Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL Digitally signed by SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
SHARMA
Date: 2023.08.09 11:58:20 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.288 of 2023
Shri M. Isaac, aged about 61 years old, S/O (L) M.
Wungnaoshing of Sorbung Village, P.O. and PS. Phungyar,
Ukhrul District, Kamjong-795 145, Manipur.
...Petitioner
-Versus1.
The State of Manipur through the Additional Chief
Secretary/ Principal Secretary/ Commissioner (TA and
Hills), Government of Manipur, Old Sectrtariat, Babupara,
P.O.
and
P.S.
Imphal,
Imphal
West
District,
Manipur795001.
2.
The Deputy Secretary (TA & Hills), Government of
Manipur, Old Secretariat, Babupara, P.O. and P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
3.
The Ukhrul Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul through
its Chief Executive Officer, Phungreitang Ukhrul, P.O.
and P.S. Ukhrul, Ukhrul District-795 142, Manipur.
4.
Shri Mark Luithing, Member, Ukhrul Autonomous District
Council now allowing to hold the charge of Caretaker
Chairman of Ukhrul Autonomous District Council, C/O
Chief Executive Officer, Ukhrul Autonomous District
Council, Manipur.
...Respondents
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
Page |2
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
::
Mr. HS Paonam, Sr. Adv.
Mr. N. Bipin, Adv.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. M. Devananda, Addl. AG
for R- 1 to 3;
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, Sr. Adv.
for R-4.
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
07.07.2023
Date of Judgment & Order ::
08.08.2023
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner to
quash the impugned order dated 27.3.2023 passed by the second
respondent, thereby allowing the fourth respondent to function as
Caretaker Chairman under the Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul
and to direct the respondents to allow the petitioner to function as
Caretaker Chairman of the Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul as
mandated by the Manipur (Hill Areas) District Councils Act, 1971
and the Rules framed thereunder.
2.
The case of the petitioner is as follows:
The Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul, had its
general election in the year 2015 and 24 persons, including the
petitioner, were declared as elected members against the 24
constituencies within the jurisdiction of Ukhrul Autonomous District
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
Page |3
Council, Ukhrul and the same was notified on 17.6.2015. Following
the constitution of a new Council, one Dr. Yaronsho Ngalung from
Ringui Village was elected as Chairman and the petitioner was
elected as Vice Chairman of the Ukhrul Autonomous District
Council and thereafter started its function to carryout its public duty
as required and expected from such an institution. The term of the
office of the members shall be 5 years. The first election of six
Autonomous District Councils was held on 1.6.2015 and the term of
the office members expired in the month of June, 2020.
2.1.
After the expiry of the term of five years of all six
Autonomous District Councils, the Hill Areas Committee has
recommended the extension of the term of the office of all six for a
period of six months and, vide order dated 19.3.2020, the period of
six months with effect from 1.6.2020 was extended. In the said
order, it has been mentioned that the election of Autonomous
District Councils shall be held in the intervening month of October
and November, 2020. After the completion of six months term of
the office of members, the Additional Chief Secretary (TA & Hills),
Government of Manipur under its office order dated 30.11.2020 was
pleased to issue an order appointing the Deputy Commissioners to
exercise all the powers and perform duties conferred and imposed
upon the Council under the Act or any other law for the time being
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
Page |4
in force for smooth functioning of the administration of the
Autonomous District Councils.
2.2.
Aggrieved
by
the
aforesaid
decision
dated
30.11.2020, W.P.(C) No.613 of 2020 and other connected writ
petitions came to be filed and, by the order dated 2.3.2021, the said
writ petitions were disposed of with certain directions.
In
compliance of the order passed in the said writ petitions and, in
supersession of the previous Government Order dated 30.11.2020,
an order dated 17.5.2021 came to be issued whereby appointing all
the existing Chairman of the Autonomous District Councils to serve
as Caretaker Chairman for smooth functioning of the administration
till the elections are held. Following the said order so issued by the
competent authority which allowed the former Chairman of all the
Autonomous District Councils including the Ukhrul Autonomous
District Council, Ukhrul to continue in their respective capacity till
the election of Autonomous District Councils are held, functional
activities of the Councils including taking of development works has
started and keeping in view of first approaching election for the new
term since their performance will be the determining factor on their
respective constituency for re-election.
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
Page |5
2.3.
The former Chairman Dr. Yaronsho Ngalung has
tendered resignation from the office of the Caretaker Chairman,
Ukhrul Autonomous District Council by submitting his resignation
letter dated 6.6.2022 and the same was accepted on 27.6.2022.
