Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W. A. No. 1119 of 2018
-12025:KER:28727
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. NITIN JAMDAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S.MANU
TUESDAY, THE 1ST DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 11TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 1119 OF 2018
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT IN WPC NO.26128 OF 2008 OF HIGH
COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANT/S:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
REVENUE (L) DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
DISTRICT COLLECTOR
KANNUR.
CHIEF ENGINEER IRRIGATION
PROJECT NO.1, KOZHIKODE.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PAZHASHI IRRIGATION PROJECT, KANNUR.
TAHSILDAR
TALUK OFFICE, KANNUR-2.
BY ADV V. TEKCHAND, SR. GP
RESPONDENT/S:
T.V. HARIDASAN
ADVOCATE, THEKKEVEETTIL HOUSE, P.O.VARAM, KANNUR670594.
CHELORA GRAMA PANCHAYATH
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, P.O.VARAM, KANNUR
DISTRICT.
W. A. No. 1119 of 2018
-22025:KER:28727
BY ADVS
P.M.PAREETH
VANIAH MARIYA DOMINIC
THIS
03.03.2025,
FOLLOWING:
WRIT
THE
APPEAL
HAVING
COURT
ON
BEEN
FINALLY
01.04.2025
HEARD
DELIVERED
ON
THE
W. A. No. 1119 of 2018
-32025:KER:28727
C. R.
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 1st day of April, 2025
Nitin Jamdar, C. J.
The State of Kerala has filed this Appeal under Section 5 of the
Kerala High Court Act, 1958, challenging the order passed by the
learned Single Judge dated 10 November 2017 in W. P. (C) No.
26128 of 2008, in which the learned Single Judge held that the
Respondent / Petitioner is entitled to the allotment of public land and
that a sale deed be executed in his favour.
2.
The subject matter of these proceedings is a portion of the land in
Re-Sy. No. 102/4 of Valiyannur Amsom Varam Desom of
Veliyannoor Village of Kannur Taluk, which was acquired for the
Pazhassi Irrigation Project from one Puthiyapurayil Nabeesa Fathibi R.
and vested the same with the Irrigation Department. A portion of the
land had remained in excess after the original use.
3.
Earlier, the State of Kerala had issued executive instructions with
respect to the lands that remained unutilised after the purpose for
which the lands were acquired was achieved that such land could be
disposed of to the erstwhile owner. The High Court of Kerala had
declared these executive instructions invalid, being in contravention of
the Kerala Land Assignment Act, 1960. The Hon'ble Supreme Court
dismissed the appeal by the State of Kerala in the case of State of Kerala
v. Bhaskaran Pillai1, confirming the view taken by the High Court that
such executive instructions could not have been issued, and once the
1 1997 (2) KLT 217 (SC)
W. A. No. 1119 of 2018
-42025:KER:28727
land by operation of Section 16 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
stood vested in the State free from all encumbrances, its alienation has
to be in the public interest.
4.
Pursuant to the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Bhaskaran Pillai, the State of Kerala issued a Government Order dated
22 December 2000 laying down a procedure for the usage of such land
by the Government Departments and making an application by the
interested party for allotment. The Respondent / Original Petitioner,
an Advocate, filed an application for assignment of the subject land on
2 July 1991. On 18 June 2005, the subject land was decided to be
assigned, and the matter was taken up before the District Assignment
Committee. The upset price of the land was fixed. An auction was
conducted on 20 September 2006 by the Tahsildar. Petitioner was the
highest bidder, and the Petitioner tendered the sale consideration on
19 October 2006. The proposal for confirmation of the sale was
returned after various queries were raised, and on 11 August 2008, by
Ext. P8 order, the District Collector, Kannur, set aside the auction sale
of 6 cents of land being in contravention of the Government Order
dated 22 December 2000. The Petitioner challenged this order by way
of W. P. (C) No. 26128 of 2008, which was allowed by the learned
Single Judge by the impugned judgment dated 10 November 2017.
5.
The impugned order noted that the shape of the land was such
that it could be utilised only by the Petitioner or the adjacent owner.
The impugned order thereafter referred to Ext. P8 and observed that
the procedure for publication of sale is the same as contemplated in the
Kerala Revenue Recovery Act, 1968 (Act of 1968), and the publication
W. A. No. 1119 of 2018
-52025:KER:28727
was done as per the procedure, and therefore, Ext. P8 impugned order
has to be set aside, and it was accordingly set aside. The Respondent
State was directed to confirm the sale. Challenging this order, the State
of Kerala is in appeal.
6.
When the appeal came up for consideration on 7 November 2018,
the Division Bench granted time to the learned Government Pleader to
take instructions on whether any Government Department or
undertaking needed the land in question. Thereafter, when the appeal
came up for consideration on 6 February 2019, taking note of the
submission of the learned Government Pleader that several
Government Departments are interested in the said land, the appeal
was admitted, and the implementation of the impugned order was
stayed.
