Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
KHOIROM KHOIROM
BIPINCHAN BIPINCHANDRA
SINGH
2024.07.19
DRA SINGH Date:
10:44:01 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC(W.P.(C)) No. 357 of 2023
[Ref.: W.P.(C) No. 358 of 2023]
1.
The State of Manipur, represented through the
Secretary/Commission
(works),
Works
Department, Secretariat, Babupara, Imphal,
Manipur - 795001.
2.
The Chief Engineer (Building), Public Works
Department, Khuyathong, Imphal, Manipur –
795001.
3.
The Executive Engineer, Building Division No. 1,
Public Works Department, Khuyathong, Imphal,
Manipur – 795001.
…. Applicants
- Versus M/s Sri Avantika Contractors (I) Ltd., represented by its
authorized representative, Office at 610-B, Nilgiri Block,
Aditya Enclave, Ameerpet, Hyderabad – 500038.
…. Respondent
BEFORE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU
For theapplicant
:
Mr. Lenin Hijam, Advocate General
Mr. O. Ratankumar, Deputy Govt.
Advocate
For the respondents :
Mr. Ajit Kumar Sinha, Sr. Advocate
Mr. T. Momo, Advocate
Date of hearing
:
Date of Judgment &
order
:
29.01.2024 & 14.06.2024
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
18.07.2024
Page 1
JUDGMENT&ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Manipur
Heard Mr. Lenin Hijam, learned Advocate General,
assisted
by
Mr.
O.
Ratankumar,
learned
Deputy
Government Advocate appearing for the applicants/respondents and
Mr. Ajit Kumar Sinha, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. T.
Momo, learned counsel appearing for the respondent/petitioner.
[2]
The above referred W.P.(C) No. 358 of 2023 was filed
by the respondent/petitioner under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India with the following prayers:
(i)
Issue a Rule-in-Nisi;
(ii)
Call for record of the case, hear the parties and make
the Rule absolute;
(iii)
Issue a writ of certiorari or a writ in the nature of
certiorari or any other appropriate writ/ direction (s)/
order(s) to quash/set aside the letter No. EE/BD-I/
Civil Sectt/ 2022-23/ 1069 dated 11.04.2023 issued
by the Respondent No. 3, whereby the Agreement
No. EE/BD-I/AGRT/2021-22/01, dt. 08.06.2021 was
terminated by the respondent no.3;
(iv)
Issue a writ of mandamus or a writ in the nature of
mandamus or any other appropriate writ/
direction(s)/ order(s) to direct the Official
Respondents to allow the petitioner to continue with
execution of the works mentioned in the Agreement
No. EE/BD-I/AGRT/2021-22/01 dt. 08.06.2021;
(v)
Issue a writ of mandamus or a writ in the nature of
mandamus or any other appropriate writ/
direction(s)/ order(s) to direct the official
respondents not to re-tender the work mentioned in
the Agreement No.EE/BD-I/AGRT/2021-22/01 dt.
08.06.2021 which was validly and lawfully awarded
to the petitioner;
(vi)
Pass any other appropriate order/ direction that this
Hon’ble Court deems fit and just in the interest of
justice;
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 2
(vii)
Award cost of the Petition to the petitioner;
In the interim:
(viii)
[3]
Pending disposal of the matter your Lordships may
be pleased to:
(a)
Grant ad-interim ex-parte stay of the letter
No. EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt(2022-23/1069 dated
11.04.2023 issued by the respondent no.3
whereby
the
agreement
No.EE/BDI/AGRT/2021-22/01 dt. 08.06.2021 was
terminated by the respondent no.3;
(b)
Pass an interim order directing the official
respondents not to re-tender the work
mentioned in the Agreement no. EE/BDI/AGRT/2021-22/01 dt. 08.06.2021 which was
validly and lawfully awarded to the petitioner;
(c)
Pass an interim order directing the official
respondents not to allow any third party or
the PWD, Manipur to carry out the work
mentioned in the Agreement No. EE/BDI/AGRT/2021-22/01 dt. 08.06.2021 during the
pendency of the present writ petition.”
The learned counsel for the respondent/petitioner
submitted that the petitioner is a certified ISO 9001-2015
engineering company delivering heavy EPC projects and significant
importance and national repute for the past two decades. On
09.03.2021, the third respondent issued e-tender notice inviting
composite bids in two bids system from eligible contractors for
construction of capital complex (Civil Secretariat Component) at
Mantripukhri, Imphal (balance work). Pursuant to the said notice,
the petitioner participated in the e-tender process. The petitioner,
being the lowest bidder having fulfilled all terms and conditions of
the tender, allotted the said work. The third applicant/respondent
issued an acceptance letter dated 27.05.2021 awarding the said
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 3
work
to
the
petitioner
at
the
negotiated
amount
of
Rs.
1,67,40,96,700/- which is inclusive of 12% GST of civil works, 18%
GST for IEL works and 15 labourcess which is 2% reduction from
the originally quoted amount of Rs. 170,82,61,939.22. In the said
letter,
the
respondent/petitioner
was
required
to
submit
performance guarantee of Rs. 5,02,22,901/- amounting to 3% the
tendered value of the work. The petitioner had also executed the
performance security bank guarantee for the said amount in favour
of the third applicant/respondent. Pursuant to the acceptance for
the work order and letter of acceptance, an agreement dated
08.06.2021 was executed between the respondent/petitioner and
the third applicants/respondents and the period for completion of
work was fixed as 12 months (02.06.2021 to 01.06.2022). The
petitioner executed 17 bank guarantees in favour of the third
applicants/respondents and the same was also communicated to the
applicants/respondents. According to the regulations, the site must
be
handed
over
with
complete
construction-ready
plans
encompassing the tendered scope of project. The work was initially
awarded to M/s Simplex Projects Limited in October, 2010.
However, the said company was not able to complete the project
within the stipulated period and, therefore, the contract was
terminated on 02.11.2019. Thereafter, the applicants/respondents
issued notice inviting tender on 28.12.2019, which was challenged
by M/s. Simplex Projects Limited, which went to filing of WA No. 39
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 4
of 2020 and, this Court, on 13.01.2021, directed the parties to have
a final joint measurement and after completion of the joint
measurement, liberty was given to the applicants/respondents State
to proceed with construction of the Civil Secretariat Complex by
following the required formalities and procedures. Thereafter, the
remaining work was awarded to the respondent/petitioner.
[4]
The learned counsel for the respondent/petitioner
submitted that the respondent/petitioner was compelled to execute
the work in compliance with the modifications and enhancements
made to the specifications and branding from multiple perspectives
leading to delays and missed milestones. In fact, the department
disposed of numerous profitable products, for example CCTV, data
network system and the aforesaid changes necessitated a rethinking of the department’s strategies, which had to be adjusted to
accommodate the changing environment. The learned counsel
would further submit that the site was handed over in a deplorable
condition with a great deal of thick jungle and debris and in a
disorderly fashion. The removal and correction works caused huge
amount of money and time to the respondent/petitioner and the
said
extra
work
amount
has
not
yet
been
paid
to
the
respondent/petitioner till date. He further submitted that the work
was awarded during pre and post-first Covid eras and the work did
not begin until after Covid pandemic was under control. When the
respondent/petitioner decided to re-start the work, the second wave
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 5
began and the respondent/petitioner was not able to start the work
and, in fact, the respondent/petitioner wrote several letters to the
applicants/respondents stating Covid issues, he further submitted
that as instructed by the Department concerned, number of extra
items have been completed at the site and, in this regard, the
respondent/petitioner had submitted a detailed estimate during
September, 2021. After deliberation and reviews by various
departmental personnel, the department approved certain items,
leaving around sixty items pending for approval.
[5]
The learned counsel for the respondent/petitioner
submitted further that the respondent/petitioner had problems in
procuring the granite of particular colour and after addressing
several
letters
to
applicants/respondents
the
approved
applicants/respondents,
the
the
The
substitute
colour.
respondent/petitioner had also submitted TDS and rate analysis for
various civil and MEP extra items and change of specification
substitute items, which was also discussed. That apart, the
respondent/petitioner had various problems qua UPVC windows, SS
railing, tiles, lifts, DG set, street lamp post, sanitary works, STP
functions and landscape design which contributed to further delay in
completion of the work and the applicants/respondents officials are
lethargic in solving the said problems. The learned counsel added
that the respondent/petitioner has already taken steps to start the
work and, on 06.11.2021, the respondent/petitioner addressed a
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 6
letter to the authorities of PWD bringing the unfortunate situation to
light.
Further,
contrary
to
the
agreement,
the
applicants/respondents authorities descoped the work of data
networking and CCTV cabling at the site and put pressure on the
respondent/petitioner to complete the work earlier than the
stipulated time period.
[6]
The learned counsel for the respondent/petitioner then
submitted that in the mean while the newly elected Government
which
came
to
power
had
given
pressure
on
the
respondent/petitioner to complete the project prior in time for
inauguration. Even then, the applicants/respondents authorities did
not take steps to facilitate such faster rate of work by the
respondent/petitioner.
On
24.05.2022,
the
third
applicant/respondent granted provisional time extension of the said
work up 30.09.2022 without prejudice to the right of the
Government to recover liquidated damages in accordance with the
provisions of Clause 5 of the MPWD General Conditions of Contract,
2020 of the agreement dated 08.06.2021. On 04.06.2022, the
respondent/petitioner
addressed
a
letter
to
the
third
applicant/respondent giving details of various factors which had led
to the delay in project completion, even after making best efforts to
complete
the
work
inspite
of
hindrances
faced
by
the
respondent/petitioner, to the shock and surprise, the third
applicant/respondent sent intimations to the respondent/petitioner
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 7
for slow progress of work and the said letters were suitably replied
by the respondent/petitioner.
[7]
The learned counsel for the respondent/petitioner
further submitted that the respondent/petitioner had continue to
execute the work within the extension period and beyond also which
was within the knowledge of the department and RA bills were also
paid during the said period. In fact, the last RA bill was paid on
06.12.2022. The respondent/petitioner was diligently carrying on
works at the site and about 95% of the works at the site are
complete. Out of the total bill of Rs. 100.78 crore submitted by the
respondent/petitioner, the department has only paid Rs. 69.11 crore
and there is outstanding of Rs.31.67 crore due. That apart, the
respondent/petitioner had also sought approval on a large number
of deviation items, which have still not been considered by the
department and remains actionable at the end of Public Works
Department.
[8]
The learned counsel for the respondent/petitioner
further submit that the respondent/petitioner was served show
cause notices in respect of the work and the respondent/petitioner
has submitted its reply to the show cause notices. The delay in
completing the balance work was a subject matter of public interest
litigation in PIL No. 34 of 2022 and the said PIL was disposed of by
this Court on 04.04.2023. While so, on 11.04.2023, the third
applicant/respondent issued the impugned order terminating the
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 8
agreement
dated
08.06.2021
executed
between
the
respondent/petitioner and the third applicant/respondent. The
respondent/petitioner submitted reply dated 13.04.2023 stating that
the department had not fulfilled its fundamental obligations and had
committed fundamental breach of agreement. However, there was
no response from the third applicant/respondent, which necessitated
the respondent/petitioner in filing the present writ petition. Thus, a
prayer has been made to set aside the impugned termination order
and to allow the respondent/petitioner to continue with the
execution of the work allotted to the respondent/petitioner, coupled
with a prayer not to vacate the interim order dated 19.04.2023
granted by this Court. However, vide order dated 01.08.2023 this
Hon’ble Court vacated the order dated 19.04.2023 by passing the
following order.
“46. As stated supra, the third respondent decided to
conduct a joint measurement of the work done by the
petitioner. In the factual scenario put forth by the
respective parties, if joint measurement is conducted, no
prejudice would be caused to the petitioner and if joint
measured is conducted, it will be helpful for the Court to
know about the exact work executed at the ground level by
the petitioner and based on the report, further steps can be
taken in this matter. Moreover, the third respondent has
every right to conduct joint measurement to assess the
work executed by the contractor at the site. The aforesaid
observation of this Court is only in the interest of both
parties and for the welfare of the public scheme and the
public money involved for construction of Civil Secretariat.
Therefore, keeping the writ petition pending, the
respondent authorities are directed to conduct joint
measurement in order to assess the construction work and
the other work done and executed by the petitioner at the
site. For the purpose of conducting joint measurement, the
interim order dated 19.4.2023 needs to be vacated enabling
the respondent authorities to carry out the joint
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 9
measurement. Therefore, in the interest of justice and
without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the
respective parties in the main writ petition, this Court is
inclined to vacate the interim order dated 19.4.2023
passed in the writ petition.
47. For the reasons stated supra, the interim order dated
19.4.203 granted by this Court in the writ petition stands
vacated. The respondent authorities are directed to conduct
the joint measurement as stated in the impugned order
dated 11.04.2023 and file a report before this Court before
the date of hearing on 04.09.2023.”
Again on the same day this Hon’ble Court passed
another interim order and the same is extracted hereunder;
“3. After delivering the order by this Court, Mr. T. Momo,
learned counsel for the petitioner represented that till the
joint measurement is taken place, both the parties may be
directed to maintain the status quo as on today.
4. Therefore, till the joint measurement is taken place, both
the parties are directed to maintain the status quo as on
today.”
[9]
Being aggrieved, the present applicants (who are the
respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 in the above referred writ petition being
WP(C) No. 358 of 2023) filed Misc. application No. 357 of 2023
praying
for
vacation/modification
of
interim
orders
dated
01.08.2023, dated 09.10.2023 passed in the instant writ petition
being WP(C) No. 358 of 2023 and its subsequent orders on the
ground that there is question of disputed facts that the same may
be allowed to deal in accordance with the Arbitration clause as per
the Contract Agreement thereby allowing the Government to
complete the project by itself in view of the public necessity involved
in the project, with the following prayer:
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 10
“i)
to vacate/modify the interim orders dated
01.08.2023 and dated 09.10.2023 and its
subsequent extension orders passed in the instant
writ petition being WP(C) No. 358 of 2023.
ii)
to dismiss the present writ petition as not
maintainable due to the disputed question of facts
involved in the present case.
to refer the case for Arbitration as provided in
Clause 25 of the Contract Agreement.
iii)
iv)
to allow the Government to continue the work so as
to enable to finish the same within a stipulated
timeframe;
v)
to pass any other appropriate order(s) or
direction(s) which the Hon’ble Court may deem fit
and proper in the facts and circumstances of the
Case.”
During the course of hearing, the prayers No. 1 & 2
are taken up for consideration of passing appropriate order as prays
for by the learned counsel for the applicants/respondents and as
agreed to by the learned counsel for the respondent/petitioner.
[10]
On 19.04.2023, when the writ petition was taken up
for admission, this Hon’ble Court granted interim order directing the
applicants/respondents not to make joint measurement. The said
interim order was extended from time to time and the State
applicants/respondents are seeking to vacate the said interim order.
[11]
The applicant/respondent Nos. 2 & 3 have filed a
preliminary affidavit dated 25.04.2023 stating that the interim order
is not called for in the writ petition and the applicant/respondent
State may be allowed to complete the work and prayed for
modification of the interim order dated 19.04.2023, with supporting
documents annexed as Annexures -B/1 to B/43. Thereafter, Joint
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 11
Measurement Report was submitted and an affidavit in that regard
was also filed on 27.09.2023. The applicant craves the leave of this
Hon’ble Court to rely upon those affidavits, documents/annexures at
the time of hearing of the present application.
On 01.08.2023, the Hon’ble Court was pleased to hear
[12]
the matter [WP(C)No. 358 of 2023] at length and after hearing the
submission made by the parties, the Hon’ble Court was inclined to
vacate the interim order dated 19.04.2023 passed in the writ
petition
in
the
interest
applicants/respondents
of
justice
authorities
to
thereby
conduct
directing
the
the
joint
measurement as stated in the impugned order dated 11.04.2023
and file a report before this Hon’ble Court before the next date of
hearing.
Further, it is also stated that after delivering the order
by this Hon’ble Court, learned counsel for the respondent/petitioner
prayed that till the joint measurement is taken place, both the
parties may be directed to maintain the status quo as on that day.
In view of the prayer made, this Hon’ble Court, vide another order
dated 01.08.2023, was pleased to order that “till the joint
measurement is taken place, both the parties are directed to
maintain the status quo as on today”.
[13]
In the said order dated 01.08.2023, the Hon’ble Court
was pleased to observe as follows:-
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 12
“…..In the factual scenario put forth by the respective
parties, if joint measurement is conducted, no prejudice
would be caused to the petitioner and if joint measurement
is conducted, it will be helpful for the Court to know about
the exact work executed at the ground level by the
petitioner and based on the report, further steps can be
taken in this matter. Moreover, the third respondent has
every right to conduct joint measurement to assess the
work executed by the contractor at the site. The aforesaid
observation of this Court is only
in the interest of both
parties and for the welfare of the public scheme and the
public money involved for construction of Civil
Secretariat.Therefore, keeping the writ petition pending,
the respondent authorities are directed to conduct joint
measurement in order to assess the construction work and
the other work done and executed by the petitioner at the
site. For the purpose of conducting joint measurement, the
interim order dated 19.04.2023 needs to be vacated
enabling the respondent authorities to carry out of the joint
measurement……”
[14]
The learned counsel for the applicants/respondents
submitted that the Joint Measurement for the work “Construction of
Capital Complex (Civil Secretariat Component) at Mantripukhri” was
conducted as per the direction of this Hon’ble High Court’s order
dated 01.08.2023. Thereafter, the Joint Measurement Report, as
furnished by the Department vide letter dated 27.09.2023, was
submitted to this Hon’ble Court through the Registrar (Judl.) vide
forwarding letter dated 27.09.2023 through the office of the
Advocate General, Manipur. It is also pertinent to mention herein
that the petitioner refused to sign in some of the items in list of
items in the Joint Measurement and the same was indicated
while submitting the report before this Hon’ble Court.
[15]
The learned counsel for the applicants/respondents
also submitted that on 09.10.2023, the petitioner filed an
affidavit with objection to the Joint Measurement Report dated
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 13
27.09.2023.
In
the
said
objection
affidavit,
the
respondent/petitioner has clearly mentioned that the representative
of SACIL had refused to sign against some of the items in the list of
items in the Joint Measurement due to the factual dispute
between writ petitioner and the State authorities. On 09.10.2023,
owing to the filing of objection affidavit and seeking time for filing
counter affidavit in MC(WP(C)) No. 140 of 2023 by the
respondent/petitioner, the matter could not be heard and adjourned
thereby extending the earlier interim order dated 01.08.2023 till the
next date.
[16]
The learned counsel for the applicants/respondents
submitted that the matter clearly involves disputed question of facts
and admitted by the writ petitioner in the objection affidavit dated
09.10.2023. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in catena of cases had held
that disputed questions of facts fall outside the writ jurisdiction of
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court in “Shubhas Jain – versus – Rajeshwari Shivam &
Ors. (2021 SCC Online SC 562)”held as follows:
“26. It is well settled that the High Court exercising its
extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, does not adjudicate hotly disputed
question of facts. It is not for the High Court to make a
comparative assessment of conflicting technical reports and
decide which one is acceptable.”
Therefore, the disputed questions of facts cannot be
decided by the Writ Court and as such the present writ petition may
be dismissed in limine by this Hon’ble Court.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 14
[17]
The learned counsel for the applicants/respondents
also submitted that the writ petition is also not maintainable as per
the Arbitration Clause 25 of the Work Agreement (annexed as
Annexure A/5 in the writ petition) which states as follows:
“Clause 25 – Settlement of Dispute & Arbitration –
Except where otherwise provided in the contract, all
questions and disputes relating to the meaning of the
specifications, design, drawings and instructions here-inbefore mentioned and as the quality of workmanship or
materials used on the work or as to any other question,
claim, right, matter or thing whatsoever in any way arising
out of or relating to the contract, designs, drawings,
specifications, estimates, instructions, orders or these
conditions or otherwise concerning the works or the
execution or failure to execute the same whether arising
during the progress of the work or after the cancellation,
termination, completion or abandonment thereof shall be
dealt with as mentioned hereinafter.
I.
