Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.04.04
TELEN KOM Date:
16:51:49 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.658 of 2021
1. The Holy Spirit Catholic Church, Tribal Colony, New Chekon, PO & PS
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur-795005, represented by its
Chairman, Dominic Paojangam Haokip, son of (late) Solomon
Chungkholet Haokip, aged about 55 years, resident of Mahabali Kabui
Khul, PO Imphal & PS Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
2. Sumpi Peter Anal, aged about 40 years, son of Sumpi Moris Anal,
resident of New Lambulane 1st street, porompat Sub-Division, PO & PS
Porompat, Imphal Eas District, Manipur- 795005, Joint Secretary Holy
Spirit Catholic Church, Tribal Colony New Checkon.
…Petitioners
– Versus –
1. The State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner(Revenue),
Government of Manipur.
2. The Principal Secretary(works), Government of Manipur.
3. The Deputy Commissioner, Imphal East, PO & PS Porompat, Imphal
East District, Manipur-795005.
4. The Sub-Divisional Officer, Porompat, PO & PS Porompat, Imphal
East District, Manipur-795005.
…. respondents.
With
MC(WP(C))No.90 of 2023
1. The State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner(Revenue),
Government of Manipur.
2. The Principal Secretary(works), Government of Manipur.
3. The Deputy Commissioner, Imphal East, PO & PS Porompat,
Imphal East District, Manipur-795005.
4. The Sub-Divisional Officer, Porompat, PO & PS Porompat, Imphal
East District, Manipur-795005.
…..Applicants
-Versus1. The Holy Spirit Catholic Church, Tribal Colony, New Chekon, PO
&
PS
Porompat,
Imphal
East
District,
Manipur-795005,
represented by its Chairman, Dominic Paojangam Haokip, son of
(late) Solomon Chungkholet Haokip, aged about 55 years, resident
of Mahabali Kabui Khul, PO Imphal & PS Porompat, Imphal East
District, Manipur.
2. Sumpi Peter Anal, aged about 40 years, son of Sumpi Moris Anal,
resident of New Lambulane 1st street, porompat Sub-Division, PO
& PS Porompat, Imphal Eas
District, Manipur- 795005, Joint
Secretary Holy Spirit Catholic Church, Tribal Colony New Checkon.
….Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(Ora)
29.03.2023
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioners for issuance of a writ
of mandamus directing the respondents not to take up eviction process of the
premises now owned by Holy Spirit Catholic Church.
2. On 4.10.2021, when the writ petition was taken up for admission, this
Court passed an interim order directing the parties to maintain status quo.
Aggrieved by the order of status quo, the State filed MC (WP) No.90 of 2023 to
vacate the interim order dated 4.10.2021 and to allow the State authorities to
remove the unauthorized religious structures on public places in compliance
with the Hon’ble Supreme Court order dated 29.9.2009 in SLP (C) No.8519 of
2006 (Union of India v. State of Gujarat and others).
3. By consent, both the writ petition as well as the miscellaneous case
were heard together and disposed of by this common order.
4. Heard Mr. A. Mohendro, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr.
Lenin Hijam, learned AG for the respondents.
5. Brief facts are as follows:
Holy Spirit Catholic Church is a Church situated at Tribal Colony, New
Checkon, Imphal East and the settlers of New Checkon area who profess
Christianity (Catholic) felt the need of a Catholic Church in the locality and, as
such, some volunteers have made efforts for establishment of a Catholic
Church.
The volunteers tried to purchase a piece of land suitable for
establishment of a Church.
After rigorous search, the volunteers met the
owners of the land where the present Church is situated and requested the
owners to transfer a piece of land for construction of a Catholic Church. The
owners agreed to allow the volunteers to use a piece of land measuring 0.16
acre out of their land for construction of the Church, but the owners refused to
transfer the piece of land.
5.1. After getting permission from the land owners, namely Rajkumari
Victoria and Rajkumar Tamphasana Devi, the Church was constructed in the
year 1990. Initially the structure was Kutcha type and later on a semi-pucca
Church was constructed in the year 1998. On 16.8.2021, the Parish Pariest,
St. paul Parish, Sangaiprou issued a certificate to the effect that Holy Spirit
Catholic Church at Tribal Colony, New Checkon is one of the unit (entity)
Churches of Catholic Christians. The Holy Spirit Catholic Church have at
present 67 members, representing each family and about 250 persons have
been attending the Church regularly.