Thereafter, the Special Secretary (TA & Hills) under order dated
4.8.2022 cancelled the order dated 17.5.2021 and also stated in the
said order that the Caretaker Chairman system under the
Autonomous District Councils has also discontinued with an
immediate effect. Aggrieved by the order dated 4.8.2022, one
Namsinrei Panmei, former Caretaker Chairman has filed W.P.(C)
No.632 of 2022 with a prayer for holding the election for constitution
of new Autonomous District Councils.
By the order dated
19.1.2023, the said writ petition was disposed of by this Court. In
compliance of the order dated 19.1.2023, the Tribal Affairs and Hills
Department was pleased to issue an order dated 14.3.2023 thereby
allowing
the
last
constituted
Caretaker
Chairman
of
the
Autonomous District Councils to function as Caretaker Chairman till
the issuance of notifications for the election of Autonomous District
Councils, Manipur.
On 27.3.2023, the Deputy Secretary (TA &
Hills), Government of Manipur issued the impugned order by which
a former member namely Mark Luithing, the fourth respondent, was
directed to function as Caretaker Chairman of the Autonomous
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
Page |6
District Council, Ukhrul till the issuance of the notification for the
election. Challenging the same, the petitioner has filed the present
writ petition.
3.
Resisting the writ petition, the second respondent filed
affidavit-in-opposition
stating
that
in
consideration
of
the
recommendation of the State Executive Committee, Relief and
Disaster Management Department and to augment the efforts in
controlling the Covid pandemic locally and the grassroot democratic
systems are functional at such critical juncture, the Government
appointed the last constituted Chairman of the Autonomous District
Councils as Caretaker Chairman as an interim measure till the
election of the Autonomous District Councils are held. It is stated
that the Manipur (Hill Areas) District Councils Act and Rules do not
provide for constitution of Caretaker Chairman in the District
Councils. As such, the Caretaker system was discontinued as per
the Cabinet decision dated 21.7.2022.
Though the Act and the
Rules do not provide for constitution of Caretaker Chairman under
the ADCs, the Government vide order dated 14.3.2023 appointed
the last constituted Chairman of ADCs as Caretaker Chairman in
compliance of the order of this Court dated 19.1.2023 passed in
W.P.(C) No.632 of 2022. Consequent upon the resignation of Dr.
Yoransho Ngalung, the office of the Caretaker Chairman, ADC
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
Page |7
Ukhrul lays vacant and as an interim measure and as stop gap
arrangement, one Mark Luithing, member of the last constituted
ADC, Ukhrul was appointed as Caretaker Chairman.
4.
The fourth respondent filed affidavit-in-opposition
stating that on the day of accepting Dr. Yaronsho Ngalung’s
resignation from the post of Caretaker Chairman on 27.6.2022, the
petitioner was no longer serving as Vice Chairman of the ADC,
Ukhrul. The post of Caretaker Chairman fell vacant with effect from
16.6.2022. The term of the ADC, Ukhrul already expired in the
month of June, 2020. For the administrative convenience and as
per the wisdom of the State Government, the fourth respondent was
allowed to function as Caretaker Chairman, ADC, Ukhrul till the
issuance of the notification for the election of ADCs, Manipur. There
is nothing wrong in the said order.
The petitioner is not an
aggrieved person to the said order as he remained silent as soon
as the office of the Caretaker Chairman of the ADC, Ukhrul became
vacant with effect from 16.6.2022.
The petitioner is no longer
holding the post of Vice Chairman of ADC, Ukhrul after the expiry
of its terms.
5.
Assailing the impugned order, Mr. HS Paonam, the
learned senior counsel for the petitioner submitted that if any
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
Page |8
vacancy arose to the office of the Chairman, as mandated by
Section 23(1) of the Manipur (Hill Areas) District Council Act, 1971
read with Rule 3 of the Manipur (Hill Areas) District Councils Rules,
1972, the council/elected members of the said Council has to
choose another member of the respective Autonomous District
Council as Chairman by holding an election by issuing appropriate
notification/order by the concerned Deputy Commissioner.
The
post of Chairman in the Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul is lying
vacant since 16.6.2022.
6.
Mr. HS Paonam, the learned senior counsel for the
petitioner further submitted that as per Rule 9, the Vice Chairman
is the only person/member who can perform the duty of the office
of the Chairman.
