Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.04.04
TELEN KOM Date:
16:53:13 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC(WP(C))No.88 of 2023
Ref:WP(C)No.94 of 2021
1. The State of Manipur, represented by the Chief Secretary,
Government of Manipur, Babupara.
2. The Commissioner(Revenue), Government of Manipur, at Manipur795001.
3. The Dy. Commissioner, Government of Manipur, at Imphal East795005.
…Applicants
– Versus –
The Evangelical Baptist Convention Church, Tribal Colony, New
Checkon, Imphal East, PO & PS, Porompat, Imphal Eastrepresented by its Chairman.
…. Respondent.
With
MC(WP(C))No.89 of 2023
Ref:WP(C)No.501 of 2022
1. The State of Manipur, represented by the Chief Secretary,
Government of Manipur, Babupara.
2. The Commissioner(Revenue), Government of Manipur, at
Manipur-795001.
3. The Dy. Commissioner, Government of Manipur, at Imphal East795005.
…Applicants
– Versus –
The Peniel Church (MELC), Tribal Colony, New Checkon, Imphal
East, PO & PS, Porompat, Imphal East- represented by its Chairman.
…. Respondent.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Applicant
:
Mr. Lenin Hijam, learned AG.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Th. Babloo, Adv.
Date of reserved.
:
29.03.2023
Date of Judgment & Order :
04.04.2023.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
These two miscellaneous cases have been filed by the State to vacate
the interim orders dated 5.2.2021 and 3.8.2022 and the subsequent extension
for maintaining status quo passed in W.P.(C) Nos.94 of 2021 and 501 of 2022
respectively and allow the State authorities to remove the unauthorized
religious structures on public street, public parks, public places etc. in
compliance with the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 29.9.2009 in
SLP (C) No.8519 of 2006 (Union of India v. State of Gujarat and others).
2. Heard Mr. Lenin Hijam, learned AG for the State and Mr. Th. Babloo,
the learned counsel for the respondent.
3. The learned Advocate counsel appearing for the applicant State
submitted that pursuant to the direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in SLP
(C) No.8519 of 2006 dated 7.12.2019, the Government of Manipur issued a
notification dated 3.4.2010 to make the Manipur Policy for Review of
Unauthorised Construction of Religious nature on Public Street, Public Parks,
Public Places and a State Level Committee was constituted for reviewing of
unauthorized construction of religious nature such as Temple, Church,
Mosque or Gurudwara etc. on public street, public parks or other public places
etc.
The
District
Commissioner/Chairperson
Level
was
Committee
constituted
headed
by
for
the
the
District
purpose
of
removal/relocation/regularization of the religious structure located in Village
No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai and in the meeting held on 24.6.2022, it was
discussed about the existence of religious structures erected on the
Government lands of 26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai, namely 9 Churches – (i)
Tangkhul Baptist Church; (ii) Pineal Church Manipur; (iii) Holy Spirit Church;
(iv) Zou Christian Bible Church; (v) Meitei Baptist Church; (vi) Zou
Presbytarian Church; (vii) Evangelical Organization Church; (viii) Kneseeya
Beith Shalom Church and (ix) Evangelical Baptist Convention Church, which
stand on the land allotted to PWD Building Division and to make further
recommendation on whether to remove, relocate or regularize the churches
as per the Hon’ble Supreme Court direction.
4. The learned Government Advocate would submit that Evangelical
Baptist Convention Church and Paniel Church buildings were constructed on
the Government Khas land meant for Government quarters without any
approval from the authority concerned and without any right or title over the
land.
The existence of the Church buildings which were reportedly
constructed on the Government Khas land without any approval for prayers
by the occupants of the Government quarters in the New Checkon now nullify
as the allotment of quarters in the New Checkon had been cancelled by the
Government Order dated 20.3.2021 and most of the occupants have been
allotted new quarters.
5. The learned Government Advocate further submitted that on
12.1.2023 a meeting was held to review the unauthorized constructions of
religious nature prior to 29.9.2009 on public street, public parks, public places
located in Village No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai.