5.2. In the year 2018, the Director of Settlement and Land Records,
Manipur addressed a letter to the Deputy Commissioner, Imphal East regarding
unauthorized construction of religious structures in connection with PIL No.19
of 2013, wherein it has been stated that Holy Spirit Catholic Church was
constructed over a piece of land, which is part and parcel of land under C.S.Dag
No.265. It has also been stated that the land under C.S. Dag No.265 of Patta
No.639 measuring 8.00 acre, Ingkhol class was recorded in the name of
Victoria Devi and Rajkumari Tamphasana Devi.
5.3. The petitioner purchased a piece of land measuring 0.16 acre on the
south eastern portion, out of the land under C/R 982 DLR, patta No.639(new)
covered by C.S. Dag No.265 measuring an area of 8.00 acre Ingkhol class
situate within the Revenue Village No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai, Porompat
Sub Division from its new owners, namely Rajkumar Balaram and Chongtham
Bijoy vide registered sale deed dated 21.12.2018 in the name of Holy Spirit
Catholic Church. Thereafter, the name of Holy Spirit Catholic Church has been
mutated in the land records of patta land as co-pattadars concerning the southeastern portion measuring 0.16 acre. After separation, the land of Holy Spirit
Catholic Church has been brought under Patta No.639/902 (new) covered by
C.S. Dag No.265/1003 and the revenue for the land has been paid from the
year 2019. The members of the Church made development works in or around
the Church building and a compound wall fencing and gate have also been
constructed.
5.4. While so, all of a sudden on 24.12.2020, the Sub Divisional Officer,
Porompat issued a notice in connection with Eviction Case No.17 of 2020
purporting to have been taken up under the Manipur Public Premises (Eviction
of Unauthorised Occupants) Act, 1978 alleging that the Holy Spirit Catholic
Church encroached over the Government land and also directed to show cause
the said notice.
On 30.12.2020, the petitioner Church submitted a reply
narrating all the facts.
5.5. On 4.1.2021, the Commissioner (Revenue) issued allotment orders
thereby allotting a piece of land in favour of Chief Engineer (Building) PWD for
construction of Government Residential Quarters and the land allotted does not
include the land under C.S. Dag No.265/1003 measuring 0.16 acre.
On
20.3.2021, the Principal Secretary and Link Secretary (Works)-cum-Estate
Officer notified construction of new Government Residential quarters by
demolishing the present old structures of Government quarters. The patta land
of Holy Spirit Catholic Church is not included in the land allotted to the PWD for
construction of multi-stored Government quarters.
5.6. On 18.3.2021, the Survey and Settlement Officer-I submitted a
report giving details of unauthorized religious structures. In the said report, the
Survey and Settlement Officer furnished wrong information to the Deputy
Commissioner stating that the land of Holy Spirit Catholic Church covered by
C.S. Dag No.265(P) measuring 0.156 acre is patta land of Chief Engineer
(Building) PWD. Having felt suspicious about the acts of the revenue officials,
the second petitioner filed an application seeking copy of jamapandi. A certified
copy of jamabandi with cancelled name of the pattadar has been issued on
5.4.2021 and the cancellation of the name of Holy Spirit Catholic Church without
affording any opportunity of being heard is bad in law.
5.7. According to the petitioners, they have apprehension that the
Government will take steps to evict the Holy Spirit Catholic Church from its
lawfully acquired land by alleging that the Church is unauthrised occupant of
the Government land without affording a chance of being heard.
In the
happening of such event, the faith of the families who are attending the Holy
Spirit Catholic Church will be at jeopardy. The respondents have no power to
evict the Holy Spirit Catholic Church from the land without adopting proper
course of law. Hence, the petitioners have filed this writ petition.
6. Resisting the writ petition, the first respondent filed affidavit-inopposition stating that the land covered by C.S. Dag No.265 was recorded as
Sarkari Khas in the original Dag Chitha in the year 1960. When the land records
were transferred from the office of the Deputy Commissioner, Porompat in the
year around 2004/2005 to Directorate of Settlement and Land Records,
Manipur for the purpose of re-survey, the names of Victoria Devi and Rajkumari
Tamphasana Devi were found recorded as co-pattadars in the jamabandi under
Patta No.639(new) covered by C.S. Dag No.265 measuring an area of 8.00
acre of Revenue Village No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai without any valid
documents. Later on names of Chongtham Bijoy and R.K.Balaram Singh were
recorded as co-pattadars vide Mutation Case No.421/AS&SO/IE-II dated
3.11.2018 and 429/AS & SO/IE-II dated 24.11.2018 respectively. However, the
said jamabandi under Patta No.639(new) covered by C.S. Dag No.265
measuring an area of 8.00 acre of Village No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai were
declared as not genuine for lack of relevant allotment order/documents vide
order dated 13.10.2020 passed by As & SO-V, DSLR in Rev. Misc. Case No.19
of 2020 after giving notice dated 6.10.2020 to the concerned pattadars and the
names of pattadars were cancelled and corrected as per above order.