If the contractor considers any work demanded of
him to be outside the requirements of the contract,
or disputes any drawings, record or decision given
in writing by the Engineer-in-Charge or if the
Engineer-in-Charge considers any act or decision of
the contractor on any matter in connection with or
arising out of the contract or carrying out of the
work, to be unacceptable and is disputed, such
party shall promptly within 15 days of the arising of
the disputes request the Chief Engineer or where
there is no Chief Engineer, the Additional Director
General (CE/ADG) who shall refer the disputes to
Dispute Redressal Committee (DRC) within 15 days
along with a list of disputes with amounts claimed
if any in respect of each such dispute. The Dispute
Redressal Committee (DRC) give its decision within
a period of 60 days extendable by 30 days by
consent of both the parties from the receipt of
reference from CE/ADG. The constitution of
Dispute Redressal Committee (DRC) shall be as
indicated in Schedule ‘F’. Provided that no party
shall be represented before the Dispute Redressal
Committee by an advocate/legal counsel etc.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 15
The DRC will submit its decision to the concerned ADG/SDG
for acceptance. ADG/SDG in a time limit of 30 days from
receipt of DRC decision will convey acceptance or otherwise
on the said decision. If the Dispute Redressal Committee
(DRC) fails to give its decision within the aforesaid period or
the ADG/SDG fails to give his decision in the aforesaid time
limit or any party is dissatisfied with the decision of Dispute
Redressal Committee (DRC)/ADG/SDG the neither party
may within a period of 30 days from the receipt of the
decision of Dispute Redressal Committee (DRC)/ADG/SDG
or on expiry of aforesaid the time limits available to
DRC/ADG/SDG, may give notice to the Chief Engineer,
Manipur PWD, or if there be no Chief Engineer, the
Additional Director General/Special Director General
concerned or if there be no Additional Director General /
Special Director General concerned of if there be no
Additional Director General / Special Director General, the
Director General, Manipur PWD for appointment of
arbitrator on prescribed proforma as per Appendix XVII
under intimation to the other party.
It is a term of contract that each party invoking arbitration
must exhaust the aforesaid mechanism of settlement of
claims/disputes prior to invoking arbitration.
The CE/ADG/DG shall in such case appoint the sole
arbitrator or one of the three arbitrators as the case may be
within 30 days of receipt of such a request and refer such
disputes to arbitration. Wherever the Arbitral Tribunal
consists of three Arbitrators, the contractor shall appoint
one arbitrator within 30 days of making request for
arbitration or of receipt of request by Engineer-in-Charge to
CE/ADG/DG for appointment of arbitrator, as the case may
be, and two appointed arbitrators shall appoint the third
arbitrator who shall act as the Presiding Arbitrator. In the
event of a.
b.
II.
A party fails to appoint the second Arbitrator,
or
The two appointed Arbitrators fail to appoint
the Presiding Arbitrator, then the Chief
Engineer, Manipur PWD shall appoint the
second or Presiding Arbitrator as the case may
be.
Disputes or difference shall be referred for
adjudication through arbitration by a Tribunal
having sole arbitrator where claimed amount is Rs.
20 crore or less. Where claimed value is more than
Rs. 20 crore, Tribunal shall consist of three
Arbitrators as above. The requirements of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996)
and any further statutory modifications or re-
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 16
enactment thereof and the rules made there under
and for the time being in force shall be applicable.
It is a term of this contract that the party invoking
arbitration shall give a list of disputes with amounts
claimed, if any, in respect of each such dispute along with
the notice for appointment of arbitration and giving
reference to the decision of ADG/SDG on the finding/
recommendation of DRC.
It is also a term of this contract that any member of the
Arbitration Tribunal shall be a Graduate Engineer with
experience in handling public works engineering and further
he shall have earlier worked at a level not lower than Chief
Engineer/ equivalent (i.e. Joint Secretary level of
Government of India). This shall be treated as a mandatory
qualification to be appointed as arbitrator.
Parties, before or at the time of appointment of Arbitral
Tribunal may agree in writing for fast track arbitration as
per the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996)
as amended in 2015.
Subject to provision in the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 (26 of 1996) as amended in 2015 whereby the
counter claims if any can be directly filed before the
arbitrator without any requirement of reference by the
appointing authority, the arbitrator shall adjudicate on only
such disputes as are referred to him by the appointing
authority and give separate award against each dispute and
claim referred to him and in all cases where the total
amount of the claims by any party exceeds Rs. 1,00,000/-,
the arbitrator shall give reasons for the award.
It is also a term of the contract that fees payable to the
arbitral tribunal shall be as approved by Chief Engineer,
PWD, Manipur. This fee shall be shared equally by parties.
The place of arbitration shall be as mentioned in Schedule
F. In case there is no mention of place of arbitration, the
arbitral tribunal shall determine the pace of arbitration.
The venue of the arbitration shall be such place as may be
fixed by the Arbitral Tribunal in consultation with both the
parties. Failing any such agreement, then the Arbitral
Tribunal shall decide the venue.”
[18]
The learned counsel for the applicants/respondents
further submitted that since the matter is regarding the disputed
question of facts and Contract Agreement with Arbitration Clause,
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 17
where the legal question does not arise, for the stated reason the
Clause 25 of the Contract Agreement may be invoked. It is worth
mentioning that since the matter is relating to the Contract
Agreement and concerning disputed facts, the writ Court may not be
the appropriate forum and the parties may be referred to
Arbitration or before Ld. Civil Court. As such, the matter be
referred to the DRC/ Arbitration invoking the provision of Clause 25
of the Contract Agreement. Moreover, in para No. 45 of the order
dated 01.08.2023, the Hon’ble Court observed as follows:
“45. As could also be seen from the general conditions of
the contract, particularly Clause 25 provides settlement of
dispute and arbitration of the conditions of the contract
agreement to settle any dispute or grievances, if any. In
view of the factual questions involved in the writ petition
and in the absence of detailed counter-affidavit filed by the
respondents resisting the allegations set out in the writ
petition, the merits of the termination of the agreement
dated 08.06.2021 cannot be gone into at this stage.”
[19]
The learned counsel for the applicants/respondents
also submitted that the work “Construction of Capital Project (Civil
Secretariat Component) at Mantripukhri” is a highly prestigious
project which is of great importance to the State and its people i.e.,
public utility. The present work has become a prestige issue for the
State Government in front of Central leadership and the Government
of Manipur has decided to complete the work on departmental basis.
It is pertinent to mention herein that after the completion of the
Project the same is awaited to be inaugurated by the Highest
Official of the Central Government as it is actually the project of
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 18
National importance. As such, speedy completion of the project is
the need of the hour in public interest. And the Government may be
allowed to complete the project.
[20]
The learned counsel for the applicants/respondents
submitted that the delay in executing the work is not the result of
the non-payment of bills to the petitioner and, in fact, up-to-date bill
amounts have been settled to the petitioner. As far as the pending
bills are concerned, the department checked those bills and found to
be heavily exceeding than the actual work done and, therefore, the
same was returned to the petitioner for correction.
[21]
The learned counsel for the respondent/petitioner has
submitted
affidavit-in-opposition
on
behalf
of
the
respondent/petitioner by denying almost all the submission and the
prayers
put
forth
in
the
miscellaneous
application
by
the
applicant/respondent and submitted that the contents of the
paragraphs are matter of records.
1.
Submitted that the present application is not maintainable
as a writ petition can be maintained in a contractual
matter despite existence of an arbitration clause as the lis
involves a public law character and the alternative forum
chosen by the parties would not be in-a-position to grant
appropriate relief. The present action of the state in
terminating the present agreement
in question is
arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of the constitutional
rights of the petitioner. Therefore, the present writ
petition is maintainable. Hence, this Hon’ble Court was
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 19
please to pass the interims orders in the present writ
petition.
2.
Further submitted that the representatives of the
respondent-company had refused to sign against the list
of items in the Joint measurements dated 27.09.2023 for
the following reasons:
(i)
The records of the measurements of the
some of the said items were not provided
to the representatives of SACIL by PWD.
(ii)
The records of the measurements of the
some of the said items were provided to
the representatives of SACIL by PWD but
without sufficient time to verify and crosscheck the measurements.
(iii)
The details of the work done regarding the
said items were not measured by PWD.
3.
Further submitted that the present action of the State in
terminating the present agreement in question is
arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of the Constitutional
rights of the petitioner and this Hon’ble Court under writ
jurisdiction is competent to decide the present dispute. It
is settled law that the need to deal with disputed
questions of fact, cannot be made a smokescreen to
guillotine a genuine claim raised in a writ petition, when
actually the resolution of a disputed question of fact is
unnecessary to grant relief to the writ applicant. The
case-laws cited by the applicants in the present
paragraph are not applicable to the present case.
4.
Further submitted that it is settled law that a writ petition
can be maintained in a contractual matter despite
existence of an arbitration clause in the following
alternatives scenarios:
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 20
(i)
Where
the
character
lis involves a public law
or
requires
a
judicial
determination in rem;
(ii)
The alternative forum chosen by the
parties would not be in a position to grant
appropriate relief;
(iii)
A statutory contract is in question or the
action of a state or its instrumentality is
demonstrably arbitrary, unreasonable or
violative of the fundamental rights of a
party;
(iv)
The matter does not relate only to the
interpretation of a contract which is within
the domain of an arbitrator.
It is also submitted that the present action of
the State in terminating the present agreement in question is
arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of the constitutional
rights of the petitioner and this Hon’ble Court under writ
jurisdiction is competent to decide the present dispute. It is
settled law that the need to deal with disputed questions of
fact, cannot be made a smokescreen to guillotine a genuine
claim raised in a writ petition, when actually the resolution of
a disputed question of fact is unnecessary to grant relief to
the writ applicant, therefore, the present writ petition is
maintainable.
5.
The respondent no. 1 craved leave of this Hon’ble
Court to file an additional affidavit and documents to
supplement the present affidavit-in-opposition, if required at
a later stage.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 21
[22]
As requested by both the learned counsels, this Court
allowed the request of both the learned counsels to file written
submissions in support of their case and the same are reproduced
herein below:
[23]
Written submissions submitted on behalf of
the State applicants/respondents:
“1. The State applicants humbly beg to submit that the
initial work, “Construction of Capital Project (Civil Secretariat
Component) at Mantripukhri, was awarded to M/S Simplex
Projects Ltd. Kolkata. Due to heavy delay in completion, the
work awarded to M/S Simplex Project Ltd. was determined
on 2.11.2019. Thereafter, the remaining work was awarded
to M/S Sri. Avantika Contractors (I) Ltd., vide Agreement
No. EE/BD-I/AGRT/2021-22/01 dated 8.6.2021 (Annexure
A/5 to the writ petition). The stipulated time period for
completion of work was 12 (twelve) months (2.6.2021 to
1.6.2022). Again, this firm could not complete the work
within time, inspite of repeated show cause notices for the
delay in the execution of work, after giving reasonable
opportunities and having no alternative, the Contract
Agreement entered between the Executive Engineer,
Building Division No. 1, PWD, Manipur and M/s Sri Avantika
Contractors (I) Ltd. in respect of the work, “Construction of
Capital
Complex
(Civil
Secretariat
Component)
at
Mantripukri” was determined vide letter No. EE/BD-I/Civil
Sectt/2022-23/1069 dated 11.4.2023.
In the said letter dated 11.4.2023 for determination
of Contract, it is clearly informed the petitioner to attend for
joint measurement by stating that failing which the Joint
Measurement will be conducted in absence of the petitioner
and the result will be final and binding. Further, it is also
stated to approach the appropriate authority as provided
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 22
under Clause No. 25 – Settlement of Dispute and arbitration
of the Conditions of the Contract Agreement to settle any
disputes or grievances, if any.
2.
That it is most respectfully submitted that the above
referred Writ Petition being WP(C) No. 358 of 2023 was
filed praying inter-alia to quash/ set aside the letter No.
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2022-23/1069 dated 11.4.2023 by which
the Contract Agreement No. EE/BD-I/AGRT/2021-22/01
dated 8.6.2021 was terminated on the basis of the
pleadings made therein.
3.
That it is humbly begs to submit that on 19.4.2023,
this Hon’ble Court granted interim order directing the
respondents not to make joint measurement (Annexure M/1
to the MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023) for the works done by
the petitioner. The said interim order was extended from
time to time.
4.
That the State Respondent highlighting all the facts,
a preliminary Affidavit dated 25.4.2023 was filed, stating
that the interim order is not called for in the writ petition
and the respondent State may be allowed to complete the
remaining work and prayed for modification of the interim
order dated 19.4.2023, with supporting documents annexed
as Annexures - B/1 to B/43 on behalf of the Respondents
No. 2 & 3 to the Writ Petition.
5.
That it is most respectfully begs to submit that on
1.8.2023, the Hon’ble Court after hearing the submission
made by the parties, was pleased to vacate the interim
order dated 19.4.2023 (Annexure M/1 to the MC(WP(C))
No. 357 of 2023) passed in the writ petition in the interest
of justice thereby directing the respondent authorities to
conduct the joint measurement as stated in the impugned
Letter dated 11.4.2023 (Annexure A/22 to the writ petition)
and to file a report before the Hon’ble Court, before the
next date of hearing.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 23
6.
That it is also to state that after delivering the Order
by this Hon’ble Court, learned counsel for the petitioner
prayed that till the joint measurement is taken place, both
the parties may be directed to maintain the status quo as
on that day. In view of the prayer made, this Hon’ble Court
vide another Order dated 1.8.2023 was pleased to order
that ‘till the joint measurement is taken place, both the
parties are directed to maintain the status quo as on today’.
(Annexures – M/2 & M/3respectively to MC(WP(C)) No. 357
of 2023).
7.
That it is most respectfully begs to submit that in
the above said Order dated 1.8.2023, the Hon’ble Court was
pleased to observe as follows –
“In the factual scenario put forth by the respective
parties,if joint measurement is conducted, no
prejudice would be caused to the petitioner and if
joint measurement is conducted, it will be
helpful for the Court to know about the exact
work executed at the ground level by the
petitioner and based on the report, further
steps can be taken in this matter. Moreover, the
third respondent has every right to conduct joint
measurement to assess the work executed by the
contractor at the site. The aforesaid observation of
this Court is only in the interest of both parties and
for the welfare of the public scheme and the public
money involved for construction of Civil Secretariat.
Therefore, keeping the writ petition pending, the
respondent authorities are directed to conduct joint
measurement in order to assess the construction
work and the other work done and executed by the
petitioner at the site. For the purpose of conducting
joint measurement, the interim order dated
19.4.2023 needs to be vacated enabling the
respondent authorities to carry out the joint
measurement.”
8.
per
That it is most respectfully begs to submit that as
the
direction
of
this
Hon’ble
Court,
the
Joint
Measurement for the work, “Construction of Capital
Complex (Civil Secretariat Component) at Mantripukhri” was
conducted as per the direction of this Hon’ble High Court’s
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 24
order dated 1.8.2023. Thereafter, the Joint Measurement
Report as furnished by the Department vide letter dated
27.9.2023 was submitted to this Hon’ble Court through the
Registrar (Judl.) vide forwarding letter dated 27.9.2023
through the office of the Advocate General, Manipur. It is
also pertinent to mention herein that the petitioner refused
to sign in some of the items in list of items in the Joint
Measurement and the same was indicated while submitting
the report before this Hon’ble Court.
9.
That the present Misc. Application being MC[WP(C)]
No. 357 of 2023 Ref.: WP(C) No. 358 of 2023 was filed by
the State Applicants/ State Respondents praying the
following prayers :
i)
to vacate/ modify the interim Orders dated
1.8.2023
and
dated
9.10.2023
and
its
subsequent extension orders passed in the
instant writ petition being WP(C) No. 385 of
2023;
ii)
to dismiss the present writ petition as not
maintainable due to the disputed question of
facts involved in the present case;
iii)
to refer the case for Arbitration as provided in
Clause 25 of the Contract Agreement;
iv)
to allow the Government to continue the
Work so as to enable to finish the same
within a stipulated timeframe; -AND-
v)
to pass any other appropriate order(s) or
direction(s) which the Hon’ble Court may
deem fit and proper in the facts and
circumstances of the Case.
10.
That it is most respectfully begs to submit that while
hearing the present Misc. Application, the State Applicants
pressed only the prayers made in prayer number (i) and (ii)
–
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 25
i)
to vacate/ modify the interim Orders dated
1.8.2023 and dated 9.10.2023 and
its
subsequent extension orders passed in the
instant writ petition being WP(C) No. 385 of
2023;
ii)
to dismiss the present writ petition as not
maintainable due to the disputed question of
facts involved in the present case;
11.
That it is most respectfully begs to state that the
State Applicants argued that interim order dated 1.8.2023
and its subsequent orders are liable to be vacated/ modified
and the writ petition deserves to be dismissed as the same
is not maintainable on the following grounds:
(a)
That the interim Order dated 1.8.2023 and
its subsequent orders are liable to be
vacated in view of the public necessity
involved
in
the
project
as
the
work
“Construction
of
Capital
Project
(Civil
Secretariat Component) at Mantripukhri” is a
highly prestigious project which is of great
importance to the State and its people i.e.,
public utility.
(b)
That there is question of disputed facts/ false
submission of fact.
(c)
That there is breach of contract Agreement
and the same may be allowed to deal in
accordance
with
the
Arbitration
clause
(Clause 25) as per the Contract Agreement
entered between the Executive Engineer,
Building Division No. 1, PWD, Manipur and
M/s Sri Avantika Contractors (I) Ltd. in
respect of the work, “Construction of Capital
Complex (Civil Secretariat Component) at
Mantripukhri”.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 26
12.
That with regards the vacation of interim order
dated 1.8.2023 and its subsequent extension orders, it is
submitted that the work, “Construction of Capital Project
(Civil Secretariat Component) at Mantripukhri” is a highly
prestigious project which is of great importance to the State
and its people i.e., public utility. The present work has
become a prestige issue for the State Government in front
of Central leadership and the Government of Manipur has
decided to complete the work on departmental basis. It is
pertinent to mention herein that after the completion of the
Project the same is awaited to be inaugurated by the
Highest Functioning of the Country as it is actually the
project of National importance. As such, speedy completion
of the project is the need of the hour in public interest. And
the State Government may be allowed to complete the
project departmentally. Further, it is submitted that the
delay in executing the work is not the result of the nonpayment of bills to the petitioner and, in fact, up-to-date bill
amounts have been settled to the petitioner. As far as the
pending bills are concerned, the department checked those
bills and found to be heavily exceeding than the actual work
done and, therefore, the same was returned to the
petitioner for correction. It may be pertinent to mention
herein that effective functioning of the State Government
Departments is being curtailed as the infrastructure
developed for the public i.e., the present work, could not be
completed owing to the existence of interim orders. In this
regard, in catena of cases, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
decided not to stop the work project of public importance.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in NG Project Limited -versusVinod Kumar Jain and Others. (2022) 6 SCC 127– Para
Nos. 19, 20 & 21 held as follows:
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 27
“19. The Specific Relief Act, 1963 was amended by
Central Act 18 of 2018 when clause (ha) was
inserted in Section 41 of the said Act to say:
“41. (ha) if it would impede or delay the
progress or completion of any infrastructure
project or interfere with the continued
provision of relevant facility related thereto
or services being the subject-matter of such
project.”
20. Such amendment was in pursuance of the report
submitted on 20-6-2016 of the Expert Committee.
The report is as under:
“The Expert Committee set on examining the
Specific Relief Act, 1963 submits its Report to Union
Law & Minister recommends modifications for
ensuring ease of doing business.
The Expert Committee set on examining the
Specific Relief Act, 1963 today submitted its Report
to Union Law & Justice Minister Shri DV Sadananda
Gowda here in New Delhi. In its report the
committee has recommended modifications in the
Specific Reliefs Act, 1963 for ensuring the ease of
doing business.
In the context of tremendous developments
which have taken place since 1963 and the present
changed scenario involving contract based
infrastructure
developments,
public
private
partnerships and other public projects, involving
huge investments; and changes required in the
present scheme of the Act and so that specific
performance is granted as a general rule and grant
of compensation or damages for non-performance
remains as an exception, the committee decided –
To change the approach, from
(i)
damages being the rule and specific
performance being the rule and
specific performance being the
exception, to specific performance
being the rule, and damages being the
alternate remedy.
(ii)
To provide guidelines for reducing the
discretion granted to courts and
tribunals while granting performance
and injunctive reliefs.
(iii) To introduce provisions for rights of
third parties (other than for
government contracts).
(iv) To
consider
addressing
unconscionable
contracts,
unfair
contracts, reciprocity in contract, etc.,
and implied terms.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 28
The committee observed that there is
a need to classify diverse public utility
contracts
as
a
distinct
class
recognising the inherent public
interest/ importance to be addressed
in the Act. Any public work must
progress without interruption. This
requires consideration whether a
court’s intervention in public works
should
be
minimal.
Smooth
functioning of public works projects
can be effectively managed through a
monitoring system and regulatory
mechanism. The role of courts in this
exercise is to interfere to the minimum
extent so that public works projects
will not be impeded or stalled.”
21. Since the construction of road is an
infrastructure project and keeping in view the intent
of the legislature that infrastructure projects
should not be stayed, the High Court would
have been well advised to hold its hand to
stay the construction of the infrastructure
project. Such provision should be kept in view
even by the writ court while exercising it
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.”
13.
That it is most respectfully begs to state that in the
Affidavit-in-Opposition dated 16th October, 2023 of the
Respondent (M/s Avantika) filed in MC(WP(C)) No. 140 of
2023 Ref.: WP(C) No. 358 of 2023 it is stated that – (i)
at para No. 5 (page No. 3), it is stated as –
“It is submitted that the respondent-company has
executed 95% of the work and so far submitted
bills of Rs. 100.78 Crores.”
at para No. 14 (page No. 7), it is also stated as
follows –
“It is submitted that the respondent-company has
executed 95% of the work, whereas the
Department had stated that the respondentcompany has completed 53.73% of the work.”