Out of the 9 religious
structures located at Government Quarters Complex, New Checkon, only 4
structures are still standing.
6. The learned Government Advocate next submitted that the State
Government has obtained loan from HUDCO for construction of Government
quarters and the project for construction of Government quarters, New
Checkon was estimated at Rs.50 crore and the construction is going on in full
swing and the new quarters will provide 392 new modern residential quarters
for Government employees.
7. The learned Government Advocate urged that the Committee after
going through the relevant reports, revenue documents and the order of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, unanimously recommended removal of the left over
4 religious structures after obtaining approval of the State Cabinet and orders
from this Court.
Since the State Cabinet in its decision dated 18.1.2023
granted approval for removal of four religious structures, the State has now
filed these miscellaneous cases to vacate the status quo order that was
granted by this Court in the writ petitions.
8. Refuting the submissions made by learned Government Advocate,
the learned counsel for the respondents submitted that Evangelical Baptist
Convention Church was constructed on a Government land in the year 1974
to cater social and spiritual needs of the Church members who are mostly
Tribal Government employee residing in Imphal East. The members of the
Church are enjoying social and religious services in the Church for more than
40 years without any objection and interruption from any quarter whatsoever,
including the Government. He would submit that in compliance of the order
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the State of Manipur has constituted State
Level Committee and Committees for District Level for consideration of such
cases of unauthorized structures of religious nature.
The State Level
Committee had also recommended as many as 188 unauthorized structures
of religious nature constructed on Government land and allotment orders have
been issued in favour of those 188 individual cases vide allotment order dated
27.9.2011.
9. The learned Advocate counsel submitted that the Evangelical Baptist
Convention Church has also submitted an application on 5.9.2011 for
allotment of the land occupied by them to the concerned authorities for
consideration under the instructions and protections given by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 29.9.2009. However, the District Level Committee has
taken a decision to remove the Evangelical Baptist Convention Church in total
defiance of the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, which is quiet
contemptuous of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
The Evangelical Baptist
Convention Church has possessed the land measuring 0.044 acres under
Dag No.265(p) located at Village No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai since the
year 1974 against the whole world including the State Government without
any objection and interruption till today and, as such the Evangelical Baptist
Convention Church has got a prescriptive right of title over the disputed land.
Only after considering the nature of the case, this Court, while issuing notice,
vide order dated 5.2.2021, passed the interim order for maintaining status quo
under the land under dispute.
10. As far as Peniel Church (MELC) is concerned, the learned counsel
for the respondent submitted that the said Church was established in the year
1997 to cater social and spiritual needs of the Church members and the
members of the Church are enjoying social and religious services in the
Church for more than 25 years without any objection from any quarter. The
location on which the Peniel Church is standing was by then a six feet deep
ditch and the Church has been established by its members by reclaiming the
land by investing huge amount of money collected from the members. The
Peniel Church is located at Village No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai under Dag
No.265(P) measuring an area of 86 ft. wide and 115 ft. long, Imphal East
District and the same is recorded in the name of the State.
11. The learned counsel further submitted that Peniel Church was
issued with an eviction notice dated 24.12.2020 by the SDO without any
authority and without taking approval from the State Cabinet or permission
from the Hon’ble Supreme Court. In a similar case, when eviction was initiated
at the instance of the Director, RIMS, the SDO, Imphal West has passed an
order on 5.10.2018 in Eviction Case No.18 of 2017 closing the eviction
process in view of the direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. Since the
direction dated 29.9.2009 of the Hon’ble Supreme Court is to the effect to
remove/relocate/regularize the unauthorized construction of religious nature
prior to 29.9.2009, the Peniel Church is entitled for allotment of land already
occupied by it since 1997. Considering the nature of the case, vide order
dated 3.8.2022, this Court, passed the interim order for maintaining status quo
in respect of the land of Peniel Church. Thus, a prayer has been made to
dismiss the miscellaneous cases.
12. This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused the
materials available on record.