But appointing a member as Chairman of
Autonomous District Council by issuing the impugned order dated
27.3.2023 is in complete arbitrary exercise of power and is against
the mandate of the provisions of the Manipur (Hill Areas) District
council Act, 1971 and the Manipur (Hill Areas) District Councils
Rules, 1972.
7.
The learned senior counsel for the petitioner urged
that the only method of appointment to the post of Chairman of a
District Autonomous Council is by way of election in accordance
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
Page |9
with the provisions of the Act and the Rules. Under the law, there
is no provision conferring or vesting the State Government to
appoint any member to the post of Chairman.
Therefore, the
impugned order is ultra vires, inasmuch as the executive imposition
on the affairs of a democratic institution formed by elected members
under the Act and the Rules. Thus, a prayer has been made to set
aside the impugned order and to allow the petitioner to function as
Caretaker Chairman of the Autonomous District Council,Ukhrul.
8.
Mr. M. Devananda, the learned Addl. Advocate
General appearing for the respondents 1 to 3 submitted that
considering the recommendation of the State Executive Committee
and to augment the efforts in controlling the Covid-19 situation, the
Government appointed the last constituted Chairman of the
Autonomous District Councils as Caretaker Chairman as an interim
measure till the election of the Autonomous District Councils are
held. In compliance with the order of this Court dated 19.1.2023
passed in W.P.(C) No.632 of 2022 etc. batch, the Government vide
order dated 14.3.2023 allowed the last constituted Chairman as
Caretaker Chairman. As the Caretaker Chairman Dr. Yaronsho
Ngalung resigned from the post, the State Government allowed the
fourth respondent to function as Caretaker Chairman, ADC, Ukhrul
till the issuance of the notification for the election.
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 10
9.
By placing reliance upon the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Basic Education Board, UP v.
Upendra Raj and others, (2008) 3 SCC 432, Mr. M. Devananda, the
learned Addl. AG submitted that when the State Government had
taken a policy decision to appoint the Caretaker Chairman of the
ADC Ukhrul, the same cannot be questioned by the petitioner,
unless it violates the constitutional or statutory provision. Since the
impugned order has been passed in accordance with the provisions
of the Act and Rules, the learned Government Advocate prayed for
dismissal of the writ petition.
10.
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, the learned senior counsel for
the fourth respondent submitted that though the Caretaker
Chairman Dr. Yaronsho Ngalung resigned the post on 16.6.2022,
the petitioner has not made any claim to allow him to function as
Caretaker Chairman.
Only after one year when the State
Government allowed the fourth respondent to function as Caretaker
Chairman Ukhrul, the petitioner has filed the writ petition
challenging the same.
11.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that
since the expiry of the term of the ADC Ukhrul, the tenure of the
petitioner as Vice Chairman of the ADC Ukhrul has not been
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 11
extended by any executive order and, as such, the petitioner does
not have any right to question the legality of the impugned order
dated 27.3.2023 on the ground that the same was issued without
following Rule 9. The effect of Rule 9 will operate so long as the
members including the petitioner held their office and not after the
expiry of their terms. When the order dated 14.3.2023 was issued,
the Vice Chairman of ADC Ukhrul was not given the benefit of the
said order. Therefore, the petitioner does not have right to take the
shelter of Rule 9. That apart, the petitioner has no locus to question
the legality of the order dated 27.3.2023 and none of the
fundamental rights are affected by the impugned order. There is no
plea of the petitioner that he is no longer holding the post of Vice
Chairman after the expiry of the term. Thus, a prayer has been
made to dismiss the writ petition.
12.
This Court considered the rival submissions and also
perused the materials available on record.
13.
The grievance of the petitioner is that valuable right of
the petitioner to function and discharge the duty and responsibility
of the Chairman as mandated by Rule 9 when the post in question
became vacant of the then incumbent Chairman on 16.6.2022 has
been sought to be deprived by the impugned order under which a
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 12
member who had never been elected either as a Chairman or Vice
Chairman of the Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul has been
allowed. Hence, the impugned order being an order violating the
fundamental and other statutory right of the petitioner is liable to be
quashed.
14.
On the other hand, it is plea of the official respondents
that consequent upon the resignation of Dr. Yoransho Ngalung, the
Caretaker Chairman of the ADC, Ukhrul, the office of the Caretaker
Chairman, ADC, Ukhrul, became vacant and, as an interim
measure and as stop gap arrangement, the fourth respondent, who
is member of the last constituted ADC, Ukhrul, was appointed as
Caretaker Chairman.
15.