“As per the Joint-measurement report the
percentage of work done by the respondentcompany is 49%, whereas according to the
respondent-company the percentage of work done
is 97.61% after the Jont-measurement.”
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 29
at para No. 16 (page No. 11), it is stated and
admitted that –
“It is submitted that as explained in the abovementioned paragraph the percentage of 95% of
the work being completed by the respondentcompany is correct, therefore, the respondentcompany has not made any false statement before
this Hon’ble Court. Moreover, the percentage of
work done by the respondent-company is
disputed and not yet determined by this Hon’ble
Court.”
As such, the work done by the petitioner is not 95% but
only 45.27% i.e., Rs. 88.91 cr. or otherwise only 53.73% as
per the claims received by the Department. If the 95%,
which is stated by the petitioner in the writ petition, is
correct, the value of work will be of Rs. 184.78 cr. And such
amount of bill is never received by the Department. It is
further to state that the Bills are to be paid on measurable
and completed works. Hence, the disputed question of facts
is clearly involved herein.
(ii)
With regards the false statement made by the
petitioner, the law settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
i.e., (2022) 12 SCC 815 (K. Jayaram & Ors -vs- Bangalore
Development Authority & Ors.) (para 13-14) is relied by the
State Applicants. Relevant portion of the same are being
reproduced hereunder –
(2022) 12 SCC 815 –Para 13 (False Statement)
(K. Jayaram & Ors -vs- Bangalore Development Authority
&Ors.)
“13. In K.D. Sharma v. SAIL [K.D. Sharma v. SAIL, (2008)
12 SCC 481], it was held thus: (SCC pp. 492-93, paras 3439)
“34. The jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under
Article 32 and of the High Court under Article 226 of
the Constitution is extraordinary, equitable and
discretionary. Prerogative writs mentioned therein are
issued for doing substantial justice. It is, therefore,
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 30
of utmost necessity that the petitioner
approaching the writ court must come with
clean hands, put forward all the facts before
the court without concealing or suppressing
anything and seek an appropriate relief. If
there is no candid disclosure of relevant and
material facts or the petitioner is guilty of
misleading the court, his petition may be
dismissed at the threshold without considering
the merits of the claim.
35. The underlying object has been succinctly stated
by
Scrutton,
L.J.,
in
the
leading
case
of R. v. Kensington
Income
Tax
Commissioners [R. v. Kensington
Income
Tax
Commissioners, (1917) 1 KB 486 : 86 LJKB 257 : 116
LT 136 (KB & CA)] in the following words : (KB p.
514)
‘… it has been for many years the rule of the
court, and one which it is of the greatest
importance to maintain, that when an applicant
comes to the court to obtain relief on an ex
parte statement he should make a full and fair
disclosure of all the material facts—it says facts,
not law. He must not misstate the law if he can
help it—the court is supposed to know the law.
But it knows nothing about the facts, and the
applicant must state fully and fairly the facts;
and the penalty by which the court enforces that
obligation is that if it finds out that the facts
have not been fully and fairly stated to it, the
court will set aside any action which it has taken
on the faith of the imperfect statement.’
36. A prerogative remedy is not a matter of course.
While exercising extraordinary power a writ court
would certainly bear in mind the conduct of the party
who invokes the jurisdiction of the court. If the
applicant makes a false statement or
suppresses material fact or attempts to mislead
the court, the court may dismiss the action on
that ground alone and may refuse to enter into
the merits of the case by stating, ‘We will not
listen to your application because of what you
have done.’ The rule has been evolved in the larger
public interest to deter unscrupulous litigants from
abusing the process of court by deceiving it.
37.
In Kensington
Income
Tax
Commissioners [R. v. Kensington
Income
Tax
Commissioners, (1917) 1 KB 486: 86 LJKB 257 : 116
LT 136 (KB & CA)] , Viscount Reading, C.J. observed :
(KB pp. 495-96)
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 31
‘… Where an ex parte application has been
made to this Court for a rule nisi or other
process, if the Court comes to the
conclusion that the affidavit in support of
the application was not candid and did
not fairly state the facts, but stated them
in such a way as to mislead the Court as
to the true facts, the Court ought, for its
own protection and to prevent an abuse
of its process, to refuse to proceed any
further with the examination of the
merits. This is a power inherent in the Court,
but one which should only be used in cases
which bring conviction to the mind of the Court
that it has been deceived. Before coming to
this conclusion, a careful examination will be
made of the facts as they are and as they have
been stated in the applicant's affidavit, and
everything will be heard that can be urged to
influence the view of the Court when it reads
the affidavit and knows the true facts. But if
the result of this examination and hearing is to
leave no doubt that the Court has been
deceived, then it will refuse to hear anything
further from the applicant in a proceeding
which has only been set in motion by means of
a misleading affidavit.’
38. The above principles have been accepted in our
legal system also. As per settled law, the party
who invokes the extraordinary jurisdiction of
this Court under Article 32 or of a High Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution is
supposed to be truthful, frank and open. He
must disclose all material facts without any
reservation even if they are against him. He
cannot be allowed to play “hide and seek” or to “pick
and choose” the facts he likes to disclose and to
suppress (keep back) or not to disclose (conceal)
other facts. The very basis of the writ jurisdiction
rests in disclosure of true and complete
(correct) facts. If material facts are suppressed or
distorted, the very functioning of writ courts and
exercise would become impossible. The petitioner
must disclose all the facts having a bearing on the
relief sought without any qualification. This is because
“the court knows law but not facts”.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 32
39. If the primary object as highlighted in Kensington
Income Tax Commissioners [R. v. Kensington Income
Tax Commissioners, (1917) 1 KB 486 : 86 LJKB 257 :
116 LT 136 (KB & CA)] is kept in mind, an applicant
who does not come with candid facts and “clean
breast” cannot hold a writ of the court with “soiled
hands”. Suppression or concealment of material
facts is not an advocacy. It is a jugglery,
manipulation,
manoeuvring
or
misrepresentation, which has no place in
equitable and prerogative jurisdiction. If the
applicant does not disclose all the material
facts fairly and truly but states them in a
distorted manner and misleads the court, the
court has inherent power in order to protect
itself and to prevent an abuse of its process to
discharge the rule nisi and refuse to proceed
further with the examination of the case on
merits. If the court does not reject the petition
on that ground, the court would be failing in its
duty. In fact, such an applicant requires to be dealt
with for contempt of court for abusing the process of
the court.”
14.
That it is humbly submitted that the matter clearly
involves disputed question of facts as admitted by the writ
petitioner in the objection affidavit dated 9.10.2023. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court in catena of cases has held that
disputed questions of facts fall outside the writ jurisdiction
of Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
The State Applicants also relied on the following settled
position of law decided by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India –
(2021
SCC
Online
SC
562)
–
para
(Disputed question of fact) (Shubhas Jain – versus Rajeshwari Shivam & Ors.)
“25. It is well settled that the High Court
exercising its extraordinary writ jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
does not adjudicate hotly disputed questions
of facts. It is not for the High Court to make a
comparative assessment of conflicting technical
reports and decide which one is acceptable.”
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 33
(2005)
SCC 725
–Paras
7,
8,
9,
(Disputed question of fact)(Orissa Agro Industries Corpn.
Ltd. & Ors. -vs- Bharati Industries & Ors.)
“7.
A bare perusal of the High Court's judgment
shows that there was clear non-application of mind.
On one hand the High Court observed that the
disputed questions cannot be gone into a writ
petition. It was also noticed that the essence of the
dispute was breach of contract. After coming to the
above conclusions the High Court should have
dismissed the writ petition. Surprisingly, the High
Court proceeded to examine the case solely on the
writ petitioner's assertion and on a very curious
reasoning that though the appellant Corporation
claimed that the value of articles lifted was nearly Rs
14.90 lakhs no details were specifically given. From
the counter-affidavit filed before the High Court it is
crystal-clear that relevant details disputing claim of
the writ petitioner were given. Value of articles lifted
by the writ petitioner is a disputed factual question.
Where a complicated question of fact is involved and
the matter requires thorough proof on factual
aspects, the High Court should not entertain the writ
petition. Whether or not the High Court should
exercise jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution would largely depend upon the
nature of dispute and if the dispute cannot be
resolved without going into the factual
controversy, the High Court should not
entertain the writ petition. As noted above, the
writ petition was primarily founded on allegation of
breach of contract. Question whether the action
of the opposite party in the writ petition
amounted to breach of contractual obligation
ultimately depends on facts and would
require material evidence to be scrutinised
and in such a case writ jurisdiction should not
be exercised. (See State of Bihar v. Jain Plastics &
Chemicals Ltd. [(2002) 1 SCC 216])
8. In a catena of cases this Court has held that
where the dispute revolves round questions of
fact, the matter ought not to be entertained
under Article 226 of the Constitution.
[See State Bank of India v. State Bank of India
Canteen Employees' Union [(1998) 5 SCC 74 : 1998
SCC (L&S) 1270] and Chairman, Grid Corpn. of
Orissa Ltd. (GRIDCO) v. Sukamani Das [(1999) 7
SCC 298] .]
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 34
9. In the instant case the High Court has itself
observed that disputed questions of fact were
involved and yet went on to give directions as
if it was adjudicating the money claim in a
suit. The course is clearly impermissible.
(See G.M.,
Kisan
Sahkari
Chini
Mills
Ltd. v. Satrughan Nishad [(2003) 8 SCC 639]
and Rourkela Shramik Sangh v. Steel Authority of
India Ltd. [(2003) 4 SCC 317 : 2003 SCC (L&S) 456]
10. In National
Highways
Authority
of
India v. Ganga Enterprises [(2003) 7 SCC 410] it
was observed by this Court that the question
whether the writ petition was maintainable in
a claim arising out of a breach of contract
should be answered first by the High Court as
it would go to the root of the matter. The writ
petitioner had displayed ingenuity in its search for
invalidating circumstances; but a writ petition is not
an appropriate remedy for impeaching contractual
obligations. (See Har Shankar v. Dy. Excise and
Taxation Commr. [(1975) 1 SCC 737: AIR 1975 SC
1121] and Divisional Forest Officer v. Bishwanath
Tea Co. Ltd. [(1981) 3 SCC 238 : AIR 1981 SC
1368])”
15.
That it is most respectfully begs to submit that as
disputed question of fact is clearly involved beyond any
doubt, the writ is not maintainable and, in this regard the
State Applicants relied upon the following settled position of
law decided by the Hon’ble Supreme of Court of India –
(1996) 6 SCC 623–Para 19 (Maintainability)
Lanzxthika -vs- Seth Karsandas Jamnadas)
(TK
“19. As the third proviso to Section 11(3) disentitles
a landlord from applying for eviction of the tenant
before the expiry of the quarantine period, the
petition filed by the landlord in this case has to be
dismissed only on that ground. Any observation
made on this case in the proceedings based
on such a non-maintainable petition must
stand erased from judicial notice. If the present
landlord filed a new petition must stand erased from
judicial notice. If the present landlord files a new
petition for eviction under the Act, as the ban period
is over, the same has to be considered and disposed
of uninfluenced by any of the observations made by
the High Court or the courts below thereto.”
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 35
(2023)
SCC
–
Paras
23,
(Maintainability)(S. Narahari & Ors. -vs- SR Kumar & Ors.)
“23. We are of the considered opinion that
only after the issue of maintainability is
decided upon, can this Court enter into the
merits of the case.
The issue of
maintainability of special leave petition is akin
to a rite of passage, and only after it is
deemed that special leave petition is
maintainable, can an entry be taken into the
merits of a dispute.”
“39. Therefore, in light of the abovementioned
observations, we are of the opinion that to put a
quietus to such an issue, it is necessary for the
same to be adjudicated and deliberated upon by a
larger Bench of this Court. Further, since only after
such a preliminary objection is decided, can the
merits of the present case be entered into, the same
is to be placed before an appropriate Bench after
the question of law is decided by the larger Bench.”
(2002)
SCC
–
Para
(Maintainability) (Gagandeep Pratishthan Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. vs- Mechano & Anr.)
“6. In view of the peculiar facts of this case without
going into the merits of the contentions raised by
the counsel for the appellants, we think it is just
and fair that we should not at this point of
time interfere with the impugned order
though the High Court could have avoided
passing such orders in proceedings where the
maintainability itself was being seriously
questioned, be that as it may, we at this stage
think it appropriate that the High Court should
consider the question of condonation of delay and
the objection of the appellants herein in regard to
maintainability of the appeal first, before proceeding
with the appeal any further. We also think it to be
just and proper that any further interim orders if
necessary in the appeal before the High Court in
regard to the suit property should be made only
after deciding the question of delay and
maintainability of the appeal and the order already
made should be confined to the appointment of a
Receiver and filing of his report only, meaning
thereby that the impugned order be confined to the
appointment of Receiver for the purpose of filing his
report as directed by the Court and nothing beyond
that, at this stage.”
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 36
(2003)
SCC
–
Para
(Maintainability) (National Highways Authority of India -vsGanga Enterprises & Anr.)
“6. The respondent then filed a writ petition in the
High Court for refund of the amount. On the
pleadings before it, the High Court raised two
questions viz.: (a) whether the forfeiture of security
deposit is without authority of law and without any
binding contract between the parties and also
contrary to Section 5 of the Contract Act; and (b)
whether the writ petition is maintainable in a
claim arising out of a breach of contract.
Question (b) should have been first answered
as it would go to the root of the matter. The
High Court instead considered Question (a) and then
chose not to answer Question (b). In our view, the
answer to Question (b) is clear. It is settled law
that disputes relating to contracts cannot be
agitated under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India. It has been so held in the cases of Kerala
SEB v. Kurien E. Kalathil [(2000) 6 SCC 293], State of
U.P. v. Bridge & Roof Co. (India) Ltd. [(1996) 6 SCC
22] and Bareilly Development Authority v. Ajai Pal
Singh [(1989) 2 SCC 116]. This is settled law. The
dispute in this case was regarding the terms of offer.
They were thus contractual disputes in respect
of which a writ court was not the proper
forum. Mr Dave, however, relied upon the cases
of Verigamto Naveen v. Govt. of A.P. [(2001) 8 SCC
344] and Harminder Singh Arora v. Union of
India [(1986) 3 SCC 247]. These, however, are
cases where the writ court was enforcing a
statutory right or duty.These cases do not lay
down that a writ court can interfere in a
matter of contract only. Thus, on the ground of
maintainability the petition should have been
dismissed.”
(2006)
SCC
–
Para
(Maintainability)(Union of India & Ors. -vs- Ranbir Singh
Rathaur & Ors.)
“42. On a bare reading of the High Court's order
and the averments in the writ petitions, one thing is
crystal clear that there was no definite allegation
against any person who was responsible for the socalled manipulation. It is also not clear as to who
were the parties in the writ petitions filed. In the
grounds indicated in the writ petitions it was stated
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 37
that there is no bar or impediment on the High
Court reviewing the petitioner's case as also
connected cases to enquire into the validity of the
acts done against the writ petitioner. Therefore, it
was an accepted position that the writ petitioners
wanted review of the High Court's order, which is
clearly impermissible. No ground for seeking such
review apparently was made out. In any event we
feel that the High Court's approach is clearly
erroneous. The present appellants in the
counter-affidavit
filed
had
raised
a
preliminary objection as regards the
maintainability of the writ petitions and had
requested the High Court to grant further
opportunity if the necessity so arises to file a
detailed
counter-affidavit
after
the
preliminary objections were decided. The
High Court in fact in one of the orders clearly
indicated that the preliminary objections were
to be decided first. But strangely it did not do
so. It reserved the judgment and delivered
the final judgment after about three years.
There is also dispute as to whether the
relevant documents were produced. What
baffles us is that in the High Court, records
with original documents were shown to it and
the Bench wanted the copies to be filed. In
the impugned judgment the High Court
proceeded on the basis as if only a few pages
of the files were shown. If that was really the
case, there was no necessity for the High
Court to direct the present appellants to file
copies. If after perusal of the documents the
High Court felt that these were not sufficient
the same would have been stated. But that
does not appear to have been done. The High
Court also had not discussed as to how the
matters which stood concluded could be
reopened in the manner done. No sufficient
grounds have been even indicated as to why
the High Court felt it necessary to do so. To
say that though finality had been achieved,
justice stood at a higher pedestal is not an
answer to the basic question as to whether
the High Court was competent to reopen the
whole issue which had become concluded.
The persons whom the High Court felt were
responsible for alleged manipulation or
persons behind false implication were not
impleaded as parties. Newspaper reports are
not to be considered as evidence. The
authenticity of the newspaper reports was not
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 38
established by the writ petitioners. Even
otherwise, this could not have been done in a
writ petition, as disputed questions of fact
were apparently involved. The matters which
the High Court found to have been
established were really not so. The
conclusions were based on untested
materials, and the writ petitioners had not
established them by evidence. Since the High
Court has not dealt with the matter in the
proper perspective we feel that it would be
proper for the High Court to rehear the
matter. The High Court shall first decide the
preliminary objections raised by the present
appellants about the non-maintainability of
the writ petitions. Normally such a course is not
to be adopted. But in view of the peculiar facts
involved, it would be the appropriate course to be
adopted in the present case. Therefore, we remit
the matter to the High Court for fresh hearing. We
make it clear that whatever we have observed
should not be treated to be the conclusive findings
on the subject-matter of controversy. The appeals
are allowed without any order as to costs. Since the
matter is pending since long, we request the High
Court to dispose of the matter as early as
practicable, preferably within four months from the
date of receipt of the judgment. No costs.”
16.
That it is most respectfully begs to submit that in
addition to the above disputed question of facts, there is a
breach of trust and violation of the terms of the Contract
Agreement and the same is to be settled as per Clause No.
25 of the Contract Agreement dated 8.6.2021 (Annexure
A/5 to the writ petition) which states as follows:
“Clause 25 – Settlement of Disputes & Arbitration Except where otherwise provided in the contract, all
questions and disputes relating to the meaning of
the specifications, design, drawings and Instructions
here-In-before mentioned and as to the quality of
workmanship or materials used on the work or as to
any other question, claim, right, matter or thing
whatsoever in any way arising out of or relating to
the contract, designs, drawings, specifications,
estimates, instructions, orders or these conditions or
otherwise concerning the works or the execution or
failure to execute the same whether arising during
the progress of the work or after the cancellation,
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 39
termination, completion or abandonment thereof
shall be dealt with as mentioned hereinafter.
I.
If the contractor considers any work
demanded of him to be outside the requirements of
the contract, or disputes any drawings, record or
decision given in writing by the Engineer-in- Charge
or if the Engineer-in-Charge considers any act or
decision of the contractor on any matter in
connection with or arising out of the contract or
carrying out of the work, to be unacceptable and is
disputed, such party shall promptly within 15 days
of the arising of the disputes request the chief
Engineer or where there is no Chief Engineer, the
Additional Director General (CE/ADG) who shall
refer the disputes to Dispute Redressal Committee
(DRC) within 15 days along with a list of disputes
with amounts claimed if any in respect of each such
dispute. The Dispute Redressal Committee (DRC)
give its decision within a period of 60 days
extendable by 30 days by consent of both the
parties from the receipt of reference from CE/ADG.
The constitution of Dispute Redressal Committee
(DRC) shall be as indicated in Schedule 'F'.
Provided that no party shall be represented before
the Dispute Redressal Committee by an
advocate/legal counsel etc.
The DRC will submit its decision to the Concerned
ADG/SDG for acceptance. ADG/SDG in a time limit
of 30 days from receipt of DRC decision will convey
acceptance or otherwise on the said decision. If the
Dispute Redressal Committee (DRC) fails to give its
decision within the aforesaid period or the
ADG/SDG fails to give his decision in the aforesaid
time limit or any party is dissatisfied with the
decision of Dispute Redressal Committee (DRC)/
ADG/ SDG the neither party may within a period of
30 days from the receipt of the decision of Dispute
Redressal Committee (DRC)/ADG/SDG or on expiry
of aforesaid the time limits available to
DRC/ADG/SDG, may give notice to the Chief
Engineer, Manipur PWD, or if there be no Chief
Engineer, the Additional Director General / Special
Director General concerned or if there be no
Additional Director General Special Director General
concerned of if there be no Additional Director
General / Special Director General, the Director
General, Manipur PWD for appointment of
arbitrator on prescribed proforma as per Appendix
XVII under intimation to the other party.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 40
It is a term of contract that each party
invoking arbitration must exhaust the aforesaid
mechanism of settlement of claims/disputes prior to
invoking arbitration.
The CE/ADG/DG shall in such case appoint
the sole arbitrator or one of the three arbitrators as
the case may be within 30 days of receipt of such a
request and refer such disputes to arbitration.
