondent
in Appeal Case No.48 of 2020 and the consequential notice dated
12.11.2020 issued to the petitioner are set aside. There will be no order
as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
NFR/FR
[[
John kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review