7.
We have heard Mr. V. Tekchand, learned Senior Government
Pleader appearing for the Appellant State and Mr. P. M. Pareeth,
learned counsel for Respondent No. 1-Original Petitioner.
8.
As stated earlier, the assignment of the excess land after satisfying
the object of the acquisition is governed by the Government Order
dated 22 December 2000. The Government Order reads as follows:-
“GOVERNMENT OF KERALA
Abstract
Land – Disposal of lands acquired under the Land
Acquisition Act and unutilized for the purpose for which it
was acquired by the Government – Instructions issued.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
W. A. No. 1119 of 2018
-6-
Revenue (P) Department
2025:KER:28727
G. O. (Ms) No. 387/2000/RD Dated, 22.12.2000,
Thiruvananthapuram
-------------------------------------------------------------------------Read: 1) G. O. (Ms) No. 530/67/RD Dated 30.10.1967.
2) G. O. (Ms) No. 222/94/RD Dated 4.5.1994.
3) Judgment dated 18.12.1999 of the High Court of
Kerala in S. A. No. 101 and 129 of 1990.
4) G. O. (Ms) No. 309/2000/RD Dated 28.9.2000.
5) Letter No. 101 & 129/50/SA/110/2000/AAG
Dated 27.11.2000 from the Additional Advocate
General.
ORDER
In the Government Order read as first paper above,
standardized instructions were issued with regard to the
procedure to be adopted for reconveyance of acquired lands.
2. In the light of the directions of the High Court
disallowing reconveyance of land acquired for public
purpose, further instructions were issued in para 3(viii) of the
G. O. read as second paper above, that such category of land
should either be used for public purpose or be disposed of by
way of assignment or lease on consideration of market value.
3. In the judgment read as third paper above, the High
Court of Kerala has directed, citing the ruling of the Supreme
Court reported in 1997 (2) KLT 217 (SC), that such lands
should be utilized only for public purpose and in
contingencies in which such utilization is not possible, it
should be disposed of in public auction.
4. After considering the matter in all its aspects,
Government were pleased to issue the Government Order
read as 4th paper above prescribing procedure for the disposal
of lands acquired for public purpose and unutilized for the
W. A. No. 1119 of 2018
-7-
purpose for which it was acquired.
2025:KER:28727
5. Now, the Additional Advocate General, in the letter read
as 5th paper above, has suggested deleting clause 5 and
amending clause 3 in this G. O. After considering his
suggestion, the Government are pleased to modify the
Government Order read as 4th paper above, as here under.
1.
When any land required for a public purpose is not
required for that purpose or for any other purpose of the
Department for which the land was acquired, the
concerned Department should bring this fact to the
notice of the District Collector concerned and hand
over possession of the land to the Revenue Department
immediately. Until such handing over possession it shall
be the responsibility of the acquiring Department to
keep the land free from any encroachment.
2.
Immediately on receipt of such intimation the District
Collector shall ascertain from all Government
Departments and the Local Bodies concerned whether
they require the land for their use, and get fully satisfied
about the genuineness of the claims made.
3.
If the land is needed by any other Government
Departments, Local Bodies or Public Sector
Undertakings, the District Collector would take further
action for the transfer / assignment of the land in
accordance with the standing instructions relating to
transfer of land between Government Departments or
between Government Departments and Local Bodies or
assignment of land to public sector undertakings as the
case may be.
4.
In the case of more than one claimant for the land, it
shall be referred to the Government for their decision.
5.
If the lands could not be disposed of as mentioned
above, it shall be disposed of in public auction,
following the procedure prescribed in the Kerala
Revenue Recovery Act for the auction of attached
W. A. No. 1119 of 2018
-82025:KER:28727
immovable properties, except the procedure prescribed
under Section 50 of the said Act for bidding on behalf
of Government. Auction should be conducted only after
fixing the upset price of the land, which should not be
below the market value of the land prevailing at the
time of auction or the amount spent by Government for
the acquisition of the land whichever is higher. The
Tahsildar concerned will conduct the auction subject to
the confirmation of sale by the District Collector.
(By order of the
Governor)
C. Chandran
Secretary to Government”
Therefore, first the excess land has to be disposed of as per the need of
other Government Departments or local bodies for public purpose
only, if there are no requirements, then the procedure of auction has to
be carried out.
9.