The petitioner contended that if the office of the
Chairman is lying vacant, the Vice Chairman has to perform the duty
of office of the Chairman of such Council as per Rule 9 of the
Manipur (Hill Areas) District Councils Rules, 1972.
For proper
appreciation, Rule 9 is extracted hereunder:
“9. Power of Vice-Chairman or other person to perform the duties
of office of or to act as Chairman:
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 13
(1)While the office of Chairman is vacant, the
duties of the officer shall be performed by the ViceChairman.
(2)During the absence of the Chairman from any
meeting of the council the Vice-Chairman or if he
is also absent, one of the Deputy Chairman, shall
act as Chairman in accordance with the provisions
of rule 5.”
16.
It is no doubt true that the only method of appointment
to the post of Chairman of the Autonomous District Council is by
way of election in accordance with the provisions of the Manipur
(Hill Areas) District Council Act, 1971 and Manipur (Hill Areas)
District Councils Rules, 1972.
17.
According to the petitioner, there is no provision
conferring or vesting the State Government to appoint any member
to the post of Chairman and, therefore, the impugned order is liable
to be set aside. In view of the aforesaid argument raised by the
petitioner, it is necessary to deal with the earlier proceedings
initiated by the parties.
18.
Upon constitution of the new Autonomous District
Council in accordance with the provisions of Section 4 of the Act,
Dr. Yaronsho Ngalung from Ringui Village was elected as Chairman
of the Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul and the petitioner herein
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 14
was elected as Vice Chairman. As per Section 13(1) of the Act, the
term of the office of the members shall be 5 years. Since the first
election of six ADCs in the State of Manipur was held on 1.6.2015,
the term of the office of the members of all the ADCs expired in the
month of June, 2020. After the expiry of the term of five years, the
Hill Areas Committee has recommended extension of term of office
of the all the members of six ADCs for a period of six months.
Accordingly, as per the provisions of Section 13(1) of the Act, the
Additional Chief Secretary (TA & Hills) issued an order dated
19.3.2020, whereby extending the term of the office of the members
for a period of six months with effect from 1.6.2020. In the said
order, it has been mentioned that election to the ADCs shall be held
in the intervening month of October and November, 2020.
Thereafter, the Additional Chief Secretary (TA & Hills) issued an
order on 30.11.2020 appointing the Deputy Commissioners to
exercise all the powers and perform the duties conferred and upon
the Council for smooth functioning of the administration of the
ADCs.
19.
Aggrieved by the issuance of the order dated
30.11.2020, a batch of writ petitions (W.P.(C) No.613 of 2020 etc.)
came to be filed before this Court. This Court, by the order dated
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 15
2.3.2021, disposed of the writ petitions with certain directions. The
operative portion of the order reads thus:
“[17] For the reasons stated hereinabove, the writ
petition being WP(C) No.613 of 2020 stands
disposed
of
with
the
observation
made
hereinabove while WP(C) No.645 of 2020 and
WP(C)
No.647
consequently,
of
the
are
impugned
allowed
and
order
dated
30.11.2020 is quashed and set aside with the
following directions.
(a)The State Government and in particular, the
Additional
Chief
Secretary
(TA
&
Hills),
Government of Manipur shall write a letter to the
Hill
Areas
Committee,
Manipur
Legislative
Assembly seeking its opinion as to whether the
term of the District Councils shall be extended or
not till the completion of the election and the said
letter shall be written within a week from the date
of receipt of a copy of this judgment and order;
(b)On receipt of such a letter from the Additional
Chief Secretary (TA & Hills), Government of
Manipur, the Hill Areas Committee, Manipur
Legislative Assembly shall furnish its opinion
within a week from the date of receipt of the letter;
(c)After the opinion of the Hill Areas Committee,
Manipur
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
Legislative
Assembly
being
duly
P a g e | 16
received, the State Government shall take a
decision
and
issue
an
appropriate
order
immediately in terms thereof.
(d)Till such an order is issued by the State
Government as mentioned in the direction (c)
above, the interim order dated 27.11.2020 passed
by this Court in WP(C) No.613 of 2020 shall
continue;
(e)The State Election Commission, Lamphelpat,
Manipur is directed to announce the date on which
the election of the District Councils shall be held
within a week from the date of receipt of a copy of
this judgment and order.
There shall be no order as to costs.”
20.