6.1. It is stated that the land in question is State land and subsequently
included in the land allotted to the Chief Engineer (Building), Public Works
Department, Manipur for construction of Government Residential quarters vide
order dated 4.1.2021 issued by the Commissioner (Revenue), Government of
Manipur. The alleged land owners, Rajkumari Victoria, Rajkumari Tamphasana
Devi, Rajkumar Balaram and Chongtham Bijoy from whom the petitioners
purchased the land in question have no right and title over the land where
Catholic Church was constructed, as the former alleged land owner from whom
he purchased the said land has no right and title over the said land.
6.2. It is stated that the sale deed being No.3224 (v) of the Sub-Registrar,
Imphal East District had been declared as non-est vide order dated 8.12.2020
by the Deputy Commissioner and the names of the pattadars were cancelled.
The petitioners have constructed the Church building and other structures
without proper verification as to the right and title of the land owners from whom
the Church purchased the land. As such the construction of Church building
and other structures is at their own risk. Since the land in question is a
Government land, notice for eviction was served upon the petitioners and
others who are encroachers to show cause why they should not vacate the
premises. Since the petitioners have no right and title over the land in question,
the writ petition is liable to be dismissed.
7. The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that Holy Spirit
Catholic Church was constructed in the year 1990 in C.S. Dag No.265 after
getting permission from the land owners Rajakumari Victoria and Rajkumar
Tamphasana Devi. The Church had purchased a piece of land measuring 0.16
acre on the south-eastern portion, out of the land under C/R 982 DLR, Patta
No.639(new) covered by C.S. Dag No.265 measuring an area of 8.00 acre
situate within the Revenue Village No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai from the new
owners, Rajkumar Balaram and Chongtham Bijoy vide sale deed dated
21.12.2018. The Church has been mutated in the land records and has been
brought under Patta No.639/902(new) covered by C.S. Dag No.265/1003
measuring 0.16 acre and separate jamabandi was also issued in the name of
the Church. While so, the SDO, Porompat issued a notice dated 24.12.2020 in
connection with Eviction Case No.17 of 2020 purporting to have been taken up
under the Manipur Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act,
1978 alleging that the petitioners have encroached over the Government land.
8. The learned counsel for the petitioners would submit that though the
Commissioner (Revenue), Government of Manipur issued allotment order
thereby allotting a piece of land in favour of the Chief Engineer (Building), PWD
for construction of Government Residential Quarters, the area of land allotted
does not include the land under C.S. Dag No.265/1003 measuring 0.16 acre
i.e. the land of Holy Spirit Catholic Church and the said land measuring 0.16
acre have distinct identity. While so, the Survey and Settlement Officer, DSLR,
Manipur, submitted a report dated 18.3.2021 to the Deputy Commissioner,
Imphal East stating that the land of Holy Spirit Catholic Church covered under
C.S. Dag No.265(P) measuring 0.156 acre is a patta land of Chief Engineer
(Building). Having felt suspicious about the acts of the revenue officials, the
second petitioner filed an application for certified copy of the jamabandi and in
the certified copy of jamabandi, the petitioners found cancellation of the name
of Holy Spirit Catholic Church without affording any opportunity to the
petitioners. Since the acts of the respondents amount to violation of the right
of Church guaranteed by Articles 14, 19, 21, 25 and 26 of the Constitution and
the petitioners have strong apprehension that Government will take steps to
evict Holy Spirit Catholic Church from its lawfulfully acquired land by alleging
that the Church is unauthorized occupant of Government land, the petitioners
have approached this Court not to evict the Church from the land in question.
Such a prayer can be allowed in the interest of worshippers of the Church.