Wherever the Arbitral Tribunal consists of three
Arbitrators, the contractor shall appoint one
arbitrator within 30 days of making request for
arbitration or of receipt of request by Engineer-inCharge to CE/ADG/DG for appointment of
arbitrator, as the case may be, and two appointed
arbitrators shall appoint the third arbitrator who
shall act as the Presiding Arbitrator. In the event of
–
a.
b.
II.
A party fails to appoint the second Arbitrator,
or
The two appointed Arbitrators fail to appoint
the Presiding Arbitrator, then the Chief
Engineer, Manipur PWD shall appoint the
second or Presiding Arbitrator as the case may
be.
Disputes or difference shall be referred for
adjudication through arbitration by a Tribunal
having sole arbitrator where claimed amount is Rs.
20 crore or less. Where claimed value is more than
Rs. 20 crore, Tribunal shall consist of three
Arbitrators as above. The requirements of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996)
and any further statutory modifications or reenactment thereof and the rules made there under
and for the time being in force shall be applicable.
It is a term of this contract that the party
invoking arbitration shall give a list of disputes with
amounts claimed, if any, in respect of each such
dispute along with the notice for appointment of
arbitrator and giving reference to the decision of
ADG/SDG on the finding / recommendation of DRC.
It is also a term of this contract that any
member of the Arbitration Tribunal shall be a
Graduate Engineer with experience in handling
public works engineering and further he shall have
earlier worked at a level not lower than Chief
Engineer/ equivalent (i.e. Joint Secretary level of
Government of India). This shall be treated as a
mandatory qualification to be appointed as
arbitrator.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 41
Parties, before or at the time of appointment
of Arbitral Tribunal may agree in writing for fasttrack arbitration as per the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996) as amended in
2015.
Subject to provision In the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996) as amended in
2015 whereby the counter claims if any can be
directly filed before the arbitrator without any
requirement of reference by the appointing
authority, the arbitrator shall adjudicate on only
such disputes as are referred to him by the
appointing authority and give separate award
against each dispute and claim referred to him and
in all cases where the total amount of the claims by
any party exceeds Rs. 1,00,000/-, the arbitrator
shall give reasons for the award.
It is also a term of the contract that fees
payable to the arbitral tribunal shall be as approved
by Chief Engineer, PWD, Manipur. This fee shall be
shared equally by parties.
The place of arbitration shall be as
mentioned in Schedule F. In case there is no
mention of place of arbitration, the arbitral tribunal
shall determine the place of arbitration.
The venue of the arbitration shall be such
place as may be fixed by the Arbitral Tribunal in
consultation with both the parties. Failing any such
agreement, then the Arbitral Tribunal shall decide
the venue.”
It is further humbly begged to submit that in this
regard, the State Applicants relied upon the decision
rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Union of India
&Ors. -vs- Puna Hinda reported in (2021) 10 SCC 690 –
Para 24, which reads as follows –
“24. Therefore, the dispute could not be raised by
way of a writ petition on the disputed questions of
fact. Though, the jurisdiction of the High Court is
wide but in respect of pure contractual matters in
the field of private law, having no statutory flavour,
are better adjudicated upon by the forum agreed to
by the parties. The dispute as to whether the
amount is payable or not and/or how much amount
is payable are disputed questions of facts. There is
no admission on the part of the appellants to infer
that the amount stands crystallised. Therefore, in
the absence of any acceptance of joint survey report
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 42
by the competent authority, no right would accrue
to the writ petitioner only because measurements
cannot be undertaken after passage of time. Maybe,
the resurvey cannot take place but the
measurement books of the work executed from time
to time would form a reasonable basis for assessing
the amount due and payable to the writ petitioner,
but such process could be undertaken only by
the agreed forum i.e. arbitration and not by
the writ court as it does not have the
expertise in respect of measurements or
construction of roads.”
17.
That the State Applicants most respectfully begs to
submit that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in catena of Cases
has decided that the judgments passed by Courts without
jurisdiction is nullify. The State Applicants relied upon the
case of Harshad Chiman Lal Modi -versus- DLF Universal
Ltd. & Anr reported in (2005) 7 SCC 791 Para No. 33.
Relevant portion is being reproduced hereunder –
“33. In Kiran Singh v. Chaman Paswan [(1955) 1
SCR 117 : AIR 1954 SC 340] this Court declared :
(SCR p. 121)
“It is a fundamental principle well established
that a decree passed by a court without
jurisdiction is a nullity, and that its invalidity
could be set up whenever and wherever it is sought
to be enforced or relied upon, even at the stage of
execution and even in collateral proceedings. A
defect of jurisdiction … strikes at the very authority
of the court to pass any decree, and such a defect
cannot be cured even by consent of parties.”
(emphasis supplied)
18.
In the fact and circumstances, there is disputed
question of fact involved in the present case and this
Hon’ble Court has no jurisdiction to deal the same. On the
other hand, the question of breach of Contract Agreement is
also involved herein and the same has to be dealt under the
Clause 25 provided in the Contract Agreement. And
importantly,
the
work
involved
herein
is
of
public
importance and the interim order dated 1.8.2023 and its
subsequent orders are liable to be vacated/ modified.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 43
In conclusion, the interim Order dated 1.8.2023 and its
subsequent orders are liable to be vacated/ modified and
the writ petition deserves to be dismissed for the ends of
justice.”
[24]
Written submissions submitted on behalf of
the respondent/petitioner in WP(C) No. 358 of
2023:
“1. The present writ petition has been preferred on behalf
of the Petitioner against the illegal termination of the work
for Construction of Capital Complex (Civil Secretariat
Component) at Mantripukhri, Imphal–Balance Work at
Imphal”-[Agreement No.EE/BD-I/AGRT/2021-22/01dt. 0806-2021], (in Short “Civil Secretariat Balance Work”)
vide letter dated 11.04.2023 issued by the Executive
Engineer,
Building
Division
No.1,
PWD,
Manipur
("Respondent No. 3”). The said Civil Secretariat Balance
Work was executed by the Petitioner as per the said
agreement. It is imperative to submit here that there is no
disputed question of facts under challenge or any such
prayer in the captioned writ petition.
2. [The present written arguments are filed in addition to
the oral arguments made on behalf of the Sri Avantika
Contractors (I) Ltd (“Petitioner”), as per the liberty
granted
by
this
Hon’ble
Court
vide
Order
dated
29.01.2024, passed in the above-mentioned matter.]
3. For the convenience of this Hon’ble Court, a chronological
list of relevant dates and events as set out as under:
08.06.2021-The Agreement No. EE/BD-I/AGRT/2021-22/01
dt.08.06.2021- Civil Secretariat Balance Work
was executed between the petitioner and the
Respondent No.3. The accepted amount of
the work was Rs.167,40,96,700.38 (Rupees
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 44
One hundred sixty seven crore forty lakh
ninety six thousand seven hundred and
thirty-eight paisa only) and the stipulated
time period for completion of work was 12
months (2.6.2021 to 1.6.2022)[A/5 Pg. 53
to 62].
24.05.2022 - Respondent No.3 vide Letter No. EE/BDI/Civil Sectt/2021-22/196, dated 24.5.2022
granted provisional time extension of the
said work upto 30-09-2022 in accordance
with the provisions of Clause 5 of MPWD
General Conditions of Contract 2020 of the
said
agreement
dated
8.6.2021.(A/11,
Pg.101).
The petitioner continued to execute the work
within the extended period and beyond also,
which was in the knowledge of the PWD and
RA bills were also paid during the said period.
2022 -
In the meantime, the delay in completing the
Civil Secretariat Balance Work, was also a
subject matter of a Public Interest Litigation
i.e. PIL No. 34 of 2022 filed before the
Hon’ble High Court of Manipur. In the said
PIL, a prayer was made for directing the
respondents therein i.e., the State and the
petitioner
herein
to
complete
the
balance/remaining work for construction of
Capital
Complex
(Civil
Secretariat
Component) at Mantripukhri, Imphal, so that
the existing Manipur Secretariat may be
shifted to the new building and there is no
traffic congestion in front of the old existing
Manipur Secretariat at Babupara, Imphal.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 45
4.4.2023 -
After hearing the parties, the Hon’ble Division
Bench of the High Court of Manipur by a
judgment
and
order
dated
04.04.2023
disposed off the said PIL No. 34 of 2022 with
the following directions given below:
“......
25. Considering the facts and circumstances
of the case and the larger public interest
involved, the PIL No.34 of 2022 is disposed
of with the following directions:
(i) The respondent State is directed to
decongest the traffic on the National Highway
in front of the Old Manipur Secretariat by
making arrangements for proper park of
vehicles on both sides. Further, the
respondent State is directed to strictly
enforce the traffic rules to ensure illegal
parked vehicles are booked.
(ii) The respondent State and the fourth
respondent are directed to comply with their
contractual obligations qua the completion of
construction of Civil Secretariat work.
(iii) The respondent State is directed to pay
the Outstanding dues as per the RA Bills
raised by the respondent No. 4 and also
approve the rates of deviations and extra
items regarding the Civil Secretariat work at
earliest.
(iv) The respondent State and the fourth
respondent are directed to co-operate and
work in concert with each other to ensure
that the Civil Secretariat work is to be
completed within a period of three months
from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.
(v) There will be no order as to costs.
…............................”
[A/21, Pg.205-220]
11.04.2023 - To the shock and surprise of the petitioner,
the Executive Engineer, PWD issued Letter
No. EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2022-23/169 dated
11.04.2023, whereby the Final action under
Clause 3 of the aforesaid agreement was
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 46
taken by terminating the said Agreement
dt. 08.06.2021[A/22, Pg. 221-224].
12.04.2023 - The petitioner gave a reply letter dated
12.04.2023
to
the
said
letter
dated
11.04.2023 wherein inter-alia it was stated
that the department had not fulfilled its
fundamental obligations and therefore, had
committed
fundamental
breach
of
the
Agreement. Further, it was stated that a
conjoint interpretation of all the above
admitted reasons the starting of work was
hampered due to several delays, defaults
and breach of contract committed by the
department and thus the provisions under
Clause- 3 of Clauses of Contract cannot be
invoked
and
withdrawal
of
accordingly
prayed
termination
letter
for
dated
11.04.2023.[A/23, Pg. 225-227].
18.04.2023 - The Petitioner herein filed the captioned writ
petition before this Hon’ble Court as there
was no response from the Respondents
regarding the reply-letter dated 12.04.2023,
praying
inter-alia
for
quashing
the
termination order dated 11.04.2023 and to
allow resumption of Civil Secretariat Balance
work. [Prayers at pages 18-20]
12.06.2023 - The Respondent herein preferred a Review
Petition bearing Review Petition No. 11 of
2023 before the Division Bench against the
final judgment and order dated 04.04.2023,
passed in PIL No. 34 of 2023. This Hon’ble
Court in its order dated 12.06.2023 observed
that “The petitioners has filed this review
petition with a grievance only in para 25(iii)
of the order dated 04.04.2023 passed in PIL
No. 34 of 2022.”
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 47
01.08.2023 - This
Hon’ble
Court
vide
order
dated
01.08.2023, directed the Respondent to
conduct a joint measurement and to submit a
report. [M/2, Pg 16 -48]
01.08.2023 - This Hon’ble Court vide order dated
01.08.2023 directed the parties to maintain
the status quo till the joint measurement
report. [M/3, Pg.49].
However, the status quo order was extended
from time to time in the interest of justice.
07.11.2023 - The Respondent preferred an application
bearing MC (WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023,
praying inter-alia vacation of the status quo
order passed by this Hon’ble Court vide order
dated
01.08.2023
and
its
subsequent
extensions orders.
22.11.2023 - The Petitioner herein preferred a contempt
petition bearing Contempt Petition No.
120 of 2023 against the respondents herein
and this Hon’ble Court vide order dated
22.11.2023 was pleased to issue notice in the
above said contempt petition. Further, the
same is pending for adjudication.
11.01.2024 - After notice was issued in the contempt
petition,
the
respondent
preferred
an
application bearing MC (Rev. Pet.) No. 01
of 2024, praying for the modification of the
order dated 12.06.2023 passed in the Review
Petition and allowing the Respondent to press
all the prayers as prayed.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 48
17.01.2024 - This Hon’ble Court vide order issued notice in
the MC (Rev. Pet.) No. 01 of 2024.
That, this Hon’ble High Court after hearing the
4.
Parties, had at this juncture had confined itself in
adjudicating the following 2 (two) questions which
are set out below:
I.
Whether
the
present
writ
petition
is
maintainable or not due to the disputed
question of facts involved in the present case?
II.
Whether the interim orders dated 01.08.2023,
09.10.2023 and subsequent extension orders
passed in the instant writ petition i.e., W.P.(C)
No. 385 of 2023 ought to be vacated/modified
or not?
III.
Whether the present writ petition is
maintainable or not due to the disputed
question of facts involved in the present
case?
5.
The present writ petition does not challenge any
disputed questions of facts nor does it involve any such
disputes. The petitioner solely challenges the legality and
validity of the termination letter dated 11.04.2024, through
which the respondent terminated the agreement dated
08.06.2021.The said termination letter is also violative of
the direction in the judgment and order dated 04.04.2023
passed by the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in Para
25(iv).
6.
The termination of the agreement dated 08.06.2021
is alleged to be driven by malafide intentions, infringing
upon the rights of the petitioner guaranteed under Article
14, 19(1)(g), and 21 of the Constitution of India. Despite
the obligation to act with fairness, reasonableness, and in
accordance with the law, the respondent authorities acted
capriciously, thereby causing prejudice to the petitioner's
rights.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 49
7.
Additionally, the present writ petition incorporates
a public law element in public law field that encompasses
the interest of the public at large. It is a well-established
legal principle that when an individual is aggrieved by the
violation of fundamental rights and the cardinal principles
of natural justice committed by a statutory authority, the
remedy in the form of a writ under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India cannot be denied. Reliance is placed
on Cube Construction Engineers v. State of Gujarat &Ors.,
SCA No. 11486 of 2021, whereby on relying on the ABL
International Ltd. v. Export Credit Guarantee Corporation
on India, (2004) 3 SCC 553, held that it is the obligation
of the High Court under Article 226, to enforce the
statutory duty of the state. The Hon’ble Supreme Court
vide order dated 31-7-2023 in SLP (C) Diary No.
24511/2023 was please to dismiss the SLP filed against
the said judgment.
8.
That, having an arbitration clause in the agreement,
does not bar the petitioner from invocation of the writ
jurisdiction. In the case of Harbanslal Sahnia & Anr. v.
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd &Ors., (2003) 2 SCC 107, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court emphasized that the High Court can
entertain a writ petition despite the availability of an
alternate remedy if certain conditions are met, including: i)
enforcement of fundamental rights; ii) failure of principles
of natural justice; iii) the impugned order being wholly
without jurisdiction; or iv) challenging the vires of the act.
That the said judgment was also upheld by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Union of India &Ors. v. Tantia
Constructions, (2011) 5 SCC 697, U.P. Power Transmission
Corporation Ltd. v. CG Power and Industrial Solutions Ltd.,
(2021) 6 SCC 15, Unitech Limited &Ors. v. Telangana State
Industrial Infrastructure Corporation, (2021) 16 SCC 35, and
M.P. Power Management Company Ltd. v. Sky Power
Southeast Solar India Private Ltd. &Ors., (2023) 2 SCC 703.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 50
9.
In the present case, the action taken by the
Respondent Department suffers from manifest, arbitrariness
and violates the cardinal principals of natural justice. That
the Petitioner herein is seeking the enforcement of rights
under Article 14, 19(1)(g), and 21, citing a violation of the
principles of natural justice.
10.
That relief sought by the Petitioner through the
instant writ petition falls outside the scope and jurisdiction
of arbitration. Consequently, the alternative forum would
not be capable of providing the appropriate relief,
specifically the invocation of the writ of certiorari and
mandamus against the respondent State. Reliance is placed
on the Hon’ble Supreme Court judgment titled as Sanajana
M. Wig v. Hindustan Petro Corporation Ltd. (2005) 8 SCC
242.
11.
It is respectfully submitted that the writ petitioner
had relied upon the various judgments of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India, where it was held that a writ
petition can be maintained in a contractual manner in the
following alternative scenarios, despite existence of an
arbitration clauses:
a)
The lis involves a public law character or
requires a judicial determination in rem;
b)
The alternate forum chosen by the parties
would
not
be
in
a
position
to
grand
appropriate relief;
c)
A statutory contract is in question or the
action of a State or its instrumentality is
demonstrably
arbitrary,
unreasonable
or
violative of the fundamental rights of a party;
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 51
d)
The matter does not relate only to the
interpretation of a contract, which is within
the domain of an arbitrator.
12.
Hence, in light of the aforesaid submission, the
present petition is maintainable under Article 226 of the
Indian Constitution whereby, petitioner is seeking an
enforcement of a fundamental right and the lis involves
public law character.
I.
Whether
the
interim
orders
dated
01.08.2023, 09.10.2023 and subsequent
extension orders passed in the instant
writ petition i.e., W.P.(C) No. 385 of 2023
ought to be vacated/modified or not?
II.
It is respectfully submitted that interim order in
the present matters was passed based on the
settled principles taking into account the three
basic grounds i.e., prima facie case, balance of
convenience
and
irreparable
loss
in
the
particular facts and circumstance of the case.
III. In the instant case, firstly prima facie case
favors the petitioner, given the substantial
completion of a significant portion of the work.
Moreover,
this
Hon’ble
Court,
through
a
judgment and final order dated 04.04.2023,
disposed of PIL No. 34 of 2022 after hearing
both parties and considering the specific facts
of the case. In this order, the Hon’ble Court
directed
the
respondent
State
and
the
petitioner herein to complete the work within
a period of 3 (three) months. Despite these
explicit directions, the Department arbitrarily
and
unlawfully
terminated
the
work
on
11.04.2023 within a week. The present writ is
filed to enforce a fundamental right, and
considering the public law character of the
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 52
dispute, it was admitted as a prima facie case
was established from the outset.
IV. Secondly, the balance of convenience distinctly
favors
the
petitioner,
considering
the
substantial time and financial resources already
invested in executing the work, which is now
approaching completion. The arbitrary and
illegal termination of the Civil Secretariat
Balance work not only poses significant financial
loss to the petitioner but also further delays in
the project's completion, leading to additional
losses to the public exchequer. Moreover, it is
emphasized that if the interim order is vacated,
the present matter would become infructuous.
Therefore, the balance of convenience leans in
favor of the Petitioner.
V.
Thirdly, petitioner is poised to suffer irreparable
loss due to the arbitrary and illegal termination,
evident in the idleness of its machinery and
materials at the work site. This idle period has
caused further delays in the ongoing works
and, additionally, impacts other projects of the
petitioner. The potential irreparable loss, which
cannot be fully compensated in monetary
terms, necessitated the granting of the interim
order.
Consequently,
this
Hon’ble
Court,
recognizing the urgency and potential harm to
the petitioner, passed an interim order dated
01.08.2023 in favor of the petitioner. This
interim relief not only addresses the immediate
concerns but also contributes to securing the
final relief sought by the petitioner in the writ
petition.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 53
VI. Therefore, the three cardinal principles i.e.,
prima facie case; balance of convenience; and
irreparable injury, which are required to be
considered in a proper perspective in the facts
and circumstances of a particular case for
granting the interim relief, lies in the favor of
the Petitioner.
VII. That the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
the case of Zenit Mataplast (P) Ltd vs State of
Maharashtra, (2009)10 SCC 388 and Benedict
Denis Kinny v. Tulip Brian Miranda & Ors.,
(2021) 12 SCC 780, held that the interim relief
is passed as a temporary arrangement to
preserve the status quo till the matter is
decided finally, to ensure that the matter does
not become either infructuous or a fait
accompli before the final hearing. Therefore,
the object of granting interim relief is, to
protect
the
petitioner
against
injury
by
violation of his right for which he could not be
adequately
compensated
in
damages
recoverable in the action.
VIII. Furthermore, it is noteworthy to mention here
that the order dated 01.08.2023, instructing
both the petitioner and Respondent No. 3 to
uphold the status quo, was issued in public
interest. Additionally, failure to grant the
status quo by this Hon’ble Court would allow
the Respondent department to establish thirdparty rights, leading to substantial delays in
the completion of the said project.
IX. Furthermore, the judgment and final order
dated 04.04.2023 passed by the Division Bench
of this Hon’ble Court has not been challenged
by the respondent before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court and thereby it has attained finality.
Hence, the Single Bench of this Hon’ble should
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 54
maintain the judicial discipline and cannot
bypass the judgment and final order dated
04.04.2023,
passed by
the larger bench.
Reliance is placed on Official Liquidator v.
Dayanand, (2008) 10 SCC 1, passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
X.
That recently the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of N.G. Projects Ltd. v. Vinod Kumar
Jain&Ors., (2022) 6 SCC 127 (“NG Projects”),
while adjudicating the similar issue, set aside
the termination by the State and directed the
state to allow the contractor to resume and
complete the work by excluding the period
spent in the stay of execution of the contract.