13. The Evangelical Baptist Convention Church has filed W.P.(C) No.94
of 2021 with the following reliefs:
“(a) To admit this petition for hearing;
(b) After hearing the parties to issue a writ in the nature of
mandamus for directing the Respondents authorities to
expedite the case of the Petitioner for allotment in term of
the allotment application dated 05.09.2011 (Annex-A/7) and
the direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court contained in the
order dated 31.01.2018 passed in SLP (C) No.8519/2016
and in terms of the Government policy called the Manipur
Policy for Review of Unauthorized Construct of Religious
Nature on public streets, public parks, public place etc., 2010
vide notification dated 03.04.2010 and its amendment dated
05.03.2011 (Annex-A/4) within a specific period of time as
done in other cases.
(c) To quash and set aside the eviction notice dated
24.12.2020 (Annex-A/11) as the same is passed without
jurisdiction, contemptuous and illegal;
(d) To quash and set aside the whole proceedings of the
Eviction Case No.17 of 2020/SDO/I/IE of the court of the
SDO, Imphal East.”
14. On 5.2.2021, when W.P.(C) No.94 of 2021 was taken up for
admission, this Court passed the following interim order:
“Heard Mr. Th.Babloo, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner.
Issue notice, returnable within 4 (four) weeks.
Mr. Shyam Sharma, learned GA accepts notice on behalf of all the
respondents. Hence, no formal notice is called for.
As an interim measure, it is directed that status-quo as on today with
regard to the writ petitioner shall be maintained till the next date.
List this case again on 05.03.2021.”
15. The Peniel Church (MELC) has filed W.P.(C) No.501 of 2022 with
the following reliefs:
“(a) to admit this petition for hearing;
(b) after hearing the parties to issue a writ in the nature of mandamus
for directing the Respondents authorities to regularize the occupation
of the Govt. land by the petitioner covered by Dag No.265 (Part)
measuring 86 ft. wide and 115 ft. long in Village No.26Wangkheirakpam, Imphal East District by way of granting allotment
in terms of the direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court contained in
the order dated 31.01.2018 passed in SLP (C) No.8519/2016 and in
terms of the Government policy called the Manipur Policy for Review
of Unauthorized Construct of Religious Nature on public streets,
public parks, public place etc., 2010 vide notification dated
03.04.2010 and its amendment dated 05.03.2011 (Annex-A/4) within
a specific period of time as done in other cases.
(c) to quash and set aside the eviction notice dated 24.12.2020
(Annex-A/6)
as
the
same
is
passed
without
jurisdiction,
contemptuous and illegal;
(d) to quash and set aside the whole proceedings of the Eviction Case
No.17 of 2020/SDO/I/IE of the Court of the SDO, Imphal East.”
16. On 3.8.2022, when the writ petition was taken up for admission, this
Court passed the following interim order:
“Heard Mr. Th. Babloo, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
and Mr. H.Debendra, learned GA appearing for the respondents.
Learned GA seeks three weeks’ time for filing counter affidavit.
Prayer is allowed.
List this case again on 7th September, 2022.
In the meantime, status quo in respect of the land of the petitioner
shall be maintained till the next date.”
17. The respondents Evangelical Baptist Convention Church and
Peniel Church (MELC) admitted that the two Churches have been constructed
on Government land. There is no whisper in the writ petition that Churches
have been constructed with the approval of the State authorities.
18. With regard to the removal of unauthorized religious structures in
public streets, public parks, public places etc., the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Union of India v. State of Gujarat and others (arising out of the
order dated 2.5.2006 passed by the Gujarat High Court in SCA No.9686 of
2006) in Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No.8519 of 2006 dated 29.9.2009
passed the following orders:
“….. As an interim measure, we direct henceforth no unauthorized
construction shall be carried out or permitted in the name of Temple,
Church, Mosque or Gurudwara etc. on public streets, public parks
or other public places etc.
In respect of the unauthorized construction of religious nature which
has already taken place, the State Governments and the Union
Territories shall review the same on case to case basis and take
appropriate steps as expeditiously as possible.”