9. On the other hand, the learned Government Advocate appearing for
the respondents submitted that the preparation of jamabandi under Patta
No.639(new) covered by C.S. Dag No.265 measuring an area of 8.00 acre of
Village No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai was declared as not genuine for lack of
relevant documents vide order dated 13.10.2020 passed by the AS & SO-V,
DSLR in Rev. Misc. Case No.19 of 2020 after giving notice dated 6.10.2020 to
the concerned pattadars and the names of the pattadars were cancelled and
corrected. Resultantly, the sale deed dated 20.12.2018 referred to by the
petitioners was also declared as non-est vide order dated 8.12.2020 by the
Deputy Commissioner. Since the name of the pattadars was cancelled and the
sale deed stood in the name of the Church was declared as non-est and also
the land in question was included in the allotment of the land to the Chief
Engineer (Building) PWD for construction of Government Residential Quarters,
the Church in question has no right over the same and, therefore, the
respondent authorities are right in initiating eviction proceedings against the
Church. Thus, a prayer has been made to dismiss the writ petition and to
vacate the interim order granted in the writ petition.
10. This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused the
materials available on record.
11. It is the plea of the petitioners that Holy Spirit Catholic Church was
constructed in year 1990 after getting permission from the land owners namely
Rajkumari Victoria and Rajkumar Tamphasana Devi. The further plea of the
petitioners is that, on 20.12.2018, Holy Spirit Catholic Church had purchased a
piece of land measuring 0.16 acres on the south-eastern portion out of the land
under C/R 982 DLR, Patta No.639(new) covered under C.S. Dag No.265
situate within the Revenue Village No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai, Porompat
Sub Division from its new owners, Rajkumar Balaram and Chongtham Bijoy. It
is also the plea of the petitioners that separate jamabandi was issued in the
name of Holy Spirit Catholic Church for the piece of land under C.S. Dag
No.639/902 in Patta No.265/1003 measuring an extent of 0.16 acres.
Therefore, the initiation of action against Holy Spirit Catholic Church alleging
that it has been constructed on a Government land is totally against the law
and, therefore, Holy Spirit Catholic Church should not evicted from the land in
question.
12. On the contrary, the respondent State contended that the land in
question is a Government land and the petitioners or even their alleged vendors
have not right over the same. Further, the names of pattadars found in the
revenue records was declared as not genuine thereby the names of pattadars
were cancelled and corrected in the revenue records vide order dated
13.10.2020 passed in Rev. Misc. Case No.19 of 2020 after notice to the
pattadars. Since the land in question is a Government land, the same was
allotted to the Chief Engineer (Building), PWD for construction of Government
Residential Quarters.
13. As could be seen from the records, on 6.10.2020, the Assistant
Survey and Settlement Officer-V issued a notice to (1) R.K.Gopalsana; (2)
Victoria; (3) R.K.Tamphasama Devi; (4) R.K.Balaram Singh; (5) Ch. Bijoy
Singh; (6) Philem bankimSingh; (7) Karam (N) Yumnam (O) Ibempishak Devi;
(8) Sawnwithangee and (9) Holy Spirit Catholic Church calling upon them to
furnish relevant documents in connection with C.S. Dag No.265 and its
corresponding C.S. Dag No.265/988, 265/694/697, 265/694 and 265/1003 of
Revenue Village No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai on or before 12.10.2020. The
said notice was responded by the aforesaid persons and after hearing them,
the Assistant Survey and Settlement Office-V has passed an order dated
13.10.2020 in Revenue Misc. Case No.19 of 2020. The order dated 13.10.2020
reads thus:
“Take
note
of
the
AS&SO-V
letter
No.700/85/AS
&
SO-
V/Misc/019/DSLR dted 03.10.2020 this court registered the Revenue
Misc Case No.19 of 2020 for the purpose of re-verification of the land
records relating to Re-verification of lad records relating to the land
covered by C.S. Dag N.265 and its corresponding C.S. Dag
No.265/988, 265/694/697, 265/694 and 265/1003 of revenue village
No.26/Wangkheirakpam Leikai, Imphal East, Porompat Tehsil,
Manipur.
Notice dated 06.10.2020 was served upon R.K.Gopalsana s/o
Gopeshwor Singh of Rajbari, Smt.Victoria w/o Sanayaima of Rajbari,
R.K.Balaram Singh s/o RK Victoria of Rajbari, Ch. Bijoy Singh s/o
R.K.Tamphasana of Rajbari, Philem bankim Singh s/o (L) Imosana
Singh of Moirang Philem Leikai, Karam (N) Yumbam (O) Ibempishak
Devi d/o (L) Manmohan Singh of Uripok, Sawnwithangee w/o
T.Vaiphei of New Checkon and Holly Spirit Catholic Church, new
Checkon directing them to submit any relevant document in connection
with the aforementioned land as the court found them connected with
the land.