In the case at hand, the District Collector, Kannur, upon
examination of the report received from the Tahsildar, Kannur, on 14
March 2006 for a proposal to dispose of 6 cents of land through a
public auction, directions were given by the Collector to the Tahsildar
on 24 March 2006 to strictly observe all the instructions mentioned in
the Government Order. After the Tahsildar reported that on 6
December 2006, the land was put for public auction and the Petitioner
was the highest bidder, the District Collector examined the record
received from the Tahsildar and found that most of the directions in
the Government Order were breached. The requirement of
ascertaining from all Government Departments and local bodies
whether they require the land was not followed. Also, no steps were
W. A. No. 1119 of 2018
-92025:KER:28727
taken to advertise the sale widely, there was no publication of the
notice at the site, the increase in the land value and the premises were
not reflected in the auction sale, and no attempts were made to fetch a
moderate rate. The District Collector found a remark of the officer who
conducted the auction that even a moderate amount would not be
fetched even if the second auction was conducted to be absurd.
Accordingly, the Collector, by order dated 11 August 2008, cancelled
the auction. The Petitioner challenged this cancellation.
10. The Petitioner is not akin to an auction purchaser of a property
put to sale in a court auction. Such an auction purchaser acquires a
different set of rights. The auction at hand is not one such auction,
even though the procedure adopted for it is the same as a court auction.
This was an auction to dispose of the property vested in the State. It is
the first principle, as emphasised by the Supreme Court in the case of
Bhaskaran Pillai, that such property vested in the Government has to
be utilised for a public purpose and only if it is not possible to do so, to
dispose of it by way of public auction at a value. Therefore, the right of
such an applicant would be subservient to the need of the Government
or other public authorities to utilise the land. This has been amply
made clear in the Government Order dated 22 December 2000.
11. The learned Government Pleader made a grievance that the
impugned order only refers to the aspect of publication and procedure
but does not refer at all to the main ground contained in Ext. P8 order
of the Collector, that is the requirement of ascertaining the needs of
Government Departments and local bodies. This submission is correct.
There is no reference in the impugned order to the Government Order
W. A. No. 1119 of 2018
-102025:KER:28727
dated 22 December 2000 at all. There is also no finding that any other
Government Departments or local bodies do not require the land.
Without referring to and dealing with the main ground in the order of
the Collector, the order could not have been set aside.
12. The requirement and need of the Government Departments and
local bodies for this land is the paramount consideration. The learned
Government Pleader has placed the following facts on record. The
Deputy Excise Commissioner, Kannur, and the District Manager,
Kerala State Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Development
Corporation, have placed their requests before the District Collector for
transferring the said land to build offices. This position existed when
the Collector passed the order. Also, the Offices of Excise Enforcement
and Anti Narcotics Special Squad, Kannur, Excise Circle, Kannur,
Excise Intelligence & Investigation Bureau and the Assistant
Commissioner (Enforcement), Kannur, are functioning in a rented
building. It is stated that these offices incur annual rental costs of
around ₹6,00,000/-. If the land is obtained, the amount paid for office
building rent will be significantly reduced. It is also stated that because
of the space limitation of existing rented buildings, storing the
properties seized in Abkari / NDPS cases is very difficult. The medical
officer also requires the land as many patients who are currently
functioning in the District Homeo Hospital, Kannur, are coming to the
speciality clinics daily. The District Manager, Kerala State Scheduled
Castes and Scheduled Tribes Development Corporation, Kannur, has
requested the land to construct a district office and start selfemployment enterprises, preparing a permanent system for selling
W. A. No. 1119 of 2018
-112025:KER:28727
traditional products. It is, therefore, clear that the land is required to be
utilised for public purposes as different Government Departments have
evinced interest in the said leftover land after acquisition proceedings.
13. The learned counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the position
of the land is such that only the Petitioner can use the same. This
submission is accepted in the impugned order. Learned Government
Pleader submitted that there is no basis for this finding as various other
government departments are interested in using the said land. If the
case of the Petitioner is that the position of the land was such that only
the Petitioner could use the land and no other person or authority, then
the heavy burden lay on the Petitioner to demonstrate the said fact.
There are no pleadings in the petition to discharge such a burden. The
conclusion that the Petitioner alone could use the land is not based on
any material.
14. The Collector had cancelled the auction on 11 August 2008, and
the impugned judgment on 10 November 2017 set aside the order of
the Collector. The impugned judgment was stayed in Appeal. The
action of the District Collector based on the Government Order dated
22 December 2000 to cancel the auction could not have been faulted.
The Appeal, therefore, is required to be allowed. The amount
deposited by the Petitioner pursuant to the auction will have to be
returned to the Petitioner.
15. In these circumstances, the Appeal is allowed. The judgment and
order passed by the learned Single Judge dated 10 November 2017 in
W. P. (C) No. 26128 of 2008 is set aside, and the writ petition is
W. A. No. 1119 of 2018
-122025:KER:28727
dismissed. The amount deposited by the Respondent-Petitioner
pursuant to the auction, if any, be returned to the Petitioner by the
Appellants.
Sd/NITIN JAMDAR
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/S. MANU
JUDGE
Eb
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review