19. Again on 7.12.2009, when the Special Leave to Appeal (Civil)
No.8519 of 2006 came up for hearing, the Hon’ble Supreme passed the
following order:
“All the Chief Secretaries, in consultation with the respective
Governments are directed to frame the policy in respect of existing
unauthorized construction of religious nature, which had already
taken place. This Court directed the respondents to review the same
on case to case base. Let the policies be formulated by all the States
and Union Territories within four weeks from today.
We are reiterating that the Chief Secretaries, the concerned District
Magistrates and the Collectors/Deputy Commissioners in-charge of
the Districts must ensure total compliance of our order. Any breach
in this respect shall be viewed seriously by this Court.”
20. It appears that in compliance of the order of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, the Government of Manipur framed a policy and published vide
notification dated 3.4.2010 and had also constituted State Level Committee
for reviewing the unauthorized construction of religious nature and the District
Committees headed by District Commissioner/Chairperson were constituted
for the purpose of removal/relocation/regularization of the religious structure.
Accordingly, the District Level Committee where the religious structures
located in Village No.26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai discussed the existence of
nine religious structures on the land allotted to the PWD Building Division,
Government of Manipur.
Out of nine religious structures located at
Government Quarters Complex in New Checkon, five were removed and four
are still standing on Dag Nos.410, 411, 412(P), 265, 267(P) and 265(P). Out
of the four, two Churches, namely, Evangelical Baptist Convention Church
and Peniel Church have come to this Court challenging the eviction notices
issued against them.
21. The respondents contended that in compliance of the direction of
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court,
the
State
Level
Committee
already
recommended as many as 188 unauthorized structures of religious nature
constructed on Government land and allotment orders have been issued in
favour of those 188 individual cases.
When the respondent Churches
submitted applications before the State authorities for allotment of the land
occupied by them, the same have not been considered, instead the District
Committee is taking action for removal of the Church structures, which is total
defiance of the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
22. The consideration for allotment of the land occupied by the
respondent Churches are within the domain of the State authorities and the
Court exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution cannot
interfere with it or direct the State to positively consider the claim of the
respondents, as the respondent Churches are standing on the Government
land. That apart, when the Hon’ble Supreme Court issued direction to remove
the unauthorized structures of religious nature standing on the Government
land, whether it is 40 years old or 25 years old, it is the bounden duty of the
State authorities to obey the direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
removing the unauthorized religious structures.
23. The specific direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court is that in
respect of unauthorized construction of religious nature which has already
taken place on public streets, public parks or other public places, the State
Government and the Union Territories were directed to review the same on
case to case basis and take appropriate steps as expeditiously as possible.
Since the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s direction is to review the existence of the
religious structure on the Government land on case to case basis, the
respondent Churches as a matter of right cannot claim to stand on the
Government land in question without being any right or title over the same.
24. Admittedly, the religious structures which were built on the
Government land in question was meant for construction of quarters solely
and there was no record shown by the respondents qua sanction accorded or
permission for construction of religious structures in the land earmarked for
the quarters.
25. As could be seen form the records, particularly the Memorandum
for Cabinet, annexed with the present miscellaneous cases, it is clear that the
subject-matter i.e. removal of unauthorized four religious structures which
have already constructed prior to 29.9.2009 within the PWD Government
Quarters at 26-Wangkheriakpam Leikai Revenue Village was discussed and
a decision was arrived at for removal of the said four religious structures built
on the Government land. For ready reference, the Memorandum for Cabinet
in File No.40/100/2022-R(Pt) and the decision thereon is quoted hereunder:
“File No.40/100/2022-R(Pt)
GOVERNMENT OF MANIPUR
SECRETARIAT : REVENUE DEPARTMENT
MEMORANDUM FOR CABINET
Subject : Consideration of the recommendation dated 12-01/2022 of the
Committee constituted vide Notification No.20/4/(76)/2009-H(Pt.1) dated
05-03-2011 in compliance of the various directions of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in SLP (C) No.8519 of 2006 (Union of India –vs- State of
Gujarat & Ors.) for removal of the unauthorized 4 (four) religious
structures which has already taken place prior to September 29, 2009
within PWD government quarters at 26-Wangkheirakpam Leikai Revenue
village.