Relevant excerpt of the judgment is reproduced
herein below:
“25. In view thereof, we find that the
action of the respondent in setting aside
the letter of acceptance granted to the
appellant suffers from manifest illegality
and cannot be sustained. Consequently,
the appeal is disposed of with a direction
to the respondent State to allow the
appellant to resume and complete the
work by excluding the period spent in the
stay of execution of the contract.”
XI.
Therefore, the relief of status quo vide order dated
01.08.2023, was granted by this Hon’ble Court after relying
on the above said three cardinal principles, which lies in
favour of the petitioner herein. Therefore, the interim
orders dated 01.08.2023, 09.10.2023 and subsequent
extension orders passed in the instant writ petition i.e.,
W.P.(C) No. 385 of 2023, cannot be vacated or modified.
Conclusions/Relief:
In
the
light
of
the
above
submissions, it is respectfully submitted that the instant writ
petition is maintainable under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India and further petitioner has satisfied the three
cardinal principles, upon which this Hon’ble Court has
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 55
granted
the
interim
relief.
Therefore,
miscellaneous
application bearing MC(W.P.(C)) No.357 of 2023, may be
dismissed and the instant writ petition bearing W.P.(C) No.
358 of 2023, may be heard on merits for final disposal.
Furthermore, it is essential to note here that, three
cardinal principles strongly support the petitioner’s case and
as per the directions passed in NG Project Supra, the
termination letter dated 11.04.2023 should be quashed.
Additionally, the Respondent must be directed to allow the
Petitioner to resume work and complete the project in the
broader interest of the public and without infringing upon
the Petitioner's fundamental rights”.
Learned counsel for the respondent/petitioner relied upon the
following Hon’ble Supreme Court judgments in support of his case;
SCA
No.
11486
of
(Cube
construction
Engineers Vs. State of Gujarat &Ors.)
SLP (C) Diary No. 24511 of 2023 (The Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
State
of
Gujarat
vs
Cube
Construction Engineering Ltd. &Ors., SLP (C) Diary
NO. 24511 of 2023, Vide order dated 31.07.2023
dismiss SLP.)
(2003) 2 SCC 107 – (HarbanslalSahnia and AnrVs.
Indian Oil Corp. Ltd. &Ors).
“7. So far as the view taken by the High Court that the
remedy by way of recourse to arbitration clause was
available to the appellants and therefore the writ petition
filed by the appellants was liable to be dismissed is
concerned, suffice it to observe that the rule of exclusion of
writ jurisdiction by availability of an alternative remedy is a
rule of discretion and not one of compulsion. In an
appropriate case, in spite of availability of the alternative
remedy, the High Court may still exercise its writ jurisdiction
in at least three contingencies: (i) where the writ petition
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 56
seeks enforcement of any of the fundamental rights; (ii)
where there is failure of principles of natural justice; or (iii)
where the orders or proceedings are wholly without
jurisdiction or the vires of an Act is challenged. (See
Whirlpool Corpn. v. Registrar of Trade Marks.) The present
case attracts applicability of the first two contingencies.
Moreover, as noted, the petitioners' dealership, which is
their bread and butter, came to be terminated for an
irrelevant and non-existent cause. In such circumstances,
we feel that the appellants should have been allowed relief
by the High Court itself instead of driving them to the need
of initiating arbitration proceedings.”
(2011) 5 SCC 697 – (Union of India & Ors. Vs Tantia
constructions).
“33. Apart from the above, even on the question of
maintainability of the writ petition on account of the
arbitration clause included in the agreement between the
parties, it is now well established that an alternative remedy
is not an absolute bar to the invocation of the writ
jurisdiction of the High Court or the Supreme Court and
that without exhausting such alternative remedy, a writ
petition would not be maintainable. The various decisions
cited by Mr. Chakraborty would clearly indicate that the
constitutional powers vested in the High Court or the
Supreme Court cannot be fettered by any alternative
remedy available to the authorities. Injustice, whenever and
wherever it takes place, has to be struck down as an
anathema to the rule of law and the provisions of the
Constitution.”
(2021) 6 SCC 15 – U.P. Power Transmission Corpn.
Ltd Vs CG Power and Industrial Solutions Ltd.)
“66. Even though there is an arbitration clause, the
petitioner herein has not opposed the writ petition on the
ground of existence of an arbitration clause. There is no
whisper of any arbitration agreement in the counteraffidavit filed by UPPTCL to the writ petition in the High
Court. In any case, the existence of an arbitration clause
does not debar the court from entertaining a writ petition.”
(2021) 16 SCC 35 – (Unitech Limited & Ors. Vs
Telangana
State
Industrial
Infrastructure
Corporation)
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 57
“38. Much of the ground which was sought to be canvassed
in the course of the pleadings is now subsumed in the
submissions which have been urged before this Court on
behalf of the State of Telangana and TSIIC. As we have
noted earlier, during the course of the hearing, the learned
Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the State of
Telangana and ISIIC informed the Court that the
entitlement of Unitech to seek a refund is not questioned
nor is the availability of the land for carrying out the project
being placed in issue. The learned Senior Counsel also did
not agitate the ground that a remedy for the recovery of
moneys arising out a contractual matter cannot be availed
of under Article 226 of the Constitution. However, to clear
the ground, it is necessary to postulate that recourse to the
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution is not
excluded altogether in a contractual matter. A public law
remedy is available for enforcing legal rights subject to wellsettled parameters.
39. A two-Judge Bench of this Court in ABL International
Ltd. v. Export Credit Guarantee Corpn. of India Ltd. 14 [ABL
International] analysed a long line of precedent of this
Court is to conclude that writs under Article 226 are
maintainable for asserting contractual rights against the
State, or its instrumentalities, as defined under Article 12 of
the Indian Constitution.
39.1. Speaking through N. Santosh Hegde, J. the Court
held: (ABL International casela, SCC p. 572, para 27)
"27.... the following legal principles emerge as to the
maintainability of a writ petition:
(a)
(b)
(c)
In an appropriate case, a writ petition as
against a State or an instrumentality of
a State arising out of a contractual
obligation is maintainable.
Merely
because
some
disputed
questions of fact arise for consideration,
same cannot be a ground to refuse to
entertain a writ petition in all cases as a
matter of rule.
A writ petition involving a consequential
relief of monetary claim is also
maintainable."
This exposition has been followed by this Court, and
has been adopted by the three-Judge Bench decisions of
this Court in State of U.P. v. Sudhir Kumar Singh and
Popatrao Vyankatrao Patil v. State of Maharashtra.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 58
39.2. The decision in ABL International, cautions that the
plenary power under Article 226 must be used with
circumspection when other remedies have been provided by
the contract. But as a statement of principle, the jurisdiction
under Article 226 is not excluded in contractual matters.
39.3. Article 23.1 of the development agreement in the
present case mandates the parties to resolve their disputes
through an arbitration. However, the presence of an
arbitration clause within a contract between a State
instrumentality and a private party has not acted as an
absolute bar to availing remedies under Article 226,
39.4. If the State instrumentality violates its constitutional
mandate under Article 14 to act fairly and reasonably, relief
under the plenary powers of Article 226 of the Constitution
would lie. This principle was recognised in ABL
International14: (ABL International case, SCC p. 572, para
28)
"28. However, while entertaining an objection as to
the maintainability of a writ petition under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, the court should
bear in mind the fact that the power to issue
prerogative writs under Article 226 of the
Constitution is plenary in nature and is not limited
by any other provisions of the Constitution. The
High Court having regard to the facts of the case,
has a discretion to entertain or not to entertain a
writ petition. The Court has imposed upon itself
certain restrictions in the exercise of this power.
(See Whirlpool Corpn. v. Registrar of Trade Marks.)
And this plenary right of the High Court to issue a
prerogative writ will not normally be exercised by
the Court to the exclusion of other available
remedies unless such action of the State or its
instrumentality is arbitrary and unreasonable so as
to violate the constitutional mandate of Article 14 or
for other valid and legitimate reasons, for which the
Court thinks it necessary to exercise the said
jurisdiction."
39.5. Therefore, while exercising its jurisdiction under
Article 226, the Court is entitled to enquire into whether the
action of the State or its instrumentalities is arbitrary or
unfair and in consequence, in violation of Article 14. The
jurisdiction under Article 226 is a valuable constitutional
safeguard against an arbitrary exercise of State power or a
misuse of authority.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 59
39.6. In determining as to whether the jurisdiction should
be exercised in a contractual dispute, the Court must,
undoubtedly eschew, disputed questions of fact which
would depend upon an evidentiary determination requiring
a trial. But equally, it is well settled that the jurisdiction
under Article 226 cannot be ousted only on the basis that
the dispute pertains to the contractual arena. This is for the
simple reason that the State and its instrumentalities are
not exempt from the duty to act fairly merely because in
their business dealings they have entered into the realm of
contract. Similarly, the presence of an arbitration clause
does (sic not) oust the jurisdiction under Article 226 in all
cases though, it still needs to be decided from case to case
as to whether recourse to a public law remedy can
justifiably be invoked.
39.7. The jurisdiction under Article 226 was rightly invoked
by the Single Judge and the Division Bench of the Andhra
Pradesh High Court in this case, when the foundational
representation of the contract has failed. TSIIC, a State
instrumentality, has not just reneged on its contractual
obligation, but hoarded the refund of the principal and
interest on the consideration that was paid by Unitech over
a decade ago. It does not dispute the entitlement of
Unitech to the refund of its principal.
40. In the present case, the basic postulate underlying the
contract between the parties was the availability of the land
which comprised the project site. The LoA dated 28-112007 stated that the allotment of land was subject to the
outcome of the pending appeal before the High Court of
Andhra Pradesh. The dispute over the title of the
Government of Andhra Pradesh was the subject of the
pending litigation. At the same time, the LoA mandated that
Unitech must pay the amount stipulated including the
purchase price of Rs. 145 crores for the land as well as the
project development expenses. A failure to do so would
constitute a significant event of default resulting in a
forfeiture of the earnest money deposit. Acting on the LoA,
Unitech did in fact comply with its obligation to pay, having
paid a total amount of Rs. 165 crores towards the purchase
price, besides the earnest money deposit and project
development expenses. The development agreement which
was executed between APIIC and Unitech contains specific
representations to the effect that APIIC was authorised to
transfer and deliver the project site admeasuring 350 acres
on an outright sale basis. Under the development
agreement, APIIC was to sell and transfer the land
absolutely together with its right, title and interest, free
from all encumbrances by executing a sale agreement. The
terms of the agreement were to prevail in the event of any
conflict with any other document which formed a part of the
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 60
bidding process. The terms of the agreement were placed
on the pedestal of the highest priority for interpretation, as
compared to other documents, including the LoA. Under the
terms of the development agreement, APIIC was obligated
to sell and transfer the land together with its right, title and
interest free from all encumbrances "forthwith upon
payment of the last instalment of the total purchase price
by the developer". That Unitech paid the total purchase
price is not in dispute. The obligation assumed by APIIC to
hand over possession together with title upon the payment
of the last instalment of the purchase price unequivocally
emerges from Article 3.1 and Article 4.1 of the development
agreement. The fulfilment of the terms of the agreement
was postulated on the availability of the land.
(2023)
SCC
–M.P.
Power
Management
Company Ltd Vs. Sky Power Southeast Solar India
Private Ltd. &Ors)
“82. We may cull out our conclusions in regard to the
points, which we have framed:
82.1. It is, undoubtedly, true that the writ jurisdiction is a
public law remedy. A matter, which lies entirely within a
private realm of affairs of public body, may not lend itself
for being dealt with under the writ jurisdiction of the Court.
82.2. The principle laid down in Bareilly Development
Authority that in the case of a non-statutory contract the
rights are governed only by the terms of the contract and
the decisions, which are purported to be followed, including
Radhakrishna Agarwal, may not continue to hold good, in
the light of what has been laid down in ABL and as followed
in the recent judgment in Sudhir Kumar Singh.
82.3. The mere fact that relief is sought under a contract
which is not statutory, will not entitle the respondent State
in a case by itself to ward off scrutiny of its action or
inaction under the contract, if the complaining party is able
to establish that the action/inaction is, per se, arbitrary.
82.4. An action will lie, undoubtedly, when the State
purports to award any largesse and, undoubtedly, this
relates to the stage prior to the contract being entered into
(see Ramana Dayaram Shetty). This scrutiny, no doubt,
would be undertaken within the nature of the judicial
review, which has been declared in the decision in Tata
Cellular v. Union of India.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 61
82.5. After the contract is entered into, there can be a
variety of circumstances, which may provide a cause of
action to a party to the contract with the State, to seek
relief by filing a writ petition.
82.6. Without intending to be exhaustive, it may include the
relief of seeking payment of amounts due to the aggrieved
party from the State. The State can, indeed, be called upon
to honour its obligations of making payment, unless it be
that there is a serious and genuine dispute raised relating to
the liability of the State to make the payment. Such dispute,
ordinarily, would include the contention that the aggrieved
party has not fulfilled its obligations and the Court finds that
such a contention by the State is not a mere ruse or a
pretence.
82.7. The existence of an alternate remedy, is,
undoubtedly, a matter to be borne in mind in declining relief
in a writ petition in a contractual matter. Again, the
question as to whether the writ petitioner must be told off
the gates, would depend upon the nature of the claim and
relief sought by the petitioner, the questions, which would
have to be decided, and, most importantly, whether there
are disputed questions of fact, resolution of which is
necessary, as an indispensable prelude to the grant of the
relief sought. Undoubtedly, while there is no prohibition, in
the writ court even deciding disputed questions of fact,
particularly when the dispute surrounds demystifying of
documents only, the Court may relegate the party to the
remedy by way of a civil suit.
82.8. The existence of a provision for arbitration, which is a
forum intended to quicken the pace of dispute resolution, is
viewed as a near bar to the entertainment of a writ petition
[see in this regard, the view of this Court even in ABL1Q
explaining how it distinguished the decision of this Court in
State of U.P. v. Bridge & Roof Co. (India) Ltd., by its
observations in SCC para 14 in ABL].
82.9. The need to deal with disputed questions of fact,
cannot be made a smokescreen to guillotine a genuine
claim raised in a writ petition, when actually the resolution
of a disputed question of fact is unnecessary to grant relief
to a writ applicant.
82.10. The reach of Article 14 enables a writ court to deal
with arbitrary State action even after a contract is entered
into by the State. A wide variety of circumstances can
generate causes of action for invoking Article 14. The
Court's approach in dealing with the same, would be guided
by, undoubtedly, the overwhelming need to obviate
arbitrary State action, in cases where the writ remedy
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 62
provides an effective and fair means of preventing
miscarriage of justice arising from palpably unreasonable
action by the State.
82.11. Termination of contract can again arise in a wide
variety of situations. If for instance, a contract is
terminated, by a person, who is demonstrated, without any
need for any argument, to be the person, who is completely
unauthorised to cancel the contract, there may not be any
necessity to drive the party to the unnecessary ordeal of a
prolix and avoidable round of litigation. The intervention by
the High Court, in such a case, where there is no dispute to
be resolved, would also be conducive in public interest,
apart from ensuring the fundamental right of the petitioner
under Article 14 of the Constitution of India. When it comes
to a challenge to the termination of a contract by the State,
which is a non-statutory body, which is acting in purported
exercise of the powers/rights under such a contract, it
would be over simplifying a complex issue to lay down any
inflexible rule in favour of the Court turning away the
petitioner to alternate fora. Ordinarily, the cases of
termination of contract by the State, acting within its
contractual domain, may not lend itself for appropriate
redress by the writ court. This is, undoubtedly, so if the
Court is duty- bound to arrive at findings, which involve
untying knots, which are presented by disputed questions of
facts. Undoubtedly, in view of ABL, if resolving the dispute,
in a case of repudiation of a contract, involves only
appreciating the true scope of documentary material in the
light of pleadings, the Court may still grant relief to an
applicant. We must enter a caveat. The Courts are today
reeling under the weight of a docket explosion, which is
truly alarming. If a case involves a large body of documents
and the Court is called upon to enter upon findings of facts
and involves merely the construction of the document, it
may not be an unsound discretion to relegate the party to
the alternate remedy. This is not to deprive the Court of its
constitutional power as laid down in ABL. It all depends
upon the facts of each case as to whether, having regard to
the scope of the dispute to be resolved, whether the Court
will still entertain the petition.
82.12. In a case the State is a party to the contract and a
breach of a contract is alleged against the State, a civil
action in the appropriate forum is, undoubtedly,
maintainable. But this is not the end of the matter. Having
regard to the position of the State and its duty to act fairly
and to eschew arbitrariness in all its actions, resort to the
constitutional remedy on the cause of action, that the action
is arbitrary, is permissible (see in this regard Shrilekha
Vidyarthi v. State of U.P.). However, it must be made clear
that every case involving breach of contract by the State,
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 63
cannot be dressed up and disguised as a case of arbitrary
State action. While the concept of an arbitrary action or
inaction cannot be cribbed or confined to any immutable
mantra, and must be laid bare, with reference to the facts
of each case, it cannot be a mere allegation of breach of
contract that would suffice. What must be involved in the
case must be action/inaction, which must be palpably
unreasonable or absolutely irrational and bereft of any
principle. An action, which is completely mala fide, can
hardly be described as a fair action and may, depending on
the facts, amount to arbitrary action. The question must be
posed and answered by the Court and all we intend to lay
down is that there is a discretion available to the Court to
grant relief in appropriate cases.
82.13. A lodestar, which may illumine the path of the Court,
would be the dimension of public interest subserved by the
Court interfering in the matter, rather than relegating the
matter to the alternate forum.
82.14. Another relevant criteria is, if the Court has
entertained the matter, then, while it is not tabooed that
the Court should not relegate the party at a later stage,
ordinarily, it would be a germane consideration, which may
persuade the Court to complete what it had started,
provided it is otherwise a sound exercise of jurisdiction to
decide the matter on merits in the writ petition itself.
82.15. Violation of natural justice has been recognised as a
ground signifying the presence of a public law element and
can found a cause of action premised on breach of Article
14. (See Sudhir Kumar Singh).
88. Here we must understand the words "first milestone" as
fulfillment of the conditions subsequent. In regard to
fulfillment of said milestone for which there was a delay of
16 days in the case of Renew Clean Energy, there was a
delay of 54 days in the case of the first respondent. It is
further noticed by the High Court that there was an order
passed in favour of Renew Clean Energy setting aside the
termination of the contract in the said petitioner's case as
confirmed by this Court. Next the High Court went on to
record that there is a dispute as to whether the respondent
had commissioned the power project in the present case.
We notice that an attempt was made by the appellant to
justify the termination on the basis that the respondent had
not commissioned the power project within the time fixed.
The High Court proceeds to notice that the aspect of
commissioning the project was not the basis for terminating
the contract. Relying on Mohinder Singh Gill, the appellants
were not permitted to supplement the reasons for
termination. Finally, the High Court has proceeded to find
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 64
that since the similar reason for termination of the
agreement in the communication dated 11-8-2017 was not
found justified in Renew Clean Energy, the impugned
communication dated 11-8-2017 was set aside. It is
thereafter that the liberty was given to the appellants to
pass fresh orders in terms of the PPA in accordance with
law.”
(2005) 8 SCC 242 – Sanajana M. Wig Vs. Hindustan
Petro Corpn. Ltd.)
“13. However, access to justice by way of public law
remedy would not be denied when a lis involves public law
character and when the forum chosen by the parties would
not be in a position to grant appropriate relief.
18. It may be true that in a given case when an action of
the party is dehors the terms and conditions contained in an
agreement as also beyond the scope and ambit of the
domestic forum created therefore, the writ petition may be
held to be maintainable; but indisputably therefore such a
case has to be made out. It may also be true, as has been
held by this Court in Amritsar Gas Service and E.
Venkatakrishna that the arbitrator may not have the
requisite jurisdiction to direct restoration of distributorship
having regard to the provisions contained in Section 14 of
the Specific Relief Act, 1963; but while entertaining a writ
petition even in such a case, the court may not lose sight of
the fact that if a serious disputed question of fact is
involved arising out of a contract qua contract, ordinarily a
writ petition would not be entertained. A writ petition,
however, will be entertained when it involves a public law
character or involves a question arising out of public law
functions on the part of the respondent….”
(2009) 10 SCC 388 – (Zenit Mataplast (P) Ltd. Vs.
State of Maharashtra)
“27. Every action of the State or its instrumentalities should
not only be fair, legitimate and above-board but should be
without any affection or aversion. It should neither be
suggestive of discrimination nor even apparently give an
impression of bias, favouritism and nepotism. The decision
should be made by the application of known principles and
rules and in general such decision should be predictable and
the citizen should know where he is, but if a decision is
taken without any principle or without any rule, it is
unpredictable and such a decision is antithesis to the
decision taken in accordance with the rule of law (vide S.G.
Jaisinghani v. Union of India, AIR p. 1434, para 14 and Haji
T.M. Hassan Rawther v. Kerala Financial Corpn.).