In compliance of the order of this Court, on 17.5.2021,
the Additional Chief Secretary (TA & Hills) has passed an order
appointing all the existing Chairman of the Autonomous District
Councils to serve as Caretaker Chairman for smooth functioning of
the administration of the Autonomous District Councils till the
election of the Autonomous District Councils are held. Accordingly,
the respective former Chairmen of the Autonomous District
Councils including Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul, continued
in their respective capacity and the functional activities are carried
out, including the developmental works.
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
While so, the former
P a g e | 17
Chairman of the Ukhrul Autonomous District Council has tendered
his resignation and, by the order dated 27.6.2022, the Deputy
Secretary (TA & Hills) ordered Dr. Yaransho Ngalung to demit the
office with effect from 16.6.2022. Thereafter, pursuant to the
decision of the Cabinet dated 21.7.2022, the order dated 17.5.2021,
whereby allowing the former Chairman to function as Caretaker
Chairman stands cancelled vide order dated 4.8.2022. Resultantly,
the Caretaker Chairman system under ADCs, Manipur discontinued
with immediate effect.
21.
Aggrieved by the order dated 4.8.2022, a batch of writ
petitions (W.P.(C) No.632 of 2022 etc.) came to be filed. This Court,
by the order dated 19.1.2023, disposed of the said writ petitions.
The operative portion of the order reads thus:
“[14]. Therefore, I am inclined to pass the following
orders:
a) The present writ petitions are disposed of.
b) The interim order granted by this Court on
04.11.2022 in writ petitions i.e. WP(C) No.935
of 2022 and subsequently in other writ petitions
in WP(C) No.704 of 2022, WP(C) No.880 of
2022 and today in WP(C) No.632 of 2022,
WP(C) No.633 of 2022, should continue till the
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 18
issuance of the notification for the elections of
ULBs and Autonomous District Councils.
[15]. With the above observations, these writ
petitions are disposed of.”
22.
In compliance of the order of this Court dated
19.1.2023 passed in the aforesaid batch of writ petitions, the
second respondent herein issued an order dated 14.03.2022,
whereby allowing the last constituted Caretaker Chairman of the
Autonomous District Councils concerned to function as Caretaker
Chairman till the issuance of the notifications for the election of
Autonomous District Councils, Manipur. Stating that the Chairman
of Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul resigned, the second
respondent allowed the fourth respondent to function as Caretaker
Chairman of Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul till the issuance
of the notification for election.
The said order is now under
challenge before this Court.
23.
At this juncture, it is pertinent to quote Rule 3 of the
Manipur (Hill Areas) District Councils Rules, 1972, which reads
thus:
“3. Election of Chairman by Council:
(1)The election of a Chairman shall be held on
such date as the Governor may fix and the
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 19
Secretary shall send to every member notice of
this date.
(2)Before the election of a Chairman the Governor
shall appoint a member of the Council who does
not intend to contest the election to preside at the
meeting.”
24.
On a perusal of the provision of Section 23(1) of the
Manipur (Hill Areas) District Council Act, 1971, it is seen that when
the offices of the Chairman and Vice Chairman become vacant, the
elected members of the said Council have to choose another
member of the respective Autonomous District Council as
Chairman by holding an election by issuing appropriate notification
by the concerned Deputy Commissioner.
25.
As stated supra, Rule 9 contemplates the manner if
the office of the Chairman is lying vacant, the Vice Chairman has to
perform the duty of the office of the Chairman of such Council.
However, it is the say of the learned Government Advocate that
Rule 9 will be attracted while the said Autonomous District Council
was in existence.
But in the instant case, as the term of the
Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul, has already expired in the
month of June, 2020 and after the expiry of the extension period,
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 20
the petitioner is no longer holding the post of Vice Chairman and,
therefore, he cannot seek the aid of Rule 9.
26.
The Chairman of the elected members of the
Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul, Maniour is upto 17.06.2020
and in terms of the provisions, the elected members terms have
been extended for a period of one year i.e. from 18.06.2020 to
17.06.2021 and thereafter, they are no longer elected members of
the Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul. Hence, in terms of the
State Policy and in compliance of the order passed by this Court in
various writ petitions, the State Government issued the order dated
27.03.2023 allowing the private respondent No. 4 Mr. Mark Luithing
to function as Caretaker Chairman under the Autonomous District
Council, Ukhrul till Notification of the Autonomous District for the
election of Autonomous District Councils, Manipur. Therefore, in
such order, the petitioner cannot be aggrieved of the order passed
by the State Government allowing the private respondents as
Caretaker Chairman of the Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul.
27.