This is to consider the recommendation dated 12-01-2022 of the Committee
constituted vide Notification No.20/4/(76)/2009-H(Pt.1) dated 05-03-2011 for
removal of the unauthorized constructions of religious nature i.e. the following
4 (four) Churches which had alredy taken place prior to September 29, 2009
inside the government quarters built during the years 1953-1955 at 26Wangkheirakpam Leikai Revenue Village, Imphal East District in compliance
of the various directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in SLP (C) No.8519 of
2006 (Union of India –vs- State of Gujarat & Ors.)
Sl.
No.
Name
Church
of
the Village & Dag Status of land
Number 26Wangkheirak
pam Leikai
Tangkhui
Baptist 410, 411 & Patta land land
Church
412(P)
recorded in the
name of Chief
Engineer
(Building), PWD,
Manipur
Peniel Church
265 & 267(P) do
Remark
Holy Spirit Church 265(P)
(Catholic Church)
Evangelical Baptist 265(P)
Convention Church
do
do
do
do
Peding in
the court
do
2. As per record of Building Divison-1 and Building Division-II, PWD, Manipur
submitted vide letter No.EE/BD-II/Misc/2022-23 dated 23-06-2022, the
government quarters at Tribal Colony, New Checkon were built during the year
1953-1955. The official number of quarters recorded was 140 in total viz. Type1-100 (one hundred) numbers, Type-20 (Twenty) numbers and Type-III-20
(Twenty) numbers.
At that time there was no official/registered religious
structure at Tribal Colony. With the passage of time, religious structures were
constructed by the occupants without giving any prior knowledge to the
government. The religious structures were built on the land lying vacant which
was meant solely for constructions of Government Quarters. There was no
record of according permission for construction of religious structures in the
land earmarked for the quarters.
The land has been recorded now as patta land of Chief Engineer (Buildings)
PWD, Manipour for construction of Government Residential Quarters.
The earlier allotment of government quarters at the site have been cancelled
and given re-allotment at other PWD government quarters.
3. Commissioner, MAHUD further placed before the Committee that
construction of the project ‘Construction of Government Residential quarters,
Checkon’ with an allocated fund of Rs.50 crores obtained as loan by Planning
and Development Authority (PDA) from HUDCO for the purpose is under full
swing at the same location. The new constructions will provide altogether 392
new modern residential quarters for the Government employees.
4. The significance of the existence of the church which was reportedly
constructed for payer by the allottees/occupants of the Government quarters
in New Checkon is now nullified as the allotment of quarters in the New
Checkon had been cancelled by Govt. vide Order No.26/19/2020-W dated 2003-2021 and re-allocated at other PWD government quarters.
5. The Committee has recommended for the removal of the 4 (four) religious
structures mentioned in Para No.1 after obtaining the approval of the State
Cabinet and thereafter seeking leave of the Hon’ble High Court in the pending
case (s).
6. The recommendation of the Committee viz for the removal of the 4 (four)
religious structures mentioned in Para No.1 after obtaining the approval of the
State Cabinet and thereafter seeking leave of the Hon’ble High Court in the
pending cases is placed before the State Cabinet for consideration and
decision.
7. Hon’ble Chief Minister (i/c Revenue) has seen this memorandum and agreed
to place the matter before the Cabinet.
8. Hon’ble Chief Minister has also consented to place the matter before the
Cabinet for its consideration & approval.
9. The proposal at para 6 above is placed before the State Cabinet for its kind
consideration and approval.
(Namoijam Kheda Varta Singh)
Secretary (Revenue)
Government of Manipur
Cabinet Decision taken on 18.01.2023
AGENDA No.1
:
Consideration of the recommendation dated 12-012022 of the committee constituted vide Notification
No.20/4/(76)/2009-H(Pt.1) dated 05-03-2011 in
compliance of the various directions of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in SLP(C) No.8519 of 2006 (Union of
India –vs- State of Gujarat & Ors.) for removal of the
unauthorized 4 (four) religious structures which has
already taken prior to September 29, 2009 within
PWD government quarters at 26 – Wangkheirakpam
Leikai Revenue Village
DECISION
:
Approved as proposed in para 6 of the Cabinet
Memorandum.