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 65
30. Interim order is passed on the basis of prima facie
findings, which are tentative. Such order is passed as a
temporary arrangement to preserve the status quo till the
matter is decided finally, to ensure that the matter does not
become either infructuous or a fait accompli before the final
hearing. The object of the interlocutory injunction is to
protect the plaintiff against injury by violation of his right for
which he could not be adequately compensated in damages
recoverable in the action if the uncertainty were resolved in
his favour at the trial (vide Anand Prasad Agarwalla v.
Tarkeshwar Prasad, and State of Assam v. Barak Upatyaka
D.U. Karmachari Sanstha).
31. Grant of an interim relief in regard to the nature and
extent thereof depends upon the facts and circumstances of
each case as no straitjacket formula can be laid down.
There may be a situation wherein the respondent-defendant
may use the suit property in such a manner that the
situation becomes irretrievable. In such afact situation,
interim relief should be granted (vide M. Gurudas v.
Rasaranjan and Shridevi v. Muralidhar). Grant of temporary
injunction is governed by three basic principles i.e. prima
facie case; balance of convenience; and irreparable injury,
which are required to be considered in a proper perspective
in the facts and circumstances of a particular case. But it
may not be appropriate for any court to hold a mini-trial at
the stage of grant of temporary injunction [vide S.M.
Dyechem Ltd. v. Cadbury (India) Ltd. and Anand Prasad
Agarwalla, SCC p. 570, para 6].”
(2021) 12 SCC 780 – Benedict Denis Kinny Vs. Tulip
Brian Miranda &Ors.)
“36. The Delhi High Court judgment's conclusion in para 33(d)
was set aside. The Delhi High Court in para 33(d), which
judgment was impugned before this Court had laid down:
(Anur Kumar Jain case, SCC OnLine Del)
"33. In view of our aforesaid discussion, we proceed to
answer the reference on the following terms:
(d) Even if a petition under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure or a writ petition under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India is entertained by the High Court
under no circumstances an order of stay should be passed
regard being had to the prohibition contained in Section
19(3)(c) of the 1988 Act."
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 66
37. Nariman, J., ultimately after referring the judgment of L.
Chandra Kumar has set aside the conclusion of the Delhi High
Court in para 33(d). The above judgment, thus, laid down that
despite restraint in Section 19(3)(c) of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, the jurisdiction of the High Court to issue an
interim order is not precluded. This Court in the above case has
dealt with a situation when a statutory provision i.e. Section
19(3) (c) of the Prevention of Corruption Act creates a specific
bar in passing a stay order. When despite the aforesaid
statutory bar, the High Court was held to have jurisdiction to
pass an interim order, in the present case, we are concerned in
a statutory scheme where there is no express or implied bar in
passing an interim order by the High Court.
38. As per Section 5-B, a candidate belonging to reserved
category, who has made an application to the Scrutiny
Committee for issuance of validity certificate prior to date of
filing of nomination is obliged to submit the certificate within six
months from the date of election (now substituted by twelve
months), failing which his election shall be deemed to have
been terminated retrospectively. The second proviso to Section
5-B creates a deeming fiction, which operates when a person
failed to produce the validity certificate within a period of six
months/twelve months from the date of his election. The
present is a case where before expiry of period of six months
from the date of election i.e. 23-2-2017, the Caste Scrutiny
Committee has rejected the claim of the respondent and a writ
petition was filed by the respondent before expiry of period of
six months and the High Court also granted an interim order on
18-8- 2017 i.e. within a period of six months, after expiry of
which the deeming fiction was to come into existence. The
interim order was passed by the High Court before a deeming
fiction of termination of election retrospectively came into
operation. The consequence of non-filing of validity certificate
within a period of six months was postponed, rather
interdicted, by the interim order of the High Court. The
jurisdiction of the High Court to pass the above interim order
dated 18-8-2017 is questioned by the appellants. Caste
Scrutiny Committee, which is a statutory authority constituted
under the State enactment to verify the caste claimed by
citizens, in event, illegally rejects the claim of citizen, does the
citizen have no right to seek judicial remedy? Can the illegal
rejection of caste claim of a citizen is a fait accompli after
expiry of period of six months? When a citizen has right to
judicial review against any decision of statutory authority, the
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 67
High Court in exercise of judicial review had every jurisdiction
to maintain the status quo so as to by lapse of time, the
petition may not become infructuous. The interim order can
always be passed by a High Court in exercise of writ jurisdiction
to maintain the status quo so that at the time of final decision
of the writ petition, the relief may not become infructuous.
39. We are conscious of the fact that the High Court has to
exercise jurisdiction under Article 226 with due regard to the
legislative intent manifested by provisions of enactment. A
nine-Judge Constitution Bench in Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v.
Union of India 16 had laid down such proposition in para 108 in
the following words: (SCC p. 635)
“108…. (x)... So far as the jurisdiction of the High Court’s
under Article 226 of the Constitution or of this Court under
Article 32 - is concerned, it remains unaffected by the
provisions of the Act. Even so, the Court would, while
exercising the jurisdiction under the said articles, have due
regard to the legislative intent manifested by the
provisions of the Act. The writ petition would naturally be
considered and disposed of in the light of and in
accordance with the provisions of Section 11-B. This is for
the reason that the power under Article 226 has to be
exercised to effectuate the regime of law and not for
abrogating it. Even while acting in exercise of the said
constitutional power, the High Court cannot ignore the law
nor can it override it. The power under Article 226 is
conceived to serve the ends of law and not to transgress
them."
(2008) 10 SCC 1 – (Official Liquidator Vs Dayanand)
“78. There have been several instances of different Benches
of the High Court not following the judgments/orders of
coordinate and even larger Benches. In some cases, the
High Courts have gone to the extent of ignoring the law laid
down by this Court without any tangible reason. Likewise,
there have been instances in which smaller Benches of this
Court have either ignored or bypassed the ratio of the
judgments of the larger Benches including the Constitution
Benches. These cases are illustrative of non-adherence to
the rule of judicial discipline which is sine qua non for
sustaining the system. In Mahadeolal Kanodia v.
Administrator General of W.B. this Court observed:
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 68
“19……If one this is more necessary in law than any
other thing, it is the quality of certainly. That quality
would totally disappear if Judges of coordinate
jurisdiction in a High Court start overruling one
another’s decisions. If one Division Bench of a High
Court is unable to distinguish a previous decision of
another Division Bench, and holding the view that the
earlier decision is wrong, itself gives effect to that
view the result would be utter confusion. The
position would be equally bad where a judge sitting
singly in the High Court is of opinion that the
previous decision of another Singly Judge on a
question of law is wrong and gives effect to that view
instead of referring the matter to a larger Bench. In
such a case lawyers would not know how to advise
their clients and all courts subordinate to the High
Court would find themselves in an embarrassing
position of having to choose between dissentient
judgments of their own High Court”
….
83. In Pradip Chandra Parija v. Pramod Chandra Patnaik the
Constitution Bench noted that the two learned Judges
denuded the correctness of an earlier Constitution Bench
judgment in Bharat Petroleum Corpn. Ltd. V. Mumbai
Shramik Sangha and reiterated the same despite the fact
that the second Constitution Bench refused to reconsider
the earlier verdict and observed:
“3. We may point out, at the outset, that in Bharat
Petroleum Corpn. Ltd. V. Mumbai Shramik Sangha a
Bench of five Judges considered a somewhat similar
question. Two learned Judges in that case doubted the
correctness of the scope attributed to a certain
provision in an earlier Constitution Bench judgment
and, accordingly, referred the matter before them
directly to a Constitution Bench. The Constitution
Bench that then heard the matter took the view that
the decision of a Constitution Bench bids a Bench of
two learned Judges and that judicial discipline obliges
them to follow it, regardless of their doubts about its
correctness. At the most, the Bench of two learned
Judges could have ordered that the matter be heard by
a Bench of three learned Judges.
***
4. The learned Attorney General submitted that a
Constitution Bench judgment of this Court was binding
on smaller Bench and a judgment of three learned
Judges was binding on Benches of two learned Judges
– a proposition that learned counsel for the appellants
did not dispute. The learned Attorney General drew our
attention to the judgment of a Constitution Bench in
Sub-committee of Judicial Accountability v. Union of
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 69
India where it has been said that ‘no coordinate Bench
of this Court can even comment upon, let alone sit in
judgment over, the discretion exercised or judgment
rendered in a cause or matter before another
coordinate Bench-. The learned Attorney General
submitted that the appropriate course for the Bench of
two learned Judges to have adopted, if it felt so
strongly that the judgment in NityanandaKar was
incorrect, was to make a reference to a Bench of three
learned Judges. That Bench of three learned Judges, if
it also took the same view of NityanandaKar, could
have referred the case to a Bench of five learned
judges.
6. In the present case the Bench of two learned Judges
has, in terms, doubted the correctness of a decision of
a Bench of three learned Judges. They have, therefore,
referred the matter directly to a Bench of five Judges.
In our view, judicial discipline and propriety demands
that a Bench of two learned Judges should follow a
decision of a Bench of three learned Judges. But if a
Bench of two learned Judges concludes that an earlier
judgment of three learned Judges is so very incorrect
that in no circumstances can it be followed, the proper
course for it to adopt is to refer the matter before it to
a Bench of three learned Judges setting out, as has
been done here, the reasons why it could not agree
with the earlier judgment. If, then, the Bench of three
learned judges also comes to the conclusion that the
earlier judgment of a Bench of three learned judges is
incorrect, reference to a Bench of five learned Judges
is justified.”
86. In Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community v. State
of Maharasthra the Constitution Bench interpreted Article
141, referred to various earlier judgments including Bharat
Petroleum Corpn. Ltd. V. Mumbai Shramik Sangha and
Pradip Chandra Parija v. Pramod Chandra Patnaik and held
that the law laid down in a decision delivered by a Bench of
larger strength is binding on any subsequent Bench of
lesser or co-equal strength and it would be inappropriate if
a Division Bench of two Judges starts overruling the
decisions of Division Benches of three Judges. The Court
further held that such a practice would be detrimental not
only to the rule of discipline and the doctrine of binding
precedents but it will also lead to inconsistency in decisions
on the point of law; consistency and certainty in the
development of law and its contemporary status- both
would be immediate casualty (Central Board of Dawoodi
Bohra Community Case, SCC p.682, paras 12 & 10).”
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 70
[25]
On perusal of the case dossier, it is seen and evident that this
Court passed series of interim as well as vacation orders. And orders
of the same are extracted herein below:
Operative portion of Interim
19.04.2023 (1st Interim order)–
order
dated
“1.
Heard Mr. Tayenjam Momo Singh, learned counsel
for the petitioner and Mr. Lenin Hijam, learned Advocate
General who takes notice for the respondents.
2.
Mr. Lenin Hijam, learned Advocate General seeks
time for filing counter affidavit.
3.
Mr. Tayenjam Momo Singh, learned counsel for the
petitioner represented that impugned order 11.04.2023 has
been passed by the Respondent No. 3 thereby terminating
the agreement of the petitioner dated 08.06.2021 and
therefore, the petitioners would be suffered a great loss by
the impugned order.
4.
Mr. Tayenjam Momo Singh also represented that as
per the impugned order dated 11.04.2023 the Respondents
are directed for joint measurement of the constructed
building. Therefore, he prayed this Court to grant an interim
order.
5.
Mr. Lenin Hijam, learned Advocate General is
strongly opposing for granting any interim order and seeks
time for filing counter and documents.
6.
Therefore, post the matter on 25.04.2023 in the
motion list. Till such time, the respondents are directed not
to make joint measurement.
[26]
7.
Interim order for stay of the impugned order will be
considered on the next date of hearing.”
The vacation of the above interim order is extracted
herein below:
Operative portion of order dated 01.08.2023
(vacation of interim order)–
“44. The Division Bench of this Court directed the
State and the petitioner to comply with their
contractual obligations qua the completion of the
construction of Civil Secretariat Work. According to
the respondents, the petitioner has violated the
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 71
terms and conditions of the agreement and
therefore the third respondent has rightly
terminated the agreement dated 08.06.2021.
45. As could also be seen from the general conditions of the
contract, particularly Clause 25 provides settlement of
dispute and arbitration of the conditions of the contract
agreement to settle any dispute or grievances, if any. In
view of the factual questions involved in the writ petition
and in the absence of detailed counter-affidavit filed by the
respondents resisting the allegations set out in the writ
petition, the merits of the termination of the agreement
dated 08.06.2021 cannot be gone into at this stage.
46. As stated supra, the third respondent decided to
conduct a joint measurement of the work done by the
petitioner. In the factual scenario put forth by the
respective parties, if joint measurement is conducted, no
prejudice would be caused to the petitioner and if joint
measured is conducted, it will be helpful for the Court to
know about the exact work executed at the ground level by
the petitioner and based on the report, further steps can be
taken in this matter. Moreover, the third respondent has
every right to conduct joint measurement to assess the
work executed by the contractor at the site. The aforesaid
observation of this Court is only in the interest of both
parties and for the welfare of the public scheme and the
public money involved for construction of Civil Secretariat.
Therefore, keeping the writ petition pending, the
respondent authorities are directed to conduct joint
measurement in order to assess the construction work and
the other work done and executed by the petitioner at the
site. For the purpose of conducting joint measurement, the
interim order dated 19.4.2023 needs to be vacated enabling
the respondent authorities to carry out the joint
measurement. Therefore, in the interest of justice and
without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the
respective parties in the main writ petition, this Court is
inclined to vacate the interim order dated 19.4.2023
passed in the writ petition.
47. For the reasons stated supra, the interim order dated
19.4.203 granted by this Court in the writ petition stands
vacated. The respondent authorities are directed to conduct
the joint measurement as stated in the impugned order
dated 11.04.2023 and file a report before this Court before
the date of hearing on 04.09.2023.
48. It is made clear that the observation made by this Court
in this order shall be confined only for the purpose of
considering the interim order and it shall not be taken as
final opinion of this Court.”
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 72
[27]
This Court on the same day after vacation of the
previous injunction order passed another interim order and the
same is extracted herein below:
Operative portion of order dated 01.08.2023
(2nd interim order)
“3. After delivering the order by this Court, Mr. T. Momo,
learned counsel for the petitioner represented that till the
joint measurement is taken place, both the parties may be
directed to maintain the status quo as on today.
4. Therefore, till the joint measurement is taken place, both
the parties are directed to maintain the status quo as on
today.”
[28]
As aggrieved, the State applicant filed the present
miscellaneous application for vacation/modification of the above
referred interim orders.
As admitted by both parties, that the present subject
matter i.e. the Construction of Capital Complex (Civil Secretariat
Component) at Mantripukhri, the parties executed a contract
agreement and the relevant portion of which both the parties are
relying upon and the same is extracted herein below:
Clause 3 and clause 25 of contract agreement
(08.06.2021):
“Clause 3 – When Contract can be Determined –
Subject to other provisions contained in this clause, the
Engineer-in- Charge may, without prejudice to any other
rights or remedy against the contractor in respect of any
delay, not following safety norms, inferior workmanship, any
claims for damages and/or any other provisions of this
contract or otherwise, and whether the date of completion
has or has not elapsed, by notice in writing absolutely
determine the contract in any of the following cases.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 73
i)
If the contractor having been given by the Engineerin-Charge a notice in writing to rectify, reconstruct or
replace any defective work or that the work is being
performed in an inefficient or otherwise improper or
unworkman like manner shall omit to comply with the
requirement of such notice for a period of seven days
thereafter.
ii)
If the contractor has, without reasonable cause,
suspended the progress of the work or has failed to
proceed with the work with due diligence and
continues to do so after a notice in writing of seven
days from Engineer-in-Charge.
iii)
If the contractor fails to complete the work or section
of work with individual date of completion on or
before within the stipulated or justified extended date,
on or before such date of completion; and the
Engineer-in-Charge without any prejudice to any other
right or remedy under any other provision in the
contract has given further reasonable time in a notice
given in writing in that behalf as either mutually
agreed or in the absence of such mutual agreement
by his own assessment making such time essence of
contract and in the opinion of Engineer-in-Charge the
contractor will be unable to complete the same or
does not complete the same within the period
specified.
iv)
If the contractor persistently neglects to carry out his
obligations under the contract and/or commits default
in complying with any of the terms and conditions of
the contract and does not remedy it or take effective
steps to remedy it within 7 days after a notice in
writing is given to him in that behalf by the Engineerin-Charge.
v)
If the contractor shall offer or give or agree to give to
any person in Government service or to any other
person on his behalf any gift or consideration of any
kind as an inducement or reward for doing or
forbearing to do or for having done or forborne to do
any act in relation to the obtaining or execution of this
or any other contract for Government.
vi)
If the contractor shall enter into a contract with
Government in connection with which commission has
been paid or agreed to be paid by him or to his
knowledge, unless the particulars of any such
commission and the terms of payment thereof have
been previously disclosed in writing to the Engineerin-charge.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 74
vii)
If the contractor had secured the contract with
Government as a result of wrong tendering or other
non-bonafide methods of competitive tendering or
commits breach of Integrity Agreement.
viii)
If the contractor being an individual, or if a firm, any
partner thereof shall at any time be adjudged
insolvent or have a receiving order or order for
administration of his estate made against him or shall
take any proceedings for liquidation or composition
(other than a voluntary liquidation for the purpose of
amalgamation or reconstruction) under any
Insolvency Act for the time being in force or make any
conveyence or assignment of his effects or
composition or arrangement for the benefit of his
creditors or purport so to do, or if any application be
made under any Insolvency Act for the time being in
force for the sequestratin of his estate or if a trust
deed be executed by him for benefit of his creditors.
ix)
If the contractor being a company shall pass a
resolution or the court shall make an order that the
company shall be wound up or if a receiver or a
manager on behalf of a creditor shall be appointed or
if circumstances shall arise which entitle the court or
the creditor to appoint a receiver or a manager or
which entitle the court to make a winding up order.
x)
If the contractor shall suffer an execution being levied
on his goods and allow it to be continued for period of
21 days.
xi)
If the contractor assigns (excluding part(s) of work
assigned to other agency(s) by the contractor as per
terms of contract), transfers, sublets (engagement of
labour on a piece-work basis or of labour with
materials not to be incorporated in the work, shall not
be deemed to be subletting) or otherwise parts with
or attempts to assign, transfer, sublet or otherwise
parts with the entire works or any portion thereof
without the prior written approval of the Engineer-inCharge.
When the contractor has made himself liable
for action under any of the cases aforesaid, the
Engineer-in-Charge on behalf of the Governor of
Manipur shall have powers:
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 75
a)
To determine the contract as aforesaid so far as
performance of work by the contractor is
concerned (of which determination notice in
writing to the contractor under the hand of the
Engineer-in- Charge shall be conclusive
evidence). Upon such determination, Security
Deposit already recovered, Security deposit
payable and Performance Guarantee under the
contract shall be liable to be forfeited and shall
be absolutely at the disposal of the
Government.
b)
After giving notice to the contractor to measure
up the work of the contractor and to take such
whole, or the balance or part thereof, as shall
be un-executed out of his hands and to give it
to another contractor to compete the work. The
contractor, whose contract is determined as
above, shall not be allowed to participate in the
tendering process for the balance work
including any new items needed to complete
the work.
In the event of above courses being adopted
by the Engineer-in-Charge, the contractor shall have
no claim to compensation for any loss sustained by
him by reasons of his having purchased or procured
any materials or entered into any engagements or
made any advances on account or with a view to the
execution of the work or the performance of the
contract. And in case action is taken under any of the
provision aforesaid, the contractor shall not be entitled
to recover or be paid any sum for any work thereof or
actually performed under this contract unless and until
the Engineer-in-Charge has certified in writing the
performance of such work and the value payable in
respect thereof and he shall only be entitled to be
paid the value so certified.
[29]
The applicant/respondent, vide letter dated 7.05.2021
sent and acceptance letter after execution of contract agreement
and the same is extracted herein below:
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 76
“PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
No EE/BO UCivilSectt/2021-22Imphal, the 27 May 2021
To
M/S Sri Avantika Contractors (I) Ltd,
610-Nilgiri Block, Aditya Enclave,
Ameerpet, Hyderabad - 500038
Subject:
Letter of Acceptance of tender for the
work "Construction of Capital
Complex (Civil Secretariat
Component) at Mantripukhri,
Imphal - Balance Works"
Dear Sir
It is to convey that your tender for the work
mentioned above has been accepted on behalf of the
Governor of Manipur and conveyed approval of the Higher
Tender committee vide no. 26/3/2021-W dt 25/05/2021 at
your negotiated amount of Rs 167, 40,96,700 (Rupees One
hundred sixty seven crore forty lakh ninety six thousand
seven hundred only) inclusive of 12% GST for Civil Works,
18% GST for IEI Works and 1% Labour Cess which is a 2%
reduction from your original quoted amount of Rs.