Of the 9(nine) persons, R.K.Balaram Singh s/o RK Victoria of Rajbari
and Ch. Bijoy Singh s/o R.K.Tamphasana only submitted Jamabandi
copies of plot of land (Ingkhol) covered by (i) C.S. Dag No.265 having
an area of 8.00 acre under patta No.639 (new) Village No.26Wangkheriakpam Leikal, Porompat, Imphal rcorded in the name of
R.K.Balaram Singh s/o RK Victoria of Rajbari and Ch. Bijoy Singh s/o
R.K.Tamphasana, (ii) C.S. Dag No.265/694/697 having an area of 0.16
acre under patta No.637/638(new) Village No.26-Wangkheriakpam
Leikai, Porompat, Imphal recorded in the name of R.K.Tamphasana
Devi w/o RK Sanayaima Singh of Rajbari and (iii) C.S. Dag No.265/694
having an area of 0.08 acre under patta No.637(new) Village No.26Wangkheriakpam Leikai, Porompat, Imphal recorded in the name of
R.K.Gopalsana s/o Gopeshwor Singh of Rajbari and Smt.Victoria w/o
Sanayaima of Rajbari along with copy of the Manipur State Council
Resolution No.42 dated 12-10-1949.
On the other hand Sawnwithangee w/o T.Vaiphei of New Checkon
submitted a copy of Jamabandi for the land covered by C.S. Dag
No.265/988 an area of 0.16 acre patta No.885 Village No.26Wangkheriakpam Leikai, Porompat, Imphal East along with allotment
Order N.21/74/73-R dated 27.08.1974 relating allotment of land
covered by C.S. Dag No.265 measuring an area of 0.16 acre under
Village No.26-Wangkheriakpam Leikai along with other related
documents.
This court noted that excepting in the case of Sawnwithangee w/o
T.Vaiphei of New Checkon, there is no allotment order in respect of
other persons. Hence the Jamabndi/Patta under (1) C.S. Dg No.265
having an area of 8.00 acre under Patta No.639(new) Village No.26Wangkheriakpam Leikai, Porompat, Imphal recorded in the name of
Smt. Victoria w/o Sanayaima of Rajabari, R.K.Tamphasana Devi d/o
Ketukisana of Rajbari, (ii) C.S. Dag No.265/694/697 having an area of
0.16
acre
under
patta
NO.637/638(new)
Village
No.26-
Wangkheriakpam Leikai, Porompat, Imphal recorded in the name of
R.K.Tamphasana Devi w/o RK Sanayaima Singh of Rajbari and (iii)
C.S. Dag No.265/1003 Patta No.369/902 recorded in the name of Holly
Spirit Catholic Church, New Checkon and (iv) C.S. Dag No.265/694
having an area of 0.08 acre udner patta No.637(new) Village No.26Wangkheriakpam Leikai, Porompat, Imphal recorded in the name of
R.K.gopalsana s/o Gopeshwor Singh of Rabari and Smt. Victoria w/o
Sanayaima of Rajbari are declared as not genuine.
14. Admitted, the aforesaid order dated 13.10.2020 passed by the
Assistant Survey and Settlement Officer has not been challenged by the
petitioners. That apart, a reading of the aforesaid order would clearly indicate
that the Holy Spirit Catholic Church has failed to prove and/or establish their
right over the land in question.
15. On a perusal of the materials available on record, it is clear that on
8.12.2020, the Deputy Commissioner/Registrar, Imphal East District passed an
order declaring the sale deed in favour of Holy Spirit Catholic Church bearing
registration No.3224(V) dated 20-12-2018 is null and void and on 23.11.2020,
the Assistant Survey and Settlement Officer-V, Manipur has requested the
Deputy Commissioner/District Registrar, Imphal East for cancellation of the
sale deed executed between Rajkumar Balaram; Chongtham Bijoy and Holy
Spirit Catholic Church, Tribal Colony, New Checko vide sale deed bearing
No.3224(V) dated 20.12.2018 of SR Porampat as the corresponding patta was
cancelled ad declared not genuine in order to avoid any legal complexity and
confusion in future.