On fair reading of the provisions of Section 13 of the
Manipur (Hill Areas) District Council Act, 1971 “provided that the
Administrative may, when satisfied that it is necessary in order to
avoid administrative difficulty, extend the term of office of all the
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 21
members by such period not exceeding one year as he thinks fit.”
Therefore, the State Government have taken a policy allowing the
4th Respondent to function as Caretaker Chairman of the
Autonomous District Council, Ukhrul till the Notification of the
election.
28.
`
Since the terms of the members of the Autonomous
District Council, Ukhrul is completed in the year 2020 and extended
till 2021 the petitioner is claiming his right to function as Chairman
in terms of Section 22 of the Manipur (Hill Areas) District Council
Act, 1971 and Rule 9 of the Manipur (Hill Areas) District Councils
Rules, 1972 is not applicable in this present case. It is also made
clear that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has passed in catena of the
cases that the Policy decision taken by the State Government
should not be interfered by the Court unless it violates constitutional
or statutory provisions, but in this present case, Act and Rules was
silent for appointment as caretaker in Chairman and Vice Chairman
in the Autonomous District Council after the completion of the terms
period of the members. In the case of Basic Education Board,
U.P. vs. Upendra Rai and Others reported in (2008) 3 SCC 432 in
paragraph 15, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that “Grant of
equivalence and/or revocation of equivalence is an administrative
decision which is in the sole discretion of the authority concerned
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 22
and the court has nothing to do with such matters. The matter of
equivalence is directed by experts appointed by the Government
and the court does not have expertise in such matters. Hence, it
should exercise judicial restraint and not interfere in it.”
29.
The petitioner was also members of the Autonomous
District Council, Ukhrul in terms of the Election of the Autonomous
District Council, Ukhrul but he was never been appointed as Vice
Chairman of the ADC, Ukhrul, and the letter issued by the Chief
Executive Officer (Autonomous District Council) Ukhrul dated
21.12.2017 is a mere letter communication between the CEO, ADC,
Ukhrul and Principal Secretary (TA& Hills), Govt. of Manipur and it
cannot be taken that he has been appointed as Vice Chairman,
ADC, Ukhrul during the tenure period of the ADC from 2015 to 2020.
The petitioner has not produced any documents to prove that he
was functioning as Vice Chairman of the ADC, Ukhrul. When he
failed to produce any documents to show that he functioned as Vice
Chairman of the ADC, Ukhrul, then he has no right to invoke Section
9 of the Manipur (Hill Areas) Councils Rule, 1972. Once the tenure
of the elected member of ADC has expired on 30.11.2020, this
petitioner cannot claim that he was the member, Vice Chairman of
the Autonomous District Council and he may be given the in-charge
of the Caretaker Chairman of the Council. Since the question of
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 23
appointment of Vice Chairman to the post of Chairman does not
arise there was not Vice Chairman at the time of appointment of the
Caretaker Chairman. The real effect of Rule 9 will operate as long
as terms of the members of the ADC is expired.
30.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Essar Steel
Ltd. Vs. Union of India & Ors. reported in (2016) 11 SCC 1 has
clearly held that executive policies are usually enacted after much
deliberation by the Government. Therefore, it would not be
appropriate for this Court to question the wisdom of the same,
unless it is demonstrated by the aggrieved persons that the said
policy has been enacted in an arbitrary, unreasonable or mala fide
manner, or that it offends that provisions of the Constitution of India.
In the present case, the petitioner has pointed out that rules have
been violated and the order dated 27.03.2023 appointing the 4 th
respondent as Caretaker Chairman was issued in violation of any
Act or rules. Therefore, the question of interference of the order
dated 27.03.2023 does not arise.
31.
It is the absolute view of this Court that the order dated
27.03.2023 appointing the fourth respondent as Caretaker
Chairman of the Council was issued by the Government of Manipur
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
P a g e | 24
by exercising its power for administrative convenience which is not
required to interfere by this Court.
32.
Therefore, the petitioner have not made out any case
before this Court for interference of the impugned order dated
27.03.2023 and the writ petition challenging the order dated
27.03.2023 is not at all maintainable and devoid of merit and hence,
it is liable to be dismissed.
33.
Therefore, I am inclined to pass the following orders.
34.
In the result,
i)
The writ petition is dismissed.
ii)
MC(WP(C)) No. 125 of 2023 is closed.
iii)
MC(WP(C)) No. 151 of 2023 is allowed.
iv)
MC(WP(C)) No. 152 of 2023 is dismissed.
v)
The interim order granted by this Court dated
03.04.2023 is vacated.
vi)
There is no order as to cost.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 288 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review