(Sd)/- xxx
Chief Secy. & Secy.
(Cabinet)
Government of Manipur.”
26. Since the action for removal of the Churches in question is based
on the decision taken by the State Cabinet pursuant to the direction of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 29.9.2009, this Court exercising writ jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India cannot interfere in the action for
removal initiated by the State authorities. The respondent Churches were built
unauthorisedly on the Government land, which was meant for construction
Government quarters.
27. Though the respondent Churches admitted that the Churches have
been built on the Government land, they still claim that the Churches are in
existence since 1974 and 1997 against the whole world including the State
Government without any objection and interruption till today and therefore they
got prescriptive right of title over the disputed land. Such a right claimed by
the respondent Churches cannot be appreciated, as no record to show that
Churches were built in the Government land after getting approval from the
State authorities.
Therefore, there is no option but to record that the
respondents are rank encroachers of the Government land.
28. Since the State has framed a policy called “The Manipur Policy for
review of unauthorized construction of Religious Nature on public parks, public
places etc. 2010” and under the said policy, the State has regularized some
of unauthorized constructions on the Government land by giving allotment as
they have established right for regularization/relocation, as the case may be
and in some cases, the authorities have taken a decision not to regularize the
same, as they have no right to stand on the Government land.
29. It is apposite to mention that the District Level Committee meeting
in regard to removal/relocation/regularization of Wangkheirakpam Leikai was
held on 24.6.2022 and in the said meeting the Committee unanimously
decided to recommend 9 Churches, including the respondent Churches for
removal, as the said religious structures were built on the land lying vacant,
which was meant for construction of Government quarters.
In the said
meeting, it was further highlighted that there are multiple Churches in the
vicinity within one kilometer radius from the location of 9 Churches, where the
occupants of the quarters can go for worship and prayers. As such, religious
right shall not be compromised without the existence of 9 Churches.
The
existence of the Churches which were reportedly constructed for prayer by the
occupants in the Government quarters at New Checkon had been cancelled
and occupants have been instructed for vacating the Government quarters for
construction of new quarters. After considering all the aspects, the Committee
concluded that 9 Churches, including the respondent Churches are existing
without any kind of authorization. In view of the aforesaid concrete decision
taken by the Committee, respondent Churches cannot contend that their claim
has not been considered and left out by the Committee.
30. What the Hon’ble Supreme Court directed is to remove those
unauthorized construction of religious structures at public places and
wherever the Government so decides to regularize such construction, it is left
to the wisdom of the Government to do so.
If there is no process for
regularization and the Government is not inclined to regularize the
unauthorized structures in the public places, these are liable to be removed,
irrespective of whether there is complaint from any quarter or not.
31. It is reiterated that since the decision of the State Cabinet to remove
the respondent Churches built on the land of the Government is pursuant to
the direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the operation of the status quo
order dated 5.2.2021 and 3.8.2022 passed in W.P.(C) Nos.94 of 2021 and
501 of 2022 in respect of the land, where the Churches stand, granted by this
Court is liable to be vacated, as prima facie, the respondent Churches have
failed to prove that the Churches were constructed with the approval of the
State authorities.
When this Court also examined the structures of the
Churches in question on case to case basis as per the direction of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, the decision of the State authorities in evicting the respondent
Churches are based on the documents, policy decision and pursuant to the
direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. Thus, the State has made out a case
to vacate of the interim orders granted by this Court in the writ petitions and,
accordingly, the miscellaneous cases filed by the State are liable to be
allowed.
32. In the result, MC (WP) No.88 of 2023 in W.P.(C) No.94 of 2021 and
MC (WP) No.89 of 2023 in W.P.(C) No.501 of 2022 are allowed. The interim
orders dated 5.2.2021 and 3.8.2022 granted in W.P.(C) Nos.94 of 2021 and
WP(C) No.501 of 2022 are vacated.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review