16. Thus, the aforesaid narrated factual facts clearly prove that Holy
Spirit Catholic Church in question or its representative has no right over the
land in question and in fact, the Holy Spirit Catholic Church had purchased
piece of land measuring an extent of 0.16 acre in C.S. Dag 265 out of 8.00 acre
from persons having no right and title over the same. Based on the cancelled
sale deed and cancelled jamabandi, now the Holy Spirit Catholic Church cannot
claim right over the land in which Holy Spirit Catholic Church now stand.
Therefore, it is clear that the Holy Spirit Catholic Church and its other structures
are standing in the Government land which was allotted by the Government of
Manipur to the Chief Engineer (Building), PWD for construction of Government
Residential Quarters. Therefore, there is no hurdle in saying that Holy Spirit
Catholic Church was constructed unauthorisedly in the Government land way
back in the year 1990 that too without the approval from the State authorities.
17. At this juncture, it is pertinent to mention that with regard to the
removal of unauthorized religious structures in public streets, public parks,
public places etc., the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Union of India v.
State of Gujarat and others (arising out of the order dated 2.5.2006 passed by
the Gujarat High Court in SCA No.9686 of 2006) in Special Leave to Appeal
(Civil) No.8519 of 2006 dated 29.9.2009 passed the following orders:
“….. As an interim measure, we direct henceforth no unauthorized
construction shall be carried out or permitted in the name of Temple,
Church, Mosque or Gurudwara etc. on public streets, public parks or
other public places etc.
In respect of the unauthorized construction of religious nature which
has already taken place, the State Governments and the Union
Territories shall review the same on case to case basis and take
appropriate steps as expeditiously as possible.”
18. Again on 7.12.2009, when the Special Leave to Appeal (Civil)
No.8519 of 2006 came up for hearing, the Hon’ble Supreme passed the
following order:
“All the Chief Secretaries, in consultation with the respective
Governments are directed to frame the policy in respect of existing
unauthorized construction of religious nature, which had already taken
place. This Court directed the respondents to review the same on case
to case base. Let the policies be formulated by all the States and Union
Territories within four weeks from today.
We are reiterating that the Chief Secretaries, the concerned District
Magistrates and the Collectors/Deputy Commissioners in-charge of
the Districts must ensure total compliance of our order. Any breach in
this respect shall be viewed seriously by this Court.”
19. It appears that in compliance of the order of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, the Government of Manipur framed a policy and published vide
notification dated 3.4.2010 and had also constituted State Level Committee for
reviewing the unauthorized construction of religious nature and the District
Committees headed by District Commissioner/Chairperson were constituted for
the purpose of removal/relocation/regularization of the religious structure.
Accordingly, the District Level Committee where the religious structures located
in Village No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai discussed existence of nine religious
structures on the land allotted to the PWD Building Division, Government of
Manipur.
Out of 9 religious structures located at Government Quarters
Complex in New Checkon, 5 were removed and 4 are still standing on the Dag
Nos.410, 411, 412(P), 265, 267(P) and 265(P). As stated supra, Holy Spirit
Catholic Church is one of the Church facing eviction proceedings.
20. Since the action for removal of the Church in question is based on
the decision taken by the State Cabinet pursuant to the direction of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 29.9.2009, this Court exercising writ jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India cannot issue direction on the respondent
authorities not to evict Holy Spirit Catholic Church standing in the Government
land.
That apart, as stated supra, Holy Spirit Catholic Church was built
unauthorisedly on the Government land which was meant for construction
Government quarters.
21. At this juncture, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners
submitted that since Holy Spirit Catholic Church is functioning with full spirit by
attending the worshipers for prayers, they may be given 15 days’ time to vacate
the Church and hand over vacant possession of the property. The learned
Government Advocate is also agreeable for grant of 15 days’ time to the
petitioners for vacating Holy Spirit Catholic Church.
22. Since the petitioners have not made out a case for interference with
the eviction proceedings initiated by the respondent authorities and the
respondent authorities proved that the Holy Spirit Catholic Church stand on the
Government land and had been constructed without approval from the State
authorities, there is no bona fide in the present writ petition.
23. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. In view of the dismissal of
the writ petition, MC (WP) No.90 of 2023 is allowed and the order of status quo
dated 4.10.2021 granted by this Court in the writ petition stands vacated. As
agreed, the petitioners are directed to vacate and hand over vacant possession
of the property in question within a period of ten days’ from today, i.e. on or
before 10.04.2023. No costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review