170,82,61,939.22
2(i)
You are requested to submit the Performance
Guarantee of atleast Rs 5,02,22,901.0 (Rupees five
crore two lakhs twenty two thousand nine hundred and
one only) i.e. 3% of the tendered amount within 7
days of issue of this letter i.e. by 02/06/2021. The
Performance Guarantee shall be in the prescribed
format as provided in the clause no.1 of the general
Conditions of Contract (Clauses of Contract) for PWD.,
Manipur and shall be initially be valid for 12 months. In
case the time of completion of the work gets enlarged,
you shall get the validity of the Performance Guarantee
extended to cover such enlarged time for completion of
the work.
(ii)
Failure to extended the validity of the performance
guarantee before the expiry of the validity period will
invite actions as appropriate under clause 1 of the
general conditions of Contract (Clauses of Contract) for
PWD, Manipur.
(iii)
After recording of the completion certificate for the
work by the competent authority, the performance
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 77
guarantee shall be returned to the contractor, without
any interest.
(iv)
In the event of the contract being determined or
rescinded under the provisions of the any of the
clauses/conditions of the agreement, the Performance
Guarantee shall stand forfeited in full and shall be
absolutely at the disposal of the Governor of Manipur
3(i)
On receipt of the prescribed performance Guarantee
only necessary letter to commence the work shall be
issued and the site of the work shall be handed over to
you thereafter.
Please note that the time allowed for carrying out the
work as entered in the tender (12months) shall be
reckoned from 10(ten) days after the date of issue of
the letter of commencement of the work/work order
and accordingly the stipulated date of completion.
You are to attend this office for signing the agreement
within one weeks’ time from the issue of
commencement/work Order as mentioned above.
5 (i)
The accepted amount is inclusive of cost of all items of
work as mentioned in the bidding document including
mobilization of all plants and equipment's, labour and
labour related amenities, temporary site office and all
other activities necessary and timely completion of the
work.
(ii)
The accepted amount id inclusive of all
taxes/surcharges as applicable from time to time
during the contract period in the state of Manipur i.e.
GST, Income Tax, Labour Welfare Cess, octroy, Toll,
ferry charges, Local Charges, Royalties, Turn Over Tax
and all other charges.
(iii)
Enhancement of the accepted amount shall not be
entertained under any circumstances and it shall
remain in except firm in cases of Extra, Substituted,
deviated items which are to be executed with written
direction of the department.
(iv)
No Cost Escalation shall be entertained under any
circumstances during the contractual period of 12
months.
6 (i)
Payment shall be made according to the Running
Account Bill subject to availability of CDA released for
the Head of Account with deduction of leviable
taxes/cesses etc.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 78
(ii)
You shall sign an undertaking to the effect that you
will not claim any bill unless and until CDA released for
the Head of Account is available according of the
availability of fund in the enclosed format (Annexure Ill) and submit along with the Performance Guarantee
by 06/02/2021.
7.
You shall submit a Work programme for completion of
the work during the stipulated time in PERT/CPM
Network Chart/ M.S Project/Primavera within 15 days
of the issue of letter of Acceptance of Tender.
8 (i)
Security Deposit shall be collected by deduction if a
sum at the rate of 2.5% gross amount of each running
bill the sum along with the sum already deposited as
earnest Money, will amount to Security Deposit of
2.5% of the Tendered value of the work, Earnest
Money shall be adjusted first in the Security Deposit
and further recovery of Security Deposit shall
commence only when the upto date amount of Security
Deposit starts exceeding the earnest money. Such
deductions will be made and held by Government
Securities or fixed deposits receipts prescribed in the
contract clauses with validity period of 24 months (one
year beyond the 12 months of contractual period). In
case the time of the completion of the work gets
enlarged, you shall get the validity of the Security
Deposit extended to cover such enlarged time for
completion of the work. This is in addition to the
Performance Guarantee that the contractor is required
to deposit as per Clause No. 2 mentioned above.
(ii)
Failure to extend the validity of the Security Deposit
deposited s Government Securities before the expiry of
the validity period will invite actions as appropriate
clause of the General Conditions of Contract (Clauses
of Contracts) PWD., Manipur.
(iii)
Security Deposit can be released against bank
Guarantee issued by a scheduled bank on as
accumulation to a minimum amount of Rs 5 lakhs
subject to the condition that amount of any Bank
Guarantee except last of shall not be less than Rs 5
lakh.
(iv)
The Bank Guarantee submitted against security deposit
shall be initially be valid for 24 months one year
beyond the contractual period of 12 months) The bank
Guarantee submitted against Earnest Money shall also
be extended as above.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 79
(v)
The model of the Performance Guarantee/bank
Guarantee Bond for security Deposit/Earnest Money is
enclosed as Annexure-II.
10.
You are also to obtain labour License as per the
prevailing provision of Labour Contract Act/Labour
permit statuses of the State.
11.
GST Registration Certificate and other certificates as
required by this office due to mandatory regulations of
the Government, Manipur, in original along with
attested copies of such certified, must procured before
any payments is made.
12.
All the terms and conditions as stipulated in the tender
documents for the work shall remain unchanged. Any
terms and conditions submitted by you other than
stipulated in the tender documents issued by this office
forming as part of the agreement shall be accepted.
13.
The Agreement will be signed by your authorized
representative and Executive Engineer, Building
Division No. 1, PWD Manipur on each and every pages
of the Contract document and on all enclosures.
14.
Jurisdiction of Court in respect of any dispute case shall
be under High Court of Manipur at Imphal.
15.
This letter of acceptance of your tender along with all
its enclosures and all other relevant documents relating
of the negotiation process shall form part of the
Agreement.
Encl.: As stated above.
Yours faithfully
Sd/(L. Vivek Ray) Executive Engineer
Building Division No. 1 PWD,
Manipur”
[30]
For determination of the dispute between the parties
in the present case, the relevance of Clause – 25 of the Settlement
of Dispute & Arbitration and the same is extracted herein below:
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 80
“Clause
–
Settlement
of
Dispute
&
Arbitration:
“Except where otherwise provided in the contract, all
questions and disputes relating to the meaning of the
specifications, design, drawings and instructions here-inbefore mentioned and as the quality of workmanship or
materials used on the work or as to any other question,
claim, right, matter or thing whatsoever in any way arising
out of or relating to the contract, designs, drawings,
specifications, estimates, instructions, orders or these
conditions or otherwise concerning the works or the
execution or failure to execute the same whether arising
during the progress of the work or after the cancellation,
termination, completion or abandonment thereof shall be
dealt with as mentioned hereinafter.
i)
If the contractor considers any work demanded of
him to be outside the requirements of the contract,
or disputes any drawings, record or decision given in
writing by the Engineer-in-Charge or if the Engineerin-Charge considers any act or decision of the
contractor on any matter in connection with or
arising out of the contract or carrying out of the
work, to be unacceptable and is disputed, such party
shall promptly within 15 days of the arising of the
disputes request the Chief Engineer or where there is
no Chief Engineer, the Additional Director General
(CE/ADG) who shall refer the disputes to Dispute
Redressal Committee (DRC) within 15 days along
with a list of disputes with amounts claimed if any in
respect of each such dispute. The Dispute Redressal
Committee (DRC) give its decision within a period of
60 days extendable by 30 days by consent of both
the parties from the receipt of reference from
CE/ADG. The constitution of Dispute Redressal
Committee (DRC) shall be as indicated in Schedule
‘F’. Provided that no party shall be represented
before the Dispute Redressal Committee by an
advocate/legal counsel etc.
The DRC will submit its decision to the concerned
ADG/SDG for acceptance. ADG/SDG in a time limit of 30
days from receipt of DRC decision will convey acceptance or
otherwise on the said decision. If the Dispute Redressal
Committee (DRC) fails to give its decision within the
aforesaid period or the ADG/SDG fails to give his decision in
the aforesaid time limit or any party is dissatisfied with the
decision of Dispute Redressal Committee (DRC)/ADG/SDG
the neither party may within a period of 30 days from the
receipt of the decision of Dispute Redressal Committee
(DRC)/ ADG/ SDG or on expiry of aforesaid the time limits
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 81
available to DRC/ADG/SDG, may give notice to the Chief
Engineer, Manipur PWD, or if there be no Chief Engineer,
the Additional Director General/ Special Director General
concerned or if there be no Additional Director General /
Special Director General concerned of if there be no
Additional Director General / Special Director General, the
Director General, Manipur PWD for appointment of arbitrator
on prescribed proforma as per Appendix XVII under
intimation to the other party.
It is a term of contract that each party invoking
arbitration must exhaust the aforesaid mechanism of
settlement of claims/disputes prior to invoking arbitration.
The CE/ADG/DG shall in such case appoint the sole
arbitrator or one of the three arbitrators as the case may be
within 30 days of receipt of such a request and refer such
disputes to arbitration. Wherever the Arbitral Tribunal
consists of three Arbitrators, the contractor shall appoint one
arbitrator within 30 days of making request for arbitration or
of receipt of request by Engineer-in-Charge to CE/ADG/DG
for appointment of arbitrator, as the case may be, and two
appointed arbitrators shall appoint the third arbitrator who
shall act as the Presiding Arbitrator. In the event of
A party fails to appoint the second Arbitrator, or
a.
b.
The two appointed Arbitrators fail to appoint the
Presiding Arbitrator, then the Chief Engineer,
Manipur PWD shall appoint the second or
Presiding Arbitrator as the case may be.
Disputes or difference shall be referred for
ii)
adjudication through arbitration by a Tribunal having sole
arbitrator where claimed amount is Rs. 20 crore or less.
Where claimed value is more than Rs. 20 crore, Tribunal shall
consist of three Arbitrators as above. The requirements of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996) and any
further statutory modifications or re-enactment thereof and
the rules made there under and for the time being in force
shall be applicable.
It is a term of this contract that the party invoking
arbitration shall give a list of disputes with amounts claimed,
if any, in respect of each such dispute along with the notice
for appointment of arbitration and giving reference to the
decision of ADG/SDG on the finding/ recommendation of
DRC.
It is also a term of this contract that any member of
the Arbitration Tribunal shall be a Graduate Engineer with
experience in handling public works engineering and further
he shall have earlier worked at a level not lower than Chief
Engineer/ equivalent (i.e. Joint Secretary level of Government
of India). This shall be treated as a mandatory qualification to
be appointed as arbitrator.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 82
Parties, before or at the time of appointment of
Arbitral Tribunal may agree in writing for fast track arbitration
as per the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (26 of 1996)
as amended in 2015.
Subject to provision in the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 (26 of 1996) as amended in 2015 whereby the
counter claims if any can be directly filed before the arbitrator
without any requirement of reference by the appointing
authority, the arbitrator shall adjudicate on only such disputes
as are referred to him by the appointing authority and give
separate award against each dispute and claim referred to
him and in all cases where the total amount of the claims by
any party exceeds Rs. 1,00,000/-, the arbitrator shall give
reasons for the award.
It is also a term of the contract that fees payable to
the arbitral tribunal shall be as approved by Chief Engineer,
PWD, Manipur. This fee shall be shared equally by parties.
The place of arbitration shall be as mentioned in
Schedule F. In case there is no mention of place of
arbitration, the arbitral tribunal shall determine the place of
arbitration.
The venue of the arbitration shall be such place as
may be fixed by the Arbitral Tribunal in consultation with both
the parties. Failing any such agreement, then the Arbitral
Tribunal shall decide the venue.”
[31]
The present respondent/petitioner in the present
miscellaneous case being aggrieved by the termination of contract
agreement dated 11.04.2023 issued by Executive Engineer, Building
Division No. I, PWD, Manipur filed the present writ petition
impugning the said termination order and the same is extracted
herein below:
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 83
Termination of Contract agreement dated 11.04.2023
“GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
No. EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2022-23/1069 Imphal, the 11 April, 2023
To,
M/S Sri Avantika Contractors (1) Ltd. #610-8, Nilgiri Block,
Aditya Enclave. Ameerpet, Hyderabad-500038
Subject:
Construction of Capital Complex (Civil
Secretariat Component) at Mantripukhri
Balance work Final Action under Clause 3
of the Contract Agreement
Ref:
i) Agrt. No EE/BD-1/AGRT/2021-22/01 dt. 08-06-20
Sir,
Whereas various notices and intimations has been served
to you for the slow progress of works as enumerated
below:A. Intimations for Slow progress of works
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/77
dt.17/08/2021
Augmentation of Labour strength and
increase of work shifts
Annexure-I
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/235 dt.
27/10/2021
Notice for slow Progress of works
Annexure-II
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/270
dt.16/11/2021
-Notice for slow Progress of works
Annexure-III
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/617
dt.30/03/2022
-Notice for slow Progress of works
Annexure-IV
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2022-23/1
dt.01/04/2022
-Intimation of the minutes of meeting
Annexure-V
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2022-23/74
dt.20/04/2022
-Hindrances due to non-availability of
aggregates
Annexure-VI
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 84
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2022 dt.27/04/2022
-Reminder notice for slow progress of
Works
Annexure-VII
EE/BD-II/Civil Sectt/2022/42
dt.02/05/2022
-Regarding non execution and
discrepancies in Electrical &
Electromechanical works for
construction of Civil Secretariat
Mantripukhri Imphal Manipur
Annexure-VIII
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2022-23/165
dt.16/05/2022 -Reminder for
submission of Work program
Annexure-IX
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/202122/dt.04/06/2022
-Delay in procurement of proritylemsilke
Polycarbonate Sheet roofing at cut out
portion and DYNA sheet roofing of Main
Conference Hall.
Annexure-X
11 EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/301
dt.21/06/2022
Reminder for submission of Work
program
Annexure-XI
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/357
dt.11/07/2022
-Reminder for submission of Revised
work program for completion
Annexure-XII
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/358
dt.11/07/2022
-Removal of substandard item
Annexure-XIII
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/382 dt.
20/07/2022
-Instruction on sanitary items to be
adopted in North & South block.
Annexure-XIV
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/387
dt.21/07/2022
-Notice for delay and inability to
complete the original works
Annexure-XV
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/424
dt.02/08/2022
-Reminder for submission of Bar-chart/
program of completion of CM Block
Annexure-XVI
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 85
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/695
dt.17/08/2022
-Sanitary fittings-reg
Annexure-XVII
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/511 dt
20/08/2022-Intentional delay in
completion of the project
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/605 dt.
23/09/2022
-Reminder for revised work programme
for completion
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/617 dt.
28/09/2022
-Reminder for re-submission of revised
work programme for completion
Annexure-XVIII
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/627
dt.04/10/2022
-Justification of rate Adopted of
extra/substitute rates
Annexure-XXI
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/630
dt.04/10/2022
-Delay and inability to complete the
works
Annexure-XXII
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/647 dt
06/10/2022
-Execution of UPVC Window at CS
projects
Annexure-XXII
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/665
dt.11/10/2022
-Notice on taking action under clause
14 of agreement
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/685
dt.14/10/2022
-Reminder to submit reply and work
program for completion of work
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/687
dt.16/10/2022
-Reminder for submission of Bar
chart/Program for completion
Annexure-XXIV
EE/ED-II/Civil Sectt/2022/203
dt.17/10/2022
-Reminder for submission of Bar
Chart/program of completion
Annexure-XXVII
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2022-23/694
dt.17/10/2022
-Seeking details on the execution of
Annexure-XXVIII
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Annexure-XIX
Annexure-XX
Annexure-XXV
Annexure-XXVI
Page 86
work of UPVC windows, Door hardware
fixtures, parking of vehicles, vitrified
tiles and false ceiling in minister's black
MISCW-1701/60/2021-WD-WD
dt.30/10/2022
-Slow progress and failure to maintain
milestone
Annexure-XXIX
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/748
dt.04/11/2022
-Reminder to complete the remaining
works
Annexure-XXX
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/881 dt.
Annexure-XXXI
14/12/2022
-for immediate construction of DAP door
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/885
dt.16/12/2022
-Failure to complete the work and
slippage from proposed milestone
Annexure-XXXII
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/889 dt.
19/12/2022
-Labour License-Para 10/violation of
LOA
Annexure-XXXIII
EE/BD-1/Civil Sectt/2021-22/934
dt.08/01/2023
-Reminder for slow progress and
inability to complete works
Annexure-XXXIV
B. Show Cause Notices
1.
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/906 dt. 2612-2022 -Show Cause Notice
Annexure-XXXV
2.
No. 102/SE-II/BD-I/Corp/2022/186 dt.
20.01.2023
- Show Cause against agreement
No. Civil Sectt/EE/BDI/Agmt/2021-22/1dt 08/06/2021
for the work Construction of
Capital Complex (Civil
Secretariat Component) at
Mantripukhri – (Sh: Balance
Works)
EE/BD-I/Civil Sectt/2021-22/947 dt. 2101-2023
- 2nd Show Cause Notice
Annexure-XXXVI
3.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Annexure-XXXVII
Page 87
II. Whereas despite repeated reminders and show cause
notices served to you, the work was delayed as per the schedule
for the completion of the work submitted by you and also have
failed to achieve milestones which is completely unsatisfactory.
III. Whereas under Clause 3 of the aforesaid agreement the
Engineer-in-Charge shall have powers to take action under
Clause 3 in the event of delay or suspension in the execution of
the aforesaid work by the contractor so that in the opinion of the
Engineer-in- Charge (which shall be final and binding), the
contractor have already failed to complete the work by the
extended date of completion, whereas you have delayed the
execution of the aforesaid work and as per the opinion of the
undersigned, the Engineer-in-Charge (which shall be final and
binding), you will be unable to secure completion of the work by
the extended date of completion and whereas you were served
with show cause in this regard under this office letter no. EE/BD1/civil Sectt/2021-22/947 dt. 21-01-2023 (list of letters and Show
Cause Notices served to you are enclosed as Annexure) and your
reply vide letter No. SACIL/CS/2022/275 dt. 24/01/2023 received
in response to show cause has been considered carefully but not
found to the satisfaction of the Engineer-in-Charge. Therefore,
under powers delegated to me under Clause 3, I, L.N.Kom, the
Engineer-in-Charge for the aforesaid work under the aforesaid
agreement, for and on behalf of the Governor of Manipur, hereby
(i) Determine the contract as aforesaid upon which
determination your earnest money deposit, security
deposit already recovered and Performance Guarantee
stand absolutely forfeited to the Government and shall be
absolutely at the disposal of Government, and
(ii) Take out such part of the work out of your hand, as
remains unexecuted, for giving it to another contractor or
execute the work through other means by the
Department to complete the work, and you shall have no
claim to compensation for any loss sustained by you by
reasons of your having purchased or procured any
materials or entered into any engagements or made any
advances on account of or with a view to the execution of
the work or the performance of the contract. You are also
hereby served with notice to the effect that the work
executed by you will be measured up on 19th April 2023
for which you are asked to attend for joint measurement
falling which the work will be measured by the
department unilaterally in your absence and result of
measurement will be final and will be binding on you.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 88
(iii) You shall not be allowed to participate in the
tendering process for the balance work, if the balance
work is to be completed through a contractor.
(iv) Further you are open to approach the appropriate
authority as provided under Clause No.25 Settlement of
Dispute and Arbitration of the Conditions of the Contract
Agreement to settle any disputes or grievances in this
regard if any.
This is without prejudice to Government's right to take action under
any other clauses or sub-clauses of the agreement and to realize
Government dues and losses and damages whatsoever under such clauses
or sub-clauses.
Encl: As stated above
Yours faithfully,
(L. N. KOM)
Executive Engineer,
Building Division No. I
PWD, Manipur”
[32]
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in (2022) 6 SCC 127 at
Para No. 19, 20 & 21 observed that
“19.
The Specific Relief Act, 1963 was amended by
Central Act 18 of 2018 when clause (ha) was
inserted in Section 41 of the said Act to say:
“41. (ha)
if it would impede or delay the
progress or completion of any
infrastructure project or interfere with
the continued provision of relevant
facility related thereto or services
being the subject-matter of such
project.”
20.
Such amendment was in pursuance of the report
submitted on 20.06.2016 of the Expert Committee. The
report is as under:
“The Expert Committee set on examining the
Specific Relief Act, 1963 submits its |Report to Union Law &
Justice Minister recommends modifications for ensuring
ease of doing business.
The Expert Committee set on examining the Specific
Relief Act, 1963 today submitted its Report to Union Law &
Justice Minister Shri D.V. Sadananda Gowda here in New
Delhi. In its report the committee has recommended
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 89
modifications in the Specific Relief Act, 1963 for ensuring
the ease of doing business.
In the context of tremendous developments which
have taken place since 1963 and the present changed
scenario
involving
contract
based
infrastructure
developments, public private partnerships and other public
projects, involving huge investments; and changes required
in the present scheme of the Act so that specific
performance is granted as a general rule and grant of
compensation or damages for non-performance remains as
an exception, the committee decided –
To change the approach, from damages being the
rule and specific performance being the exception, to
specific performance being the rule, and damages being the
alternate remedy.
To provide guidelines for reducing the discretion
granted to courts and tribunals while granting performance
and injunctive reliefs.
To introduce provisions for rights of third parties
(other than for government contracts).
To consider addressing unconscionable contracts,
unfair contracts, reciprocity in contracts, etc. and implied
terms.
The committee observed that there is a need to
classify diverse public utility contracts as a distinct class
recognizing the inherent public interest/importance to be
addressed in the Act. Any public work must progress
without interruption. This requires consideration whether a
court’s intervention in Public Works would be minimal.
Smooth functioning of public works projects can be
effectively managed through a monitoring system and
regulatory mechanism. The role of courts in this exercise is
to interfere to the minimum extent so that public works
projects will not be impeded or stalled.
21.
Since the construction of road is an infrastructure
project and keeping in view the intent of the legislature that
infrastructure projects should not be stayed, the High Court
would have been well advised to hold its hand to stay the
construction of the infrastructure project. Such provision
should be kept in view even by the writ court while
exercising its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.”
[33]
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in (2021)20 SCC 454 at
Para No. 25 observed that
“25. It is well settled that the High Court exercising its
extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, does not adjudicate hotly disputed
questions of facts. It is not for the High Court to make a
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 90
comparative assessment of conflicting technical reports and
decide which one is acceptable.”
[34]
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in (2005) 12 SCC 725
at Para No. 7, 8, 9 & 10 observed that
“7.
A bare perusal of the High Court’s judgment shows
that there was clear non-application of mind. On one hand
the High Court observed that the disputed questions cannot
be gone into a writ petition. It was also noticed that the
essence of the dispute was breach of contract. After coming
to the above conclusions the High Court should have
dismissed the writ petition. Surprisingly, the High Court
proceeded to examine the case solely on the writ
petitioner’s assertion and on a very curious reasoning that
though the appellant Corporation claimed that the value of
articles lifted was nearly R. 14.90 lakhs no details were
specifically given. From the counter-affidavit filed before the
High Court it is crystal-clear that relevant details disputing
claim of the writ petitioner were given. Value of articles
lifted by the writ petitioner is a disputed factual question.
Where a complicated question of fact is involved and the
matter requires thorough proof on factual aspects, the High
Court should not entertain the writ petition. Whether or not
the High Court should exercise jurisdiction under Article 226
of the Constitution would largely depend upon the nature of
dispute and if the dispute cannot be resolved without going
into the factual controversy, the High Court should not
entertain the writ petition. As noted above, the writ petition
was primarily founded on allegation of breach of contract.
Question whether the action of the opposite party in the
writ petition amounted to breach of contractual obligation
ultimately depends on facts and would require material
evidence to be scrutinized and in such a case writ
jurisdiction should not be exercised. [see State of Bihar V.
Jain Plastics & Chemicals Ltd.]
8.
In a catena of cases this Court has held that where
the dispute resolves round questions of fact, the matter
ought not to be entertained under Article 226 of the
Constitution [see State Bank of India V. State Bank of
India Canteen Employees Union and Chairman, Gird
Corpn. Of Orissa Ltd. (GRIDCO) V. Sukamani Das]
9.
In the instant case, the High Court has itself
observed that disputed questions of fact were involved and
yet went on to give directions as if it was adjudicating the
money claim in a suit. The course is clearly impermissible.
[see G.M., Kisan Sahkari Chini Mills Ltd. V. Satrughan
Nishad and Rourkela Shramik Sangh V. Steel Authority of
India Ltd.]
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 91
10.
In National Highways Authority of India V. Ganga
Enterprises, it was observed by this Court that the question
whether the writ petition was maintainable in a claim arising
out of a breach of contract should be answered first by the
High Court as it would go to the root of the matter. The writ
petitioner had displayed ingenuity in its search for
invalidating circumstances; but a writ petition is not an
appropriate remedy for impeaching contractual obligations.
[see Har Shgakar V. Dy. Excise and Taxation Commr. and
Divisional Forest Officer V. Bishwanath Tea Co. Ltd.]”
[35]
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in (2021) 10 SCC 690 at
Para No. 24 observed that
“24. Therefore, the dispute could not be raised by way of
a writ petition on the disputed questions of fact. Though,
the jurisdiction of the High Court is wide but in respect of
pure contractual matters in the field of private law, having
no statutory flavor, are better adjudicated upon by the
forum agreed to by the parties. The dispute as to whether
the amount is payable or not and / or how much amount is
payable are disputed questions of facts. There is no
admission on the part of the appellants to infer that the
amount stands crystallized. Therefore, in the absence of any
acceptance of joint survey report by the competent
authority, no right would accrue to the writ petitioner only
because measurements cannot be undertaken after passage
of time. Maybe, the resurvey cannot take place but the
measurement books of work executed from time to time
would form a reasonable basis for assessing the amount
due and payable to the writ petitioner, but such process
could be undertaken only by the agreed forum i.e.
arbitration and not by the writ court as it does not have the
expertise in respect of measurement or construction of
roads.”
[36]
Perusal of the record, it is evident that there exists the
dispute of fact between the two parties in respect of the work as the
petitioner/respondent (M/s Avantika) in their affidavit-in-opposition
dated 16.10.2023 filed in Misc. Case No. 140 of 2023 wherein the
respondent/petitioner submitted that -
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 92
“at para No. 5 (page No. 3), it is stated as –
It is submitted that the respondent-company has
executed 95% of the work and so far submitted bills
of Rs. 100.78 crores.”
at para No. 14 (page No. 7), it is also stated as
follows“It is submitted that the respondent-company has
executed 95% of the work, whereas the Department
had stated that the respondent-company has
completed 53.73% of the work.”
As per the Joint-measurement report the percentage
of work done by the respondent-company is 49%
whereas according to the respondent-company the
percentage of work done in 97.61% after the Jointmeasurement.”
at para No. 16 (page No. 11), it is stated and
admitted that –
“It is submitted that as explained in the abovementioned paragraph the percentage of 95% of the
work being completed by the respondent-company
is correct, therefore the respondent-company has
not made any false statement before this Hon’ble
Court. Moreover, the percentage of work done by
the respondent-company is disputed and not yet
determined by this Hon’ble Court.”
[37]
Per contra, the learned counsel for the applicant/
respondent submits that the work done by the respondent/petitioner
was not 35% but only 45.27% i.e. Rs. 88.91 crores or otherwise
only 53.73 as per the claim received by the Department. But, if the
35% which was stated by the petitioner in the writ petition is
correct, the value of work will be of Rs. 184.78 crores but, such
amount of bill are never received by the Department. Further, it is
clarified by the learned counsel that the bills are to be paid on
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 93
measurement uncompleted works. Accordingly, the learned counsel
submitted that there exists disputed question of fact.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in (2022) 12 SCC 815 at
para No. 13 observed that
“13.
In K.D. Sharma V. SAIL [K.D. Sharma V. SAIL,
(2008) 12 SCC 481], it was held that (SCC pp. 49293, paras 34 – 39).
“34.
The jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under
Article 32 and of the High Court under Article
226 of the Constitution is extraordinary,
equitable and discretionary. Prerogative writs
mentioned therein are issued for doing
substantial justice. It is, therefore, of
utmost necessity that the petitioner
approaching the writ court must come with
clean hands, put forward all the facts
before the court without concealing or
suppressing anything and seek an
appropriate relief. If there is candid
disclosure of relevant and material facts or
the petitioner is guilty of misleading the
court, his petition may be dismissed at the
threshold without considering the merits of
the claim.
35.
The underlying object has been succinctly
stated by Scrutton, L.J., in the leading case
of
R.v.
Kensington
Income
Tax
Commissioners [R.v. Kensington Income Tax
Commissioners, (1971) 1 KB 486 : 86 LJKB
257 : 116 LT 136 (KB & CA) in the following
words:
‘………….. it has been for many years
the rule of the court, and one which
it is of the greatest importance to
maintain, that when an applicant
comes to the court to obtain itself on
an ex parte statement he should
make a full and fair disclosure of all
the material facts – it says facts, not
law. He must not misstate the law if
he can help it – the court is supposed
to know the law. But it knows nothing
about the facts, and the applicant
must state fully and fairly the facts;
and the penalty by which the court
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 94
enforces that obligation is that if it
finds out that the facts have not been
fully and fairly stated to it, the court
will set aside any action which it has
taken on the faith of the imperfect
statement.’
36.
A prerogative remedy is not a matter of
course. While exercising extraordinary power
a writ court would certainly bear in mind the
conduct of the party who invokes the
jurisdiction of the court. If the applicant
makes a false statement or suppresses
material fact or attempts to mislead the
court, the court may dismiss the action on
that ground alone and may refuse to enter
into the merits of the case by stating. ‘We
will not listen to your application because
of what you have done.’The rule has been
evolved in the larger public interest to deter
unscrupulous litigants from abusing the
process of court by deceiving it.
37.
In Kensington Income Tax Commissioners
[R.
v.
Kensington
Income
Tax
Commissioners, (1917) 1 KB 486 : 85 LJKB
257 : 116 LT 136 (KB & CA)], Viscount
Reading, C.J. observed : (KB pp 495 – 96)
‘………….. Where an ex parte
application has been made to this
Court for a rule nisi or other process,
if the court comes to the conclusion
that the affidavit in support of the
application was not candid and did
not fairly state the facts, but stated
them in such a way as to mislead
the Court as to the true facts, the
Court ought, for its own protection
and to prevent an abuse of its
process, to refuse to proceed any
further with the examination of the
merits. This is a power inherent in
the Court, but one which should only
be used in cases which bring
conviction to the mind of the court
that it has been deceived. Before
coming to this conclusion, a careful
examination will be made of the facts
as they are and as they have been
stated in the applicant’s affidavit, and
everything will be heard that can be
urged to influence the view of the
court when it reads the affidavit and
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 95
knows the true facts. But if the result
of this examination and hearing is to
leave no doubt that the court has
been deceived, then it will refuse to
hear anything further from the
applicant in a proceeding which has
only been set in motion by means of
a misleading affidavit.’
38.
The above principles have been accepted in
our legal system also. As per settled law,
the party who invokes the extraordinary
jurisdiction of this Court under Article 32 or
of a High Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution is supposed to be truthful,
frank and open. He must disclose all
material facts without any reservation even
if they are against him. He cannot be
allowed to play “hide and seek” or to “pick
and choose” the facts he likes to disclose
and to suppose (keep back) or not to
disclose (conceal) other facts. The very basis
of the writ jurisdiction rests in disclosure of
true and complete (correct) false. If
material facts are suppressed or distorted,
the very functioning of writ courts and
exercise would become impossible. The
petitioner must disclose all the facts having a
bearing on the relief sought without any
qualification. This is because “the court
knows law but not facts”.
39.
If the primary object as highlighted in
Kensingston Income Tax Commissioners
[R.V.
Kensington
Income
Tax
Commissioners, (1917) 1 KB 486 : 86 LJKB
257 : 116 LT 136 (KB & CA) is kept in mind,
an applicant who does not come with candid
facts and “clean breast” cannot hold a writ of
the court with “soiled hands”. Suppression
or concealment of material facts is not an
advocacy. It is a jugglery, manipulation,
maneuvering or misrepresentation, which
has no place in equitable and prerogative
jurisdiction. If the applicant does not
disclose all the material facts fairly and
truly but states them in a distorted manner
and misleads the court, the court has
inherent power in order to protect itself
and to prevent an abuse of its process to
discharge the rule nisi and refuse to
proceed further with the examination of
the case on merits. If the court does not
reject the petition on that ground, the court
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 96
would be failing in its duty. In fact, such an
applicant requires to be dealt with for
contempt of court for abusing the process of
the court.”
[38]
It
is
a
fact
that
the
contract
between
the
applicants/respondents and respondent/petitioner entered into a
contract for the construction of remaining work amounting to Rs.
133,38,53,287.00
for
Construction
of
Capital
Complex
(Civil
Secretariat component) at Mantripukhri and the agreement was
executed
between
the
respondent/petitioner
and
applicant/respondent No. 3 on 08.06.2021. The agreement was
made in the following terms –
(a)
For agreement of Rs. 167.40 Crores : 12
months
(b)
For revised Agreement amount of Rs. 194.49
Crores : 14 months
It is also evident that the contract work was initially
awarded to M/s Simplex Projects, but due to non-completion of the
work within the stipulated time between the M/s Simplex Projects
Limited
and
terminated
the
applicants/respondents,
on
09.11.2019.
the
Thereafter,
contract
the
was
present
respondent/petitioner was awarded to execute the remaining work
within the above mentioned stipulated time. It is also evident that
the extension of the work was granted to the respondent/petitioner
3 (three) times due to various factors and reasons. Lastly, the
respondent/petitioner by a letter dated 18.07.2022 requested the
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 97
State applicant for extension of 240 (two hundred and forty) days
time and the applicants/respondents wrote letters for the delay of
completion of work to the respondent/petitioner and at the same
time, the respondent/petitioner replied explaining various reasons
for the delay of completion of the work.
It is also seen and evident that the bill payment for the
portion of completed work as claimed by the respondent/petitioner
and also claim made by the applicants/respondents and, paid by the
applicants/respondents
are
disputed
fact,
as
per
the
respondent/petitioner’s contention/assertion, out of total bill amount
of Rs. 100.78 crores, the applicants/respondents paid only a sum of
69.11 crores and 31.67 crores is due. On 26.12.2022, 20.01.2023
and 21.01.2023 the applicants/respondents sent show cause notices
for the said work. The respondent/petitioner replied the said notices
by putting the reasons of delay on 30.12.2022 and 24.01.2023.
It is also seen and evident that in connection with
delay in completion of the work, PIL 34 of 2022 was filed before this
Hon’ble Court for directing the respondents and petitioners to
complete the remaining work so that the existing Manipur
Secretariat may be shifted to the new building and with the said
direction, this Hon’ble Court disposed of the PIL No. 34 of 2022. The
Division Bench of this Hon’ble High Court after hearing the
respective parties while disposing the said PIL issued the following
directions:
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 98
“Considering the facts and circumstances of the case and
the larger public interest involved, the PIL No. 34 of 2022 is
disposed of with the following directions:
(i)
The respondent State is directed to
decongest the traffic on the National
Highway in front of the Old Manipur
Secretariat by making arrangements for
proper park of vehicles on both sides.
Further, the respondent State is directed to
strictly enforce the traffic rules to ensure
illegal parked vehicles are booked.
(ii)
The respondent State and the fourth
respondent are directed to comply with their
contractual obligations qua the completion of
construction of Civil Secretariat work.
(iii)
The respondent State is directed to pay the
Outstanding dues as per the RA Bills raised
by the respondent No. 4 and also approve
the rates of deviations and extra items
regarding the Civil Secretariat work at
earliest.
(iv)
The respondent State and the fourth
respondent are directed to co-operate and
work in the concert with each other to
ensure that the Civil Secretariat work is to be
completed within a period of three months
from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.
(v)
There will be no order as to costs.”
But, the contract agreement was terminated by the
applicants/respondents under clause (3) of the agreement. As
aggrieved, the respondent/petitioner filed the present writ petition.
[39]
It is also seen and evident that as per the direction of
this Hon’ble High Court’s order dated 01.08.2023, the joint
measurement for the work for Construction of Capital Complex (Civil
Secretariat component) at Mantripukhri was carried out and joint
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 99
measurement report was furnished by the applicants/respondents
on 27.09.2023 through the Registrar (Judicial). However, the
respondent/petitioner refused to sign on some of the items in the
list of items in the joint measurement. Thereafter, on 09.10.2023
the respondent/petitioner filed an affidavit with objection to the joint
measurement,
due
to
the
factual
dispute
between
the
respondent/petitioner and the applicants/respondents.
[40]
The respondent/petitioner filed contempt case (C) No.
120 of 2023 praying for taking contempt proceeding against the
applicants/respondents no. 1 to 4 for their willful and deliberate
disobedience of the final judgment and order dated 04.04.2023 in
PIL No. 34 of 2022 and the same is pending before the Hon’ble
Division Bench of this High Court.
[41]
The applicants/respondents (State of Manipur through
the Chief Secretary, Government of Manipur) filed review petition
being No. 11 of 2023 praying for review/modification of the
impugned judgment and order dated 04.04.2023 passed in PIL No.
34 of 2022 and to consider the PIL on merit and the same is
pending before Hon’ble Division Bench of this High Court.
[42]
Further, it is also seen and evident that in the order
dated 01.08.2023 this Hon’ble Court was pleased to give directions
to both the learned counsels to maintain status quo and portion of
the said order is extracted herein below:
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 100
“3. After delivering the order by this Court, Mr. T. Momo,
learned counsel for the petitioner represented that till the
joint measurement is taken place, both the parties may be
directed to maintain the status quo as on today.
4. Therefore, till the joint measurement is taken place, both
the parties are directed to maintain the status quo as on
today.”
A perusal of the above paragraphs, it is seen and
evident that the status quo order was given for specific period of
time i.e. status quo to maintain till the joint measurement takes
place and as per both the learned counsels and on facts as
extracted earlier, it is admitted position of fact that the joint
measurement has already been taken place and the report of the
same was submitted before this Hon’ble Court and the same is
placed on record. Point that needs to be underscored here is that
neither of the parties filed any appeals for revision against the
above mentioned interim order.
[43]
It
is
also
seen
and
evident
that
the
respondent/petitioner in one of the paragraphs of the counter
affidavit
in
reply
to
the
present
application
of
the
applicants/respondents requested to give opportunity to file an
additional affidavit and documents to supplement the affidavit in
opposition and the same is extracted herein below:
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 101
“The respondent no. 1 craved leave of this Hon’ble
Court to file an additional affidavit and documents
to supplement the present affidavit-in-opposition, if
required at a later stage.”
[44]
It is also an admitted fact that the pleas taken by the
respondent/petitioner are that as the present subject matter
involved a public law character and the alternative forum chosen by
the parties would not be in a position to grant appropriate relief, the
present action of the State Government in terminating the present
agreement in question is arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of the
constitutional
right
of
the
petitioner.
Therefore,
the
respondent/petitioner appropriately has taken step and filed the
present writ petition and the maintainability issue raised by the
applicants/respondents is not maintainable.
[45]
In support of this plea, the respondent/petitioner
relied upon series of Apex Court’s judgments which are extracted
herein above.
[46]
On the other hand, the learned AG submitted that
there is question of disputed facts in the present litigation between
the parties. There is breach of contract agreement and as such the
matter may be allowed to be dealt with according to Arbitration
Clause (Clause 25) as per the contract agreement entered between
the two parties. Further, it is submitted by the learned AG that the
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 102
involvement of disputed question of facts was admitted by the writ
petitioner in the objection affidavit dated 9.10.2023. With these
submissions, learned AG in support of this cited several Hon’ble
Apex Court’s judgments which are extracted herein above.
[47]
The
learned
AG,
further,
submitted
that
the
respondent/petitioner filed the present writ petition by concealing or
suppressing the relevant and material facts and as such the Court
may dismiss the petition on this ground alone. In support of his
plea, the learned AG relied upon the Apex Court’s judgments
referred to in the preceding paragraphs.
[48]
After taking into consideration of the aforesaid reasons
and in view of the observations made above and after hearing the
learned counsel for the parties at length and also after going
through the pleas taken by the parties as reproduced earlier and on
the basis of narration made regarding the cases of the parties, this
Court is of the view that it will be proper to hear both the parties at
length on merit in the writ petition being WP(C) No. 358 of 2023
and dispose of instead of dealing only with the maintainability issue
raised herein by the applicants/respondents.
[49]
In the circumstances, both parties are directed to file
their respective additional affidavits, if any, if desired to do so,
before the date of final hearing.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 103
But for the prayer No. (i) in the present miscellaneous
application i.e.
“to vacate/modify the interim orders dated 01.08.2023 and
dated 09.10.2023 and its subsequent extension orders
passed in the instant writ petition being WP(C) No. 358 of
2023.”
[50]
On perusal of the orders dated 01.08.2023 and
09.10.2023 of this Court which are extracted earlier, it is seen and
emerged that the said interim order dated 01.08.2023 was passed
for the specific purpose for specific period i.e. “till the joint
measurement is taken place, both the parties may be directed to
maintain the status quo as on today. Therefore, till the joint
measurement is taken place, both the parties are directed to
maintain the status quo as on today”. But, the order dated
09.10.2023 was just the extension of the said interim order dated
01.08.2023.
[51]
As it is an admitted position of the fact that the joint
measurement was already made and the report has also already
been filed and placed on record before this Court. As put out earlier,
the said order dated 09.10.2023 was just the extension of the order
dated 01.08.2023. Accordingly, I am of the considered view that the
continuation of the status quo order i.e. order dated 01.08.2023 and
its subsequent extension orders are not called for. It is worth to
mention herein that both the parties did not file any appeal/revision
against the said interim orders.
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 104
[52]
Accordingly, the status quo order dated 01.08.2023
and its subsequent extension orders are vacated.
[53]
With the above observation and direction, this present
miscellaneous application is disposed of.
[54]
List the writ petition being W.P.(C) No. 358 of 2023 for
final hearing on 01.08.2024.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Lucy/Bipin
MC(WP(C)) No. 357 of 2023
Page 105
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review